Family Perspectives on Pathways to Mental Health Care for Children and Youth in Rural Communities

Community Health Systems Resource Group, The Hospital for Sick Children, Toronto, Ontario, Canada.
The Journal of Rural Health (Impact Factor: 1.45). 02/2006; 22(2):182-8. DOI: 10.1111/j.1748-0361.2006.00029.x
Source: PubMed


There is insufficient literature documenting the mental health experiences and needs of rural communities, and a lack of focus on children in particular. This is of concern given that up to 20% of children and youth suffer from a diagnosable mental health problem.
This study examines issues of access to mental health care for children and youth in rural communities from the family perspective.
In-depth interviews were conducted in rural Ontario, Canada, with 30 parents of children aged 3-17 who had been diagnosed with emotional and behavioral disorders.
Interview data indicate 3 overall thematic areas that describe the main barriers and facilitators to care. These include personal, systemic, and environmental factors. Family members are constantly negotiating ongoing tension, struggle, and contradiction vis-à-vis their attempts to access and provide mental health care. Most factors identified as barriers are also, under different circumstances, facilitators. Analysis clustered around the contrasts, contradictions, and paradoxes present throughout the interviews.
The route to mental health care for children in rural communities is complex, dynamic, and nonlinear, with multiple roadblocks. Although faced with multiple roadblocks, there are also several factors that help minimize these barriers.

Download full-text


Available from: Katherine Boydell
  • Source
    • "We knew from the literature and from our ethnographic fieldwork of the fractures and mistreatment that many families and young people come upon when dealing with issues of mental health. We also knew that struggles in school were often related to the stigma that attaches itself to youth who experience lack of care, lack of funds and lack of meaningful service integration (Boydell et al., 2006; Tilleczek et al., 2014). Our report provided a trustworthy analysis of the complex barriers and facilitative factors relevant to the 30 families and 30 service providers we had interviewed . "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: This paper addresses the use of participatory videography as a way of knowing and bearing witness to the complexity of young lives in educational research. We outline the principles for engaging young people in participatory videography. Working in the framework of humanities-infused praxis with, for, and by young people, we explore the place of visibility and invisibility. We identify what is gained, lost and unsettled in the use of video as a cultural process and production. We offer our theoretical and aesthetic considerations in relation to two projects. The first is a project about the youth mental health system in rural Canada, wherein we explore the fractured system visually through documentary filmmaking in the cinéma vérité cinema genre. The second is a project in which we are working with young Aboriginal Canadians who are framing the intersections of mental health and technology through filmmaking. We interrogate videography as a form of cultural production with the potential for engaging young people in educative experience, symbolic activity and cultural production. Youth videography offers opportunities for comparative education research in which social and cultural analyses are made visible. We explicate videography as a potentially meaningful experience for youth and for a deeper cultural analysis in educational research while addressing the tensions surrounding its claim to veracity.
    Preview · Article · Apr 2015 · Research in Comparative and International Education
  • Source
    • "Forbes, Morgan and Janzen (2006) found that, while both rural and urban residents with dementia reported barriers to accessing healthcare such as long wait times and cost, rural residents often additionally reported that they did not know where to access care. Boydell et al. (2006) found that barriers to accessing mental healthcare for children in rural areas may include not only a lack of services and a lack of awareness of services, but also a fear of stigma related to the smaller social networks in rural communities. Overall, at least three related points emerge from a review of existing rural health services research. "

    Preview · Article · Jun 2014
  • Source
    • "Corcoran et al. (2007) stated that the fear of labeling results in the adoption of certain coping mechanisms by family members (excusing secrecy, denial). The same attributes were also observed in the study of Judge et al. (2008) and Boydell et al. (2006). Link et al. (1991) stated that psychiatric labels are associated with negative societal reactions which exacerbate the course of the person's disorder. "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: According to the clinical perspective, early diagnosis of the prodromal phase and early treatment provision in the first episode of psychosis (FEP) is able to prevent or reduce morbidity. The main aim of this study is to inventory and analyze the most important causes of treatment delay from the perspective of patients, families and healthcare providers. The secondary aim is to point out the most important consequences of treatment delay. The study was conducted on 28 patients hospitalized for FEP of a schizophrenia spectrum disorder in the Psychiatry Clinic of Timisoara and Day-care center 2009. The corresponding sample of relatives consisted of 25 relatives, and the sample of health care providers of 10 general practitioners and 11 psychiatrists. A semi-structured interview with open-ended questions was used. Data analysis generated the following themes: society's beliefs and attitude about mental illness; fear of stigma and labeling, insufficient information, lack of infrastructure from the perspective of the professionals, and modified threshold for treatment initiation. Efforts at the level of Communities as well as efforts at the level of psychiatry specialists could help individuals and their families to overcome the illness situation and improve their quality of life.
    Full-text · Article · Dec 2010 · Psychiatria Danubina
Show more