ArticlePublisher preview available

Unraveling the Daily Stress Crossover Between Unemployed Individuals and Their Employed Spouses

Authors:
To read the full-text of this research, you can request a copy directly from the authors.

Abstract

This study examined the dynamic relationship of distress levels between spouses when one is unemployed (and looking for a job) while the other is engaged in full-time employment. Using the diary survey method, we sampled 100 couples in China for 10 days and tested a model comprising three stress crossover mechanisms: the direct crossover, the mediating crossover, and the common stressor mechanisms. Results supported the direct crossover and common stressor mechanisms. Other stressors (e.g., work–family conflict and negative job search experience) were also related to distress of the unemployed individuals and their employed spouses. Additionally, we found a three-way interaction involving gender, marital satisfaction, and distress levels of employed spouses. We discuss how the study contributes to the unemployment and stress crossover literatures.
Unraveling the Daily Stress Crossover Between Unemployed Individuals
and Their Employed Spouses
Zhaoli Song
National University of Singapore Maw-Der Foo
University of Colorado at Boulder
Marilyn A. Uy
University of Victoria Shuhua Sun
National University of Singapore
This study examined the dynamic relationship of distress levels between spouses when one is unem-
ployed (and looking for a job) while the other is engaged in full-time employment. Using the diary survey
method, we sampled 100 couples in China for 10 days and tested a model comprising three stress
crossover mechanisms: the direct crossover, the mediating crossover, and the common stressor mecha-
nisms. Results supported the direct crossover and common stressor mechanisms. Other stressors (e.g.,
work–family conflict and negative job search experience) were also related to distress of the unemployed
individuals and their employed spouses. Additionally, we found a three-way interaction involving gender,
marital satisfaction, and distress levels of employed spouses. We discuss how the study contributes to the
unemployment and stress crossover literatures.
Keywords: stress, crossover, diary survey, unemployment, work–family interface
Research on unemployment provides compelling evidence of
the adverse impact of job loss on the unemployed individual
that goes beyond income deprivation and employment benefits
(Fryer, 1995) to include increased levels of distress and depres-
sion (Catalano, 1991; Hamilton, Hoffman, Broman, & Rauma,
1993; McKee-Ryan, Song, Wanberg, & Kinicki, 2005). Studies
also have revealed that the consequence of job loss extend
beyond these individuals to include their families (Broman,
Hamilton, & Hoffman, 1990; Dooley, Fielding, & Levi, 1996;
Howe, Levy, & Caplan, 2004; J. H. Larson, 1984; Vinokur,
Price, & Caplan, 1996; Westman, Etzion, & Horovitz, 2004).
Researchers have suggested that people respond to stressful
situations in the context of relationships with significant others
(Bodenmann, 1997; Giunta & Compas, 1993), such as spousal
relationships, often regarded as among the most important
relationships (Howe, Caplan, Foster, Lockshin, & McGrath,
1995). Despite spousal influences on one’s experiences, with a
few notable exceptions (e.g., Vinokur & Caplan, 1987; Vinokur
et al., 1996), most unemployment studies have neglected these
influences. Little is known about how unemployed individuals
influence their spouses’ stress levels and vice versa.
Because unemployment is a shared life event affecting unem-
ployed persons and their spouses, researchers should examine the
reciprocal influences and experiences of both spouses to under-
stand how the family, as a system, responds to stress during
unemployment. We proposed and tested a model to explain cou-
ples’ distress when one spouse is unemployed and looking for a
job while the other spouse is working full-time. Such a family
situation can be plagued with a variety of stressors. Specifically,
stress reactions can occur when the stress experienced by one
person influences the stress experienced by another person,
the so-called crossover process (Westman, 2001). We tested three
stress crossover mechanisms, namely, the direct crossover, the
mediating crossover, and the common stressor mechanisms. We
also included in our model the stressors originating from each
spouse’s specific life situations, such as work–family conflict of
the employed spouse and job-search experiences of the unem-
ployed spouse. By taking into account different types of stressors,
our study sheds light on the dyadic-level stress dynamics among
married couples during unemployment and on the interplay of
unemployment experiences and shared experiences between
spouses. Moreover, our study also examined how gender may play
a role in the stress crossover process. Traditional gender role
theories postulate that because men and women undertake differ-
ent social roles, they should have different response patterns to-
ward their work, family responsibilities, unemployment, and their
spouses’ stress. We tested gender differences of stress reactions
and distress crossover in the post hoc analyses and found asym-
This article was published Online First October 4, 2010.
Zhaoli Song and Shuhua Sun, Department of Management and Organi-
zation, Business School, National University of Singapore, Singapore;
Maw-Der Foo, Management Division, Leeds School of Business, Univer-
sity of Colorado at Boulder; Marilyn A. Uy, Faculty of Business, Univer-
sity of Victoria, Victoria, British Columbia, Canada.
We thank Connie Wanberg and Angelo Kinicki for comments on an
earlier version of this article. We also thank Shuhua Zhang from Shengy-
ang Normal University for assistance in data collection. This project was
supported by two research grants from National University of Singapore
(R-317–000059–112 and R-317-000-071-112) awarded to Zhaoli Song
and a Chinese National Nature Science Foundation Grant (70571080)
awarded to Shuhua Zhang.
Correspondence concerning this article should be addressed to Zhaoli Song,
Department of Management and Organization, National University of Singa-
pore, 1 Business Link, Singapore 117592. E-mail: bizszl@nus.edu.sg
Journal of Applied Psychology © 2010 American Psychological Association
2011, Vol. 96, No. 1, 151–168 0021-9010/10/$12.00 DOI: 10.1037/a0021035
151
This document is copyrighted by the American Psychological Association or one of its allied publishers.
This article is intended solely for the personal use of the individual user and is not to be disseminated broadly.
... In contrast, crossover effects indicate a dyadic, interindividual transmission of emotions to a person within the same domain (e.g., the partner; Demerouti et al., 2005). Song et al. (2011) found support for direct crossover as well as common stressors. Direct crossover happens when one partner is strained and transfers their negative emotions directly to the other partner (Rook et al., 1991;Song et al., 2011). ...
... Song et al. (2011) found support for direct crossover as well as common stressors. Direct crossover happens when one partner is strained and transfers their negative emotions directly to the other partner (Rook et al., 1991;Song et al., 2011). Common or mutual stressors are frequent within the same household (Song et al., 2011). ...
... Direct crossover happens when one partner is strained and transfers their negative emotions directly to the other partner (Rook et al., 1991;Song et al., 2011). Common or mutual stressors are frequent within the same household (Song et al., 2011). ...
... Three studies used a 3-wave longitudinal design, and one study used a 6-wave longitudinal design. Two studies used a diary study with lengths of time were 14 and 15 consecutive days (Mustillo et al., 2021;Song et al., 2011), and one study used an experience sampling method (Yang & Dahm, 2021). Time lags in the longitudinal studies ranged from one month, six weeks, three months, and from a year to two years. ...
... Work and family, both the fundamental facets of an adult's life, have emerged as topics in which scholars have a great deal of research interest with enhancement in methodology rigor. Our study found shifting trend from the traditional cross sectional design onto more complicated research design such as, panel data study Yucel & Fan, 2019), autoregressive design (Yucel & Borgmann, 2022), diary study (Mustillo et al., 2021;Song et al., 2011) and over 1 year longitudinal study. ...
Article
Work and family are essential aspects of adulthood, exerting a substantial impact on well-being and satisfaction. Work–family conflict refers to conflicts that originate at work and then affect family life and vice versa. Higher levels of stress, the emergence of physical and mental health issues, detrimental effects on family relationships, and poorer life satisfaction are a few outcomes that may have an influence on both individuals and other family members. Work–family conflict can have a socioeconomic impact on broader public health, as it may result in poor job performance and high absenteeism rates at work. This current study aims to identify the mechanisms of spillover–crossover within the work–family interferences. Using a systematic literature review from 57 articles collected from three prestigious databases: Scopus, Web of Science, and PsycINFO, the study found that direct crossover is the predominant form of transmission. However, the crossover phenomenon is not only found in marital relationships but includes interactions between parents-children, superiors-subordinates, and employees-customers. This systematic literature review advances a novel framework by synthesizing these findings, thereby promoting a comprehensive understanding of the spillover–crossover effects of work–family conflict. In turn, this understanding can serve as the basis for the formulation of workplace policies, offering a promising path forward for both individuals and society.
... In this section, we examine the methods used previously to measure stress contagion. Processes of stress contagion have been extensively examined in diverse contexts, including working environments (e.g., Bakker et al. 2009), romantic relationships (e.g., Song et al. 2011), or mother-infant relationships (e.g., Waters et al. 2014). Contagion processes have also been explored in psychological and educational sciences. ...
Article
Full-text available
Purpose: Our study focuses on stress contagion in vocational school classes, examining how students’ stress experiences affect their spatial classmates. For this purpose, we apply a novel formal network model that allows us to differentiate between endogenousand exogenous peer effects in the stress contagion process. Using the network model, we investigate effects on students’ stress levels, considering the stress and Coping experiences of spatial peers as well as didactic-methodological context factors. Methods: We test our statistical model using secondary data collected in a study involving 53 students from two classes at a public German vocational training school. The students’ experiences of stress (time pressure, pressure to succeed) and Coping strategies (understanding of the subject matter, self-confidence) were captured using the experience sampling method, while classroom characteristics (e.g., teacher instruction, cooperative work) were recorded through video-based analysis of lessons. Utilizing the panel data, we employ maximum likelihood estimation to assess the spatial peer effects model for both classrooms. Results: Among other findings, all model specifications revealed significant peer effects for both stress measures, indicating that the higher the stress experience of immediate peers in the classroom, the higher the individual stress experienced by the students. Concerning the considered context factors, we found, for example, that increased cooperative work leads to higher levels of stress experience. Conclusion: From a substantive perspective, our results underscore the role of peer-to-peer contagion in the vocational classroom and thus suggest a nuanced examination of cooperative practices. From a research methodology perspective, our Approach illustrates how various methods (such as experience sampling, video-based Classroom observation, and spatial network information) complement and enrich each other, highlighting the added value of our network analytical approach Keywords: Stress contagion, Paradox of cooperation, Spatial network, Experience sampling, Video-based classroom observation, Network econometric approach
... This individual's work-family conflict might then crossover to affect their partner's well-being (Bakker & Demerouti, 2013). Broadly, crossover can be direct (i.e., via response elicitation from a partner), indirect (i.e., via social behavior changes), or due to common stressors (e.g., Li et al., 2021;Song et al., 2011;Westman, 2001Westman, , 2006. ...
Article
Full-text available
Dual-income couples, where both partners in a romantic couple are employed, comprise a considerable portion of the workforce. Both partners can carry strain from paid work into the home, and the spillover-crossover model posits that individuals carry strain from one domain into another, affecting their well-being (i.e., spillover) and their partner’s well-being (i.e., crossover). Here, we present a meta-analysis examining the influence of actor’s and partner’s work-family conflict on their own and their partner’s marital satisfaction. We apply the actor-partner interdependence model to meta-analysis, demonstrating a methodologically robust synthesis of dyadic data. This novel approach allows us to rigorously test spillover-crossover theory and contribute to the scholarship on dual-income couples by providing a more holistic, field-wide summary of the relationships between work-family conflict and marital satisfaction. Results suggest that dual-income couples’ work-family conflict has a significant impact on their own and their partner’s marital satisfaction; spillover and crossover occurring between actor and partner work-family conflict explains variance in both actor and partner marital satisfaction. Our study provides methodological evidence to support the inclusion of dyadic data in meta-analysis, as well as expands our understanding of spillover and crossover in dual-income couples. Suggestions for future research and practice are presented.
... The crossover literature suggests that these mechanisms are not mutually exclusive and can operate simultaneously (Peng et al., 2020;Song et al., 2011;Westman & Etzion, 2005). Since our main goal is to unpack the relationships between remote employee WFC and divorce intentions of the couple through both spouses' psychological and social interactions stemming from WFC experienced by a remote employee, we focus specifically on the processes of direct and indirect crossover in our proposed model. ...
Article
This research examines the detrimental impact of remote employees' work‐to‐family conflict (WFC) on divorce intentions for both the remote employee and spouse. Building upon the spillover‐crossover framework and relative deprivation theory, we examine the paths of spillover to the remote employee's divorce intentions, crossover influences of a remote employee's WFC on divorce intentions through the spouse (i.e., relative deprivation, resentment toward the employee's remote work, and relationship tension), and crossback of the remote employee's WFC through the spouse and back to their own divorce intentions. Surveying 311 remote employees and their spouses at two‐time points, we find that remote employee WFC predicts divorce intentions for the remote employee through the spillover path. Further, the remote employee WFC crosses over to the spouse through two different paths to impact spouse divorce intentions. Taken together, our research extends the existing WFC literature and broadens our understanding of the spillover and crossover effects through which remote employees' WFC could undermine both partners' perceptions of the marital relationship.
Chapter
Entrepreneurship research has focused on traditional firm-level outcomes such as firm performance or growth. Yet, the pursuit of entrepreneurship is for deeply personal reasons. Thereby, as a self-organized human pursuit, how entrepreneurship relates to personal wellbeing or personal fulfillment is important but frequently overlooked. It is of utmost importance to examine the connection between entrepreneurship and wellbeing as entrepreneurs face various challenges and have to make quick decision facing uncertainty but how they experience and appreciate their work and how their work impacts their wellbeing is still nascent. While non-academic outlets have examined work burnout, stress, and fatigue of entrepreneurs and their causes and ways to overcome them, the academic literature is just starting to examine this important research area. Throughout this book chapter, we cover the concepts of wellbeing and how it relates to research on entrepreneurship and entrepreneurial pursuit. The concept of psychological wellbeing plays a vital role in scholarly work and policy debates. Entrepreneurship pursuit, which is an integral part of living for a fulfilled life, is closely related to an individual’s capacity to work and maintain positive relationships. An entrepreneurial pursuit can be a source of satisfaction and personal fulfillment and can push the entrepreneur in achieving their goals and persisting with their entrepreneurial endeavors under conditions of uncertainty. The sense of satisfaction derived from an entrepreneurial pursuit can be the driving force for positive social change. We emphasize the importance of investigating wellbeing as a crucial outcome in entrepreneurship research. Further, we draw upon the important role of wellbeing as being a driver for entrepreneurial pursuits (whether the antecedent to entrepreneurial pursuit is the lack of wellbeing or on the contrary positive affect). The emotional aspect is important for entrepreneurship researchers to consider since entrepreneurs are driven by their emotional state as they are constantly facing uncertainty and time pressures in their entrepreneurial journey. Entrepreneurship research has started to examine wellbeing as a critical psychological antecedent, yet most studies have focused on positive emotions often disregarding the role of negative emotions being an equally important driver to entrepreneurial pursuit and actions.KeywordsEntrepreneurshipWellbeingEmotionHealthADHD
Article
Full-text available
Self‐efficacy exerts a positive impact on several self‐regulatory functions to support goal accomplishment and performance. However, in contexts that are characterized by uncertainty and ambiguity, such as entrepreneurship, there might be a tipping point to this relationship, prompting calls for deeper investigations on the nonlinear effect. In particular, the underlying mechanisms explaining why and when the nonlinear effect occurs are unclear. Drawing on theories of self‐regulation, we examine the nonlinear effect of entrepreneurial self‐efficacy on venture goal progress through the entrepreneur's active feedback‐seeking and venture effort. We also propose that the entrepreneur's state error mastery orientation moderates the nonlinear effect. Conducting a six‐wave repeated measures study among 84 early‐stage entrepreneurs in a business accelerator in the Philippines, we use a within‐person approach to test our hypotheses and research model. Results suggest that self‐regulatory mechanisms in terms of feedback seeking, effort, and state error mastery orientation help to unpack why and when self‐efficacy exerts a nonlinear effect on performance outcomes.
Article
Full-text available
Over 400 married couples participated in a 3-year prospective study of economic pressure and marital relations. The research (a) empirically evaluated the family stress model of economic stress influences on marital distress and (b) extended the model to include specific interactional characteristics of spouses hypothesized to protect against economic pressure. Findings provided support for the basic mediational model, which proposes that economic pressure increases risk for emotional distress, which, in turn, increases risk for marital conflict and subsequent marital distress. Regarding resilience to economic stress, high marital support reduced the association between economic pressure and emotional distress. In addition, effective couple problem solving reduced the adverse influence of marital conflict on marital distress. Overall, the findings provided substantial support for the extended family stress model.
Article
Full-text available
A comprehensive model of the work–family interface was developed and tested. The proposed model extended prior research by explicitly distinguishing between work interfering with family and family interfering with work. This distinction allowed testing of hypotheses concerning the unique antecedents and outcomes of both forms of work–family conflict and a reciprocal relationship between them. The influence of gender, race, and job type on the generalizability of the model was also examined. Data were obtained through household interviews with a random sample of 631 individuals. The model was tested with structural equation modeling techniques. Results were strongly supportive. In addition, although the model was invariant across gender and race, there were differences across blue- and white-collar workers. Implications for future research on the work–family interface are discussed.
Article
Full-text available
This study examined daily stress processes among 75 married couples across 20 assessments during a 6-month period. The somatic and psychological effects of common everyday hassles were investigated. Overall, there was a significant relationship between daily stress and the occurrence of both concurrent and subsequent health problems such as flu, sore throat, headaches, and backaches. The relationship of daily stress to mood disturbance was more complex. The negative effects of stress on mood were limited to a single day, with the following day characterized by mood scores that were better than usual. Furthermore, striking individual differences were found in the extent to which daily stress was associated with health and mood across time. Participants with unsupportive social relationships and low self-esteem were more likely to experience an increase in psychological and somatic problems both on and following stressful days than were participants high in self-esteem and social support. These data suggest that persons with low psychosocial resources are vulnerable to illness and mood disturbance when their stress levels increase, even if they generally have little stress in their lives.
Article
Full-text available
Social ties can be stressful as well as supportive. Are these opposing effects linked, and can they help explain subgroup differences in the efficacy of social support? These questions were applied to data on social support in response to stressful life events. The subjects were 314 women randomly chosen from the registration list of a neighborhood health center in Boston. The data were from the initial interviews of a larger study. The findings include the following: (a) The mobilization of social support was associated with better psychological well-being for women with greater personal resources, but not for those with lower levels of personal resources. (b) Women with lower levels of personal resources were more distressed by life events in the lives of their significant others, especially as the number of these events increased. (c) The subgroup effects of interpersonal support and stress on psychological well-being were independent, separate effects. In sum, women with greater material and psychological resources derived more beneficial support and suffered less stress from their social ties.
Article
Full-text available
Directions for explicating relations among stress, support, and adaptational outcomes are suggested. Attention is drawn to the distinctiveness of marriage as a source of stress and support in adult life. In addition, the literature on marital and family therapy points to the potentially deleterious effects of overinvolvement in close relationships. If research and theory on social support are to become relevant to clinical intervention, the current emphasis on the benefits of perceived social support needs to be balanced by (a) consideration of the costs and constraints of participating in social relationships and (b) a concern for how such perceptions arise.
Article
Full-text available
We examined the role of the quality of reemployment in the process of coping with job loss using a panel design and a four-month interval for 100 displaced workers. The dynamic process of coping with job loss changed between the anticipatory and outcome stages. The quality of reemployment played a key role, interacting with time in such a way that satisfactorily reemployed workers experienced reduced economic discrepancies and replenished coping resources. The dissatisfactorily reemployed and the unemployed continued to experience negative effects.