ArticlePDF Available

Value Computations in Ventral Medial Prefrontal Cortex during Charitable Decision Making Incorporate Input from Regions Involved in Social Cognition

January 2010
The Journal of Neuroscience : The Official Journal of the Society for Neuroscience 30(2):583-90

DOI:10.1523/JNEUROSCI.4089-09.2010

Source
PubMed

License
CC BY-NC-SA 4.0

Authors:

Todd A Hare

University of Zurich

Colin Farrell Camerer

California Institute of Technology

Dan Knoepfle

Stanford University

Antonio Vicente Rangel

Central University of Venezuela

Little is known about the neural networks supporting value computation during complex social decisions. We investigated this question using functional magnetic resonance imaging while subjects made donations to different charities. We found that the blood oxygenation level-dependent signal in ventral medial prefrontal cortex (VMPFC) correlated with the subjective value of voluntary donations. Furthermore, the region of the VMPFC identified showed considerable overlap with regions that have been shown to encode for the value of basic rewards at the time of choice, suggesting that it might serve as a common valuation system during decision making. In addition, functional connectivity analyses indicated that the value signal in VMPFC might integrate inputs from networks, including the anterior insula and posterior superior temporal cortex, that are thought to be involved in social cognition.

…

Figures - uploaded by Todd A Hare

Content may be subject to copyright.

Content uploaded by Todd A Hare

Content may be subject to copyright.

Available via license: CC BY-NC-SA 4.0

Content may be subject to copyright.

A preview of the PDF is not available

Moral conviction interacts with metacognitive ability in modulating neural activity during sociopolitical decision-making

Article

Dec 2024
COGN AFFECT BEHAV NE

The extent to which a belief is rooted in one’s sense of morality has significant societal implications. While moral conviction can inspire positive collective action, it can also prompt dogmatism, intolerance, and societal divisions. Research in social psychology has documented the functional characteristics of moral conviction and shows that poor metacognition exacerbates its negative outcomes. However, the cognitive and neural mechanisms underlying moral conviction, their relationship with metacognition, and how moral conviction is integrated into the valuation and decision-making process remain unclear. This study investigated these neurocognitive processes during decision-making on sociopolitical issues varying in moral conviction. Participants (N = 44) underwent fMRI scanning while deciding, on each trial, which of two groups of political protesters they supported more. As predicted, stronger moral conviction was associated with faster decision times. Hemodynamic responses in the anterior insula (aINS), anterior cingulate cortex (ACC), and lateral prefrontal cortex (lPFC) were elevated during decisions with higher moral conviction, supporting the emotional and cognitive dimensions of moral conviction. Functional connectivity between lPFC and vmPFC was greater on trials higher in moral conviction, elucidating mechanisms through which moral conviction is incorporated into valuation. Average support for the two displayed groups of protesters was positively associated with brain activity in regions involved in valuation, particularly vmPFC and amygdala. Metacognitive sensitivity, the ability to discriminate one’s correct from incorrect judgments, measured in a perceptual task, negatively correlated with parametric effects of moral conviction in the brain, providing new evidence that metacognition modulates responses to morally convicted issues.

Systematic and Bibliometric Review of Neuroeconomics and Neurofinance Research: Current Status, Thematic Trends, and Future Directions

Article

Dec 2024
J ECON SURV

The aim of this study is to provide a systematic and bibliometric overview of neuroeconomics and neurofinance research. The study analyzes 507 articles published in peer-reviewed journals in the Web of Science (WoS) database spanning from 1994 to February 2024. The research is conducted in two phases; initially, a performance analysis, followed by a science mapping analysis. Through performance analysis, we pinpoint significant authors, notable journals, leading countries, and influential articles within these research fields. With the science mapping, we utilize co-citation, bibliographic coupling, and co-word analyses to uncover the thematic and intellectual framework of research in neuroeconomics and neurofinance. Overall, we reveal prominent research themes, including reward, decision-making under risk, value, game theory, and intertemporal choices. Classical decision-making theory divides the decision-making process into three interconnected stages: identifying options, evaluating them, and making a choice. The research themes we revealed through science mapping analysis constitute different aspects of the evaluation stage. Accordingly, our results suggest that neuroeconomics and neurofinance research has mainly concentrated on the evaluation stage (and, to a lesser extent, the choice stage with value theme), while the process of identifying options has been relatively understudied, despite its vital significance in less structured, real-world situations. Alongside revealing research themes, we ultimately spotlight research directions within neuroeconomics and neurofinance.

Perilaku Prososial

Chapter

Full-text available

Jun 2023

Nurfitriany Fakhri

Attenuation processes in positive social emotion upregulation: Disentangling functional role of ventrolateral prefrontal cortex

Article

Feb 2025

Being honest when tempted to cheat elicits activation in reward-related brain regions and protects mood

Preprint

Full-text available

Jan 2025

Scientific discourse often posits that for humans being honest in tempting situations, where cheating would go unnoticed, is inherently costly. Because honesty requires sacrificing immediate extrinsic rewards and enduring the aversive costs of recruiting control processes, it is difficult to argue that honesty holds inherent value for the individual. In this research, we challenge this assumption by demonstrating that honesty can be intrinsically rewarding, offsetting the inherent costs of control (Study 1) and mitigating the negative emotional impact of foregoing extrinsic rewards (Study 2). Specifically, we found that choosing honesty over a reward was associated with increased activity in reward-related brain regions, reflecting its intrinsic value (Study 1, n = 65), and a weaker negative effect on participants’ mood after missing an additional reward, highlighting its emotional buffering effects (Study 2, n = 2,005). These findings suggest that beyond the moral imperative, honesty carries an immediate intrinsic benefit that can promote honest behavior.

Economic inequality and relative deprivation influence prosocial decisions towards moral and immoral causes

Article

Full-text available

Dec 2024

Economic inequality influences the decisions made by people including prosocial decisions. People make prosocial choices to support organizations that might be moral or immoral in nature. Prosocial choices create moral conflict pitting material values against moral values. Prosociality towards moral cause involves moral gain at material cost. Contrastingly, prosociality towards immoral cause involves material gain at moral cost. How are such choices affected by economic inequality and feelings of relative deprivation? Under high and low economic inequality, we had three experimentally induced relative deprivation groups; best-off, middle, and worst-off. We found that high economic inequality led to more prosocial decisions towards immoral causes in order to gain monetary benefit. Additionally, the worst-off group gave more to immoral causes as compared to best-off group. However, it was the middle group that donated most to immoral cause for material benefit. This was not the case for moral cause. Our study presents important findings for understanding the charitable activities of not just rich and poor, but also middle-income groups under high economic inequality. Our findings suggest that deprived individuals ameliorate their status quo through immoral choices but also show generosity at personal cost in order to help others. This suggests that prosocial behavior is more complex and contextually dependent than earlier understood.

Neural correlates of empathy in donation decisions: Insights from EEG and machine learning

Article

Nov 2024
NEUROSCIENCE

Modality-specific and modality-general representations of subjective value in frontal cortex

Article

Full-text available

Nov 2024

Neuroeconomics theories propose that the value associated with diverse rewards or reward-predicting stimuli is encoded along a common reference scale, irrespective of their sensory properties. However, in a dynamic environment with changing stimulus-reward pairings, the brain must also represent the sensory features of rewarding stimuli. The mechanism by which the brain balances these needs—deriving a common reference scale for valuation while maintaining sensitivity to sensory contexts—remains unclear. To investigate this, we conducted an fMRI study with human participants engaged in a dynamic foraging task, which required integrating the reward history of auditory or visual choice options and updating the subjective value for each sensory modality. Univariate fMRI analysis revealed modality-specific value representations in the orbitofrontal cortex (OFC) and modality-general value representations in the ventromedial prefrontal cortex (vmPFC), confirmed by an exploratory multivariate pattern classification approach. Crucially, modality-specific value representations were absent when the task involved instruction-based rather than value-based choices. Effective connectivity analysis showed that modality-specific value representations emerged from selective bidirectional interactions across the auditory and visual sensory cortices, the corresponding OFC clusters, and the vmPFC. These results illustrate how the brain enables a valuation process that is sensitive to the sensory context of rewarding stimuli.

Neural Mechanisms of Cooperation and Fairness in Iterative Prisoner's Dilemma

Article

Sep 2024
BEHAV BRAIN RES

Policy shaping based on the learned preferences of others accounts for risky decision-making under social observation

Preprint

Full-text available

Sep 2024

Observing others’ choices influences individuals’ decisions, often leading them to follow others. However, it is repeatedly reported that being observed by others tends to make people act more riskily. We hypothesized that this discrepancy arises from individuals’ belief that others prefer riskier choices than they do. To examine this hypothesis, we used a gambling task where on some trials, individuals were informed that their choices would be observed by a risk- averse or seeking partner. Most important, individuals were given chances to learn each partner’s preference beforehand. As expected, individuals initially believed that partners would make relatively riskier choices than they would. Against two alternative explanations, we found that individuals simulated partners’ choices and weighed these simulated choices in making their own choices. Using functional magnetic resonance imaging, we showed that decision probabilities adjusted with the simulated partners’ choices were represented in the temporoparietal junction (TPJ). Moreover, individual differences in the functional connectivity between the TPJ and the medial prefrontal cortex (mPFC) were explained by the interaction between model-estimated social reliance and sensitivity to social cues in the mPFC. These findings provide a neuromechanistic account of how being observed by others affects individuals’ decision-making, highlighting the roles of the mPFC and TPJ in simulating social contexts based on individuals’ beliefs.

Social neuroeconomics: The neural circuitry of social preferences

Article

Full-text available

Oct 2007

Combining the methods of neuroscience and economics generates powerful tools for studying the brain processes behind human social interaction. We argue that hedonic interpretations of theories of social preferences provide a useful framework that generates interesting predictions and helps interpret brain activations involved in altruistic, fair and trusting behaviors. These behaviours are consistently associated with activation in reward-related brain areas such as the striatum and with prefrontal activity implicated in cognitive control, the processing of emotions, and integration of benefits and costs, consistent with resolution of a conflict between self-interest and other-regarding motives.

The moderator-mediator variable distinction in social psychological research: Conceptual, strategic, and statistical considerations

Article

Full-text available

Jan 1986
J PERS SOC PSYCHOL

In this article, we attempt to distinguish between the properties of moderator and mediator variables at a number of levels. First, we seek to make theorists and researchers aware of the importance of not using the terms moderator and mediator interchangeably by carefully elaborating, both conceptually and strategically, the many ways in which moderators and mediators differ. We then go beyond this largely pedagogical function and delineate the conceptual and strategic implications of making use of such distinctions with regard to a wide range of phenomena, including control and stress, attitudes, and personality traits. We also provide a specific compendium of analytic procedures appropriate for making the most effective use of the moderator and mediator distinction, both separately and in terms of a broader causal system that includes both moderators and mediators. (46 ref) (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2012 APA, all rights reserved)

Multiple forms of value learning and the function of dopamine

Article

Full-text available

Jan 2008

A Theory Of Fairness, Competition, and Cooperation

Article

Full-text available

Aug 1999

There is strong evidence that people exploit their bargaining power in competitive markets but not in bilateral bargaining situations. There is also strong evidence that people exploit free-riding opportunities in voluntary cooperation games. Yet, when they are given the opportunity to punish free riders, stable cooperation is maintained, although punishment is costly for those who punish. This paper asks whether there is a simple common principle that can explain this puzzling evidence. We show that if some people care about equity the puzzles can be resolved. It turns out that the economic environment determines whether the fair types or the selfish types dominate equilibrium behavior.

The Neural Correlated of Subjective Value During Intertemporal Choice

Article

Jan 2007

Neuroimaging studies of decision-making have generally related neural activity to objective measures (such as reward magnitude, probability or delay), despite choice preferences being subjective. However, economic theories posit that decision-makers behave as though different options have different subjective values. Here we use functional magnetic resonance imaging to show that neural activity in several brain regions—particularly the ventral striatum, medial prefrontal cortex and posterior cingulate cortex—tracks the revealed subjective value of delayed monetary rewards. This similarity provides unambiguous evidence that the subjective value of potential rewards is explicitly represented in the human brain.

Dissociating the Role of the Orbitofrontal Cortex and the Striatum in the Computation of Goal Values and Prediction Errors

Article

May 2008

To make sound economic decisions, the brain needs to compute several different value-related signals. These include goal values that measure the predicted reward that results from the outcome generated by each of the actions under consideration, decision values that measure the net value of taking the different actions, and prediction errors that measure deviations from individuals' previous reward expectations. We used functional magnetic resonance imaging and a novel decision-making paradigm to dissociate the neural basis of these three computations. Our results show that they are supported by different neural substrates: goal values are correlated with activity in the medial orbitofrontal cortex, decision values are correlated with activity in the central orbitofrontal cortex, and prediction errors are correlated with activity in the ventral striatum.

A framework for studying the neurobiology of value-based decision making

Article

Jul 2008
NAT REV NEUROSCI

Neuroeconomics is the study of the neurobiological and computational basis of value-based decision making. Its goal is to provide a biologically based account of human behaviour that can be applied in both the natural and the social sciences. This Review proposes a framework to investigate different aspects of the neurobiology of decision making. The framework allows us to bring together recent findings in the field, highlight some of the most important outstanding problems, define a common lexicon that bridges the different disciplines that inform neuroeconomics, and point the way to future applications.

Multiple Forms of Value Learning and the Function of Dopamine

Article

Dec 2009

This chapter describes behavioral evidence for distinct value functions. A classical economic notion of choice assumes that people evaluate options according to their expected utilities. Human and animal actions, however, are not nearly so unitary. Psychologists have long attempted to distinguish bona fide decisions from other behaviors, such as reflexes, that might only appear to be choice-like. In one view, for an action to qualify as truly volitional or goal-directed it should depend on two factors, which echo the probability and utility of an outcome from the standard formula for expected utility. The first is knowledge of the contingency between the action and some outcome; the second is the valuation of that outcome as a desirable goal. A critical distinction between reflexive responses and goal-directed actions is that the latter are controlled by knowledge of their relationship to their consequences whereas the former are not. Classic examples of reflexive responses that have a misleading veneer of choice-like goal-directedness about them can be found in simple conditioning situations.

The Human Brain: Surface, Three-Dimensional Sectional Anatomy and MRI

Article

Aug 1992

David G. Jacobs

Microeconomic Theory

Book

Jan 1995

This textbook aims to provide a comprehensive overview of the essentials of microeconomics. It offers unprecedented depth of coverage, whilst allowing lecturers to 'tailor-make' their courses to suit personal priorities. Covering topics such as noncooperative game theory, information economics, mechanism design and general equilibrium under uncertainty, it is written in a clear, accessible and engaging style and provides practice exercises and a full appendix of terminology.