Shifts in caterpillar biomass phenology due to climate change and its impact on the breeding biology of an insectivorous bird. Oecologia

Netherlands Institute of Ecology (NIOO-KNAW), P.O. Box 40, 6666 ZG, Heteren, The Netherlands.
Oecologia (Impact Factor: 3.09). 03/2006; 147(1):164-72. DOI: 10.1007/s00442-005-0299-6
Source: PubMed


Timing of reproduction has major fitness consequences, which can only be understood when the phenology of the food for the offspring is quantified. For insectivorous birds, like great tits (Parus major), synchronisation of their offspring needs and abundance of caterpillars is the main selection pressure. We measured caterpillar biomass over a 20-year period and showed that the annual peak date is correlated with temperatures from 8 March to 17 May. Laying dates also correlate with temperatures, but over an earlier period (16 March-20 April). However, as we would predict from a reliable cue used by birds to time their reproduction, also the food peak correlates with these temperatures. Moreover, the slopes of the phenology of the birds and caterpillar biomass, when regressed against the temperatures in this earlier period, do not differ. The major difference is that due to climate change, the relationship between the timing of the food peak and the temperatures over the 16 March-20 April period is changing, while this is not so for great tit laying dates. As a consequence, the synchrony between offspring needs and the caterpillar biomass has been disrupted in the recent warm decades. This may have severe consequences as we show that both the number of fledglings as well as their fledging weight is affected by this synchrony. We use the descriptive models for both the caterpillar biomass peak as for the great tit laying dates to predict shifts in caterpillar and bird phenology 2005-2100, using an IPCC climate scenario. The birds will start breeding earlier and this advancement is predicted to be at the same rate as the advancement of the food peak, and hence they will not reduce the amount of the current mistiming of about 10 days.

Download full-text


Available from: Marcel E Visser, Nov 27, 2014
  • Source
    • "Therefore, under increased temperatures, range expansion of residents would be more likely to occur. Other components of migrant life history may place additional pressures on these species with climate change, such as mismatches in migratory timing, e.g. with food supplies (Visser et al. 2006), and increased variability of weather events during migration (Hedenström et al. 2007). "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Mounting evidence shows that organisms have already begun to respond to global climate change. Advances in our knowledge of how climate shapes species distributional patterns has helped us better understand the response of birds to climate change. However, the distribution of birds across the landscape is also driven by biotic and abiotic components, including habitat characteristics. We therefore developed statistical models of 147 bird species distributions in the eastern United States, using climate, elevation, and the distributions of 39 tree species to predict contemporary bird distributions. We used randomForest, a robust regression-based decision tree ensemble method to predict contemporary bird distributions. These models were then projected onto three models of climate change under high and low emission scenarios for both climate and the projected change in suitable habitat for the 39 tree species. The resulting bird species models indicated that breeding habitat will decrease by at least 10% for 61-79 species (depending on model and emissions scenario) and increase by at least 10% for 38-52 species in the eastern United States. Alternatively, running the species models using only climate/elevation (omitting tree species), we found that the predictive power of these models was significantly reduced (p<0.001). When these climate/elevation-only models were projected onto the climate change scenarios, the change in suitable habitat was more extreme in 60% of the species. In the end, the strong associations with vegetation tempers a climate/elevation-only response to climate change and indicates that refugia of suitable habitat may persist for these bird species in the eastern US, even after the redistribution of tree species. These results suggest the importance of interacting biotic processes and that further fine-scale research exploring how climate change may disrupt species specific requirements is needed.
    Full-text · Article · Jan 2021 · Ecography
  • Source
    • "The most commonly discussed consequences of climate change involve phenological mismatches between locally adapted traits and novel environmental conditions (Root et al. 2003). Although phenological mismatches under climate change have been widely described (Parmesan 2007;Miller-Rushing et al. 2010;Thackeray et al. 2010), only a few studies have quantified actual demographic consequences of climate change: some populations successfully responded via phenotypic plasticity or evolution (Reale et al. 2003;Charmantier et al. 2008), while others experienced declines in vital rates due to inability to sufficiently track change (Both et al. 2006;Visser et al. 2006;Lane et al. 2012;Tafani et al. 2013). Further, progress in attributing phenological mismatches directly to climate change has been hampered by the fact that climate variables change in complex ways across space and time, and often interact with other stressors that can confound the signal from climate change. "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Anthropogenic climate change has created myriad stressors that threaten to cause local extinctions if wild populations fail to adapt to novel conditions. We studied individual and population-level fitness costs of a climate change-induced stressor: camouflage mismatch in seasonally colour molting species confronting decreasing snow cover duration. Based on field measurements of radiocollared snowshoe hares, we found strong selection on coat colour molt phenology, such that animals mismatched with the colour of their background experienced weekly survival decreases up to 7%. In the absence of adaptive response, we show that these mortality costs would result in strong population-level declines by the end of the century. However, natural selection acting on wide individual variation in molt phenology might enable evolutionary adaptation to camouflage mismatch. We conclude that evolutionary rescue will be critical for hares and other colour molting species to keep up with climate change.
    Full-text · Article · Jan 2016 · Ecology Letters
  • Source
    • "Because the accuracy of phenology estimates can be sensitive to diff erences in observers and monitoring procedures (Chung et al. 2011), the peak cherry blossom date, which is tracked annually by trained observers using a standardized procedure, provided a standard measure for comparing annual variation in the timing of phenology for our study site. Th e leafi ng phenology of most trees species, including cherry trees, and the emergence of spring-feeding caterpillars (the primary breeding resource for redstarts; Sherry and Holmes 1997) are strongly correlated with the average annual minimum temperature (Abu-Asab et al. 2001, Visser et al. 2006, Chung et al. 2011, Valtonen et al. 2011), so annual variation in cherry blossom phenology provided a reliable surrogate for the phenology of plants and insects in the region surrounding our study site. Peak cherry blossom dates for the years of our study were mean-centered on the long-term average so that positive values indicate later than average phenology and negative values indicate earlier than average phenology. "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Long-distance dispersal is a fundamental process in ecology and evolution but the factors that influence these movements remain poorly understood in most species. We used stable hydrogen isotopes to quantify the rate and direction of long-distance immigration in a breeding population of American redstarts and to test whether the settlement decisions that result in long-distance dispersal are driven by habitat saturation or by the phenology of breeding-season resources. Our results provide evidence that both natal dispersal and breeding dispersal were influenced by the timing of breeding-season phenology, with both age classes more likely to disperse north in years when the onset of breeding-season phenology occurs earlier than normal. Yearlings were also more likely to disperse north following winters with poor habitat quality on their non-breeding grounds, demonstrating that carry-over effects from the non-breeding season influence natal dispersal in this species. Collectively, these results are consistent with the hypothesis that American redstarts use the phenology of breeding season resources as a cue to select breeding sites. Our results suggest that long-distance dispersal may allow individuals to rapidly respond to advancing phenology caused by global climate change, though their ability to do so may be constrained by long-term decline in habitat quality predicted for their tropical non-breeding grounds.
    Full-text · Article · Oct 2015 · Ecography
Show more