Skill retention in adults and in children 3 months after basic life support training using a simple personal resuscitation manikin

Department of Anaesthesia, Section 4231, Centre of Head and Orthopaedics, Copenhagen University Hospital, Rigshospitalet, Blegdamsvej 9, DK-2100 Copenhagen, Denmark.
Resuscitation (Impact Factor: 4.17). 09/2007; 74(2):296-302. DOI: 10.1016/j.resuscitation.2006.12.012
Source: PubMed


As 70-80% of cardiac arrests occur at home, widespread training is needed to increase the likelihood of basic life support (BLS) being performed before the arrival of Emergency Medical Services personnel. Teaching BLS in public schools has been recommended to achieve this.
To compare BLS skill retention in school children with adults when using a simple personal resuscitation manikin.
The MiniAnne (Laerdal Medical, Norway) was distributed to 76 pupils (age 12-14 years) in three public schools and to 194 employees (age 22-51 years) in an insurance company. Using the enclosed DVD, the participants carried out a 24 min BLS course and took home the manikin for subsequent self-training. After 3 months, skill retention was assessed using the ResusciAnne and the PC Skill reporting System 2.0 (Laerdal Medical, Norway) in a 5 min test. A combined score ranging from 12 to 52 points was calculated and in addition, 12 different variables were compared.
The combined score was significantly higher in adults (35 points versus 32 points, P=0.0005). The adults performed significantly better than the children in all but four variables. 'Ventilation-compression ratio' and 'hand-position' were not significantly different. The children performed significantly better in the variables 'total compressions' (median 199 versus 154, P=0.0003), and 'hands-off time' (median 158.5s versus 188.5s, P<0.0001).
Three months after a BLS course, adults had higher overall BLS skill retention scores than school children when using a simple personal resuscitation manikin.

Download full-text


Available from: Christian S Meyhoff
  • Source
    • "When the analysis includes more accurate methods of assessment, such as the volume of air supplied by mouth-to-mouth respiration, the retention levels are lower12,15. Only studies that include populations receiving intensive and frequent training demonstrate consistently better performance12-15, although the uptake of re-training courses is low in the general adult population14. Adaptations to the training methods that are already available do not seem to be effective16. Considering the data as a whole, we can conclude that knowledge retention is generally low and deteriorates with time regardless of either the assessment performed or the target population. "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Diseases of the circulatory system are the most common cause of death in Brazil. Because the general population is often the first to identify problems related to the circulatory system, it is important that they are trained. However, training is challenging owing to the number of persons to be trained and the maintenance of training. To assess the delivery of a medical-student led cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR) training program and to assess prior knowledge of CPR as well as immediate and delayed retention of CPR training among middle school students. Two public and two private schools were selected. CPR training consisted of a video class followed by practice on manikins that was supervised by medical students. Multiple choice questionnaires were provided before, immediately after, and at 6 months after CPR training. The questions were related to general knowledge, the sequence of procedures, and the method to administer each component (ventilation, chest compression, and automated external defibrillation). The instructors met in a focus group after the sessions to identify the potential problems faced. In total, 147 students completed the 6-month follow-up. The public school students had a lower prior knowledge, but this difference disappeared immediately after training. After the 6-month follow-up period, these public school students demonstrated lower retention. The main problem faced was teaching mouth-to-mouth resuscitation. The method used by medical students to teach middle school students was based on the see-and-practice technique. This method was effective in achieving both immediate and late retention of acquired knowledge. The greater retention of knowledge among private school students may reflect cultural factors.
    Full-text · Article · Aug 2013 · Arquivos brasileiros de cardiologia
  • Source
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Objetivos: Conocer las opiniones y actitudes de profesores de Institutos de Secundaria de Lugo sobre la enseñanza de la reanimación cardiopulmonar básica (RCP-B) en sus centros. Método: Un cuestionario autoadministrado se hace llegar a 2 institutos de Enseñanza Media de Lugo; consta de 12 preguntas de respuesta cerrada, precedidas de una explicación sobre la muerte súbita, la RCP-B precoz y la desfibrilación precoz. Resultados: De 120 cuestionarios, se cumplimentan 56 (46,6%). De ellos, 11 profesores (19,6%) han asistido alguna vez a un curso de RCP-B. Veintitrés (41,1%) desconocen la existencia de los desfibriladores semiautomáticos (DESA). A 52 (92,95%) les parece interesante que sus alumnos hagan un curso de RCP-B y DESA en el Instituto. El 76,8% opina que la enseñanza de la RCP-B sería útil en la Educación Secundaria Obligatoria (ESO); el 57,2% piensan que debería impartirse a partir de 3ºESO. Cuarenta y ocho (85,7%) están interesados en participar en un curso de RCP-B como alumnos. En cuanto al personal idóneo para impartir la RCP-B en los institutos, 46 (82,1%) prefieren que sea personal sanitario. Veintidós profesores (39,3%) están dispuestos a impartir esta materia si se les forma primero. Conclusiones: A la mayoría de los profesores les parece útil incluir la enseñanza de la RCP-B en el currículo de los alumnos de la ESO, y ellos mismos están interesados en recibir esta formación. Aunque la mayor parte prefiere que se imparta por personal sanitario, la mitad de ellos estarían dispuestos a hacerlo si se les entrenase primero.
    Preview · Article ·
  • Source
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Background Outcome from out-of-hospital cardiac arrest is generally unfavorable and greatly depends on the frequency and quality of bystander CPR. In order to improve the situation extensive educational efforts are necessary to teach CPR to society. The school period is particularly suitable because at this time resuscitation can be anchored as a cultural skill early in the course of a life long learning. In the German-speaking area many different individual projects exist, however, they are not linked together organizationally or in content. This article attempts to bring together experiences from published projects and to derive basic principles for implementation in the German-speaking area. Methods Against the background of literature, considerations are made on learning objectives, timepoints for training, training formats and implementation. Results The most important contents especially for shorter training formats are: recognition of cardiac arrest, recruiting helpers and emergency medical service and chest compressions. Also, the use of an automated external defibrillator (AED) is of value. In contrast ventilation and recovery position play a subordinate role and should not be included in compact training formats for reasons of clarity. A special problem is the low availability of qualified teachers and regional solutions must be found. At present, the German Resuscitation Council is developing a standard national curriculum for school.
    Full-text · Article · Aug 2009 · Notfall
Show more