A Holistic Framework to Improve the Uptake and Impact of eHealth Technologies

Department of Psychology, Health and Technology/Center for eHealth Research and Disease Management, Faculty of Behavioural Sciences, University of Twente, Enschede, Netherlands.
Journal of Medical Internet Research (Impact Factor: 3.43). 12/2011; 13(4):e111. DOI: 10.2196/jmir.1672
Source: PubMed


Many eHealth technologies are not successful in realizing sustainable innovations in health care practices. One of the reasons for this is that the current development of eHealth technology often disregards the interdependencies between technology, human characteristics, and the socioeconomic environment, resulting in technology that has a low impact in health care practices. To overcome the hurdles with eHealth design and implementation, a new, holistic approach to the development of eHealth technologies is needed, one that takes into account the complexity of health care and the rituals and habits of patients and other stakeholders.
The aim of this viewpoint paper is to improve the uptake and impact of eHealth technologies by advocating a holistic approach toward their development and eventual integration in the health sector.
To identify the potential and limitations of current eHealth frameworks (1999-2009), we carried out a literature search in the following electronic databases: PubMed, ScienceDirect, Web of Knowledge, PiCarta, and Google Scholar. Of the 60 papers that were identified, 44 were selected for full review. We excluded those papers that did not describe hands-on guidelines or quality criteria for the design, implementation, and evaluation of eHealth technologies (28 papers). From the results retrieved, we identified 16 eHealth frameworks that matched the inclusion criteria. The outcomes were used to posit strategies and principles for a holistic approach toward the development of eHealth technologies; these principles underpin our holistic eHealth framework.
A total of 16 frameworks qualified for a final analysis, based on their theoretical backgrounds and visions on eHealth, and the strategies and conditions for the research and development of eHealth technologies. Despite their potential, the relationship between the visions on eHealth, proposed strategies, and research methods is obscure, perhaps due to a rather conceptual approach that focuses on the rationale behind the frameworks rather than on practical guidelines. In addition, the Web 2.0 technologies that call for a more stakeholder-driven approach are beyond the scope of current frameworks. To overcome these limitations, we composed a holistic framework based on a participatory development approach, persuasive design techniques, and business modeling.
To demonstrate the impact of eHealth technologies more effectively, a fresh way of thinking is required about how technology can be used to innovate health care. It also requires new concepts and instruments to develop and implement technologies in practice. The proposed framework serves as an evidence-based roadmap.

Download full-text


Available from: Hans C. Ossebaard, Feb 05, 2014
  • Source
    • "These findings are useful to researchers who are interested in capitalising on technological innovation to provide physical activity feedback across various biologically important and healthful physical activity dimensions. Prior research indicates that the effectiveness of technology-enabled health behaviour interventions is likely to be enhanced when the patient is involved in its development [27,28] and particularly in the application of physical activity feedback [29,30]. In this regard, we have used these results to inform a randomised controlled trial (Mi-PACT, ISRCTN18008011) that is currently underway and that will determine whether the provision of multidimensional personalised feedback helps patients to change their physical activity and reduce risk of chronic disease. "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Innovative physical activity monitoring technology can be used to depict rich visual feedback that encompasses the various aspects of physical activity known to be important for health. However, it is unknown whether patients who are at risk of chronic disease would understand such sophisticated personalised feedback or whether they would find it useful and motivating. The purpose of the present study was to determine whether technology-enabled multidimensional physical activity graphics and visualisations are comprehensible and usable for patients at risk of chronic disease.
    Full-text · Article · May 2015 · PLoS ONE
  • Source
    • "User experience and value are closely intertwined. In order to be successful, health technologies should be designed to be driven by user values[9,16,35]. According to Ervasti[9], achieving an understanding of customers' values will greatly help to design and market successful services for target customers. "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: In recent years, mobile and web-based solutions for health and wellbeing have become popular. The topic that has been covered the most has been the promotion of physical health, although the importance of mental and social well-being has also been acknowledged recently. Studies have shown that mental health interventions can be successfully designed to be delivered via mobile channels. However, the role of mobile applications in disease prevention and self management of health is not so well understood. The aim of this study is to explore the need for stress-management solutions by studying the prevalence of health complaints in an academic organization (n = 756). It also describes findings from a field study exploring the user experience of a mobile coaching application for stress-management among the three most prevalent complaint groups (n = 30). The findings show that the three most prevalent complaints are tiredness, depression, and neck problems. All of the 13 complaints were more common among women than men, except loneliness and problems in social life. User experience study showed that most participants found the application useful and they would recommend it to other people. Use activity of the mobile coaching application was highest among the tiredness group. The findings are especially useful in the design new solutions for disease prevention and self-management of health.
    Full-text · Article · Jan 2015
  • Source
    • "However, the results also showed that the PHR is mostly illness-driven instead of user-centered (with little attention for the needs of the end-users), indicating that involving the end-users (via a contextual inquiry and value specification [21]) is valuable in the development of new technologies [24]. By involving the end-users and having an eye for their needs, the added value of the new technology is already evident in the first stages of the developmental cycle [26], which may in turn lead to a better diffusion of the technology. "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: A Personal Health Record is a promising technology for improving the quality of chronic disease management. Despite the efforts that have been made in a research project to develop a Personal Health Record for patients with type 2 diabetes mellitus in primary care (e-Vita), considerable differences have been reported between the number of registered users in the participating primary practices. Interviews among practice nurses indicated that a lack of infrastructure (integration in daily care processes), the ability to try the Personal Health Record with minimal investments and without commitment (trialability) and the relative advantage of using a Personal Health Record in comparison with other methods were important factors for the diffusion of the Personal Health Record in primary care.
    Full-text · Article · Dec 2014 · International Journal on Advances in Life Sciences
Show more