Social support in an Internet weight loss community

Department of Internal Medicine, Division of General Medicine, The University of Texas Medical School at Houston, 6410 Fannin Street, Houston, TX 77030, USA.
International Journal of Medical Informatics (Impact Factor: 2). 11/2009; 79(1):5-13. DOI: 10.1016/j.ijmedinf.2009.10.003
Source: PubMed


To describe social support for weight loss shared by members of a large Internet weight loss community.
We conducted a mixed-methods study with surveys (n=193) and interviews (n=13) of community members along with a content analysis of discussion forum messages (n=1924 messages). Qualitative data were analyzed for social support themes.
Survey respondents were primarily white (91.4%) and female (93.8%) with mean age 37.3 years and mean body mass index 30.9. They used forums frequently, with 56.8% reading messages, 36.1% replying to messages, and 18.5% posting messages to start a discussion related to weight loss on a daily or more frequent basis. Major social support themes were encouragement and motivation, mentioned at least once by 87.6% of survey respondents, followed by information (58.5%) and shared experiences (42.5%). Subthemes included testimonies, recognition for success, accountability, friendly competition, and humor. Members valued convenience, anonymity, and the non-judgmental interactions as unique characteristics of Internet-mediated support.
This Internet weight loss community plays a prominent role in participants' weight loss efforts. Social support within Internet weight loss communities merits further evaluation as a weight loss resource for clinicians to recommend to patients. Understanding these communities could improve how health professionals evaluate, build, harness, and manipulate social support for weight loss.

Full-text preview

Available from:
  • Source
    • "They pointed out that social media could help those who lack social support establish connections and obtain support. Hwang et al. (2010) investigated peer support in an online weight loss community, and suggested that 60 percent of the participants considered online members were more helpful than other contacts on the issue of weight loss. Convenience, anonymity, and none-judgment are the three distinct features valued most by the respondents. "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Purpose-The purpose of this paper is to propose a new approach recommending friends to social networking users who are also using weight loss app in the context of social networks. Design/methodology/approach-Social network has been recognized as an effective way to enhance overweight and obesity interventions in past studies. However, effective measures integrating social network with weight loss are very limited in the healthcare area. To bridge this gap, this study develops a measure for friend recommendation using the data obtained by weight loss apps; designs methods to model weight-gain-related behaviors (WGRB); constructs a novel "behavior network;" and develops two measurements in experiments to examine the proposed approach. Findings-The approach for friend recommendation is based on Friend Recommendation for Health Weight (FRHW) algorithm. By running this algorithm on a real data set, the experiment results show that the algorithm can recommend a friend who has a healthy lifestyle to a target user. The advantages of the proposed mechanism have been well justified via comparisons with popular friend recommenders in past studies. Originality/value-The conventional methods for friend recommenders in social networks are only concerned with similarities of pairs rather than interactions between people. The system cannot account for the potential influences among people. The method pioneers to model a WGRB as recommendation mechanismthat allow recommended friends to simultaneously fulfill two criteria. They are: first, similarity to the target person; and second, ensuring the positive influence toward weight loss. The second criterion is obviously important in practice and thus the approach is valuable to the literature.
    Full-text · Article · Aug 2015 · Industrial Management & Data Systems
  • Source
    • "It has been found to be positively associated with people's well-being, which can be attributed to it buffering effect (i.e., protecting people from potentially adverse effects of stressful events) and its main or direct effect on well-being of social support (Cohen and Syme 1985). Accordingly, studies have focused on examining the content of social support, such as emotional, informational, and instrumental, and their varying compositional characteristics for different health conditions (e.g., (Coulson et al. 2007; Hwang et al. 2010)). Besides distributed in more conventional discussion forums, conversations also take place in the comments on self-reported personal health information (Frost and Massagli 2008). "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: The pervasiveness of online health communities and recent exponential growth of health tracking technologies provide new possibilities for weight management, an important health issue that remains prevalent. To enhance the understanding of how to support them to succeed, we investigate people’s practices and experiences over the course of weight management, interviewing users from a well-established online peer-to-peer weight management community that integrates a calorie tracking tool. We find that support for weight loss maintenance was surprisingly overlooked, which we identify as a missed opportunity both for recognizing and leveraging individual member’s success and for enhancing community development. Our findings further characterize the changes people experience when they have transited from weight loss to weight loss maintenance. These changes of experience converge onto four facets, including motivation, goal recognition, social support, and social presence. We discuss the specific challenges and associated design opportunities these changes of experience afford for supporting long-term success of weight management.
    Full-text · Article · Jun 2015 · Computer Supported Cooperative Work
  • Source
    • "Given the nature of social network sites, it is not unexpected that a recent study has found success in using social network sites in implementing weight loss programmes (Napolitano et al., 2013). Social network sites can provide social support which can encourage physical activity and weight loss among participants (Hwang et al., 2010; Voorhees et al., 2005). SDT, with its explanation of autonomous motivation resulting from social relatedness needs fulfilment could be a suitable theoretical framework for studying interventions with a social network component. "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: The use of information and communications technology in physical activity intervention programmes has been found to be effective in some instances. We conducted a field study to examine the changes to activity level and psychological consequences of incorporating social network interactions into physical activity intervention programme using the self-determination theory framework. Sixty-two students from a local university in Singapore were allocated into four groups comprising a control group, a 3 hours physical activity intervention group, a 3 hours physical activity intervention group linked via Facebook, and a 1 hour physical exercise intervention group linked via Facebook. Measures on the level of physical activity, perceived autonomy, competency, relatedness, enjoyment and vitality were taken before and after the intervention programme. Repeated ANOVA and MANOVA analyses were conducted. The results showed that participants in the two groups with the 3 hours physical activity intervention reported a significant increase in the level of physical activity level compared to participants in other groups. Although the use of social network sites did not have any material effect on the physical intervention programmes, it enhanced competence and enjoyment in the activity. This suggests that the use of social network sites in physical activity intervention programmes yielded some positive psychological effects but the maximization of benefits need to be studied further.
    Full-text · Article · May 2015 · International journal of sport psychology
Show more