Obesity has become a critical health issue in many developed countries, including New Zealand. While the aetiology of obesity is likely to be multifactorial, overconsumption is deemed as a key behavioural contributor to the growing obesity rate. Emerging sensory nutritional research has proposed that obesity is linked to altered olfactory and gustatory sensitivities, which can in turn influence consumption, particularly of foods rich in sugar, salt, and fats. Despite being promising, empirical studies to test for this hypothesis have returned highly controversial results. The present doctoral thesis aims to ‘systematically evaluate the role of olfaction and gustation in regulating an individual’s adiposity and eating behaviour’, using well-validated psychophysical, nutritional, and food-psychological approach.
The present thesis firstly aimed to develop and test for new approaches to quantify individual chemosensory sensitivities to food-related stimuli, based on assessments of individual performance to decremental (d′(d)) and incremental (d′(i)) stimulus range. Subsequently, these sensitivity measures were analysed against inter-individual differences in adiposity measures and eating behaviour. Additional exploratory research was performed to further analyse possible factors driving chemosensory links to food-related behaviour. Two separate datasets were collected in this thesis, with Data Collection 1 involving N=70 (age range = 21-39 years, BMI range = 20.5-48.1 kg·m-2) and Data Collection 2 involving N=61 (age range = 21-39 years, BMI range = 19.7-41.5 kg·m-2) participants.
The results from the first analysis show that individuals’ sensitivities to decremental stimulus range (d′(d)) and to incremental stimulus range (d′(i)) represent distinct measures. Furthermore, the measure of d′(d) is positively associated with adiposity measures, whereas d′(i) exhibits a negative relationship. Furthermore, these two separate sensitivity measures had significant, but contradictory, relationships with snack intake and total habitual energy intake. Specifically, individuals with poor olfactory and gustatory sensitivities (high d′(d) and low d′(i)) appeared to consume more sweet versus savoury snacks, than their counterparts, pointing to an important differentiating role of snack consumption.
In the context of the aforementioned findings, the last study of the thesis tested whether exposure to olfactory and gustatory cues in a meal influences subsequent snack choice and intake. With a repeated-subject design over one control and four testing sessions, the participants had breakfasts with manipulated olfactory and gustatory characteristics and recorded their snack intake throughout the day. Results from this study revealed that high-intensity olfactory and gustatory characteristics of a meal reduce sweet snack intake and increase the non-sweet snack intake, while total snack intake is maintained across the sessions. Specifically, individuals with high gustatory sensitivity showed more sensory-specific effects compared to the low-sensitivity group. Moreover, the high-BMI group showed sensory-specific effects for low- and high-intensity sweet taste cues, in contrast, the low-BMI group showed sensory-specific effects only for the high-intensity taste cues. Overall, the findings of this specific study highlight that the olfactory and gustatory cues of a meal may have a day-long effect on snack choice, providing novel insights into the observed association between sensory sensitivity and adiposity.
Overall, this doctoral thesis systematically assessed the role of individual olfactory and gustatory sensitivities in influencing adiposity and eating behaviour. With multifactorial data ranging across sensory science, nutrition and food psychology, this thesis provides new insights into inter and intra-individual differences in olfactory and gustatory sensitivities, and their important links to eating behaviour.