Cost-Effectiveness of Vitamin Therapy for Age-Related Macular Degeneration

RTI International, Research Triangle Park, North Carolina, USA.
Ophthalmology (Impact Factor: 6.14). 08/2007; 114(7):1319-26. DOI: 10.1016/j.ophtha.2006.10.041
Source: PubMed


To determine the cost-effectiveness of vitamin therapy (antioxidants plus zinc) for all indicated patients diagnosed with age-related macular degeneration (AMD).
We compared the impacts of vitamin therapy with those of no vitamin therapy using a computerized, stochastic, agent-based model. The model simulated the natural history of AMD and patterns of ophthalmic service use in the United States in a cohort from age 50 years until 100 or death.
The model created 20 million simulated individuals. These individuals each received both the intervention (vitamin therapy after diagnosis) and the control (no vitamin therapy). Expected outcomes generated when vitamins were taken after diagnosis were compared with the expected outcomes generated when they were not.
The model created individuals representative of patients in the U.S. Incidence of early AMD was based on published studies, as was vision loss and response to choroidal neovascularization therapies. Post-incident disease progression was governed by previously unpublished data drawn from the Age-Related Eye Disease Study.
Extent of disease progression, years and severity of visual impairment, cost of ophthalmic care and nursing home services, and quality-adjusted life years (QALYs). Costs and benefits were considered from the health care perspective and discounted using a 3% rate. The analysis was run for 50 years starting in 2003.
Compared with no therapy, vitamin therapy yielded a cost-effectiveness ratio of $21,387 per QALY gained and lowered the percentage of patients with AMD who ever developed visual impairment in the better-seeing eye from 7.0% to 5.6%.
Our model demonstrates that vitamin therapy for AMD improves quality of life at a reasonable cost.

Download full-text


Available from: David B Rein
  • Source
    • "ABM also has demonstrated application to the field of human behavior study [11]–[12], and in more traditional settings of scheduling in medical environments [13]. Additionally, ABM has been shown to provide value in predicting ophthalmic outcomes as well, particularly in the field of age-related macular degeneration [14]–[15]. "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Agent-based models are valuable for examining systems where large numbers of discrete individuals interact with each other, or with some environment. Diabetic Veterans seeking eye care at a Veterans Administration hospital represent one such cohort. The objective of this study was to develop an agent-based template to be used as a model for a patient with diabetic retinopathy (DR). This template may be replicated arbitrarily many times in order to generate a large cohort which is representative of a real-world population, upon which in-silico experimentation may be conducted. Agent-based template development was performed in java-based computer simulation suite AnyLogic Professional 6.6. The model was informed by medical data abstracted from 535 patient records representing a retrospective cohort of current patients of the VA St. Louis Healthcare System Eye clinic. Logistic regression was performed to determine the predictors associated with advancing stages of DR. Predicted probabilities obtained from logistic regression were used to generate the stage of DR in the simulated cohort. The simulated cohort of DR patients exhibited no significant deviation from the test population of real-world patients in proportion of stage of DR, duration of diabetes mellitus (DM), or the other abstracted predictors. Simulated patients after 10 years were significantly more likely to exhibit proliferative DR (P<0.001). Agent-based modeling is an emerging platform, capable of simulating large cohorts of individuals based on manageable data abstraction efforts. The modeling method described may be useful in simulating many different conditions where course of disease is described in categorical stages.
    Full-text · Article · Jun 2013 · PLoS ONE
  • Source
    • "Two categories of pigments, carotenoids and anthocyanins , impart colors and serve as antioxidants. Carotenoids abundant in potato are in the category of xanthophylls, where lutein and zeaxanthin are known to be important photoprotectant compounds in the human retina (Rein et al. 2007) that must be obtained in the diet. Lutein supplementation in the diet has been correlated with improvement in visual function in patients suffering from macular degeneration and cataracts (Olmedilla et al. 2001). "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: The potato is a vegetable that develops underground as a stem. It is a propagule in the sense that the potato itself is used as seed for the following crop. As a food it is a rich source of nutrients. All potatoes have carotenoids in the flesh which are xanthophylls. Of greatest interest are lutein and zeaxanthin, components of the human retina that must be obtained from foods for proper eye health. Potatoes grown outside the center of origin in the Andes of South America may contain from 50 to 350 micrograms zeaxanthin equivalents per 100g FW. Potatoes developed by farmers in the Andes, especially the Papa Amarilla class of cultivars, may contain as much as 2,000μg per 100g FW. Xanthophylls are fat soluble, have half-lives of several days in the human body, and are antioxidants that associate with membranes in the cell. Anthocyanins are radically different compounds conferring red to purple coloration to skin and flesh of potato. Potatoes with color of this type range from 1.5mg cyanidin equivalents per 100g FW, in colored skin but non-colored flesh types and up to 40mg in colored skin, solidly colored flesh types. Potent antioxidants, anthocyanins are water soluble and have a half-life of several hours in the body. Some of the anthocyanins are strong anti-inflammatory agents. Potato is recognized as containing minerals, though never mentioned as a particularly rich source. A survey of advanced breeding lines and varieties at different growing locations indicates that different genotypes display a large range of iron content. Iron is the most problematic mineral from a dietary standpoint. Absorption from food is hindered by phytic acid and polyphenols, which are abundant in small grains and food legumes, while present in minute amounts in potato. The difficulty in absorption is countered further in the presence of vitamin C, which aids iron absorption. Potato is a substantial source of vitamin C and theoretically could be a principal component of a food matrix that provides highly absorbable iron. La papa es una hortaliza que se desarrolla como tallo bajo tierra. Es un propágulo en el sentido de que la papa en sí es usada como semilla para el siguiente cultivo. Como alimento es una rica fuente de nutrientes. Todas las papas contienen carotenoides en la pulpa los cuales son xantófilas. Los de mayor interés son la luteína y la zeaxantina, componentes de la retina humana y que se deben obtener de los alimentos para la salud apropiada de los ojos. Las papas que se cultivan fuera de su centro de origen en los Andes de Sudamérica pueden contener 50 a 350 microgramos de equivalentes de zeaxantina por 100 gramos de peso fresco (PF). Las papas desarrolladas por los agricultores en los Andes, especialmente del tipo Papa Amarilla pueden contener hasta 2000 microgramos por 100 gramos de PF. Las xantofilas son lipo solubles, tienen una vida media de varios días en el cuerpo humano, y son antioxidantes que se asocian con las membranas en la célula. Las antocianinas son compuestos radicalmente diferentes que confieren una coloración roja a la cáscara y pulpa de papa. Papas con este tipo de color contienen 1.5mg de equivalentes de cianidina por 100g de PF, en los tipos de cáscara coloreada pero pulpa no coloreada y hasta 40mg en los tipos de cáscara coloreada, pulpa totalmente de color. Las antocianinas, potentes antioxidantes, son solubles en agua y tienen una vida media en el cuerpo, de varias horas. Algunas antocianinas son potentes agentes anti-inflamatorios. La papa es reconocida como fuente rica en minerales, aunque nunca es mencionada como fuente particularmente rica. Una inspección de las líneas avanzadas de mejoramiento y variedades de distintas localidades de cultivo indica que diferentes genotipos muestran un amplio contenido de hierro. El hierro es el mineral más problemático desde el punto de vista dietético. La absorción de hierro a partir del alimento es obstaculizada por el ácido fítico y polifenoles, los cuales están presentes en abundancia en granos menudos y leguminosas comestibles, mientras que en la papa hay pequeñísimas cantidades. La dificultad de absorción es contrarrestada en presencia de vitamina C, la cual ayuda la absorción de hierro. La papa es una fuente sustancial de vitamina C y teóricamente puede ser el componente principal de una matriz alimentaria que proporcione hierro altamente absorbible.
    Preview · Article · Aug 2008 · American Journal of Potato Research
  • [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: • The evidence base for the use of dietary supplements is well documented for some, such as the essential nutrients, but it is scant for others, such as some designer supplements and botanicals. • Popular dietary supplements consumed by older Americans that have national public health recommendations and established guidelines for use include omega-3 fatty acids; the B vitamins, folic acid, vitamins B6, and B12; vitamins D and E; and the minerals, calcium, potassium, and magnesium. • Dietary supplements not endorsed by national public health recommendations but with a considerable evidence base upon which randomized clinical trials can be planned or guidelines for use might be formulated include coenzyme Q10, creatine, and the botanicals black cohosh, French pine bark, Ginkgo biloba, and saw palmetto. • A clinical deficiency of vitamins or minerals, other than iron and possibly vitamin D, is uncommon in the United States, except for certain high-risk groups. • In situations when recommended nutrients cannot be obtained by food alone or retained by the body because of impaired absorption or other physiologic limitations, dietary supplements can provide benefit. When taken, multivitamin preparations should include 100% of the daily value for vitamins B12, B6, D, and folic acid.
    No preview · Article ·
Show more