ArticlePDF Available

Abstract and Figures

Swimming is a recommended activity to achieve good health and to prevent certain pathologies of the circulatory, pulmonary and locomotive systems. However, recent research has focused on the possible hazard of chlorinated swimming pools. Chlorine reacts with organic compounds found in the water, giving way to the formation of disinfection by-products (DBPs). DBPs enter the human body by water ingestion, inhalation and dermal absorption. The most important DBPs are trihalomethanes, like chloroform, and chloramines, mainly trichloramine. Acute problems by accidental exposure to chlorine and its DBPs were reported years ago but their chronic effects have only been known since the beginning of the 21st century. Recent studies connect swimming in chlorinated pools with the prevalence of panting, asthma and hay fever. Besides, several DBPs are volatile and can be inhaled, not only by swimmers but also by those near the swimming pool. Although there are other environmental factors that could contribute to the increase of respiratory disorders, some authors have given rise to the so-called „chlorine hypothesis” which postulates that the increase in asthma in developed countries can be explained, in part, by the effects of DBPs present in chlorinated swimming pools. In order to constrain their potential negative effects, it is necessary (a) to control the amount of chemical agents used in swimming pools, (b) not to raise water temperature excessively, (c) to maintain effective ventilation and (d) to have strict hygiene rules for swimmers. However, the best way to avoid these problems would be using alternative disinfection systems.
Content may be subject to copyright.
A preview of the PDF is not available
... Swimming has been recommended to improve health and the quality of life (Zarzoso, Llana, & Pérez-Soriano, 2010). It is well known that swimming provides plenty of benefits for the health and it is currently recommended not only as a means to treat common back pain, circulatory problems, but it is also considered as the most appropriate activity for asthmatic children (Chowdhury, Alhooshani, & Karanfil, 2014). ...
... It is well known that swimming provides plenty of benefits for the health and it is currently recommended not only as a means to treat common back pain, circulatory problems, but it is also considered as the most appropriate activity for asthmatic children (Chowdhury, Alhooshani, & Karanfil, 2014). However, many studies have been warning in the last 10 years that the chemical products used for water disinfection in swimming pools, especially the chlorine derivatives, could lead to a number of health problems (Florentin, Hautemanière, & Hartemann, 2011;Zarzoso et al., 2010). ...
... DBPs are generated through the reaction of chlorine with organic and inorganic matter in water (Florentin et al., 2011;Kanan & Karanfil, 2011;Lee et al., 2010). Thus, DBPs can remain in water or can be volatilized to the swimming pool atmosphere, and swimmers are therefore exposed to these products mainly by ingestion, inhalation, and dermal absorption (Zarzoso et al., 2010). In this sense, previous studies have associated the DBPs exposition with pathologies in the eyes and skin (Fantuzzi et al., 2010(Fantuzzi et al., , 2012Fernández-Luna, Burillo, Felipe, Gallardo, & Tamaral, 2013;Parrat et al., 2012), in the ear canal (Wang, Liu, Shiao, & Wang, 2005), in the respiratory system (Fantuzzi et al., 2010;Fernández-Luna, Burillo, et al., 2013), and with potential mutagenic effects Richardson et al., 2010). ...
... To ensure the health of swimmers, chlorine-based disinfectants are used to effectively reduce the risk of bacterial and viral infection in swimming pool facilities. However, when chlorine reacts with organic compounds in the pool water (e.g., sweat, urine, soap residues, cosmetics, suntan oil, dirt, and other solid waste material), several volatile chemical compounds are produced in the form of trihalomethanes, chloramines, and haloacetic acids [56]. In turn, exposure to these chemical compounds can occur in swimmers via three direct avenues: (a) ingestion of pool water, (b) inhalation of airborne chlorine and chlorine analogs in the air space located immediately above the pool surface, and (c) direct skin contact with the pool water [57]. ...
... Encourage swimming pool maintenance staff to stay current on the latest information regarding the efficacy of potential substitute disinfectant methods such as electro-physical systems (electrolytic copper and electrolytic silver), ozone disinfection, and ultraviolet disinfection [56]. ...
Article
Full-text available
Swimming is one of the most popular sports worldwide. Competitive swimming is one of the most watched sports during the Olympic Games. Swimming has unique medical challenges as a result of a variety of environmental and chemical exposures. Musculoskeletal overuse injuries, overtraining, respiratory problems, and dermatologic conditions are among the most common problems swimmers encounter. Although not unique to swimming, overtraining is a serious condition which can have significant negative impact on swimmers' health and performance. This review article is an attempt to discuss various issues that a medical team should consider when caring for swimmers.
... Both free and combined chlorine determine the antiseptic properties of the disinfectant. Since free and combined chlorine can occur simultaneously, determining the form of residual chlorine is very important for the course and effect of water disinfection and for the organoleptic and health properties of the water [48][49][50]. The minimum concentration of free chlorine in outdoor sports-type pools should be 0.3 mg·Cl 2 /L, and in recreational-type pools and those equipped with hydromassage facilities it should be 0.7 mg·-Cl 2 /L. ...
Article
Full-text available
Like all public utility, swimming pools had been treated with special procedures during the COVID-19 pandemic. In addition to the basic rules (social distance + hand disinfection + masks), applicable to all citizens, the managers of swimming pools were obliged to reduce the number of swimmers and to increase the effects of water treatment. Monitoring, control and rapid response to unfavourable changes in the quality of swimming pool water are the basis for minimizing the risk of disease transmission or exposure of bathers to pathogens. The main purpose of this work is to analyse and compare the quality of swimming pool water in a municipal outdoor swimming pool complex, before (2018-2019) and during the COVID-19 pandemic (2020-2021). Water samples taken from a paddling pool for children (CP), a recreational pool (RP), and a sports pool (SP) were analysed. The results of the research, based on real case studies, were compared with the documents on water quality in swimming pools in force at the time. An analysis was carried out to determine the relationships between swimming pool water quality before and during the COVID-19 pandemic. The tested parameters determining the quality of water were physico-chemical parameters (temperature, pH, redox, turbidity, nitrates, chemical oxygen demand, free chlorine, chloramines and trihalomethane THM) and bacteriological parameters (colony forming units CFU of Pseudomonas aeruginosa, Escherichia coli, Legionella sp.). Based on the results of the analysis of the parameters mentioned-above, the validation of the procedures applied during the COVID-19 hazard and their impact on the quality of swimming pool water were evaluated. The results of the pool water quality tests were discussed with particular emphasis on disinfection by-products (THM and combined chlorine). Detailed analysis showed better water quality in the first year of the pandemic (2020) compared to 2018-2019 (before COVID-19) and 2021 (the second year of COVID-19 pandemic). The following parameters were found to be significantly different: THM (before 0.069 mg/L and during 0.034 mg/L), free chlorine (before 0.86 mg/L and during 0.66 mg/L), and redox potential (before 667 and during 713 mV).
... Another grave problem with the recreational water is the use of chlorine which is the most commonly used chemical for disinfecting swimming pools [36]. There are studies that prove that chlorine chemical treatment provokes transformations in the permeability of lung epithelium via the skin and the eyes [37][38][39]. Therefore, it is imperative that chlorine should not exceed the prescribed limits. ...
Article
Full-text available
Otitis is an ear inflammation characterized by an accumulation of polluted fluids in the ear, inflating the drum, causing ear pain, and draining the mucous membrane (pus) into the ear canal if the drum is perforated. Swimmer’s otitis, also known as acute external otitis, is a medical condition that frequently affects competitive swimmers. The risk factor analysis study was based on data obtained between May 2018 and May 2019 from four public swimming pools in Patras, Achaia. A checklist was created to evaluate the pools’ operational conditions, and it included information on the pools’ sanitation as well as swimming pool hygiene guidelines. In addition, a questionnaire was devised to collect data on pool swimmers’ use of the pools. Microbiological testing of the pool water was done ahead of time, and data on external otitis cases from hospitals was gathered. Based on this information, a risk factor analysis was conducted. Gender, weight, and age do not appear to have an impact on the number of otitis media cases that occur because of swimming in the pools. There is also no statistically significant link between episodes and the frequency of otitis events in locker rooms, restrooms, or swimming pools. The frequency with which swimmers utilize the pool, rather than the pool’s microbial burden, is the most significant determinant in otitis episodes. Furthermore, there is no statistically significant link between chlorine odor and otitis episodes. Additionally, several abnormalities in the ear or the child’s history do not appear to affect otitis episodes. More research is needed to determine whether infections are linked to microbial load or if other factors are responsible for the emergence of waterborne infections.
... The most frequently used disinfection method is chlorination, which removes pathogens with chlorine or its derivatives, but the free chlorine reacts with organic matter (e.g. urine, saliva, and sweat) and forms a mixture of potentially harmful disinfectant by-products, including chloramines (Who, 2006;Zarzoso, Llana, & Pérez-Soriano, 2010). Chloramines contain the inorganic compounds monochloramine (NH 2 Cl), dichloramine (NHCl2) and trichloramine (NCl3). ...
Article
Full-text available
LANGUAGE NOTE | Document text in English; abstract also in Chinese. There is growing interest in the potentially harmful effects in swimming pools, and the potential for swimming-related health hazards, which is gaining importance in competitive swimmers. This review was focused to discuss the following topics: (1) prevalence of respiratory difficulties in swimmers; (2) the possible factors and mechanisms which lead to the development of airway disorders in elite swimmers; (3) diet and nutrient supplementation for the management and prevention of airway problems. Summaries were concluded in this review according to the current knowledge of the respiratory problems in swimmers: (1) a high prevalence of respiratory symptoms and respiratory diseases in the elite swimmer population; (2) the potentially harmful effects in airway epithelial damage and lung permeability may caused by exposure in cold air, chlorinated products in swimming pools, and high intensity training in swimmers. (3) Observational studies have reported associations between airway symptoms and nutritional intervention (i.e. polyunsaturated fatty acid, dietary antioxidants, and vitamin D), which may have application for promoting health and sports performance for swimmers. 運動選手(如游泳選手)發生呼吸系統疾病問題逐漸受到重視,本篇綜評旨在討論下列課題:(1)選手發生呼吸道疾病之發生率;(2)發生呼吸疾病之可能原因及機轉;(3)飲食與營養補充對減低呼吸疾病症狀之探討。統整相關文獻後,獲以下結語:(1)游泳選手發生呼吸道疾病之情形高於其他運動者(如:冬季運動項目、短跑與長跑等);(2)長期處於含氯物質及其氯產物環境,對吸呼道黏膜及肺組織將有所傷,而冷空氣環境及高強度訓練模式,亦是增加游泳選手發生呼吸道不適症狀的影響因素;(3)多元不飽和脂肪酸、抗氧化物質及維生素D等營養素,在減低呼吸疾病臨床研究上證實有改善效益,對於呼吸道疾病發生率較高的游泳選手而言,應是不錯的飲食及營養補充介入不錯的選擇。
... Moreover, the reaction of FRC with organic compounds in foods and drinks during their preparation promotes formation of disinfection byproducts such as trihalomethanes (THMs) (Ghanbari et al. 1983, Fukayama et al. 1986, Tan et al. 1987, Kastl et al. 2003, Huang 2005, Hua et al. 2015, Li and Mitch 2018. The toxic effects of high concentrations of chlorine and its byproducts (DBPs) on the respiratory system are documented (Kohlhammer and Heinrich 2007, Zarzoso et al. 2010, Angione et al. 2011, Kucharski 2018), but effects of low concentrations of these compounds have not yet been fully determined (Kucharski 2018). When FRC is ingested, its disinfection effect is unimportant and could be considered as an additive (Moshtaghie et al. 1996, Huang andBatterman 2009). ...
Article
While chlorination is critical for water disinfection, a knowledge gap includes the nature of free residual chlorine (FRC) decay, which was investigated using four physical methods (SSA, SSR with and without a lid, heating, and incubator shaker). Keeping water samples in SSA and SSR methods for 24 h resulted in the FRC decline by 62% and 51%, respectively. The heterotrophic plate count (HPC) increased significantly between initial (3.17 ± 2.6–3.82 ± 1.1 CFU/mL) and final samples (6.7 ± 1.5–94.7 ± 4.72 CFU/mL) for both SSA and SSR methods. Thermodynamic behavior (ΔH versus ΔG) of FRC decay of the different methods was characterized.
... Najczęściej stosowanym środkiem dezynfekcyjnym, zabezpieczającym przed wtórnym zanieczyszczeniem wody basenowej jest chlor. Reaguje on jednak z materią organiczną wprowadzaną przez osoby kąpiące się, tworząc w wodzie basenowej uboczne produkty dezynfekcji (UPD), będące z kolei zagrożeniem i dla nich, i dla personelu obiektu basenowego [7][8][9]. Według obecnego stanu wiedzy można zidentyfikować około 600 różnych UPD [10,11]. Jednak w dokumentach regulujących jakość wody basenowej, dopuszczalne stężenia określone zostały tylko dla chloru związanego (chloramin), sumy trihalometanów (THM) i chloroformu [4,12,13]. ...
Article
Full-text available
Wpływ chlorowania szokowego na zawartość chloramin w wodzie basenu rehabilitacyjnego Impact of shock chlorination on the chloramine content in the rehabilitation pool water JOANNA WYCZARSKA-KOKOT, KLAUDIUSZ GRÜBEL Zawartość chloramin w wodzie basenowej, ze względu na ich niekorzystny wpływ na zdrowie osób korzystają-cych z kąpieli oraz personelu obiektów basenowych, obligatoryjnie kontrolowana jest raz dziennie w próbkach wody basenowej. Stężenie chloramin (chloru związanego), bez względu na funkcję basenu, nie powinno być większe niż 0,3 mgCl 2 /dm 3. Zaleca się jednak utrzymywanie jak najmniejszego stężenia chloramin, a w base-nach o szczególnym przeznaczeniu, m.in. w basenach rehabilitacyjnych, zaleca się by nie przekraczało 0,2 mgCl 2 /dm 3. Pomimo dostępności wielu środków i nowoczesnych metod dezynfekcji wody, problem dużych stężeń chloramin w wodach basenowych jest ciągle aktualny. Głównym celem przeprowadzonych badań była analiza wpływu sekwencyjnie zastosowanego chlorowania szokowego na zawartość chloramin w wodzie basenu rehabilitacyjnego. Na podstawie analiz fizyczno-chemicznych i bakteriologicznych próbek wody z niecki baseno-wej oceniono jakość wody po każdorazowo zastosowanym chlorowaniu szokowym. Stwierdzono krótkotrwałe, kil-kugodzinne obniżenie stężenia chloramin do wartości poniżej 0,2 mgCl 2 /dm 3. Dodatkowa analiza wpływu poten-cjału redox na zawartość chloramin pozwoliła stwierdzić, że wartości redox powyżej 750 mV również wpływały na zmniejszenie zawartości chloramin. Słowa kluczowe: woda basenowa, chlorowanie szokowe, chloraminy. The content of chloramines in swimming pool water, due to their negative impact on the health of swimmers and the staff of pool facilities, is obligatorily inspected once a day in pool water samples. The concentration of chloramines (combined chlorine), regardless of the function of the pool, should not be higher than 0.3 mgCl 2 /dm 3. However, it is recommended to keep chloramines as low as possible, and in pools for special purposes, including in rehabilitation pools, it is recommended not to exceed 0.2 mgCl 2 /dm 3. Despite the availability of various disinfectants and modern methods of water disinfection, the problem of high concentrations of chloramines in pool waters is still relevant. The main purpose of the research was to analyze the impact of sequentially applied shock chlorination on the chloramine content in the water of the rehabilitation pool. Analyzing physically, chemically and bacteriologically pool water samples the quality of water was assessed after each shock chlorination. There was a short-lasting reduction of the chloramine concentration to the value below 0.2 mgCl 2 /dm 3 for several hours. An additional analysis of the impact of redox potential on the chloramines content showed that redox values above 750 mV also reduced chloramines.
... The indicator of the DBP content in swimming pool water is combined chlorine [4,[14][15][16]. These two parameters (the content of free and combined chlorine) are the basic parameters of swimming pool water quality, determining the level of health-safe bathing [1,[17][18][19][20]. To ensure the health safety of swimmers, it is necessary to achieve a very good level of mixing water in a pool basin with treated water supplied with disinfectants. ...
Article
Full-text available
The analysis of free chlorine concentrations in swimming pool water makes it possible to assess the antiseptic effect of the disinfectant. The concentration of combined chlorine determines the comfort of swimming and indicates if there is a threat from DBP (disinfection by-products). The distribution of free and combined chlorine concentration was analyzed in four basins differing in seasonality of use and in the applied water flow systems. After considering the distribution of free and combined chlorine content in characteristic points of pools, an attempt was made to determine the most reliable point for assessing the quality of water and its suitability for swimming. Such searches should aim to identify the places with the worst water quality. The most uniform distribution of the concentrations of both free and combined chlorine was observed at the middle point of swimming pools, while at points near the corners and walls of swimming pools a varied distribution was observed. Such a control strategy, based on the least favorable test results at a point considered as characteristic, would make it possible to verify the parameters of the swimming pool water treatment system and thus minimize the risk to swimmers’ health.
... The most frequently used disinfection method is chlorination, which removes pathogens with chlorine or its derivatives, but the free chlorine reacts with organic matter (e.g. urine, saliva, and sweat) and forms a mixture of potentially harmful disinfectant by-products, including chloramines (Who, 2006;Zarzoso, Llana, & Pérez-Soriano, 2010). Chloramines contain the inorganic compounds monochloramine (NH 2 Cl), dichloramine (NHCl2) and trichloramine (NCl3). ...
Article
Full-text available
Dry eye syndrome is one of the eye health risks frequently suffered by swimmers who swim without goggles. It is initiated by direct contact of eyes with irritants from the disinfection process in the swimming pool. The purpose of this study was to analyze risk differences of using goggles for dry eye syndrome in the Sub Laboratory FIO Surabaya State University (Unesa). This research was an observational with cross sectional study design. The results of statistical tests showed that there were significant differences between swimmers using goggles and without goggles (p = 0,000). An examination of water found that the level of residual chlorine was (<1 mg / l), pH (<7), and alkalinity (> 200 mg / l). It calls the needs for strengthen the precaution for the presence of chemical risks. The result showed that the parameters did not satisfy the requirements of Permenkes RI No. 32 of 2017 about Standard for Environmental Quality and Water Health Requirements for Sanitary Hygiene Needs, Swimming Pools, Solus Per Aqua, and Public Baths. It can be concluded that there are differences in the risk of dry eye syndrome between swimmers who used goggles and without goggles. Swimmers is recommended to wear goggles while swimming to avoid the risk of dry eye syndrome. Furthermore, managers need to monitoring pool water quality in to order comply with term and reduce the risk of dry eye syndrome.
Article
Full-text available
18 different swimming pool waters in the Bonn-Rhein-Sieg area were analysed for trihalogenmethanes, halogenated acetic acids, 2,2-dichloropropionic acid, dihalogenacetonitriles and chloral hydrate. Most substances mentioned above were determined in almost every sample reaching total concentrations up to 538 micrograms/l. Considering the results one can see that some of the main pollutants are polar organic compounds like di- and trichloroacetic acid as well as chloral hydrate.
Article
Full-text available
Specific sampling and analytical methods were developed to assess the concentration of chloramines in the atmosphere of indoor swimming pools because swimming instructors had complained of irritation (mainly eye and lung). The sampling method is based upon the reduction of chloramines to chlorides which are then analysed by ion chromatography. The chloramine concentration in the atmosphere of 13 swimming pools (including five recreational centres and one reeducation centre) was measured, showing that the concentrations were higher in the recreational centres. The influence of slides, bubbling baths, waves and other activities were demonstrated. A correlation was made between the level of pollutants and the complaints registered, leading to the proposal of a ‘comfort’ limit value.
Article
Disinfection is mandatory for swimming pools because transmission of disease by bacteria, virus and protozoa is the most significant health issue. However another issue arises, and care should be taken to minimise the risks from disinfection by-products (DBPs). Public pools are usually disinfected by gaseous chlorine of sodium hypochlorite; home pools typically use 'stabilised chlorine'. The use of chlorine produces a variety of disinfection byproducts (DBPs), such as trihalomethanes (THMs), which have been detected in the blood and breath of swimmers and of nonswimmers at indoo pools. Also produced are halogenated acetic acids (HAAs) and haloketones, which irritate the eyes, skin, and mucous membranes; trichloramine, which is linked with swimming pool-associated asthma; and halogenated derivatives of UV sun screens, some of which show endocrine effects. Precursors of DBPs include human body substances, chemicals used in cosmetics and sun screens, and natural organic matter. A 1.6- 2.0-fold increased risk for bladder cancer has been associated with swimming or showering/bathing with chlorinated water. Bladder cancer risk from THM exposure (all routes combined) was greatest among those with the GSTT1-1 gene. DBPs may be reduced by engineering and behavioural means, such as applying new oxidation and filtration methods, reducing bromide and iodide in the source water, increasing air circulation in indoor pools and assuring the cleanliness of swimmers. The positive health effects gained by swimming can be increased by reducing all potential adverse health risks.
Article
Dichloroacetic acid (DCAA) and trichloroacetic acid (TCAA) are major nonvolatile disinfection by-products of water chlorination. These compounds are currently being considered for regulation because of potential adverse health effects. In the current study, DCAA and TCAA dermal exposures were investigated in four human subjects during a thirty minute walk or swim in a pool by measuring the pool water concentrations and urinary excretion rates of DCAA and TCAA. These two compounds were eliminated in urine within approximately 3 hours of the exposure, with the dermal DCAA dose being ~6 μg from pool water containing 600 μg/L. The amount of water ingested by each subject during a 30 minute swim was estimated to be between 12 and 45 mL. The DCAA permeability coefficient at pH 7 was calculated to be between 1 and 8 x 10-3 cm/h, when assuming that only 3% of the dermal dose, as was observed for ingestion, was excreted and between 2 and 9 x 10-5 cm/h, assuming that 48% of the dermal dose, an upper limit, was excreted. Exposure estimates indicate that ingestion is the major route of exposure and that the dermal contribution during typical household uses is a minor contributor to the total exposure of these compounds from chlorinated drinking water.
Article
Haloforms in drinking water created by chlorination recently generated a tumult in the US, and EPA is still exploring their possible consequences. These chlorinated products have raised concern in Europe as well, as signified by this article, which explains possible mechanisms of haloform formation and conceivable ploys for minimizing its existence.
Article
Chlorination of both drinking waters and wastewaters leads to the generation of various chlorinated degradation products of natural fulvic acids. Fulvic acids constitute the bulk of the organic matter in colored surface or ground waters. Meta dihydroxybenzene structures are proposed as main reactive sites of the molecule. Experimental evidence is presented for possible reaction pathways leading to haloforms and other chlorinated by-products.
Article
A survey of the “chlorination practice” of swimming-pool waters is presented taking the case of covered pools in Bremen. Chlorination of water may result in specific health hazards by various halogenated chemicals. Trihalomethanes (THMs), among others, are determined in water and air samples. We succeeded in identifying one organic “precursor” of the synthesis of THMs in swimming pools. An estimate of the average and maximum burden of the user/swimmer is given. Short and long range alternative measures are proposed to diminish the health hazards. We conclude from this work that the application of chlorine for disinfection should be minimized.