Butter J, McGaghie WC, Cohen ER, Kaye M, Wayne DB. Simulation-based mastery learning improves cardiac auscultation skills in medical students

Augusta Webster, MD Office of Medical Education and Faculty Development, Northwestern University Feinberg School of Medicine, Chicago, IL, USA.
Journal of General Internal Medicine (Impact Factor: 3.42). 03/2010; 25(8):780-5. DOI: 10.1007/s11606-010-1309-x
Source: PubMed


Cardiac auscultation is a core clinical skill. However, prior studies show that trainee skills are often deficient and that clinical experience is not a proxy for competence.
To describe a mastery model of cardiac auscultation education and evaluate its effectiveness in improving bedside cardiac auscultation skills.
Untreated control group design with pretest and posttest.
Third-year students who received a cardiac auscultation curriculum and fourth year students who did not.
A cardiac auscultation curriculum consisting of a computer tutorial and a cardiac patient simulator. All third-year students were required to meet or exceed a minimum passing score (MPS) set by an expert panel at posttest.
Diagnostic accuracy with simulated heart sounds and actual patients.
Trained third-year students (n = 77) demonstrated significantly higher cardiac auscultation accuracy compared to untrained fourth year students (n = 31) in assessment of simulated heart sounds (93.8% vs. 73.9%, p < 0.001) and with real patients (81.8% vs. 75.1%, p = 0.003). USMLE scores correlated modestly with a computer-based multiple choice assessment using simulated heart sounds but not with bedside skills on real patients.
A cardiac auscultation curriculum consisting of deliberate practice with a computer-based tutorial and a cardiac patient simulator resulted in improved assessment of simulated heart sounds and more accurate examination of actual patients.

Download full-text


Available from: John Butter, Aug 21, 2014
  • Source
    • "To transfer a skill successfully, students must learn to adjust their performance to the variety of conditions in real clinical situations [12,13]. Few studies have shown that simulation training improves participants’ performance on real patients [14,15], and no studies have investigated UC performance. "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Inexperienced interns are responsible for most iatrogenic complications after urethral catheterization (UC). Although training on simulators is common, little is known about the transfer of learned skills to real clinical practice. This study aimed to evaluate the short- and long-term effects of UC simulated skills training on performance on real patients and to examine whether watching a video of the procedure immediately before assessment enhanced clinical performance. This was an experimental study of the effect of a UC simulation-based skills course on medical students' short-term (after one week) and long-term (after six weeks) performance. The additional effect of video instruction before performance testing on real patients was studied in a randomized trial. Sixty-four students participated in the study, which was preceded by a pilot study investigating the validity aspects of a UC assessment form. The pilot study demonstrated sufficient inter-rater reliability, intra-class correlation coefficient 0.86, and a significant ability to discriminate between trainee performances when using the assessment form, p= 0.001. In the main study, more than 90% of students demonstrated an acceptable performance or better when tested on real patients. There was no significant difference in the total score between the one-week and the six-week groups when tested on real patients and no significant difference between the video and the control groups. Medical students demonstrated good transfer of UC skills learned in the skills lab to real clinical situations up to six weeks after training. Simulated UC training should be the standard for all medical school curricula to reduce avoidable complications. However, this study did not demonstrate that an instructional video, as a supplement to simulated skills training, improved clinical UC performance. Current Controlled Trials ISRCTN:ISRCTN90745002.
    Full-text · Article · Feb 2013 · BMC Medical Education
  • Source
    • "focused, repetitive practice; (2) rigorously measuring performance to provide feedback and encourage learners to correct errors through repeated practice; and (3) evaluating learners to certify mastery and promote them to the next task (McGaghie et al. 2011). In clinical medicine, deliberate practice has previously been applied mainly to procedural and physical exam skills, such as advanced cardiac life support (Wayne et al. 2008), central line insertion (Barsuk et al. 2009), and cardiac auscultation (Butter et al. 2010). "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Background: Oral case presentations are critical for patient care and student assessment. The best method to prepare early medical students for oral presentations is unknown. Aim: We aimed to develop and evaluate a curriculum of on-line learning and deliberate practice to improve pre-clinical students' case presentation skills. Methods: We developed a web-based, interactive curriculum emphasizing conciseness and clinical reasoning. Using a waitlist control design, we randomly assigned groups of second-year students to receive the curriculum in December 2010 or in April 2011. We evaluated their presentations at three time points. We also examined the performance of an untrained class of students as a historical comparison. Results: We evaluated 132 second-year medical students at three time points. After the curriculum, mean scores of the intervention students improved from 60.2% to 70.1%, while scores of the waitlist control students improved less, from 61.8% to 64.5% (p < 0.01 for between-group difference in improvement). Once all students had received the curriculum, mean scores for the intervention and waitlist control students rose to 77.8% and 78.4%, respectively, compared to 68.1% for the untrained comparison students (p < 0.0001 compared to all curriculum students). Conclusion: An on-line curriculum followed by deliberate practice improved students' oral presentation skills.
    Full-text · Article · Aug 2012 · Medical Teacher
  • Source
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: The development of a high harmonic gyrotron using a permanent magnet system is presented. On the basis of the design for a high harmonic gyrotron, using an encircling large-orbit electron beam and a permanent magnet system (large orbit gyrotron, LOG), a gyrotron tube has been constructed. The construction of a permanent magnet system has been also completed. The maximum field intensity is a little bit higher than 1 T. This work is being carried out as a collaboration with the Shin-etsu Kagaku Company, Institute of Applied Physics, Russian Academy of Science (IAP-RAS) and Institute of Electronics, and Bulgarian Academy of Science (IE-BAS). The gyrotron has already achieved 3rd, 4th and 5th harmonic operations with relatively high efficiency. Corresponding frequencies are 89 GHz, 113 GHz and 138 GHz, respectively. The output power at the 3rd harmonic operation was 2.5 kW and the efficiency 6.3%.
    Full-text · Conference Paper · Jul 2004
Show more