Context.—
Peripheral neuropathy is common in persons infected with the human immunodeficiency
virus (HIV) but few data on symptomatic treatment are available.Objective.—
To evaluate the efficacy of a standardized acupuncture regimen (SAR)
and amitriptyline hydrochloride for the relief of pain due to HIV-related
peripheral neuropathy in HIV-infected patients.Design.—
Randomized, placebo-controlled, multicenter clinical trial. Each site
enrolled patients into 1 of the following 3 options: (1) a modified double-blind
2 × 2 factorial design of SAR, amitriptyline, or the combination compared
with placebo, (2) a modified double-blind design of an SAR vs control points,
or (3) a double-blind design of amitriptyline vs placebo.Setting.—
Terry Beirn Community Programs for Clinical Research on AIDS (HIV primary
care providers) in 10 US cities.Patients.—
Patients with HIV-associated, symptomatic, lower-extremity peripheral
neuropathy. Of 250 patients enrolled, 239 were in the acupuncture comparison
(125 in the factorial option and 114 in the SAR option vs control points option),
and 136 patients were in the amitriptyline comparison (125 in the factorial
option and 11 in amitriptyline option vs placebo option).Interventions.—
Standarized acupuncture regimen vs control points, amitriptyline (75
mg/d) vs placebo, or both for 14 weeks.Main Outcome Measure.—
Changes in mean pain scores at 6 and 14 weeks, using a pain scale ranging
from 0.0 (no pain) to 1.75 (extremely intense), recorded daily.Results.—
Patients in all 4 groups showed reduction in mean pain scores at 6 and
14 weeks compared with baseline values. For both the acupuncture and amitriptyline
comparisons, changes in pain score were not significantly different between
the 2 groups. At 6 weeks, the estimated difference in pain reduction for patients
in the SAR group compared with those in the control points group (a negative
value indicates a greater reduction for the "active" treatment) was 0.01 (95%
confidence interval [CI], −0.11 to 0.12; P
=.88) and for patients in the amitriptyline group vs those in the placebo
group was −0.07 (95% CI, −0.22 to 0.08; P=.38).
At 14 weeks, the difference for those in the SAR group compared with those
in the control points group was −0.08 (95% CI, −0.21 to 0.06; P=.26) and for amitriptyline compared with placebo was
0.00 (95% CI, −0.18 to 0.19; P=.99).Conclusions.—
In this study, neither acupuncture nor amitriptyline was more effective
than placebo in relieving pain caused by HIV-related peripheral neuropathy.
Figures in this Article
PERIPHERAL NEUROPATHIES are diagnosed in 30% to 35% of patients with
human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) and cause pain and dysesthesias.1- 2 Symptomatic treatment includes antidepressants,
nonnarcotic and narcotic analgesics, anticonvulsants, and acupuncture.2- 3 The use of these treatments is based
on anecdotal4 information and trials in other
disease conditions.5
We chose to examine the efficacy of 2 commonly used treatments, amitriptyline
hydrochloride and acupuncture, for HIV-related peripheral neuropathy. Amitriptyline
is frequently prescribed for neuropathic pain and has been shown to be an
effective treatment for diabetic, hereditary, toxic, and idiopathic neuropathies.6- 7
Although several trials that reported examining acupuncture for chronic
painful conditions claim efficacy,8- 9
these studies have methodological limitations, including small sample sizes
and inadequate controls for the nonspecific effects of acupuncture.9- 11 Meta-analyses of studies
of acupuncture for chronic pain show a response rate of approximately 70%
for acupuncture, 50% for "sham" acupuncture (needling points not considered
effective), and 30% for control treatments, such as sham transcutaneous electrical
nerve stimulation.9- 10,12- 13
To evaluate the effect of both a nonstandard and standard medical therapy
for peripheral neuropathy, we performed a multicenter, modified double-blind,
randomized, placebo-controlled study of the separate and combined efficacy
of a standardized acupuncture regimen (SAR) and amitriptyline for the relief
of pain caused by HIV-related peripheral neuropathy.