A Two-Tiered Model for Simulating the Ecological and Evolutionary Dynamics of Rapidly Evolving Viruses, with an Application to Influenza

Department of Biology, Duke University, , PO Box 90338, Durham, NC 27708, USA.
Journal of The Royal Society Interface (Impact Factor: 3.92). 03/2010; 7(50):1257-74. DOI: 10.1098/rsif.2010.0007
Source: PubMed


Understanding the epidemiological and evolutionary dynamics of rapidly evolving pathogens is one of the most challenging problems facing disease ecologists today. To date, many mathematical and individual-based models have provided key insights into the factors that may regulate these dynamics. However, in many of these models, abstractions have been made to the simulated sequences that limit an effective interface with empirical data. This is especially the case for rapidly evolving viruses in which de novo mutations result in antigenically novel variants. With this focus, we present a simple two-tiered 'phylodynamic' model whose purpose is to simulate, along with case data, sequence data that will allow for a more quantitative interface with observed sequence data. The model differs from previous approaches in that it separates the simulation of the epidemiological dynamics (tier 1) from the molecular evolution of the virus's dominant antigenic protein (tier 2). This separation of phenotypic dynamics from genetic dynamics results in a modular model that is computationally simpler and allows sequences to be simulated with specifications such as sequence length, nucleotide composition and molecular constraints. To illustrate its use, we apply the model to influenza A (H3N2) dynamics in humans, influenza B dynamics in humans and influenza A (H3N8) dynamics in equine hosts. In all three of these illustrative examples, we show that the model can simulate sequences that are quantitatively similar in pattern to those empirically observed. Future work should focus on statistical estimation of model parameters for these examples as well as the possibility of applying this model, or variants thereof, to other host-virus systems.

Full-text preview

Available from:
  • Source
    • "Yet, how likely the accumulation of the additional three mutations assumed to confer airborne transmissibility are to evolve, and how this compares with the likelihood of re-assortment remains unanswered [14]. Theoretical frameworks combining IAVs' evolutionary and epidemic dynamics have been developed in recent years, shedding light on the mechanisms of seasonal IAV global evolution, largely driven by the interplay of cross-immunity and seasonality15161718192021. Most approaches explored the extent of IAVs' evolution at the level of the human population, with selection acting upon IAV transmission . "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Large outbreaks of zoonotic influenza A virus (IAV) infections may presage an influenza pandemic. However, the likelihood that an airborne-transmissible variant evolves upon zoonotic infection or co-infection with zoonotic and seasonal IAVs remains poorly understood, as does the relative importance of accumulating mutations versus re-assortment in this process. Using discrete-time probabilistic models, we determined quantitative probability ranges that transmissible variants with 1–5 mutations and transmissible re-assortants evolve after a given number of zoonotic IAV infections. The systematic exploration of a large population of model parameter values was designed to account for uncertainty and variability in influenza virus infection, epidemiological and evolutionary processes. The models suggested that immunocompromised individuals are at high risk of generating IAV variants with pandemic potential by accumulation of mutations. Yet, both immunocompetent and immunocompromised individuals could generate high viral loads of single and double mutants, which may facilitate their onward transmission and the subsequent accumulation of additional 1–2 mutations in newly-infected individuals. This may result in the evolution of a full transmissible genotype along short chains of contact transmission. Although co-infection with zoonotic and seasonal IAVs was shown to be a rare event, it consistently resulted in high viral loads of re-assortants, which may facilitate their onward transmission among humans. The prevention or limitation of zoonotic IAV infection in immunocompromised and contact individuals, including health care workers, as well as vaccination against seasonal IAVs—limiting the risk of co-infection—should be considered fundamental tools to thwart the evolution of a novel pandemic IAV by accumulation of mutations and re-assortment.
    Full-text · Article · Oct 2015 · Vaccine
  • Source
    • "Additionally, they are not amenable to analytic treatment. In recent years, along with other contributions in agent-based modeling frameworks (Cobey and Pascual, 2011; Buckee et al., 2011; Zinder et al., 2013), the effort to deal with multistrain dynamics in a deterministic setting has been continued (Adams and Sasaki, 2007, 2009; Minayev and Ferguson, 2009a,b; Koelle et al., 2010; Kucharski and Gog, 2012). "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Starting from common assumptions, we build a rate equation model for multi-strain disease dynamics in terms of immune repertoire classes. We then move to a strain-level description where a low-order closure reminiscent of a pair approximation can be applied. We characterize the endemic equilibrium of the ensuing model in the absence of mutation and discuss the presence of degeneracy regarding the prevalence of the different strains. Finally we study the behavior of the system under the injection of mutant strains.
    Preview · Article · Apr 2014 · Journal of Theoretical Biology
  • Source
    • "duce a spurious signal of clonal interference in the frequency propagator statistics . This model describes neutral searches in epitope sequence space interspersed with selective sweeps triggered by beneficial escape mutants ( Ferguson et . al , 2003 ; Gog et al . , 2003 ; Tria et al . , 2005 ; Koelle et al . , 2006 ; Minayev and Ferguson , 2009 ; Koelle et al . , 2010 ) . Starting from an initial genotype with fitness F 0 , new epitope mutations are neutral with probability 1"
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: The seasonal influenza A virus undergoes rapid evolution to escape human immune response. Adaptive changes occur primarily in antigenic epitopes, the antibody-binding domains of the viral hemagglutinin. This process involves recurrent selective sweeps, in which clusters of simultaneous nucleotide fixations in the hemagglutinin coding sequence are observed about every 4 years. Here, we show that influenza A (H3N2) evolves by strong clonal interference. This mode of evolution is a red queen race between viral strains with different beneficial mutations. Clonal interference explains and quantifies the observed sweep pattern: we find an average of at least one strongly beneficial amino acid substitution per year, and a given selective sweep has three to four driving mutations on average. The inference of selection and clonal interference is based on frequency time series of single-nucleotide polymorphisms, which are obtained from a sample of influenza genome sequences over 39 years. Our results imply that mode and speed of influenza evolution are governed not only by positive selection within, but also by background selection outside antigenic epitopes: immune adaptation and conservation of other viral functions interfere with each other. Hence, adapting viral proteins are predicted to be particularly brittle. We conclude that a quantitative understanding of influenza's evolutionary and epidemiological dynamics must be based on all genomic domains and functions coupled by clonal interference.
    Full-text · Article · Jul 2012 · Genetics
Show more