Race, Disadvantage and Faculty Experiences in Academic Medicine

Women's Studies Research Center, National Initiative on Gender, Culture and Leadership in Medicine: C-Change, Brandeis University, Waltham, MA 02454-9110, USA.
Journal of General Internal Medicine (Impact Factor: 3.42). 12/2010; 25(12):1363-9. DOI: 10.1007/s11606-010-1478-7
Source: PubMed


Despite compelling reasons to draw on the contributions of under-represented minority (URM) faculty members, US medical schools lack these faculty, particularly in leadership and senior roles.
The study's purpose was to document URM faculty perceptions and experience of the culture of academic medicine in the US and to raise awareness of obstacles to achieving the goal of having people of color in positions of leadership in academic medicine.
The authors conducted a qualitative interview study in 2006-2007 of faculty in five US medical schools chosen for their diverse regional and organizational attributes.
Using purposeful sampling of medical faculty, 96 faculty were interviewed from four different career stages (early, plateaued, leaders and left academic medicine) and diverse specialties with an oversampling of URM faculty.
We identified patterns and themes emergent in the coded data. Analysis was inductive and data driven.
Predominant themes underscored during analyses regarding the experience of URM faculty were: difficulty of cross-cultural relationships; isolation and feeling invisible; lack of mentoring, role models and social capital; disrespect, overt and covert bias/discrimination; different performance expectations related to race/ethnicity; devaluing of research on community health care and health disparities; the unfair burden of being identified with affirmative action and responsibility for diversity efforts; leadership's role in diversity goals; and financial hardship.
Achieving an inclusive culture for diverse medical school faculty would help meet the mission of academic medicine to train a physician and research workforce that meets the disparate needs of our multicultural society. Medical school leaders need to value the inclusion of URM faculty. Failure to fully engage the skills and insights of URM faculty impairs our ability to provide the best science, education or medical care.

Download full-text


Available from: Linda Pololi
  • Source
    • "Although public and private sectors have increased efforts to recruit more CDF (American Association of Colleges of Nursing, 2010; Jacob & Sanchez, 2011), studies reported that CDF are less satisfied with their profession and tend to advance more slowly than their non-CDF colleagues (Peterson, Friedman, Ash, Franco, & Carr, 2004; Pololi, Cooper, & Carr, 2010). In an indepth interview of CDF in five U.S. medical schools, factors such as isolation, feeling invisible, disrespect from their colleagues, overt and covert bias/discrimination, devaluing of research on community health care and health disparities, and a lack of mentoring were all barriers that CDF face in academia (Pololi et al., 2010). In addition, CDF have different needs and challenges from those of native faculty members because of language, cultural differences in norms and behaviors, and the way education was received. "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Despite the benefits of culturally diverse faculty (CDF) in nursing education, studies on strategies to help them succeed in academia are lacking. The purposes of this article were to identify factors important for CDF's academic success by first surveying faculty teaching strategies that may be useful for CDF as they work with students, and to explore some factors that may be useful for administrators/leaders to help CDF be successful in academia. Data from 20 participants who met the inclusion criteria were used for data analysis. CDF seem to incorporate cultural issues in their teaching. A summary of teaching strategies and factors that CDF want from administrators/leaders are listed in this study.
    Preview · Article · Sep 2013 · Journal of professional nursing: official journal of the American Association of Colleges of Nursing
  • Source
    • "Our study identified that a multicultural team puts additional stress on both host nurses and immigrant nurses as they need to learn from each other and make allowances for team members. Acknowledging the efforts team members make in adapting to the multicultural work environment through organisational arrangements, job descriptions and resource development may mitigate workplace stress that contribute negatively to workforce integration (Dreachslin et al., 2004; Pasca and Wagner, 2011; Pololi et al., 2010). In addition, some senior nurses in our study demonstrated leadership in smoothing over immigrant nurses' adaptation to the ward by initiating a programme for newly employed immigrant nurses, and by organising a forum for them to interact with host nurses. "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Variations in nursing practice and communication difficulties pose a challenge for the successful integration into the workforce of immigrant nurses. Evidence for this is found in cultural clashes, interpersonal conflicts, communication problems, prejudiced attitudes and discrimination towards immigrant nurses. While the evidence shows that integrating immigrant nurses into the nursing workforce is shaped by factors that are socially constructed, studies that examine social structures affecting workforce integration are sparse.
    Full-text · Article · Aug 2013 · International journal of nursing studies
  • Source
    • "Widening access to medical school is a priority in medical selection (General Medical Council and Postgraduate Medical Education and Training Board 2001; Ferguson et al. 2002; The Future of Higher Education 2003; McManus et al. 2005; Guiding principles for the admission of medical students 2007; James et al. 2008). Widening access results in greater background diversity, enhancing medical students' educational experience (Carrasquillo & Lee-Rey 2008; Saha et al. 2008) and producing a motivated and successful workforce reflecting the diversity of the constituent community it serves (Patterson & Ferguson 2007; Pololi, Cooper & Carr 2010; Andrioloe & Jeffe 2011). As such, diverse strategies for widening access have been adopted that focus on: (1) selecting both academic and non-cognitive characteristics (Ferguson et al. 2000, 2002, 2003; Albanese et al. 2003; Cooper & Tauber 2005; Powis et al. 2007), (2) providing access courses (Holmes 2002; Greenhalgh et al. 2006; Reeves et al. 2008), (3) giving guidance on completing application forms (Kamali et al. 2005) and (4) lowering the academic entrance requirements (McManus et al. 2005). "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Widening access to medical school is a priority in medical selection. If disadvantaged students do not apply, interventions cannot be effective. To date, no studies have examined factors that predict who chooses to apply to medicine and if socio-demographics influence the profile of those who apply to study medicine. A large database provided by the UK University and Colleges Admissions Service on all 1,225,156 applicants to UK universities over a 3-year period (2002-2004) was analysed. The relationship between demographics, preference to study medicine and academic performance prior to entry (A level score) were explored using logistic and linear regression and path modelling. Those applying to study medicine were more likely to be female, non-white, of higher socio-economic status and from fee-paying schools. Applying to study medicine was associated with increased academic entrance performance over and above socio-demographic factors. Importantly, in those applying to study medicine socio-demographic inequalities in entrance exam performance was either reduced (for ethnicity and SES) or abolished (for sex and schooling). It is argued that early interventions are needed to increase applications for certain groups to help to reduce socio-demographic inequalities in entrance exam performance and hence medical school admissions.
    Full-text · Article · May 2012 · Medical Teacher
Show more