ArticlePDF Available

Abstract and Figures

Poppy seed-containing foods are popular dishes in Hungary and some other Central European countries. The alkaloids of poppy are used in the production of medicines. Poppy seeds used as food may also contain considerable amounts of alkaloids, which raises the question of food safety. Morphine, codeine, thebaine and noscapine concentrations of poppy seed samples from the period 2001-2010 and consumption data from two Hungarian surveys, carried out in 2003 and 2009, were evaluated. Exposure calculations were made for morphine intake by both point estimate and probabilistic methods, and the uncertainty of the calculated values was estimated. The point estimate for the acute consumer exposure, calculated using the 97.5th percentiles of morphine concentration and of poppy seed consumption and taking into account the reduction of morphine content by processing, was 78.64 µg (kg bw)⁻¹ day⁻¹ for adults, and 116.90 µg (kg bw)⁻¹ day⁻¹ for children. Based on probabilistic estimations, the 97.5th and 99th percentile exposures ranged between 18.3-25.4 and 25.6-47.4 µg (kg bw)⁻¹ day⁻¹ for adults, and between 32.9 and 66.4 µg (kg bw)⁻¹ day⁻¹ for children, respectively. As a no observed effect level (NOEL) had not been established, the significance of exposure could not be assessed.
Content may be subject to copyright.
This article was downloaded by: [A. Zentai]
On: 29 February 2012, At: 00:38
Publisher: Taylor & Francis
Informa Ltd Registered in England and Wales Registered Number: 1072954 Registered office: Mortimer House,
37-41 Mortimer Street, London W1T 3JH, UK
Food Additives & Contaminants: Part A: Chemistry,
Analysis, Control, Exposure & Risk Assessment
Publication details, including instructions for authors and subscription information:
http://www.tandfonline.com/loi/tfac20
Exposure of consumers to morphine from poppy seeds
in Hungary
A. Zentai a , J. Sali a , M. Szeitzné-Szabó a , I.J. Szabó a & Á. Ambrus a
a Hungarian Food Safety Office, Budapest 1097, Gyáli út 2–6, Hungary
Available online: 10 Nov 2011
To cite this article: A. Zentai, J. Sali, M. Szeitzné-Szabó, I.J. Szabó & Á. Ambrus (2012): Exposure of consumers to morphine
from poppy seeds in Hungary, Food Additives & Contaminants: Part A: Chemistry, Analysis, Control, Exposure & Risk
Assessment, 29:3, 403-414
To link to this article: http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/19440049.2011.636762
PLEASE SCROLL DOWN FOR ARTICLE
Full terms and conditions of use: http://www.tandfonline.com/page/terms-and-conditions
This article may be used for research, teaching, and private study purposes. Any substantial or systematic
reproduction, redistribution, reselling, loan, sub-licensing, systematic supply, or distribution in any form to
anyone is expressly forbidden.
The publisher does not give any warranty express or implied or make any representation that the contents
will be complete or accurate or up to date. The accuracy of any instructions, formulae, and drug doses should
be independently verified with primary sources. The publisher shall not be liable for any loss, actions, claims,
proceedings, demand, or costs or damages whatsoever or howsoever caused arising directly or indirectly in
connection with or arising out of the use of this material.
Food Additives and Contaminants
Vol. 29, No. 3, March 2012, 403–414
Exposure of consumers to morphine from poppy seeds in Hungary
A. Zentai*, J. Sali, M. Szeitzne
´-Szabo
´, I.J. Szabo
´and A
´. Ambrus
Hungarian Food Safety Office, Budapest 1097, Gya
´li u
´t 2–6, Hungary
(Received 25 May 2011; final version received 27 October 2011)
Poppy seed-containing foods are popular dishes in Hungary and some other Central European countries.
The alkaloids of poppy are used in the production of medicines. Poppy seeds used as food may also contain
considerable amounts of alkaloids, which raises the question of food safety. Morphine, codeine, thebaine and
noscapine concentrations of poppy seed samples from the period 2001–2010 and consumption data from two
Hungarian surveys, carried out in 2003 and 2009, were evaluated. Exposure calculations were made for morphine
intake by both point estimate and probabilistic methods, and the uncertainty of the calculated values was
estimated. The point estimate for the acute consumer exposure, calculated using the 97.5th percentiles of
morphine concentration and of poppy seed consumption and taking into account the reduction of morphine
content by processing, was 78.64 mg (kg bw)
1
day
1
for adults, and 116.90 mg (kg bw)
1
day
1
for children. Based
on probabilistic estimations, the 97.5th and 99th percentile exposures ranged between 18.3–25.4 and 25.6–47.4 mg
(kg bw)
1
day
1
for adults, and between 32.9 and 66.4 mg (kg bw)
1
day
1
for children, respectively. As a no
observed effect level (NOEL) had not been established, the significance of exposure could not be assessed.
Keywords: natural toxicants – alkaloids; exposure – probability modelling; exposure assessment
Introduction
Foods made from poppy seeds are popular in
Hungary. However, their natural alkaloid content
can be of concern. The poppy plant (Papaver
somniferum L.) contains several alkaloids, for instance
morphine, codeine, noscapine and thebaine. These are
important substances in the production of medicines.
Poppy plant varieties are grown for industrial and
dietary purposes as well. The published literature
indicates that poppy seeds contain only very low or
non-detectable levels of alkaloids (Lachenmeier et al.
2010), but the seeds may be contaminated during
harvest. The poppy seeds from plants cultivated for
industrial alkaloid production in Hungary are allowed
for human consumption only after proper cleaning.
Occasionally, the poppy seed marketed as a food
ingredient could contain high amounts of the alkaloids.
During the past five years the poppy seed was the
subject of increased research, particularly regarding the
reduction of its morphine contents. This was the result
of a serious intoxication case of an infant in Germany
in 2005 (Lachenmeier et al. 2010).
The consumption of large amounts of highly
contaminated poppy seeds may lead to light-
headedness and enteroparesis in sensitive individuals.
The symptoms described are in agreement with the
toxicological actions of morphine. In particular,
reports indicate that morphine intake from poppy
seeds may be on the scale of therapeutic morphine
doses (Battilani et al. 2009). In Hungary, official
authorities have recorded data of illnesses caused by
poppy seed consumption since 1985. The symptoms
ranged from paleness to nausea, vomiting, diarrhoea,
headache, stomach cramps, trembling, flushing, a
bitter sensation, stupor, dizziness, drowsiness, shiver-
ing, depression and itchy skin. Ground raw poppy seed
was consumed in all cases. However, the amount eaten
was not recorded (personal communication by the
National Institute for Food and Nutrition Science
2006).
After ingestion, morphine is relatively quickly
absorbed from the gastrointestinal tract, mainly from
the upper small intestine and, to a lesser degree, from
the stomach. The maximum effect of morphine is
achieved about 30 min after ingestion. The effect of a
single dose lasts about 4–6 h (Federal Institute for Risk
Assessment 2005). Morphine is metabolised mainly in
the liver and it undergoes conjugation with glucuronic
acid principally at the 3-hydroxyl group. Morphine is
excreted in urine mainly as morphine-3-glucuronide. In
addition to the 3,6-diglucuronide, other minor metab-
olites that have been identified include normorphine
and the 3-ethereal sulphate (Battilani et al. 2009).
Secondary conjugation also occurs at the 6-hydroxyl
group to form the 6-glucuronide, which is pharmaco-
logically active, and to a limited extent the
*Corresponding author. Email: zentai.andrea@mebih.gov.hu
ISSN 1944–0049 print/ISSN 1944–0057 online
ß2012 Taylor & Francis
http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/19440049.2011.636762
http://www.tandfonline.com
Downloaded by [A. Zentai] at 00:38 29 February 2012
3,6-diglucuronide. The low bioavailability (20–40%) in
the case of oral morphine administration can be
attributed to elimination through metabolism in the
intestinal mucosa and liver (Battilani et al. 2009).
There is no internationally accepted reference point
for the toxicity of poppy seed alkaloids. At a national
level, the German Federal Institute for Risk
Assessment (BfR) estimated 6.3 mg (kg bw)
1
day
1
as
a provisional daily upper intake level of morphine from
poppy seeds in 2005, based on the lowest oral
therapeutic dose of 1.9 mg morphine (2.5 mg morphine
sulphate pentahydrate) per person and a safety factor
of 5 (Federal Institute for Risk Assessment 2005). The
lowest starting oral dose administered to adults with
normal kidney function for pain killing is 2 30 and
210 mg day
1
for patients with restricted renal
diuretic capacity (Embey-Isztin 1996). Taking into
account the lowest 10 mg single dose, it is about five
times higher than the oral therapeutic dose used in the
BfR study. In the European Union, only Hungary has
a national legislation (17/1999 Eu
¨M rendelet 1999) that
specifies the maximum permitted levels at 30 mg kg
1
for morphine, 40 mg kg
1
for morphine and noscapine,
20 mg kg
1
for noscapine, 20 mg kg
1
for codeine, and
20 mg kg
1
for thebaine in poppy seed.
According to several studies, proper cleaning,
washing, grinding and baking could reduce signifi-
cantly the alkaloid contents of poppy seeds. Sproll
et al. (2006, 2007) studied the effect of processing on
the morphine level of poppy seed and found that the
optimal treatment for reduction consists of washing,
drying and grinding. All washing treatments led to a
significant reduction of the morphine content with a
minimal removal of 48% and a maximum removal of
the total morphine content. With cold water, only
about 60% of morphine was removed. At temperatures
above 60C, a significantly higher proportion, around
90%, could be removed. The length of poppy seed
rinsing also increased the level of reduction. Grinding
reduced the morphine and codeine contents on average
by 24% and about 20%, respectively (Sproll et al.
2007). In another study, Sproll et al. (2006) reported
morphine losses of 34% 5% due to grinding. They
also found that during baking up to 135C the
reduction of morphine was relatively low (around
30%), but at 220C a reduction of 80–90% was
observed.
The present study presents the results of the
evaluation of the acute exposure of Hungarian poppy
seed consumers to morphine, calculated with both
point estimate and probabilistic methods, based on the
alkaloid content of poppy seed marketed in Hungary
during 2001–2010, and on consumption data from the
surveys conducted in 2003 (Rodler et al. 2005) and
2009 (Szeitz-Szabo
´et al. 2011), also taking into
account the effect of processing. The uncertainty of
the calculated values was also estimated.
Materials and methods
The results of morphine, thebaine, noscapine and
codeine analyses in 737 poppy seed samples were
obtained from the market surveys carried out by the
Hungarian authorities. The National Institute for
Food Hygiene and Nutrition provided 566 data
samples from 2001 to 2006, and 171 data samples
were supplied by the Central Agricultural Office for
2007–2010.
During the first study period the alkaloid content
was measured with thin-layer chromatography accord-
ing to Hungarian standard MSZ 690:1993. In this
method the morphine was extracted with chloroform-
isopropyl alcohol, purified with 0.1 mol l
1
HCl solu-
tion, separated and detected on silica GF
254
TLC plate.
The recovery rate was 80%. The LOQ for morphine
was 2 mg kg
1
, and it varied between 2, 3, 4, 5 and
8mgkg
1
for noscapine, codeine and thebaine. The
results were confirmed with HPLC-UV detection.
Morphine was determined with HPLC-MS/MS
during 2007–2010. The poppy seed test portions were
extracted with methanol containing 1% HCl by
shaking for 2 h. The filtered extracts were directly
injected into the HPLC column (C18 5 mm) and
detected with MS/MS. The typical method perfor-
mance parameters reported were: LOQ ¼1mgkg
1
,
LOD ¼0.2 mg kg
1
, recoveries of 78–93%, 70–94%,
51–96% and 84–101%, and the reproducibility relative
standard deviation (RSD) at around 30 mg kg
1
was
6.3%, 5.9%, 7.6% and 15.2% for morphine, codeine,
thebaine and noscapine, respectively. The accuracy and
selectivity of the method were tested by spiking poppy
seed with known alkaloid contents and hemp which
does not contain alkaloids. The alkaloid standards of
known purity were purchased from Sigma-Aldrich Co.
LLC (J. Do
¨mso
¨di, personal communication).
Consumption data obtained with 3-day dietary
record methods from the years 2003 and 2009 were
used for the assessment. In 2003, 1360 adult consumers
recorded 79 poppy seed consumption days (1.94%),
while 4992 consumers (age range between 0 and 101
years) reported 327 poppy seed consumption days
(2.18%) in 2009. Regarding consumption data of
children and adolescents of 1–18 years of age, infor-
mation was only available from the consumption
survey conducted in 2009, where 1010 young respon-
ders reported 85 poppy seed consumption days in total
(2.81%). In the 2009 survey there were data available
about the recipes for foods, so it was possible to
evaluate the data for processing effects. The poppy
seed was consumed in ground form on 65% of days
and only in 35% of the cases was it consumed in baked
cakes.
In view of the infrequent consumption of poppy
seed and the rapid decrease of the potential adverse
effects of its alkaloid content, only the acute exposure
404 A. Zentai et al.
Downloaded by [A. Zentai] at 00:38 29 February 2012
of consumers is a concern. For the estimation of acute
exposure, both the alkaloid concentration data and the
poppy seed consumption data (eaters only) obtained
during the two periods were considered separately, and
after combining them for the whole time period
(2001–2010 for alkaloid concentrations, and
2003 þ2009 for the poppy seed consumptions).
For point estimate, the exposure was calculated
using the 97.5th percentile of daily poppy seed
consumptions and the 97.5th percentile of morphine
concentrations (European Food Safety Authority
(EFSA) 2007).
As consumption data for ground poppy seed and
baked poppy seed were available from the 2009 survey,
the effect of processing on morphine intake could also
be studied. The processing factor (P
f
) was calculated as
the ratio of the concentration of morphine in processed
(ground or ground and baked) poppy seed and raw
poppy seed (Food and Agriculture Organisation
(FAO) 2009). As poppy seed is not washed as part of
commercial or bakery operations in Hungary, the
effect of washing was not considered. The P
f
of 0.71 for
grinding of poppy seed was calculated from the 34%
and 24% average losses of morphine (Sproll et al. 2006,
2007). Strudels and cakes are baked in Hungary
typically at 180C. The P
f
of 0.31 for the baking of
cakes was estimated using an MS Excel exponential
trend line-fitting function from the reduction of
morphine content observed at 135 and 220C (Sproll
et al. 2006) assuming the reported quadratic relation-
ship. The combined processing factors including grind-
ing for morphine content in baked poppy seed was
0.71 0.31 ¼0.22. The morphine intakes were reduced
by the calculated processing factors according to the
form of consumed poppy.
For probabilistic modelling, parametric distribu-
tions were fitted to the morphine concentrations and
consumption data applying the @RISK programme
package. The uncertainty of the fitted parameters was
not estimated. The relative frequency distributions of
the original data and the fitted distributions were also
visually evaluated. Parametric distributions giving the
best fit for both the morphine concentrations and
consumption data were used to generate 200,000 and
500,000 random values. The generated lognormal or
gamma distributions were expected to cover the
high experimental values and beyond those
observed. Morphine exposure of children and adoles-
cents, as a subset of the total population, was
calculated similarly.
In summary, the exposure was calculated with each
of the following methods, for comparison:
Method (a): All consumption data were multiplied by
all morphine concentration data.
Method (b): The 200,000 or 500,000 pairs of random
values of morphine concentrations and poppy seed
consumptions, drawn from the selected parametric
distributions, were multiplied with each other. This is a
parametric alternative to method (a).
Method (c): The combined original data populations
(737 morphine concentrations and 406 poppy seed
consumptions) were bootstrapped 10,000 times and the
resulting morphine concentrations were multiplied by
the resulting consumption values (10,000 iterations).
The cumulative relative frequencies of exposure were
calculated from each iterations, using the NIST (2011)
definition for percentile calculations. This non-para-
metric bootstrapping procedure (Efron and Tibshirani
1994) was used to quantify uncertainty due to the
limited sample sizes.
Methods (d1) and (d2): Morphine intake was calcu-
lated using the abovementioned processing factors for
ground and baked poppy seeds applying procedures
(b) and (c).
The poppy seed consumption in raw ground form
and in baked cakes showed distinctly different pat-
terns, therefore parametric distributions were sepa-
rately fitted on the two datasets. The exposures of
consumers to morphine derived from consuming
ground poppy seed and cakes containing poppy seed
were calculated separately from the resampled distri-
butions of consumption and morphine data. As the
separate consumption data were only available from
the 2009 survey, the lognormal distribution fitted on
2007–2010 morphine concentration data was used for
the calculations. In order to obtain representative
exposure values for the combined poppy seed con-
sumption, the proportion of consumption days of
ground poppy seed (65%) and ground and baked
poppy seed (35%) were taken into account and 325,688
and 174,312 random samples were drawn from the
generated ground and baked poppy seed consumption
data population, respectively. The same number of
concentration data were drawn from the generated
morphine population. The exposures calculated from
the two sets of data were evaluated separately and in
combination.
The results obtained with these different methods
were compared and evaluated together.
Results and discussion
Alkaloid levels in poppy seeds in Hungary
Altogether 737 poppy seed samples were analysed.
Morphine was detected in 736 out of 737 samples.
Codeine and thebaine were detected in 61.3% and
63.0% of the cases, respectively. Noscapine was
detected in 6.2% of the samples only. In more than
half of the samples three or four alkaloids were
detected together. Table 1 presents the summary of
the detectable alkaloids and their selected percentiles,
in the samples.
Morphine content of the samples varied to a great
extent, with median of 11 mg kg
1
and highest values
Food Additives and Contaminants 405
Downloaded by [A. Zentai] at 00:38 29 February 2012
of 222, 238, 267 and 533 mg kg
1
. The 97.5th and 95th
percentiles and the median values of morphine con-
centrations were calculated with Harrell–Davis
(Peter Craig, personal communication), and the bino-
mial (Hamilton et al. 2004) methods, and with MS
Excel (Table 2). The binomial method enabled one to
estimate the probability that a given ranked value is the
selected percentile of the population. The Harrell–
Davis and the binomial methods resulted in very
similar estimates, while the 97.5th percentiles obtained
with Excel were lower. Consequently, the average
values of the median, 95th and 97.5th estimates
obtained with the Harrell–Davis and binomial meth-
ods are given in Table 3 for the alkaloids detected in
poppy seeds. The average estimated 97.5th percentile
of morphine concentrations and the similarly estimated
97.5th percentile of poppy seed consumptions were
used when calculating the point estimates of morphine
intake.
The relative frequency distributions of morphine
concentrations measured during the two survey periods
were similar (Figure 1). The ratios of the 97.5th
percentile and median values of the morphine 2007–
2010 and 2001–2006 datasets were 1.064 and 1.055,
respectively. The ratios indicate that the morphine
concentrations measured with different methods
during 2001–2006 and 2007–2010 were not
Table 1. Number of poppy seed samples analysed and the percentage of alkaloids detected in the samples above the LOQ.
Years 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010
Sample number 80 77 173 55 82 99 71 54 25 21
Morphine, % detected 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 99.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0
Median 7.92 16.99 10.38 9.48 15.05 10.93 11.14 12.88 12.70 8.08
97.5th percentile 68.12 300.01 82.40 41.01 89.63 128.80 137.87 110.41 27.63 26.69
Codeine, % detected 30.0 64.9 48.0 56.4 75.6 69.7 80.3 75.9 96.0 52.4
Median of codeine concentrations 0.30 2.00 0.30 2.00 2.00 2.00 2.00 1.70 2.00 1.10
97.5th percentile of codeine concentrations 10.13 33.95 21.10 8.60 29.98 20.55 25.28 12.40 4.28 3.50
Noscapine, % detected 3.8 5.2 4.0 0.0 0.0 3.0 9.9 18.5 32.0 19.0
Median of noscapine concentrations 0.30 0.30 1.30 1.30 1.30 1.30 0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20
97.5th percentile of noscapine concentrations 2.05 5.20 4.00 1.30 1.30 4.98 6.28 6.22 11.58 5.10
Thebaine, % detected 27.5 61.0 50.9 61.8 67.1 78.8 90.1 70.4 92.0 71.4
Median of thebaine concentrations 0.30 2.00 2.00 2.00 2.00 2.00 3.40 1.70 2.50 1.40
97.5th percentile of thebaine concentrations 10.00 46.20 22.00 15.55 22.00 16.40 42.33 15.03 7.16 4.00
Notes: Calculated 97.5th percentiles are only indicative values and should be interpreted with caution, as the limited sample
number does not make their precise calculation possible. The percentiles were calculated with MS Excel.
Table 2. Calculated 97.5th percentiles and medians of morphine data (mg kg
1
).
Year; number
of samples
97.5th percentile of concentration Median concentration
Excel Harrell–Davis
Binomial method
Excel Harrell–Davis
Binomial method
LCL Calculated value UCL LCL Calculated value UCL
2001–2006; 566 80.00 85.74 67.00 89.21 160.00 11.00 10.95 10.00 10.95 11.00
2007–2010; 171 52.70 90.67 2.90 95.40 4202.00
a
11.40 11.53 10.80 11.57 12.70
2001–2010; 737 80.00 83.57 67.00 86.09 141.00 11.00 10.99 11.00 11.00 11.00
Notes: Harrell–Davis, values calculated with Harrell–Davis method; LCL, lower limit of 95% confidence interval; UCL: upper
limit of 95% confidence interval.
a
Number of data points was not sufficient for the estimation of confidence limits accurately.
Table 3. Distribution characteristics of the alkaloid levels
(mg kg
1
) in all (2001–2010) samples.
Median
a
Average
b
P0.95
a
P0.975
a
Maximum
Morphine 11.0 18.7 57.6 84.8 533.0
Codeine 2.0 3.6 17.2 25.7 60.0
Noscapine 1.2 1.2 1.6 4.7 40.0
Thebaine 2.0 4.0 15.8 23.9 120.0
Notes:
a
The median, 95th and 97.5th percentiles are the
average of the estimates obtained with Harrell–Davis and
binomial methods.
b
Average concentrations were calculated with the reported
LOQ/6 values for non-detected results (European
Commission Directorate – General Health and Consumer
Protection 2003).
406 A. Zentai et al.
Downloaded by [A. Zentai] at 00:38 29 February 2012
substantially different. The Mann–Whitney U-test
confirmed that the difference was not significant
(p¼0.35) (McDonald 2009).
The medians and 97.5th percentile concentrations
of alkaloids calculated for the 10 years of data
separately (Table 1) did not indicate a clear trend
when changing of morphine content. The calculated
97.5th percentiles were lower in the last years (2009 and
2010), but they may be attributed to the smaller
number of samples analysed, as the probability of
detecting at least one value above the 97.5th percentile
is only 40–45% in the case of 21–25 samples. Based on
these results, the combination of morphine data of the
10 years is justified.
Consumption of poppy seeds in Hungary
In the 2003 food consumption survey, poppy seed
consumption occurred on 1.94% of all consumption
days. Considering the body weight of consumers, the
highest, 97.5th percentile and average daily consump-
tion were 1.0, 0.80 and 0.34 g (kg bw)
1
day
1
,
respectively.
Poppy seed consumption was recorded on 327 out
of 14,976 days (2.18%) in the 2009 food consumption
survey. The average and 97.5th percentile consump-
tions were 0.44 and 1.20 g (kg bw)
1
day
1
, respec-
tively. The highest adult consumption was recorded by
a 20-year-old, 62-kg man (1.68 g (kg bw)
1
day
1
). The
average and 97.5th percentile consumptions of children
and adolescents were 0.67 and 1.77 g (kg bw)
1
day
1
,
respectively. The highest poppy seed consumption was
recorded by a 4-year-old, 22-kg girl (2.73 g (kg bw)
1
day
1
); while the youngest poppy seed consumer was 1
year old. It should be pointed out that none of the
consumption survey periods included Christmas, when
cakes are traditionally prepared with poppy seed.
The relative and cumulative frequency distributions
of 2003 and 2009 consumption data are shown
in Figure 2. The characteristics of the distributions
are given in Table 4. The difference in the consumption
figures might be attributed to the relatively small
number of consumption days in 2003.
There was detailed information on the form of
consumed poppy seed from the 2009 survey only. Out
of the 327 consumption days, pasta with ground, raw
poppy seed was consumed on 213 (65%) occasions,
and baked cakes were consumed on 114 (35%)
occasions. Consumption levels of raw, ground poppy
seed were generally higher than those of baked poppy
(Table 4).
Morphine intake from the consumption of poppy
seeds
Point estimate
Following the FAO/WHO recommended method
(World Health Organization (WHO) 1997) and the
current practice of the European Food Safety
Authority (EFSA) (2011), the 97.5th percentile of
poppy seed consumptions of eaters and the 97.5th
percentile of morphine concentration data were used
for calculating point estimates of acute intake.
In order to assess the potential consequence of
morphine concentrations and consumption values
obtained during the two periods, the intakes were
calculated from the two consumption datasets sepa-
rately and from the combined consumption data as
well as the separate and combined morphine concen-
tration datasets. The results are summarised in Table 5.
Figure 1. Relative frequency distributions of morphine concentrations detected in poppy seed.
Food Additives and Contaminants 407
Downloaded by [A. Zentai] at 00:38 29 February 2012
Figure 2. (a) Distributions of poppy seed consumption data in 2003 and 2009; and (b) distribution of poppy seed consumption in
ground raw and baked form in 2009.
Table 4. Poppy seed consumption (g (kg bw)
1
day
1
) based on the 2003 and 2009 surveys.
Survey data
2009
2003 2003 þ2009 Ratio
a
All Ground Baked
Number of days 327 213 114 79 406
Minimum 0.042 0.048 0.042 0.031 0.031
Average 0.440 0.516 0.300 0.340 0.421 1.294
Maximum 2.727 2.727 1.677 1.000 2.727
SD 0.304 0.294 0.271 0.183 0.287
CV 0.689 0.570 0.902 0.538 0.681
Median
b
0.395 0.439 0.217 0.337 0.382 1.172
P0.975
b
1.255 1.235 0.954 0.862 1.190 1.456
Notes:
a
Ratio of 2009/2003 consumption based on food survey data.
b
Median and P0.975 estimates were obtained with Harrell–Davis and binomial methods.
408 A. Zentai et al.
Downloaded by [A. Zentai] at 00:38 29 February 2012
Based on consumption of raw poppy seed, the
point estimate (using average percentiles calculated by
the binomial and Harrell–Davis calculation methods)
for the acute consumer exposure ranges between 73.1
and 116.7 mg (kg bw)
1
day
1
. The lowest exposure
(73.1 mg (kg bw)
1
day
1
) was obtained from the
combination of the 2003 consumption data and all
morphine concentrations, the highest exposure
(116.7 mg (kg bw)
1
day
1
) resulted from the com-
bination of 2009 consumption and 2007–2010 mor-
phine data.
The approximate 95% confidence limits for the
estimated intakes were calculated using the binomial
method from the ranked values bracketing the 68%
confidence intervals ((1 0.683)/2 ¼0.1587;
0.1587 0.1587 ¼0.025) of the 97.5th percentiles of
the corresponding datasets estimated based on the
binomial method (Figure 3). The standard deviation
(SD) of the selected percentile ‘p’ is calculated as:
SD ¼ffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi
ðNpqÞ
p
where Nis the number of data points; and pþq¼1
(Diem and Seldrup 1982). The 68% confidence inter-
vals around the estimated 97.5th percentile for N¼737
correspond to the 17 4¼13th and 18 þ4¼22nd
ranked values (67 and 112 mg kg
1
), where the largest
value has first rank. As the best estimate (i.e. the
average of two calculation methods) of the 97.5th
percentile was close to the value estimated with the
binomial method, the confidence intervals calculated
with the values obtained from the binomial method
provide an acceptably close approximation. Due to the
low number of data points, the 95% confidence limits
for the 2003 consumption data and 2007–2010 mor-
phine concentrations encompassed practically the
whole datasets. Therefore, confidence limits could
not be calculated for those combinations.
Morphine short-term intakes of children and ado-
lescents (1–18 years) calculated from the 2007–2010
and 2001–2010 morphine concentrations and the 85
consumption days data of raw poppy seed were 164.7
and 150.2 mg (kg bw)
1
day
1
, respectively. The mor-
phine intake was higher than that of the whole
population due to the higher average and 97.5th
percentile of the poppy seed consumption of the age
group of 1–18 years. The small number of data did not
allow the calculation of the confidence intervals for the
estimated intakes to be made.
Probabilistic estimation of morphine intake
Probabilistic modelling was carried out with option
methods (a), (b), (c) and (d) described above. The
results are summarised in the following.
Table 5. Point estimate with 95% confidence intervals of acute exposure to morphine (mg(kg bw)
1
day
1
) from raw poppy seed
consumption.
Best estimates
a
(and 68% confidence intervals)
b
for morphine P0.975 concentrations in time periods (mgg
1
)
Best estimates
a
(and 68% confidence intervals)
b
for
P0.975 consumptions in time periods (g (kg bw)
1
day
1
)
2001–2006
87.48
(67.00–120.00)
2007–2010
93.04
2001–2010
84.83
(67.0–112.0)
Acute exposure
2003 0.86 75.42 80.21 73.14
2009 1.26 (1.18–1.33) 109.73 (78.79–159.96) 116.70 106.41 (78.79–149.30)
2003 þ2009 1.19 (1.11–1.32) 104.02 (74.44–158.88) 110.63 100.87 (74.44–148.29)
Notes:
a
Best estimate calculated as the average of estimated 97.5th percentile with Harrell–Davis and binomial method.
b
The 68% confidence interval calculated as P0.975 SD, as shown in Figure 3. The number of 2003 consumption figures and
2007–2010 morphine results were not sufficient for calculation of the confidence intervals.
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40
Prob ability [%]
Ranked mor
p
hine concentrations:1= lar
g
est
p(x).x
Figure 3. Probability density function of the 97.5th percen-
tile of all morphine concentrations (2001–2010 data).
Explanation for the confidence limits: the 97.5th percentile
lies between the 17th and 18th ranked values from largest to
smallest. The 68% of the values (median SD) are between
the 17 4¼13 and 18 þ4¼22 ranked values.
Food Additives and Contaminants 409
Downloaded by [A. Zentai] at 00:38 29 February 2012
.The 200,000 values generated from the fitted
lognormal distributions covered the maximum
recorded consumption figures in each dataset;
however, the maximum experimental mor-
phine concentration could only be covered in
two out of three cases (columns B, C and D1
in Table 6). When 500,000 values were gener-
ated, the highest values obtained were sub-
stantially higher than the highest experimental
value (column D2). The results suggest that
the heavy tail of the empirical consumption
data can only be covered if a large number of
data points are generated from the fitted
distribution.
.The random morphine values generated from
the fitted gamma distribution, however,
underestimated the upper tail of the morphine
experimental data (the highest generated
and experimental values were 180.1 and
202, or 191.2 and 533 mgg
1
, respectively).
Consequently, the gamma distribution was
not suitable for estimating high quantiles of
exposure.
.When random samples were drawn from the
fitted lognormal distributions, the intake esti-
mates obtained from the different datasets
were in the same range below the 95th
percentile, but showed larger differences at
Table 6. Estimated cumulative distribution function (ECDF) of morphine intake from the consumption of poppy seed
calculated with probabilistic modelling.
ECDF A B C D1 D2 E FG HIJ
0.2 1.7 1.4 1.9 1.7 1.6 0.7 1.7 0.6 2.5 2.9 1.4
0.3 2.4 2.0 2.7 2.4 2.3 1.1 2.5 1.1 3.6 4.1 2.3
0.4 3.2 2.7 3.5 3.2 3.0 1.7 3.4 1.7 4.9 5.3 3.2
0.5 4.1 3.5 4.5 4.2 4.0 2.5 4.3 2.4 6.5 6.7 4.2
0.6 5.1 4.6 5.8 5.5 5.3 3.3 5.4 3.1 8.7 8.6 5.4
0.65 5.8 5.2 6.6 6.3 6.1 3.9 6.1 3.6 10.1 9.5 6.1
0.7 6.6 6.1 7.5 7.3 7.2 4.5 6.9 4.2 11.8 10.9 7.0
0.8 9.2 8.4 10.1 10.2 10.2 6.3 9.7 5.9 16.8 15.0 9.4
0.9 15.4 13.1 15.2 16.0 16.6 9.7 16.1 9.9 27.6 24.6 14.4
0.95 25.0 18.7 21.2 23.3 24.7 13.7 26.1 16.2 41.5 39.3 21.7
0.975 38.8 25.6 28.4 32.0 34.7 18.3 40.9 25.4 59.1 63.3 32.9
0.99 72.6 36.8 39.7 46.5 52.4 25.6 76.2 47.4 88.8 112.0 66.4
0.999 222.1 76.7 78.9 101.7 121.8 50.4 224.4 151.4 204.7 320.0 166.0
0.9999 489.1 147.4 131.9 195.9 235.5 84.9 499.7 336.9 398.1 702.7 321.7
*
1
1.74 4.37 4.67 10.61 4.67
*
2
1 2.73 2.73 2.73 2.73
*
3
498.4 250.6 569.4 719.8 719.8
*
4
533 202 533 533 533
Notes: Exposure results from processed poppy seed are underlined.
Explanation: 1: Poppy seed consumption (g (kg bw)
1
day
1
): maximum value of 200,000 or 500,000 generated data with the
parameters providing the best fit; 2: poppy seed consumption (g (kg bw)
1
day
1
): maximum experimental value; 3: morphine
concentration (mgg
1
): maximum values of 200,000 or 500,000 generated data with the parameters providing the best fit; and 4:
morphine concentration (mgg
1
): maximum experimental value.
Method (a), unprocessed poppy: Column A: multiplying all experimental 2003 þ2009 poppy consumption data (g (kg bw)
1
day
1
) with all (2001–2010) morphine data (mgg
1
) (406*737 data).
Method (b), unprocessed poppy: Column B: ln (2003 poppy seed consumption (g (kg bw)
1
day
1
)) and ln (morphine 2001–2006
(mgg
1
)), 200,000 data populations; Column C: ln (2009 poppy seed consumption (g (kgbw)
1
day
1
)) and ln (morphine 2007–
2010 (mgg
1
)), 200,000 data populations; Column D1: ln (2003 þ2009 poppy seed consumption (g (kg bw)
1
day
1
)) and ln
(morphine 2001–2010 (mgg
1
)), 200,000 data populations; Column D2: ln (2003 þ2009 poppy seed consumption (g (kg bw)
1
day
1
)) and ln (morphine 2001–2010 (mgg
1
)), 500,000 data populations.
Method (b), processed poppy: Column E: ln (2009 poppy seed consumption (g (kg bw)
1
day
1
)) and ln (morphine 2007–2010
(mgg
1
)), 500,000 data populations.
Method (c), unprocessed poppy: Column F: median of percentile exposure values obtained with bootstrapping of all
experimental 2009 poppy consumption data (g (kg bw)
1
day
1
) and 2001–2010 morphine data (mgg
1
).
Method (c), processed poppy: Column G: median of percentile exposure values obtained bootstrapping of experimental 2009
poppy consumption data (g (kg bw)
1
day
1
) with 2001–2010 morphine data (mgg
1
).
Children, method (b), unprocessed poppy: Column H: ln (2009 children poppy seed consumption (g (kg bw)
1
day
1
)) and ln
(morphine 2001–2010 (mgg
1
)), 500,000 data populations.
Children, method (a), unprocessed poppy: Column I: multiplying all experimental 2009 poppy consumption data of children with
all (2001–2010) morphine data (mgg
1
) (85*737 data).
Children, method (c), processed poppy: Column J: median of percentile exposure values obtained bootstrapping of experimental
2009 children poppy consumption data (g (kg bw)
1
day
1
) with 2007–2010 morphine data (mgg
1
).
410 A. Zentai et al.
Downloaded by [A. Zentai] at 00:38 29 February 2012
or above the 95th percentile of the cumulative
relative frequency distributions (Table 6, col-
umns B, C, D1 and D2). The difference
between the cumulative relative frequencies
corresponding to the intakes obtained with the
three combinations of data represents the
uncertainty of the exposure estimation based
on the calculations with the limited subsets of
data.
.The results obtained by multiplying all the
experimental data and bootstrapping
(methods (a) and (c)) are much higher than
those obtained by method (b) and therefore
represent worst-case situations (see columns A
and D2, and columns H and I).
.The comparison of columns C and E illus-
trates the effect of processing based on the
2009 consumption and 2007–2010 morphine
concentrations. The ratio of exposure from
raw poppy seed and from processed poppy
seed in the percentiles above 95th is between
0.639 and 0.646, which indicates that the
grinding (P
f
¼0.71) was the main source of
reduction of exposure.
.The comparison of columns F and G illus-
trates the effect of processing on exposure
based on 10,000 bootstrapped data (the expo-
sure percentiles were calculated from each
iteration and the medians are shown in Table
6). The ratios of corresponding percentiles are
between 0.621 and 0.675 at the higher
percentiles.
.The exposure of children (mg (kg bw)
1
day
1
)
to poppy seed shown in columns H, I and J is
about one to two times higher than of adults
(columns D2, A and G) at the 97.5th to
99.99th percentiles.
The cumulative distribution of the exposure calcu-
lated by multiplying the morphine concentration and
consumption data obtained from their fitted lognormal
distributions and by multiplying all of the experimental
data (method (a)) are close to each other up to about
the 90th percentile of the exposure (columns A, D1 and
D2). At the 99.9th and 99.99th percentiles, however,
the differences are more than two times, even in the
cases where the highest modelled values for poppy seed
consumption and morphine concentrations are higher
than the corresponding experimental values. The
possible reason for the large differences at high
percentiles was further studied. The highest morphine
concentrations observed in poppy seed samples were
187, 200, 202, 222, 238, 267 and 533 mg kg
1
, and the
highest poppy seed consumptions were 1.30, 1.32, 1.33,
1.54, 1.58, 1.68 and 2.73 g (kg bw)
1
day
1
. It was
found that the four highest morphine concentrations
in combination with the highest 20 poppy seed
consumption values resulted in exposures above the
99.99th percentile cumulative exposure (489.1 mg
(kg bw)
1
day
1
). If the highest morphine and poppy
seed consumption values (533 mg kg
1
and 2.73 g
(kg bw)
1
day
1
) were omitted from the calculation,
then the 99.99th percentiles would be 267 mg (kg bw)
1
day
1
. These results explain why lower exposure values
were obtained when they were calculated from the
results of random sampling of fitted populations
(columns D1 and D2 in Table 6), because in the
latter cases the probability of selecting the highest
values from both populations of 200,000 or 500,000
with random sampling is very low.
The range of estimated cumulative relative fre-
quencies was calculated by bootstrapping, drawing
10,000 random samples with replacement from both
the combined 737 morphine concentrations and the
406 poppy seed consumption data, and multiplying all
concentrations with all consumption data in each case
to calculate the morphine intake (mg (kg bw)
1
day
1
).
The procedure was repeated 10,000 times (bootstrap
method (c)). The median and 95% confidence limits of
the calculated cumulative relative frequencies are
shown in Figure 4. The horizontal lines within the
confidence limits show the intake range belonging to a
given cumulative percentile. The vertical line between
the confidence intervals indicates the range of the
percentage of the consumption days of morphine
intake around the selected one. The results showed
that the 95% confidence interval of the estimated
cumulative frequencies, indicating the uncertainty of
the estimation, was the narrowest at the 50th percentile
and increased at higher and lower percentiles. For
instance, the relative 95% interval of the estimated
50th, 95th, 97.5th, 99th, 99.9th and 99.99th cumulative
percentiles were in the order of 13.2%, 27.7%, 40.1%,
50.3%, 69.7% and 80.5%.
Figure 4. Median and 95% confidence intervals of the
exposure to morphine through consumption of poppy seed.
Food Additives and Contaminants 411
Downloaded by [A. Zentai] at 00:38 29 February 2012
Figure 5 shows examples for the frequency distri-
butions of estimated percentiles obtained from 10,000
bootstrap samples. At or below the 99th percentile the
calculated values approximate a normal distribution.
However, at higher percentiles the distribution is
becoming scattered and their ranges become wider, as
expected.
Effect of processing on morphine intake
The calculations, assuming that the morphine concen-
trations measured in raw poppy seed are present in
consumed food, provide an overestimate of the intake.
In order to obtain a more realistic estimate, the effects
of washing, grinding and baking were taken into
consideration. In Hungary, poppy seeds produced on a
commercial scale are not washed. Taking into account
that 65% of poppy seeds are consumed unbaked, and
35% are consumed baked, the acute intake of mor-
phine was recalculated by applying the calculated
processing factors (0.71 and 0.22). The estimated
exposure decreased by 32.6% for adults and by
29.0% for children, respectively (from 116.70 to
78.64 mg (kg bw)
1
day
1
and from 164.70 to
116.90 mg (kg bw)
1
day
1
respectively).
Regarding the probabilistic exposure estimate of
processed poppy seed consumption, it was found that
the intake was decreased by about 33–38% at the
upper percentiles. These findings are in accordance
with the higher intakes of ground poppy seed (the
estimated processing factor is 0.71) than that
consumed in cakes, and consequently ground poppy
seed consumption is the cause of the high morphine
intake.
Counting for a consumer of 60 kg (body weight),
the starting oral therapeutic dose reported by
Embey-Isztin (1996) would be about 167 mg
(kg bw)
1
, while the lowest oral therapeutic dose
reported by the BfR would be about 31.7 mg
(kg bw)
1
. The results from probabilistic calculations
suggest that the 31.7 mg (kg bw)
1
dose could be
reached only above the 97.5th percentile of the adult
poppy seed eaters (Table 6, columns B, C, D1 and D2).
Looking at children’s exposure (Table 6, column H),
above the 90th–95th percentiles could be in the range
of the estimated lowest therapeutic dose referred by the
BfR. The probability of reaching the starting oral
therapeutic dose of 167 mg (kg bw)
1
is very low and
practically negligible.
The provisional daily upper intake level (6.3 mg
(kg bw)
1
day
1
) established by the BfR has an incor-
porated uncertainty factor of 5. This is not likely to be
exceeded by the median adult exposure; however,
children have higher intake than adults. Around 65%
of the cumulative distribution of morphine intake of
adults and 50% of children corresponds to the 6.3 mg
(kg bw)
1
day
1
provisional daily upper intake calcu-
lated with the morphine content of unprocessed
poppy seed.
Taking into account that poppy seed is consumed
in processed form, it was concluded that exposures are
about 35% lower than the scenarios calculated without
counting for processing losses.
Figure 5. Relative frequency of estimated quantile values calculated from 10,000 bootstrap. Solid line: normal distribution fitted
on results; dashed line: lognormal distribution fitted on results.
412 A. Zentai et al.
Downloaded by [A. Zentai] at 00:38 29 February 2012
By applying the point estimation methodology, the
calculated acute intake exceeds the BfR reference
value, but it does not reach the starting oral therapeu-
tic dose. It should be noted that this is a very
conservative intake calculation; the probability that a
‘big eater’ consumes from the highly contaminated
food is low.
Conclusion
The most prominent alkaloid of poppy seed is
morphine, which was present in detectable amounts
practically in all samples analysed in Hungary during
2001–2010. As the poppy seed was consumed in only a
small fraction of the dietary survey days, the chronic
intake is not of a concern. Consequently only the
short-term intakes of poppy seed alkaloids were
estimated in our study, which was based on the
measured alkaloid content of raw poppy seed, also
taking into account the estimated effect of grinding
and baking. The intake calculation performed with the
fitted lognormal distributions gave the best fit on the
original data. The 97.5th percentile exposure of adults
ranged from 25.6 to 34.7 mg (kg bw)
1
day
1
depending
on the time period. The calculated 97.5th percentile of
children’s exposure was 59.1 mg (kg bw)
1
day
1
.
Taking into account the reduction of morphine content
by processing, the 97.5th and 99th percentile exposures
based on probabilistic estimations ranged between 18.3
and 25.4 and between 25.6 and 47.4 mg (kg bw)
1
day
1
for adults, and between 32.9 and 66.4 mg (kg bw)
1
day
1
for children, respectively.
The poppy seed was used on 65% of consumption
days as flavouring ingredient of pasta in ground form.
The average and 97.5th percentile consumptions of
poppy seed in baked form were 60% and 77% of that
eaten in ground form, respectively. The high morphine
intake primarily derives from the consumption of
ground raw poppy seed. According to current market-
ing practice, the poppy seed is cleaned only by venti-
lation and screening, but is not washed. Consequently,
the morphine content of the commercialised raw poppy
seed is reduced before consumption by about 35% due
to the effect of grinding. The consequences of the
pattern and form of consumption are reflected in the
results of estimated short-term exposure which indi-
cated that the morphine intake from processed poppy
seed was about 35% lower than the values calculated
from the morphine content of raw poppy seed.
The five-fold difference in reported lowest oral
therapeutic doses of 167 and 31.7 mg (kg bw)
1
of
morphine indicates the large uncertainty in the esti-
mation of the reference dose value for assessing the
potential adverse affects of exposure of consumers to
morphine.
Reliable risk assessment was not possible because
internationally accepted acute reference doses for
morphine and the other alkaloids detected in poppy
seeds have not yet been established. Even less or no
information is available on the potential adverse effects
of the codeine, thebaine and noscapine content of
poppy seeds individually or in combination, and the
bioavailability of these alkaloids.
Further scientific studies, meeting the relevant
standards, are required in order to establish the acute
reference dose in order to assess the actual risk. The
effect of technological steps, the degradation of mor-
phine in the digestive system during absorption, and
the effect of the poppy alkaloid ‘cocktail’ compared
with purified morphine should also be taken into
account. Above that, the necessary risk management
options could be established to reduce the alkaloid
intake. Our findings contribute to the scientific risk
assessment by providing exact, statistically well-
founded exposure data of poppy seed alkaloids, with
a specific focus on morphine.
Acknowledgements
The authors are grateful to the former National Institute for
Food Hygiene and Nutrition (now named the National
Institute for Food and Nutrition Science) and the Central
Agricultural Office for providing the results of alkaloid
analysis in poppy seed; and to Peter Craig, Durham
University, for providing the Excel template for the calcu-
lation of percentiles with the Harrell–Davis method.
References
17/1999 Eu
¨M rendelet. 1999. 17/1999 (VI. 16.) Eu
¨M rendelet
az e
´lelmiszerek vegyi szennyezettse
´ge
´nek megengedheto
00
me
´rte
´ke
´ro
00 l; [cited 2011 Oct 21]. Available
from: http://www.complex.hu/jr/gen/hjegy_doc.cgi?
docid=99900017.EUM/
Battilani P, Costa LG, Dossena A, Gullino ML, Marchelli R,
Galaverna G, Pietri A, Dall’Asta C, Giorni P, Spadaro D,
et al. 2009. Scientific information on mycotoxins and
natural plant toxicants. Scientific/Technical Report sub-
mitted to EFSA. Parma: European Food Safety Authority
(EFSA); [cited 2011 Oct 21]. Available from: http://
www.efsa.europa.eu/en/supporting/doc/24e.pdf/
Diem K, Seldrup J. 1982. Introduction to statistics.
Statistical tables mathematical formulae. In: Lenter C,
editor. Geigy scientific tables. Vol. 2. Basel (Switzerland):
Ciba–Geigy. p. 219.
Efron B, Tibshirani R. 1994. An introduction to the
bootstrap. Boca Raton (Florida): Chapman & Hall/CRC.
Embey-Isztin D. 1996. Analgesic treatment of patients with
tumor. Ha
´ziorvos Tova
´bbke
´pzo
00 Szemle 1:49–50; [cited
2011 Oct 21]. Available from: http://sunrise.sote.hu/htsz/
embey.htm/ (in Hungarian).
European Commission Directorate – General Health and
Consumer Protection. 2003. Collection of occurrence data
of Fusarium toxins in food and assessment of dietary
intake by the population of EU Member States, Report of
experts participating in Task 3.2.10. April 2003. Brussels
Food Additives and Contaminants 413
Downloaded by [A. Zentai] at 00:38 29 February 2012
(Belgium): European Commission; [cited 2011 Oct 21].
Available from: http://ec.europa.eu/food/fs/scoop/
task3210.pdf/
European Food Safety Authority (EFSA). 2007. Reasoned
opinion on the potential chronic and acute risk to
consumers health arising from proposed temporary EU
MRLs. EFSA; [cited 2011 Oct 21]. Available from: http://
www.efsa.europa.eu/en/efsajournal/pub/32r.htm/
European Food Safety Authority (EFSA). 2011. EFSA
model for chronic and acute risk assessment – rev. 2_0.
EFSA; [cited 2011 Oct 21]. Available from: www.efsa.
europa.eu/en/mrls/docs/calculationacutechronic_2.xls/
Federal Institute for Risk Assessment. 2005. BfR recom-
mends provisional daily upper intake level and a guidance
value for morphine in poppy seeds. BfR Health
Assessment No. 012/2006.
Food and Agriculture Organisation (FAO). 2009. FAO
Manual on the submission and evaluation of pesticide
residues data for the estimation of maximum residue
levels in food and feed. Rome (Italy): FAO; [cited 2011
Oct 21]. Available from: http://www.fao.org/fileadmin/
templates/agphome/documents/Pests_Pesticides/JMPR/
FAO_manual2nded_Oct07.pdf/
Hamilton DJ, Ambrus A, Dieterle RM, Felsot A, Harris C,
Petersen B, Racke K, Wong S-S, Gonzalez R, Tanaka K.
2004. Pesticide residues in food-acute dietary intake. Pest
Manag Sci. 60:311–339.
Lachenmeier DW, Sproll C, Musshoff F. 2010. Poppy seed
foods and opiate drug testing – where are we to day? Ther
Drug Monit. 32:11–18.
McDonald JH. 2009. Handbook of biological statistics;
[cited 2011 Oct 21]. Available from: http://udel.edu/
mcdonald/statkruskalwallis.html/
MSZ 690:1993. Determination of morphine content
in poppy seed for food purpose; 2003 2nd ed. Budapest
(in Hungarian).
NIST. 2011. NIST/SEMATECH e-Handbook of Statistical
Methods; [cited 2011 Oct 21]. Available from: http://#160
www.itl.nist.gov/div898/handbook/prc/section2/prc252.htm/
Rodler I, Bı
´ro
´L, Greiner E, Zajka
´s G, Szo
´ra
´d I, Varga A,
Domonkos A, A
´goston H, Bala
´zs A
´, Mozsa
´ry E, et al.
2005. Ta
´pla
´lkoza
´si vizsga
´lat Magyarorsza
´gon, 2003–2004.
Orvosi Hetilap. 146(34):1781–1789.
Sproll C, Perz RC, Buschmann R, Lachenmeier DW. 2007.
Guidelines for reduction of morphine in poppy seed
intended for food purposes. Eur Food Res Technol.
226:307–310.
Sproll C, Perz RC, Lachenmeier DW. 2006. Optimized
LC/MS/MS analysis of morphine and codeine in poppy
seed and evaluation of their fate during food processing
as a basis for risk analysis. J Agric Food Chem. 54:
5292–5298.
Szeitz-Szabo
´M, Biro
´L, Biro
´Gy, Sali J. 2011.
Dietary survey in Hungary, 2009. Part I: Macronutrients,
alcohol, caffeine, fibre. Acta Alimentaria. 40:142–152.
World Health Organization (WHO). 1997. International
estimated short-term intake (IESTI) and international
estimated daily intake (IEDI). Geneva (Switzerland):
WHO; [cited 2011 Oct 21]. Available from: http://
www.who.int/foodsafety/chem/acute_data/en/index1.html/
414 A. Zentai et al.
Downloaded by [A. Zentai] at 00:38 29 February 2012
... Sproll, Perz, Buschmann and Lachenmeier (2007) found that using hot water can reduce about 100%. In addition, the grinding of the seeds can get a significantly morphine reduction (25-35%) (Sproll et al., 2007;Zentai et al., 2012). This is a very important concept for the elaboration food that contain crude poppy seeds as toppings. ...
... Almost all of them use multiple reaction monitoring (MRM) which provides even more reliable quantitative data of the analytes (Guo et al., 2013;López et al., 2018;Powers et al., 2018;Sproll et al., 2006;Stranska et al., 2013). In these works, the stationary phase was C18 (Guo et al., 2013;López et al., 2018;Powers et al., 2018;Sproll et al., 2006;Stranska et al., 2013;Zentai et al., 2012). Gradient elution was applied with a mobile phase that consisted in a mixture of MeOH:water (Guo et al., 2013) or MeOH:acetonitrile:water with a low percent of formic acid (Powers et al., 2018;Stranska et al., 2013). ...
Article
Background In recent years, there has been increasing interest from health authorities in avoiding consumer exposure to opium alkaloids in food. Thus, recent cases of intoxication and false positive drug tests, from the consumption of poppy seeds and food, have been detected. In order to know more certainly the concentration of these substances in food and to establish more reliably the consumption of these toxics in the population, data on their presence in food should be further collected. These compounds are found at ultra-trace levels in complex matrices, so it is important to develop efficient analytical methods based on selective analytical techniques and adequate sample treatment, which is key to avoid matrix effects. Scope and approach This review summarizes the actual situation of opioids in food products. It establishes the cause of their presence in food, the risk of consumption and actions to prevent their exposure. In addition, it sums the techniques of sample treatment and analysis of all available articles on opioids in different samples. Key findings and conclusions The studies that have been made of opioids are mainly about morphine. For this reason, there is a need to do more studies with all of them. Besides, most of the studies are in biological samples, following consumption of poppy seeds or foods. Therefore, there is to develop and validate new methods that are effective for complex matrices such are foods, to know exactly the actual exposure to consumers and how to decrease it.
... A separate analysis of opium alkaloids in poppy seeds performed by the Hungarian Food Safety Office found maximum concentrations of 530, 60, and 120 mg kg -1 for morphine, codeine, and thebaine, respectively. 28 An analysis of blue poppy seeds (n = 32) from 2018 found concentrations ranged from 0.2-241 mg kg -1 for morphine, < 0.1-348 mg kg -1 for codeine, and < 0.1-106 mg kg -1 for thebaine. 20 Even variation within a sample type can be large, as noted by previous research stating that relative standard deviation can reach as high as 40%. ...
... 20 The present analysis found morphine values similar or lower than previously reported, but the maximum codeine value was 6-fold greater than highest value reported by BfR, and the maximum thebaine concentration was approximately two-fold greater than the highest value reported by two different authors. 20,28 It is interesting to note the high concentrations of thebaine in certain samples, since it is a precursor to codeine and morphine in the biosynthetic pathway of poppy. 29 While there was no correlation between thebaine and the other opium alkaloids analyzed, the negative relationship between codeine and morphine may reflect codeine being the precursor to morphine in the biosynthesis pathway. ...
Article
Full-text available
Limited information exists on the effectiveness of potential treatments to reduce levels of opium alkaloids that may be present in seeds from poppy (Papaver somniferum L.). Poppy seeds containing morphine at relatively lower (14.7 mg kg⁻¹) and higher (210.0 mg kg⁻¹) concentrations were subjected to dry heat and steam treatments, water washing, and baking. Sample extracts were then analyzed using liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry (LC-MS/MS) for the opium alkaloids morphine, codeine, and thebaine. The results indicated that thermal treatment promoted opium alkaloid degradation in poppy seed samples, with a 50% loss of morphine observed after 30-40 min at 200 °C. Water washing reduced concentrations of opium alkaloids in poppy seeds by approximately 50-80%, while steam treatment resulted in a reduction of morphine in only one sample type. Importantly, baking had no significant effect on concentrations of opium alkaloids. Overall, these results indicate that opium alkaloids may not be significantly affected by baking or steam application and that poppy seeds may require water washing or extended thermal treatment to promote reduction of these compounds.
... Several extraction protocols for opium and other plant alkaloids published in literature were reviewed. Opium alkaloids have been extracted from poppy seeds with methanol (Acevska, Dimitrovska, et al., 2012;Acevska, Stefkov, Petkovska, Kulevanova, & Dimitrovska, 2012) or acidified methanol (Sproll et al., 2006;Zentai, Sali, Szeitzne-Szabo, Szabo, & Ambrus, 2012), from hot broths with 0.1 M hydrochloric acid (Guo et al., 2013) or with acetonitrile/water and acetic acid in a QuEChERS extraction (Mol, Van Dam, Zomer, & Mulder, 2011). Ergot and tropane alkaloids can be efficiently extracted from cereal food products using a mixture of methanol/water/formic acid (60/40/0.4 ...
... mg/kg). The median concentration of morphine, codeine, thebaine and noscapine in poppy seeds in this survey was similar to those found in poppy seeds collected in Hungary between 2001 and 2010 (Zentai et al., 2012). ...
Article
A straightforward method to determine the content of six opium alkaloids (morphine, codeine, thebaine, noscapine, papaverine and narceine) in poppy seeds and bakery products was developed and validated down to a limit of quantification (LOQ) of 0.1 mg/kg. The method was based on extraction with acetonitrile/water/formic acid, ten-fold dilution and analysis by LC-MS/MS using a pH 10 carbonate buffer. The method was applied for the analysis of 41 samples collected in 2015 in the Netherlands and Germany. All samples contained morphine ranging from 0.2 to 240 mg/kg. The levels of codeine and thebaine ranged from below LOQ to 348 mg/kg and from below LOQ to 106 mg/kg, respectively. Sixty percent of the samples exceeded the guidance reference value of 4 mg/kg of morphine set by BfR in Germany, whereas 25% of the samples did not comply with the limits set for morphine, codeine, thebaine and noscapine by Hungarian legislation.
... Zentai et al. [20] analyzed the presence of morphine in commercially available poppy seeds in Hungary from 2001 to 2010. Morphine was present in almost all samples during the study period, with the highest concentration reaching 533 mg/kg. ...
Article
Full-text available
Opium poppy is a plant used in both the pharmaceutical and food industries. Substances found on the surface of dry poppy seeds belong to the group of opium alkaloids. However, the presence of these substances in food products poses a risk to consumer health, which is why new permissible levels for both substances in poppy seeds and derivative products have been introduced in Regulation (EU) 2023/915. This research aimed to analyze the content of all six opium alkaloids in poppy seeds provided directly by producers as well as those available on the local market in Poland. The research confirmed the presence of morphine in all examined poppy seed samples. The alkaloid content ranged from 12.46 to 102.86 mg/kg for seeds purchased in local markets and from 1.1 to 110.1 mg/kg for seeds obtained directly from producers. Both groups showed similar levels of morphine content as well as other OAs, which significantly exceeded the permissible limit of 20 mg/kg set by the European Commission (EU) 2023/915. These results indicate that the presence of morphine and other opium alkaloids in poppy seeds exceeds permissible levels, posing a serious health issue and necessitating further research and improvement in processing methods.
... The top surface temperature of these muffins at the end of the 16 min baking period were found to be 136 ± 1 °C. of other opium alkaloids in poppy seeds. 18,24 We also found high variability of noscapine concentrations within a single poppy seed sample, which may be reflective of the degree of latex contamination occurring during harvest. Noteworthy from our results is that we are reporting one of the highest levels of noscapine in commercially available poppy seeds described in the literature. ...
Article
Full-text available
Limited information is available on methods to reduce concentrations of the opium alkaloid noscapine in poppy seeds. A series of experiment were conducted using poppy seeds to evaluate the impact of thermal treatments, water rinsing, and baking on noscapine concentrations. A sample set of commercially available poppy seeds (n=15) was screened for noscapine using liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry. The mean and median noscapine concentrations for poppy seed samples above the limit of quantitation (LOQ) was 89.9 and 28.4 mg/kg, respectively. Six out of 15 samples were less than the LOQ. Poppy seed samples containing a mean noscapine concentration of 121 mg/kg were subjected to dry heat treatments ranging from 120-200 °C and a 5 min rinse with water. Baking experiments were also done by incorporating the poppy seeds into a muffin batter and baking in an oven at 200 °C. The dry heat treatment experiments showed that noscapine degraded at 160-200 °C, with a 50% loss of noscapine observed after 3.44 ± 0.46 min at 200 °C. Although the mean concentration of noscapine decreased when a muffin containing poppy seeds was baked at 200 °C for 16 min, these changes were not statistically significant (P>0.05). Rinsing the poppy seeds with water did not have a significant effect on noscapine concentrations. Together, these data allow for better characterization of potential dietary exposure to noscapine and indicate that certain thermal treatments can be effective for reduction of noscapine in poppy seeds.
... Concerning the extraction solvent in the literature, many authors use methanol to extract opioids from poppy seeds [9,17,[40][41][42]. Others use acidified methanol [6,43] or a mixture of acetonitrile/water/formic acid 80/19/1(v/v/v) [1]. For this reason, in the present study, these three types of solvents were evaluated in two agitation modes, ultrasound (US) and magnetic stirring with 2.5 g of poppy seeds and 10 mL of solvent during 10 min. ...
Article
Full-text available
In recent years, health authorities have become increasingly concerned about preventing consumer exposure to opium alkaloids present in Papaver somniferum L. poppy seeds. In this study, a simple, rapid and efficient method has been optimised to determine all main opioids in poppy seeds (morphine, codeine, thebaine, papaverine, noscapine and oripavine) by UHPLC-QqQ-MS/MS. For this purpose, solid-liquid extraction (SLE) of samples was optimised and six magnetic adsorbent materials with a core of Fe3O4 coated with amorphous and mesostructured silica, both functionalised with octadecyl-silane or octyl-silane were characterised and evaluated for magnetic solid-phase extraction (MSPE). The material with the best results was non-functionalised mesostructured silica and, with it, the MSPE procedure was optimised. This method was validated and used to quantify six opioids in 14 edible seed samples (eleven poppy seeds and three seed mixes). Considerable amounts were found (1.5–249.0 mg/kg morphine, <0.2 µg/kg–45.8 mg/kg codeine, <2.4 µg/kg–136.2 mg/kg thebaine, <0.2 µg/kg–27.1 mg/kg papaverine, <0.2 µg/kg–108.7 mg/kg noscapine and <240 µg/kg–33.4 mg/kg oripavine), exceeding maximum limits established in some EU countries and the reference level of morphine in the EU. Furthermore, in some commercial samples for human consumption, inadequate labelling was found because significant amounts of alkaloids were detected even though Papaver rhoeas L. seeds were declared on the product label.
Chapter
Plants are one of the essential assets of medicine. Papaver somniferum (scientific name) is native to Southeastern Europe and Asia. The poppy plant is a common herb that is known for its nutritive purposes. Papaver somniferum, which is generally called as the opium poppy, is a source of drugs that have historically been used to help those suffering from pain. It contains several phytochemicals, mainly isolated from seeds. It consists of a lot of alkaloids such as morphine, codeine, narcotine, etc. It can be used in a variety of food products and to make soaps, paints, and other products of industry. This chapter covers cultivation aspects, production, pharmaceutical, food, cosmetic, and ethnobotanical uses. It also consists of biogenic synthesis from poppy seeds.
Article
Full-text available
Morphine and codeine are the two principal opiates found in the opium poppy (Papaver somniferum L.) and are therapeutically used for pain management. Poppy seeds with low opiates are primarily used for culinary purposes due to their nutritional and sensory attributes. Intentional adulteration of poppy seeds is common, often combined with immature, less expensive, exhausted, or substituted with morphologically similar seeds, viz., amaranth, quinoa, and sesame. For a safer food supply chain, preventive measures must be implemented to mitigate contamination or adulteration. Moreover, the simultaneous analysis of P. somniferum and its adulterants is largely unknown. Pre- and post-processing further complicate the alkaloid content and may pose a significant health hazard. To address these issues, two independent methods were investigated with eight botanically verified and fifteen commercial samples. Microscopical features were established for the authenticity of raw poppy seeds. Morphine, codeine, and thebaine quantities ranged from 0.8–223, 0.2–386, and 0.1–176 mg/kg, respectively, using LC-QToF. In most cases, conventional opiates have a higher content than papaverine and noscapine. The analytical methodology provided a chemical profile of 47 compounds that can be effectively applied to distinguish poppy seeds from their adulterants and may serve as an effective tool to combat ongoing adulteration.
Article
Full-text available
Poppy seeds are obtained from the opium poppy (Papaver somniferum L.). They are used as food and to produce edible oil. The opium poppy plant contains narcotic alkaloids such as morphine and codeine. Poppy seeds do not contain the opium alkaloids, but can become contaminated with alkaloids as a result of pest damage and during harvesting. The European Commission asked EFSA to provide an update of the Scientific Opinion on opium alkaloids in poppy seeds. The assessment is based on data on morphine, codeine, thebaine, oripavine, noscapine and papaverine in poppy seed samples. The CONTAM Panel confirms the acute reference dose (ARfD) of 10 μg morphine/kg body weight (bw) and concluded that the concentration of codeine in the poppy seed samples should be taken into account by converting codeine to morphine equivalents, using a factor of 0.2. The ARfD is therefore a group ARfD for morphine and codeine, expressed in morphine equivalents. Mean and high levels of dietary exposure to morphine equivalents from poppy seeds considered to have high levels of opium alkaloids (i.e. poppy seeds from varieties primarily grown for pharmaceutical use) exceed the ARfD in most age groups. For poppy seeds considered to have relatively low concentrations of opium alkaloids (i.e. primarily varieties for food use), some exceedance of the ARfD is also seen at high levels of dietary exposure in most surveys. For noscapine and papaverine, the available data do not allow making a hazard characterisation. However, comparison of the dietary exposure to the recommended therapeutical doses does not suggest a health concern for these alkaloids. For thebaine and oripavine, no risk characterisation was done due to insufficient data. However, for thebaine, limited evidence indicates a higher acute lethality than for morphine and the estimated exposure could present a health risk.
Article
Medicinal Plants: Chemistry, Biology and Omics reviews the phytochemistry, chemotaxonomy, molecular biology, and phylogeny of selected medicinal plant tribes and genera, and their relevance to drug efficacy. Medicinal plants provide a myriad of pharmaceutically active components, which have been commonly used in traditional Chinese medicine and worldwide for thousands of years. Increasing interest in plant-based medicinal resources has led to additional discoveries of many novel compounds, in various angiosperm and gymnosperm species, and investigations on their chemotaxonomy, molecular phylogeny and pharmacology. Chapters in this book explore the interrelationship within traditional Chinese medicinal plant groups and between Chinese species and species outside of China. Chapters also discuss the incongruence between chemotaxonomy and molecular phylogeny, concluding with chapters on systems biology and "-omics? technologies (genomics, transcriptomics, proteomics, and metabolomics), and how they will play an increasingly important role in future pharmaceutical research.
Article
Full-text available
Consumer risk assessment is a crucial step in the regulatory approval of pesticide use on food crops. Recently, an additional hurdle has been added to the formal consumer risk assessment process with the introduction of short-term intake or exposure assessment and a comparable short-term toxicity reference, the acute reference dose. Exposure to residues during one meal or over one day is important for short-term or acute intake. Exposure in the short term can be substantially higher than average because the consumption of a food on a single occasion can be very large compared with typical long-term or mean consumption and the food may have a much larger residue than average. Furthermore, the residue level in a single unit of a fruit or vegetable may be higher by a factor (defined as the variability factor, which we have shown to be typically x3 for the 97.5th percentile unit) than the average residue in the lot. Available marketplace data and supervised residue trial data are examined in an investigation of the variability of residues in units of fruit and vegetables. A method is described for estimating the 97.5th percentile value from sets of unit residue data. Variability appears to be generally independent of the pesticide, the crop, crop unit size and the residue level. The deposition of pesticide on the individual unit during application is probably the most significant factor. The diets used in the calculations ideally come from individual and household surveys with enough consumers of each specific food to determine large portion sizes. The diets should distinguish the different forms of a food consumed, eg canned, frozen or fresh, because the residue levels associated with the different forms may be quite different. Dietary intakes may be calculated by a deterministic method or a probabilistic method. In the deterministic method the intake is estimated with the assumptions of large portion consumption of a 'high residue' food (high residue in the sense that the pesticide was used at the highest recommended label rate, the crop was harvested at the smallest interval after treatment and the residue in the edible portion was the highest found in any of the supervised trials in line with these use conditions). The deterministic calculation also includes a variability factor for those foods consumed as units (eg apples, carrots) to allow for the elevated residue in some single units which may not be seen in composited samples. In the probabilistic method the distribution of dietary consumption and the distribution of possible residues are combined in repeated probabilistic calculations to yield a distribution of possible residue intakes. Additional information such as percentage commodity treated and combination of residues from multiple commodities may be incorporated into probabilistic calculations. The IUPAC Advisory Committee on Crop Protection Chemistry has made 11 recommendations relating to acute dietary exposure.
Article
Full-text available
The third Hungarian national dietary survey was conducted in 2003-2004. This publication describes the first part of the energy and nutrient intake findings in a sample consisting of a population of 1179 persons over 19 years of age (energy and macro nutrients). Energy and nutrient intake values were calculated based on 3 x 24- hour dietary records filled out by the subjects themselves. The authors evaluated the results in light of the two previous dietary surveys in Hungary and the Hungarian and international reference intake data. The total fat intake found in this survey lower than the previous data marks a favourable development, just as the higher unsaturated fatty acid and lower saturated fatty acid energy percent, and furthermore the lower cholesterol intake level. The favourable developments include further a polyunsaturated/saturated fatty acid ratio considerably higher than that obtained earlier (the values conforming to the international reference data), a higher carbohydrate energy percentage, as well as lower added sugar energy percentage, this latter being in the recommended range. The overweight ratio in men was 58.9%, while the female value was 49.5%, not much different from the previous survey data.
Article
In 2009 Hungarian Food Safety Office (HFSO) performed a countrywide representative dietary survey to obtain food consumption data for quantitative food safety risk assessment utilizable in the field of public health nutrition as well. The consumption of foodstuffs, daily energy- and nutrient intakes, nutritional habits and dietary supplement usage of Hungarian population was assessed. The complex system has included three-day dietary record and a food consumption frequency questionnaire. Some anthropometric parameters were also self-recorded. According to the body mass index, a considerable proportion of both the 31-60 years old males (69%) and females (46%) were overweight or obese. The energy intake of the Hungarian adult population is slightly exceeds the recommendation. The intake of proteins is satisfactory in general. The average intake of total fats is very high (36.1-38.9 energy percent), and the fatty acid composition - mostly the ratio of n-6/n-3 fatty acids - is unfavourable, but the fatty acid pattern regarding saturated- (SFA), mono- (MUFA) and polyunsaturated (PUFA) fatty acid ratio shows favourable tendency. The proportion of complex carbohydrates within the intake of energy providing macronutrients is far lower than the optimal level, but it is a positive finding that added sugar intake is below the outmost recommendation. The average daily cholesterol intake is high (males: 469 mg, females: 335 mg), whilst the dietary fibre intake is lower than the recommended. The article provides data on alcohol, caffeine and fibre consumption, too.
Article
Due to major concerns about morphine present in poppy seed intended for use in food, the establishment of maximum limits is currently discussed and options to reduce its content are searched. With the aim to propose guidelines for consumers and bakeries about minimization of the morphine content in poppy seed, the kinetics of morphine degradation during grinding as well as the possibility to reduce the morphine content by washing steps are evaluated in this study. A significant reduction of morphine by grinding using standard poppy seed mills was ascertained. The degradation occurs directly at grinding and does not continue during subsequent storage. Washing the poppy seed with hot water (60°C) is an effective way to reduce the morphine content by approx. 70%. The optimal treatment of poppy seed consists of washing, drying, and grinding. This process significantly reduces the morphine content and simultaneously improves the organoleptical quality of the product.
Article
Seeds of the opium poppy plant are legally sold and widely consumed as food. Due to contamination during harvesting, the seeds can contain morphine and other opiate alkaloids. The objective of this study is to review the toxicology of poppy seed foods regarding influence on opiate drug tests. Computer-assisted literature review resulted in 95 identified references. Normal poppy seed consumption is generally regarded as safe. During food processing, the morphine content is considerably reduced (up to 90%). The possibility of false-positive opiate drug tests after poppy food ingestion exists. There are no unambiguous markers available to differentiate poppy food ingestion from heroin or pharmaceutical morphine use. This is also a problem in heroin-assisted maintenance programs. A basic requirement in such substitution programs is the patients' abstinence from any other drugs, including additional illicit heroin. Also a lack of forensic ingestion trials was detected that consider all factors influencing the morphine content in biologic matrices after consumption. Most studies did not control for the losses during food processing, so that the initial morphine dosage was overestimated. The large reduction of the morphine content during past years raises questions about the validity of the "poppy seed defence." However, a threshold of food use that would not lead to positive drug tests with certainty is currently unavailable. Research is needed to prove if the morphine contents in today's foods still pose the possibility of influencing drug tests. Future trials should consider processing-related morphine losses.