“The Caregiving Context in Institution-Reared and Family-Reared Infants and Toddlers in Romania.”

Tulane University, LA, USA.
Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry (Impact Factor: 6.46). 03/2007; 48(2):210-8. DOI: 10.1111/j.1469-7610.2006.01694.x
Source: PubMed


We assess individual differences in the caregiving environments of young children being raised in institutions in Romania in relation to developmental characteristics such as physical growth, cognitive development, emotional expression, and problem and competence behaviors.
Videotaped observations of the child and favorite caregiver in their 'home' environment were coded for caregiving quality, and this was related to child characteristics. Child emotional reactivity was assessed during responses to interactional tasks. Cognitive development was assessed from child responses to the Bayley Scales of Infant Development. Data regarding problem behaviors and competence were obtained from caregiver report. Children reared in institutions were compared on all of these measures to never institutionalized children to assist gauging degree of impairment.
Children raised in institutions demonstrated marked delays in cognitive development, poorer physical growth, and marked deficits in competence. Individual differences in caregiving environment were associated with cognitive development, competence, and negative behavior among these young children being reared in institutions.
These data confirm previous findings regarding deficits associated with institutional care and extend our understanding of the impact of individual differences in caregiving quality on the development of young children in institutions.

Download full-text


Available from: Charles H Zeanah
  • Source
    • " convictions in adulthood , even after adjusting for number and duration of place - ments ( Dregan & Gulliford , 2012 ; Johnson , Browne , & Hamiliton - Giachristis , 2006 ) . However , a sizeable proportion of evidence that illustrates better outcomes for foster care focuses on infants and younger children ( Smyke , Dumitrescu , & Zeanah , 2002 ; Smyke et al . , 2007 ; van IJzendoorn , Luijk , & Juffer , 2008 ; Zeanah , Smyke , Koga , & Carlson , 2005 ) . On the other hand , several studies that included older children above 4 years of age demonstrated good outcomes in institutional care ( Knorth , Harder , Zandberg , & Kendrick , 2008 ; McKenzie , 1997 , 1999 ; van IJzendoorn et al . , 2008 ; Wolff"
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: The negative impact of childhood maltreatment, which can often extend well into adulthood, consistently appears to be ameliorated if victimized children possess several resiliencies or strengths. However, little is known about how vulnerable children's outcomes are affected by different levels of strengths across different out-of-home placement settings. Hence, this study examined the association of two factors — children's strengths and placement type, with outcomes at two time-points during out-of-home care. The Child and Adolescent Needs and Strengths (CANS) tool was used to assess the outcomes of 285 children placed in residential homes or foster care in Singapore. Multiple regressions were conducted on CANS domain scores to evaluate whether level of baseline strengths and placement type predicted outcomes at two time-points after controlling for race, prior placements, age, gender, interpersonal trauma, and baseline needs scores. Results indicate that relative to residential care, foster care children are reported to be younger, with lower baseline needs, more prior placements, fewer baseline strengths and suffered fewer types of interpersonal trauma. After controlling for covariates, higher baseline strengths significantly predicted lower baseline needs of children across 3 of 4 CANS domains, regardless of placement settings. However, at reassessment 1 year later, there were significant interactions between strengths and placement type, whereby baseline strengths significantly predicted lower life functioning needs only in foster care. To conclude, in both residential and foster care, the protective effects of high strengths against child maltreatment were similarly apparent at baseline, despite clear differences in children's profiles across placement types. Over time, these initial benefits appeared to persist somewhat for children in foster care but seemed to diminish in more restrictive, residential settings and this warrants further investigation on children with more similar profiles. Nonetheless, it is clear that the continual development of children's strengths should be prioritized in case planning.
    Full-text · Article · Nov 2015 · Children and Youth Services Review
    • "The present article thus addresses whether—and how—these known sources of influence operate in concert with each other to shape the behavioral development of toddlers. In line with a developmental psychopathology framework emphasizing the dynamic relation between (temporally) distal and proximal causes (Cicchetti, 2006), we predicted that the early exposure to maltreatment in the family of origin will shape vulnerability to behavior difficulties in toddlers who continue to experience inadequate care in less stable institutional environments; and that this will be so even after controlling for potentially confounding factors like gender and age at time of institutionalization, keeping with previous research (Smyke et al., 2007). In other words, we expected that the pre-institutionalization experience of maltreatment would be amplified by the anticipated adverse effects of lower quality care during institutionalization. "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: The current study extends research on the effects of institutionalization, most notably by examining whether—and how—both pre-institutional maltreatment in the family and the stability and consistency of institutional care interact to shape emotional and behavioral development. Fifty Portuguese children, placed in residential institutions when 8 days to 26 months of age, were evaluated using the Child Behavior Checklist when aged 18–31 months. Caregiver-rated internalizing and externalizing behavior problems proved to be unrelated to both early family and institutional experiences, as main effects, but the interaction of these factors significantly predicted externalizing problems: a history of maltreatment in the family coupled with unstable institutional caregiving arrangements predicted especially elevated levels of externalizing problems. Results are discussed in terms of the importance of more distal and proximate developmental experiences.
    No preview · Article · Nov 2014 · Child Abuse & Neglect
  • Source
    • "Studies of HPA axis activity in these children have yielded mixed results, perhaps because social deprivation is typically confounded with physical deprivation, malnutrition, pathogen exposure and abuse, which may also impact the HPA axis. Despite heterogeneity across institutions, institutional rearing nearly uniformly involves fewer supportive adult—child interactions than most family contexts (Smyke et al., 2007; van IJzendoorn et al., 2011). Toddlers living in an orphanage in Romania were found to exhibit lower morning and slightly elevated evening cortisol levels (Carlson and Earls, 1997); however, preschool-aged children in a Ukrainian institution exhibited normal diurnal rhythms, although those who had been growth-stunted had elevated levels (Dobrova-Krol et al., 2008). "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Growing evidence suggests that early social deprivation impacts the activity of the hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenocortical axis. Early adverse care in the form of institutional or orphanage care provides a human model for early social deprivation. The present study examined changes in diurnal cortisol during the transition to family care in the first 2 years post-adoption. Children adopted between 15 and 36 months from institutional care were examined four times during their first 2 years post-adoption (N=58). Comparison groups included same-aged peers reared in their birth families (N=50) and children adopted during their first year from overseas foster care (N=47). Children provided daily cortisol samples at roughly 2, 9, 17, and 25 months post-adoption. Post-institutionalized and post-foster care children exhibited less steep diurnal cortisol compared to non-adopted same-aged peers; these differences did not diminish across the 2 year period. For post-institutionalized children, lower social care quality in institutions was associated with less steep cortisol slopes. Lastly, shallower diurnal cortisol was a mediator between adoption status and increased behavioral problems 2 years post-adoption. Consistent with the non-human primate literature, early social deprivation may contribute to early programming of the HPA axis.
    Full-text · Article · Aug 2014 · Psychoneuroendocrinology
Show more