A Pilot Study Comparing the Effects of Mindfulness-Based and Cognitive-Behavioral Stress Reduction

Department of Psychology, University of New Mexico, Albuquerque, NM 85131-1161, USA.
The Journal of Alternative and Complementary Medicine (Impact Factor: 1.59). 05/2008; 14(3):251-8. DOI: 10.1089/acm.2007.0641
Source: PubMed


The objective of this pilot study was to compare the effects of two mind-body interventions: mindfulness-based stress reduction (MBSR) and cognitive-behavioral stress reduction (CBSR).
Fifty (50) subjects were recruited from the community and took part in MBSR (n = 36) and CBSR (n = 14) courses. Participants self-selected into MBSR or CBSR courses taught at different times. There were no initial differences between the MBSR and CBSR subjects on demographics, including age, gender, education, and income.
MBSR was an 8-week course using meditation, gentle yoga, and body scanning exercises to increase mindfulness. CBSR was an 8-week course using cognitive and behavioral techniques to change thinking and reduce distress.
Perceived stress, depression, psychological well-being, neuroticism, binge eating, energy, pain, and mindfulness were assessed before and after each course. Pre-post scores for each intervention were compared by using paired t tests. Pre-post scores across interventions were compared by using a general linear model with repeated measures. SETTINGS/LOCATIONS: Weekly meetings for both courses were held in a large room on a university medical center campus.
MBSR subjects improved on all eight outcomes, with all of the differences being significant. CBSR subjects improved on six of eight outcomes, with significant improvements on well-being, perceived stress, and depression. Multivariate analyses showed that the MBSR subjects had better outcomes across all variables, when compared with the CBSR subjects. Univariate analyses showed that MBSR subjects had better outcomes with regard to mindfulness, energy, pain, and a trend for binge eating.
While MBSR and CBSR may both be effective in reducing perceived stress and depression, MBSR may be more effective in increasing mindfulness and energy and reducing pain. Future studies should continue to examine the differential effects of cognitive behavioral and mindfulness-based interventions and attempt to explain the reasons for the differences.

Download full-text


Available from: Jennifer Bernard, Apr 17, 2014
  • Source
    • "Use of MBSR has been studied in clinical and healthy populations for almost three decades. This technique has been linked to generally improved health in stressed populations (Grossman, Niemann, Schmidt, & Walach, 2004; Monti et al., 2006), decreased average daily cortisol levels (Carlson, Speca, Faris, & Patel, 2007), increased immune responsiveness (Davidson et al., 2003), lower self-reported distress (Astin et al., 2003; Smith et al., 2008; Speca, Carlson, Goodey, & Angen, 2000; Tacon, McComb, Caldera, & Randolph, 2003), and reduced depressive and physical symptoms (Dobkin & Zhao, 2011; Gallegos, Hoerger, Talbot, Moynihan, & Duberstein, 2013). In patients with cancer, MBSR increased meaningfulness, decreased psychological symptoms and fatigue, and improved sleep. "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: This article provides an overview of the mechanisms of action, evidence base, and practice of mindfulness, with an emphasis on how to easily incorporate this valuable skill into practice. PubMed, CINAHL, PsychInfo Databases. Conscious attention to the present moment in a receptive way is known as mindfulness. A growing body of research indicates that mindfulness can be taught and cultivated to improve physical and mental health. Accordingly, as part of the coaching competency, mindfulness can be practiced and taught by advanced practice nurses to support lifestyle and behavioral changes, decrease perceived stress, enhance quality of life, and, ultimately, improve health and health outcomes.
    Full-text · Article · Sep 2014 · Journal of the American Association of Nurse Practitioners
  • Source
    • "Recently, meditation-based approaches, such as mindfulness-based stress reduction (MBSR), have come into wide use.113,114 These stress management program are shown to be effective in both nonclinical healthy subjects and patients with mental and physical illnesses.106,113 MBSR is a group program that focuses upon the progressive acquisition of mindfulness. "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Mental health is essential for individual and public health. To improve mental health, promotion, prevention, and the treatment of disease are required. These three kinds of interventions are interrelated but independent from one another. Although separate efforts for mental health promotion and prevention are needed as well as the public need of mental health promotion and well-being, psychiatrists usually are not accustomed to mental health promotion and prevention. This review introduces an overview of the concept, subjects according to target populations, and various intervention strategies for mental health promotion and prevention of mental illnesses. Based on literatures to date, understanding of developmental psychology, lifestyle medicine, and biopsychosocial contributors of mental health with a macroscopic perspective might help to practice mental health promotion and illness prevention.
    Full-text · Article · Dec 2013 · Psychiatry investigation
  • Source
    • "The authors also measured anxiety, depression, general health, and post-concussion symptoms, all without significant changes (McMillan et al. 2002). MBSR has also proved a clinically effective method for a wide range of conditions as stress, depression, pain, and fatigue after cancer (Carlson and Garland 2005; Grossmana et al. 2004; Kabat- Zinn et al. 1985; Smith et al. 2008). Mindfulness meditation is also suggested to be linked to improvement in attention and cognitive flexibility (Moore and Malinowski 2009), changes in brain neuronal connectivity, with indicated improved attention (Kilpatrick et al. 2011), and is also suggested to improve the ability to improve attention and recognition of items which temporarily appear close up (Slagter et al. 2007). "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Abstract Mental fatigue is, for many, a very distressing and long-term problem after a traumatic brain injury (TBI) or stroke. This will make it more difficult for the individual to return to work and resume social activities, and it can take several years to find the right balance between rest and activity in daily life, to find strategies and to accept the new situation. The aim of this study was to evaluate the effect of an advanced mindfulness program following a MBSR program, designed for subjects suffering from long-term mental fatigue after a brain injury. The advanced program was based on The Brahma Viharas, meditative practices known for cultivating four mental states: compassion, metta, appreciative joy, and equanimity. Fourteen participants followed the 8-month advanced mindfulness program, with group visits once a month and a final all-day retreat. All the participants were suffering from mental fatigue at least 1 year after a brain injury following a stroke or a TBI. The assessments after the advanced program showed a significant and sustained positive effect on mental fatigue and on tests measuring information processing speed and attention. With mindfulness practice it was possible to improve wakefulness during meditation and, above all, improve the mental fatigue levels. We propose that mindfulness is a promising treatment for mental fatigue after a stroke or TBI.
    Full-text · Article · Oct 2013 · Mindfulness
Show more