Content uploaded by Franco Mutinelli
Author content
All content in this area was uploaded by Franco Mutinelli
Content may be subject to copyright.
Scientific
note
A
scientific
note
on
oxalic
acid
by
topical
application
for
the
control
of
varroosis
F
Mutinelli
A
Baggio
F
Capolongo
R Piro
L
Prandin
L
Biasion
1
Istituto
Zooprofilattico
Sperimentale
delle
Venezie,
via
Romea
14/A,
I -
35020
Legnaro
(PD);
2
Istituto
di
Patologia
e
Igiene
Veterinaria,
Facoltà
di
Medicina
Veterinaria,
Università
di
Padova,
Agripolis,
I-35020
Legnaro
(PD),
Italy
(Received
9
June
1997;
accepted
7
October
1997)
oxalic
acid
/
varroosis
/ honeybee
/
honey
/
residues
Tests
on
the
use
of
oxalic
acid
for
controlling
varroosis
(Takeuchi
et
al,
1983;
Zjuman,
1987;
Radetzki
et
al,
1994;
Nanetti
et
al,
1995;
Imdorf
et
al,
1997)
have
given
very
good
results
either
in
terms
of
efficacy
(23.8-90.3%;
95%;
97.29%;
98%
and
99.5%,
respectively)
or
tolerability
by
bees.
In
these
previous
investigations
bees
were
sprayed
with
2-3%
oxalic
acid
water
solution
(3-5
mL
per
each
comb
side)
during
a
broodless
period.
It
was
our
aim
to
evaluate
the
activity
of
5%
(w/v)
oxalic
acid
in
a
water-sugar
solution
by
topical
application
on
the
bees.
We
also
planned
to
verify
the
possible
effect
of
these
treatments
on
the
oxalic
acid
content
of
honey.
The
trial
was
carried
out
on
15
Dadant-Blatt
hives
with
an
’anti-Varroa’
tray
and
five
or
six
combs
occupied
by
bees.
The
hives
were
located
in
the
province
of
Padova
(northeastern
Italy).
Five
hives
treated
with
20%
water-sugar
solution
were
used
as
control.
The
solution
used
for
the
topical
treatment
had
the
following
composition:
5%
(w/v)
oxalic
acid
(70
g
dihydrate
oxalic
acid,
Prolabo,
No
20
558.296),
sugar
(200
g)
and
distilled
water
to
1000
mL.
The
dosage
was
25-30
mL
per
hive
(5
mL
per
comb
covered
by
bees).
At
the
time
of
administration
it
was
sunny,
10
°C
and
some
bees
were
flying.
The
treatment
was
repeated
weekly
three
times
(30
October,
6
November,
13
November).
Perizin®
(Bayer)
was
used
for
the
control
treat-
ments.
It
was
administered
twice
at
a
12-day
interval
(21
November
and
3
December)
accord-
ing
to
the
producer
instructions.
The
first
con-
trol
treatment
was
carried
out
8
days
after
the
last
administration
of
the
acid.
Bee
mortality
was
determined
using
’under-
basket
traps’
applied
to
each
hive
(Accorti,
1994).
The
mean
efficacy
of
the
three
treatments
with
oxalic
acid
was
95%
(±
7.39%)
(table
I).
At
the
time
of
administration
capped
brood
accounted
for
approximately
3400
cells
per
hive.
A
73.7%
mean
efficacy
was
achieved
after
the
first
oxalic
acid
treatment.
The
results
obtained
in
each
hive
were
homogeneous
except
for
one
hive,
which
accounted
for
a
22.6%
efficacy.
In
the
treated
hives
no
queenlessness
was
recorded
and
bee
mortality
(12.59
bees/day)
did
not
differ
sig-
nificantly
from
that
observed
in
the
control
hives
(12.32
bees/day).
No
behavioural
changes
were
detected
in
bees
at
the
time
of
administration.
In
this
trial
topical
administration
of
oxalic
acid
resulted
in
a
mean
efficacy
slightly
lower
than
the
spray
one
(98.3%
after
only
one
treat-
*
Correspondence
and
reprints
Tel: (39) 49 8084261;
fax: (39) 49 8830277
ment
in
broodless
period)
(Nanetti
et
al,
1995),
but
it
is
surely
easier
and
faster
to
apply,
even
though
at
least
two
administrations
are
required
when
brood
is
still
present.
Oxalic
acid
has
been
determined
as
oxalate
using
a
commercially
available
kit
(Oxalate
SIGMA
Diagnostics
kit,
Cat
No
591-D)
adapted
to
honey
(detection
level
≥
3 ppm).
The
content
of
oxalic
acid
in
honey
taken
from
the
nest
of
treated
hives
did
not
change
during
the
trial
(pre-
treatment
oxalic
acid
content:
239.79
±
61.72
ppm).
The
difference
between
pre-
and
post-treatment
content
was
not
significant
(two-
tailed
t-test;
t
= 0.461,
ns)
(table
I).
This
shows
that
the
possible
increase
in
the
natural
content
of
this
organic
acid
in
honey
(Kary,
1987)
can
be
avoided,
when
the
protocol
described
above
is
followed.
From
the
toxicological
standpoint
it
is
advis-
able
to
avoid
ingestion,
inhalation
as
well
as
any
skin
or
mucosal
contact
with
oxalic acid
wearing
protective
glasses
and
gloves
(Reynolds,
1993).
Eine
wissenschaftliche
Notiz
zur
topikalen
Anwendung
von
Oxalsäure
in
der
Behand-
lung
der
Varroose
Note
scientifique
sur
I’application
topique
d’acide
oxalique
dans
le
traitement
de
la
varroose
REFERENCES
Accorti
M
(1994)
Le
api
e
il
monitoraggio
ambientale.
Valutazioni
a
lungo
termine
sulle
gabbie
per
la
rac-
colta delle
api
morte.
Apicoltura
9,
19-29
Imdorf A,
Charriere
JD,
Bachofen
B
(1997)
Efficiency
checking
of
the
Varroa jacobsoni
control
methods
by
means
of oxalic
acid.
Apiacta
32,
89-91
Kary
I
(1987)
Untersuchungen
zur
Rückstandsproble-
matik
in
Bienenhonig
im
Rahmen
der
Varroatose-
bekämpfung.
Dissertation,
Justus-Liebig
Univer-
sität
Giessen,
Deutschland,
1-124
Nanetti
A,
Massi
A,
Mutinelli
F,
Cremasco
S
(1995)
L’acido
ossalico
nel
controllo
della
varroasi:
note
preliminari.
Apitalia
22,
29-32
Radetzki
T,
Reiter M,
von Negelein
B
(1994) Oxalsäure
zur
Varroabekämpfung.
Schweiz
Bienen-Ztg
117,
263-267
Reynolds
JEF
(ed)
( 1993)
Supplementary
drugs
and
other
substances.
In:
Martindale
The
Extra
Phar-
macopoeia,
The
Pharmaceutical
Press,
London
Takeuchi
K,
Sakai
T
(1983)
Control
of
Varroa jacob-
soni
mites
with
oxalic
acid
spray.
Honeybee
Science
4, 113-116
(in
Japanese)
Zyuman
BV,
Kadochnikov
AYu,
Bannikov
AI,
Sha-
rikov
AP
(1987)
Combined
measures
against
Var-
roa jacobsoni
infestation
of
bees.
Veterinariya
(Moscow)
6,
40-43
(in
Russian)