The Effect of Various Wound Dressings on the Activity of Debriding Enzymes

Department of Research and Development, Healthpoint, Ltd, Fort Worth, Texas, USA.
Advances in skin & wound care (Impact Factor: 1.11). 10/2010; 23(10):456-62. DOI: 10.1097/
Source: PubMed


To understand the compatibility between the debriding enzymes collagenase and papain, and various wound dressings.
The extracts from a silver dressing (Acticoat; Smith & Nephew, St Petersburg, Florida), iodine dressings (Iodoflex and Iodosorb; Smith & Nephew), a pigment-complexed polyvinyl alcohol (PVA) dressing (Hydrofera Blue; Healthpoint, Ltd, Fort Worth, Texas), and collagen dressings (Hydrofera Blue and FibraCol Plus; Systagenix Wound Management, Quincy, Massachusetts) were examined in vitro with collagenase and papain (papain was used in papain-urea debriding agents, no longer available on today's US market).
All testing was in vitro and performed at Healthpoint, Ltd.
Testing was not performed using human or animal subjects. All in vitro testing was conducted in the lab using artificial wound eschar substrate and other lab equipment.
The main outcome measure was percent collagenase and papain activity lost when combined with each type of dressing tested.
The results demonstrated that the pigment-complexed polyvinyl alcohol dressing and the collagen dressing were compatible with collagenase, whereas the iodine dressings inhibit the activity of collagenase. The nanocrystal silver dressing (Acticoat) caused more than a 50% loss in activity when combined with collagenase. Papain displayed varying levels of inhibition with all dressings tested with the enzyme. The iodine dressings significantly inhibit papain activity, whereas the other dressings exhibited inhibitory activity ranging from 10% to 30%.
Antimicrobial dressings are widely used for management of wound bioburden. Frequently, they are used in combination with other topical therapeutic drugs, such as enzymatic debriding agents for the removal of wound necrotic tissues. Such combined applications may have greater potential to achieve multiple healing activities simultaneously, including exudate and bioburden management, debridement, and tissue regeneration. Overall, the authors' testing found that collagenase was observed to be more tolerant when used with the dressings tested than papain. These findings merit further exploration in clinical wounds to confirm clinical validity.

Download full-text


Available from: Lei Shi, Apr 30, 2014
  • Source
    • "CUPE and BPLP performed intermediate inhibition strength against microorganisms, where the differences were still significant with around 20 and 50% reduction for E. coli and S. aureus, respectively, at day 28 (p < 0.01). In comparison, the commercially available wound dressing, Hydrofera Blue, showed no antimicrobial property at the early time points, but gradually activated its germicidal function at the late time points due to the slow release of antimicrobial dyes, methylene blue, which is incorporated within Hydrofera Blue (Shi et al., 2010). Most importantly, Figure 4 shows that the bacteria turbidity incubated with POC scaffolds reduced 68% for E. coli and 83% for S. aureus after 28 h of incubation compared to free bacteria control indicating that POC has similar or better bacteria-killing properties compared to that of free citric acid (29 mg/ml) and commercial Hydrofera Blue samples at late time points. "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Citrate-based polymers possess unique advantages for various biomedical applications since citric acid is a natural metabolism product, which is biocompatible and antimicrobial. In polymer synthesis, citric acid also provides multiple functional groups to control the crosslinking of polymers and active binding sites for further conjugation of biomolecules. Our group recently developed a number of citrate-based polymers for various biomedical applications by taking advantage of their controllable chemical, mechanical, and biological characteristics. In this study, various citric acid derived biodegradable polymers were synthesized and investigated for their physicochemical and antimicrobial properties. Results indicate that citric acid derived polymers reduced bacterial proliferation to different degrees based on their chemical composition. Among the studied polymers, poly(octamethylene citrate) showed ~70-80% suppression to microbe proliferation, owing to its relatively higher ratio of citric acid contents. Crosslinked urethane-doped polyester elastomers and biodegradable photoluminescent polymers also exhibited significant bacteria reduction of ~20 and ~50% for Staphylococcus aureus and Escherichia coli, respectively. Thus, the intrinsic antibacterial properties in citrate-based polymers enable them to inhibit bacteria growth without incorporation of antibiotics, silver nanoparticles, and other traditional bacteria-killing agents suggesting that the citrate-based polymers are unique beneficial materials for wound dressing, tissue engineering, and other potential medical applications where antimicrobial property is desired.
    Full-text · Article · Jul 2014 · Frontiers in Bioengineering and Biotechnology
  • Source

    Preview · Article · Dec 1997 · The Bone & Joint Journal
  • [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Abstract: The presence of a chronic ulcer presents a challenge to clinicians in long-term care while being both a physical and psychological burden to the residents and their families. Dressings play an important adjunctive role in concert with overall efforts to manage the underlying causes of chronic, non-healing wounds. With more than 2000 dressings and a variety of treatment protocols available, chronic wound management is as much an art as it is science. Each wound requires a unique combination of dressings that is matched to the needs of the patient and the clinical presentation of the wound. Treatment often depends on the skill level of the clinician and the ability to develop appropriate interventions and plan of care. This retrospective series of four case studies serves to demonstrate the improved potential for healing outcomes when collagen dressings are used appropriately.
    No preview · Article · Aug 2011 · Wounds: a compendium of clinical research and practice
Show more