A Meta-Analysis of the Impact of Short-Term Sleep Deprivation on Cognitive Variables

Division of Sleep and Chronobiology, Department of Psychiatry, University of Pennsylvania School of Medicine, 423 Guardian Drive, Philadelphia, PA 19104, USA.
Psychological Bulletin (Impact Factor: 14.76). 05/2010; 136(3):375-89. DOI: 10.1037/a0018883
Source: PubMed


A substantial amount of research has been conducted in an effort to understand the impact of short-term (<48 hr) total sleep deprivation (SD) on outcomes in various cognitive domains. Despite this wealth of information, there has been disagreement on how these data should be interpreted, arising in part because the relative magnitude of effect sizes in these domains is not known. To address this question, we conducted a meta-analysis to discover the effects of short-term SD on both speed and accuracy measures in 6 cognitive categories: simple attention, complex attention, working memory, processing speed, short-term memory, and reasoning. Seventy articles containing 147 cognitive tests were found that met inclusion criteria for this study. Effect sizes ranged from small and nonsignificant (reasoning accuracy: g = -0.125, 95% CI [-0.27, 0.02]) to large (lapses in simple attention: g = -0.776, 95% CI [-0.96, -0.60], p < .001). Across cognitive domains, significant differences were observed for both speed and accuracy; however, there were no differences between speed and accuracy measures within each cognitive domain. Of several moderators tested, only time awake was a significant predictor of between-studies variability, and only for accuracy measures, suggesting that heterogeneity in test characteristics may account for a significant amount of the remaining between-studies variance. The theoretical implications of these findings for the study of SD and cognition are discussed.

Download full-text


Available from: Julian Lim, Apr 22, 2014
    • "Our results of blunting of assessment of disgust in the morning of day 2, after around 24 h without sleep, also disagree with those of Maccari et al. (2014), who showed impaired evaluations of valence of positive and neutral faces. Possible explanations for the differential effects between the studies in this field include: 1) the necessity or not of speeded response (as in Cote et al. (2014) and Maccari et al. (2014)], which is impaired in sleep deprived individuals and varies throughout the day, as do perception and mood (Goel et al., 2009; Lim & Dinges, 2010; Motomura et al., 2013; Schnell et al., 2014; Talbot et al., 2010) and can thus confound results; 2) the fact that the time of day in which participants were assessed pre and post sleep deprivation was not always the same (no control of circadian rhythms as in Huck et al. (2008) and Maccari et al. (2014)], p. 3) the evaluation of just labelling of facial expressions (as in Huck et al., 2008) and/or fewer possibilities for assigning intensity of emotions to faces (i.e. only 4-point scales as in Cote et al. (2014) and Van der Helm et al. (2010)]. "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Changes in sleep patterns negatively influence some emotional responses, but their effects on facial expressiveness identification are unclear. To investigate these effects, 21 young, healthy, male volunteers of intermediate chronotype evaluated emotional expressiveness of faces depicting 6 basic emotions in 5 emotional gradients every 4 h over 36 h of continuous wakefulness. To measure attention and mood we used the Psychomotor Vigilance test and the Positive and Negative Affect Schedule Expanded, respectively. We found effects of emotional gradient for all types of emotions (100% > 80% > 60% > 40% > 20%) during all tested periods, with no indications of circadian effects. The only emotional rating to be affected was disgust, which was progressively blunted throughout the experiment. This effect did not parallel homeostatic and circadian changes in mood, alertness or attention. We conclude that identifying disgust on facial photographs is particularly sensitive to lack of sleep irrespective of sleep-induced changes in mood and attention in males.
    No preview · Article · Dec 2015 · Cognition and Emotion
  • Source
    • "Furthermore, with a reasonable sample size in the current study, our statistical power available to detect large effects of the sort to have practical impact on real-world task performance ought to have been sufficient. The notable exception was red-light monitoring in MATB, precisely the kind of task found to be most disrupted by fatigue (Lim & Dinges, 2010). Subjective ratings had shown this task to be both boring, and of low subjective priority (Gutzwiller et al., 2014). "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: The goal of this study was to advance understanding and prediction of the impact of circadian rhythm on aspects of complex task performance during unexpected automation failures, and subsequent fault management. Participants trained on two tasks: a process control simulation, featuring automated support; and a multi-tasking platform. Participants then completed one task in a very early morning (circadian night) session, and the other during a late afternoon (circadian day) session. Small effects of time of day were seen on simple components of task performance, but impacts on more demanding components, such as those that occur following an automation failure, were muted relative to previous studies where circadian rhythm was compounded with sleep deprivation and fatigue. Circadian low participants engaged in compensatory strategies, rather than passively monitoring the automation. The findings and implications are discussed in the context of a model that includes the effects of sleep and fatigue factors.
    Full-text · Conference Paper · Oct 2015
  • Source
    • "The present study examined individual differences in a purely energetic aspect of cognitive performance—the ability to maintain a basal level of responsiveness to well-discriminable visual targets (Langner & Eickhoff, 2013; Lim & Dinges, 2010). To this end, a low-event-rate simple RT task (psychomotor vigilance task) was used to study the effects of TOT on performance. "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: The goal of this study is to understand the interface between subjectively assessed and objectively measured attention functioning. To this end, we assessed both self-report data using the Cognitive Failures Questionnaire (CFQ) and sustained-attention performance using a low-demand psychomotor vigilance task that required participants to respond to visual targets. Unlike previous studies, reliability of task performance was ensured, testing individuals twice within a retest interval of 1 week. Given that everyday life attentional lapse tendencies vary even in normal-population samples, we asked whether there is a relationship with laboratory performance, in general and as a consequence of time on task (TOT). As a result, low (versus high) CFQ scorers were somewhat different in their average response speed but became particularly prone to lapsing during the task period, as reflected in standard measures of response-speed variability as well as ex-Gaussian parameters of distributional skewness. In conclusion, we argue that persistence to sustained demand might be an important aspect of construct validity that must be evoked by a manipulation of TOT, which may be useful for the evaluation of questionnaires in ecologically valid situations.
    Full-text · Article · Oct 2015 · Applied Cognitive Psychology
Show more