ABSTRACT
Background:
Thyroid diseases affect more women than men around the world. These pathologies constitute the second most common endocrinopathies, after diabetes mellitus. These diseases have universal distribution characteristics, with remarkable expression variation according across continents, races, countries, and within the same country depending on the iodine content distribution. In females, the physiological phenomena of puberty, pregnancy and postpartum period increase bodily iodine demand. These acute shifts in iodine requirement partly explain the greater frequency with which thyroid diseases develop in women (especially in the context of deficiency or excessive intake of iodine). In addition to the above-mentioned physiological shifts, racial, genetic and other environmental factors are recognized in many types of thyroid diseases. The impact of pregnancy on the thyroid gland is highly remarkable; hence, it is largely blamed for the occurrence of goiter and thyroid nodules (TN) especially against an iodinedeficient background. Thyroid disorders during pregnancy constitute a huge risk for the mother and pregnancy, as well as for the somatic and psychomotor development of the embryo/fetus and/or the infant. A further challenge is faced by clinicians in the presence of somatic or, behavioral changes (easily suggestive of psychic or psycho-affective disorders), as well as biochemical and immunological deviations that occur during pregnancy; these deviations often distort the clinical picture and delay the diagnosis and timely management of thyroid disorders.
In addition to biochemical tests, morphological tests are of great importance in the diagnosis and follow-up of subjects with thyroid pathologies. Thyroid ultrasound (TUS) is the main
morphological examination recommended in pregnant women because of its safety. It does not use ionizing radiation (as do radio-isotopic or radiological tests); it is widespread and very accessible to people. It is non-invasive and generally does not require prior preparation before its completion, and the cost is relatively affordable. Chinese women differ from their Congolese counterparts in terms of parity. This difference in obstetric history between the two populations is due to the variations in individual national birth control policies of the two countries. While a Chinese woman is limited to two children, their counterparts in the Democratic Republic of the Congo (DRC) have no limit to the number of children; hence, desire, health and wealth are the ruling considerations. We therefore found it useful to compare TUS results in the two
populations; Chinese pregnant women and Congolese (DRC). Our cohort of two intercontinental groups not only offers racial and genetic predispositions disparities, but also highlights both environmental and birth policy (parity) variations and effects.
Objective:
This study first aimed to compare ultrasonographic features of goiter and thyroid nodules between the two populations (Chinese and Congolese pregnant women), and second to deduce a possible association between obstetric and environmental factors acting in synergy with race or genetic predispositions on the occurrence of goiter and thyroid nodules.
Design and methods:
A retrospective comparative study was performed for a cohort of ninety-two (92) pregnant women composed of 51 Chinese and 41 Congolese, who consulted for thyroid disorders at the Department of Endocrinology of Shandong Provincial Qianfoshan Hospital in the People Republic of China (PRC) and the University Clinics of Kinshasa in the D.R. Congo between February 2016 and July 2017. Thyroid ultrasound was performed using a 7.5-9 MHz frequency linear-array transducer with a Doppler device. We evaluated the thyroid ultrasonographic characteristics of the thyroid gland (especially those with goiter and nodules) as well as thyroid hormone levels. Ellipse formula [(height x width x thickness) x π/6] was used to calculate the volumes of thyroid lobes and those of TN. Thyroid gland appearance and TN characteristics (number (one nodule or multiple), echogenicity, internal contents, nodular vascularity, calcification, margin characteristics, and the maximum diameter of the single or dominant thyroid nodule) were recorded.
Results
The mean cohort age overall was 31.9±5.0 (22-48) years (30.7±4.4 (range 22-40) and 33.6±5.3 (range 23-48) among the Chinese and Congolese women, respectively (P>0.05)). Congolese women had more parity than Chinese. The mean thyroid volume was 12.9±1.1 and 68.2±7.7 mL for the Chinese and the Congolese women, respectively (P=0.000). Thirty-five of the 41 (85.4%) Congolese pregnant women had goiter, while only eight out of 51 (15.7%) Chinese had goiter.
An influence of race and geographic location in the development of goiter was noted in this study; Congolese women were found to be 5.8 times more likely to develop a goiter than were Chinese women (odds ratio (OR)=5.8, P<0.001). However, parity seemed to be the main risk factor of goiter for women overall; the prevalence of goiter was higher among women having at least three births in the past (OR=8.3, P<0.001 vs nulliparous). Most goiters (62.5%) in the Chinese group were on the basis of Hashimoto’s thyroiditis (HT), while 88.6% of them were nodular in the Congolese group. The prevalence of TN was 10 times higher among Congolese women than among Chinese (OR=10.1, P<0.001) and correlated with parity in the two study populations (three times higher among women with at least three births in the past (OR=3.3, P<0.001 vs nulliparous)). Multiple thyroid nodules (MTN) were associated with parity among Congolese women (OR=4.5, P=0.04). The mean maximal diameter (32.8±3 mm vs 7.2±1 mm, P=0.001) and mean volume (29.1±4 mL vs 0.2±0.1 mL, P=0.003) of single/dominant nodules were greater among Congolese than among Chinese women. The Chinese group exhibited more cystic nodules (47.1%), while their comparative group had more mixed cystic-solid types (37.1%). Notably, the thyroid parenchyma was especially hypoechoic and heterogeneous on grayscale ultrasound, with hypervascularization on Doppler among Chinese pregnant women; while their counterparts in the Congolese group were similarly heterogeneous, the thyroids were nodular with normal vascularization and very minimal intraparenchymal calcification.
Conclusion:
Ultrasonography detected a higher prevalence of goiter and thyroid nodules in the Congolese than in the Chinese pregnant women. Our results showed that parity played a substantial role in the occurrence of these diseases, possibly varying according to regions (or environments).
Possible interaction between many factors (such as parity and iodine deficiency) with genetic predispositions (possibly) could have a paramount role in the nodular phenotypic expression of thyroid nodules. Our data suggest that optimal iodine consumption and a good birth control policy (especially in the D.R. Congo) could play an essential role in reducing the prevalence of thyroid disorders among women.
Keywords: Thyroid ultrasound; Aspects of goiter and thyroid nodules; Nodular phenotypic expression; Chinese and Congolese pregnant women; Birth control policy and parity.