Content uploaded by Satoshi Kakishima
Author content
All content in this area was uploaded by Satoshi Kakishima on Aug 14, 2016
Content may be subject to copyright.
Chemical Identity of a Rotting Animal-Like Odor Emitted
from the Inflorescence of the Titan Arum (Amorphophallus titanum)
Mika SHIRASU,1Kouki FUJIOKA,2Satoshi KAKISHIMA,3Shunji NAGAI,4Yasuko TOMIZAWA,5
Hirokazu TSUKAYA,6Jin MURATA,3Yoshinobu MANOME,2and Kazushige TOUHARA1;y
1Department of Applied Biological Chemistry, Graduate School of Agricultural and Life Sciences,
The University of Tokyo, Tokyo 113-8657, Japan
2Department of Molecular Cell Biology, Institute of DNA Medicine, Jikei University School of Medicine,
Tokyo 105-8461, Japan
3Botanical Gardens, Graduate School of Science, The University of Tokyo, Tokyo 112-0001, Japan
4National Cancer Center, Hospital East, Chiba 277-8577, Japan
5Department of Cardiovascular Surgery, Tokyo Women’s Medical University, Tokyo 162-8666, Japan
6Department of Biological Science, Graduate School of Science, The University of Tokyo, Tokyo 113-0033, Japan
Received September 28, 2010; Accepted November 3, 2010; Online Publication, December 7, 2010
[doi:10.1271/bbb.100692]
The titan arum, Amorphophallus titanum, is a flower-
ing plant with the largest inflorescence in the world. The
flower emits a unique rotting animal-like odor that
attracts insects for pollination. To determine the chemi-
cal identity of this characteristic odor, we performed gas
chromatography-mass spectrometry-olfactometry anal-
ysis of volatiles derived from the inflorescence. The
main odorant causing the smell during the flower-
opening phase was identified as dimethyl trisulfide, a
compound with a sulfury odor that has been found to be
emitted from some vegetables, microorganisms, and
cancerous wounds.
Key words: Amorphophallus titanum; odor; gas chroma-
tography-mass spectrometry; olfactometry;
dimethyl trisulfide
The genus Amorphophallus is well known for the
characteristic odor of its inflorescence.
1)
Among the
species of the genus Amorphophallus,Amorphophallus
titanum (Becc.) Becc. ex Arcangeli is famous for the
large size of the inflorescence (Fig. 1A) and for emitting
a rotting animal-like odor.
2,3)
This odor probably attracts
pollinators such as carrion beetles and flies.
1)
Previous
studies using gas chromatography-mass spectrometry
(GC-MS) have identified several odorants, including
dimethyl oligosulfides, that are emitted from A. tita-
num,
1)
but it is not certain whether these odorants reflect
the odor of the flower as humans experienced it. In
addition, due to the rarity of flowering events, detailed
study of this species was limited until recently. In the
Botanical Gardens of The University of Tokyo, on July
22, 2010, we had an opportunity to analyze the smell of
the inflorescence of an A. titanum plant. The GC-MS-
olfactometry (GC-MS-O) technique allowed us to
analyze emitted odorous compounds that contribute to
the rotting animal-like smell during the flowering
period.
First we evaluated the intensity and quality of the
odors emitted from the inflorescence of A. titanum
during flowering by human nose (Fig. 2A). At the
beginning of flowering, a faint rotten fruit-like odor was
detected occasionally. Then the odor emitted from the
flower gradually intensified. During full opening of the
spathe, a strong rotting animal-like odor was emitted
constantly. In addition, infrared radiation from the
surface of the inflorescence was measured with a
thermograph (Neothermo TVS-600; Avionics Japan,
Tokyo), as described elsewhere.
4,5)
The odor became
stronger with heat production from the spadix, as
previously reported (Fig. 2B and C).
3,6)
After the peak
of the spadix temperature, the inflorescence began to
secrete a fluid from the spadix in which a rotten fish-like
odor was sensed.
Next we collected volatile compounds emitted from
the A. titanum. The volatiles derived from the inflor-
escence were absorbed directly to Carboxen/PDMS
(Carboxen/Polydimethylsiloxane) SPME (solid phase
micro extraction) fibers (SUPELCO, Bellefonte, PA)
that had been placed inside of the inflorescence from
21:00 to 23:00 on July 22 (Figs. 1B(a) and 2A). The
compounds on the SPME fibers were then analyzed by
GC-MS-O which enabled us to examine the mass spectra
and odor qualities of individual GC-separated odorants
simultaneously. Shimadzu GCMS-QP2010 (Shimadzu,
Kyoto) (a stabilwax column of 60 m 0.32 mm i.d.
with a film thickness of 0.5 mm) was combined with a
sniffing port equipped with a Sniffer9000 system
(Brechbuhler, Houston, TX) in splitless mode (MS and
sniffing port at ratio of 1:4.7). The column temperature
was programmed to rise at 5 C/min from 50 C (2-min
hold) to 230 C (30-min hold) (total run time, 68 min).
The interface temperature was maintained at 200 C and
the ion source temperature at 230 C. Mass spectra were
obtained in full scan mode (range 20–400) by electron
impact using the NIST library database.
yTo whom correspondence should be addressed. Fax: +81-3-5841-8024; E-mail: ktouhara@mail.ecc.u-tokyo.ac.jp
Abbreviations: GC-MS, gas chromatography-mass spectrometry; GC-MS-O, GC-MS-olfactometry; TIC, total ion chromatogram; RT, retention
time; DMTS, dimethyl trisulfide; DMDS, dimethyl disulfide
Biosci. Biotechnol. Biochem.,74 (12), 2550–2554, 2010
Communication
Figure 3A shows total ion chromatograms (TIC) of a
SPME-absorbed sample collected by the method shown
in Fig. 1B(a). The odor characters sensed at the sniffing
port are described under the chart. GC-MS-O analysis
and evaluation of odors were performed by three
persons. The sensory characters of the odor-positive
peaks and the identified odorants are summarized in
Fig. 3D. The characteristic rotting animal-like surfury
odor, which was identical to the odor we sensed in the
inflorescence during the opening of the spathe, came
out at a retention time (RT) of 18.79 min. The mass
spectrum of the peak predicted the structure of dimethyl
trisulfide (DMTS) (Fig. 3C). The mass spectrum and the
retention time of authentic DMTS (Wako, Tokyo) were
identical to those of the peak compound, confirming
that the sulfury odor at RT ¼18:79 min was DMTS
(Fig. 3C).
In addition, the gaseous odor (RT ¼9:06 min) was
identified as methyl thiolacetate, and the cheesy, foot-
like valerian odor (RT ¼25:93 min) was identified as
isovaleric acid (Fig. 3A). The green odor at RT ¼16:19
could not be identified due to low concentration or to
overlapping peaks in the TIC. Dimethyl disulfide
(DMDS), which has been reported to be a major odorant
emitted from A. titanum, was also detected abundantly
at RT ¼9:80 min, but we could not sense the odor by
GC-MS-O analysis due to a high threshold,
7,8)
suggest-
ing that the contribution of DMDS to human olfactory
perception is not significant. The presence of a large
amount of DMDS, however, is plausible, because
DMDS is thought to be a precursor of DMTS which is
biosynthesized from methionine or S-methyl-L-cysteine
sulfoxide via methanethiol, which was also detected by
GC-MS (Fig. 3A).
9,10)
Considering that GC-MS-O anal-
ysis directly identifies crucial volatiles that contribute to
the quality of the smell that humans sense, these results
suggest that the main odorous component of A. titanum
is DMTS. GC-MS-O analysis of another flowering
A. titanum cultivated in a greenhouse at Flower Park
Kagoshima gave the same results (flower opening on
August 2, 2010) (data not shown).
At the end of the flower-opening phase, the odor
quality of the inflorescence changed gradually following
secretion of the odorous fluid from the spadix. The fluid
secreted from the spadix was collected from 1:00 to 3:00
on July 23, and head-space volatile compounds from a
10 ml sample enclosed in a 40 ml glass vial were absorbed
to SPME fibers for 7 h (Fig. 1B(b)). GC-MS-O analysis
of the SPME sample showed a strong rotten fish-like
odor similar to the odor we sensed at the end of the
flower-opening phase at RT ¼3:33 min, and this was
identified as trimethylamine (Fig. 3B, inset). Green,
burnt odor (RT ¼6:13 min) was identified as 3-methyl
butanal, and a vinegary odor (RT ¼20:47 min) as acetic
acid (Fig. 3B).
Time Event Odor quality
14:00 Opening of the spathe Slight rotten fruit-like odor
16:00
18:00
Yellow pickled radish
Spathe full opened Rotting animal-like odor
20:00
22:00 Spadix warming phase
0:00
Fluid exuded from the spadix
2:00
Rotten fish, Rotten egg
4:00
6:00
8:00 Closing of the spathe
Strong rotting animal-like odor
Rotten egg
daytime
nighttime
daytime
28oC35oC
19:47
0:47
ABC
18:00
22:00
2:00
6:00
-2
0
2
4
6
28
30
32
34
36
Spadix temperature (oC)
16:00
20:00
0:00
4:00
8:00
Spadix temp - ambient temp (oC)
July 22
July 23
Fig. 2. Scheme of the Flowering Behavior, Odor Quality and Thermogenesis of A. titanum.
(A) Flowering events and characteristic odors of A. titanum. The darkness of the gray indicates the intensity of the rotting animal-like odor.
(B) Time course record of spadix temperature (black line). Difference between the spadix and the ambient temperature (red line).
(C) Representative thermographic images (top, taken at 19:47 on July 22, 2010; bottom, taken at 0:47 on July 23, 2010). Scale bar, 20 cm.
Spadix
Spathe
AB
Fluid
Gas
SPME
SPME
(a)
(b)
Spadix
Spathe
Fig. 1. Odor Sampling from a Flower of Amorphophallus titanum.
(A) Full opening of the spathe of an A. titanum with a height of
1.6 m in the Koishikawa Botanical Gardens in July 2010. Scale bar,
20 cm. (B) Methods of collecting volatiles emitted from A. titanum.
(a) Volatile compounds from the inflorescence were directly
absorbed to SPME fibers placed between the spadix and the spathe.
(b) A fluid secreted onto the spadix was collected, and the head-
space volatiles from the fluid were absorbed to SPME fibers. Scale
bar, 20 cm.
Odor from a Flower of the Titan Arum 2551
Finally, we attempted to evaluate flower odor objec-
tively by using an electronic nose, FF-2A (Shimadzu,
Kyoto).
11,12)
The device contains electronic sensors with
various sensitivities and selectivities for volatile com-
pounds, and is standardized with nine gases (hydrogen
sulfide, methylmercaptan, ammonia, trimethylamine,
propionic acid, butylaldehyde, butylacetate, toluene,
and heptane), the odor quality of which can be
categorized into nine groups (hydrogen sulfide, sulfur,
ammonia, amine, organic acid, aldehyde, ester, aromatic
group and carbon hydrate). The flower smell was
collected directly into a 2 L tedlar bag (SUPELCO,
Bellefonte, PA) with a sampling pump (GL Sciences) at
21:00 on July 23. The collected air was diluted 5-fold
with odorless nitrogen gas and injected into the FF-2A.
Various concentrations of DMTS and DMDS were also
applied to the device. The virtual odor index in terms of
the nine aromatic categories is plotted in Fig. 4. For the
sample of A. titanum, the sulfur category was identified
as the highest odor index, and organic acid, aldehyde,
amine, and ester categories constituted lower index
categories (Fig. 4A). In a series of diluted DMTS, the
chart pattern of 0.01 ppm DMTS was similar to that of
the A. titanum sample (Fig. 4), which was fairly
consistent with the approximate concentration of DMTS
emitted as calculated at the basis of the GC-MS analysis
(data not shown). The chart pattern of DMDS was also
similar to that of the A. titanum sample, but the overall
odor intensity was weaker than that of DMTS (see
Fig. 4B and E). These results again confirm that DMTS
is the major contributor to the flower smell for human
olfactory sensation.
In conclusion, simultaneous evaluation of odor qual-
ity and the molecular masses of volatiles by GC-MS-O
enabled us to identify DMTS as the main odorant that
causes the rotting animal-like odor of A. titanum during
CD
126
15 32
45
64
79
111
100
80
60
40
20
0
20 40 60 80 100 120
m/z
Intensity (%)
126
32
45
64
79
111
100
80
60
40
20
0
20 40 60 80 100 120
m/z
Intensity (%)
2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20 22 24 26 28 30
0.0×10 -00
1.0×10 07
2.0×10 07
Time (min)
Intensity
Green
Sulfury
Valerian
Gaseous
A
S O SSS
O
OH
Gas-SPME
RT=18.8 min
Authentic DMTS
B
2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20 22 24 26 28 30
0.0×10 -00
1.0×10 07
2.0×10 07
Time (min)
Intensity
Rotten fish
Acidity
Sulfury
Green, burnt
O
OH
O
N
Fluid-SPME
Gas Fluid
3.33 Rotten fish Trimethylamine - ++
6.13 Green, burnt 3-Methyl-butanal - +
9.06 Gaseous Methyl thiolacetate + -
16.19 Green + -
18.79 Surfury Dimethyl trisulfide ++ +
20.47 Acidity Acetic acid - +
25.93 Valerian, cheese, feet Isovaleric acid + -
RT Odor character Odorant Odor intensity
2 3 4 5
0
5.0×10 06
1.0×10 07
1.5×10 07
TIC
2 3 4
0
5.0×10 06
1.0×10 07
1.5×10 07
5
TIC
m/z
EI
C
EI
C
SCH3H
SS
Fig. 3. GC-MS-O Analysis of SPME-Absorbed Head-Space Volatiles Emitted from A. titanum.
(A) Total ion chromatogram of volatile compounds absorbed to SPME fibers by the method described in Fig. 1B(a). Characteristics of odors
sensed at the sniffing port of GC-MS-O are described at the bottom of the chart. (B) Total ion chromatogram of head-space volatiles emitted from
the fluid of spadix, as described in Fig. 1B(b). Inset in (A) and (B) is the close-up TIC from 2 min to 5 min. The light gray and dark gray lines
indicate extracted ion chromatograms of the molecular ion peaks of trimethylamine (m=z59) and methanethiol respectively (m=z48)
respectively. (C) Mass spectrum of the peak at 18.8 min of TIC in Fig. 3A (top). Mass spectrum of authentic DMTS (bottom). (D) Retention
times (RTs), odor characters, and chemical identities of odor-positive peaks by GC-MS-O analysis. The intensities of the odors at the odor-
positive peaks in Fig. 3A (odor intensity, Gas) and 3B (odor intensity, Fluid) are categorized into three groups: not detected (), slight (þ),
strong (þþ).
2552 M. SHIRASU et al.
the opening of the spathe. Trimethylamine was found to
be the odorant that caused the rotten-fish odor at the end
of flowering. We also identified several other com-
pounds contributing to the odor of the inflorescence,
including methyl thiolacetate, 3-methyl butanal, acetic
acid, and isovaleric acid.
DMTS has been reported to be present in volatiles
emitted from vegetables such as cooked onion and
cabbage, decayed meats, and fermented food and drink,
which usually cause fly attraction.
13,14)
Indeed, oligo-
sulphides emitted from the flower of dead-horse arum
(Helicodiceros muscivorus) have been reported to be
attractants for flies,
15)
suggesting that A. titanum also
fools flies into pollinating it by mimicking the odors of
fermented products and rotting animal bodies. On the
other hand, an interesting coincidence is that DMTS is
known to be the main source of the malodor of fungating
cancer wounds in human.
16)
Indeed, the odor index
pattern of the head-space volatiles of a gauze pad placed
on a breast cancer wound was very similar to that of
A. titanum on electronic nose FF-2A (Fig. 4G). It is an
intriguing question how mechanisms of producing
DMTS have been acquired in various organisms as a
signal for various purposes during the process of
evolution.
Acknowledgment
We are grateful to Tadashi Yamaguchi (Botanical
Gardens, Graduate School of Science, the University of
Tokyo) for the photograph of A. titanum in Fig. 1A.
This research was approved by the Research Ethics
Committee of the University of Tokyo. It was supported
in part by grants from the Ministry of Education,
Culture, Sports, Science, and Technology (MEXT) of
Japan.
References
1) Kite GC and Hetterschield LA, Phytochemistry,46, 71–75
(1997).
2) Barthlott W, Szarzynski J, Vlek P, Lobin W, and Korotkova
NA, Plant Biol.,11, 499–505 (2009).
acid
Hydrogen
sulfide
Sulfur
Ammonia
Amine
OrganicAldehyde
Ester
Aromatic
group
Carbon
hydrate
0
101
102
103
A A.titanum
B 0.001 ppm DMTS
Hydrogen
sulfide
Sulfur
Ammonia
Amine
Aldehyde
Ester
Aromatic
group
Carbon
hydrate
0
101
102
103
acid
Organic
C 0.01 ppm DMTS
Hydrogen
sulfide
Sulfur
Ammonia
Amine
Aldehyde
Ester
Aromatic
group
Carbon
hydrate
0
101
102
103
acid
Organic
D 0.1 ppm DMTS
Hydrogen
sulfide
Sulfur
Ammonia
Amine
Aldehyde
Ester
Aromatic
group
Carbon
hydrate
0
101
102
103
acid
Organic
E 0.001 ppm DMDS
Hydrogen
sulfide
Sulfur
Ammonia
Amine
Aldehyde
Ester
Aromatic
group
Carbon
hydrate
0
101
102
103
acid
Organic
F 0.01 ppm DMDS
Hydrogen
sulfide
Sulfur
Ammonia
Amine
Aldehyde
Ester
Aromatic
group
Carbon
hydrate
0
101
102
103
acid
Organic
G Breast cancer
Hydrogen
sulfide
Sulfur
Ammonia
Amine
Aldehyde
Ester
Aromatic
group
Carbon
hydrate
0
101
102
103
acid
Organic
Fig. 4. Odor Index Chart of Volatiles from A. titanum and Various Concentrations of DMTS in Nine Standard Gases Categories as Determined by
Means of an Electronic Nose Device.
Charts depicting odor index values of A. titanum (A), 0.001 ppm DMTS (B), 0.01 ppm DMTS (C), 0.1ppm DMTS (D), 0.001 ppm DMDS (E),
0.01 ppm DMDS (F), and breast cancer wounds (G) (n¼3, shown by different colors). Odor indexes 10, 102, and 103mean that most humans
can detect odors at 10-, 100-, and 1,000-fold dilution respectively.
Odor from a Flower of the Titan Arum 2553
3) Korotkova N and Barthlott W, Plant Signal. Behav.,4, 1096–
1098 (2009).
4) Tsukaya H, Fujikawa K, and Wu SG, J. Plant. Res.,115, 263–
268 (2002).
5) Kakishima S, Terajima Y, Murata J, and Tsukaya H, Plant Biol.,
in press.
6) Lamprecht I and Seymour RS, J. Therm. Anal. Cal.,102, 127–
136 (2010).
7) Martin N, Neelz V, and Spinnler HE, Food Qual. Pref.,15,
247–257 (2004).
8) Vazquez-Landaverde PA, Torres JA, and Qian MC, J. Dairy
Sci.,89, 2919–2927 (2006).
9) Schmidt A, Rennenberg H, Wilson LG, and Filner P, Phyto-
chemistry,24, 1181–1185 (1985).
10) Chin HW and Lindsay RC, J. Agric. Food Chem.,42, 1529–
1536 (1994).
11) Fujioka K, Arakawa E, Kita J, Aoyama Y, Okuda T, Manome
Y, and Yamamoto K, PLoS One,4, e7939 (2009).
12) Kita J, Aoyama Y, Kinoshita M, Akamaru H, and Okada M,
Shimadzu Rev. (in Japanese), 64, 63–73 (2007).
13) Berger C, Khan JA, Molimard P, Martin N, and Spinnler HE,
Appl. Environ. Microbiol.,65, 5510–5514 (1999).
14) Isogai A, Kanda R, Hiraga Y, Nishimura T, Iwata H, and
Goto-Yamamoto N, J. Agric. Food Chem.,57, 189–195 (2009).
15) Stensmyr MC, Urru I, Collu I, Celander M, Hansson BS, and
Angioy AM, Nature,420, 625–626 (2002).
16) Shirasu M, Nagai S, Hayashi R, Ochiai A, and Touhara K,
Biosci. Biotechnol. Biochem.,73, 2117–2120 (2009).
2554 M. SHIRASU et al.