Stability of inbred mouse strains in behavior and brain size between laboratories and across decades

Department of Psychology, University of Alberta, Edmonton, AB, Canada T6G 2E9.
Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences (Impact Factor: 9.67). 11/2006; 103(44):16364-9. DOI: 10.1073/pnas.0605342103
Source: PubMed


If we conduct the same experiment in two laboratories or repeat a classical study many years later, will we obtain the same results? Recent research with mice in neural and behavioral genetics yielded different results in different laboratories for certain phenotypes, and these findings suggested to some researchers that behavior may be too unstable for fine-scale genetic analysis. Here we expand the range of data on this question to additional laboratories and phenotypes, and, for the first time in this field, we formally compare recent data with experiments conducted 30-50 years ago. For ethanol preference and locomotor activity, strain differences have been highly stable over a period of 40-50 years, and most strain correlations are in the range of r = 0.85-0.98, as high as or higher than for brain weight. For anxiety-related behavior on the elevated plus maze, on the other hand, strain means often differ dramatically across laboratories or even when the same laboratory is moved to another site within a university. When a wide range of phenotypes is considered, no inbred strain appears to be exceptionally stable or labile across laboratories in any general sense, and there is no tendency to observe higher correlations among studies done more recently. Phenotypic drift over decades for most of the behaviors examined appears to be minimal.

Download full-text


Available from: Alexander A Bachmanov, Nov 25, 2014
    • "Housing laboratory animals (defined as intended for research or teaching use, regardless of housing type [Association for Assessment and Accreditation of Laboratory Animal Care International, 2015a]) in simple and uniform conditions is done to limit environmental variability and increase the internal validity of studies, as well as facilitate sample collection, treatments, and husbandry procedures. Recently, it has been demonstrated that highly controlled and standardized laboratory environments for rodent models are generating reduced repeatability and reproducibility in research outcomes [Branchi et al., 2011; Crabbe et al., 1999; Paylor, 2009; Richter et al., 2009 Richter et al., , 2010 Richter et al., , 2011 Schumann et al., 2014; Wahlsten et al., 2006; Wurbel, 2000]. For example, rodent tests comparing results from four repeated experiments using subjects in highly controlled cages (same aged subjects and one enrichment item) versus subjects in less controlled cages (varying aged subjects and enrichment items) show that the highly controlled condition had low within experiment variation, but significant between experiment differences, resulting in low repeatability; the latter condition, however , had greater within experiment variation and low between experiment differences, resulting in greater repeatability in research results [Richter et al., 2009 [Richter et al., , 2010 [Richter et al., , 2011. "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Macaque species, specifically rhesus (Macaca mulatta), are the most common nonhuman primates (NHPs) used in biomedical research due to their suitability as a model of high priority diseases (e.g., HIV, obesity, cognitive aging), cost effective breeding and housing compared to most other NHPs, and close evolutionary relationship to humans. With this close evolutionary relationship, however, is a shared adaptation for a socially stimulating environment, without which both their welfare and suitability as a research model are compromised. While outdoor social group housing provides the best approximation of a social environment that matches the macaque behavioral biology in the wild, this is not always possible at all facilities, where animals may be housed indoors in small groups, in pairs, or alone. Further, animals may experience many housing changes in their lifetime depending on project needs, changes in social status, management needs, or health concerns. Here, we review the evidence for the physiological and health effects of social housing changes and the potential impacts on research outcomes for studies using macaques, particularly rhesus. We situate our review in the context of increasing regulatory pressure for research facilities to both house NHPs socially and mitigate trauma from social aggression. To meet these regulatory requirements and further refine the macaque model for research, significant advances must be made in our understanding and management of rhesus macaque social housing, particularly pair-housing since it is the most common social housing configuration for macaques while on research projects. Because most NHPs are adapted for sociality, a social context is likely important for improving repeatability, reproducibility, and external validity of primate biomedical research. Am. J. Primatol. © 2016 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.
    No preview · Article · Feb 2016 · American Journal of Primatology
  • Source
    • "under study (Sena et al., 2010). Although less well studied, there is no reason to assume that issues regarding quality of research are different in psychopharmacology than in other fields of CNS research (Wahlsten et al., 2006; Button et al., 2013; Groenink et al., 2014). "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Psychopharmacology has had some bad publicity lately. Frankly, there have been some major problems along the way in developing new effective drugs for psychiatric disorders. After a prolonged period of high investments but low success rates, big pharmaceutical companies seem to retract their activities in the psychopharmacology field. Yet, the burden of mental disorders is likely to keep on growing in the next decades. In this position paper, we focus on drug development for depression and anxiety disorders, to narrow the scope of the assay. We describe the current situation of the psychopharmacology field, and analyse some of the methods and paradigms that have brought us here, but which should perhaps change to bring us even further. In addition, some of the factors contributing to the current stagnation in psychopharmacology are discussed. Finally, we suggest a number of changes that could lead to a more rational strategy for central nervous system drug development and which may circumvent some of the pitfalls leading to "me too" approaches. Central to the suggested changes, is the notion that mental disorders do not lead to several symptoms, but a network of causally related symptoms convolutes into a mental disorder. We call upon academia to put these changes in the early phases of drug development into effect. Copyright © 2015. Published by Elsevier B.V.
    Full-text · Article · Mar 2015 · European journal of pharmacology
  • Source
    • "However, these issues have been poorly explored so far and hence require a more thorough investigation (Tian et al., 2009). Genetically distinct inbred mice differ from one another in their anxiety traits and other behaviors concerning their locomotor activities, stress responses, learning skills, and drug responses (Hovatta and Barlow, 2008; Wahlsten et al., 2006). Here, we took advantage of these well-characterized inbred mice strains, and utilized a series of approaches, including flow cytometry, RT-qPCR, genome-wide brain transcriptome analysis, genotype–phenotype correlation, and gene functional clustering, to examine the profile of microglial activation, and to explore its association with anxiety-related behaviors among these strains. "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Objectives: Microglia play important roles in neurodevelopmental and pathological progression of mental disorders. But how genetic predisposition and environment risk factors may act in combination to affect microglial activation and the underlying molecular mechanisms remains unclear. Methods: Flow cytometry, RT-qPCR, and analysis of genome-wide brain transcriptomes, genotype–phenotype correlation, and gene functional clustering were employed to study the microglial profile both before and after LPS treatment across four inbred mice strains (C57BL/6J, FVB/N, DBA/2J, and 129S2/Sv) with different anxiety traits, and its relationship with anxiety traits and brain gene expression. Results: We found that naïve DBA/2J mice had significantly more M1 microglia. After a systemic LPS challenge, polarization to M1 microglia in DBA/2J and 129S2/Sv mice was more prominent than the other strains, and was correlated with their anxiety-like behaviors. Macrophage M1/M2 polarization in the spleen showed a similar pattern in DBA/2J and 129S2/Sv mice in response to LPS challenge. Furthermore, DBA/2J mice expressed higher mRNA levels of Il1b, Il6, and Tnf, and higher Nos2/Arg1 ratio but lower Chi3l3 level in the hypothalamus before and after LPS stimulation, respectively. We further discovered a group of myeloid transcription factors that may underpin strain-specific differences in microglial activation. Conclusions: Proinflammatory microglial activation reflects anxiety traits in mice, especially after LPS challenge. Our work sheds new light in understanding the potential molecular mechanisms of stress-induced microglial activation and polarization.
    Full-text · Article · Sep 2014 · Brain Behavior and Immunity
Show more