Theoretical Predictions for How Temperature Affects the Dynamics of Interacting Herbivores and Plants

National Center for Ecological Analysis and Synthesis, Santa Barbara, California 93101, USA.
The American Naturalist (Impact Factor: 3.83). 11/2011; 178(5):626-38. DOI: 10.1086/662171
Source: PubMed


Concern about climate change has spurred experimental tests of how warming affects species' abundance and performance. As this body of research grows, interpretation and extrapolation to other species and systems have been limited by a lack of theory. To address the need for theory for how warming affects species interactions, we used consumer-prey models and the metabolic theory of ecology to develop quantitative predictions for how systematic differences between the temperature dependence of heterotrophic and autotrophic population growth lead to temperature-dependent herbivory. We found that herbivore and plant abundances change with temperature in proportion to the ratio of autotrophic to heterotrophic metabolic temperature dependences. This result is consistent across five different formulations of consumer-prey models and over varying resource supply rates. Two models predict that temperature-dependent herbivory causes primary producer abundance to be independent of temperature. This finding contradicts simpler extensions of metabolic theory to abundance that ignore trophic interactions, and is consistent with patterns in terrestrial ecosystems. When applied to experimental data, the model explained 77% and 66% of the variation in phytoplankton and zooplankton abundances, respectively. We suggest that metabolic theory provides a foundation for understanding the effects of temperature change on multitrophic ecological communities.

Download full-text


Available from: Benjamin Gilbert, Feb 15, 2014
  • Source
    • "To contribute to an understanding of what can be inferred from stink bug salivary flange data, we sought to relate variation in the number of flanges to variation in growth rates and quantity of excreta, both used as indicators of food consumption . Relative growth rates should be partly influenced by food consumption rates and are relevant to population dynamics of herbivores (O'Connor et al. 2011). Likewise, rates of defecation should be partly influenced by food consumption (Powles et al. 1972). "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Counts of salivary sheaths and salivary flanges have been widely used in studies of feeding behavior and crop damage of pestiferous stink bugs (Hemiptera: Pentatomidae) and other sheath-feeding Hemiptera. While salivary flanges can effectively predict crop damage by stink bugs, previous studies have assumed that food consumption (e.g., ingestion) and preference can also be inferred from flange data. Yet this assumption has remained untested. We investigated the relationship between the number of stink bug salivary flanges and consumption of cotton bolls for two important agricultural pest species: Nezara viridula (L.) and Euschistus servus (Say). We inferred food consumption rates from mea-sures of relative growth rate and excreta quantity. To measure excreta, we quantified the color intensity, or chromaticity, of excreta using digital image analysis. We found a positive relationship between growth rate and the number of flanges for fifth instars of E. servus. However, we found no relationship between growth or excretion and the number of flanges for all stages of N. viridula and for E. servus adults. Our results indicate that counts of salivary flanges should not be used to infer food consumption or preference in studies on N. viridula and E. servus adults, but can be used in studies of E. servus nymphs. Species-and stage-specific differences in the relationship between consumption and salivary flanges suggests distinct feeding strategies among species and stages; such differences may be potentially important in determining crop damage from pestiferous stink bugs.
    Full-text · Article · Mar 2015 · Annals of the Entomological Society of America
    • "Several models have been developed to assess how food web dynamics might be influenced by seawater warming (O'Connor et al. 2011). One of the predictions of the models is that both herbivore and plant abundances will change proportionally to a ratio of the temperature dependencies of the autotroph to the heterotroph of interest (O'Connor et al. 2011). A modeling approach to assess the effects of elevated seawater temperature on herbivore feeding preferences, macroalgal abundances, and food web dynamics would complement the present study and provide broader insights into assessments of future impacts of climate change on coastal macroalgal communities of the western Antarctic Peninsula. "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: As mean global temperatures continue to rise, regional seawater temperature measurements have revealed that some geographic areas are warming faster than others. One region that is experiencing particularly rapid warming is the western Antarctic Peninsula. Previous studies investigating direct effects of warming on Antarctic marine invertebrates have established that small increases in temperature can have significant impacts on aspects of behavior, physiology, and growth rates in these largely stenothermal organisms. To investigate how warming may impact feeding preferences of an ecologically important mesograzer on macroalgae of the Antarctic Peninsula, we examined the impacts of exposure to acute elevated temperature on the ecologically important omnivorous amphipod Gondogeneiea antarctica (Chevreux) at Palmer Station, Antarctica (64°46′S, 64°03′W) in April–May 2011. Amphipods were exposed to 1.5 °C (mean monthly upper summer temperature) or 3.5 °C (representative of current transient summer temperature peaks and projected mean for 2100) for a 24 h period. These amphipods were then used in choice-feeding assays with artificial food containing chemical extracts from six species of sympatric macroalgae known to produce feeding deterrents. We found that during acute exposure to elevated temperature (+2.0 °C), amphipods lost their feeding preferences in assays with artificial foods containing lipophilic (one macroalga), hydrophilic (three macroalgae), or combined lipophilic/hydrophilic (one macroalga) extracts. Our findings suggest that increased frequency in transient peaks and longer-term upward trends in ambient summer seawater temperature have the potential to alter feeding preferences in a common mesograzer that could influence macroalgal communities that dominate benthic communities along the western Antarctic Peninsula.
    No preview · Article · Feb 2015 · Marine Biology
  • Source
    • "Furthermore, predicting the effects of environmental change on populations benefits from understanding the environmental dependence of biological processes (Ives 1995; Thomas et al. 2004; Deutsch et al. 2008; Vasseur et al. 2014). Empirical relationships between the rates of physiological processes and one particularly important environmental variable, temperature, have been documented for many processes and taxa (Gillooly et al. 2001, 2002; Dell et al. 2010), including rates of food ingestion by individuals (Englund et al. 2011; O'Connor et al. 2011; Dell et al. 2014), rates of population growth (Savage et al. 2004), and rates of various ecosystem processes (Ernest et al. 2003; Allen et al. 2005; Yvon-Durocher et al. 2012). These and other relationships have been used to predict effects of temperature on population dynamics (Vasseur and McCann 2005). "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Understanding and quantifying the temperature dependence of population parameters, such as intrinsic growth rate and carrying capacity, is critical for predicting the ecological responses to environmental change. Many studies provide empirical estimates of such temperature dependencies, but a thorough investigation of the methods used to infer them has not been performed yet. We created artificial population time series using a stochastic logistic model parameterized with the Arrhenius equation, so that activation energy drives the temperature dependence of population parameters. We simulated different experimental designs and used different inference methods, varying the likelihood functions and other aspects of the parameter estimation methods. Finally, we applied the best performing inference methods to real data for the species Paramecium caudatum. The relative error of the estimates of activation energy varied between 5% and 30%. The fraction of habitat sampled played the most important role in determining the relative error; sampling at least 1% of the habitat kept it below 50%. We found that methods that simultaneously use all time series data (direct methods) and methods that estimate population parameters separately for each temperature (indirect methods) are complementary. Indirect methods provide a clearer insight into the shape of the functional form describing the temperature dependence of population parameters; direct methods enable a more accurate estimation of the parameters of such functional forms. Using both methods, we found that growth rate and carrying capacity of Paramecium caudatum scale with temperature according to different activation energies. Our study shows how careful choice of experimental design and inference methods can increase the accuracy of the inferred relationships between temperature and population parameters. The comparison of estimation methods provided here can increase the accuracy of model predictions, with important implications in understanding and predicting the effects of temperature on the dynamics of populations.
    Full-text · Article · Dec 2014 · Ecology and Evolution
Show more