Article

The Role of Customary Institutions in Managing Conflict on Grazing Land - A Case Study from Mieso District, Eastern Ethiopia

Authors:
To read the full-text of this research, you can request a copy directly from the author.

Abstract

This paper examines interethnic conflict on grazing land previously accessed as common property. The study was undertaken in Mieso District of eastern Ethiopia where two ethnic groups experience different production systems – pastoral and agropastoral. Game theoretic approach and analytic narratives have been used as analytical tools. Results show that the historical change in land use by one of the ethnic groups, resource scarcity, violation of customary norms, power asymmetry and livestock raids are some of the factors that have contributed to the recurrence of the conflict. The role of raids in triggering conflict and restricting access to grazing area becomes particularly important. Socio-economic and political factors are responsible for power asymmetry and increasing scale of raids. The joint effect of an increase in trend of violence and a decline in capacity of customary authority in conflict management advances state role in establishing enforceable property rights institutions. This would be successful only if policies and intervention efforts are redirected at: 1) suppressing incentives for violence, 2) establishing new institutional structures, in consultation with clan elders of both parties and 3) building internal capacity to monitor conflict-escalating events.

No full-text available

Request Full-text Paper PDF

To read the full-text of this research,
you can request a copy directly from the author.

... Peace building is largely equated with the construction of a social environment that advances a sense of confidence and improves conditions of life. As conflict occurs at personal, communal, social, national and global levels, the styles of conflict resolution/management used differ largely at these different levels [5]. ...
... Beyene [5] indicated that the high success rate of elders' interventions in conflict resolution was witnessed in spite of its revealed weaknesses than other types of third parties such as diplomats, professional mediators, and good offices from international organizations like the UN. In this connection, a large study of mediation in international conflicts between 1945 and 1990, over half (55%) of the high-level mediation attempts were unsuccessful. ...
... Indigenous conflict mediators typically possess moral status, seniority, neutrality and respect of the community; they are acceptable to all parties and demonstrate leadership capacity. Resolutions are generally accepted and respected by all concerned parties [5]. ...
... The lack of equal access to land is an important source of conflict (Menbere, 2013). The imbalance of power among land users and the lack of equitable access to natural resources have contributed to the recurrence of conflicts in Ethiopia (Beyene, 2007;Lode and Kassa, 2001;Tadesse et al., 2015). Loss of access to key resources and eviction without compensation are drivers of conflict between affected communities, the government, and the private sector (Ochieng, 2011). ...
... The traditional governance systems that involve conflict resolution are called the Gadaa 7 and Madaa 8 in the Karrayyu and Afar societies, respectively. However, the role of traditional leaders in land conflict resolution has declined (Beyene, 2007). For example, 54% of the conflicts in Afar were solved by the government, and only 31% were solved by the traditional elders' council (Stickler et al., 2018). ...
Article
Full-text available
We examined the determinants of conflict among agro-pastoral households in areas affected by large-scale land investments in Ethiopia. We combined household and community surveys to collect data and used descriptive statistics and a binary logit model to analyze them. The results indicated that, in the last decade, land conflicts were prevalent in more than a quarter of the studied communities and that they increased since the establishment of large-scale land investments. The scarcity of pastureland and tenure insecurity are the key drivers of land conflict. We conclude that the state appropriation of traditional pastures for industrial plantations and a lack of property rights for the commons exacerbate land conflicts.
... The imbalance of power between land users and the lack of equitable access to natural resources have contributed to the recurrence of conflict in Ethiopia (Beyene, 2007;Lode and Kassa, 2001;Tadesse et al., 2015). Loss of access to key resources and eviction without compensation are drivers of conflict between affected communities, the government, and the private sector (Ochieng, 2011). ...
... However, the role of traditional leaders in land conflict resolution has been declining (Beyene, 2007). For instance, 54% of the conflicts in Afar were solved through the government and only 31% by the traditional elder's council (Stickler et al., 2018). ...
... The free access of automatic weapons of one group and the denial of the others create unequal power relations. A study conducted in the area by Beyene (2007) has also confirmed the existence of power asymmetry between these conflicting parties. This power asymmetry between the contending parties has its own repercussions on the efforts of the peace process made at various levels. ...
Article
Comme tant d'autres pays africains, l'Ethiopie est confrontée à plusieurs conflits qui déchirent les différents groupes ethniques ou claniques qui habitent son territoire. Différentes causes justifient l'intensité et la persistance de ces conflits. Basé sur un travail de terrain auprès des responsables communautaires et religieux et des représentants des femmes, des jeunes, et des partis politiques à travers des interviews et des discussions de groupes, cet article se penche sur les causes des conflits ethniques entre les Issa, les Afar et les Ittu qui vivent dans la partie orientale de l'Ethiopie. Suivant leurs causes, l'étude fait la distinction entre les conflits de relation, les conflits de valeur et les conflits structurels. Les premiers sont basés sur de fausses perceptions ou des stéréotypes ainsi que sur des comportements négatifs répétitifs d'un groupe vis-à-vis de l'autre. Les seconds sont dus aux différents critères d'appréciation des comportements utilisés par chaque groupe tandis que les derniers sont causés par des modes destructifs comportementaux, la distribution des ressources, l'exercice inégalitaire de pouvoir et d'autorité ainsi que par des facteurs environnementaux qui empêchent la coopération entre les groupes. L'article contient certaines recommandations en vue du règlement de ces conflits.
... It costs less and takes less time to bring criminals to justice and to bring justice to the victim. According to [11], the use of formal institutions to settle disputes especially for rural peoples is very difficult because these rural people expending more time in this justice system and administrative institutions that led them to economic disaster. This formal justice system is not only affecting their income but also deteriorates the social relationship of the rural society as resulted in the decision rendered by the court system does not consider the background of conflicting parties that leads the kinship relation becomes hostile and relatives' relationship is highly affected by it and encountered by tension. ...
Article
Full-text available
Ethnic-based border conflicts are/were common in eastern Ethiopia among the Afar, Ittu-Oromo and Issa-Somali pastoral groups. The qualitative data required for the study were collected from community leaders, ordinary members of the communities, and administrative and political bodies at various levels through one-on-one interviews, focus group discussions and field observations. The quantitative data were also collected through household survey from the 128 households randomly drawn from the three districts of Meiso-Mullu, Meiso and Amibara. This research attempted to identify the trends and prevalence of violent conflicts and tensions observed and the factors encouraging the rival groups to instigate conflicts. The results revealed that the trend of violent conflicts is increasing because of increased resource scarcity, absence of property rights, weak customary institutions, and among others. The new political and administrative arrangements following the introduction of ethnic based federalism gave the existing conflicts new shapes and paradigms. The research revealed that socio-political and resource factors were found to be important in explaining the existing conflicts in the study areas. The competition over scarce natural resources particularly on water and pasture land was found to be one of the important causes for most (agro) pastoral conflicts in the study area. Such conflicts become more intense, severe, frequent, and violent when the competing groups differ in their ethnic groupings and when there are no clearly defined property rights between these rival groups (including the absence of clearly defined regional boundaries).
Technical Report
Full-text available
A number of ethnic-based conflicts were observed in eastern Ethiopia in the past between various ethnic groups such as between the Afar and the Oromo, between the Oromo and the Somali, between the Somali and the Afar ethnic/clan groups. This research attempted to identify the conflicts and tensions observed between the Oromo and Somali ethnic/clan agro-pastoralist and pastoralist groups in the eastern parts of the country. The results revealed that the new political and administrative arrangements following the introduction of ethnic based federalism gave the existing conflicts new shapes and paradigms. The current conflicts in the study area are generally between the Oromo, the Afar and the Somali ethnic/clan members. The causes of conflicts in the study area are multi-dimensional, complex and dynamic in nature. It has changed its nature across the different regimes in Ethiopian past history. The research revealed that social, economic, institutional, resource and environmental factors were found to be the important factors in explaining the conflicts and tensions observed in the study areas. The competition over scarce natural resources particularly on water and pasture land was found to be one of the important causes for most (agro) pastoral conflicts in the study area. Such conflicts become more intense, severe, frequent, and violent when the competing groups differ in their ethnic groupings and when there are no clearly defined property rights between the groups (including the absence of clearly defined regional boundaries). Owing the ethnic-based federal administrative structure, the indigenous institutions of conflict resolution, were found to be more effective, as compared to modern institutions in managing intra-ethnic/clan conflicts, and less effective in addressing inter-ethnic conflicts.
Thesis
Bodendegradation ist ein wachsendes Problem von Pakistan, die Biomasse Verlust verursacht und hat einen schlechten Einfluss auf die Wirtschaft des Landes. Nordöstlich von der Provinz Punjab, die berühmt für die Reisanbau ist, leidet auch mit diesem Problem. Zusammen mit einigen anderen Gründen, sind institutionelle Aufbau in den Regionen und der Landnutzungsänderungen der Hauptgründe für diesen Abbau. Obwohl das Land ist, die privaten Eigentümern, aber wegen der Störung der bestehenden Eigentumsrechte und die jüngste Stadterweiterung in der Region hat interfamiliären Konflikte zwischen Grundbesitzern im Zusammenhang mit Entfremdung Land provoziert. Diese Konflikte haben ein Potenzial von gefährden ländlichen Setup und der landwirtschaftlichen Produktion des Landes. Das Ziel der Studie ist es, diese Konflikte Ansatz, den Schwerpunkt auf die Notwendigkeit des institutionellen Wandels für die Nutzung von landwirtschaftlichen degradierten Flächen und mögliche Governance-Struktur für Land Umwandlung in Pakistan. Die Organe der Sustainability Framework von Hagedorn et al (2002) wird verwendet werden, und einige politische Empfehlungen gehen abgeleitet werden.
Article
Against the backdrop of climate change, population increase and changing economic and social structures, this article analyzes dynamic interactions between Maasai pastoralists and settled agricultural communities in River Njoro Watershed, Kenya. Here, policy changes led to transition of land ownership from communal to private ownership, creating a new institutional environment and abetting modification of institutions governing sharing of resources. Primary data used in the study were collected from settled farmers and pastoralists. Changing property rights from communal to individual holdings have forced communities to modify their indigenous communal institutional arrangements and renegotiate gender roles to cope with the changing property rights. As a result, women’s workload has increased and their traditional control of resources has slipped; hence, they have sought new alternatives to meet traditional obligations. Therefore, they have negotiated new identities within family and community institutions. Men, on the other hand, are gaining from the private property rights regime.
ResearchGate has not been able to resolve any references for this publication.