ArticlePDF Available

Abstract and Figures

To characterise the distribution of silicone oil in ocular tissues in globes enucleated after complicated retinal detachment, and to document the distribution and nature of any associated inflammatory response. 9 enucleated globes that had previously undergone retinal detachment surgery with silicone oil and 7 control globes that had undergone enucleation after retinal detachment surgery (n = 2) or ocular trauma (n = 5) were studied. Sections were histologically examined using light microscopy to document the distribution of silicone oil in ocular tissues. Immunohistochemical analysis was carried out using the ABC technique and a panel of monoclonal and polyclonal antibodies. Electron microscopy was undertaken to observe the penetration of silicone oil in the trabecular meshwork of the anterior chamber drainage angle. Silicone oil was distributed throughout the globes-notably in the iris, ciliary body, retina, trabecular meshwork and epiretinal membranes. Focal areas of intraretinal silicone were associated with disorganised retinal architecture, retinectomy sites or subretinal oil. The distribution of macrophages was closely related to the distribution of silicone oil. T and B lymphocytes were not associated with silicone oil unless additional pathology was also present-for example, cyclitic membrane or uveitis. One of the nine eyes had silicone oil present in the optic nerve. In the control globes, the inflammatory response was mediated primarily by macrophages and T lymphocytes, and was less marked than that observed in the silicone oil globes. This study shows that silicone oil may be sequestered in varied ocular tissues and is associated with localised inflammation mediated by macrophages.
Content may be subject to copyright.
EXTENDED REPORT
Immunopathology of intraocular silicone oil: enucleated eyes
Louisa Wickham, Riaz H Asaria, Robert Alexander, Phil Luthert, David G Charteris
...................................................................................................................................
See end of article for
authors’ affiliations
........................
Correspondence to:
L Wickham, Moorfields Eye
Hospital, City Road, London
EC1V 2PD, UK; louisa.
wickham@moorfields.nhs.uk
Accepted
14 September 2006
Published Online First
27 September 2006
........................
Br J Ophthalmol 2007;91:253–257. doi: 10.1136/bjo.2006.103564
Aims: To characterise the distribution of silicone oil in ocular tissues in globes enucleated after complicated
retinal detachment, and to document the distribution and nature of any associated inflammatory response.
Method: 9 enucleated globes that had previously undergone retinal detachment surgery with silicone oil and
7 control globes that had undergone enucleation after retinal detachment surgery (n = 2) or ocular trauma
(n = 5) were studied. Sections were histologically examined using light microscopy to document the
distribution of silicone oil in ocular tissues. Immunohistochemical analysis was carried out using the ABC
technique and a panel of monoclonal and polyclonal antibodies. Electron microscopy was undertaken to
observe the penetration of silicone oil in the trabecular meshwork of the anterior chamber drainage angle.
Results: Silicone oil was distributed throughout the globes—notably in the iris, ciliary body, retina, trabecular
meshwork and epiretinal membranes. Focal areas of intraretinal silicone were associated with disorganised
retinal architecture, retinectomy sites or subretinal oil. The distribution of macrophages was closely related to
the distribution of silicone oil. T and B lymphocytes were not associated with silicone oil unless additional
pathology was also present—for example, cyclitic membrane or uveitis. One of the nine eyes had silicone oil
present in the optic nerve. In the control globes, the inflammatory response was mediated primarily by
macrophages and T lymphocytes, and was less marked than that observed in the silicone oil globes.
Conclusion: This study shows that silicone oil may be sequestered in varied ocular tissues and is associated
with localised inflammation mediated by macrophages.
S
ilicone oil is often used as a tamponade agent in the
treatment of complicated retinal detachments. However,
its benefits must be weighed against the risk of the
complications associated with its use—cataract, band kerato-
pathy, secondary glaucoma and potentially reduced visual
acuity.
1–5
The toxic effects of silicone oil are thought to be due
to the migration and subsequent sequestration of silicone oil
within ocular tissues as shown by several histopathological
and clinical case series.
6–14
Silicone oil has been observed in
varied intraocular structures from the cornea to the retina, and
also with progression through the optic nerve to the optic
chiasm and brain.
6812
The presence of an associated inflam-
matory response in ocular tissue has also been documented,
characteristically showing macrophages and giant cells laden
with lipid vacuoles.
13–18
In eyes that have undergone enucleation
for advanced pathology, a degree of inflammation can be
expected and it can be difficult to distinguish the inflammation
due to the underlying pathology from that attributable to
silicone oil. The nature and distribution of the inflammatory
response associated specifically with silicone oil has yet to be
characterised.
14
This study was undertaken to analyse the distribution of
silicone oil and its associated immunopathology in silicone-oil-
filled globes, and to compare it with that seen in enucleated
globes from patients with no history of silicone oil exposure. In
addition, transmission electron microscopy was carried out on
four of the silicone-oil-filled globes and on three of the control
globes to determine the nature of silicone oil migration in the
trabecular meshwork of the drainage angle.
METHODS
This study was granted ethics approval by the Moorfields local
research ethics committee (CHAD 1009).
Nine silicone-oil-filled eyes and seven control eyes enucleated
after retinal reattachment surgery were analysed. Wherever
possible, clinical case details were obtained from the referring
hospital.
Processing/staining
Formaldehyde-fixed specimens were embedded into paraffin
wax using xylene as the ante-medium. Tissue sections were
stained by the haematoxylin and eosin sequence to assess
general morphology. The immunohistochemical distribution of
CD45RO (UCHL1) and CD45 (leucocyte common antigen) for T
lymphocytes, CD20 (L26) for B lymphocytes, Mac 387 and
CD68 (PGM1) for macrophages, Cam 5.2 for retinal pigment
epithelium cells and glial fibrillary acidic protein (GFAP) for
glial tissue was studied using a conventional alkaline phos-
phatase avidin-biotin complex method. The antigens were
visualised as the red final reaction product of Vector red (Vector
Laboratories, Peterborough, UK). Appropriate negative (using
non-immune serum from the same species as the primary
antibody and at the same protein concentration) and positive
(using tissues known to express the antigen) controls were
analysed. Table 1 outlines the primary antibodies used and the
antigen retrieval information.
A semiquantitative analysis of the cellular response and
degree of silicone infiltration in intraocular tissues was under-
taken. Grade + was used to indicate the presence of silicone oil
or the presence of inflammatory cells. If silicone oil was
observed in ocular tissues in .5 high-powered fields, grade ++
was recorded. The diameter of one high-powered field was
0.5 mm. Similarly, the presence of macrophages in .5 high-
powered fields was denoted as ++.
Transmission electron microscopy
Specimens originally prepared for routine wax embedding were
dewaxed overnight in xylene, and then rehydrated to 10-min
rinses in 36100% and 1690%, 70% and 50% ethanol. After
2610-min changes of distilled water, blocks were fixed for 2 h
in 1% osmium tetroxide, dehydrated to absolute alcohol by
reversing the above process, passed through 2620-min changes
of epoxy propane and left overnight in a 1:1 mixture of epoxy
Abbreviations: GFAP, glial fibrillary acidic protein
253
www.bjophthalmol.com
propane:araldite resin. After 12 h, the specimens were placed in
100% resin for 6 h with rotation, and then embedded and cured
overnight in an oven at 60
˚
C.
Semi-thin (1 mm) sections for light microscopy and ultra-
thin (70 nm) sections for transmission electron microscopy
were cut using a Leica Ultracut S microtome fitted with a
diamond knife. Semi-thin sections were stained with alcoholic
toluidine blue. Ultra-thin sections were contrasted by sequen-
tial staining with saturated uranyl acetate in 50% ethanol
followed by lead citrate, and viewed and photographed in a
JEOL 1010 transmission electron microscope (JEOL Ltd, Tokyo,
Japan) operating at 80 kV.
RESULTS
Silicone oil globes
Clinical details
The silicone-oil-filled group consisted of six males and three
females. The average age at the time of enucleation was
40.4 years (range 11–86 years). The cause of initial presenta-
tion was rhegmatogenous retinal detachment (n = 3), pene-
trating eye injury (n = 4) and blunt trauma (n = 2). Silicone oil
was present in all nine eyes at the time of enucleation. It was
possible to document the duration of silicone oil tamponade in
six of the nine cases: the average duration was 5 years (range
7 months–14 years).
Globes
Macroscopically, seven of the nine patients were aphakic at the
time of enucleation and two patients were pseudophakic. A
total retinal detachment was observed in two globes and a
funnel retinal detachment in another two. In addition, a
suprachoroidal haemorrhage was also noted in one globe.
In the silicone-oil-filled globes, macrophage distribution was
closely related to the distribution of silicone oil (table 2). The
number of macrophages per high-powered field generally
reflected the degree of silicone oil distribution in the tissue.
When this was not the case, there was a history of secondary
pathology—for example, in one eye, an increased macrophage
response in the anterior chamber was secondary to a perforated
corneal ulcer and associated hypopyon. Similarly, one patient
(number 4) had a membrane occluding the anterior chamber
drainage angle with an associated macrophage and T lympho-
cyte infiltrate. Silicone oil was present in epiretinal membranes
on the retinal surface in all nine globes, and in seven this was
associated with a macrophage response. Giant cells were
observed in epiretinal membranes in three globes. In four eyes
silicone oil was found in the retina, with focal areas of retinal
infiltration by macrophages occurring at retinectomy sites
(either in the anterior frill of residual retina or at the posterior
margin of the retinectomy), in grossly disorganised retina, or
associated with the presence of subretinal silicone oil (fig 1).
Silicone oil sequestered in the drainage angle, iris, ciliary body,
retina and in epiretinal membrane was notable by the presence
of small eccentric pigment granules in and adjacent to
microglobules of oil. In lipid-laden macrophages, these pigment
granules were also observed in and surrounding the phago-
cytosed silicone microglobule (fig 1). These pigment granules
were not observed in silicone oil found in the optic nerve (fig 2).
Silicone oil, in association with macrophages, was present in
the optic nerve in one patient who had a history of prolonged
raised intraocular pressure due to secondary glaucoma 3 years
after his initial surgery (fig 2). In this eye, silicone oil was
observed in an epiretinal membrane but was not found
elsewhere in the globe.
T lymphocytes were seen in five of the nine specimens. When
present, T lymphocytes were found in cyclitic membranes
(n = 1), proliferative vitreoretinopathy epiretinal membranes
(n = 1), in membranes occluding the anterior chamber drai-
nage angle (n = 2) and perivascularly in areas of inflammation
(n = 4; fig 3). Perivascular populations of T lymphocytes were
also found in the choroid and sclera (n = 4). T lymphocytes
were not distributed in association with silicone oil. B
lymphocytes were found in three of the nine specimens.
When present, B lymphocyte populations were found together
with T lymphocytes.
The distribution of retinal GFAP was increased in all nine
globes, being observed in all retinal layers. This did not differ
from the control globes, where GFAP distribution was also
increased in all seven eyes.
Transmission electron microscopy of the globes showed
silicone oil in the trabecular meshwork in three of the four
patients analysed (fig 4). Silicone oil was seen as discrete
Table 1 Antigens studied
Antigen Target Antibody source Antigen retrieval* Antibody dilution
CD45RO T lymphocytes Dako Heat mediated 1:800
CD45 T lymphocytes Dako Heat mediated 1:800
CD20cy B lymphocytes Dako Heat mediated 1:600
Mac 387 Macrophages Dako Trypsin 1:100
CD68 Macrophages Dako Trypsin 1:100
Cam 5.2 RPE cells BD Biosciences Trypsin 1:50
GFAP Glial tissue Dako Trypsin 1:2000
GPAF, glial fibrillary acidic protein; RPE, retinal pigment epithelium.
Dako, Ely, UK; BD Biosciences, California, USA.
*Tissue sections were treated either by heat mediation, performed in an 800-W microwave oven by heating 50 g/l urea
in 50 mM TRIS-HCl buffer, pH 9.5, for 10 min, followed by cooling for a further 25 min; or by trypsination, performed in
a37
˚
C incubator by exposure to 1 g/l trypsin in 100 mM TRIS-HCl buffer, pH 7.8, for 15 min.
Figure 1 Immunochemistry of the anterior edge of a retinectomy site in an
enucleated globe after treatment with silicone oil. Intraretinal macrophages
(CD68 antibody (red), haematoxylin counterstain) containing
phagocytosed silicone oil (arrow) and eccentric pigment granules
(arrowhead) are shown. Original magnification 6400.
254 Wickham, Asaria, Alexander, et al
www.bjophthalmol.com
microglobules with small eccentric pigment granules (fig 5) on
light microscopy.
Control globes
Clinical details
In the control group, five cases were male and two cases female.
The average age at the time of enucleation was 45.7 years
(range 23–71 years). The presenting pathologies were rhegma-
togenous retinal detachment (n = 2), penetrating eye injury
(n = 4) and blunt trauma (n = 1).
Globes
Macroscopically, one patient was aphakic and six patients were
phakic. A total retinal detachment was noted in three globes
and a funnel retinal detachment in one. A staphyloma and
encirclement band was also observed in one globe.
In the control population, T lymphocytes were present in five
of the seven globes. As in the case of the globes containing
silicone oil, T lymphocytes were found in epiretinal proliferative
vitreoretinopathy membranes (n = 2), cyclitic membranes
(n = 2) and perivascularly (n = 3). B lymphocytes were found
in association with T lymphocytes in two eyes. Macrophage
infiltration was much less marked than that seen in the
silicone-oil-filled eyes, and their distribution mirrored that of T
lymphocytes. A scanty distribution of macrophages was also
seen in areas of chronically detached retina and subretinal fluid
(fig 6). In this group, optically empty spaces similar to those
found in the silicone-oil-filled group were noted (fig 6)
distributed in the retinal architecture and choroid. These spaces
were not found in any other ocular structure, and could be
distinguished from those found in the silicone-oil-filled globes
by the absence of localised inflammatory cells and pigment
granules.
Staining for GFAP was observed throughout the retinal layers
in all seven control globes. Comparison of the silicone oil globes
and the controls showed no differences in the distribution of
GFAP.
DISCUSSION
This study shows widespread infiltration of ocular tissue by
silicone oil, in agreement with the findings of several previous
reports.
5–14
In addition, by immunohistochemical analysis we
have shown that the intraocular inflammatory response
associated with sequestered silicone oil differs from that seen
in eyes with similar pathologies but without silicone oil.
Examination of nine globes exposed to silicone oil found that
the oil was closely associated with localised inflammation,
suggesting that the inflammatory response was at least partly
attributable to the presence of silicone oil rather than coexisting
ocular pathology. Further evidence of this is the absence of an
intense localised macrophage response in control eyes.
Macrophages often contained phagocytosed silicone oil and
seemed to remain viable despite large volumes of silicone oil in
the cell, a finding that has been noted in other studies.
17 19
Inflammatory responses mediated by T and B lymphocytes
were not found in regions of silicone sequestration unless
associated with other pathology—for example, cyclitic mem-
branes, which suggests that these cells do not have a major role
in the response to the presence of silicone oil. This was also
supported by similar findings in the control globes where T and
B lymphocyte infiltration was observed at sites of intraocular
Figure 2 Light photomicrograph (haematoxylin and eosin) showing the
presence of silicone oil in the cupped optic nerve head. Original
magnification 6100.
Table 2 Distribution of silicone oil in intraocular tissues of the silicone oil globes
Patient
ERM Retina Optic nerve Ciliary body Iris Angle/TM Cornea Conjunctiva
Oil M Oil M Oil M Oil M Oil M Oil M Oil M Oil M
1 ++ ++ + –––++ ++ + ++ ++ ++ ––++
2 ++ ++ + + NA NA ++++––––NANA
3 ++ ––+ ––+++ + ––––––
4 ++ ++ ––––––++ ––++
5 ++ ++ + + –––+ ––––––
6 + –––––––+++ + ––––
7 ++ ++ ––––––+ ––––––
8 ++ ++ + + ––+++++++ ++
9 ++––++ + ––––––––
ERM, epiretinal membrane; M, macrophage distribution; TM, trabecular meshwork; NA = specimen did not contain this structure; +, presence of silicone oil or
inflammatory cells; ++, silicone oil was observed in ocular tissues in .5 high-powered fields; –, absent.
Figure 3 Immunohistochemistry of a control globe showing perivascular T
lymphocytes (arrow: CD45 antibody (red), haematoxylin counterstain).
Original magnification 6200.
Immunopathology of intraocular silicone oil 255
www.bjophthalmol.com
inflammation (epiretinal and cyclitic membranes and perivas-
cularly) and in the subretinal fluid of chronic detachments.
Our study also supports the findings of two previous studies
which observed that tissue infiltrated with silicone oil is usually
confined to the retinal surface.
20 21
In the silicone-oil-filled
globes, intraretinal silicone oil was observed only when the
retinal architecture was considerably disorganised—for exam-
ple, at retinectomy sites or in areas where subretinal oil was
noted. A similar finding was reported by Kirchhof et al
22
in a
case series of eight eyes in which intraretinal silicone oil was
absent unless accompanied by subretinal oil. In addition, it has
been hypothesised that the integrity of the outer limiting
membrane may impede further silicone oil migration.
23
Silicone oil was observed in the optic nerve of one globe in a
patient with a history of raised intraocular pressure after oil
injection. In a previously reported series of 74 globes, silicone
oil was present in the optic nerve in 14 cases (24%), and in 10 of
the 14 eyes with silicone oil in the optic nerve, there was a
history of raised intraocular pressure after silicone oil injection,
6
a finding that has also been documented in other case
reports.
924
Migration of silicone oil into the optic nerve may
be responsible for cases of unexplained visual loss before and
after silicone oil removal, which have recently been
reported.
25 26
Our study also showed ultrastructural evidence of silicone in
the trabecular meshwork in four patients, and immunohisto-
chemically we found a macrophage response associated with oil
in the meshwork. A previous study failed to show evidence of
silicone oil or macrophages in the drainage angle in two
patients with secondary glaucoma attributed to silicone oil.
27
The differences between these studies and the drainage angle
findings may be related to sampling artefacts depending on
which part of the angle is studied. Overall, our results suggest
trabecular infiltration by silicone oil and an associated
trabeculitis. These changes are likely to persist even after oil
removal, and may well account for the chronically raised
intraocular pressure seen in eyes that have previously had
intraocular silicone oil.
It should be noted, however, that the globes studied have in
general advanced intraocular pathology (as is the case in
previous similar series), and the infiltration of silicone oil we
have found may not reflect its distribution in eyes with less
advanced pathology and shorter durations of silicone oil
exposure. We have noted in a series of retinectomy specimens
(where pathological changes are less advanced) that silicone
infiltration into the retina was uncommon and generally
confined to regions of disorganised and gliotic retina (data
submitted). Nevertheless, the widespread distribution of
silicone oil suggests its potential (given appropriate intraocular
conditions such as retinal scarring) to cause ongoing pathology.
The difficulty of having complete certainty in detecting
silicone oil in intraocular tissue deserves emphasis. Silicone oil
is removed during the routine processing of tissue for
histological analysis, and therefore its presence appears as
optically empty spaces in tissue sections. Similar findings are
also found in tissues that have not been exposed to silicone
oil,
21–23
and may be due to tissue oedema, gliosis or processing
artefacts. In long-standing retinal detachment or other
advanced retinal pathology, areas of retinal oedema may be
seen as rounded, optically empty spaces, and can be very
difficult to distinguish from silicone oil. In the current study,
the presence of silicone oil was closely related to an
inflammatory response that can suggest the presence of foreign
material. We observed that optically empty spaces due to
silicone oil were also associated with small eccentric granules of
Figure 4 Transmission electron micrograph showing the presence of
silicone oil in the trabecular meshwork of the anterior chamber in a globe
treated with silicone oil (arrow). Original magnification 62000.
Figure 5 Transmission electron micrograph of a microglobule of silicone
oil in the trabecular meshwork with eccentric pigment granules (arrow).
Magnification 65000.
Figure 6 Immunochemistry showing optically empty spaces (arrow heads)
seen in the retina of a control globe. A single macrophage (CD68 antibody
(red), haematoxylin counterstain) is also shown (arrow). Original
magnification 6200.
256 Wickham, Asaria, Alexander, et al
www.bjophthalmol.com
pigment both within and surrounding the oil globule,
apparently related to the macrophage-mediated inflammatory
response as shown in fig 1. This finding was not seen in
optically empty spaces in the control specimens (fig 6).
In conclusion, this study has shown that silicone oil may be
sequestered in varied ocular tissues—notably iris, ciliary body,
trabecular meshwork, retina and epiretinal membranes. In
globes with advanced pathology, silicone oil seems to initiate a
localised inflammatory response mediated by macrophages,
whereas other associated ocular pathology is characterised by
a marked T lymphocyte infiltrate, with some involvement of
B lymphocytes and macrophages. Our findings suggest that
intraretinal oil usually occurs as a result of persistent retinal
detachment or retinal injury; however, sequestration of silicone
oil in other tissues, notably the drainage angle, ciliary body and
optic nerve, may occur despite retinal reattachment surgery.
Removal of silicone oil may not reverse the inflammatory cycle
initiated by its injection, and explains the ability of silicone oil
to cause multiple long-term sequelae.
Authors’ affiliations
.......................
Louisa Wickham, David G Charteris, Moorfields Eye Hospital, London, UK
Riaz H Asaria, Royal Free Hospital, London, UK
Robert Alexander, Phil Luthert, Institute of Ophthalmology, London, UK
Competing interests: None declared.
REFERENCES
1 Leaver P. Complications of intraocular silicone oil. Retina. 2nd edn. Ryan SJ,
Glaser BM, eds. St Louis, MO: Mosby, 1994.
2 Watzke RC. Silicone retinopoesis for retinal detachment: a long-term clinical
evaluation. Arch Ophthalmol 1967;77:185–96.
3 Abrams GW, Azen S, McCuen B, et al. Vitrectomy with silicone oil or long-acting
gas in eyes with severe proliferative vitreoretinopathy: results of additional long-
term follow up. Silicone Study Report 11. Arch Ophthalmol 1997;115:335–44.
4 Foulks G, Hatchell D, Proia A, et al. Histopathology of silicone oil keratopathy in
humans. Cornea 1991;10:29–37.
5 Honavar S, Goyal M, Majji A, et al. Glaucoma after pars plana vitrectomy and
silicone oil injection for complicated retinal detachments. Ophthalmology
1999;106:169–77.
6 Budde M, Cursiefen C, Holbach LM, et al. Silicone oil-associated optic nerve
degeneration. Am J Ophthalmol 2001;131:392–4.
7 Srinivasan A, Singh AK, Desai SP, et al. Foreign body episcleral granulomas
complicating intravitreal silicone oil tamponade – a clinicopathological study.
Ophthalmology 2003;110:1837–40.
8 Eckle D, Kampik A, Hintschich C, et al. Visual field defect in association with
chiasmal migration of intraocular silicone oil. Br J Ophthalmol 2005;89:918–20.
9 Ni C, Wang W, Albert D, et al. Intravitreous silicone injection – histopathological
findings in a human eye after 12 years. Arch Ophthalmol 1983;101:1399–401.
10 Chung J, Spaide R. Intraretinal silicone oil vacuoles after macular hole surgery
with internal limiting membrane peeling. Am J Ophthalmol 2003;136:766–7.
11 Donahue SP, Friberg TR, Johnson BL. Intraconjunctival cavitary inclusions of
silicone oil complicating retinal detachment repair. Am J Ophthalmol
1992;114:639–40.
12 Eller A, Friberg T, Mah F. Migration of silicone oil into the brain:a complication of
intraocular silicone oil for retinal tamponade. Am J Ophthalmol
2000;129:685–8.
13 Shaikh S, Egbert, Goldblum, et al. Granulomatous local cell reaction to
intravitreal silicone. Arch Ophthalmol 2000;118:1133–4.
14 Knorr HLJ, Seltsam A, Holbach LM, et al. Intraocular silicone oil: a
clinicopathological study of 36 enucleated eyes. Ophthalmologe
1996;93:130–8.
15 Parmley VC, Barishak YR, Howes EL, et al. Foreign-body giant cell reaction to
liquid silicone. Am J Ophthalmol 1986;101:680–3.
16 Heidenkummer HP, Messmer EM, Kampik A. Recurrent vitreoretinal membranes
during intravitreal silicone oil tamponade. Morphological and
immunohistochemical investigations. Ophthalmologe 1996;93:121–5.
17 Betis F, Leguay JM, Hofman P. Multinucleated giant cells in periretinal silicone
granulomas are associated with progressive proliferative vitreoretinopathy.
Eur J Ophthalmol 2003;13:634–41.
18 Jerden J, Pepose J, Michels R, et al. Proliferative vitreoretinopathy membranes –
an immunohistochemical study. Ophthalmology 1989;96:801–10.
19 Bornfeld N, El-Hifnawi E, Laqua H. Ultrastructural characteristics of preretinal
membranes from human eyes filled with silicone oil. Am J Ophthalmol
1987;103:770–5.
20 Lewis H, Burke JM, Abrams GW, et al. Perisilicone proliferation after vitrectomy
for proliferative vitreoretinopathy. Ophthalmology 1988;95:583–91.
21 Eckardt C, Nicolai U, Czank M, et al. Identification of silicone oil in the retina
after intravitreal injection. Retina 1992;12:S17–22.
22 Kirchhof B, Tavakolian H, Heimann K. Histopathological findings in eyes after
silicone oil injection. Graefe’s Arch Clin Exp Ophthalmol 1986;224:34–7.
23 Shikishima K, Ohki K, Machi N, et al. Effects and distribution of intravitreally or
subretinally injected silicone oil identified in rabbit retina using osmium tetroxide
method. Jpn J Ophthalmol 1992;36:469–78.
24 Shields C, Eagle R. Pseudo-Schnabel’s cavernous degeneration of the optic nerve
secondary to intraocular oil. Arch Ophthalmol 1989;107:714–17.
25 Newsom RS, Johnston R, Sullivan PM, et al. Sudden visual loss after removal of
silicone oil. Retina 2004;24:871–7.
26 Herbert EN, Habib M, Steel D, et al. Central scotoma associated with intraocular
silicone oil tamponade develops before oil removal. Graefe’s Arch Clin Exp
Ophthalmol 2006;244(2):248–52.
27 Cvenkel B, Zupan M, Hvala A. Transmission electron microscopic analysis of
trabecular meshwork in secondary glaucoma after intravitreal silicone oil
injection. Int Ophthalmol 1997;20:43–7.
Immunopathology of intraocular silicone oil 257
www.bjophthalmol.com
... Thus, on the one hand, the clinically detectable SO droplets may represent only a minimal part of the whole SO emulsion; on the other hand, an uncertain amount of small SO droplets may be present intraocularly in absence of any clinical evidence. Emulsified SO droplets may play a crucial role in the pathogenesis of most of the complications potentially associated with SO tamponade, such as intraocular inflammation, ocular hypertension, glaucoma, keratopathy, optic neuropathy, epiretinal membranes (ERM), and fibrosis [2,56,61,74,75]. ...
... With regard to intraretinal SO, whether the intraretinal hyperreflective dots represent migrated or phagocytosed SO-emulsified droplets is still unclear [82]. Indeed, on one hand, the presence of macrophages containing phagocytosed SO has been demonstrated histologically in ERM and intraretinally after SO tamponade [61,74]; on the other hand, emulsified SO may migrate within retinal layers, in particular in the presence of iatrogenic defects of inner limiting membrane (ILM) [82,85]. Odrobina et al. [84] analyzed 24 SO-filled eyes and suggested that the appearance of hyperreflective round-shaped bodies may be time-dependent since their incidence increased as the follow-up lengthened. ...
... The pathogenesis of SO-associated retinal changes is not yet fully understood and multiple mechanisms have been suggested to contribute to their development. Mechanical stress and biochemical toxicity have been initially suggested to have a primary role in the set of microstructural retinal alterations demonstrated histologically in enucleated eyes after SO tamponade, also described as "SO-associated retinopathy" [6,74]. The experimental evidence of decreased viability of ARPE-19 cells after contact with SO on the basolateral side but not on the apical surface, supported a direct negative mechanical effect of SO on the retinal tissue [119]. ...
Article
Full-text available
Silicone oils (SO) are used as long-term intraocular tamponades and have an irreplaceable role in vitreoretinal surgery. They can, however, be associated with multiple and potentially severe complications, involving different ocular tissues, in particular retina and cornea. Recent advances in ophthalmic imaging have allowed the precise characterization of retinal and corneal microstructural changes, at a subclinical level. This detailed analysis of SO-related retinal and corneal changes has improved our understanding of their pathogenesis and offer the potential for optimized monitoring and management of patients with SO-filled eyes. This review aims to provide clinicians and ophthalmic scientists with an updated and comprehensive overview of the corneal and retinal changes associated with SO tamponade.
... The correlation between SO emulsi cation and elevated IOP, as observed in prior studies [9,13] was con rmed in our study. Wickham et al used transmission electron microscopy and detected SO in the trabecular meshwork [14]. In addition, Rentsch et al [15] reported SO-laden macrophages within the trabecular meshwork of three human eyes, which were enucleated due to glaucoma following SO injection. ...
... In addition, Rentsch et al [15] reported SO-laden macrophages within the trabecular meshwork of three human eyes, which were enucleated due to glaucoma following SO injection. It has also been proposed that SO might initiate localized in ammation in the trabecular meshwork [14,16]. Here, we found that impregnation of the ACA was more frequent in patients with IOP > 21 mmHg or using antiglaucoma medications (Supplementary Table 4). ...
Preprint
Full-text available
Background To investigate the characteristics of silicone oil (SO) emulsification after vitrectomy for rhegmatogenous retinal detachment (RRD) and possible correlations with clinical factors. Methods Patients who underwent primary pars plana vitrectomy with SO injection for RRD followed by SO removal at the Eye and ENT Hospital of Fudan University between January 2016 and January 2020 were included. Ultrasound biomicroscopy (UBM) images of the anterior segment were taken before SO removal. Eight signs of SO emulsification in the UBM images were graded as 1 (present) or 0 (not present) and the grades for all signs in each eye were summed. Correlations between SO emulsification grade and clinical factors were determined. Results A total of 118 patients (118 eyes) were enrolled in this study. Emulsified SO particles were found in all 118 eyes (100%). The eight signs were more frequently detected in the superior part of the eye. The mean total SO emulsification grade was 19.99 ± 12.98 (range: 1–36). Younger age and male (both P < 0.05) were associated with higher total SO emulsification grade. Patients with intraocular pressure (IOP) > 21 mmHg or the use of antiglaucoma medications at the time of SO removal had a higher total SO emulsification grade, were younger, and were more frequently male (all P < 0.05) than patients without ocular hypertension. Conclusions UBM could play an important role in the diagnosis and grading of SO emulsification. Younger patients and males are more prone to SO emulsification, which may lead to elevated IOP.
... Our study found the correlation between SO emulsification and elevated IOP, which was also observed in prior studies (9,13). Wickham et al. used transmission electron microscopy and detected SO in the trabecular meshwork (14). In addition, Rentsch et al. (15) reported SO-laden macrophages within the trabecular meshwork of three human eyes, which were enucleated due to glaucoma following SO injection. ...
... In addition, Rentsch et al. (15) reported SO-laden macrophages within the trabecular meshwork of three human eyes, which were enucleated due to glaucoma following SO injection. It has also been proposed that SO might initiate localized inflammation in the trabecular meshwork (14,16). Formerly Federman and Schubert (2) reported that 100% of eyes injected with SO showed some degree of emulsification. ...
Article
Full-text available
Purpose: To investigate the characteristics of silicone oil (SO) emulsification after vitrectomy for rhegmatogenous retinal detachment (RRD) and possible correlations with clinical factors. Methods: Patients who underwent primary pars plana vitrectomy with SO injection for RRD followed by SO removal at the Eye and ENT Hospital of Fudan University between January 2016 and January 2020 were included. Ultrasound biomicroscopy (UBM) images of the anterior segment were taken before SO removal. Eight signs of SO emulsification in the UBM images were graded as 1 (present) or 0 (not present) and the grades for all signs in each eye were summed. Correlations between SO emulsification grade and clinical factors were determined. Results: A total of 118 patients (118 eyes) were enrolled in this study. Emulsified SO particles were found in all 118 eyes (100%). The eight signs were more frequently detected in the superior part of the eye. The mean total SO emulsification grade was 19.99 ± 12.98 (range: 1–36). Younger age and male (both P < 0.05) were associated with higher total SO emulsification grade. Patients with intraocular pressure (IOP) > 21 mmHg or the use of antiglaucoma medications at the time of SO removal had a higher total SO emulsification grade, were younger, and were more frequently male (all P < 0.05) than patients without ocular hypertension. Conclusions: UBM could play an important role in the diagnosis and grading of SO emulsification. Younger patients and males are more prone to SO emulsification, which may lead to elevated IOP.
... In addition, electron microscopy of enucleated eyes previously filled with SO showed evidence of tiny emulsified SO droplets within the trabecular meshwork, suggesting that simply removing the visible bulk of SO does not necessary mean that the trabecular meshwork is free of SO and that IOP will drop. 34 Budenz et al. 13 argued that SO removal alone to control IOP tends to result in uncontrolled IOP with an increased need for glaucoma surgery. Furthermore, Moisseiev et al. 12 reported that after SO removal alone, IOP control could not be achieved in their patients even after glaucoma surgery was performed. ...
Article
Full-text available
Objectives Our aim was to perform a perfluorobutylpentane (F4H5) washout in conjunction with glaucoma drainage device (GDD) placement in patients with silicone oil (SO)-induced glaucoma. In this report we present our preliminary results concerning the effectiveness in clearing the SO and the safety of the procedure. Materials and Methods Eight patients who previously underwent pars plana vitrectomy with SO tamponade due to retinal detachment were selected. Removal of SO was performed on average 10 months after initial surgery. All patients developed glaucoma with evidence of SO remnants in the anterior chamber (AC) and angle. Removal of the remaining SO with F4H5 washout was performed in all cases with concomitant insertion of a GDD to treat the refractory glaucoma. Intraocular pressure (IOP), SO remnants, endothelial cell count, and need for glaucoma medications were evaluated up to 12 months after the surgical procedure. Results All patients had uneventful surgery with no major complications 12 months postoperatively. A marked reduction of SO remnants in the AC and angle was observed in all cases after surgery. There was a 60.9% decrease in mean IOP 12 months postoperatively (p<0.05) and the need for glaucoma medication was lower in all patients (mean topical medicines: 4 preoperatively vs. 0.75±0.89 postoperatively; p<0.05). Endothelial cell density showed no significant change (mean 2012±129 cells/mm² preoperatively vs. 1985±134 cells/mm² postoperatively; p>0.05), and there were no signs of corneal edema. Conclusion F4H5 is an effective emulsifier for removing SO remnants and may be safely used in conjunction with GDD placement in order to control IOP in eyes with silicone oil-induced glaucoma.
... 4 Although the effects of SO on various ocular structures such as cornea, trabecular meshwork, retina, and optic nerve, have been studied, no speci c study has investigated the changes occurring in the lamina cribrosa (LC) after SO injection. 5 LC is a collagenous meshwork trabecula that is located in the posterior scleral canal of the optic nerve head. 6 It surrounds and supports retinal ganglion cell (RGC) axons, the central retinal vein and the central retinal artery. ...
Preprint
Full-text available
Purpose To assess changes in lamina cribrosa (LC) characteristics in eyes with silicone oil (SO) due to rhegmatogenous retinal detachment (RRD). Method This cross-sectional contralateral eye study was conducted on 49 patients with unilateral RRD who underwent pars plana vitrectomy and SO injection. The contralateral eyes served as controls. Thickness and depth of LC of both eyes of the participants were evaluated using enhanced depth imaging technique via optical coherence tomography. Results The average age of the participants was 57.6 ± 10.5 years and the mean duration of post-op SO retainment was 1.7 ± 6.4 months. The mean LCD in eyes with SO tamponade was 347.6 ± 64.3 µm, whereas, in healthy eyes, it was 329.6 ± 76.7 µm (P = 0.232). On the other hand, the LC in eyes with SO tamponade was significantly thinner compared to that in healthy eyes (270.1 ± 45.1 µm and 303.2 ± 48.6 µm, respectively) (P < 0.0001). Subgroup analysis revealed that after excluding patients who were underwent anti-glaucoma medications, similar findings was resulted. Conclusion We showed that eyes with silicone oil exhibit a significantly thinner LC compared to healthy eyes, with no difference in the depth of the LC between the two groups.
... Optical coherence tomography (OCT) is a non-contact and non-invasive technology used to describe and monitor retinal layers and optic nerve morphology. It can detect retinal nerve tissue loss by quantitatively measuring RNFL thickness at high resolution [20][21][22][23]. Meanwhile, recent advances in vitreoretinal surgery have improved surgical outcomes [24]. ...
Article
Full-text available
Rhegmatogenous retinal detachment (RRD) is a serious and emergency condition that may cause visual disturbance. Treatment includes pars plana vitrectomy with a tamponade such as intraocular gas or silicone oil (SO). In many countries, silicone oil is still favorable compared to intraocular gases as tamponade for reattachment of retinal detachment surgery. The application provides a higher anatomical success rate, especially in cases of proliferative vitreoretinopathy (PVR) that were previously considered untreatable. Objective assessment of the retinal nerve fiber layer (RNFL) using optical coherence tomography (OCT) in the eye with silicone oil tamponade is a challenge because of the limitations and difficulties in taking images. This study aims to assess the RNFL thickness changes in rhegmatogenous retinal detachment patients using SO tamponade and its subsequent removal conducted on a total of 35 post-operative RRD patients. Central macular and RNFL thickness, as well as best-corrected visual acuity (BCVA), were recorded at the time of tamponade and after the removal of the SO at 1, 4, and 8 weeks, respectively. The results showed that the changes in RNFL thickness significantly decreased in the group of ≤6 months, especially in the superior and temporal quadrants, and BCVA increased after SO removal (p < 0.05). Central macular thickness was significant (p < 0.001) at the end of the visit. Improved visual acuity is associated with decreased RNFL and central macular thickness after SO removal.
... SO increases the accumulation of pro-inflammatory cytokines in the retro-silicone oil fluid. In fact, in the ocular tissues an inflammatory response happens since macrophages and giant cells with lipid vacuoles have been found [46]. Diffusion of metabolites and cytokines away from the retina was reduced in SO filled eyes [47], leading to the risk of developing intraretinal cysts and CME. ...
Article
Full-text available
Background: The aim of this study was to assess long-term macular vascular changes and their correlation with functional recovery in patients successfully treated for Macula-ON and Macula-OFF rhegmatogenous retinal detachment (RRD). Methods: This retrospective observational study included 82 eyes of 82 patients who received primary successful retinal detachment surgery, 33 Macula-ON and 49 Macula-OFF. Superficial and deep capillary plexuses (SCP and DCP) were evaluated by optical coherence tomography angiography (OCTA), and were correlated with visual acuity (VA), surgical technique and tamponade at 12 months after surgery. The fellow eyes were used as controls. Results: At 12-month follow-up, there was a significant decrease in the vessel density (VD) in the SCP in the operated eyes compared to control eyes (p < 0.05) in both the Macula-ON and Macula-OFF groups. Vessel length density (VLD) decrease in SCP was more extended in the Macula-OFF group. No difference in the DCP perfusion parameters was found, compared to controls. Subgroup analysis dependent on the type of surgery or tamponade showed no significant differences of VD and VLD. An inverse correlation was found between the SCP VD and the duration of silicone oil (SO) tamponade (p = 0.039). A significant correlation was observed between parafoveal SCP VD and final best corrected visual acuity (BCVA) (p = 0.028). The multivariate linear regression analysis showed that only the type of tamponade was significantly correlated with the final BCVA in the Macula-ON group (p = 0.004). Conclusions: Our study described long-term perfusion changes in RRD after surgery, with lower SCP VD and VLD in the operated eyes compared to the fellow ones, not influenced by type of surgery or tamponade. The choice of tamponade and SO removal timing may affect functional outcomes, especially in Macula-ON RRD. In conclusion, such functional and perfusion changes can be considered biomarkers that highlight the relevance of careful management of this sight-threatening disease.
... Silicone oil (SO) has been used as an intraocular tamponade, since many years in vitreoretinal surgery, and its toxic effects on retina have been reported through several studies [1][2][3][4]. Some recent studies have reported that SO leads to a reduction in choroidal thickness (CT) [5,6], which can also be considered a toxic effect on choroidal tissues [5,7]. ...
Article
Full-text available
Purpose To investigate the effects of refractive accommodation on subfoveal choroidal thickness (SFCT) in silicone oil (SO)-filled eyes. Methods This retrospective, self-comparative study was conducted on 40 patients with unilateral macula-on rhegmatogenous retinal detachment, who underwent vitrectomy and SO tamponade. The SFCT of SO-filled eyes and the fellow control eyes were measured using optical coherence tomography at their one-month visit after surgery. The patients wore soft contact positive lenses for 24 h in the SO-filled eyes, to correct their refractive error. SFCT and choroidal vascularity index (CVI) were measured before and after wearing the contact lenses. Mean SFCT was compared between SO-filled eyes and the fellow control eyes, and SFCT and CVI were compared before and after refractive error correction in the SO-filled eyes. Results Mean SFCT of SO-filled eyes (221.52 ± 38.41 um) was less than that of the fellow eyes (273.41 ± 31.30 um) ( P < 0.001). After refractive error correction, the mean SFCT increased to 269.28 ± 36.90 um( P < 0.001). However, CVI decreased from 57.01 ± 2.41 to 55.39 ± 2.39 ( P < 0.05). Conclusions SFCT reduction in SO-filled eyes was primarily due to the hyperopia status. The non-uniform change in CVI suggests that changes in CT are mainly attributed to a greater expansion of the stromal area instead of the choroidal vascular area. Trial registration This study protocol was reviewed and approved by the Ethics Committee of the Central Theater General Hospital, approval number No. [2020]058–1, retrospectively registered.
Article
Silicone oil is an established intraocular surgical aid, which enables the treatment of the most complex starting situations but no other alternative has been found; however, the available data indicate that an unclear loss of visual acuity during or after an intraocular silicone oil tamponade possibly occurs more frequently than assumed from the clinical routine. Various pathological mechanisms are under discussion as causes, but the exact causes are actually unclear. In addition to atrophic alterations in the optical coherence tomography (OCT) examination, there are a clear reduction in visual acuity and mostly a central scotoma with otherwise inconspicuous findings. Unclear loss of visual acuity can also occur after removal of the silicone oil. Whether this is caused by the same pathological mechanism is unclear. Furthermore, there are no reproducible risk factors that appear a priori to possibly cause an unclear loss of vision under silicone oil; however, oil removal as soon as possible and a good adjustment of the intraocular pressure are recommended by the authors. Overall, a silicone oil tamponade should be carefully weighed up even when using modern highly purified silicone oils and it should therefore continue to be reserved particularly for unfavorable initial situations or complicated courses with the necessity for a silicone oil tamponade. Against this background, a study for systematic recording and processing of cases of unclear loss of visual acuity after silicone oil tamponade seems to be meaningful.
Article
Objective To determine the incidence and associations of glaucoma after pars plana vitrectomy (PPV) and silicone oil injection (SOI) for complicated retinal detachments and the response to treatment.
Article
Silicone oil was injected into the eyes of 28 rabbits. Utilizing the specific affinity of osmium tetroxide for lipids, the pathological features and histochemical localization of silicone oil within the retina were studied. This osmium tetroxide technique makes it possible to identify the presence of silicone oil particles in the ocular tissues. It was demonstrated that in eyes with silicone oil injected into the vitreous cavity or subretinal space, silicone oil was detected in the inner retinal layer and in phagocytes in the vitreous cavity but not in the outer retinal layer, retinal pigment epithelium and choroid. In addition, prominent subretinal and epiretinal proliferation with abundant phagocytes containing silicone oil particles were noted in the eyes with subretinal injection of silicone oil through an artificial retinal break. This study suggests that when injected subretinally silicone oil induces excessive subretinal and epiretinal proliferation.
Article
Retinal tissue obtained from 2 eyes that had been injected with silicone oil for 2 years was stained with monoclonal antibodies against macrophages and studied by light and electron microscopy and energy-dispersive x-ray analysis. Both specimens showed areas with a relatively intact architecture as well as parts with loss of normal structure. In both areas, immunostaining showed single intraretinal macrophages. Energy-dispersive x-ray results clearly demonstrated that some of the intracellular and extracellular vacuoles within the retina represented the storage sites of silicone.
Article
Corneal endothelial decompensation is a frequent complication when silicone oil is used as a tamponade following vitrectomy for treatment of proliferative vitreoretinopathy in an aphakic eye. We evaluated the clinical, histopathological, and ultrastructural features of silicone oil-induced keratopathy in 10 patients who developed corneal complications requiring penetrating keratoplasty. Clinically, some cases showed corneal edema, corneal hypesthesia, endothelial opacification, band keratopathy, and peripheral corneal vascularization. Histopathologically, retrocorneal membranes were present, and different degrees of stromal hypercellularity, superficial stromal calcification, and vascularization were noted. The ultrastructural features of endothelial cell loss and retrocorneal membrane formation are consistent with changes previously reported in rabbits and cats receiving intracameral silicone oil injections.
Article
We removed preretinal membranes previously in contact with an intraocular silicone oil bubble from 22 human eyes for ultrastructural examination. All had membrane-bound intracytoplasmic vacuoles, which most likely had been filled with silicone oil before tissue processing. The vacuolation was more pronounced at the surface of the membrane. In the course of ingestion of silicone oil by preretinal cells, giant vacuoles may form by fusion of smaller vacuoles as these cells lack the ability to digest silicone oil.
Article
Proliferative vitreoretinopathy (PVR) is the leading cause of failure after retinal detachment surgery. Therefore, both the extracellular matrix and cellular components of preretinal membranes from 23 eyes with PVR were characterized immunohistochemically. The membrane stroma was composed primarily of types I, II, and III collagen. Laminin and both heparan sulfate proteoglycans and collagens types IV and V were co-distributed in discrete regions within the stroma. Glial and retinal pigment epithelial (RPE) cell populations were identified in these membranes using specific immunohistochemical markers as was a small but significant macrophage population. Double-labeling experiments indicated that RPE cells in these membranes expressed the class II histocompatibility antigen HLA-DR, although neither the RPE monolayer in situ nor cultured RPE cells was HLA-DR positive unless induced by gamma interferon. Only rare isolated vascular endothelial cells were detected in 5 of the 23 membranes.
Article
A 29-year-old man sustained severe trauma to his left eye requiring corneoscleral wound repair and retinal detachment repair. Because of a persistent retinal detachment, he underwent vitrectomy and silicone oil implantation into the vitreous cavity. Over the ensuing 2 years 4 months, the eye gradually became glaucomatous, blind, and painful, requiring enucleation. Histopathologic examination revealed that coalescent globules of silicone oil had infiltrated the entire length of the attached atrophic optic nerve. Superficially reminiscent of the changes seen in Schnabel's cavernous optic atrophy, this observation provides evidence for the theory of Zimmerman et al concerning the pathogenesis of cavernous degeneration of the optic nerve in glaucomatous eyes.
Article
From 1983 to 1986, silicone oil injections were used to treat 31 patients with retinal detachment (RD) and advanced proliferative vitreoretinopathy (PVR). In 19 eyes (61%), perisilicone proliferation (PSP) developed causing recurrent RDs in 15 eyes (49%). At an average of 5 weeks after surgery, PSP occurred and was characterized by extensive transparent preretinal membranes with denser focal areas. Microscopic examination of five preretinal membranes showed droplets of silicone oil and necrotic cells on the silicone side and glial or retinal pigment epithelial cells, or both, on the retinal side, often in layers separated by extracellular matrix. Silicone oil was present in periretinal membranes removed several months after the intraocular silicone had been evacuated indicating that silicone within cells may persist despite the removal of silicone. The use of silicone oil to provide tamponade in eyes with recurrent PVR is associated with a high incidence of periretinal proliferation that frequently leads to recurrent RD and visual failure.
Article
Although intravitreal injections of liquid silicone have long been used in complicated retinal detachments and long-term complications such as keratopathy, glaucoma, and cataract are well-known, the effect of liquid silicone on the retina, iris, and angle structures is not as well defined. Histopathologic study of one human eye that was enucleated 20 months after liquid silicone injection showed an intraocular foreign-body giant cell reaction.