Objective
To investigate if muscle energy technique (MET) to the thoracic spine decreases the pain and disability associated with shoulder impingement syndrome (SIS).
Design
Single centre, three-arm, randomised controlled trial, single-blind, placebo control with concealed allocation and a 12-month follow-up.
Setting
Private osteopathic practice.
Interventions
Participants were randomly allocated to: MET to the thoracic spine (MET-only), MET plus soft tissue massage (MET&STM) or placebo.
Participants
3 groups of 25 (n=75) participants ≥ 40 years with SIS received allocated intervention once a week for 15 minutes, 4 consecutive weeks.
Outcome measures
Primary outcome measure: Disabilities of the Arm, Shoulder and Hand (DASH) questionnaire. Secondary outcome measures: Shoulder Pain and Disability Index (SPADI) questionnaire, visual analogue scale (VAS-mm/100) –current, 7-day average, 4-week average, patient specific functional scale (PSFS) and global rating of change (GROC). Measures recorded at baseline, discharge, 4-weeks follow-up, 6-months and 12-months. Also baseline and discharge thoracic posture and range of motion (ROM) measured using an inclinometer.
Statistical Analysis
Mixed effects linear regression model for DASH, SPADI, VAS, PSFS, GROC and thoracic posture and ROM.
Results
MET-only group demonstrated significantly greater improvement in pain and disability (DASH, SPADI, VAS 7-day average) compared to placebo at discharge (mean difference DASH=-8.4; 95% CI -14.0,-2.8; SPADI=-14.7;-23.0,-6.3; VAS=-15.5;-24.5,-6.5), 6 -months (-11.1;-18.6,-3.7; -14.9;-26.3,-3.5; -14.1;-26.0,-2.2) and 12 -months (-13.4;-23.9,-2.9; -19.0;-32.4,-5.7; -17.3;-30.9,-3.8). MET&STM group also demonstrated greater improvement in disability, but not pain compared to placebo at discharge (DASH=-8.2;-14.0,-2.3; SPADI= -13.5;-22.3,-4.8) and 6 months (-9.0;-16.9,-1.2; -12.4;-24.3,-0.5). For the PSFS, MET-only improved compared to placebo at discharge (1.3;0.1,2.5) and 12 months (1.8;0.5,3.2); MET&STM at 12 months (1.7;0.3,3.0). GROC: MET-only improved compared to placebo at discharge (1.5;0.9,2.2) and 4 weeks (1.0;0.1,1.9); MET&STM at discharge (1.2;0.5,1.9) and 6 months (1.2;0.1,1.3). There were no differences between MET-only and MET&STM, and no between-group differences in thoracic posture or ROM.
Conclusion
MET of the thoracic spine with or without STM improved the pain and disability in individuals over 40 with SIS and may be recommended as a treatment approach for SIS.