Normative misperceptions and temporal precedence of perceived norms and drinking

Department of Psychiatry and Behavioral Sciences, University of Washington, Box 356560, Seattle, Washington 98195-6560, USA.
Journal of studies on alcohol 04/2006; 67(2):290-9. DOI: 10.15288/jsa.2006.67.290
Source: PubMed


Previous research has shown that students overestimate the drinking of their peers, and that perceived norms are strongly associated with drinking behavior. Explanations for these findings have been based largely on cross-sectional data, precluding the ability to evaluate the stability of normative misperceptions or to disentangle the direction of influence between perceived norms and drinking. The present research was designed to evaluate (1) the stability of normative misperceptions and (2) temporal precedence of perceived norms and drinking.
Participants were college students (N = 164; 94 women) who completed assessments of perceived norms and reported behavior for drinking frequency and weekly quantity. Most participants (68%) completed the same measures again two months later.
Results indicated large and stable overestimations of peer drinking for frequency and weekly quantity. Results also showed that for weekly quantity, perceived norms predicted later drinking, but drinking also predicted later perceived norms. Results for frequency revealed perceived norms predicted later drinking, but drinking did not predict later perceived norms.
These findings underscore the importance of longitudinal designs in evaluating normative influences on drinking. The present findings suggest that normative misperceptions are stable, at least over a relatively short time period. Findings support a mutual influence model of the relationship between perceived norms and drinking quantity but are more strongly associated with conformity explanations for the relationship between perceived norms and drinking frequency. Results are discussed in terms of implications for prevention interventions.

Full-text preview

Available from:
    • "Participants' responses for each day of the week were summed to generate a typical weekly drinking variable. Previous research has established the Daily Drinking Questionnaire to have good concurrent validity and test–retest reliability (Marlatt et al., 1998; Neighbors et al., 2006). "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Objective: Although the concepts of harmonious and obsessive passion have been productive in explaining why people eagerly engage in such activities as sports, Internet use, and gambling, previous research has not yet extended these models to explain alcohol and marijuana use among college students. The current research was conducted to clarify the relationships among harmonious and obsessive passion, alcohol and marijuana use, and negative consequences. Method: Two studies were conducted using online assessments. In Study 1, 748 heavy drinking college students (58% female) were recruited and completed measures of passion for drinking alcohol, alcohol use, and alcohol-related negative consequences. In Study 2, 352 regular marijuana-using students (54% female) were recruited and completed assessments of marijuana passion, marijuana use, and marijuana-related consequences. Results: Study 1 found that among heavy drinking college students, harmonious passion was a stronger predictor of increased consumption than was obsessive passion, whereas obsessive passion was a stronger predictor of alcohol-related problems than was harmonious passion. Study 2 revealed similar findings with regard to harmonious passion predicting marijuana consumption; however, unlike Study 1, no significant difference between the passions was found in predicting marijuana-related problems. Conclusions: This research provides a novel perspective on motivation for alcohol and marijuana use. Findings suggest that understanding the locus of young adults' passion for substance use may be helpful in identifying those who are likely to develop a substance use disorder and therefore may be the most in need of assistance and intervention.
    No preview · Article · Sep 2015 · Journal of studies on alcohol and drugs
    • "In the face of mounting evidence that individual outcomes are affected by social phenomena that occur outside of one's egocentric network (e.g., see [59] [76] [113]), it is increasingly important that scholars attempt to develop a picture of the larger social network in which individuals are embedded. Scholars are also finding that alters' actual behaviors – for example, with respect to health-related behaviors such as risky sexual activity and substance use, or with respect to the supportiveness of network members – often differ from perceived behavior (e.g., see [13] [98] [108] [143]). Such findings suggest that some form of whole network data go a long way in predicting individual outcomes. "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: This paper highlights the importance of the social networks perspective in social science research and describes the main approaches to measuring social networks and closely related phenomena - including social capital and kin networks - in existing household panel surveys. It then identifies cutting-edge techniques for collecting new data on social networks within the context of a household panel survey design. We focus in particular on possible extensions to traditional egocentric network data collection, the proper enumeration of kin networks and social support in unstable and complex families, measurement of communication via information and communication technology, and identification of the social network properties of social media participation.
    No preview · Article · Aug 2015 · Journal of economic and social measurement
    • "To derive typical alcohol consumption, we added the number of drinks consumed during an average week. The Daily Drinking Questionnaire is sensitive to differences in students' drinking because it has no fixed endpoint (Larimer et al., 2001) and has good test–retest reliability (Neighbors, Dillard, Lewis, Bergstrom, & Neil, 2006). Figure 1) We tested an eight-factor measurement model for the CMNI–29 using confirmatory factor analysis. 2 To set the metric of the latent variables, we set the variances to 1, and all loadings were free to vary. "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: The transition from high school to college has been characterized as a vulnerable periodmarked by increased involvement in high-risk behaviors such as alcohol use (Fromme, Corbin, & Kruse, 2008) and heavy drinking (Sher & Rutledge, 2007). Drinking games (DGs) in particular can contribute to problematic alcohol use among college students. Although it has been suggested that DGs are a male-dominated drinking activity (Pedersen & LaBrie, 2008; Borsari, 2004), to our knowledge, there have been no published studies to date examining the role of gender-relevant factors and DGs participation. One gender-relevant factor is masculine norms, which describe the societal beliefs, values, and expectations about what it means to be a 3man ́(Mahalik et al., 2003). Masculine norms have been found to be associated with alcohol use not just among college men, but also among Asian American college men specifically. Whether or not there are similar associations between masculine norms and DGs participation is unknown. As such, the degree to which these relationships vary as a function of race/ethnicity warrants further inquiry. Pedersen and LaBrie (2006) found that White students reported more frequent DGs participation and drank more while gaming than non-White students. Controlling for typical alcohol consumption, the present study examined the associations between distinct masculine norms and frequency of DGs participation, and tested whether such relationships are similar between White and Asian American college freshmen men. Participants consisted of 475 college freshmen men (mean age=18.1; White, n=338; Asian American, n=137) attending a large public university in the Mid-Atlantic region of the U.S. Participants completed a web-based survey and reported how often they played DGs, their daily drinking behaviors, and completed the Conformity to Masculine Norms Inventory-29. Using structural equation modeling, we found that conformity to playboy masculine norms was positively associated with frequency of participation in DGs among the total sample. However, the associations between masculine norms and DGs participation differed between Whites and Asian Americans, such that conformity to the masculine norms of being a playboy and heterosexual presentation were significantly associated with more frequent DGs participation for White but not Asian American men. Heterosexual presentation was positively associated with frequent participation in DGs for White men, even while controlling for typical alcohol consumption. This is contrary to prior research, which found heterosexual presentation to be protective against increased alcohol use (Iwamoto et al., 2014). Perhaps DGs are a specific type of social drinking activity that is attractive to those seeking to showcase 3manly ́ways of consuming alcohol (i.e., heavy consumption and being able to hold one's liquor). College clinical practitioners and health providers could assess conformity to masculine norms, with careful attention given to White, male freshmen. Practitioners could in turn use such information in individual or group settings to facilitate discussion and encourage reflection on how these norms may place certain students at risk for DGs participation (Iwamoto et al., 2014). In closing, the present study contributes to our understanding of distinct masculine norms and their relevance to DGs participation for specific racial/ethnic groups.
    No preview · Conference Paper · Aug 2015
Show more