ArticlePDF Available

Herbivore handling of a plant's trichome: The case of Heliconius charithonia (L.) (Lepidoptera : Nymphalidae) and Passiflora Lobata (Killip) Hutch. (Passifloraceae)

Authors:

Abstract and Figures

Trichomes reduce herbivore attack on plants by physically and/or chemically inhibiting movement or other activities. Despite evidence that herbivores are negatively affected by trichomes there also reports of insect counter-adaptations that circumvent the plants defense. This paper reports on a study that investigated the likely mechanisms employed by larvae of the nymphalid butterfly, Heliconius charithonia (L.), that allow it to feed on a host that is presumably protected by hooked trichomes (Passiflora lobata (Killip) Hutch). Evidence were gathered using data from direct observations of larval movement and behavior, faeces analysis, scanning electron microscopy of plant surface and experimental analysis of larval movement on plants with and without trichomes (manually removed). The latter involved a comparison with a non specialist congener, Heliconius pachinus Salvin. Observations showed that H. charithonia larvae are capable of freeing themselves from entrapment on trichome tips by physical force. Moreover, wandering larvae lay silk mats on the trichomes and remove their tips by biting. In fact, trichome tips were found in the faeces. Experimental removal of trichomes aided in the movement of the non specialist but had no noticeable effect on the specialist larvae. These results support the suggestion that trichomes are capable of deterring a non specialist herbivore (H. pachinus). The precise mechanisms that allow the success of H. charithonia are not known, but I suggest that a blend of behavioral as well as physical resistance mechanisms is involved. Future studies should ascertain whether larval integument provides physical resistance to trichomes.
Content may be subject to copyright.
May - June 2008 247
ECOLOGY, BEHAVIOR AND BIONOMICS
Herbivore Handling of a Plant’s Trichome: The Case of Heliconius
charithonia (L.) (Lepidoptera: Nymphalidae) and Passi ora lobata (Killip)
Hutch. (Passi oraceae)
MÁRCIO Z. CARDOSO
Depto. Botânica, Ecologia e Zoologia, Centro de Biociências, Univ. Federal do Rio Grande do Norte, 59072-970
Natal, RN, mzc@cb.ufrn.br
Neotropical Entomology 37(3):247-252 (2008)
Interação Herbívoro-Tricoma: o Caso de Heliconius charithonia (L.) (Lepidoptera: Nymphalidae) e Passi ora
lobata (Killip) Hutch. (Passi oraceae)
RESUMO - Apesar de as evidências mostrarem que herbívoros são negativamente afetados pelos
tricomas, há também relatos de contra-adaptações que sobrepujam as defesas das plantas. Este estudo
busca os prováveis mecanismos usados pelas larvas da borboleta ninfalídea Heliconius charithonia
(L.) que permitem que elas se alimentem de uma planta hospedeira que é, presumivelmente, protegida
por tricomas uncinados (curvados) (Passi ora lobata (Killip) Hutch.). Para isso realizou-se observação
direta de movimento e comportamento da larva, análise de fezes, microscopia eletrônica de varredura
da superfície foliar e análise experimental do movimento de larvas em plantas com e sem tricomas
(removidos manualmente). O experimento foi feito comparando o comportamento dessas larvas
com o de larvas de um não-especialista, Heliconius pachinus Salvin. As larvas de H. charithonia
são capazes de se desvencilhar do aprisionamento pelos tricomas usando força física. Além disso, ao
movimentar-se, a larva espalha os de seda sobre os tricomas e retira suas pontas com as mandíbulas.
De fato, pontas de tricoma foram encontradas nas fezes das larvas. A remoção experimental dos
tricomas auxiliou o movimento da larva não-especialista, mas não teve efeitos notáveis sobre a
larva especialista. Os resultados con rmam que os tricomas são capazes de deter um herbívoro não
especializado (H. pachinus). Os exatos mecanismos responsáveis pelo sucesso de H. charithonia ainda
são desconhecidos, mas sugere-se que a combinação de mecanismos comportamentais e de resistência
física estejam envolvidos e estudos futuros necessitam veri car a possibilidade de resistência física
no tegumento das larvas.
PALAVRAS-CHAVE: Herbivoria, defesa mecânica, interação inseto-planta
ABSTRACT - Trichomes reduce herbivore attack on plants by physically and/or chemically inhibiting
movement or other activities. Despite evidence that herbivores are negatively affected by trichomes
there also reports of insect counter-adaptations that circumvent the plant’s defense. This paper reports
on a study that investigated the likely mechanisms employed by larvae of the nymphalid butter y,
Heliconius charithonia (L.), that allow it to feed on a host that is presumably protected by hooked
trichomes (Passi ora lobata (Killip) Hutch). Evidence were gathered using data from direct observations
of larval movement and behavior, faeces analysis, scanning electron microscopy of plant surface and
experimental analysis of larval movement on plants with and without trichomes (manually removed). The
latter involved a comparison with a non specialist congener, Heliconius pachinus Salvin. Observations
showed that H. charithonia larvae are capable of freeing themselves from entrapment on trichome tips
by physical force. Moreover, wandering larvae lay silk mats on the trichomes and remove their tips
by biting. In fact, trichome tips were found in the faeces. Experimental removal of trichomes aided in
the movement of the non specialist but had no noticeable effect on the specialist larvae. These results
support the suggestion that trichomes are capable of deterring a non specialist herbivore (H. pachinus).
The precise mechanisms that allow the success of H. charithonia are not known, but I suggest that
a blend of behavioral as well as physical resistance mechanisms is involved. Future studies should
ascertain whether larval integument provides physical resistance to trichomes.
KEY WORDS: Herbivory, mechanical defense, insect-plant interaction
248 Cardoso - Herbivore Handling of a Plant’s Trichome: The Case of Heliconius charithonia (L.) (Lepidoptera...
The surface of many plant species are covered with
protective trichomes that can negatively impact wandering
herbivores by physically obstructing the animal’s movement or
releasing protective chemicals (Levin 1973, Van Dam & Hare
1998, Fordyce & Agrawal 2001). Plants of the genus Passi ora
L. (Passi oraceae) are better known for the employment of
cyanogenic-based chemical defense (Spencer 1988) than by
the use of physical defense against herbivores. Yet, in the
Pseudodysosmia Harms section [subgenus Decaloba (DC)
Rchb.)] of the Passi ora all 18 species bear hollow, hook-
like structures known as uncinate trichomes (MacDougal
1994), that are very effective in deterring caterpillars of the
specialist herbivore Heliconius Kluk (Gilbert 1971). Among
the Passi oraceae, uncinate trichomes are a unique feature of
the Pseudodysosmia group and are found in no other species in
the Passi ora genus (MacDougal 1994).
Although butter ies in the Heliconiiti group (Heliconius
and related genera) are the major herbivores to attack Passi ora
(Benson et al. 1975), Gilbert (1971) has shown that Heliconius
larvae die from entrapment in the hooks of the trichomes of
Passi ora adenopoda DC. In fact, in view of the seemingly
insurmountable trichome defense, he stated that “it is dif cult
to imagine how heliconiines might circumvent the highly
effective and speci c mechanical defense of P. adenopoda
without drastic developmental alterations”. In fact, later
studies have found that hooked trichome Passi ora species
are virtually free of herbivores aside from a small subset of
heliconiiti species (Benson et al. 1975, MacDougal 1994).
Indeed, only two species are commonly listed as herbivores:
Heliconius charithonia (L.) (Fig. 1) and Dione moneta Hübner
(Lepidoptera: Nymphalidae) (Benson et al. 1975, MacDougal
1994). Therefore, although trichomes seem to be highly
effective as a defense, some species have developed the ability
to somehow circumvent the physical barrier, perhaps through
developmental alterations as suggested by Gilbert (1971).
In view of the fact that, in general, some larvae of
Heliconius are unable to cope with the trichomes while
others are apparently unharmed, I set out to examine the
likely mechanisms employed by H. charithonia in order to
survive where other caterpillars perish. This report presents
observational as well as experimental data with the goal of
shedding light on this mechanistical question.
Material and Methods
The study was conducted using individuals collected from
populations housed in glass greenhouses (4 x 6.5 m) at the
University of Texas, Austin. Butter ies and the host plant
derive from founders collected in Sirena Station, Corcovado
National Park, Costa Rica. In Sirena, H. charithonia feeds on
Passi ora lobata (Killip) Hutch., a member of the hooked
trichome clade (Gilbert 1984, MacDougal 1994).
Larval behavior. Observations on larval behavior were made
in the greenhouses directly on a full grown host plant, and in
the laboratory. Larval observations in the laboratory were made
on leaves collected in the greenhouse and kept in a vial with
water to prevent wilting. Larval behavior was observed with
the naked eye or under a scope, with the leaf slightly tilted so
as to see the contact between the caterpillar and the leaf surface.
The goals of these observations were to examine the general
behavior of the caterpillars when moving or foraging on a leaf
with trichomes. Most of these behavioral observations were
made with the specialist herbivore, H. charithonia. A sample
of faeces of H. charithonia larvae was diluted in distilled
water and examined for leaf remains, a technique commonly
employed in studying food choice in grasshoppers (Mulkern
1967). Additionally, opportunistic observations were made
with larvae of other heliconiiti species: Dryas julia (Fabricius),
Agraulis vanillae (L.) and H. erato (L.).
Experimental removal of trichomes. In order to ascertain
whether larval movement is arrested by the trichomes, late
instars (4th and 5th) of the specialist herbivore, H. charithonia,
and of the non-specialist, H. pachinus Salvin, were placed
on isolated P. lobata leaves and followed for several hours.
Selection of H. pachinus was made to increase phylogenetic
Fig. 1. A 5th instar larva of H. charithonia crawling on the leaf of P. lobata. The trichomes are the translucent structures
highlighted by the ash burst. The arrows point the sclerotized plates on the larval prolegs. Bar scale is ca. 1 cm. Photo by
Lawrence Gilbert.
May - June 2008 Neotropical Entomology 37(3) 249
independence, because it belongs to a clade distinct from H.
charithonia (Gilbert 1991).
Prior to larval placement, experimental P. lobata leaves
were subjected to a shaving treatment for trichome removal.
First, peeling was done by putting a stick tape on the leaf
surface and pulling it out repeatedly, until the investigator
deemed necessary. To ensure maximal trichome removal a
shaver was also used. After peeling, it was passed as close
to the surface as possible. Control leaves did not have their
trichomes removed. Treated and untreated leaves were paired
according to their size (as measured by the length of the main
vein). The place where the larva was initially put was recorded
on the leaf surface with a marking pen. Subsequently, larval
movement was monitored for 5h at intervals of 1.5h.
A larval movement was recorded as such every time
the larva moved away from the point where it was last
seen. No movement was recorded when the larva did not
move from the release point or from the point where it was
last recorded. The number of moves made by a larva was
counted and transformed into proportion of moves made
(out of four possible moves), ranging from zero (no moves)
to one (moved in all occasions). Since these data were not
normally distributed I used a Wilcoxon non parametric test
and compared movement rate for each species separately.
Trichome density. Observations of trichome characteristics
were made under a Bausch & Lomb Stereo zoom scope, with
the petiole immersed in water and with the light source aimed
at a 90° angle from the leaf blade. Because trichomes are
translucent and dif cult to see under direct light, visibility
was improved by spraying a light powder onto the surface of
the leaf. Trichome density was estimated on a representative
leaf by counting the number of trichomes in ve randomly
chosen areas (10 x 10 mm quadrats) on both the upper and
lower leaf surfaces. Leaf area was estimated by scanning the
leaf and using imaging software to compute size (NIH Image
for the Macintosh).
Leaf SEM. Leaf samples of P. lobata kept in Sorensen buffer
were xed in 2.5% glutaraldehyde and rinsed in a buffer with
distilled water solution three times. Subsequently, samples
were dehydrated by an alcohol graded series (25-100%),
followed by critical point dry, stub mounting and metal coating
for SEM in a Hitachi S-340 scanning electron microscope.
Pictures were taken to characterize trichome morphology and
also to study damage caused by the herbivore. The areas of
the leaf where a larva had been observed under the scope were
marked and cut out for direct inspection.
Results
Larval behavior. In general terms, there is nothing special
about the larval behavior of H. charithonia that sets it apart from
other larvae. The crawling larva lays silk as it moves on the leaf
and, at times, a trichome would seem to disturb the movement.
For example, a leg would get stuck and, yet, the larva would
simply pull it away. Apart from that, the most striking behavior
was that the larva seemed to cut away some trichome tips as it
moved. While performing this task their mandibles would on
Fig. 2. Proportional number of moves made by 4th and
5th instar larvae of H. charithonia (bars on left) and H.
pachinus (bars on right) when left on P. lobata leaves that
had trichomes removed (peeled treatment – gray bars) or in
control leaves with trichomes (intact treatment – black bars).
Larval movements were recorded for 5h at intervals of 1.5h.
Numbers above bars refer to number of larvae tested and
lines are + 1 standard error. Movement rates were compared
between treatments within species using a Wilcoxon test. NS,
not signi cant; *, P = 0.022.
0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1
Intact Peeled Intact Peeled
H. charithonia H. pachinus
3
2
4
5
NS
*
Total moves (proportion)
occasion get caught by the tip of the trichomes. Nevertheless,
the larvae would pull their mandibles without any visible harm.
Sometimes, that would make them spit gut contents. Most
interestingly, though, H. charithonia would bit the tips of the
trichomes in front of it. As a consequence, several trichome
tips were found in the faeces sample, con rming the larvae’s
ability to handle the trichomes.
In some opportunistic observations, larvae of D. julia, A.
vanillae and H. erato were followed on the leaf of P. lobata.
D. julia moved as fast as H. charithonia. Leg pulling ability
was seen on Dryas and Agraulis but not on H. erato. In fact,
the single H. erato larva observed was trapped and dead 24h
later after being put on the leaf.
Experimental removal of trichomes. Removal of trichomes
increased movement of H. pachinus larvae (Fig. 2). On
average, larvae on control (intact) plants moved 12.5%, while
those on peeled leaves moved 75%. These differences were
signi cant (Wilcoxon, χ2 approximation = 5.25, df = 1, P
= 0.022). In contrast, H. charithonia larvae moved equally
well in both treatments with a tendency to move more in the
treated leaf (62.5% vs. 83%, control vs. treatment; Wilcoxon,
χ2 approximation = 0.42, df = 1, P = 0.52) (Fig. 2)
Trichome density. Trichomes cover the whole plant in P.
lobata. Trichome distribution on leaves varies between upper
and lower surfaces, with more trichomes on the upper than
on the lower surface. On a representative leaf, the average
trichome density on the upper side was 15.8 ± 2.40 trichomes.
mm-2 (n = 5 quadrats), while on the under side the density was
4.4 ± 1.73 trichomes.mm-2 (n = 5), a signi cant difference
(t-test, t = 8.6, df = 8, P < 0.0001). For an estimated leaf area
of 7.09 cm2, this gives an estimate of 11,202 trichomes on
the upper surface and 3,120 on the lower surface.
250 Cardoso - Herbivore Handling of a Plant’s Trichome: The Case of Heliconius charithonia (L.) (Lepidoptera...
ABC
D
EF
GH I
Fig. 3. Scanning electron micrography of samples of P. lobata leaves. A. General view of the leaf upper surface and
dispersion of hooked trichomes (magni cation and scale: 170X, 59 μm); B. Closer view of three trichomes. Notice the
hooked nature of the trichome tip and size differences between them (300X, 33 μm); C. Leaf vein and surface epidermis
covered with larval silk (113X, 88 μm); D. Trichome tip and the larval silk thread attached to it (1008X, 9.5 μm); E. Leaf
vein covered with silk thread (160X, 63 μm); F. Larval silk thread holding on to trichome structure. Notice that at least
three threads seem to tie it down (440X, 23 μm); G-I. Trichomes with tips removed by H. charithonia larva (300X, 33 μm;
160X, 63 μm; 160X, 63 μm, respectively).
Leaf SEM. The SEM pictures show a striking landscape (Fig.
3 A-I). The whole leaf blade is covered with menacing hooked
trichomes. Although trichome measurements were not made,
one can see at least two size classes with the same orientation
(Fig. 3 A,B). Trichomes seem to be densely spread on the leaf
blade (see section on estimates of trichome density), both on
the blade itself (Fig. 3 A,B) and on veins (Fig. 3 A,C,E-I). The
pictures in Fig. 3 also show the areas where the larvae crawled
(Fig. 3 C-I), revealed by the presence of ne thread lines. These
ne lines are larval silk spun by the caterpillars as a support
for movement, and cover most of the surface, including the
trichomes. In fact, perhaps adding insult to injury, trichomes
may be used as supports for laying down the silk thread (Fig.
3 D-F). One can also see that many trichomes have their
tips removed (Fig. 3 G-I), con rming observations of larval
behavior made under the scope. Many trichomes present on
the main vein from the lower surface, where the larvae H.
charithonia move frequently, had their tips taken away.
Discussion
The role of trichomes as effective mechanical barriers
to herbivores is well established (Levin 1973, Valverde et
al. 2001, Hanley et al. 2007). In fact, both Gilbert (1971)
and Pillemer & Tingey (1976) demonstrated with stunning
scanning electron images of dead herbivores the dramatic
consequences of entrapment by hooked trichomes. Many
other studies have shown the negative effect of trichomes
on herbivores (e.g., Hoffman & McEvoy 1986, Wilkens
et al 1996, Van Dam & Hare 1998, Medeiros & Moreira
2002) by traits such as trichome presence, density, shape,
length and glandular nature (Voigt et al. 2007). In my study,
trichome presence and shape affected larval movement of
non specialist Heliconius, con rming its defensive role. On
the other hand, movements by the specialist H. charithonia
were not signi cantly affected by them, yet larvae tended to
wander more on the treated leaf. In fact, even for specialists,
May - June 2008 Neotropical Entomology 37(3) 251
trichomes may increase handling time and/or time spent
moving on a leaf (Fordyce & Agrawal 2001) and they
therefore incur a cost to the herbivore.
My observations on free ranging caterpillars showed
that they usually stay on the under surface of the leaf, where
trichome density is lower, crawling along the main vein up
to the tip of the leaf. The fact that many hookless trichomes
were found in this area suggests that hook removal may be
an important adaptation that enables H. charithonia to avoid
getting trapped by the trichomes, a behavior that seems to be
restricted to H. charithonia. Moreover, the fact that the larval
faeces contained trichome hooks (and not the whole trichome)
suggests that trichome trimming may be needed in order to
handle trichomes. Finally, the potential harm trichomes may
incur on a specialist was unknowingly demonstrated when
I dropped a H. charithonia larvae on a P. lobata leaf and
accidentally injured it; the larvae subsequently died.
Silk weaving may also be important because it provides a
surface to which the crochets can connect that is independent
of leaf anatomy (e.g., Rathcke & Poole 1975). However
this alone cannot be considered a key characteristic given
that larvae in general are known to weave in order to
create a stable surface on which to crawl (Alexander 1961,
Craig 1997, Sugiura & Yamazaki 2006). Quite possibly,
morphology (eg Medeiros & Moreira 2002, Medeiros &
Bolignon 2007) may be an important component of the suite
that enables H. charithonia to handle the plant’s trichomes.
For example, I noticed that crawling larva of H. charithonia
can actually pull their legs from the hold of the trichome
hook, something that larvae of D. julia and A. vanillae larvae
were also capable of doing. A preliminary inspection on the
legs of several Heliconius larvae did not reveal any noticeable
difference in crochet size, number or arrangement that would
explain this ability. However, the lateral sclerotized proleg
plate (Fig. 1) of H. charithonia is more pigmented, which
may indicate a tougher plate, and is similar in appearance to
the ones in Dryas and Agraulis. Could this help these larvae
avoid entrapment? This hypothesis clearly deserves further
investigation.
Although no speci c characteristic can be pinpointed
as to how H. charithonia overcomes the host’s defenses, it
seems likely that a suite of behavioral (eg hook removal,
silk spinning) and mechanical traits (eg ability to detach
from trichome hook) allow it do so. It would be interesting
to ascertain whether there are costs associated with the
seemingly ample advantage of exploiting a host that is
unavailable to all other Heliconius. The herbivore offense
by H. charithonia larvae (Karban & Agrawal 2002) suggests
that it forages with nesse (sensu Dussourd 1993).
Acknowledgments
I would like to thank Larry Gilbert for enthusiastic
discussions regarding the project and for collecting P.
lobata for the experiments; R. Riess for helping in leaf tissue
preparation and SEM operation; J. MacDougal for providing
publication and discussions on the hooked Passi ora; G.
Sword for suggesting the fecal analysis and A. Almeida,
A. Freitas and J. Vasconcellos-Neto for improvements to
the manuscript. Butter ies and plants were collected under
permits from the Costa Rican government to Larry Gilbert.
Thanks to CAPES for providing a doctoral fellowship.
References
Alexander, A.J. 1961. A study on the biology and behavior of
caterpillars, pupae and emerging butter ies of the subfamily
Heliconiinae in Trinidad, West Indies. Part I. Some aspects of
larval behavior. Zoologica 46: 1-24.
Benson, W.W., K.S. Brown & L.E. Gilbert. 1975. Coevolution of
plants and herbivores: Passion ower butter ies. Evolution
29: 659-680.
Craig, C.L. 1997. Evolution of arthropod silks. Annu. Rev. Entomol.
42: 231-267.
Dussourd, D.E. 1993. Foraging with nesse: Caterpillar adaptations
for circumventing plant defenses, p.92-131. In N.E. Stamp &
T.M. Casey (eds.), Caterpillars, ecological and evolutionary
constraints on foraging. Chapman & Hall, New York, 548p.
Fordyce, J.A. & A. Agrawal. 2001. The role of plant trichomes and
caterpillar group size on growth and defence of the pipevine
swallowtail Battus philenor. J. Anim. Ecol. 70: 997-1005.
Gilbert, L.E. 1971. Butter y-plant coevolution: Has Passi ora
adenopoda won the selectional race with heliconiine
butter ies? Science 172: 585-586.
Gilbert, L.E. 1984. The biology of butter y communities, p.41-
54. In R. Vane-Wright & P.R. Ackery (eds.), The biology of
butter ies. Academic Press, London, 429p.
Gilbert, L.E. 1991. Biodiversity of a Central American Heliconius
community: Patterns, process, and problems, p 403-427. In P.W.
Price, T.M. Lewinsohn, G.W. Fernandes & W.W. Benson (eds.),
Plant-Animal Interactions: Evolutionary ecology in tropical and
temperate regions. Wiley-Interscience, New York, 639p.
Hanley, M. E., R.B. Lamont, M.M. Fairbanks & C.M. Rafferty.
2007. Plant structural traits and their role in anti-herbivore
defence. Perspect. Plant Ecol. Evol. Syst. 8: 157-178.
Hoffman, G.D. & P.B. McEvoy. 1986. Mechanical limitations
on feeding by meadow spittlebugs Philaenus spumarius
(Homoptera: Cercopidae) on wild and cultivated host plants.
Ecol. Entomol. 11: 415-426.
Karban, R & A. Agrawal. 2002. Herbivore offense. Annu. Rev.
Ecol. Syst. 33: 641-664.
Levin, D. 1973. The role of trichomes in plant defense. Q. Rev.
Biol. 48: 3-15.
MacDougal, J.M. 1994. Revision of Passi ora subgenus Decaloba
section Pseudodysosmia (Passi oraceae). Syst. Bot. Monogr.
41: 1-146.
Medeiros, L. & D.S. Bolignon. 2007. Adaptations of two specialist
herbivores to movement on the hairy leaf surface of their
host, Solanum guaraniticum Hassl (Solanaceae). Rev. Brasil.
Entomol. 51: 210-216.
252 Cardoso - Herbivore Handling of a Plant’s Trichome: The Case of Heliconius charithonia (L.) (Lepidoptera...
Medeiros, L. & G.R.P. Moreira. 2002. Moving on hairy surfaces:
modi cations of Gratiana spadicea larval legs to attach on
its host plant Solanum sisymbriifolium. Entomol. Exp. Appl.
102: 295-305.
Mulkern, G.B. 1967. Food selection by grasshoppers. Annu. Rev.
Entomol. 12: 59-78.
Pillemer, E.A. & W.M. Tingey. 1976. Hooked trichomes: a physical
plant barrier to a major agricultural pest. Science 193: 482-484.
Rathcke, B.J. & R.W. Poole. 1975. Coevolutionary race continues:
Butter y larval adaptation to plant trichomes. Science 187:
175-176.
Spencer, K.C. 1988. Chemical mediation of coevolution in the
Passi ora-Heliconius interaction, p.167-240. In K.C. Spencer
(ed.), Chemical mediation of coevolution. Academic Press,
San Diego, 609p.
Sugiura, S. & K. Yamazaki. 2006. The role of silk threads as lifelines
for caterpillars: Pattern and signi cance of lifeline-climbing
behaviour. Ecol. Entomol. 31: 52-57.
Valverde, P.L., J. Fornoni & J. Núñez-Farfán. 2001. Defensive role
of leaf trichomes in resistance to herbivorous insects in Datura
stramonium. J. Evol. Biol. 14: 424-432.
Van Dam, N. & J.D. Hare. 1998. Biological activity of Datura
wrightii glandular trichome exudates against Manduca sexta
larvae. J. Chem. Ecol. 24: 1529-1549.
Voigt, D., E. Gorb & S. Gorb. 2007. Plant surface-bug interactions:
Dicyphus errans stalking along trichomes. Arthropod-Plant
Inter. 1: 221-243.
Wilkens, R.T., G.O. Shea, S. Halbreich & N.E. Stamp. 1996.
Resource availability and the trichome defense of tomato
plants. Oecologia 106: 181-191.
Received 17/X/06. Accepted 20/III/08.
... Therefore, trichomes have been used to develop insect-resistance varieties in many important crops such as alfalfa, soybean, chickpea, cotton, sorghum, potato, and tomato 1,2 . On the other hand, some generalist and specialist herbivore insects can avoid trichome-based plant defenses to the detriment of the plant 5,6 . Some insect species perform better on plants with trichomes, and trichomes' positive effect in enhancing insect locomotion has been described. ...
Article
Full-text available
The combined release of the predatory mite Amblyseius swirskii (Athias-Henriot) and the mirid Nesidiocoris tenuis (Reuter) provides effective biological control of the tobacco whitefly (Bemisia tabaci (Gennadius)) in greenhouse eggplant. However, knowing how plants’ trichomes affect pest-predator interactions could improve whitefly management. Here, the effect of two varieties with either the presence or absence of trichomes was assessed on naturally occurring whitefly populations and predator abundance in a first experiment under field conditions. Predator-prey models were developed to assess the effect of trichomes on pest and predator population dynamics under field conditions. In a second semi-field experiment, the occurrence and oviposition preferences of B. tabaci and A. swirskii in the same eggplant varieties were compared. Significantly higher numbers of whitefly and mite, adults and eggs, were found on the hairy variety in both experiments. However, no differences were found in N. tenuis abundance between varieties under field conditions. Predator-prey models showed that whitefly growth rate increased in the hairy variety. N. tenuis and A. swirskii showed different fitness parameters according to the variety, with the former displaying better performance in the hairless variety and the latter in the hairy variety. Both predators effectively controlled the increase in whitefly populations in both varieties. Overall, the findings suggest that the hairless variety is more effective in deterring whiteflies. Additionally, the higher population of A. swirskii on the hairy variety indicates that this predator benefited from both the presence of trichomes and the prey.
... These host plant defences, and the need to overcome them, are thought to be the main promoter of larval aggregation in some systems (Clark & Faeth, 1997;Denno & Benrey, 1997;Despland, 2019;Fordyce & Agrawal, 2001;Kawasaki et al., 2009;Rentería et al., 2022). For example, some larvae will meticulously remove leaf trichome tips to reduce their harmful impact (Cardoso, 2008), but this is likely to be a costly task for an individual. Some gregarious larvae are well-equipped to deal with trichomes and collectively cover them in silk to avoid contact (e.g. ...
Article
Full-text available
Insect herbivores, such as lepidopteran larvae, often have close evolutionary relationships with their host plants, with which they may be locked in an evolutionary arms race. Larval grouping behaviour may be one behavioural adaptation that improves host plant feeding, but aggregation also comes with costs, such as higher competition and limited resource access. Here, we use the Heliconiini butterfly tribe to explore the impact of host plant traits on the evolution of larval gregariousness. Heliconiini almost exclusively utilise species from the Passifloraceae as larval host plants. Passifloraceae display incredible diversity in leaf shape and a range of anti‐herbivore defences, suggesting they are responding to, and influencing, the evolution of Heliconiini larvae. By analysing larval social behaviour as both a binary (solitary or gregarious) and categorical (increasing larval group size) trait, we revisit the multiple origins of larval gregariousness across Heliconiini. We investigate whether host habitat, leaf defences and leaf size are important drivers of, or constraints on, larval gregariousness. Whereas our data do not reveal links between larval gregariousness and the host plant traits included in this study, we do find an interaction between host plant specialisation and larval behaviour, revealing gregarious larvae to be more likely to feed on a narrower range of host plant species than solitary larvae. We also find evidence that this increased specialisation typically precedes the evolutionary transition to gregarious behaviour. The comparatively greater host specialisation of gregarious larvae suggests that there are specific morphological and/or ecological features of their host plants that favour this behaviour.
... Некоторые авторы считают, что опушение рассеивает избыточную солнечную энергию и увеличивает эффективность фотосинтеза [21,22,24]. Ещё одна функция трихом -защита растений от растительноядных членистоногих, которые поедают их листья [16,19,25]. Так, Ненько с соавторами (2012) у H. syriacus на листьях обнаружены волоски-трихомы различной сложности: простые, двойные и звездчатые. ...
... Trichomes act as a barrier during attacks from insects and small herbivores by limiting their movement and can negatively influence insect oviposition and feeding, thus preventing pest invasion [25,[32][33][34]. Furthermore, trichomes are often composed of cellulose and other substances of low nutritional value and are not palatable for insects [35,36]. Mechanical defense might also be influenced by trichome density over the surface of the leaf. ...
Article
Full-text available
Cyphostemma hypoleucum (Harv.) Desc. ex Wild & R.B. Drumm is a perennial climber, indigenous to Southern Africa, and belongs to the Vitaceae. Although there have been many studies of Vitaceae micromorphology, only a few taxa have been described in detail. This study aimed to characterize the micro-morphology of the leaf indumentum and determining its possible functions. Stereo microscope, scanning electron microscope (SEM), and transmission electron microscope (TEM) were used to produce images. Micrographs of stereomicroscopy and SEM showed the presence of non-glandular trichomes. In addition, pearl glands were observed on the abaxial surface using a stereo microscope and SEM. These were characterized by a short stalk and a spherical- shaped head. The density of trichomes decreased on both surfaces of leaves as the leaf expanded. Idioblasts that contained raphide crystals were also detected in tissues. The results obtained from various microscopy techniques confirmed that non-glandular trichomes serve as the main external appendages of the leaves. Additionally, their functions may include serving as a mechanical barrier against environmental factors such as low humidity, intense light, elevated temperatures, as well as herbivory and insect oviposition. Our results may also be added to the existing body of knowledge with regard to microscopic research and taxonomic applications.
... The fourth group includes 8 plants that are covered with scales, dots, or spots such as Deverra triradiata, Deverra tortuosa, and Sarcocornia fruticosa. A scale or peltate hair is a type of trichome that has a plate or shield-shaped cluster of cells attached directly to the surface or borne on a stalk of some kind and had a role in physical defense against insect herbivores (Cardoso, 2008). The fifth group includes 4 species that do not appear to have any form of defense, but they are weak plants that occur under woody plants or rocks and hence are out of reach by grazing animals. ...
Article
Full-text available
The present study aimed to evaluate the floristic characteristics of the wild plants in Wadi Degla Protectorate, including taxonomic diversity, life and sex forms, dispersal types, economic potential, threats, and national and global floristic distributions. Field visits were conducted during January and April (2021), and the study area was divided to 185 locations to comprise all the Wadi. From each location, plant and seed specimens were collected. In the present study, 161 plants belonged to 128 genera, and 43 families were recorded. They inhabited three habitats (upstream, midstream, and downstream). Therophytes were the most represented life form. Bisexuals were the most represented sex form. Sarcochores were the most represented dispersal type, followed by desmochores. For small geographic range — national habitat — non-abundant plants were the most represented rarity form. For national scales, the Mediterranean and Sinai regions were the richest wild plants. For global scales, the Saharo-Sindian and Mediterranean regions were the most represented elements. Medicinal plants were the most represented good, while solid wastes were the most represented threat.
Article
Full-text available
According to Mexican herbaria, scientific database and literature, 91 Passiflora species are registered in Mexico; thus, worldwide, this country presents the fifth largest diversity for this genus. Among Passiflora species, the most important economic species include yellow and red passion fruit (Passiflora edulis). Moreover, in southern Mexico, herein Campeche, Chiapas, Quintana Roo, and Yucatán states, there is reported 50% of this country Passiflora diversity. There, it was recorded 55 Passiflora species, 50 in Chiapas, whereas Quintana Roo has 23, Campeche 22, and Yucatán 17. At the municipality level, Ocosingo, Chiapas, presented the highest number of Passiflora species, 21; followed by Othón P. Blanco, Quintana Roo, with 14; and Calakmul, Campeche, 11. In its territory, Chiapas presents five biogeographical regions, explaining, at least in part, its richness in Passiflora species. The fruits of several species of this genus have been used in local communities as food, mainly beverages, and traditional medicine.
Preprint
Full-text available
Wide-ranging species are subject to varying biotic and abiotic selection pressures across their distribution. While local adaptation does not manifest in obvious morphological changes, population genomic studies can reveal cryptic diversity and provide insights into local adaptive processes. In this study, we investigated the biogeographic history and genomic diversity across the range of the zebra longwing butterfly Heliconius charithonia, a species with a widespread distribution in the Neotropics, but which is phenotypically homogenous across its range. We examined whole genome sequence data from 55 individuals from the eight described subspecies. We infer that there were at least two distinct colonization events of the Caribbean islands from the mainland. The second colonization wave occurred relatively recently, accounting for the genetic homogeneity observed across the species' range. Despite low divergence across most of the genome, two large non-recombining genomic regions showed deeply divergent haplotypes that correspond to chromosomal inversions. Phylogenetic analyses indicate ancient origins of these inversion polymorphisms, and there is no evidence that they were introgressed from another extant lineage of Heliconius. These ancient polymorphisms are likely maintained by heterogeneous selection across the landscape, with the inversion on chromosome 19 likely playing a role in local adaptation to cold and desiccation. Our findings underscore the importance of genomic analysis in uncovering hidden diversity and adaptation in phenotypically homogenous species and highlight the significant role of chromosomal inversions in driving local adaptation.
Article
Acraea terpsicore (Linnaeus, 1758) can utilize multiple host plants, particularly those in genus Passiflora, and poses a potential pest risk for introduced Passiflora plants and economically significant crops. In this study, the ovipositional preferences of an A. terpsicore population were investigated on four Passiflora species, including the wild host plant P. foetida, the fruit crop plant P. edulis, and two ornamental flower plants, P. × alata-caerulea and P. × coccinea-caerulea, as well as two non-Passiflora plants, Cucumis sativus and Vigna unguiculata. From a total of 4,059 eggs and 3,135 caterpillars, the majority of eggs were oviposited on P. foetida (50.63 %), followed by P. × coccinea-caerulea (23.40 %), P. × alata-caerulea (20.65 %), and P. edulis (5.32 %). Similarly, caterpillars were predominantly observed on P. foetida (38.66 %) and P. × coccinea-caerulea (38.50 %), followed by P. × alata-caerulea (17.86 %) and P. edulis (4.98 %). Meanwhile, neither eggs nor caterpillars were found on the non-Passiflora plants. Interestingly, the abundance of predatory arthropods mirrored the distribution of caterpillars. In addition, temperature and humidity strongly influenced the number of observed eggs and caterpillars. Although A. terpsicore preferred to oviposit on P. foetida, its caterpillars were equally abundant on P. × coccinea-caerulea. These differential ovipositional preferences and caterpillar proportions may be attributed to ovipositional preferences rather than caterpillars’ preferences. Although A. terpsicore is regarded as a non-pest species at present, this status may be altered if it encounters congeneric plants resembling its wild host plant within landscapes.
Thesis
Full-text available
Разработана экспериментально-компьютерная платформа ICGPhenoPlant для высокопроизводительного фенотипирования растений на основе анализа цифровых изображений и изучение с ее помощью взаимосвязи признаков фенотипа растений с генотипом и ответом на воздействие окружающей среды. Платформа включает приложения: LHDetect2 для оценки количественных характеристик опушения листьев пшеницы, картофеля и табака; SeedСounter для оценки признаков размера, формы и цвета оболочки зерен пшеницы; WERecognizer для оценки характеристик размера и формы колоса пшеницы. Разработаны базы данных WheatPGE и SpikeDroid для хранения данных о фенотипе, генотипе и месте произрастания растений пшеницы в процессе селекционно-генетического эксперимента. Разработанная система позволила провести анализ связи фенотипа и генотипа для признаков опушения листьев пшеницы, признаков зерен пшеницы в популяции ITMI, разработать описание характеристик колосьев пшеницы в базе данных SpikeDroid.
Article
The introduction of exotic plants into different habitats can have varied consequences for local herbivorous insects, such as altered the nutrient profiles that induce the host plant shifting or reduced food availability by competition with native plants. Acraea terpsicore (Linnaeus, 1758), a common butterfly in Southeast Asia that uses Passiflora as a host plant, has been studied to compare larval performance and adult phenotypes on one local wild Passiflora plant, P. foetida and 3 exotic congeneric plants, P. edulis, a fruit crop plant, and P. x alata-caerulea and P. x coccinea-caerulea, both hybrid ornamental plants. Laboratory caterpillars that fed on P. edulis and P. x alata-caerulea died within 1-10 days, while caterpillars fed on P. foetida and P. x coccinea-caerulea completed their life cycle in 30.42 ± 0.25 days. Although the caterpillars differed in several food utilization indices, the relative growth rate and consumption index were not affected. Adult butterflies that hatched from caterpillars fed on these experimental plants had different phenotypes, especially wing colors. Therefore, although some congeneric exotic plants may have a negative impact on the butterfly population, some exotic plants can serve as alternative larval host plants and expand the ecological niche of butterflies. Difference in the composition and concentration of nutrients and defensive chemicals in each host plant may exert an impact on the phenotypic traits of butterflies, such as their body size, coloration, and wing shape. Whether butterflies may separate into different subpopulations in the future due to phenotypic variation should be further examined.
Article
Full-text available
Plant trichomes can difficult the attachment and movement of small insects. Here, we examine the hypothesis that the success on the use of densely haired hosts by two cassidine species is determined by differential morphology and behavior. Larvae of Gratiana graminea (Klug, 1829) and Gratiana conformis (Boheman, 1854) move on the leaf surface of their host, Solanum guaraniticum Hassl by anchoring their tarsungulus on the trichome rays or by inserting the tarsungulus tip directly into epidermis. This kind of movement is only possible due to a similar tarsungulus shape among the species. Tarsungulus growth pattern is also similar between species, being relatively small on the posterior aperture, matching the diameter of the host plant trichome rays. The tarsungulus shape associated with differences on ontogenetic growth and attachment pattern allow these two Cassidinae larvae to efficiently move on the pubescent leaf surface of their host.
Article
Modern patterns of passifloraceous host plant choice by heliconiine butterflies suggest parallel evolution in the two groups with appreciable mutual influence. There are strong associations between the morphologically primitive and advanced sections of each taxon, with the single exception of the most derived Heliconius, which use primitive Passiflora in a specialized manner. The tracking of passion vine diversification by heliconians is thought to have involved a series of radiations of the insects onto plant groups containing smaller and smaller vines. We believe that competitive exclusion from larger plants has been an important factor in promoting switches to smaller plants in these protected insects, and that such usage resulted in complex behavioral adaptations enabling the efficient use of small, sporadically appearing meristems for oviposition. The association of many very successful heliconians with the small but fast-growing Plectostemma group of Passiflora and other similar vines is probably significant, and the reradiation of the Heliconius line back onto and across the infrequently occurring Astrophea meristems was no doubt necessarily predicated upon the evolution of an efficient search behavior by their more generalized ancestors. The five major recognizable radiations of heliconians seem to be able to successfully coexist today because of fundamental differences in the ways they divide up hosts. There occur many striking adaptations in passion vines which have evolved in response to selective pressure from heliconians and other insect herbivores. These can only be interpreted in an ecological context, and we are unable at present to perceive relict modifications specifically related to past herbivore defense adaptations in these plants. Extrapolating from current patterns, however, we conclude that such past adaptations existed and are most certainly being preserved in a cryptic state. Present day cases of adaptive racial divergences in heliconian species suggest that selective pressures are strong and dynamic coadaptive evolution is actively taking place among heliconians, passion vines, and other components in their complex environments.
Article
Section Pseudodysosmia of Passiflora subg. Decaloba comprises 18 species, including 2 subspecies, of herbaceous to slightly woody climbers characterized by uncinate trichomes, circinate development of the tendril, filaments of the corona in 1 series (rarely a few vestigial filaments of a second and inner row in several species), and a cucurbitaceous appearance. This group, distributed in Mexico, Central America, and South America, has radiated primarily into temperate regions of southern Mexico, where many of its species exhibit the growth habit of annual stems arising from perennial roots. An overview is given of the morphology of the genus Passiflora in comparison to that of sect. Pseudodysosmia. The fruits of species of sect. Pseudodysosmia are unusually diverse for an alliance of closely related species in Passiflora and include dehiscent reddish fruits and indehiscent purple or pale green fruits. Flowers are probably uniformly pollinated by bees and are generally xenogamous. Herbivory and chemistry of the group are reviewed. This revision is based primarily on study of morphology of live plants from the field and greenhouse and of herbarium specimens. Four new species and one new subspecies are described (P. pendens, P. pilosa subsp. dimidiata, P. pterocarpa, P. trichopoda, and P. uncinata). A key, nomenclature, detailed descriptions, citations of localities, and a list of exsiccatae as well as illustrations and distribution maps for each species are presented.
Article
Trichomes occur in a multitude of forms and sizes. Although they have been used widely for taxonomic purposes, their adaptive significance has been all but ignored by the evolutionist and ecologist. It is clear that trichomes play a role in plant defense, especially with regard to phytophagous insects. In numerous species there is a negative correlation between trichome density and insect feeding and oviposition responses, and the nutrition of larvae. Specialized hooked trichomes may impale adults or larvae as well. Trichome may also complement the chemical defense of a plant by possessing glands which exude terpenes, phenolics, alkaloids or other substances which are olfactory or gustatory repellents. In essence, glandular trichomes afford an outer line of chemical defense by advertising the presence of "noxious" compounds. In some groups of plants, protection against large mammals is achieved by the presence of stinging trichomes. Intraspecific variation for trichome type and density is known in many sp...