Variations in Phytoestrogen Content between Different Mill Dates of the Same Diet Produces Significant Differences in the Time of Vaginal Opening in CD-1 Mice and F344 Rats but Not in CD Sprague-Dawley Rats

Comparative Medicine Branch, National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences, National Institutes of Health, Department of Health and Human Services, Research Triangle Park, NC 27709, USA.
Environmental Health Perspectives (Impact Factor: 7.98). 01/2008; 115(12):1717-26. DOI: 10.1289/ehp.10165
Source: PubMed


The optimum test diet and rodent species/strain for evaluating endocrine-disrupting compounds (EDCs) are critical.
We conducted studies to evaluate rodent species sensitivity and the effects of diets varying in phytoestrogen content on the time of vaginal opening (VO) in CD-1 mice, Fischer 344 (F344) rats, and CD Sprague-Dawley (S-D) rats.
Mice were weaned on postnatal day (PND) 15 and rats on PND19 and randomly assigned to control or test diets. Body weights, food consumption, and time of VO were recorded.
The time of VO was significantly advanced in F344 rats fed diets containing daidzein and genistein, whereas these same diets did not advance VO in S-D rats. When animals were fed the AIN-76A diet spiked with genistein, time of VO was significantly advanced at all doses in CD-1 mice, at the two highest doses in F344 rats, and at the highest dose in S-D rats. The time of VO in F344 rats was more highly correlated with the phytoestrogen content than with the total metabolizable energy (ME) of 12 diets.
The S-D rat is less sensitive to dietary phytoestrogens compared with the F344 rat or the CD-1 mouse, suggesting that the S-D rat is not the ideal model for evaluating estrogenic activity of EDCs. The profound effects of dietary phytoestrogens on the time of VO, an estrogen-sensitive marker, indicate that a standardized open-formula phytoestrogen-free diet containing a low ME level should be used to optimize the sensitivity of estrogenic bioassays.

Download full-text


Available from: Elizabeth Padilla-Banks
  • Source
    • "A1: There are noticeable interspecies differences in endocrine biology, for example, in the timing of critical windows of vulnerability to EASs/EDCs during development or in the hormones required to maintain pregnancy and similar interspecies differences in endocrine-mediated pathogenesis. It was reported that the same EAS/EDC exposure may result in different phenotype modifications according to the rodent species or strains.4748 Numerous differences in toxicokinetics are described from one species to another.49 "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: In the present review, we first summarize the main benefits, limitations and pitfalls of conventional in vivo approaches to assessing male reproductive structures and functions in rodents in cases of endocrine active substance (EAS) exposure from the postulate that they may provide data that can be extrapolated to humans. Then, we briefly present some integrated approaches in rodents we have recently developed at the organism level. We particularly focus on the possible effects and modes of action (MOA) of these substances at low doses and in mixtures, real-life conditions and at the organ level, deciphering the precise effects and MOA on the fetal testis. It can be considered that the in vivo experimental EAS exposure of rodents remains the first choice for studies and is a necessary tool (together with the epidemiological approach) for understanding the reproductive effects and MOA of EASs, provided the pitfalls and limitations of the rodent models are known and considered. We also provide some evidence that classical rodent models may be refined for studying the multiple consequences of EAS exposure, not only on the reproductive axis but also on various hormonally regulated organs and tissues, among which several are implicated in the complex process of mammalian reproduction. Such models constitute an interesting way of approaching human exposure conditions. Finally, we show that organotypic culture models are powerful complementary tools, especially when focusing on the MOA. All these approaches have contributed in a combinatorial manner to a better understanding of the impact of EAS exposure on human reproduction.
    Full-text · Article · Jan 2014 · Asian Journal of Andrology
  • Source
    • "Additionally, vaginal opening was advanced in CD-1 mice fed a diet spiked with 150, 300, or 450 mg genistein/g food and in F344 rats fed the 300 and 450 mg genistein/g food diets (Thigpen et al., 2007). Each of these experiments was also performed with Sprague-Dawley rats, but no advance in vaginal opening was noted in this strain (Thigpen et al., 2007). Thus, these experiments highlight the necessity of choosing the appropriate animal species and strain for testing xenoestrogen-sensitive endpoints. "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: The United States presently uses more than 80 000 chemicals, a number that is estimated to grow by 2000 chemicals each year. Although generally not considered toxic at current exposure levels, many of these chemicals interfere with the endocrine system and may have profound effects on reproduction. Exposure to endocrine-disrupting chemicals (EDCs) is associated with an earlier onset of puberty, decreased fecundity and fertility, altered sexual behavior, and increased incidence of abnormalities and cancers of the reproductive tract in humans and in laboratory animals. Importantly, it appears that developing organisms may be particularly sensitive to slight variations in the hormonal milieu that occurs after exposure to some chemicals. In this chapter we review the sources and mechanisms of several well-studied EDCs and the evidence that exposure to these chemicals affects many aspects of mammalian reproduction.
    Full-text · Chapter · Jan 2010
  • Source
    • "These differences in phytoestrogen effects in previous studies may be due, in part, to the different rat strains used in those studies. A recent report [66] showed that Sprague-Dawley rats were less sensitive to phytoestrogens than Fisher 344 rats or CD-1 mice in evaluations of estrogenic activity. To compare results from the present study with those found in previous experiments employing Noble rats, a computer-assisted literature search was conducted. "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: High dietary intake of selenium or isoflavones reduces risk factors for prostate cancer. We tested whether combined supplementation of these two dietary components would reduce prostate cancer risk factors in rats more than supplementation of each component individually. Male Noble rat pups were exposed from conception to diets containing an adequate (0.33-0.45 mg/kg diet) or high (3.33-3.45 mg/kg) concentration of selenium as Se-methylselenocysteine and a low (10 mg/kg) or high (600 mg/kg) level of isoflavones in a 2 x 2 factorial design. Pups consumed their respective diets until sacrifice at 35, 100, or 200 days. Male Noble rat breeders, whose exposure to the diets began after puberty, were sacrificed at 336 days. Rats were weighed biweekly. Blood was collected at the time of sacrifice and body fat and prostates were dissected and weighed. Serum levels of leptin, IGF-1, and testosterone were determined using ELISA kits. Serum levels of isoflavones were assayed by GC/MS. Liver activity of selenium-dependent glutathione peroxidase 1 was measured as an indicator of selenium status. Serum isoflavone concentrations were nearly 100-fold higher at 35 days of age (1187.1 vs. 14.4 ng/mL, mean +/- SD) in pups fed the high vs. low isoflavone diets, and remained so at 100 and 200 days, and in breeders. There were no dietary differences in liver glutathione peroxidase activity in pups or breeders. High isoflavone intake significantly (p = 0.001-0.047) reduced body weight in rat pups from 35 days onward, but not in breeders. Body fat and leptin were likewise significantly reduced by high isoflavones in pups while effects in breeders were less pronounced but still significant. High intake of Se and isoflavones each decreased serum IGF-1 in pups at 100 and 200 days, but not in breeders. No consistent dietary effects were observed on serum testosterone or relative weights of prostates. In pups, the combination of high isoflavones and high selenium produced the lowest weight gain, the lowest serum leptin, and the lowest serum IGF-1 concentrations of all four diets. Combined intake of high selenium and high isoflavones may achieve greater chemopreventive effects than either compound individually. The timing of supplementation may determine the significance of its effects.
    Full-text · Article · Dec 2008 · Nutrition & Metabolism
Show more