Article

The Regulation Dilemma: Cooperation and Conflict in Environmental Governance

Authors:
To read the full-text of this research, you can request a copy directly from the authors.

Abstract

"Across the United States and around the world, businesses have joined voluntary environmental codes proposed by governments and nonstate actors. Many codes require firms to establish internal environmental management systems that seek to improve firms' environmental performance and compliance with mandatory regulations. At the same time, governments are also experimenting with programs that provide incentives for business to self-policies their regulatory compliance, and promptly report and correct regulatory violations. In light of these two trends, this paper examines how governments' approach to regulatory enforcement can influence firms' incentives to comply with mandatory environmental laws and to join voluntary codes that could take them beyond compliance. Our inquiry shows that cooperative regulatory enforcement, in which firms self-police their environmental operations and governments provide regulatory relief for voluntarily disclosed violations, yields optimal, 'win-win' outcomes only when both sides cooperate. If firms are likely to evade compliance, governments are better off adopting a deterrence approach. And, if governments insist on rigidly interpreting and strictly enforcing the law, firms may have strong incentives to evade regulations and/or not join voluntary codes. Cooperation, though not easy, is possible if both sides can credibly signal that they will forgo opportunism."

No full-text available

Request Full-text Paper PDF

To read the full-text of this research,
you can request a copy directly from the authors.

... Today, companies worldwide are actively following environmental regulations set by governmental and non-governmental organizations. These regulations often require companies to establish a comprehensive internal environmental management system (EMS) to enhance ecological performance and regulatory compliance [5]. As a core aspect of social and political activities, corporate environmental compliance holds substantial significance. ...
... However, an analysis of citation counts reveals that Aseem and Ntim demonstrate more significant academic influence. Aseem [5] published five articles related to the topic, accumulating a cumulative 509 citations. His collaboration with Potoski is particularly notable; together they have explored issues such as cooperation and conflict in environmental governance, Voluntary Environmental Programs [42,43], and environmental governance based on the ISO 14001 [44] framework [45]. ...
... Initially, the research primarily focused on the influence of policies on corporate environmental regulation models [5,105]. Various environmental policies have compelled businesses to adopt different management approaches. ...
Article
Full-text available
Against the backdrop of the global energy crisis and climate change, corporate environmental compliance has emerged as a key aspect of environmental regulation and a focal point of academic interest. It plays a crucial role in alleviating regulatory pressure, enabling green innovations, enhancing performance, and fostering sustainable development. Despite extensive research in the field, comprehensive reviews and bibliometric analyses remain scarce. To address this gap, this study meticulously analyzed 851 papers indexed in the WoS’s SSCI and SCI from 2004 to 2024. Using visualization tools like VOSviewer and CiteSpace, it conducted a multidimensional bibliometric analysis and systematic review, identifying core authors such as Aseem, Ntim, and Zeng, high-productivity countries including China, the USA, and the UK, and key journals like the Journal of Cleaner Production and Sustainability. Keyword co-occurrence and cluster analysis revealed central research themes of environmental information disclosure, innovation, and environmental management systems. Burst analysis highlighted emerging hot topics, notably ecological and green innovation, and the interplay between Total Factor Productivity and environmental regulations. Additionally, we identified several critical gaps in the field. For instance, research on corporate environmental governance mechanisms in the context of digital transformation remains insufficient. Furthermore, the effectiveness of multi-stakeholder collaborative governance frameworks requires ongoing investigation. Therefore, we encourage future researchers to focus on the following topics: digitization and environmental compliance, multi-stakeholder participation mechanisms, cost–benefit analysis of corporate environmental compliance, and the impact of political and regulatory environments on corporate environmental compliance.
... Overall, according to Lee et al. (2016), public disclosure of performance does not make VAs more attractive to companies, even though it can be rewarding for well-performing ones. Darnall and Sides (2008) found that self-reporting is not an efficient way to The CP network has successfully grown, meaning that they have managed to keep participation easy and attractive enough for joining (Potoski and Prakash, 2004;van der Heijden, 2020). However, both participation in events and participation in reporting show that most members are not particularly engaged in being active. ...
... This may indicate situation in which the network concentrates more on recruiting new members than activating the existing ones. While the will to increase the network is understandable (Potoski and Prakash, 2004), a lack of activity and engagement is potentially problematic for the aims of the network. ...
... CP seems to be facing a regulation dilemma (Potoski and Prakash, 2004): they seek to keep the participation threshold low, but then the network does not push the members to be active and adopt ambitious goals. As a result, some companies present very ambitious goals, such as carbon negativity, while others limit their aims at the level of changing light bulbs or decreasing the use of printing paper. ...
Article
Full-text available
Private actors are important for urban climate action, because the public sector can control the carbon footprint of a city only partly. Public-private partnerships have been created through different voluntary approaches, such as city-level voluntary networks for companies with the aim to engage private actors in climate change mitigation and to support learning processes by bringing different actors together. If these processes are to happen, network members should connect with each other through voluntary networking activities. These connections can be studied using methods from network science. As a case example, we study the event-participation-based structures of the Climate Partners network of the City of Helsinki between 2011 and 2018, and develop an index to measure whether active event participation by a company is associated with taking more ambitious mitigation measures. The results show that the network manages to bring together companies from different fields but has difficulties with engaging them and encouraging ambitious climate goals. Our results can help to further develop networking activities. The tools we develop and share allow the replication of the analysis for other data sets, offering a basis for a comparative analysis of different networks. This opens new horizons for studying public-private networking and its effects.
... On the one hand, a vast array of arguments has been put forward in favor of using hard regulation to improve compliance and performance (Gray and Shimshack 2011;May 2005;Mukamel et al. 2012;Wilms 1982;Winter and May 2001). The deterrence-based approach, however, incurs high enforcement and compliance costs, and can lead to confrontation (Mukamel et al. 2011;Potoski and Prakash 2004). On the other hand, numerous studies suggest that soft regulation fosters normative and social motivations for compliance (May 2002(May , 2005Potoski and Prakash 2004;Stafford 2012;Winter and May 2001). ...
... The deterrence-based approach, however, incurs high enforcement and compliance costs, and can lead to confrontation (Mukamel et al. 2011;Potoski and Prakash 2004). On the other hand, numerous studies suggest that soft regulation fosters normative and social motivations for compliance (May 2002(May , 2005Potoski and Prakash 2004;Stafford 2012;Winter and May 2001). Despite its impact, soft regulation has its own limitations, including lower accountability (Girth 2014;May 2005). ...
... Recent trends in government regulation reflect changes from the emphasis on desired actions to desired outcomes; and from regulation administered by the government to indirect regulation relying on third-party entities, information, and self-regulation (Carpenter, Grimmer, and Lomazoff 2010;May 2002). More evidence is needed to evaluate these trends (May 2002;Potoski and Prakash 2004). Thus, there is a need systematically to study various regulatory tools across policy contexts to better understand what combination of mechanisms is effective given the nature of the market and service characteristics. ...
Article
Structuring managerial discretion has been a key government policy tool in contemporary regulation and governance. This article explores how a policy that constrains managers’ discretion in recruitment influences the performance of public services. The National Background Check Program (NBCP) is a federal program aimed at strengthening states’ criminal background checks targeting direct patient access employees in nursing homes, where abuse, neglect and misappropriations have been a persistent concern. We combine secondary administrative panel data on Medicare and Medicaid certified nursing facilities with primary data collected from states on their NBCP efforts. We find that NBCP participation, funding and the implementation of fingerprinting requirement, in particular, are associated with fewer deficiencies and higher star ratings. These findings suggest that, while constraining managerial discretion, government regulation is an important tool that federal and state agencies can use to control the performance of public and private entities in some markets and provide market enhancing signals to consumers.
... This article examines nonprofits' participation in government-sponsored voluntary accreditation in the context of NPM reform. Accreditation programs commonly face "recruitment challenges" in many sectors, including the nonprofit one (Breen 2012;Gugerty 2010;Potoski and Prakash 2013). Low participation jeopardizes the legitimacy and success of any voluntary program which relies on setting standards and promoting normative and behavioral changes (Carter, Scott, and Mahallati 2017). ...
... Voluntary regulatory programs emerged as part of a new era of regulation aimed at correcting the conventional command and control's shortcomings, such as high transaction cost and political backlash (Potoski and Prakash 2004). They are now booming in both the Global North and Global South (Breen et al. 2019;Prakash and Gugerty 2010). ...
... For instance, nonprofits proactively adopt program evaluation or participate in self-regulation to secure external funding (AbouAssi 2015; Carman 2011). Studies of state-sponsored voluntary programs also argue that organizations participate in these programs to gain exclusive material and reputational benefits (Delmas and Toffel 2008;Potoski and Prakash 2004). State initiatives can offer more perquisites than nongovernmental voluntary programs, including regulatory relief, a strong credibility signal through public authority endorsement, and advantageous technical assistance (Amirkhanyan 2009;MacIndoe 2013). ...
Article
Full-text available
Around the world, voluntary programs are an increasingly prevalent regulatory instrument in governing nonprofit organizations. But accounts of mechanisms driving nonprofits’ participation in those programs are underdeveloped. This article combines and expands insights from voluntary regulation and institutional work theories to examine the impact of government’s informal relational work on nonprofits’ regulatory participation. Drawing on interviews and survey data from a random sample of 203 nonprofits in Shenzhen, China, the authors study the country’s pioneering government-sponsored voluntary accreditation program and its varying receptions among nonprofits. The empirical analysis shows that politically embedded nonprofits, those with closer organizational connections with the local government, are more likely to participate in accreditation. Since government agencies rely on existing regulatory networks to conduct relational work at both organizational and personal levels to persuade or cajole nonprofits to participate, they tend to direct their recruitment efforts towards more politically embedded nonprofits. However, these targeted recruitment practices may generate reactions much more complicated than the dichotomy of acceptance versus resistance, which ultimately facilitates some nonprofits seeking accreditation while deterring others.
... The cooperative model stands in contrast to a "coercive" (or deterrence based) approach (cf. Earnhart et al., 2020;Earnhart and Glicksman, 2015;Potoski and Prakash, 2004) that relies on the threat of market exclusion regardless of differences in suppliers' ability to comply. ...
... It relaxes the assumption of perfect information and emphasizes education, innovation and selected enforcement based on specific circumstances of non-compliance (Earnhart and Glicksman, 2015). The most important element underpinning the feasibility of the cooperative model is the ability of regulators and suppliers to collaborate effectively (Clark, 2017;Pires, 2008;Potoski and Prakash, 2004), so that regulators can effectively assess suppliers' compliance and also distinguish their motivations from their abilities to comply (Wilhelm et al., 2016a). ...
... For effective and equitable enforcement to work, actors should be able to credibly signal their willingness to cooperate (Potoski and Prakash, 2004) across tiers, and the development of technologies that enable effective monitoring and dialogue across tiers are key to achieve this. The regulator must be able to interact with suppliers, to monitor suppliers' behavior, and to send credible signals about sanctions. ...
... The cooperative model stands in contrast to a "coercive" (or deterrence based) approach (cf. Earnhart et al., 2020;Earnhart and Glicksman, 2015;Potoski and Prakash, 2004) that relies on the threat of market exclusion regardless of differences in suppliers' ability to comply. ...
... It relaxes the assumption of perfect information and emphasizes education, innovation and selected enforcement based on specific circumstances of non-compliance (Earnhart and Glicksman, 2015). The most important element underpinning the feasibility of the cooperative model is the ability of regulators and suppliers to collaborate effectively (Clark, 2017;Pires, 2008;Potoski and Prakash, 2004), so that regulators can effectively assess suppliers' compliance and also distinguish their motivations from their abilities to comply (Wilhelm et al., 2016a). ...
... For effective and equitable enforcement to work, actors should be able to credibly signal their willingness to cooperate (Potoski and Prakash, 2004) across tiers, and the development of technologies that enable effective monitoring and dialogue across tiers are key to achieve this. The regulator must be able to interact with suppliers, to monitor suppliers' behavior, and to send credible signals about sanctions. ...
Preprint
Full-text available
To address ongoing deforestation for global food commodities production, companies and governments have adopted a range of forest-focused supply chain policies. In the Brazilian Amazon, these policies take the form of market exclusion mechanisms that aim to disincentivize deforestation by excluding products originating from areas that don't meet legal forest requirements. Strict exclusionary policies are likely to result in negative livelihood effects and leakage if some farmers are not able to comply, and most supply chain implementation strategies fail to deal with farmers' heterogeneous compliance capacities in an equitable manner. A more cooperative model of enforcement that uses flexible and negotiated approaches to compliance management may in principle enable more marginal and disadvantaged farmers to achieve compliance, thereby improving both the effectiveness of supply chain policies and their equity. However, we show that even cooperative models of enforcement are prone to exhibit coercive tendencies in multi-tier supply chains, leading to severe equity shortcomings.
... However, the relationship between IQ and CSP is more vivid in the lower quantile of CSP. Our findings add value to existing corporate governance, sustainability, and public management literature (see also, Kaufmann and Lafarre, 2021;Potoski and Prakash, 2004;Husted and Sousa-Filho, 2017;Azam et al., 2021) by empirically examining the impact of the macro environment on corporate behaviour towards sustainable directions by combining data on national-level IQ with firm-level CSP. The study offers useful insights into how the quality of the macro environment can guide sustainable policies at the micro level. ...
... GE can shape a firm's achievement of CSP in two main ways. First, governmental trends to institutionalize rules and regulations may ensure a firm's social and environmental activities and thereby shape CSP (Potoski and Prakash, 2004). For example, by a government setting of a minimum wage, a certain tax rate, and a limit on CO 2 emissions, a firm's contribution towards society and the environment are measured and monitored periodically (Lee, 2012;van Buren III, 2005). ...
Article
Full-text available
By analysing 796 companies' data from 21 European countries, this research uncovered the nexus between institutional quality (IQ) and corporate sustainable performance (CSP). The relationship was theoretically examined with the lens of institutional theory and then empirically tested. The findings show that IQ has a positive and significant impact in safeguarding CSP, and firms’ characteristics play an essential preamble in this regard. We additionally found the heterogeneous impact of IQ on CSP. To come to a conclusion, we have applied random effect, two-step system GMM and quantile regression models. Our findings are consistent and empirically robust; therefore, the study disseminates key messages to policymakers and practitioners about the role of IQ in safeguarding CSP.
... 24 Various VEPs have emerged as companies proactively take steps beyond compliance with legal requirements to address environmental impacts. [24][25][26][27][28] A common aspect of VEPs is the tendency for companies to join in precompetitive collaboration to address a challenge that extends beyond what any single company can solve. Effective VEPs often have (1) strong membership standards to avoid the risk of members freeriding; (2) excludability, so members are incentivized to participate; (3) monitoring of members' commitments and sanctioning mechanisms to address noncompliance; and (4) motivations for consumers and shareholders to reward members for premium goods produced. ...
... While the impacts of VEPs are notoriously difficult to assess, they are largely characterized by the existence of membership standards and sanctioning mechanisms. 27,115,116 The Ellen MacArthur Circular Economy Foundation (CEF) and Alliance to End Plastic Waste (AEPW) are notable VEPs with memberships committed to addressing the problems of (plastic) waste in precompetitive collaboration. In a broader sense, voluntary commitments made under the auspices of the UN Ocean Conference (2017) (https://oceanconference.un.org/commitments/) https://ourocean2019.no/commitments/) can also be considered in this space due to the voluntary corporate commitment registries associated with these conferences. ...
Article
Plastic pollution has caused significant environmental and health challenges. Corporations that contribute to the manufacture, use, and distribution of plastics can play a vital role in addressing global plastic pollution and many are committing to voluntary pledges. However, the extent to which corporations’ voluntary commitments are helping solve the problem remains underexplored. Here, we develop a novel typology to characterize voluntary commitments to reduce plastic pollution made between 2015 and 2020 by 973 companies, including the top 300 of the Fortune Global 500. We find that 72% of these companies have made some form of commitment(s) to reduce plastic pollution. About 67% of companies participating in voluntary environmental programs (VEPs) and 17% of non-VEP participants made measurable and timebound commitments. However, rather than tackle virgin plastics, most companies target packaging and general plastics and frequently emphasize recycling-related efforts. Growing commitments on plastic pollution are made by large and important companies, but significantly more efforts beyond plastic recycling are required to effectively address plastic pollution challenges.
... This also includes integrating the principles of sustainable development into business strategies that affect the attitudes and behavior of the members of an organization and the community (Carballo & Castromán, 2014). This theoretical framework will help solve various problems derived from inaccurate measurement of the BOER such as certain business ethics dilemmas (Candau & Dienesch, 2016;Potoski & Prakash, 2004). It will also help identify current and future research opportunities and give structure and perspective to the interdisciplinary literature in the field. ...
... Organizations have developed an extensive series of practices to comply with the corresponding regulation that informs their environmental behavior. This development has promoted research that seeks to understand the effects and effectiveness of the regulation (Camisón, 2010;Clemens & Douglas, 2006;McCarthy & Zen, 2010;Potoski & Prakash, 2004;Wilson, Williams, & Kemp, 2012). ...
Article
Business‐oriented environmental regulation is expected to have a fundamental role in mitigating the adverse effects of human activity on the natural environment. However, its effectiveness and efficiency are not well established. A systematic literature review reveals validity and reliability problems in the measurement of business‐oriented environmental regulation. From a sustainable development perspective, we develop a theoretical framework that aims to enhance the measurement and assessment of this kind of regulation. Our theoretical framework proposes that the goals of business‐oriented environmental regulation must articulate a measurement system in a 3 × 3 matrix: three measurement levels (stringency, response, and outcome—in this cause–effect order) and three sustainability dimensions (environmental, social, and economic—in this constraint order). For each cell, we propose a combination of objective and subjective indicators. This theoretical framework expands existing approaches to business‐oriented environmental regulation measurement by integrating a sustainable development perspective into a measurement framework in a structured theory‐driven manner. Not only will this measurement system be useful for improving environmental policy, but it will also allow companies to improve their business strategy and come closer to complying with environmental regulations in order to effectively contribute to solutions for current environmental problems and help achieve a sustainable development.
... This may be attributed to two main reasons. Firstly, it takes a long time and much effort to reach the so-called 'regulatory convergence'-a term that means new policy regulations are adopted by industries at both national and international levels [19]. Secondly, there is reported evidence from some industries, such as aviation [20], that the introduction of new regulations or other changes in safety routines may themselves be the cause of new near misses and eventually incidents with severe consequences. ...
Article
Full-text available
Shipping activities continue to experience growth across a multitude of industrial sectors within the Arctic, hence there are risks in terms of severity and likelihood of accidents. The Arctic region is inherently dangerous to transportation and human existence due to its extreme climate and environmental conditions, and hence the complexities associated with emergency situations within the maritime domain are amplified when operating within the Arctic and North-Atlantic (ANA). The definition and characterisation of potential seaborne disasters and catastrophic incidents in the ANA region are significant enablers in providing a set of critical and sustainable tools for Search and Rescue (SAR), Oil Spill Response (OSR), and emergency management practitioners. Therefore, in this paper we aim to identify and characterise high-priority potential seaborne disasters and catastrophic incidents in the ANA region such as cruise ship accidents, oil leaks, radiological leaks, and fishing boat groundings. These were compiled as an outcome of a set of workshops carried out as part of the ARCSAR, EU Horizon 2020 funded project , and from analysis of the literature. We also provide root cause analysis techniques, tools for strategic decision-making, and means of mitigation. We demonstrate how such tools can be used by applying some of them to a selective case study and drawing lessons learned from the application of root cause analysis, which can help emergency response organisations with preparedness work and hence more efficient response. In doing so, we provide a set of tools that can be used for strategic and operational learning. Such approaches can help standardise the definition and characterisation of potential seaborne disasters and catastrophic incidents in the ANA region in both prospective and retrospective analysis.
... Regulatory regimes are often conceptualized on the spectrum between command and control and self-regulation regarding the levels of coerciveness (Treger, 2023). On the extreme hand of the coercive regulatory regime, rule makers constrain improper behavior through coercive regulations and laws, enforcing strict supervision and constraints (Jackson et al., 2020;Potoski & Prakash, 2004). On the other hand, the market or the individual is granted more freedom, with new and milder government interventions (Potoski & Prakash, 2005;Zehavi, 2012). ...
Article
A wealth of studies has discussed the impact of different regulatory regimes on firms, but have ignored the differences in citizens' attitudes toward firms in different regulatory regimes. Exploring these attitudes is crucial to understanding the micro‐effects of regulatory regimes and market developments. This study aims to investigates the impact of regulatory regimes on citizens' trust in regulated sectors and uncovers the underlying impact mechanisms. Using a survey experiment within the context of algorithm regulation ( N = 1224), we reveal that the coerciveness of regulatory regimes positively influences citizens' trust in regulated firms. Furthermore, we identify problem‐solving and problem exposure perceptions as key mediators in this relationship. The findings contribute to the ongoing debate between regulation and trust, shedding light on their interplay in contemporary society and providing practical implications for policymakers and businesses navigating complex regulatory landscapes.
... Strict environmental regulations serve as a deterrent to ecological damage resulting from corporate operations, thereby suppressing behaviors associated with manipulating actual profitability. It is crucial to note that the implementation phase of environmental regulations, accounting for approximately 90% of the regulatory process, is of paramount importance alongside the formulation phase (Potoski & Prakash, 2004). Through rigorous assessments and the enforcement of environmental policies, environmental auditing compels local governments to adhere strictly to environmental legislation, compelling firms to address the environmental impact of financial manipulation, consequently incurring increased expenses (Nash & Ehrenfeld, 1997). ...
Article
Full-text available
This study comprehensively examines the impact of government environmental audits on real earnings management among Chinese A-share listed firms between 2012 and 2021. Employing a time-varying Difference-in-Differences (DID) methodology, the research investigates how these audits affect various forms of earnings manipulation, including production, sales, and expense manipulation. The findings reveal that government environmental audits effectively curb these practices, particularly in environmentally sensitive companies. The severity of audit enforcement correlates positively with reductions in real earnings management techniques, underscoring the pivotal role of robust regulatory frameworks in advancing corporate transparency, sustainability, and governance objectives. Furthermore, the study elucidates mechanisms through which environmental audits deter earnings manipulation, offering insights into the broader implications for environmental stewardship and corporate sustainability. By highlighting the relationship between environmental auditing and corporate behavior, this study contributes to a deeper understanding of how regulatory oversight can promote financial integrity and environmental responsibility, laying the groundwork for sustainable economic development. The research also provides practical insights for policy makers, emphasizing the importance of targeted regulatory measures to mitigate manipulative activities and foster a more sustainable corporate landscape.
... Findings of misconduct measuring the quality of audits relate to the knowledge and expertise of auditors. Meanwhile, the reporting of violations depends on the auditor's encouragement to disclose the violations (Potoski & Prakash, 2004). This encouragement will depend on the independence that the auditor has. ...
Article
Full-text available
The Public Accountant (auditor) profession is like a "double-edged sword", on the one hand auditors must pay attention to the credibility and ethics of the profession, but on the other hand they must also face pressure from clients in various decision-making. must face pressure from clients in various decision-making auditor's decision making. If the auditor is unable to resist pressure from clients such as personal, emotional or financial pressure, the auditor's independence will be compromised. personal, emotional or financial pressure, the auditor's independence has been reduced and can affect audit quality. and can affect audit quality. This study aims to analyze and prove empirical evidence of the effect of experience, knowledge, length of contact with clients, pressure from clients, peer review, and non-audit services provided by KAP on audit quality. provided by KAP on audit quality. The sample used was 79 respondents, namely auditors at 18 KAPs in Semarang City. Meanwhile, to answer the research hypothesis using multiple regression analysis tools analysis tool, after previously testing classical assumptions. Based on the results of the study, it can be concluded that experience in conducting audits, the knowledge of an auditor and the review of fellow auditors (peer review) have a positive effect on audit quality. So that the more deeper and broader the knowledge of an auditor and the more experienced in the field of auditing as well as peer review from fellow auditors (peer review). auditing field as well as peer review from fellow auditors, the better the audit quality will be. better the quality of the audit performed. Meanwhile, the length of the relationship with the client, pressure from clients, and non-audit services provided by KAP.
... The German environmental protection agency defined EB as "a binding bargaining or a non-binding bargaining in the economic field designed to protect the environment, in order to achieve environmental goals, to reduce environmental burden activities or to terminate environmental burden activities". For example, polluting companies make promises to the government and society and agree to carry out environmental governance [27]. The conceptual interpretation of the environmental sector of the European Union pointed out that organizations, including enterprises and groups, make environmental commitments to public rights agencies (including governments) through negotiation [3]. ...
Article
Full-text available
Environmental pollution has become a serious problem in China due to the development of industrialization and urbanization since the reform policies and opening of the economy. Nowadays, ENGOs function as a third party for environmental protection through various awareness and bargaining activities. This study aims to analyze the role of ENGOs in environmental bargaining (EB) and the influencing factors by combining the EB theories. A structural equation model of ENGOs participation in EB was established to compare the role of ENGOs in bargaining the “Kunming PX incident” and the “Nujiang dam incident” in Yunnan, China. The findings show that complex powers and interests play a vital role during EB. The relationship network, media, and human resources are among the most significant factors influencing the role of ENGO out of all the other factors such as funding, openness, knowledge, scale and experience. The strength of ENGO relationship network is crucial for solving environmental problems. This study also suggests that in order for ENGOs to effectively engage in EB, they should be placed in the proper context in the negotiating process. It is necessary to set up efficient public involvement platforms and processes for effective EB.
... Our rationale is that firms which follow ESG reporting guidelines are obligated to follow a reporting template, which provides a clearer understanding of what information firms should disclose. The template also encourages greater reporting around specific sustainability indicators codified in the guidelines (Potoski & Prakash, 2004). While ESG guidelines do not specify the number of pages or words that should be contained in a firm's sustainability report, firms are expected to fulfill the elaborated expectations of guidelines by disclosing specific information about their ESG actions, performance goals, impacts, and leadership. ...
... Firms act to moderate their political environments to improve or defend their competitive advantage (Potoski & Prakash, 2004). For example, in countries without an established legal framework or with little effective law enforcement, circumvention of laws or regulations may be considered a viable strategy. ...
Article
Full-text available
The success of a firm’s supply chain strategy depends on resources in the political environment and the supply network in which it operates. If the political environment is not conducive to a firm’s supply chain strategy, a firm can either change its supply chain strategy or seek a political environment that is more favorable to its supply chain. This paper examines this second alternative. The structure-conduct performance (SCP) paradigm and the competitive dynamics literature are used to explore the relationships between political actions that leverage supply network resources, supply chain strategies, and firm performance. We extend a well-known typology of political actions from the strategic management literature and suggest that beyond influencing or complying with the political environment, firms may choose to moderate the political environment (circumvent or submit) or stay neutral (free ride). An integrated model is developed to explore the relationships between political actions and supply chain strategy, along with a series of propositions outlining how political actions can facilitate supply chain risk management strategies. Finally, suggestions are provided for future research.
... Thus, local governments may be more likely to rely on states to address social equity concerns, as states are typically in a stronger position to engage in redistributive spending (Zeemering 2012; Pierce, Chow and DeShazo 2020). Through the provision of resources, states can promote the adoption of social regulatory policies among local governments (Potoski and Prakash 2004). Therefore, state fiscal support may have a greater influence on local-level policy commitment related to the environmental and social equity aspects of sustainability. ...
Article
The literature on interlocal sustainability has acknowledged that the resources and authority of state governments influence the collaborative sustainability policy actions of local governments. However, there is an absence of empirical evidence that shows how this influence varies across the environmental protection, economic development, and social equity pillars of sustainability. This study uses data from a 2015 national survey of U.S. cities to shed light on the connection between state-level interventions and regional partnerships across the three primary sustainability policy dimensions. With an understanding gleaned from the concept of contested federalism, this analysis employed Bayesian techniques to examine how state fiscal support for sustainability, along with fiscal and functional decentralization in state systems, affect municipal collaborative policy efforts. The findings suggest a positive link between supportive state-level endeavors and local-level collaborations. However, state influences can have different implications across the three pillars of sustainability.
... Our rationale is that firms which follow ESG reporting guidelines are obligated to follow a reporting template, which provides a clearer understanding of what information firms should disclose. The template also encourages greater reporting around specific sustainability indicators codified in the guidelines (Potoski & Prakash, 2004). While ESG guidelines do not specify the number of pages or words that should be contained in a firm's sustainability report, firms are expected to fulfill the elaborated expectations of guidelines by disclosing specific information about their ESG actions, performance goals, impacts, and leadership. ...
Article
Full-text available
Environment, social, and governance (ESG) reporting guidelines are institutional rules that can enhance the credibility of firms' publicly disclosed information related to ESG. Reporting is often voluntary and global ESG reporting guidelines typically rely on process‐focused third party verification. However, in developing its reporting guidelines, the Japanese government gave firms the unusual option of pursuing either process‐ or content‐focused verification. This paper draws on the unique Japanese setting to examine whether firms that use ESG reporting guidelines increase their quantity of disclosed sustainability information. Furthermore, it assesses whether, given the option, (1) firms tend to pursue process‐ or content‐focused verification, and (2) which type of verification leads to greater information disclosure. We show that firms that follow ESG guidelines disclose 39% more sustainability information compared to firms that publish sustainability reports but do not follow ESG reporting guidelines. Content‐focused verification leads to greater information disclosure than process‐focused verification in that firms publish 23% more text in their sustainability reports. Moreover, given the option, firms prefer to use content‐ over process‐focused verification. However, most global ESG reporting guidelines endorse process‐focused verification and this verification is less effective than content‐focused verification at encouraging firms' information disclosure. Our findings raise a timely and relevant question about the movement by global ESG standard developers to promote process‐ rather than content‐focused verification. They also suggest that firms that wish to create sustainability distinction by way of ESG reporting may benefit by advocating for more robust forms of verification.
... Firms act to moderate their political environments to improve or defend their competitive advantage (Potoski & Prakash, 2004). For example, in countries without an established legal framework or with little effective law enforcement, circumvention of laws or regulations may be considered a viable strategy. ...
Article
Full-text available
The success of a firm’s supply chain strategy depends on resources in the political environment and the supply network in which it operates. If the political environment is not conducive to a firm’s supply chain strategy, a firm can either change its supply chain strategy or seek a political environment that is more favorable to its supply chain. This paper examines this second alternative. The structure‐conduct‐performance (SCP) paradigm and the competitive dynamics literature are used to explore the relationships between political actions that leverage supply network resources, supply chain strategies, and firm performance. We extend a well‐known typology of political actions from the strategic management literature and suggest that beyond influencing or complying with the political environment, firms may choose to moderate the political environment (circumvent or submit) or stay neutral (free ride). An integrated model is developed to explore the relationships between political actions and supply chain strategy, along with a series of propositions outlining how political actions can facilitate supply chain risk management strategies. Finally, suggestions are provided for future research.
... Our rationale is that firms which follow ESG reporting guidelines are obligated to follow a reporting template, which provides a clearer understanding of what information firms should disclose. The template also encourages greater reporting around specific sustainability indicators codified in the guidelines (Potoski & Prakash, 2004). While ESG guidelines do not specify the number of pages or words that should be contained in a firm's sustainability report, firms are expected to fulfill the elaborated expectations of guidelines by disclosing specific information about their ESG actions, performance goals, impacts, and leadership. ...
Preprint
Full-text available
ESG reporting guidelines are institutional rules that can enhance the credibility of firms’ publicly disclosed information related to environment, social, and governance (ESG). Reporting is often voluntary and global ESG reporting guidelines typically rely on process-focused third party verification. However, in developing its reporting guidelines, the Japanese government gave firms the unusual option of pursuing either process- or content-focused verification. This paper draws on the unique Japanese setting to examine whether firms that use ESG reporting guidelines increase their quantity of disclosed sustainability information. Further, it assesses whether, given the option, firms tend to pursue process- or content-focused verification, and which type of verification leads to greater information disclosure. We show that firms that follow ESG guidelines disclose 39 percent more sustainability information compared to firms that publish sustainability reports but do not follow ESG reporting guidelines. Content-focused verification leads to greater information disclosure than process-focused verification in that firms publish 23 percent more text in their sustainability reports. Moreover, given the option, firms prefer to use content- over process-focused verification. However, most global ESG reporting guidelines endorse process-focused verification and this verification is less effective than content-focused verification at encouraging firms’ information disclosure. Our findings raise a timely and relevant question about the movement by global ESG standard developers to promote process- rather than content-focused verification. They also suggest that firms that wish to create sustainability distinction by way of ESG reporting may benefit by advocating for more robust forms of verification.
... Broadly, studies show that regulatory arbitrage can be reduced through formal governmental regulations or voluntary, self-regulatory action by firms. Potoski and Prakash argued across a series of papers (see for example, Potoski & Prakash, 2013, Potoski & Prakash, 2004, Prakash & Potoski, 2007, Prakash & Potoski, 2006 that the diffusion of ISO environmental standards has challenged the pollution haven hypothesis. Private regulatory arrangements have attracted considerable academic and policymaking interest, as a wide range of company-sponsored regulatory arrangements have proliferated (Mayer & Gereffi, 2010). ...
Article
Full-text available
Multinational enterprises operating global value chains are being increasingly pressured to source from suppliers that adopt green private standards. Likewise, public policymakers are also pressured to reduce national pollution levels to contribute to sustainable development initiatives. In this context, while there is extensive debate on how domestic, country-specific environmental regulations interact with private standards (adopted by firms) in reducing national pollution levels, less is known about the role of international trade policies, which have recently embraced an array of sustainability issues. Our paper seeks to extend our understanding of the extent to which ISO environmental certifications affect a country’s level of emissions of greenhouse gases and air pollutants, and whether the European Union’s environmental protection (EP) standards – as mediated through trade agreements – condition this response. Prior research provides mixed evidence on the impact of the adoption of ISO-14001 on pollution reduction. Based on prior literature and using institutional theory and environmental stewardship perspectives, we expect that membership of trade agreements with EP provisions would complement the effect of ISO-14001 uptakes in reducing national pollution levels. Our arguments and results emphasize the complexity between private and public regulations on pollution reduction.
... But there is an additional reason for this conspicuous avoidance of clear-cut advice: The decision-maker is generally absent from the model (Purshouse et al 2014). In real world situations, environmental and economic players are subject to the final decision of an upper instance, generally not included in the model 1 , which ultimately takes the decision (government, administrative agencies, etc.) or, at least, accept agreements reached at lower instances (Adger et al 2003, Potoski & Prakash 2004 2 . The direct consequence of the decision-maker's absence from these models is that its own beliefs, viewpoints and management style cannot be modeled, despite their importance for the conflict outcome. ...
... Incentivized regulation rather than coercive rigidity can lead to more cooperative and voluntary policy enforcement [33][34][35]. Coercive state mandates, especially those that omit vertical consistency, can push local actors to deviate from the principal's policy goals [36,37]. Following this logic, we assert that states with supportive policies that align with local interests and encourage cost-effective energy efficiency strategies can motivate municipalities to commit to programs that rely on vertical consistency. ...
Article
Full-text available
The state and local governments throughout the United States interact within a complex system of multilevel governance to advance sustainability. However, we know little about what this hierarchical system of exchanges means for municipalities as they work to achieve energy efficient government operations. Drawing on a perspective of “contested federalism”, we examine how the transaction costs of state–local government relations affect the efforts of U.S. cities to lead by example and promote sustainability within their internal processes. We apply a Bayesian item response theory approach to assess the effects of state-level fiscal and policy interventions on municipal commitments to energy efficiency programs within their internal operations. Our findings suggest that increased fiscal support for state energy programs enhances municipal commitments to government focused energy efficiency. We also find a positive connection between state energy efficiency standards and municipal efforts to enhance energy efficiency within their internal operations. The alignment of state resources and policy efforts with municipal actions can reduce commitment and agency costs that obstruct policy outcomes. The findings speak to the importance of multilevel governance exchanges in municipal efforts to become leaders in sustainability.
... The weak effectiveness of traditional global intergovernmental environmental regulations together with the globalisation of world markets became drivers of the development of voluntary market-based mechanisms of environmental regulation and responsibility, also known as "Non-state Market-Driven (NSMD) Governance Systems" (Cashore, 2002), "voluntary environmental programs (VEPs)" (Potoski, Prakash, 2004, 2011, "transnational private regulation" (Bartley, 2007) and "Market-based voluntary sustainability standards (VSS)" (Meeting Sustainability Goals, 2016), that are an important core part of "global environmental governance" (Auld et al., 2018). Many of the above-mentioned terms have been used to refer to a range of market-based, institutional instruments used to manage environmental and social impacts of production processes. ...
Article
Full-text available
This article examines the current state and drivers of environmental transparency in the Russian Mining and Metals sector. The study is based upon 2016–19 successive annual rankings calculated transparently, using publicly available information and a third-party-verified ranking system. Ranking results reveal a definite in-crease in the transparency level of one of the most closed industries in Russia. The findings from the study show that a company’s presence in the stock markets has a positive impact on its openness in environmental matters. However, a company’s listing on an international stock exchange does not guarantee high environmental transparency. Some evidence of a correlation between ranking positions and participation of diversified financial-industrial groups in the share capital was also found. Overall, our analyses suggest that ESG (envi-ronmental, social and governance) management in the Russian mining and metals sector is only in the process of development. To overcome this, the environmental transparency ranking of mining and metals companies in Russia creates a new mechanism for raising public awareness and dialogue between the public and one of the most closed industries. The ranking initiated calculation of industry-average quantitative impact indicators that, as the sample grows, will transform into an important benchmark for corporate self-assessment when comparing Russian practices with those of the largest international and foreign mining and metal companies across the globe
... Over the years, the agency has developed other mechanisms of education, awareness, regulatory relief, and voluntary programs that have resulted in not only important benefit to human health and the environment, but also benefited the goal of mutual goodwill within communities that were often at odds. 23,58 The policy mechanisms for increasing the supply of innovation to realize systematic and sustainable solutions could include expansion of supplementary environmental projects; 59 60 Demand-side opportunities include standards and eco-labels, economic incentives, procurement and demonstration, as well as information-based programs. 60,61 This range of an "expanded toolbox" to achieve environmental prosperity is an important step in EPA's evolution. ...
Article
The people of the United States and the world owe the United States Environmental Protection Agency (U.S. EPA) a debt of gratitude for preserving, protecting, and defending human health and the environment for the past half century. As we celebrate the 50th anniversary of the founding of the U.S. EPA, there are two truths about the agency that are difficult to deny: (1) U.S. EPA and its people constitute a renowned agency that has greatly improved both environmental and public health in the United States, and has served as the leading model for nations around the world; and (2) the approaches, tools, structures, and legal frameworks that created the achievements of the U.S. EPA must evolve—and grow—to deal with the issues facing the country and the planet in the next 50 years. Building on the creativity, innovation, and brilliance of individuals and groups working at the U.S. EPA over the course of the last half century, we present 10 recommendations organized in three areas: organization, paradigms, and strategies and tools. Underlying these recommendations are the frameworks of sustainability and systems thinking and guiding these recommendations is the goal of evolving the Environmental Protection Agency to the Environmental Prosperity Agency.
... This raises a further question regarding whether corporate voluntary initiatives, such as the SBTi, displace or discourage direct government action towards achieving national mitigation targets. Literature exploring voluntary environmental initiatives has questioned the extent that firms pre-empt government regulation with less-costly voluntary action, aiming to discourage government action [41]. The limitations of the SBTi highlighted in this paper should prompt further research exploring how the SBTi interacts with government policy making to mitigate corporate GHG emissions. ...
Article
Full-text available
Companies are increasingly seeking to align their actions with the goals of the Paris Agreement. Over 1000 such companies have committed to the science-based targets initiative which seeks to align corporate carbon reduction targets with global decarbonisation trajectories. These ‘science-based targets’ are developed using a common set of resources and target-setting methodologies, then independently assessed and approved by a technical advisory group. Despite the initiative’s rapid rise to public prominence, it has received little attention to date in the academic literature. This paper discusses development of the initiative based upon a quantitative assessment of progress against each component of the science-based targets set by 81 early adopters, using information gathered from company annual reports, corporate social responsibility websites and Carbon Disclosure Project (CDP) responses. The analysis reveals a mixed picture of progress. Though the majority of targets assessed were on track and, in some cases, had already been achieved, just under half of the companies assessed were falling behind on one or more of their targets. Progress varied significantly by target scope, with more limited progress against targets focused on Scope 3 emissions. Company reporting practices were highly variable and often of poor quality. This paper concludes with a range of recommendations to improve the transparency, consistency and comparability of targets within this key agenda-setting initiative.
Article
Several studies indicate that people are less compliant when they feel distrusted. This can pose a challenge for public administration, as some forms of control may signal distrust towards people and could undermine their motivation to comply. In this study, we question whether feeling distrusted is necessarily negative for compliance. In two experiments on tax compliance (N = 239), we examine the case in which the individual is distrusted by the authority. Mediation analyses indicate that distrust reduces opportunism, and this is in turn associated with higher compliance. In a survey experiment on compliance with COVID-19 rules (N = 590), we examine the case in which the individual’s group is distrusted by other members of society. A mediation analysis indicates that distrust increases opportunism, but only for participants who already see themselves as less compliant than average, and this is in turn associated with a lower willingness to comply in the near future. These findings challenge the notion that distrust necessarily leads to retaliation or negative reciprocity, and indicate that the cautious communication of distrust may even be positive in some cases.
Article
Data protection regulations like the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) are increasingly important in securing individuals’ privacy as society goes digital. The success of any regulation, however good, ultimately depends on how well it is executed. Existing literature fails to answer what good execution means in this context. We research what practitioners think are the objectives of data protection regulators and how they evaluate their effectiveness. We explore novel ways to assess regulator performance more systematically. We surveyed 70 chief information security officers and conducted 23 structured interviews. The interviewees included informed business executives, lawyers, digital rights activists, and four national regulators. We supplement it with an analysis of diverse enforcement databases. Our findings indicate a mismatch between the broad presumed objectives attributed to regulators and the narrow criteria used to judge them in practice. Perception of the regulator’s effectiveness is subjective, sanctions-focused, and influenced by one’s role and responsibilities. Moreover, the independence of regulators, intentionally designed to insulate them from daily politics, raises serious questions of accountability. We examine the historical, cultural, and organizational motivations behind the current byzantine complexity of the GDPR regime. Lastly, we contribute a series of key performance indicators and make structural suggestions around centralized and standardized reporting of cases to deliver improved learning, legitimacy, transparency, and comparability. We believe our findings have important implications for the future development of regulator assessment and accountability in Europe and in the growing number of GDPR-like regimes outside Europe.
Chapter
During the last century many radical changes and innovations have taken place. Particularly during the last seven decades, there have been unprecedented advances in development and industrialisation with dramatic economic and technological changes. Such changes have resulted in positive impacts, but also negative ones. A number of milestones have been reached since the first definition of sustainability appeared in 1713 by Hans Carl von Carlowitz to reach the current state of sustainable development (SD), e.g. ‘Our Common Future’, the Rio Conference, the Johannesburg Conference, and the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs). A number of sustainability perspectives can be found: (1) Central focus; (2) Substitutability of natural capital; (3) Constituency; (4) Trends; and, (5) Scope. These perspectives show that SD is a broad, complex, controversial, open ended, and challenging notion that is open to different, and in many cases mutually exclusive, definitions and interpretations. This has created much controversy, especially since such characteristics makes sustainability difficult to implement or be of practical value. In many cases, SD is considered to address only the environmental dimension. In other cases, it focusses on the three ‘pillars’ (economic, environmental, and social). SD encompasses four dimensions (economic, environmental, social, and time), as well as their interrelations.
Chapter
Compliance has become key to our contemporary markets, societies, and modes of governance across a variety of public and private domains. While this has stimulated a rich body of empirical and practical expertise on compliance, thus far, there has been no comprehensive understanding of what compliance is or how it influences various fields and sectors. The academic knowledge of compliance has remained siloed along different disciplinary domains, regulatory and legal spheres, and mechanisms and interventions. This handbook bridges these divides to provide the first one-stop overview of what compliance is, how we can best study it, and the core mechanisms that shape it. Written by leading experts, chapters offer perspectives from across law, regulatory studies, management science, criminology, economics, sociology, and psychology. This volume is the definitive and comprehensive account of compliance.
Article
Voluntary environmental arrangements generally coexist with State-based and private rules, creating a property rights system that legitimizes certain behaviors. In a world of positive transaction costs, legitimacy ensues from imperfect monitoring activities, opening room for opportunism. In this paper, we discuss how the existence of multiple rules in a scenario of high monitoring costs affects the performance of an environmental policy. We discuss the case of deferred prosecution agreements (TAC, acronym in Portuguese), which are voluntary arrangements designed with the goal of incentivizing slaughterhouses to monitor the environmental practices of ranchers in the Brazilian Amazon. More specifically, we study how the signature of a TAC agreement affects deforestation rates in the Brazilian Amazônia Legal region at the municipality level. This paper adopts a difference-in-differences approach to analyze a sample of Brazilian municipalities between 2006 and 2017. Our results, which remain robust across alternative estimators and subsamples, show that the signature of a TAC agreement increases deforestation rates by 0.2 standard deviations. We argue that the signature of a TAC agreement, by creating an imperfect proxy for “good behavior” that enables both compliant and non-compliant organizations to access credit, may incentivize deforestation in the Brazilian Amazon.
Article
In its 20 years of operation, the Carbon Disclosure Project (CDP) has been enormously successful as a private governor of corporate climate risk disclosure. Despite an influx of potentially competitive government‐led disclosure initiatives and interventions, the use of CDP's platform has nonetheless accelerated. To explain this outcome, we argue that public interventions augment the value of private governance for firms when the costs of compliance overlap, benefits of compliance with private rules are undiminished, and normalization helps kickstart positive feedback effects. These conditions of complementarity are made possible by private governors leveraging authority, access, and adaptability as public responses materialize. We illustrate our argument with two cases: the Non‐Financial Reporting Directive in the European Union and the G20's Taskforce for Climate‐Related Financial Disclosures. In elaborating the conditions for complementarity beyond a functional division of governing labor, our study helps clarify how public and private governance co‐evolve in a mutually reinforcing manner.
Article
Environmental management literature has extensively explored why the regulated community, particularly private firms, join voluntary environmental programs (VEPs) in which participants promise to regulate “beyond compliance.” However, the notion of locus has been rarely considered a key determinant of a firm's VEP participation. This study examines how regional pressures encourage firms' VEP participation. Drawing on a dataset of over 1000 industrial facilities related to five government sponsored VEPs in Korea, it investigates how three types of regional pressures—regulators, industrial peers, and community members—affect firms' decision to join VEPs. The major findings are that firms located in the same region as their conglomerate peers, as well as firms located in a place where a large amount of odor pollutant is released, are more likely to participate in VEPs. These results demonstrate the impact of social attributes derived from the geographic location of firms on facilities' VEP engagement.
Article
Water resources are indispensable strategic primary resources for sustainable social development. To solve the water shortage problem, promoting the innovation and diffusion of water-saving technology is the key to improvement. In contrast, governmental regulation is a necessary means to promote the innovation of water-saving technology. This study builds a game model with the involvement of governments and businesses. The objective of the game model is to simulate the performance of imposing a tax or a subsidy to promote water-saving technology. In addition, this study introduces the bionic model Lotka–Volterra to investigate the diffusion process of water-saving technology by simulating the performance of the growth rate and competition coefficient. To explain this process more scientifically and intuitively, this paper uses MATLAB to simulate it. The results show that (i) when the subsidy coefficient is between 0.6 and 0.7, the enthusiasm of the government and enterprises to participate in innovating water-saving technology is high; (ii) when the tax penalty coefficient is higher than 0.8, it can not only motivate governmental control but also promote the innovation of enterprises’ water-saving technology; and (iii) the final equilibrium of the diffusion of water-saving technology is irrelevant to the growth rate in the long term, but it is closely related to the competition coefficient. Based on the above conclusions, this paper puts forward some relevant political suggestions to promote the innovation and diffusion of water-saving technology, such as reasonably increasing the water resources tax and government subsidies.
Chapter
Given the widely heldenvironmental policyimplementing negative perceptions about government bureaucratsbureaucrats, you might cringe at the outset of a story about a government regulatorregulators at a state environmental agencyenvironmental agencies.
Article
The national environmental quality has maintained a momentum of improvement, while the tension between the performance evaluation system and local officials’ behavior has been a significant concern. Based on panel data from 224 prefecture-level cities in China from 2003 to 2018, this paper examined the impact of the characteristics of officials on environmental pollution governance using a fixed-effect model. The empirical results demonstrate an incentive for officials to reduce pollution emissions and improve environmental protection when their native place coincides with the province where they work. The reverse incentive occurs when their native place coincides with the prefecture-level city where they work. Given the fact that eco-policy is the transmission mechanism, a more reasonable assessment system should pay more attention to officials’ characteristics, such as younger female officials are more likely to implement environmental policies, party school education may not be helpful for pollution governance, education level, professional background and working experience has little correlation with environment. Besides, a significant mediating effect shows that officials with hometown identity are encouraged to do more in environmental protection. An official incentive framework on ‘working effort’ should be employed to enhance the effectiveness of environmental governance.
Chapter
Iran is a vulnerable country to desertification and soil degradation and to respond to this problem, some laws and regulations such as Act on Soil Protection Act, as well as institutional arrangements for environmental protection and soil preservation, have been initiated. However, the efficiency of these instruments in building an effective soil governance system is disputable. This chapter intends to exercise the legal challenges of Iran in soil protection governance. To do so it firstly considers the state of soil degradation and protection in Iran and then examines the development of soil protection governance in its legal system. This chapter, emphasizing on the contribution of institutional efficiency and legal enforcement in soil governance, concludes that Iran’s legal system faces with a body of legal, institutional and social obstacles in development and improvement of soil protection governance pillars, i.e. integrated instruments and cross-sectoral collaboration in multilevel protection.
Article
Full-text available
Do visible industrial accidents damage firms’ reputations and depress their stock market returns, and do these penalties spill over to other firms in the industry? On April 20, 2010, the Deepwater Horizon offshore oil rig in the Gulf of Mexico leased by BP exploded and sank, causing 11 deaths and the largest marine oil spill in US history. We examine the impact of this accident on BP’s reputation and stock market performance using data from YouGov’s BrandIndex and Capital IQ’s financial data for the period 2007–2017. We employ a synthetic control analysis to examine the extent and duration of these penalties. We find that in the aftermath of the Deepwater accident, BP’s reputation declined by approximately 50% relative to the synthetic control, and this decline persisted through the end of 2017. Yet, in terms of financial market returns, though the stock price dropped drastically in the first two months, we do not find a statistically significant decline in the stock market returns either in the mid-term (1–2 years) or the long term (2–7 years). In terms of spillover effects, we find no evidence of reputational damage or a decline in stock market returns for other oil and gas firms. These findings suggest that while environmental accidents invite swift and lasting reputational penalties, they might not depress the stock market performance in the long run. Moreover, the impact either on reputation or stock market returns does not necessarily spill over to other firms in the same industry.
Chapter
During the last century, many radical changes and innovations have taken place. In particular, during the last five decades, there have been unprecedented advances in development and industrialisation with dramatic economic and technological changes. Such changes have resulted in positive impacts (increase of economic activities, improvements in agriculture, access to energy, and rise of individual average income) but also negative ones (fast population growth, overconsumption, loss of biodiversity, greenhouse gas emissions, and climate change). A number of milestones have been reached since the first definition of sustainability appeared in 1713 by Hans Carl von Carlowitz to reach the current state of sustainable development (SD), e.g. Our Common Future, the Rio Conference, the Johannesburg Conference, and the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs). As we trace this journey, a number of sustainability perspectives can be found: (1) central focus, (2) substitutability of natural capital, (3) constituency, (4) trends, and (5) scope. These perspectives show that SD is a broad, complex, controversial, open-ended, and challenging notion that is open to different, and in many cases mutually exclusive, definitions and interpretations. This has created much controversy, especially since such characteristics makes sustainability difficult to implement or be of practical value. In many cases, SD is considered to address only the environmental dimension. In other cases, it focuses on the three “pillars” (economic, environmental, and social). For the purposes of this book, SD encompasses four dimensions (economic, environmental, social, and time), as well as their interrelations. SD and sustainability have been used interchangeably, but they are inherently different. SD is the process by which we achieve sustainability, and sustainability is an ideal dynamic state. The terms are also contextual; at the institutional and governmental levels SD is preferred, whereas in the organisational level, sustainability is more widely used.
Article
Chinese provincial governments choose to become active and leading participants in standardization projects rather than opt out of them. As most extant literatures focus on the effect of standardization without government intervention, a research question then arises whether standardization with government's lead could increase the output of innovation product like patent within a region. By investigating the case of China's standardization at provincial level, this study attempts to explore the association between standardization led by government and regional innovation performance. A series of panel data analyses shows the following. (1) Increasing the supply of local standards by provincial government significantly promotes the innovation performances of the cities in this province. (2) Policy of provincial governments to disclose standard content freely also benefit the cities' innovation performances in these particular provinces. (3) The fiscal investment of city government in science and technology positively moderates the effect of provincial government's lead in local standardization on the city's innovation performance. These results suggest that besides financial sponsorship, government could also directly contribute to innovation in a non-financial way by leading standardization. Our study adds to the discussion about government's possible roles in innovation.
Article
Is state/private co-regulation of industry better than either state regulation or private self-regulation alone? Clearly yes, answers Mr. Ginosar. Using the overall theoretical framework of the “New Governance,” Ginosar compares the regulation of broadcast advertising in Israel and Britain as both case studies and models, and creates a framework for analysis. Ginosar argues that the shift from hierarchical control to pluralistic control is a more effective and efficient way to serve the public interest.
Chapter
Environmental harms and crimes that affect non-human nature (including animals) have the potential for greater societal impact than the ‘everyday’ crimes that are the subject of mainstream criminal justice and much criminological study. Yet such crimes are often dealt with outside of the mainstream of criminal law and criminal justice. Instead of falling within the remit of the criminal law, some environmental harms are engaged with specifically through the prism of environmental law and within a civil and administrative framework rather than a distinctly criminal justice one.
Article
To address ongoing deforestation for global food commodities production, companies and governments have adopted a range of forest-focused supply chain policies. In the Brazilian Amazon, these policies take the form of market exclusion mechanisms, i.e., immediately dropping suppliers who have cleared their land after a specific cut-off date. Theory suggests that strict exclusionary policies such as these are likely to result in both negative livelihood effects and reduce effectiveness of the policy if some farmers are not able to comply. It is proposed that a more cooperative model of enforcement that uses flexible and negotiated approaches to compliance management may enable more marginal and disadvantaged farmers to achieve compliance, thereby improving both the effectiveness of supply chain policies and their equity. Through our case study of cattle in the Brazilian Amazon, we examine the degree to which a purportedly cooperative supply chain policy exhibits coercive tendencies at different tiers and the degree to which these tendencies influence effectiveness and equity outcomes of the policy. We show that, surprisingly, even cooperative models of enforcement are prone to exhibit coercive tendencies in multi-tier supply chains, leading to severe equity shortcomings. We provide recommendations and a research agenda to mitigate effectiveness-equity tradeoffs in multi-tier, forest-focused supply chain policies in the aim to improve the design, adoption, and implementation of such policies.
Chapter
Over the past three decades, the relationship between ecology and public policy has changed because of the increasing role of scientific uncertainty in environmental policy making. While earlier policy questions might have been solved simply by looking at the scientific technicalities of the issues, the increased role of scientific uncertainty in environmental policy making requires that we re-examine the methods used in decision-making. Previously, policymakers use scientific data to support their decision-making disciplinary boundaries are less useful because uncertain environmental policy problems span the natural sciences, engineering, economics, politics, and ethics. The chapter serves as a bridge integrating environmental ecosystem, media, and justice into policy for public health and safety. The chapter attempts to demonstrate the linkage between the environmental policy from a holistic perspective with the interaction of air, water, land, and human on public health and safety.
Article
This study investigates the impact of China’s new Environmental Protection Law on the green innovation behaviour of listed companies in high-polluting industries. The implementation of China’s strict and new Environmental Protection Law provides a quasi-natural experimental setting for examining the causal effect of environmental regulation on corporate green innovation. Based on data of the application for environmental patents of high-polluting firms listed in Shanghai and Shenzhen Stock Exchanges from 2010 to 2017, this study analyses the change in the green innovation behaviour of firms after the implementation of China’s new and stringent Environmental Protection Law using the PSM-DID approach. We find that firms tend to file more applications for environmental patents, including patents for inventions and utility models after the implementation of the new Environmental Protection Law. Further analysis shows that while this effect is stronger for state-owned enterprises, it is weaker for firms headquartered in cities where economies depend more on the secondary industry. Firms in concentrated industries have more incentive to file applications for green invention patents than those in competitive industries. The study has important implications for policy makers on better implementing the environmental protection law in developing countries.
Article
State and local governments engage each other in a broad set of complicated interdependent relationships. Yet, there is limited research on what these multilevel governance relationships mean for community-focused sustainability. This study applies a transaction cost federalism framework to examine the hierarchical influences of state fiscal support and policy actions on municipal commitments to sustainability at the community-level. An analysis of U.S. cities reveals that state investments in energy programs encourage municipal efforts for incentivized energy efficiency initiatives for local taxpayers. Larger percentages of state funding directed to energy programs lead to stronger municipal commitments to incentivized sustainability programs such as individual grants, direct loans and tax incentives. The results suggest that stable and supportive multilevel governance systems are key for reducing political transaction costs inherent within vertical systems driven by coercive authority. These findings produce theoretical and practical implications for understanding community-level sustainability within the face of “contested federalism.”
Article
What are the forces that drive increasing adoption of voluntary agreements in the policy field? This paper attempts to answer the question by analyzing the mechanism behind the adoption by 877 entities of the voluntary energy efficiency and GHG reduction agreement (VA) that was in place between 1999 and 2010 in South Korea. We argue that in South Korea's distinct regulatory context, participation in a public voluntary program (PVP), a VA, is a manifestation of participant entities' varied motivations as well as regulatory and social-normative pressures that arise from the institutionalization of the VA program. In addition, aligning the PVP with other policy programs such as eco-labelling program was found to have provided additional incentives for adoption while public ownership, socioeconomic status and environmental management capacity of targeted entities were significant factors. Thus, this study analyzes changes in the motives of participant entities over the course of the program's maturation and demonstrates how government and industries adopt and manage a PVP for policy learning and strategic regulation in the area of energy efficiency management and GHG reduction.
Article
This study focuses on de facto environmental enforcement and tests whether the practice of environmental enforcement discriminates against foreign-invested firms in a developing country. Using original firm-level enforcement data in the Jiangsu province of China, 2012–2014, this article examines the effect of foreign ownership on the enforcement of three regulatory instruments: economic incentives, command-and-control, and naming-and-shaming. After controlling for firms’ environmental performance, I find that firms with foreign ownership 1) pay fewer pollution fees, 2) are less likely to be punished, and 3) are more likely to obtain the highest score in the environmental credit rating system than domestic firms.
Article
Full-text available
A new global activism is shaming the world's top companies into enacting codes of conduct and opening their Third World factories for inspection. But before you run a victory lap in your new sweatshop-free sneakers, ask yourself: Do these voluntary arrangements truly help workers and the environment, or do they merely weaken local governments while adding more green to the corporate bottom line?
Article
Full-text available
Responsible Care is a voluntary code of conduct developed, enforced, and monitored by the Chemical Manufacturers Association. Voluntary codes could be designed and enforced by regulators, nonprofit groups, industry associations, and individual firms. They could vary in their scope, focusing on firms around the globe, in a given region, within a country, or in a given industry. This article focuses on Responsible Care’s self-regulatory services that pertain to establishing, monitoring, and enforcing industry-wide environmental, health, and safety standards. Employing insights from the club theory, stakeholder theory, institutionalist theory, and the corporate social performance perspective, it examines the demand and supply sides of voluntary codes. Finally, it discusses theoretical implications and the key challenges faced by Responsible Care in the future.
Article
Full-text available
A good reputation can be an effective bond for honest behavior in a community of traders if members of the community know how others have behaved in the past - even if any particular pair of traders meets only infrequently. In a large community, it would be impossibly costly for traders to be perfectly informed about each other's behavior, but there exist institutions that can restore the effectiveness of a reputation system using much less extensive information. The system of judges used to enforce commercial law before the rise of the state was such an institution, and it successfully encouraged merchants (1) to behave honestly, (2) to impose sanctions on violators, (3) to become adequately informed about how others had behaved, (4) to provide evidence against violators of the code, and (5) to pay any judgments assessed against them, even though each of these behaviors might be personally costly. Copyright 1990 Blackwell Publishers Ltd..
Article
Last July, the Environmental Protection Agency publicly recommitted itself to its reinvention efforts in a report titled Aiming for Excellence: Actions to Encourage Stewardship and Accelerate Environmental Progress. One of the 'actions' continues the agency's search for workable and effective programs that use incentives to inspire and reward those businesses achieving environmental performance beyond what is required by law or regulation. This proposal would create a 'dual track' regulatory system. The new Performance Track would invite facilities to meet certain voluntary requirements, in return for which they would receive a mix of regulatory, financial, and other benefits. The remaining facilities would stay on the other track-the existing compliance-oriented system.
Article
Article
Plan of the Book. Introduction: Environmental Management.Part 1: BETWEEN REGULATION AND SELF-REGULATION.1. Business Perspectives on Regulation. 2. International Policy and Voluntary Initiatives. 3. Strategies and The Environment.Part 2: FROM THEORY TO PRACTICE.4. Environmental Management Systems and Standards. 5. Environmental Reporting. 6. Environmental Management Accounting. 7. Conclusions: Dilemmas of Environmental Management. Bibliography. Index.
Article
Companies in many countries complain of the unfairness of having to compete against foreign rivals facing more lenient environmental regulations. In this article I examine the competitive conditions for firms in such a position. I outline the development of ct new pollution-reduction paradigm centered on lowering costs by reducing pollution and, using twelve scenarios of international differences in environmental regulatory regimes faced by first movers and imitators, make propositions on which factors are important to the maintainability of these advantages.
Article
The term "Prisoner's Dilemma" comes from the original anecdote used to illustrate this game of strategy. Two prisoners, held incommunicado, are charged with the same crime. They can be convicted only if either confesses. If both prisoners confess, their payoff is minus one. If neither confesses, it is plus one. If only one confesses, he is set free for having turned state's evidence and is given a reward of plus two to boot. The prisoner who holds out is convicted on the strength of the other's testimony and is given a more severe sentence than if he had confessed. His payoff is minus two. It is in the interest of each to confess no matter what the other does, but it is in their collective interest to hold out. There is no satisfactory solution to the paradox of this game. Its simplicity is misleading. What seems rational from your own point of view, turns out to be detrimental in the end. This book is an account of many experiments in which Prisoner's Dilemma was played. Analyzing the results, one can learn how people are motivated to trust or distrust their partners, to keep faith or to betray, to be guided by joint or selfish interest. The method represents an important step toward building a bridge between psychology which is based on hard data and reproducible experiments and psychology which is concerned with internal conflict.
Article
Even when political interests control bureaucratic outputs, the control of policy outcomes is complicated by trade-offs between controllable versus effective implementation strategies. I use a nested game framework to explain why a cooperative strategy can increase enforcement effectiveness in the narrow administrative game and why principal-agent control problems and collective action problems associated with the strategy lead policy beneficiaries to oppose the effective strategy in the broader political games. Analyses of state-level Occupational Safety and Health Administration enforcement provide evidence that cooperation does enhance the impact of enforcement in reducing workplace injury rates but that policy beneficiaries oppose and sabotage cooperation. The interactions between administrative effectiveness and interest group politics in this and other implementation situations require that both be analyzed simultaneously, and the nested game framework can provide a systematic approach to such analyses.
Article
Historically. management theory has ignored the constraints imposed by the biophysical (natural) environment. Building upon resource-based theory, this article attempts to fill this void by proposing a natural-resource-based view of the firm-a theory of competitive advantage based upon the firm's relationship to the natural environment. It is composed of three interconnected strategies: pollution prevention, product stewardship, and sustainable development. Propositions are advanced for each of these strategies regarding key resource requirements and their contributions to sustained competitive advantage.
Article
The study of urban politics has undergone considerable change over the last ten to fifteen years. During the 1950s and 1960s the ‘community power’ approach became well-established in American political science as the dominant form of analysis of local politics, although it was less marked in Britain. In contrast, and in part as reaction, to the ecological determinism and naturalistic explanation of the Chicago school in urban sociology that preceded it, power and decision making were seen as key features in explaining urban processes. Intentionality and human action were afforded explanatory dominance. In turn, however, this approach came under sustained critique as part of the ‘anti-behaviouralist’ or structuralist resurgence in Western social science in the 1970s which attributed causal primacy to structural determination and system contradictions, not actors or voluntarism. Yet structural approaches face methodological problems of functionalism and circularity, and in constructing tests of empirical adequacy and falsifiability. Some of the more interesting, recently-published work in urban politics seeks to maintain a non-behaviouralist, more structuralist interpretation of local policy outcomes within empirically-grounded analyses that allow space for politics and power. Dunleavy, Friedland and Saunders provided three of the best examples of such an approach, and have each sought to understand either a particular policy, or a set of policies in a particular locality, through frameworks which in varying degrees incorporate structuralist assumptions. They seek to apply objective cost-benefit analyses of public policies as empirically refutable hypotheses and accept the necessity of objective criteria for assessing whether or not interests have been met in any given situation. This article examines the extent to which these selected ‘non-behaviouralist’ interpretations of urban politics have successfully been applied to empirical contexts. A central element in this examination is a consideration of the way in which business is seen as a major influence in local politics.
Article
Increasing attention to environmental management has raised many new dilemmas for firms. How can managers deal with environmental issues in a competitive situation that is international and heterogeneous? What are the strategic and financial implications of environmental management? How can they cope with regulation, considering the choices which range from compliance to voluntary initiatives? And how do other firms organise their environmental management and communicate with stakeholders? This book examines these different topics, without dogma or prescription. It demonstrates the complexity of an area in which there are often no right or easy answers. The Economics of Environmental Management: 7 shows the links between the main functional areas of a business and environmental management; 7 examines regulation and self-regulation in different countries and worldwide; 7 pays specific attention to multinational enterprises; 7 gives an international state of the art on environmental management systems and standards (especially ISO 14001 and EMAS); on environmental reporting and verification; and on environmental management accounting; 7 contains international case examples and a wealth of annotated references to paper and electronic sources.
Article
Environmental Management Systems (EMSS) represent a new generation of voluntary “beyond compliance” environmental policies that neither set substantive goals nor specify final outcomes. As a result, many stakeholder groups are lukewarm toward them. Since 1993 two major supranational EMSs—ISO 14001 and the European Union's Environmental Management and Audit Scheme (EMAS)—have been introduced. Firms receive formal accreditation after their EMS has been certified by outside verifiers. This accreditation can potentially bestow monetary and nonmonetary benefits on these firms. Firm-level EMS adoption patterns in the United Kingdom, Germany, and the United States vary, thereby suggesting that national contexts influence firms' responses to them. In Germany and the U.K. a significant number of sites have become either ISO 14001 or EMAS certified, while the take-up of ISO 14001 in the U.S. (EMAS is available only to European sites) has been less enthusiastic. This article begins with the hypothesis that firms in countries with adversarial economies— where regulators and business are on less than friendly terms—are less likely to adopt EMS-based programs. This hypothesis explains why ISO 14001 take-up has been relatively high in the U.K. and relatively low in the U.S. However, it cannot explain (1) the high rate of take-up of both ISO 14001 and EMAS in Germany, where the stringency of environmental legislation has been a contentious issue between the government and industry and (2) why EMAS has been more popular in Germany than in the U.K. This article argues that the original hypothesis, while largely correct, is underspecified. To better explain the cross-national differences in EMS adoption, one must take into account the type of adversarial economy (adversarial legalism versus prescriptive interventionism) and the nature of the policy regime (procedural versus substantive).
Article
Using data from electric utilities, this study shows that spending on well designed regulations has a positive productivity impact but that spending on less well-designed regulations has a negative effect. Better-designed regulations are flexible and grant firms latitude on how to meet goals, allow them time to deploy new means to meet goals, and set ambitious goals that stretch them beyond current practices.
Article
This article reports data that contrast with an extended tradition of viewing litigation as incompatible with ongoing relationships. Within the regulatory process at the U. S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), nongovernmental actors having the most sustained relationships with EPA are the ones most likely to engage in litigation against the agency. Litigation within regulatory relationships is not explained by existing theory, which treats litigation largely as a function of relationships. A disturbance theory of disputing, which focuses on how litigation interacts with existing relationships, provides a more robust account of litigation generally and of its compatibility with ongoing regulatory relationships.
Article
Environmental policy in the United States has always been characterized by high levels of political conflict. At the same time, however, policy makers have shown a capacity to learn from their own and others' experience. This article examines U.S. environmental policy since 1970 as a learning process and, more specifically, as an effort to develop three kinds of capacities for policy learning. The first decade and a half may be seen in terms of technical learning, characterized by a high degree of technical and legal proficiency, but also narrow problem definitions, institutional fragmentation, and adversarial relations among actors. In the 1980s, growing recognition of deficiencies in technical learning led to a search for new goals, strategies, and policy instruments, in what may be termed conceptual learning . By the early 1990s, policy makers also recognized a need for a new set of capacities at social learning, reflecting trends in European environmental policy, international interest in the concept of sustainability, and dissatisfaction with the U.S. experience. Social learning stresses communication and interaction among actors. Most industrial nations, including the United States, are working to develop and integrate capacities for all three kinds of learning. Efforts to integrate capacities for conceptual and social learning in the United States have had mixed success, however, because the institutional and legal framework for environmental policy still is founded on technical learning.
Article
Compared to other economically advanced democracies, the United States is uniquely prone to adversarial, legalistic modes of policy formulation and implementation, shaped by the prospect of judicial review. While adversarial legalism facilitates the expression of justice-claims and challenges to official dogma, its costs are often neglected or minimized. A survey of existing research, together with a case study of environmental regulation in the Port of Oakland, indicates the extent to which adversarial legalism causes (or threatens) enormous dispute-resolving costs and procedural delays, which in turn distort policy outcomes. Adversarial legalism, moreover, has increased in recent decades, as Americans have attempted to implement the ambitious, socially transformative policies of activist government through political structures, forms of legislation, and legal procedures that reflect deep suspicion of governmental authority.
Article
Proponents of federal environmental standards argue that competition for industrial development creates a “race to the bottom” in which states relax their own environmental standards to avoid losing businesses to states with more “business-friendly” regulations. This article presents results from a unique survey of state clean air programs that show—contrary to the race to the bottom—a substantial number of states exceed federal EPA standards in a broad variety of clean air programs. Multivariate analyses of these state policies indicate that states strengthen their environmental programs in response to citizen demands rather than weaken their programs in deference to economic pressures.
Book
This book transcends current debate on government regulation by lucidly outlining how regulations can be a fruitful combination of persuasion and sanctions. The regulation of business by the United States government is often ineffective despite being more adversarial in tone than in other nations. The authors draw on both empirical studies of regulation from around the world and modern game theory to illustrate innovative solutions to this problem. Their ideas include an argument for the empowerment of private and public interest groups in the regulatory process and a provocative discussion of how the government can support and encourage industry self-regulation.
Book
Over the last two decades environmental issues have become important in public and business policy. This book asks why firms sometimes voluntarily adopt environmental policies which go beyond legal requirements. It employs a new-institutionalist perspective, and argues that existing explanations, especially from neoclassical economics, concentrate on external factors at the expense of internal dynamics. Prakash argues that ‘beyond-compliance’ policies are due to two types of intra-firm processes, which he describes as power- and leadership-based. His argument is supported by analysis of ten cases within two firms - Baxter International Inc. and Eli Lilly and Company - including interviews with managers, and access to meetings and documents. This book therefore examines the internal working of firms’ environmental policy in a theoretically rigorous way, providing a significant contribution to the theory of the firm. It will be valuable for students of business and environmental studies, as well as political economy and public policy.