Improving operating room efficiency through process redesign

Case Western Reserve University, Cleveland, Ohio, United States
Surgery (Impact Factor: 3.38). 10/2006; 140(4):509-14; discussion 514-6. DOI: 10.1016/j.surg.2006.06.018
Source: PubMed


Operating rooms (ORs) are important resources for patient care and revenue, yet a significant portion of OR time is taken up by nonoperative activities. We hypothesized that redesigning the process that occurs between operations would lead to a decrease in nonoperative time (NOT = room turnover time plus anesthesia induction and emergence time).
Following a 3-month multidisciplinary planning process, a prospective study to reduce NOT was initiated in 2 of 17 ORs at a tertiary care academic medical center. Unlike previous reports, which have limited the number of participants, we constructed a process that was restricted only by case duration. The plan focused on minimizing nonoperative tasks in the OR, effecting parallel performance of activities, and reducing nonclinical disruptions. Eligible cases were those with an estimated operative time of 2 hours or less. A target NOT of 35 minutes was established. Cases of similar duration in the remaining ORs served as a concurrent control group.
Twenty-three surgeons, 13 anesthesiologists, and 11 nurses worked in the project ORs over a 3-month period. Residents participated in all cases. There was a significant reduction in NOT (42.2 +/- 12.9 vs 65 +/- 21.7 minutes), turnover time (26.4 +/- 11.2 vs 42.8 +/- 21.7 minutes), and anesthesia-related time (16.9 vs 21.9 minutes, all P < .001) in the project rooms compared with cases of similar duration in control ORs. Process-related delays were identified in 70% of cases when NOT exceeded the 35-minute target.
These results demonstrate that a coordinated multidisciplinary process redesign can significantly reduce NOT. This process is applicable to most ORs and has optimal benefit for cases of 2 hours or less in duration. The high percentage of residual process-related delays suggests that further improvements can be anticipated.

Full-text preview

Available from:
    • "Operating Rooms (ORs) are important assets for hospitals as they generate the largest revenue and, at the same time, represent the largest cost source. According to " Healthcare Financial Management Association " (HFMA), ORs account for a large share of hospital care services and expenditure, at the same time, ORs result in an estimated 40% of hospital revenue[2]. Therefore, small improvements in efficiency could translate into significant savings and benefits to the patient as well as the hospital. "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Surgery is one of the key functions in hospitals; it generates significant revenue and admissions to hospitals. In this paper we address the decision of choosing a case-mix for a surgery department. The objective of this study is to generate an optimal case-mix plan of surgery patients with uncertain surgery operations, which includes uncertainty in surgery durations, length of stay, surgery demand and the availability of nurses. In order to obtain an optimal case-mix plan, a stochastic optimization model is proposed and the sample average approximation method is applied. The proposed model is used to determine the number of surgery cases to be weekly served, the amount of operating rooms’ time dedicated to each specialty and the number of ward beds dedicated to each specialty. The optimal case-mix selection criterion is based upon a weighted score taking into account both the waiting list and the historical demand of each patient category. The score aims to maximizing the service level of the operating rooms by increasing the total number of surgery cases that could be served. A computational experiment is presented to demonstrate the performance of the proposed method. The results show that the stochastic model solution outperforms the expected value problem solution. Additional analysis is conducted to study the effect of varying the number of ORs and nurses capacity on the overall ORs’ performance.
    No preview · Article · Sep 2015 · Health Care Management Science
  • Source
    • "Once the earlier patient is moved outside the OR (e.g., to the recovery room), the newly anaesthetised patient is ready to be transferred to the OR. Conducting anaesthesia induction in a separate room can save time for preparing the OR before surgery, thereby improving OR efficiency (Harders et al., 2006). From a BPM viewpoint, it is advantageous to perform the anaesthesia induction on the trolley where: a. there is an anaesthesia room adjacent to the OR; and b. there is another patient in the OR. "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: The present study brings together for the first time the techniques of hierarchical task analysis (HTA), human error identification (HEI), and business process management (BPM) to select practices that can eliminate or reduce potential errors in a surgical setting. We applied the above approaches to the improvement of the patient positioning process for lumbar spine surgery referred to as 'direct lateral interbody fusion' (DLIF). Observations were conducted to gain knowledge on current DLIF positioning practices, and an HTA was constructed. Potential errors associated with the practices specific to DLIF patient positioning were identified. Based on literature review and expert views alternative practices are proposed aimed at improving the DLIF patient positioning process. To our knowledge, this is the first attempt to use BPM in association with HEI/HTA for the purpose of improving the performance and safety of a surgical process - with promising results.
    Full-text · Article · Dec 2013 · Applied ergonomics
    • "The review of the literature highlights several different ways in which the concept of efficiency has been defined in health care. Some authors studied the efficiency through a qualitative approach (Harders et al., 2006;Marijamaa, Torkki, Hirvensalo, &amp; Kirvela¨,Kirvela¨, 2009), giving as acquired the concept of efficiency. Despite adopting a qualitative approach, this paper, asArakelian et al. (2008Arakelian et al. ( , 2011) studies, doesn't adopt a specific construct, but investigates how medical staffs experience, perceive and understand operating room efficiency in daily work. "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: This paper focuses on efficiency as a central theme of the Italian health care reforms, combining macrolevel policies with microlevel (i.e., operating room) perceptions of the concept. According to the phenomenographic approach, this analysis investigates how the components of a surgical team (22 semistructured interviews) experience efficiency in their daily workflows. The main findings show that the concept of efficiency is multidimensional. According to participants' perspective, several categories of efficiency collected in an outcome space emphasize an holistic view of efficiency driving health policies and strategies. SOCIAL IMPLICATIONS: The suggestion of further relationships between perspectives and other constructs (i.e., quality, safety, patient focus, process) at micro and macro level could enhance the impact of health reforms. A qualitative approach conducted at microlevel help to recognize the phenomenon (of efficiency), engaging the individual conception that practitioners have of the health efficiency.
    No preview · Article · Dec 2012 · Advances in Health Care Management
Show more