Content uploaded by Irina Codita
Author content
All content in this area was uploaded by Irina Codita on Mar 23, 2015
Content may be subject to copyright.
INTRODUCTION
Contaminated surfaces are possible vehicles in
infection transmission. This aspect stimulated scien-
tific research on materials with antimicrobial activity
in the last years, when antimicrobial resistance be-
came a public health concern. Different implications
in several areas of activity, including the medical
environment have been communicated (1-14).
It is known that both Copper and Silver effi-
ciently inactivate microbes by direct contact (13).
Due to this property, objects made of Silver have
been used since ancient times. Copper has not been
used much due to its known toxicity. Massive use of
these metals was not possible also due to their rela-
tively high cost. Aiming at using these metals in less
quantity while benefitting from their antimicrobial
effect, we evaluated the antimicrobial activity of
nanometric thin Silver and Copper films covering less
expensive materials. The final result of such an
approach would be the extensive use of Ag and Cu to
control infection in hospitals, schools, passenger
transportation vehicles and in every area of activity
where infection may occur.
IV.2. MATERIALS AND METHODS
Copper and Silver covered surfaces
50x50x2 mm stainless steel plates were covered
with Cu and also Ag nanolayers using the Thermoio-
nic Vacuum Arc (TVA) plasma source (14).
The TVA plasma is suitable for the deposition of
adherent, very thin metallic films under vacuum envi-
ronment, on different substrates: stainless steel, plas-
tics, textiles etc. Images of the TVA plasma ignited in
Ag and also in Cu vapors are presented in Fig. 1. The
substrates were placed above the plasma source, as
can be observed in this figure.
Apart from stainless steel plates, Silver and Co-
pper covered spherical shape samples were also used
to evaluate the effects of metal ions on the production
of staphylococcal thermonuclease.
Testing for antimicrobial activity was performed
in the Nosocomial Infections and Antimicrobial Re-
sistance Reference Laboratory or in the Zoonoses Refe-
rence Laboratory, “Cantacuzino” National Institute of
Research-Development for Microbiology and Im-
munology, Bucharest.
204
ABSTRACT
Contaminated surfaces are possible vehicles in infection transmission. It is known that both Copper
(Cu) and Silver (Ag) efficiently inactivate microbes by direct contact. Aiming at using these metals for
benefitting from their antimicrobial effect, but to avoid subsequent toxic effects, we evaluated the
antimicrobial activity of nanometric thin Silver and Copper films covering less expensive materials.
Using a modified version of the Japan Industrial Standard JIS Z 2801:2000, we demonstrated the
antimicrobial activity of the surfaces covered with metal ions nanofilms on microorganisms possi-
bly involved in nosocomial infections and on Bacillus anthracis, bacteria with possible implication
in bioterrorist attacks. Copper covered surfaces proved to have better antimicrobial activity than
Silver surfaces. Silver covered surfaces showed better activity on Gram negative bacteria than on
Gram positive cocci.
Going deeper with studies on antimicrobial effects using new methods with better direct and/or
functional discriminatory capacity is needed in order to provide additional information on the
mechanisms of Silver and Copper nanofilms antimicrobial activity.
ANTIMICROBIAL ACTIVITY OF COPPER AND SILVER NANOFILMS
ON NOSOCOMIAL BACTERIAL SPECIES
Irina Codiþã1*, Dana Caplan1, Elena-Carmina Drãgulescu1, Elena Branduºa Lixandru1, Luminiþa Coldea1,
Cerasella Dragomirescu1, Cristina Surdu-Bob2, Marius Badulescu2
1“Cantacuzino” National Institute of Research-Development for Microbiology and Immunology, Bucharest;
2National Institute of Research-Development for Lasers, Plasma and Radiation Physics, Bucharest
Key words: Silver, Copper, nanofilms, antimicrobial activity, nosocomial pathogens, Bacillus anthracis
*
Corresponding author:
Irina Codiþã, I.N.C.D.M.I. CANTACUZINO, Splaiul Independenþei 103, sector 5, 050096, Bucureºti, România,
email: adirina_2005@yahoo.com
Microbial strains
We used eight bacterial strains, from which
seven belonged to species known as being involved
in nosocomial infections.
One Bacillus anthracis nonpathogen strain, B.
anthracis 34 F2Sterne was introduced in the study
because of the possible use of this species as inten-
tional attack biological weapon.
Reference disc diffusion susceptible strains and
other strains recommended to be used for antimicro-
bial activity testing were introduced in the study, as
follows: S. aureus ATCC 25923, S. aureus ATCC
6538, E. coli ATCC 25922, E. coli ATCC 35218, Ente-
rococcus faecium ATCC 35667, Enterococcus faecalis
ATCC 51299, Pseudomonas aeruginosa 27853.
Antimicrobial activity testing
The antimicrobial activity of the metalic ions
nanofilm covered surfaces was tested using a proto-
col representing a modified version of the Japanese
Industrial Standard JIS Z 2801:2000, adapted after
Necula et al., 2009 (12).
We used Copper and Silver nanofilms covered
stainless steel plates, 50/50/2 mm and stainless steel
uncovered plates with the same profile, as negative
probes. All plates used in the experiment were
cleaned with 70% ethanol, rinsed with distilled water
and UV sterilised for 15 minutes, each side before
being inoculated with the bacterial suspension.
Bacterial suspensions were prepared in Trypticase
Soy Broth, corresponding to a 107UFC/ml concen-
tration (0.03 OD620). This concentration is equiva-
lent to a bacterial suspension obtained by preparing
a 1/10 dilution of a suspension corresponding to the
0.5 McFarland standard.
Nitrocellulose filters with 0.40 mporosity, 25 mm
Ø, UV sterilised were used to apply the bacterial
inoculum.
Antimicrobial activity of Copper and Silver nanofilms on nosocomial bacterial species
205
Figure 1. The TVA plasma ignited in a) Ag and b) Cu vapors and samples; c) plates and d) spheres
covered with Ag/Cu. Original images obtained at the National Institute of Research-Development
for Lasers, Plasma and Radiation Physics, Bucharest
These filters were firstly placed on the surface of
a blood-agar plate and a 40 ml volume of bacterial
suspension prepared as described was applied on
their upper surface. The liquid component of the sus-
pension was absorbed by the agar, whilst the bacte-
ria remained on the filter surface (Fig. 2).
A 40 ml 1% Tryptic Soy Broth (TSB) in 10 mM
phosphate volume was centrally placed on the Copper
or Silver covered plates or on the stainless steel
uncovered plates.
The filter inoculated with the microbial suspen-
sion was then carefully placed on the top of the TSB-
phosphate drop, with the initial upside down. Metal
plates were placed in Petri sterile plates and mentained
at 36 ± 1 oC, in a humid athmosphere, for different
time intervals in order to establish the needed time
for bacterial suspension inactivation.
After incubation, the filter-plate installation was
flooded with a 20 mL volume of physiologic saline
and washed by shaking for 60 seconds with a mecha-
nical shaker.
Decimal dilutions were prepared from the washing
liquid from -1 to -7, and 10 ml from each dilution where
then transferred on blood agar plates, in sectors. Tri-
plicate experiments were performed for each strain-
metal plate binome and for each incubation time.
After incubating the plates inoculated with wa-
shing liquid dilutions for 18 hours at 37oC, we counted
the colonies grown on the sectors with distinct colony
growth and calculated the medium number of
CFU/ml in the washing liquid.
Thermonuclease activity
Thermonuclease or heat stable nuclease is an
enzyme elaborated by S. aureus.
Testing of thermonuclease by Lachica method
was performed to detect possible effects on proteins
activity due to the action of metalic ions nanofilms
placed on metalic surfaces.
A series of spherical 2 mm diameter metal ions
nanofilm covered samples were placed in S. aureus
broth cultures and were incubated for 2 hours at 36
± 1oC and then tested for thermonuclease activity.
Lachica method principle is based on detecting
changes in nucleic acids-bromthymol blau comple-
xes caused by the thermonuclease activity, which are
resulting in turning of the complex purple color to a
pink color.
Semiquantitative evaluation of S. aureus thermo-
nuclease activity was done by appreciating the pink
diameter of nucleic acids lysis of each bacterial sus-
pension incubated in the presence of a different num-
ber of metalic ions nanofilm covered balls.
RESULTS
Antimicrobial activity of Copper or Silver nano-
film covered surfaces on bacterial strains with pos-
sible implication in nosocomial infections
Medium number of CFU/ml in the metal plate-
filter installation washing liquid obtained in triplicate
was used for tracing antimicrobial activity curves for
the stainleess steel uncovered and Copper or Silver
covered plates.
All results are presented in the following tables
and graphs.
206
CODIÞÃ et al.
Fig. 2. Schematic representation of the test used for antimicrobial activity invetigation of the stainless
steel and metal ions nanofilm covered plates. All bacteria will be in contact with the plate surface, as
the filter diameter is smaller than the plate dimensions. After Necula et al. (2009).
a. The liquid component of the b. The inoculated filter is placed with the
bacterial suspension is absorbed; side with retained bacteria in contact with
bacteria are retained on the filter the metal plate
Antimicrobial activity of Copper and Silver nanofilms on nosocomial bacterial species
207
Staphylococcus aureus ATCC 25923
Table 3. Antimicrobial activity of metal plates covered with different metal ions nanofilms
depending on the length of the contact time - Staphylococcus aureus ATCC 25923
Fig. 3. Time dependent curves of antimicrobial activity of Copper and Silver nanofilm covered surfaces
expressed by the number of CFU/ml recovered from the washing liquid, Staphylococcus aureus ATCC
25923. Comparison with the stainless steel uncovered surface
Staphylococcus aureus ATCC 6538
Table 4. Antimicrobial activity of metal plates covered with different metal ions nanofilms
depending on the length of the contact time - Staphylococcus aureus ATCC 6538
Fig. 4. Time dependent curves of Copper and Silver nanofilm covered surfaces antimicrobial activity
expressed by the number of CFU/ml recovered from the washing liquid, Staphylococcus aureus ATCC
6538. Comparison with the stainless steel uncovered surface
208
CODIÞÃ et al.
Enterococcus faecium ATCC 35667
Table 5. Antimicrobial activity of metal plates covered with different metal ions nanofilms
depending on the length of the contact time - Enterococcus faecium ATCC 35667
Fig. 5. Time dependent curves of Copper and Silver nanofilm covered surfaces antimicrobial activity
expressed by the number of CFU/ml recovered from the washing liquid, Enterococcus faecium ATCC
35667. Comparison with the stainless steel uncovered surface.
Enterococcus faecalis ATCC 51299
Table 6. Antimicrobial activity of metal plates covered with different metal ions nanofilms
depending on the length of the contact time - Enterococcus faecalis ATCC 51229
Fig. 6. Time dependent curves of Copper and Silver nanofilm covered surfaces antimicrobial activity
expressed by the number of CFU/ml recovered from the washing liquid, Enterococcus faecalis ATCC
51229. Comparison with the stainless steel uncovered surface
Antimicrobial activity of Copper and Silver nanofilms on nosocomial bacterial species
209
E. coli 25922
Table 7. Antimicrobial activity of metal plates covered with different metal ions nanofilms
depending on the length of the contact time - Escherichia coli ATCC 25922
Fig. 7. Time dependent curves of Copper and Silver nanofilm covered surfaces antimicrobial activity
expressed by the number of CFU/ml recovered from the washing liquid, Escherichia coli ATCC 25922.
Comparison with the stainless steel uncovered surface
E. coli ATCC 35218
Table 8. Antimicrobial activity of metal plates covered with different metal ions nanofilms
depending on the length of the contact time - E. coli ATCC 35218
Fig. 8. Time dependent curves of Copper and Silver nanofilm covered surfaces antimicrobial activity
expressed by the number of CFU/ml recovered from the washing liquid, E. coli ATCC 35218. Comparison
with the stainless steel uncovered surface
210
CODIÞÃ et al.
Pseudomonas aeruginosa ATCC 27853
Table 9. Antimicrobial activity of metal plates covered with different metal ions nanofilms
depending on the length of the contact time - Pseudomonas aeruginosa ATCC 27853
Fig. 9. Time dependent curves of Copper and Silver nanofilm covered surfaces antimicrobial activity
expressed by the number of CFU/ml recovered from the washing liquid, Pseudomonas aeruginosa ATCC
27853. Comparison with the stainless steel uncovered surface.
Silver or Copper covered surfaces antimicrobial activity on Bacillus anthracis 34 F2 Sterne strain
Table 10. Antimicrobial activity of metal plates covered with different metal ions nanofilms
depending on the length of the contact time - Bacillus anthracis 34 F2 Sterne
Fig. 10. Time dependent curves of Copper and Silver nanofilm covered surfaces antimicrobial activity
expressed by the number of CFU/ml recovered from the washing liquid, Bacillus anthracis 34 F2 Sterne.
Comparison with the stainless steel uncovered surface.
The effect of Copper and Silver nanofilm on S.
aureus thermonuclease activity
Semiquantitative results of S. aureus thermonu-
clease activity obtained by Lachica method (Fig. 11)
are presented in Table 11.
Preliminary results are leading to the hypothesis
that Copper and Silver are acting depending on the
doses to stimulate the enzyme production in low to
moderate doses, or to inhibit it, in high doses.
DISCUSSION
Possible mechanisms of metal ions antimicrobial
action have been put forward, like oligodynamic effect,
absorbtion in the electric field, catalysis process, dena-
turating action of Silver on the bacterial cell enzymes.
Interaction between a bacterial cell and the surface
is governed primarily by van der Waals and electrosta-
tic forces, depending on the physicochemical pro-
perties of the substratum and the bacterial surface, such
as hydrophobicity, free energy and surface charge (8).
The results obtained in our study demonstrated
the antimicrobial properties of surfaces covered with
metallic Silver or Copper nanofilms prepared using
plasma in vacuum.
Antimicrobial effects were better for Copper,
which has a rapid bactericidal effect on all tested bac-
terial species. With Silver we noticed differences de-
pending on the bacterial species, Gram negative rods
showing greater susceptibility than Gram positive
cocci. On the other hand, differences between Gram
positive cocci of the same Genus and species sugges-
ted possible acquired resistance mechanisms.
The screening study results are encouraging us to
go deeper by using Atomic Force Microscopy and ex-
tending the area of observation on the possible effects
of metal ions covered surfaces on bacterial enzyme
production and activity in potentially nosocomial mi-
croorganisms.
Preliminary results obtained in our study brought
positive proof for Copper nanofilm covered surfaces
use in nosocomial infection prevention and/or dimi-
nishing. These results confirm recent research results
communicated by international teams after the initia-
tion of our project (4).
CONCLUSIONS
1. The methods used in this study were able to
detect the antimicrobial activity of the surfaces covered
with metal ions nanofilms on microorganisms with
possible implication in nosocomial infections.
2. Our experiments demonstrated the antimicro-
bial activity of the surfaces covered with Copper and
Silver nanofilms obtained by TVA plasma on most
potentially nosocomial microorganisms as well as on
Bacillus anthracis, bacteria with possible implication
in bioterrorist attacks.
3. Copper covered surfaces proved to have bet-
ter antimicrobial activity than Silver surfaces.
4. Silver covered surfaces showed better activity
on Gram negative bacteria than on Gram positive
cocci.
5. Going deeper with studies on antimicrobial
effects by using Atomic Force Microscopy studies (8,
15, 16) and by extending our observations about the
metal ions effects on the proteic enzyme production
and activity could provide additional information on
the mechanisms of Silver and Copper nanofilms
antimicrobial activity.
Antimicrobial activity of Copper and Silver nanofilms on nosocomial bacterial species
211
Table 11. Semiquantitative results expressing
the thermonuclease activity appreciated by
measuring the diameter of the pink turned zones
Fig. 11. Checking the thermonuclease activity on
Lachica medium
Legenda: M - positive reference sample; 3 Ag - 3 Silver
balls; 6 Ag - 6 Silver balls; 12 Ag - 12 Silver balls; 24
Ag - 24 silver balls; 1 - 1 Copper ball; 2 - 2 Copper
balls; 4 - 4 Copper balls; 8 - 8 Copper balls
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
I.C., E-C.D. acknowledge the support of this work
from the Romanian Ministry of Research through
project PNII-42129/2008.
C.S-B is grateful for the financial support from
POSDRU/89/1.5/S/60746.
REFERENCES
1. Aarestrup, F. M., Hasman, H. - Susceptibility of different
bacterial species isolated from food animals to copper
sulphate, zinc chloride and antimicrobial substances
used for disinfection - 2004, Vet. Microbiol, 100, 83-89.
2. Barkow G., Gabbay J., Putting copper into action: cop-
per impregnated products with potent biocid activities -
The FASEB J, 2004, 18, 1728-1730.
3. Carson, K., C., Bartlett, J. G., Tan, T.-J., Riley, T., V. - In
Vitro Susceptibility of Methicillin-Resistant Staphylo-
coccus aureus and Methicillin-Susceptible Staphylo-
coccus aureus to a New Antimicrobial, Copper Silicate -
Antimicrob. Ag. Chemother., 2007, 51, 12, 4505-4507.
4. Casey, A. L., Lambert, P., A., Miruszenko, L., Elliott, T.
S. J. - Copper for preventing Microbial environmental
Contamination, ICAAC poster, October 2008.
5. Dan Z. G., Ni H.W., Xu B.F, Xiong J. and Xiong P.Y.-
Microstructure and antibacterial properties of AISI 420
stainless steel implanted by copper ions - Thin solid
films, 2005, 492, 1-2, 93-100.
6. Faúndez G., Troncoso M, Navarrete P. and Figueroa G. -
Antimicrobial activity of Copper surfaces against sus-
pensions of Salmonella enterica and Campylobacter
jejuni - BMC Microbiology 2004, 4, 19.
7. Hasman, H., Aarestrup, F., M. - Relationship between
copper, glycopeptide, and macrolide resistance among
Enterococcus faecium strains isolated from pigs in
Denmark between 1997 and 2003 - Antimicrob. Agents
Chemother, 2005, 49, 454-456.
8. Nan, L., Liu, Y., Lu, M., Yang, K. - Study on antibacte-
rial mechanism of copper-bearing austenitic antibacteri-
al stainless steel by atomic force microscopy - J Mater
Sci. Mater. Med., 2008, 19, 3057-3062.
9. Nan, L. et al. - Antibacterial Mechanism of Copper-bea-
ring Antibacterial Stainless Steel against E. Coli - J.
Mater. Sci. Technol - 2008, 24, 197-201.
10. Liu Q. et al. - Antimicrobial nanoparticles for water
disinfection and microbial control: Potential applica-
tios and implications, Water Research, 2008, 42, 18,
4591-4602.
11. McLean RJ, Hussain AA, Sayer M, Vincent PJ, Hughes
DJ, Smith TJ - Antibacterial activity of multilayer silver-
copper surface films on catheter material - Can. J.
Microbiol., 1993, 39, 9, 895-9.
12. Necula, B., S., Fratila-Apachitei, L., E., Zaat, S., A., J.,
Apachitei, I., Duszczyk, J. - In vitro antibacterial activity
of porous TiO2-Ag composite layers against methi-
cillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus - Acta Bioma-
terialia 2009, 5, 3573-3580.
13. Santo, C., E., Morais, P. V., Grass, G. - Isolation and
characterization of bacteria resistant to metalic Copper
surfaces - Appl. Environ. Microbiol., 2010, 76, 5,
1341-1348.
14. Surdu-Bob, C., Mustata, I., Iacob, C. - General charac-
teristics of the Thermoionic Vacuum Arc plasma - J.
Optoel. Adv. Mat., 2007, 9, 9, 2932 - 2934.
15. Dufrene, Y., F. - Recent progress in the application of
atomic force microscopy imaging and force spectro-
scopy to microbiology - Curr. Opin. Microbiol. 2003,
6, 317-323.
16. Kromet A. et al. - How long do nosocomial pathogens
persist on inanimate surfaces? A systematic review,
BMC Infectious Disease, 2006, 6, 130.
212
CODIÞÃ et al.