ArticlePDF Available

A 36-Hospital Time and Motion Study: How Do Medical-Surgical Nurses Spend Their Time?

Authors:
  • More then Reality LLC

Abstract and Figures

Context: Nurses are the primary hospital caregivers. Increasing the efficiency and effectiveness of nursing care is essential to hospital function and the delivery of safe patient care.Objective: We undertook a time and motion study to document how nurses spend their time. The goal was to identify drivers of inefficiency in nursing work processes and nursing unit design.Design: Nurses from 36 medical-surgical units were invited to participate in research protocols designed to assess how nurses spend their time, nurse location and movement, and nurse physiologic response.Main Outcome Measures: Nurses' time was divided into categories of activities (nursing practice, unit-related functions, nonclinical activities, and waste) and locations (patient room, nurse station, on-unit, off-unit). Total distance traveled and energy expenditure were assessed. Distance traveled was evaluated across types of unit design.Results: A total of 767 nurses participated. More than three-quarters of all reported time was devoted to nursing practice. Three subcategories accounted for most of nursing practice time: documentation (35.3%; 147.5 minutes), medication administration (17.2%; 72 minutes), and care coordination (20.6%; 86 minutes). Patient care activities accounted for 19.3% (81 minutes) of nursing practice time, and only 7.2% (31 minutes) of nursing practice time was considered to be used for patient assessment and reading of vital signs.Conclusion: The time and motion study identified three main targets for improving the efficiency of nursing care: documentation, medication administration, and care coordination. Changes in technology, work processes, and unit organization and design may allow for substantial improvements in the use of nurses' time and the safe delivery of care.
Content may be subject to copyright.
A preview of the PDF is not available
... Dealing with OFs is time-consuming for nurses and represents wasted resources for patients and hospitals: Between 10% (Gurses & Carayon, 2009;Hendrich et al., 2008;Tucker & Spear, 2006) and 12% (Tucker, Heisler, & Janisse, 2014) of nurses' time during a work shift is directed toward overcoming OFs. Direct observation of nurses' 8-hour shift work showed that a failure was experienced every 37 minutes, and overcoming each of these failures delayed care by an average of 5.5 minutes (Tucker et al., 2014). ...
... OFs and the effort and time required to overcome them create inefficiency and take valuable time away from patient care. OFs consume 10% of nurses' time (Hendrich et al., 2008;Tucker, 2004). More nursing time per patient results in better patient outcomes (Needleman et al., 2011), and OFs require an average of 5.5 min to overcome (Tucker et al., 2013). ...
Article
Full-text available
Note: Additional authors are listed on the last page. Abstract: Frontline nurses encounter operational failures (OFs), or breakdowns in system processes, that hinder care, erode quality, and threaten patient safety. Previous research has relied on external observers to identify OFs; nurses have been passive participants in the identification of system failures that impede their ability to deliver safe and effective care. To better understand frontline nurses' direct experiences with OFs in hospitals, we conducted a multi-site study within a national research network to describe the rate and categories of OFs detected by nurses as they provided direct patient care. Data were collected by 774 nurses working in 67 adult and pediatric medical-surgical units in 23 hospitals. Nurses systematically recorded data about OFs encountered during 10 work shifts over a 20-day period. In total, nurses reported 27,298 OFs over 4,497 shifts, a rate of 6.07 OFs per shift. The highest rate of failures occurred in the category of Equip-ment/Supplies, and the lowest rate occurred in the category of Physical Unit/Lay-out. No differences in OF rate were detected based on hospital size, teaching status, or unit type. Given the scale of this study, we conclude that OFs are frequent and varied across system processes, and that organizations may readily obtain crucial information about OFs from frontline nurses. Nurses' detection of OFs could provide organizations with rich, real-time information about system operations to improve organizational reliability. ß
... 39 According to a study by Hendrich et al, nurses were involved in patient care, documentation, medicine delivery, coordination, patient assessment, and vital sign reading. 40 which had remarkably comparable results to those of our investigation. Susan Hassmiller listed nine issues that need to be resolved by both individual nurses and the nursing profession. ...
Article
Full-text available
Background: Nurses are important health caregivers in Bangladesh. They help to improve health-facilities every day and reach it to helpless people. This study aimed to assess the responsibilities of professional nurses in public health hospitals. Methods: The descriptive cross-sectional study conducted at Rajshahi Medical College (RMCH), Bangladesh from 18 September 2018 to 19 February 2019 included 300 individuals with following inclusion and exclusion criteria. A pre-tested questionnaire was used as a tool for data collection. Results: Majority of participants age range of 31-40y 46.33%, 41-50y 27%, 20-30y, and 51-60y 19% and 7.67%, respectively. Moreover, Female are 96.33% and males constitute only 7.74%. Based on religion, Muslim 87%, Hindu 10%, Christian 1.67%, and Buddhist 1.33%. Beginning of education, diploma was compared to very few with advanced training for instance Master's and Ph.D. 38.67% nurses were 1-5 years of experience. But only 11 had ≥21 years of experience. A significant portion, 48.02%, had a good level of assessment of patients and 36.67% of individuals excelled at a high level of proficiency. While only 2% showed an inferior level of patient assessment. Improvement of quality care, the majority of respondents 48.33% good, 17.67% excellent, 21.67% average, and 3.33% poor quality care. Conclusions: Nurses are the key element of the healthcare system. The study outcomes showing their best to provide quality service despite of lack of resources. If the responsible authority has a deep look at this domain, in the future they could make a role model in Bangladesh.
... While specific tasks, such as medication administration, are authorized only for RNs to perform, responsibilities are typically divided as follows: RNs are responsible for specific nursing care, documentation, and care planning, while LVNs primarily manage basic nursing care, hygiene, and food and drink provision. Care related services (CRS) can play a role in care units, as research indicates that both RNs and LVNs perform tasks that can be delegated to individuals with specific service competencies but who do not necessarily have healthcare expertise [10][11][12]. ...
Article
Full-text available
Background The growing concern about a dwindling healthcare workforce, exacerbated by demographic changes, calls for innovative solutions. One viable approach involves implementing new professional roles and restructuring existing healthcare teams within hospital care units. Objectives To evaluate the implementation of an innovative task-shifting concept, care-related services (CRS), from the managers’ perspective in somatic care units across the hospitals in a region in Sweden. Methods The qualitative study was conducted in 2022, after the implementation of CRS. Individual interviews were conducted with 24 key stakeholders, including 14 care unit managers, six CRS managers, and four process managers. A qualitative content analysis was performed, utilizing the Consolidated Framework of Implementation Research (CFIR). Results The implementation of CRS involved collaboration between care unit managers, CRS managers, and project managers, alongside CRS staff, registered nurses (RNs), and licensed vocational nurses (LVNs). In particular, their roles encompassed defining boundaries, establishing routines, and managing personnel. Throughout the implementation process, challenges emerged, stemming from undefined goals, difficulties in recruiting qualified CRS staff, and issues associated with seamlessly integrating CRS into existing work routines. These challenges arose due to a constrained timeframe, widespread team apprehension, shortcomings in the training of CRS staff, unclear task allocation, and an increased workload for care unit managers. Factors associated with successful CRS implementation included effective cooperation among managers and an open-minded approach. Conclusions Our findings highlight the crucial role of clear communication, effective recruitment, integration of CRS staff, clarification of roles, responsibilities, and defined goals for successful CRS implementation.
... The motion study technique seeks out to make processes more efficient by reducing the involved motions (6). The time and motion study techniques, which improve working conditions and offer benefits to improve productivity, are implemented successfully in various industrial and service institutions including healthcare institutions (2,(7)(8)(9). Application of these techniques in healthcare institutions adds efficiency and quality to service delivery (2,9,10). Reducing errors in healthcare and removing non-value adding activities in processes depend on using these techniques (11). ...
Article
Full-text available
Objective: This study aimed to determine the standard time required for the performed job and to examine the standard job critically for productivity improvement in the pathology laboratory. Material and methods: In this study that was conducted at a tertiary teaching hospital, observation, fishbone diagram, and flow charts were used to collect the information about the job process. All employees were observed from September 2017 to June 2018. The observations were recorded by video camera in order to overcome the Hawthorne effect. Nine basic procedure steps were followed for productivity improvement. Results: Within the scope of the study, the jobs of "trimming tissue blocks" and "sectioning of tissue blocks" was selected. The standard time required was 0.19 minutes for "trimming tissue blocks" and 0.34 minutes for "sectioning of tissue blocks". The procedure steps, named "Removal of tissue block" and "Fixing the block to the device", were removed from the flow chart to define the improved method. The implementation of the improved method brought in a gain of 11.28 work days per year. Conclusion: It is obvious that the pathology laboratory needs to take certain measures to improve working conditions and increase efficiency. Our results demonstrate applying the study techniques could reduce the workload and processing time. This study also shows that the study techniques can be applied in the hospital laboratory. Incorporation of all pathology technicians in the change or innovation process will be important in maintaining the achievements.
... In our study, with prolonged use of the solution, clinicians reported a 6.7% increase in their belief that the solution increased their work productivity. Evidence shows that equipping frontline clinicians with technology that increases their efficiency [19], improves data accuracy and reduces errors [4,19], improves practice capacity, and elevates the quality of wound care [4,46,47], which linearly progresses along with overall users' satisfaction with the adopted technology [31,47]. ...
... In a time and motion study of medical/ surgical nurses, it was observed that documentation took 33% of the nurses' time, whereas only 19.3% of time was spent in patient care. 30 Our survey found that there were many areas in the clinical and nonclinical realms in which responding neonatal RDNs were interested in spending more time (see Fig. 4). This increased involvement would likely require a substantial readjustment of daily workload or additional staffing hours to be feasible. ...
Article
Neonatal registered dietitian nutritionists (RDNs) are critical members of the neonatal intensive care unit (NICU) team due to their unique skillset of growth assessment, nutrition evaluation, and implementation of nutrition best practices. There is a paucity of data on appropriate staffing of neonatal RDNs in NICUs to promote improved patient outcomes. Here, the authors describe current neonatal RDN staffing and responsibilities in the US NICUs.
Article
Full-text available
The worldwide nursing shortage has led to the exploration of using robotics to support care delivery and reduce nurses’ workload. In this observational, mixed-method study, we examined the implementation of a robotic nurse assistant (RNA) in a hospital ward to support vital signs measurements, medication, and item delivery. Human–robot interaction was assessed in four domains: usability, social acceptance, user experience, and its societal impact. Patients in a general medicine ward were recruited to participate in a one-time trial with the RNA and a post-trial 75-question survey. Patients’ interactions with the RNA were video recorded for analysis including patients’ behaviours, facial emotions, and visual attention. Focus group discussions with nurses elicited their perceptions of working with the RNA, areas for improvement, and scalability. Sixty-seven patients aged 21–79 participated in the trial. Eight in 10 patients reported positive interactions with the RNA. When the RNA did not perform to expectations, only 25% of patients attributed fault to the RNA. Video analysis showed patients at ease interacting with the RNA despite some technical problems. Nurses saw potential for the RNA taking over routine tasks. However, they were sceptical of real time savings and were concerned with the RNA’s ability to work well with older patients. Patients and nurses suggested greater interactivity between RNA and patients. Future studies should examine potential timesaving and whether time saved translated to nurses performing higher value clinical tasks. The utility of improved RNA’s social capability in a hospital setting should be explored as well.
Article
Objective This report describes a root cause analysis of incorrect provider assignments and a standardized workflow developed to improve the clarity and accuracy of provider assignments. Materials and Methods A multidisciplinary working group involving housestaff was assembled. Key drivers were identified using value stream mapping and fishbone analysis. A report was developed to allow for the analysis of correct provider assignments. A standardized workflow was created and piloted with a single service line. Pre- and post-pilot surveys were administered to nursing staff and participating housestaff on the unit. Results Four key drivers were identified. A standardized workflow was created with an exclusive treatment team role in Epic held by a single provider at any given time, with a corresponding patient list column displaying provider information for each patient. Pre- and post-survey responses report decreased confusion, decreased provider identification errors, and increased user satisfaction among RNs and residents with sustained uptake over time. Conclusion This work demonstrates structured root cause analysis, notably engaging housestaff, to develop a standardized workflow for an understudied and growing problem. The development of tools and strategies to address the widespread burdens resulting from clinical communication failures is needed.
Article
Objective This study aimed to investigate the effect of spatial adjacencies on nurses’ walking patterns and the subsequent impact on staff satisfaction with perceived accessibility and adjacency-related issues. Background Recognizing the crucial importance of spatial adjacencies in healthcare facilities is essential, as they significantly affect staff morale, fatigue management, operational efficiency, error reduction, and overall patient care excellence, highlighting the need for objective assessments to evaluate the impact of facility layout and space configuration on workflow patterns and staff satisfaction in patient care units. Methods Integrating on-site observations with survey data, we explored how spatial adjacencies affect staff walking behavior and satisfaction in two med-surgical unit floors. Results The findings highlighted a significant frequency of movements between nurse stations, patient rooms, and medication areas. Regression analysis identified several contributing factors to staff satisfaction, including the proximity of supplies, team visibility, ease of access across departments, and the location of equipment rooms. Specifically, satisfaction with the proximity of supplies was positively associated with increased provider satisfaction with workflow, quality of care, and workplace. Additionally, valuable feedback from staff revealed concerns regarding break room placement, medication area functionality, and disparities in the availability of supplies. Conclusion This study highlighted the critical need for carefully planned spatial adjacency strategies to enhance workflow efficiency and raise clinical staff satisfaction within healthcare facilities. The actionable insights gleaned from this research offer valuable direction to architects, healthcare administrators, and design professionals, enabling the creation of environments that positively resonate with healthcare providers and improve healthcare operations.
Article
Full-text available
This article explores the role of financial incentives in the implementation of patient-centric care from a nursing perspective. Recognizing the pivotal influence nurses wield in shaping patient experiences, the study investigates how financial motivators impact the adoption of patient-centric practices. The article employs a mixed-methods approach to analyze the effectiveness of financial incentives, shedding light on both quantitative outcomes and qualitative insights from nursing professionals. The findings Contribute To The Ongoing Discourse On Optimizing Patient-Centric Care Strategies Within healthcare settings.
Article
Full-text available
Objectives: To survey operating theatre and intensive care unit staff about attitudes concerning error, stress, and teamwork and to compare these attitudes with those of airline cockpit crew. Design: Cross sectional surveys. Setting: Urban teaching and non-teaching hospitals in the United States, Israel, Germany, Switzerland, and Italy. Major airlines around the world. Participants: 1033 doctors, nurses, fellows, and residents working in operating theatres and intensive care units and over 30 000 cockpit crew members (captains, first officers, and second officers). Main outcome measures: Perceptions of error, stress, and teamwork. Results: Pilots were least likely to deny the effects of fatigue on performance (26% v 70% of consultant surgeons and 47% of consultant anaesthetists). Most pilots (97%) and intensive care staff (94%) rejected steep hierarchies (in which senior team members are not open to input from junior members), but only 55% of consultant surgeons rejected such hierarchies. High levels of teamwork with consultant surgeons were reported by 73% of surgical residents, 64% of consultant surgeons, 39% of anaesthesia consultants, 28% of surgical nurses, 25% of anaesthetic nurses, and 10% of anaesthetic residents. Only a third of staff reported that errors are handled appropriately at their hospital. A third of intensive care staff did not acknowledge that they make errors. Over half of intensive care staff reported that they find it difficult to discuss mistakes. Conclusions: Medical staff reported that error is important but difficult to discuss and not handled well in their hospital. Barriers to discussing error are more important since medical staff seem to deny the effect of stress and fatigue on performance. Further problems include differing perceptions of teamwork among team members and reluctance of senior theatre staff to accept input from junior members.
Article
Full-text available
To survey operating theatre and intensive care unit staff about attitudes concerning error, stress, and teamwork and to compare these attitudes with those of airline cockpit crew. : Cross sectional surveys. : Urban teaching and non-teaching hospitals in the United States, Israel, Germany, Switzerland, and Italy. Major airlines around the world. : 1033 doctors, nurses, fellows, and residents working in operating theatres and intensive care units and over 30 000 cockpit crew members (captains, first officers, and second officers). : Perceptions of error, stress, and teamwork. : Pilots were least likely to deny the effects of fatigue on performance (26% v 70% of consultant surgeons and 47% of consultant anaesthetists). Most pilots (97%) and intensive care staff (94%) rejected steep hierarchies (in which senior team members are not open to input from junior members), but only 55% of consultant surgeons rejected such hierarchies. High levels of teamwork with consultant surgeons were reported by 73% of surgical residents, 64% of consultant surgeons, 39% of anaesthesia consultants, 28% of surgical nurses, 25% of anaesthetic nurses, and 10% of anaesthetic residents. Only a third of staff reported that errors are handled appropriately at their hospital. A third of intensive care staff did not acknowledge that they make errors. Over half of intensive care staff reported that they find it difficult to discuss mistakes. Medical staff reported that error is important but difficult to discuss and not handled well in their hospital. Barriers to discussing error are more important since medical staff seem to deny the effect of stress and fatigue on performance. Further problems include differing perceptions of teamwork among team members and reluctance of senior theatre staff to accept input from junior members.
Article
Full-text available
The organizational context in which nurses practice is important in explaining variation in patient outcomes, but research has been hampered by the absence of instruments to measure organizational attributes empirically. To report on the development and utility of the Revised Nursing Work Index (NWI-R) in measuring characteristics of professional nursing practice environments. The NWI-R was used in a national acquired immunodeficiency syndrome (AIDS) care study. The sample consisted of 40 units in 20 hospitals. Of these 20 hospitals, 10 provided AIDS care in both dedicated AIDS units and general medical units, thus introducing to the design an element of internal control. The remaining 10 hospitals were selected through a matching procedure. Three of the matched control hospitals were magnet hospitals. Nurses were recruited into the study if they worked at least 16 hours per week on the study unit. The nurses completed the NWI-R in addition to other measures. A response rate of 86% was attained. Response rates per unit ranged from 73% to 100%. Cronbach's alpha was 0.96 for the entire NWI-R, with aggregated subscale alphas of 0.84 to 0.91. Validity of the NWI-R was demonstrated by the origin of the instrument, its ability to differentiate nurses who worked within a professional practice environment from those who did not, and its ability to explain differences in nurse burnout. The NWI-R has been found to capture organizational attributes that characterize professional nursing practice environments.
Article
Operational failures in healthcare can hinder employees, potentially decreasing both productivity and quality of care. At the same time, regulatory agencies, industry experts, and consumers increasingly demand that health care organizations learn from prior failures to prevent recurrence. Building on the notion that learning from operational failures requires an accurate understanding of their nature, this paper reports on an in-depth study of operational failures encountered by hospital nurses. Data analysis suggests that in this context (1) most operational failures stem from breakdowns in the supply of materials and information across organizational boundaries and (2) employees quickly compensate for most failures. We propose that these two conditions—lack of control of processes that create failures and the ease with which employees restore functioning—make it difficult for organizations to recognize these incidents as learning opportunities, and if they do, to capitalize on the opportunity. This has an important implication for efforts to generate organizational learning and improvement from employees’ experiences with failures. Highly interdependent front-line workers do not control organizational processes responsible for the majority of failures they encounter and have a difficult task convincing powerful associates that these obstacles warrant solution efforts, making it likely operational failures will persist.
Article
Nurses spend an average of only 31% of their time with patients. The authors determined how nurses spend their time and suggest three ways to reduce time spent on non-essential nursing functions: delegation of some tasks to support personnel, greater use of pharmacy personnel in a decentralized setting, and greater use of computers. Together these changes may both decrease demand for nurses' time and enable professional nurses to focus their energy on tasks that require professional expertise.
Article
The objective of this study is to investigate whether hospitals known to be good places to practice nursing have lower Medicare mortality than hospitals that are otherwise similar with respect to a variety of non-nursing organizational characteristics. Research to date on determinants of hospital mortality has not focused on the organization of nursing. We capitalize on the existence of a set of studies of 39 hospitals that, for reasons other than patient outcomes, have been singled out as hospitals known for good nursing care. We match these "magnet" hospitals with 195 control hospitals, selected from all nonmagnet U.S. hospitals with over 100 Medicare discharges, using a multivariate matched sampling procedure that controls for hospital characteristics. Medicare mortality rates of magnet versus control hospitals are compared using variance components models, which pool information on the five matches per magnet hospital, and adjust for differences in patient composition as measured by predicted mortality. The magnet hospitals' observed mortality rates are 7.7% lower (9 fewer deaths per 1,000 Medicare discharges) than the matched control hospitals (P = .011). After adjusting for differences in predicted mortality, the magnet hospitals have a 4.6% lower mortality rate (P = .026 [95% confidence interval 0.9 to 9.4 fewer deaths per 1,000]). The same factors that lead hospitals to be identified as effective from the standpoint of the organization of nursing care are associated with lower mortality among Medicare patients.
Article
We all know the changes in our health care system have been substantial and far-reaching. But what effects are downsizing, restructuring, and the use of unlicensed personnel having on the quality of patient care you deliver and on your work life? More than 7,000 survey respondents gave us their answers.