Development of Public Health Priorities for End-of-Life Initiatives

Division of Adult and Community Health, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Atlanta, Georgia 30341, USA.
American Journal of Preventive Medicine (Impact Factor: 4.53). 01/2006; 29(5):453-60. DOI: 10.1016/j.amepre.2005.08.014
Source: PubMed


Recently, end-of-life (EOL) issues have captured the attention of the public health community. This study reports a project to help state health departments better understand their potential role in addressing EOL issues and develop initial priorities for EOL activities.
The project involved two studies. Study 1 (October 2002 to September 2003) involved a concept mapping process to solicit and organize recommendations from key stakeholders. Concept mapping integrates qualitative group processes with multivariate statistical analysis to represent the ideas of stakeholders visually through maps. A key-informant approach was used to identify stakeholder participants with expertise in aging, cancer, public health, and EOL. In two meetings, stakeholders used the maps to develop short-, intermediate-, and long-term recommendations for EOL initiatives. Study 2 (October 2003 to September 2004) involved a modified Delphi process with three iterations to prioritize recommendations for initial action from among a group of short-term recommendations.
Study 1 resulted in 103 recommendations for EOL initiatives across nine domains. Study 2 resulted in consensus on five initial recommendations from three domains: identifying an EOL point of contact in state health departments, collecting and analyzing data about EOL, incorporating EOL principles into state comprehensive cancer control plans, educating the public about hospice and palliative care, and educating the public about the importance of advance directives.
Diverse perspectives of key public health stakeholders resulted in a series of short- and longer-term recommendations for EOL action. These recommendations can guide future efforts by state health departments and other public health agencies to address EOL issues.

Download full-text


Available from: Mary Kane
  • Source
    • "Several projects have used concept mapping to create logic models (Anderson et al., 2006), prioritize strategies (Rao et al., 2005), and plan and evaluate programs (Rosas, 2005). Project 2, conducted from April to July, 2013, involved a Delphi process. "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Mobility, broadly defined as movement in all of its forms from ambulation to transportation, is critical to supporting optimal aging. This article describes two projects to develop a framework and a set of priority actions designed to promote mobility among community-dwelling older adults. Project 1 involved a concept-mapping process to solicit and organize action items into domains from a broad group of stakeholders to create the framework. Concept mapping uses qualitative group processes with multivariate statistical analysis to represent the ideas visually through maps. A snowball technique was used to identify stakeholders (n = 211). A 12-member steering committee developed a focus prompt, "One specific action that can lead to positive change in mobility for older adults in the United States is . . ." Project 2 included a Delphi technique (n = 43) with three iterations to prioritize four to six items using results from the concept mapping rating process. Project 1 resulted in 102 items across nine domains (Research to Practice, Independence and Engagement, Built Environment and Safety, Transportation, Policy, Housing and Accessibility, Community Supports, Training, and Coordinated Action). The number of items ranged from 6 to 18 per domain. Project 2 resulted in agreement on four items that reflect the importance of promoting environmental strategies through collaborative initiatives aimed at planning and best practices focusing on environmental enhancements or transit, training of professionals, and integration of mobility into state and local public health plans. These findings can be applied to support coordinated, multidisciplinary research and practice to promote mobility among older adults.
    Full-text · Article · Oct 2014 · Health Education & Behavior
  • Source
    • "The implementation of a health promoting approach would provide an ideal opportunity for early stage care to be provided to patients who face life-limiting illness through, for example, the provision of education and information about palliative care services/illnesses that may, in turn, challenge personal fears and change attitudes (Scott, 1992). However, Kellehear (2009) warns against merely understanding health promoting palliative care purely as an approach to changing attitudes through awareness raising, education provision and increasing access to services as suggested by Rao et al. (2005). He emphasises the need to work in partnership with communities to stimulate community change and develop community led supports. "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: People facing death or experiencing loss, are a key group who, until very recently, were excluded from the health promotion discourse (Kellehear, 1999). This is despite the fact that a focus on health (as defined by maintaining a sense of wellbeing) is important for those facing the end of life (Kellehear, 1999). Milford Care Centre is the first and only specialist palliative care provider in Ireland to consider strategically and invest financially in the area of health promoting palliative care. In 2011 a pilot Compassionate Communities Project (CCP) commenced in North West Limerick City. An evaluation of this initial pilot, completed by an independent research consultant highlighted, the views of people toward death, dying, loss and care in North West Limerick City, summarised the structure of the pilot and outlined the main outcomes and recommendations for further development (Brereton, 2012). Following the evaluation of Phase One of the CCP, Milford Care Centre agreed that the pilot project would be extended for a further twelve months, taking the project to Phase Two (June 2012-May 2013). Phase Two of the pilot extends the project to the whole of Limerick City and to Newcastlewest, thus providing two geographic areas that are diverse in their both their location and population. Two part-time community development workers were appointed to the project, supported by a Project Advisory Committee, and managed by the Principal Social Worker. The aims of the CCP have remained consistent throughout Phase One and Two: “To enrich and support society to live compassionately with death, dying, loss and care and to demonstrate and evaluate the process of developing a compassionate community model in an Irish context.” In order to achieve these aims, three core strands of activity were proposed for Phase Two...
    Full-text · Technical Report · Jan 2013
  • Source
    • "ivity that are directly relevant to the provision of palliative care: • Public education. • Patient, family and caregiver education. • Research, epidemiology and evaluation. • Professional education. • Policy and planning. Importantly, these areas are accompanied by a set of recommendations for action; for example, in the public education cluster, Rao et. al (2005) describe strategies to raise public awareness of palliative care, increase the use of advanced health directives,"
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: This article provides a critical review of the literature relevant to the conceptual foundations of health promoting palliative care. It explores the separate emergence and evolution of palliative care and health promotion as distinct concerns in health care, and reviews the early considerations given to their potential convergence. Finally, this article examines the proposal of health promoting palliative care as a specific approach to providing end of life care through a social model of palliative care. Research is needed to explore the impact for communities, health care services and policy when such an approach is implemented within palliative care organisations.
    Full-text · Article · Jun 2010 · Critical Public Health
Show more