ArticlePDF Available

Ecology. Danger of deep-sea mining

Authors:
www.sciencemag.org SCIENCE VOL 316 18 MAY 2007
987
CREDIT: RALPH WHITE/CORBIS
POLICYFORUM
O
ver the past few months,
the possibility of mineral
exploitation in the deep
sea (1) has moved closer to reality
with completion of the first
undersea exploration for massive
sulfide deposits. Analyses of tar-
get deposits in a zone of active
hydrothermal vent systems in the
territorial waters of Papua New
Guinea (PNG) have revealed gold,
copper, zinc, and silver in concen-
trations that far surpass those of
current terrestrial mining ven-
tures (2). With mining technology
in an advanced stage of develop-
ment, skyrocketing metal prices,
and depletion of metal-rich terres-
trial mines, sea-floor mining act-
ivities are now scheduled to begin by 2009.
Initial interest in deep-sea mining was
centered on extracting manganese nodules
from spatially extensive sea-floor deposits in
international seas distant from continents.
However, ratification of the United Nations
Convention on the Law of the Sea in 1994,
which imposed financial burdens and environ-
mental safeguards, together with low metal
prices, drastically lowered interest in nodule
mining. Prospecting and exploration activities
have since shifted to the Exclusive Economic
Zones (EEZs), where it is the responsibility of
individual nations to issue mining licenses and
define environmental safeguards. Discovery
of extensive massive sulfide deposits at com-
mercial ore grades within the EEZs of PNG
and, more recently, New Zealand has set off a
new phase of exploration (3).
The first site for such mining is expected to
be the Manus backarc basin of PNG, in close
proximity to active sulfide-forming hydrother-
mal vent systems. Hydrothermal vents are
home to unique and diverse ecosystems (4).
They are not only of scientific interest, but are
being explored for pharmaceutical and biotech-
nological applications (56). Whereas individ-
ual manganese nodule mine claims extend
across sea floor areas the size of Switzerland,
massive sulfide mining will concentrate on
small (1 km
2
in size),
high-grade deposits with-
in the uppermost 20 m of
the sea floor. An average
of 2 megatons of ore per
year is to be extracted by
Nautilus Minerals, Inc.,
in a single strip-mining
operation using remotely
operated underwater mine
cutters. It will be trans-
ferred from the sea floor
to a mining platform by
hydraulic pumps (6).
Environmental risks
including benthic distur-
bances, sediment plumes,
and toxic effects on the
water column have been
assessed for the large manganese nodule min-
ing endeavors in the equatorial Pacific (7).
These risks were judged to be so large and
unpredictable that a number of studies recom-
mended the abandonment of manganese min-
ing efforts to avoid a large-scale and long-term
risk to Pacific ecosystems and fisheries (8).
Benthic disturbances and far-reaching sedi-
ment plumes would probably be less during
massive sulfide mining (relative to nodule
mining) because of the absence of sediment
cover on the recently created ocean floor of
active hydrothermal vent systems. However,
explored mining sites are less than 1 km from
active vents, where there is a likely potential of
smothering, clogging, and contamination of
vent communities by drifting particles.
Organisms surviving these perturbations
would be subject to a radical change in habitat
conditions with hard substrata being replaced
by soft particles settling from the mining
plume (5). Mining could also potentially alter
hydrologic patterns that supply vent commu-
nities with essential nutrients and hot water. A
further problem may arise during dewatering
of ores on mining platforms, resulting in dis-
charge of highly nutrient enriched deep-water
into oligotrophic surface waters, which can
drift to nearby shelf areas.
These impacts may not be limited to eco-
systems within the EEZ of the country issuing
mining permits and could thus be in violation
of international environmental law (9). If the
first deep-sea mining effort is successful, a
wave of interest in deep-sea mining of mas-
sive sulfide deposits is likely to result. In fact,
250 of these deposits have been identified in
deep-sea areas worldwide (10).
There has been little progress toward cre-
ation of environmental regulatory systems
specific to deep-sea mining by governments
with jurisdiction over massive sulfide depos-
its. Some of these governments have a poor
track record of mine oversight and regulation
on land, so prospects appear poor for sound
regulation of underwater mining (11, 12). It is
time to implement scientific, technological,
and legal measures to minimize negative en-
vironmental impacts (including discouraging
deep-sea mining activities near sensitive
habitats) and to set up mechanisms to recover
costs of regulation and enforcement from this
nascent industry. Large capital investments
and generation of revenues by underwater
mining operations are likely to make regula-
tion after onset of commercial operations
even more difficult once deep-sea mining
becomes a reality.
References
1. J. L. Mero, The Mineral Resources of the Sea (Elsevier,
Amsterdam, 1965).
2. K. Heilman, “Nautilus one step closer to undersea min-
ing,” 4 October 2006, resourceinvestor.com.
3. G. P. Glasby, Science 289, 551 (2000).
4. C. L. Van Dover et al., Science 294, 818 (2001).
5. P. A. Rona, Science 299, 673 (2003).
6. D. Clifford, Mining Magazine 2005 (September), p. 58
(2005).
7. H. Thiel, Forschungsverbund, Tiefsee-Umweltschutz, in
ISOPE: Ocean Mining Symposium Proceedings, Tsukuba
Japan, 21 to 22 November 1995 [International Society of
Offshore and Polar Engineers (ISOPE), Golden, CO,
1995], pp. 39–45.
8. Tusch Research Group, in Proceedings International
Symposium Kiel Institute of International Law, R.
Wolfrum, Ed., Kiel, Germany, 17 to 20 May 1989
(Duncker & Humblot, Berlin, 1990).
9. L. Glowka, in Managing Risks to Biodiversity and the
Environment on the High Sea, Including Tools Such as
Marine Protected Areas: Scientific Requirements and
Legal Aspects, H. Thiel, A. Koslow, Eds. (Proceedings of
the Expert Workshop held at the International Academy
for Nature Conservation, Isle of Vilm, Germany, 27
February to 4 March 2001 [BfN (Bundesamt für
Naturschutz) Skripten 43, Federal Agency for Nature
Conservation, Bonn, Germany, 2001), pp. 195–204;
www.bfn.de/0502_meeres_kuestennaturschutz.html?&no
_cache=1&L=1.
10. M. D. Hannington et al., “A global database of seafloor
hydrothermal systems” (Geological Survey of Canada,
Open File 4598, 1CD-ROM, Ottawa, 2004).
11. J. Schneider, Neues Jahr. Geol. Palaeontol. Abh. 208,
397 (1998).
12. J. Halfar, R. M. Fujita, Mar. Policy 26, 103 (2002).
10.1126/science.1138289
Plans for deep-sea mining could pose a serious
threat to marine ecosystems.
Danger of Deep-Sea Mining
Jochen Halfar
1
and Rodney M. Fujita
2
ECOLOGY
1
Department of Chemical and Physical Sciences,
University of Toronto at Mississauga, Mississauga,
Ontario, Canada, L5L 1C6; e-mail: jochen.halfar@
utoronto.ca.
2
Environmental Defense, Oakland, CA
94618, USA; e-mail: rfujita@environmentaldefense.org
Published by AAAS
... Observing near-bed turbulence is especially crucial for deep-sea mining, which started in the middle twentieth century (Mero, 1965), which has a great potential to disturb natural habitat (Halfar & Fujita, 2007;van Dover, 2011). While deep-sea mining still has various challenges in technical, economical, and commercial aspects (Sharma, 2011), the International Seabed Authority (ISA), in 2013, published statements for environmental impact assessment, including physical oceanographic surveys to evaluate particle dispersal due to eddy diffusion (ISA, 2013). ...
Chapter
Both the diffusion of turbid water (plume) and the redeposition of suspended particles associated with deep sea mining are expected to have a negative impact on the surrounding environment. In order to understand the actual conditions of the mixed environment near the seafloor, it is necessary to evaluate these environmental impacts. In a review of guidelines for environmental impact assessment related to deep-sea mining published by the International Seabed Authority (ISA), the necessity of quantifying turbulence throughout the water column and vertical eddy diffusivity was suggested. Therefore, it is important to elucidate the dynamics of turbulence in the water column and directly above the seabed in the vicinity of deep-sea mining operations. However, the reality of deep-sea turbulence remains largely unexplored, and measurement techniques for deep-sea turbulence immediately above the seafloor have only recently been established. Consequently, while measurements of turbulence from the ocean surface to just above the seafloor have become possible, there are still challenges in terms of operation and cost. In this chapter, we present the results of our field survey of deep-sea turbulence intensity in different geographical environments and describe a method for estimating deep-sea turbulence (patent pending in Japan in 2021, application number: 2021–140,907) that we developed to solve the problems of deep-sea turbulence measurements. In addition, we have described a turbulence visualization technique using a shadowgraph-based imaging system with a high-resolution camera in order to understand the dynamics of suspended particles in situ, such as just above the deep-sea floor.
... 20,21 Potential deep sea mining sites can be identied by autonomous underwater vehicles or remotely operated vehicles, which can then collect polymetallic nodules from the seabed using a vacuum-like system or scrape cobalt-rich crusts from underwater formations. 22,23 Polymetallic sulphides occur near hydrothermal vent systems and require more traditional mining techniques, similar to terrestrial mining. [24][25][26] Deep sea mining operations have serious environmental concerns, such as habitat destruction, 27 threat to biodiversity, sediment plumes through disruption of the seabed, 28 and could release toxic substances trapped in the seabed and impact carbon sequestration. ...
Article
Full-text available
Mining provides raw materials critical to our energy, agriculture, infrastructure, and technology but is associated with many environmental challenges. Resource recovery alternatives like urban mining rely on inconsistent supply streams and complicated disassembly and sorting, while extreme mining alternatives such as deep sea and space mining are potentially even less sustainable than traditional mining. This perspective investigates biological mining with emphasis on the potential of fungi for scavenging metals, minerals, and rare earth elements. “Mycomining” produces only biomass-based organic waste and can offer more versatile growth conditions than phytomining using hyperaccumulating plants including substrates ranging from soil, wood, water, and rock to living organisms and dark, space-restricted, or extreme i.e., pH levels, high salt, acidic, radioactive environments. This concept could represent a useful supplement to urban and phytomining to offset demand for traditional mining and is particularly viable when conventional mining may be inefficient or uneconomical i.e., with low-grade ores and sites unsuited to traditional mining for geographical, political, or social reasons.
... There is overwhelming scientific evidence of serious adverse effects on the sea environment. These include the destruction of natural landforms and the wildlife they support and the formation of large sediment plumes that disrupt aquatic life (for example, Ahnert and Borowski, 2000;DFO, 2000;Halfar and Fujita, 2007;Sharma, 2011;Van Dover et al., 2017;Miller et al., 2018;Orcutt et al., 2020;Scales, 2021;Farran, 2022). ...
Article
Full-text available
The discovery of rare metal resources in international waters has raised seabed mining claims for large areas of the bottom. There is abundant scientific evidence of major negative consequences for the maritime environment, such as the destruction of natural landforms and the fauna that depend on them, as well as the production of enormous silt plumes that disrupt aquatic life. This study investigated the environmental risks of seabed mining for metal resources in the Baltic Sea using a combination of hydrodynamic, particle-tracking, and sediment-transport models. The models were applied for ten years i.e., 2000-2009 under prevailing conditions to simulate seabed mining operations. The focus was on sediment concentration near the seabed and its spread. The mean background concentrations were low with small seasonal bed-level variations throughout the Baltic Sea Basin. Late summer and early autumn periods were the most active. Seabed mining significantly alters the dynamics of sediment suspensions and bed level variations. The concentrations increase unsustainably to high levels, posing a serious threat to the ecological health of the Baltic Sea. The Gotland basins in the Baltic Sea are the most susceptible to mining. The bed level variations will be ten-fold, exposing the highly contaminated sediments at the seabed to the flow. In less than a year, 30-60% of the total particles released in each basin reached the thermocline layers. This study suggests that seabed mining in the Baltic Sea is not sustainable.
... Given the recent expansion of exploration activities and the imminence of large scale mineral exploitation, scientists are warning about the potential of commercial-scale seabed mining to cause severe and wide-spread environmental damage [3] [7]. Much of the damage may be long term or irreversible and restoration may, in some areas, be impractical, owing to the very slow rate of substrate reformation after mineral deposits have been removed [5]. ...
Article
Full-text available
The International Seabed Authority is an international organization created in 1982 by the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea and the Implementation Agreement of Part XI of the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea 1994 to administer the Area and the resources found therein. However, the persistent complains of the absence of an exploitation regulation in the Area for over two decades is a call for concern on the effectiveness of the International Seabed Authority in exercising its role of managing the Area. This paper is focused on investigating the strategies adopted by the International Seabed Authority for the management of the Area and the challenges it encounters in this regard. The paper does so through the exploitation of secondary and primary sources of information. Secondary data were collected from books, academic journals, magazines, and official publications touching the subject matter. To compliment secondary data, primary data was also used and this was done essentially through interviews, focus group discussions and questionnaires. The data collected were analyzed with the use of a thematic content approach. The ensuing results revealed that the strategies range from the adoption of a Strategic Plan, and the establishment of a Mining Code to Environmental Management Plans.
Chapter
The marine environment is an essential component of the global life-support system. From deep oceans to coastal reefs, from mudflats to seagrass beds, oceans and marine systems provide us with essential services: carbon capture for climate mitigation and renewable energy and protection from storm surges, to name but a few. This chapter discusses the nature and extent of pollution in the marine environment, touching on the history of marine pollution, the types of pollutants, the pathways of marine pollution as well as the nature, impact and effects of pollution on the marine environment. The focus is on the marine environment generally.
Preprint
Full-text available
TARİHİN EN BÜYÜK MADENCİLİK OPERASYONU BAŞLAMAK ÜZERE; DENİZ MADENCİLİĞİ “…okyanusun derinliklerinde işletilmesi oldukça kolay olan çinko, demir, gümüş ve altın madenleri vardır…”. Ünlü Fransız romancısı ve yazarı, bana göre ise düşünürü Jules Verne’nin 1870 yılında yayınladığı “Denizler Altında 20.000 Fersah” adlı eserinde bu cümle kullanılır. Jules Verne’nin günümüzden yaklaşık 150 yıl önce kurduğu bu hayali artık insanoğlu gerçekleştirmeye çok yakın. Günümüzde derin deniz madenciliğine gerçek anlamda başlamaya hazırız. Okyanus madenciliği yeni bir fikir değil; elmaslar, on yıllardır Güney Afrika’nın sığ sularından çıkarılıyor. Karadaki mineral depolarımızın çoğunu tüketiyoruz ve uzak olsa da, okyanusun dibi asteroidlerden daha değerli ve ulaşılabilir
Article
Full-text available
Within the endemic invertebrate faunas of hydrothermal vents, five biogeographic provinces are recognized. Invertebrates at two Indian Ocean vent fields (Kairei and Edmond) belong to a sixth province, despite ecological settings and invertebrate-bacterial symbioses similar to those of both western Pacific and Atlantic vents. Most organisms found at these Indian Ocean vent fields have evolutionary affinities with western Pacific vent faunas, but a shrimp that ecologically dominates Indian Ocean vents closely resembles its Mid-Atlantic counterpart. These findings contribute to a global assessment of the biogeography of chemosynthetic faunas and indicate that the Indian Ocean vent community follows asymmetric assembly rules biased toward Pacific evolutionary alliances.
Article
Many serious potential direct or indirect environmental impacts are to be expected from marine mining of nearshore-, shelf- as well as from deep searesources. Today the more or less harmful hazards cannot be quantified in every detail, but the general dangers for the various marine environments are foreseeable by all means. This is true for coastal and shelf regions offshore of countries which have several of the resources described below as well as for the manganese nodule mining in the international zone of the deep sea. Drastic future conflicts between industrialised and other nations concerning the marine resources, the common heritage of mankind, cannot be excluded. The sea is not only a source for the satisfaction of our present resource needs. Already today the seas are sinks for a large number of harmful pollutants stemming from our civilisation. A plundering of the sea for further economical growth can be disastrous for the various marine environments and means that future generations will be deprivated of the benefits of the sea.
Article
Interest in deep-sea mining developed in the early 1970s, with a focus on manganese nodules in international waters. Mining may actually occur first, however, on rich polymetallic sulfide deposits associated with hydrothermal vents within exclusive economic zones. Even though mining for polymetallic sulfides may not take place for several years, precautionary performance standards, environmental regulations, and the establishment of Marine Protected Areas may help guide the marine mining industry toward a goal of minimizing environmental impacts. Once substantial investments in prospecting and exploring a potential mining site are made, implementation of environmental regulations may prove to be much more difficult.
Article
In his Perspective, [Rona][1] reviews recent advances in knowledge of sea-floor resources. Knowledge is expanding from those minerals eroded from land--metals, gemstones, sand, and gravel--to those minerals concentrated by plate tectonic processes in ocean basins. Exploration of the oceans is at an early stage and development of marine mining is subject to economic and environmental considerations. [1]: http://www.sciencemag.org/cgi/content/full/299/5607/673
Article
The first attempt to exploit deep-sea manganese nodules ended in failure as a result of the collapse of world metal prices, the onerous provisions imposed by the U. N. Conference on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS), and the overoptimistic assumptions about the viability of nodule mining. Attention then focused on cobalt-rich manganese crusts from seamounts. Since the mid-1980s, a number of new players have committed themselves to long-term programs to establish the viability of mining deep-sea manganese nodules. These programs require heavy subsidy by host governments. Gold-rich submarine hydrothermal deposits located at convergent plate margins are now emerging as a more promising prospect for mining than deep-sea manganese deposits.
  • J Schneider
  • Neues Jahr
J. Schneider, Neues Jahr. Geol. Palaeontol. Abh. 208, 397 (1998).
  • C L Van Dover
C. L. Van Dover et al., Science 294, 818 (2001).
Including Tools Such as Marine Protected Areas: Scientific Requirements and Legal Aspects
  • L Glowka
L. Glowka, in Managing Risks to Biodiversity and the Environment on the High Sea, Including Tools Such as Marine Protected Areas: Scientific Requirements and Legal Aspects, H. Thiel, A. Koslow, Eds. (Proceedings of the Expert Workshop held at the International Academy for Nature Conservation, Isle of Vilm, Germany, 27 February to 4 March 2001 [BfN (Bundesamt für Naturschutz) Skripten 43, Federal Agency for Nature Conservation, Bonn, Germany, 2001), pp. 195–204; www.bfn.de/0502_meeres_kuestennaturschutz.html?&no _cache=1&L=1.
  • H Thiel
  • Forschungsverbund
  • Tiefsee-Umweltschutz
H. Thiel, Forschungsverbund, Tiefsee-Umweltschutz, in ISOPE: Ocean Mining Symposium Proceedings, Tsukuba Japan, 21 to 22 November 1995 [International Society of Offshore and Polar Engineers (ISOPE), Golden, CO, 1995], pp. 39–45.