Dimensional, Categorical, or Dimensional-Categories: Testing the Latent Structure of Anxiety Sensitivity Among Adults Using Factor-Mixture Modeling

ArticleinBehavior therapy 41(4):515-29 · December 2010with 154 Reads
DOI: 10.1016/j.beth.2010.02.003 · Source: PubMed
Abstract
The present study tested multiple, competing latent structural models of anxiety sensitivity (AS), as measured by the Anxiety Sensitivity Index-3 (ASI-3; Taylor et al., 2007). Data were collected from 3 sites in North America (N=634). Participants were predominantly university students (M=21.3 years, SD=5.4). ASI-3 data were evaluated using an integration of mixture modeling and confirmatory factor analysis-factor mixture modeling (FMM; Muthén, 2008). Results supported a 2-class 3-factor partially invariant model of AS. Specifically, the FMM analyses indicated that AS is a taxonic (two-class) variable, and that each categorical class has a unique multidimensional factor structure. Consistent with the specific point-prediction regarding the hypothesized parameters of the putative latent class variable, FMM indicated that the putatively "high-risk" subgroup of cases or latent form of AS composed approximately 12% of the studied sample whereas the putatively "normative" subgroup of cases or latent form of AS composed 88% of the sample. In addition, the AS Physical and Psychological Concerns subscales, but not the Social Concerns subscale, most strongly discriminated between the two latent classes. Finally, comparison of continuous levels of AS Physical and Psychological Concerns between FMM-derived AS latent classes and independent clinical samples of patients with anxiety disorders provided empirical support for the theorized taxonic-dimensional model of AS and anxiety psychopathology vulnerability. Findings are discussed in regard to the implications of this and related research into the nature of AS and anxiety psychopathology vulnerability.

Do you want to read the rest of this article?

Request full-text
Request Full-text Paper PDF
  • Article
    Anxiety sensitivity, defined as the fear of anxiety and arousal-related sensations, has been among the most influential cognitive-based transdiagnostic risk and maintenance factors in the study and treatment of emotional and related disorders. The currently available anxiety sensitivity measures are limited by their length. Specifically, the length of these instruments discourages the adoption of routine anxiety sensitivity assessment in clinical or medical settings (e.g., primary care). The goals of this study were to develop and assess the validity and reliability of a short version of the Anxiety Sensitivity Index-3 (ASI-3; Taylor et al., 2007), entitled the Short Scale Anxiety Sensitivity Index (SSASI), using three independent clinical samples. Results indicated that the abbreviated five-item version of the SSASI had good internal consistency and a robust association with the ASI-3. Further, across the samples, there was evidence of unidimensionality and excellent convergent and discriminant validity. There also was evidence of partial measurement invariance across sex and full measurement invariance across time. Overall, the five-item scale offers a single score that can be employed to measure anxiety sensitivity. Use of the SSASI may facilitate screening efforts and symptom tracking for anxiety sensitivity, particularly within clinical settings where practical demands necessitate the use of brief assessment instruments.
  • Article
    Full-text available
    Purpose: Patient-reported outcome measures (PROMs) are frequently used in heterogeneous patient populations. PROM scores may lead to biased inferences when sources of heterogeneity (e.g., gender, ethnicity, and social factors) are ignored. Latent variable mixture models (LVMMs) can be used to examine measurement invariance (MI) when sources of heterogeneity in the population are not known a priori. The goal of this article is to discuss the use of LVMMs to identify invariant items within the context of test construction. Methods: The Draper-Lindely-de Finetti (DLD) framework for the measurement of latent variables provides a theoretical context for the use of LVMMs to identify the most invariant items in test construction. In an expository analysis using 39 items measuring daily activities, LVMMs were conducted to compare 1- and 2-class item response theory models (IRT). If the 2-class model had better fit, item-level logistic regression differential item functioning (DIF) analyses were conducted to identify items that were not invariant. These items were removed and LVMMs and DIF testing repeated until all remaining items showed MI. Results: The 39 items had an essentially unidimensional measurement structure. However, a 1-class IRT model resulted in many statistically significant bivariate residuals, indicating suboptimal fit due to remaining local dependence. A 2-class LVMM had better fit. Through subsequent rounds of LVMMs and DIF testing, nine items were identified as being most invariant. Conclusions: The DLD framework and the use of LVMMs have significant potential for advancing theoretical developments and research on item selection and the development of PROMs for heterogeneous populations.
  • ... Anxiety Sensitivity Index – 3 (ASI – 3;Taylor et al., 2007) It is an 18-item scale measuring fear of anxious arousal. Past work has documented that fear of cognitive or psychological dyscontrol due to anxious arousal (e.g., " It scares me when I am unable to keep my mind on a task " ) specifically is most predictive of anxiety-related psychopathology (Olthuis et al., 2014); and taxometric and factor mixture modeling research documented that anxiety sensitivity has a latent taxonic structure – such that lower vs. higher values on measures of anxiety sensitivity reflect qualitatively distinct forms or kinds of anxiety sensitivity (adaptive versus maladaptive) rather than a dimensional latent construct (Bernstein et al., 2006Bernstein et al., , 2010Bernstein et al., , 2013Bernstein and Zvolensky, 2007;Leen-Feldner et al., 2005). In the present study we used ASI-3 sub-scale measuring the cognitive fear of dyscontrol due to anxious arousal (α = .85 in the present study). ...
    Article
    Re-examining decades of the social construal of Oxytocin, the General Approach-Avoidance Hypothesis of Oxytocin (GAAO) predicts that Oxytocin will modulate responding to emotionally-evocative and personally-relevant social and non-social stimuli due to its action on the neural substrate of approach and avoidance motivation. We report the first critical experimental test of GAAO predictions by means of a double-blind intra-nasal administration of Oxytocin vs. placebo in 90 healthy adults (N = 90, 50% women). As predicted, we found that among men and women for whom negative emotion (anxious arousal) is motivationally-relevant, intra-nasal administration of Oxytocin reduced behavioral avoidance of emotionally-evocative negatively-valenced social and non-social stimuli, but not closely matched emotionally-neutral stimuli. Findings cannot be explained by extant social theories of Oxytocin. We discuss the implications of the present findings for basic and translational clinical Oxytocin research.
  • Article
    Person-centered methods are useful for studying individual differences in terms of (dis)similarities between response profiles on multivariate outcomes. Multivariate distance matrix regression (MDMR) tests the significance of associations of response profile (dis)similarities and a set of predictors using permutation tests. This paper extends MDMR by deriving and empirically validating the asymptotic null distribution of its test statistic, and by proposing an effect size for individual outcome variables, which is shown to recover true associations. These extensions alleviate the computational burden of permutation tests currently used in MDMR and render more informative results, thus making MDMR accessible to new research domains.
  • Article
    Prior research has found that health anxiety is related to poor patient outcomes in primary care settings. Health anxiety is characterized by at least two presentations: with either severe or no/mild somatic symptoms. Preliminary data indicate that anxiety sensitivity may be important for understanding the presentation of health anxiety with severe somatic symptoms. We further examined whether the combination of health anxiety and somatic symptoms was related to anxiety sensitivity. Participants were adults presenting for treatment at a community health center (N=538). As predicted, the interactive effect between health anxiety and somatic symptoms was associated with anxiety sensitivity cognitive concerns. Health anxiety shared a stronger association with anxiety sensitivity cognitive concerns when coupled with severe, relative to mild, somatic symptoms. Contrary to predictions, the interactive effect was not associated with the other dimensions of anxiety sensitivity. We discuss the potential relevancy of anxiety sensitivity cognitive concerns to the combined presentation of health anxiety and severe somatic symptoms, as well as how this dimension of anxiety sensitivity could be treated in primary care settings.
  • ... Factor mixture modeling (FMM) evaluations of anxiety sensitivity have proposed two major models . Bernstein, Stickle, & Schmidt, (2013) and Bernstein et al. (2010) originally identified a 2 class 3 factor model for anxiety sensitivity. In this model, individuals can be divided in two classes (anxiety sensitivity taxon and anxiety sensitivity normative) with three factors within each class (physical concerns, cognitive concerns and social concerns). ...
  • Article
    Anxiety sensitivity (AS; fear of anxiety and internal sensations) has been implicated in a variety of aspects of smoking, including difficulties achieving and maintaining abstinence during tobacco cessation. However, research has yet to evaluate whether AS impacts premature termination of initiating a quit attempt. Therefore, the aim of the present investigation was to explore the extent to which AS was associated with tobacco cessation dropout, as indexed by attendance on the scheduled quit day visit. Participants included 84 adult daily cigarette smokers (61.7% male; Mage = 34.6 years, SD = 13.9), who were recruited to participate in a self-guided quit attempt (an attempt to quit smoking without professional or pharmacological aid). Results indicated that after controlling for the effects of participant sex, race, current (past month) psychological disorder, cigarettes smoked per day, number of years as a regular smoker, and pre-quit levels of motivation to quit, AS significantly predicted increased odds of study dropout prior to attending the scheduled quit day. These findings suggest that AS may be a mechanism involved with challenges in the initiation of quitting.
  • ... 39 Research has noted that when utilizing a continuous measurement of AS, it is optimally derived from the combined scores on the physical and cognitive subscales, while omitting the items related to the social subscale. 40 Thus, the pre- sent investigation utilized a composite score derived from these two subscales (physical and cognitive). Internal consistency of ASI-3 (combined score of the physical and cognitive subscales) in the current sample was α = 0.91. ...
    Article
    Introduction: Anxiety sensitivity, defined as the extent to which individuals believe anxiety and internal sensations have harmful consequences, is associated with the maintenance and relapse of smoking. Yet, little is known about how anxiety sensitivity interplays with negative affect during the quit process in terms of smoking behavior. To address this gap, the current study examined the dynamic interplay between anxiety sensitivity, negative affect, and smoking lapse behavior during the course of a self-guided (unaided) quit attempt. Methods: Fifty-four participants (33.3% female; Mage = 34.6, SD = 13.8) completed ecological momentary assessment procedures, reporting on negative affect and smoking status via a handheld computer device, three times per day for the initial 14 days of the self-guided cessation attempt. Results: As expected, a significant interaction was observed, such that participants characterized by high levels of anxiety sensitivity were at a higher risk of smoking on days when negative affect was high (relative to low). Results also revealed a significant interaction between anxiety sensitivity and daily smoking lapse behavior in terms of daily change in negative affect. Participants characterized by high levels of anxiety sensitivity reported significant increases in same-day negative affect on days when they endorsed smoking relative to days they endorsed abstinence. Conclusions: This study provides novel information about the nature of anxiety sensitivity, negative affect, and smoking behavior during a quit attempt. Results suggests there is a need for specialized intervention strategies to enhance smoking outcome among this high-risk group that will meet their unique 'affective needs.'
  • ... In sum, response patterns are rather indicative of groups engaging in different response styles than groups being differentially sensitive to sets of cues (AS items) as postulated in the THAS. To ascertain the validity of this conclusion, an additional analysis was conducted using an alternative (ad hoc) classification of groups proposed by Bernstein et al. (2010) instead of the MRM classification (see ESM 1). This analysis corroborated a response style interpretation as well. ...
    ... In line with the common notion that response styles are biases that are consistent across time and questionnaire (Jackson & Messick, 1958 ), we demonstrated that latent classes identified in ASI-3 subscales emerged for self-report scales measuring other constructs as well. The notion of quantitative individual differences in AS being superimposed by qualitative interindividual differences – an adaptive and maladaptive form of AS (Bernstein et al., 2007Bernstein et al., , 2010) – is not supported by our study. In this regard, our results are consistent with failed rigorous replication attempts of Bernstein et al.'s taxometric analyses by independent researchers (Broman-Fulks et al., 2008, 2010). ...
    Article
    Anxiety Sensitivity (AS) denotes the tendency to fear anxiety-related sensations. Trait AS is an established risk factor for anxiety pathology. The Anxiety Sensitivity Index-3 (ASI-3) is a widely used measure of AS and its three most robust dimensions with well-established construct validity. At present, the dimensional conceptualization of AS, and thus, the construct validity of the ASI-3 is challenged. A latent class structure with two distinct and qualitatively different forms, an adaptive form (normative AS) and a maladaptive form (AS taxon, predisposing for anxiety pathology) was postulated. Item Response Theory (IRT) models were applied to item-level data of the ASI-3 in an attempt to replicate previous findings in a large nonclinical sample (N = 2,603) and to examine possible interpretations for the latent discontinuity observed. Two latent classes with a pattern of distinct responses to ASI-3 items were found. However, classes were indicative of participant's differential use of the response scale (midpoint and extreme response style) rather than differing in AS content (adaptive and maladaptive AS forms). A dimensional structure of AS and the construct validity of the ASI-3 was supported.
  • Article
    Anxiety sensitivity (AS), the belief that anxious arousal is harmful, is a malleable risk factor that has been implicated in anxiety and depression symptoms in adolescents. Although there is some evidence that adolescents possess distinct developmental trajectories, few studies have explored this topic. This study examined the developmental trajectory of AS in 248 adolescents ( M age = 11.0 years, SD = 0.82; 56% male) across 6 years, beginning when children were age 11. This study also examined the influence of AS trajectories on anxiety and depression at age 16. Finally, this study examined the utility of AS classes in identifying anxiety and depression growth. Three AS classes were found, described by normative-stable, high-stable, and high-unstable trajectories. Adolescents in the high-stable and the high-unstable AS classes had higher levels of anxiety and depression at age 16 than did adolescents in the normative-stable AS class. In addition, the anxiety and depression trajectories fit by AS class mirrored the AS class trajectories. These findings suggest three AS trajectories can be identified in adolescents. These trajectories are discussed in relation to a developmental perspective of AS.