Content uploaded by Eberhard Spoerl
Author content
All content in this area was uploaded by Eberhard Spoerl on Mar 31, 2015
Content may be subject to copyright.
Depth dependence of stiffening on riboflavin/UVA treated corneas
Schilde, T.; Spoerl, E.; Kohlhaas, M.; Pillunat, L. E.
Department of Ophthalmology, University of Dresden
Fetscherstr. 74, Germany-01307 Dresden
Purpose:
Treatment of keratoconus with riboflavin/UVA is based on a significant stiffening of the cornea. This second study
should show until which depth the mechanical stabilization after collagen-crosslinking would be provable
biochemically.
Method:
10 out of 20 enucleated porcine eyes were treated with riboflavin as photosensitizer and UVA (370nm, 3mW/cm²,
30min), the other 10 eyes served as controls. With a microkeratom two flaps of 200µm thickness were cut from
each eye and afterwards laid in collagenase solution (NaCl + collagenase; 1:1). The surfaces of the flaps were
measured digitally and compared daily to characterize the solvent behaviour.
Results:
The resistance (regarding corneal collagen against enzymatic digestion) of the treated flaps, that were cut firstly
was considerably (p=0,001) higher compared to those which were cut secondly and to the control flaps. But even
the flaps that were cut secondly showed a significant increase of resistance (p=0,02) in comparison with the
untreated flaps. The half-life of the surfaces of the treated flaps which were cut firstly was 220 hours, of those cut
secondly 80 hours. The both untreated flaps had a half-life of 50 hours.
Conclusions:
The biochemical study showed, that treatment of the cornea with riboflavin/UVA leads to a significant collagen-
crosslinking not only in the anterior slice of 200µm but also in the following 200µm. This locally limited
crosslinking-effect may be explained by the absorption behaviour for UVA of the riboflavin-treated cornea. 65% of
UVA-irradiation is absorbed in the first 200µm and only 25-30% in the next 200µm. Therefore, deeper laying
structures and especially the endothelium are not influenced.
Department of Ophthalmology
University of Dresden
Fetscherstr. 74
01309 Dresden
Germany
Contact:
Thomas Schilde
Thomas.Schilde@web.de
Commercial Relationship:
T. Schilde, None;
E. Spoerl, None;
M. Kohlhaas, None;
L.E. Pillunat, None
Depth Dependence of Stiffening
on Riboflavin/UVA Treated Corneas
T. Schilde; E. Spoerl; M. Kohlhaas; L.E. Pillunat
Department of Ophthalmology, University of Dresden, Dresden, Germany
Purpose: It was shown that treatment of keratoconus with riboflavin/UVA is based on a significant stiffening of the cornea (ARVO 2004
abstr.nr.2888). Aim of this study was to evaluate how deep the mechanical stabilization after collagen-crosslinking could be shown
biochemically.
Methods: 10 out of 20 enucleated porcine eyes were treated with riboflavin as photosensitizer and UVA (370nm; 3mW/cm²; 30 min), the
other 10 eyes served as controls. With a microkeratom two flaps of 200µm thickness were cut from each eye and afterwards were put in
collagenase solution (NaCl + collagenase A). The surfaces of the flaps were measured digitally and compared daily to characterize the
solvent behavior.
Results: The resistance (regarding corneal collagen against enzymatic digestion) of the treated superficial flaps was considerably higher
(P=0.001) compared to those which were cut secondly and to the control flaps. But even the flaps from deeper layers showed a significant
increase of resistance (P=0.02) in comparison with the untreated flaps. The half-life of the surfaces of the treated superficial flaps was 220
hours, of those cut secondly 80 hours. The both untreated flaps had a half-life of 50 hours.
Fig.1: experimental equipment Fig.2: riboflavin/UVA application Fig.3: cutting flaps with a Fig.4: dissected flaps (200µm) Fig.5: half-life of the
microkeratom surfaces
Fig.6: solvent behaviour: Fig.7: solvent behaviour: Fig.8: digitally measurement Fig.9: digitally measurement Fig.10: results
treated superficial flaps treated superficial flaps calibrate the computer- of the solved surfaces
after 3 hours after 171 hours program
Conclusion: This biochemical study showed that treatment of cornea with riboflavin/UVA leads to a significant collagen-crosslinking not
only in the anterior slice of 200µm but also in the following 200µm. This locally limited crosslinking-effect may be explained by the
absorption behaviour for UVA of the riboflavin-treated cornea. 65% of UVA- irradiation is absorbed in the first 200µm and only 25 – 30% in
the next 200µm. Therefore, deeper laying structures and especially the endothelium seem to be not influenced.
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
1 21 28 46 68 73 127 146 194 240 315
time in h
surface in mm²
koflap1
koflap2
uvflap1
uvflap2
P=0.3P=0.01
deeper
layers
P=0.025080flap from
flap
P=0.00150220superficial
untreatedtreated
Purpose: Treatment of keratoconus with riboflavin/UVA is based on a significant stiffening of the cornea. Aim of the study was to examine to which depth of the
cornea the stiffening effect is present biomechanically.
Methods: 20 enucleated porcine eyes were treated with riboflavin as photosensitizer and UVA (370 nm, 3 mW/cm², 30 min) and 20 eyes served as controls. Two
consecutive flaps of 200 μm thickness were cut with a microkeratom from each. Each flap was divided into stripes of 5 mm width and 7 mm length. Stress-strain curves
were measured with a material tester to characterize the stiffening effect. For statictics ANOVA was used. Additionally, the same procedure was realized at a pair of
human corneas.
Fig.1: UVA-radiation Fig. 2: rotormicrokeratom Fig. 3: cornea stripe Fig. 4: stress-strain measuring Fig. 5: biomechanical surveyors table
Results: Stress at 5 % strain was 261±133x10³ N/m² for the superficial treated flaps in comparison to 104±52x10³ N/m² corresponding control flaps. This difference
was statistically significant (P=0.0001). The deep treated flaps showed a stress of 105±56x10³ N/m² compared to the corresponding control flaps with 103±62x10³
N/m². This difference was not statistically significant (P=0.94). The stiffness of the superficial flap was statistically significant increased in comparison to the deeper
flaps (P = 0.001). The stiffness between the superficial and deep control flaps was not statistically significant different (P=0.9).
The same stiffening effect was also observed in the human eye. Contrary to the porcine cornea the superficial flap of the human cornea is stiffer than the second flap.
Fig. 6: Fig. 7
Conclusions: Treatment of the cornea with riboflavin/UVA leads to a significant stiffening only in the anterior 200 μm of the cornea. This locally limited stiffening
effect might be explained by the absorption behaviour of the riboflavin-treated cornea for UVA. 65 - 70 % of UVA-irradiation is absorbed in the first 200 μm and only 20
% in the next 200 μm.
Evaluation of the stiffening effect of riboflavin/UVA treatment in
different depth of the cornea
G.Unger, T. Schilde, E. Spoerl, M. Kohlhaas, L.E. Pillunat
Department of Ophthalmology, University of Dresden, Dresden, Germany
Department of Ophthalmology
University of Dresden
Fetscherstr. 74
01309 Dresden
Germany
Contact:
Gabriele Unger
gabriele.unger@uniklinikum-
dresden.de
Commercial Relationship:
G. Unger, none
T. Schilde, none
E. Spoerl, none
M. Kohlhaas, none
L.E. Pillunat, none
0
200
400
600
800
1000
1200
0 2 4 6 8 10
Strain in %
Stress in 10³ N/m²
first treated flaps
first untreated flaps
second untreated flaps
second treated flaps
porcine cornea
0
200
400
600
800
1000
1200
0 2 4 6 8 10
Strain in %
Stress in 10³ N/m²
first untreated flap
first treated flap
second untreated flap
second treated flap
human cornea (65 years)