ArticlePDF Available

Changes in chain restaurant kids' meal beverage offerings on online ordering platforms after a healthy beverage default policy in New Orleans, Louisiana

Authors:
Short communication
Changes in chain restaurant kids meal beverage offerings on online
ordering platforms after a healthy beverage default policy in New
Orleans, Louisiana
Samantha Marinello
a,*
, Julien Leider
b
, Melissa Fuster
c
, Megan Knapp
d
, Lisa M. Powell
a
a
Health Policy and Administration (MC 923), School of Public Health, University of Illinois Chicago, 1603 W Taylor St, Chicago, IL 60612, USA
b
Institute for Health Research and Policy, School of Public Health, University of Illinois Chicago, 1747 W Roosevelt Rd, Chicago, IL 60608, USA
c
Celia Scott Weatherhead School of Public Health and Tropical Medicine, Tulane University, 1440 Canal Street, New Orleans, LA 70112, USA
d
Department of Public Health Sciences, Xavier University of Louisiana, 1 Drexel Drive, New Orleans, LA 70125, USA
ARTICLE INFO
Keywords:
Kidsmeals
Healthy beverage default
Online ordering platforms
Restaurant policy
Nutrition policy
ABSTRACT
Objective: Consumption of restaurant food is associated with poorer diet quality and greater consumption of
sugar-sweetened beverages among children; and online restaurant purchases have increased substantially. New
Orleans, Louisiana, enacted a healthy beverage default (HBD) ordinance effective January 1st, 2023, that
restricted beverages automatically included with kidsmeals, but that did not apply to online ordering platforms.
This study evaluated whether this ordinance impacted online offerings.
Methods: Data on online kids meal beverage offerings one month before and 811 months after the ordinance
effective date were collected for chain restaurants in New Orleans and Baton Rouge, Louisiana. Online ordering
platforms included restaurant websites/applications and three third-party platforms (Grubhub, Uber Eats, and
DoorDash). Difference-in-differences (DID) weighted logistic regression models with robust standard errors
clustered on restaurant were used to estimate relative changes in (1) compliance with HBD ordinance re-
quirements, (2) default offerings of only water, milk, and 100 % juice, and (3) any default offerings of soda.
Results: The DID results revealed no statistically signicant changes in compliance or beverage offerings in
restaurants in New Orleans compared to Baton Rouge following the HBD ordinance; further, nearly all estimated
odds ratios were close to 1, indicating no meaningful differences in changes in outcomes across sites.
Conclusions: This study found no evidence that the New Orleans HBD ordinance led to changes in kidsmeal
default beverage offerings on online ordering platforms. The results underscore the need for HBD policies that
specically apply to online ordering platforms, and for enforcement and monitoring of these platforms.
1. Introduction
In 2022, nearly 40 % of U.S. household food expenditures were spent
at fast-food and full-service restaurants (U.S. Department of Agriculture,
2024). Industry data show that restaurant purchases through online
ordering platforms have increased substantially (McKinsey and Com-
pany, 2021). These ndings are consistent with a large international
study, which found increases in purchases from online food delivery
services between 2018 and 2021 (Gupta et al., 2024). Children may be
more affected by the increasing popularity of online ordering platforms,
as adults living with children are more likely to use these services
(Keeble et al., 2020). Because restaurant food is a signicant contributor
to childrens dietary intake (Fryar et al., 2020), policies that aim to
improve the healthfulness of kids meals, which are generally of low
nutritional quality (Dunn et al., 2020), have the potential to improve
diet and reduce chronic diseases. Consumption of restaurant food among
children is associated with higher intake of total energy and sugar, as
well as greater consumption of sugar-sweetened beverages (SSBs)
(Powell and Nguyen, 2013)the largest contributor of added sugars in
childrens diets (Bowman et al., 2019). Fast food and SSBs have also
been identied as primary dietary risk factors for overweight and
obesity among children (Jakobsen et al., 2023).
In an effort to encourage healthier beverage choices and improve
dietary intake among children in restaurant settings, a number of U.S.
jurisdictions have enacted laws that restrict default beverage offerings
that are automatically included in kids meals (Perez et al., 2022).
* Corresponding author.
E-mail address: smarin23@uic.edu (S. Marinello).
Contents lists available at ScienceDirect
Preventive Medicine Reports
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/pmedr
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.pmedr.2025.103067
Received 13 December 2024; Received in revised form 4 April 2025; Accepted 6 April 2025
Preventive Medicine Reports 53 (2025) 103067
Available online 9 April 2025
2211-3355/© 2025 The Authors. Published by Elsevier Inc. This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license ( http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-
nc-nd/4.0/ ).
Nearly all limit default beverages to water, milk, and 100 % juice
meeting certain criteria (Perez et al., 2022). While default interventions
vary substantially in their ability to inuence choices, in some contexts
they are highly effective; for example, default opt-ins have been shown
to dramatically increase organ donation signup and enrollment in
retirement savings plans (Jachimowicz et al., 2019). They are also found
to improve nutrition-related choices, including, for example, default
offerings as part of school lunches (Vecchio and Cavallo, 2019).
Before healthy beverage default (HBD) policies can improve kids
beverage purchases, they must rst impact kidsmeal beverage offerings
at restaurants; this includes physical restaurant locations as well as
online ordering platforms. To date, a limited number of pre-post eval-
uations of restaurant compliance with enacted HBD laws have been
conducted in California, Wilmington, Delaware, Columbus, Ohio, and
Illinois (Pipito et al., 2022; Powell et al., 2023; Powell et al., 2024;
Ritchie et al., 2022). With the exception of California restaurant interior
and drive-thru menu boards, these studies found no statistically signif-
icant changes in default offerings on either menu boards or online
ordering platforms (Pipito et al., 2022; Powell et al., 2023; Powell et al.,
2024; Ritchie et al., 2022). The purpose of this study was to assess the
impact of the New Orleans, Louisiana, HBD ordinance (City of New
Orleans, 2022; New Orleans Health Department, 2022) on default bev-
erages included with kids meals on restaurant online ordering plat-
forms. This policy went into effect January 1st, 2023, and applied to
physical restaurant locations. To our knowledge, this is the rst evalu-
ation of the New Orleans HBD ordinance.
2. Methods
This study used a pre-post intervention-comparison site research
design to examine changes in kids meal beverage offerings following
the effective date of the New Orleans HBD ordinance. Data were
collected from online ordering platforms in New Orleans, the interven-
tion site, and Baton Rouge, Louisiana, a nearby comparison-site city, one
month before the policy effective date (in December 2022) and 811
months after (in SeptemberDecember 2023). This study did not require
institutional review board approval because data were collected from
online ordering systems and no human subjects were involved.
2.1. Measures and outcomes
Data on kids meal beverage offerings from online menus were
collected and coded using the Food Policy Program Fast-Food Restau-
rant KidsMeal audit tool, which has been shown to have high interrater
reliability (Powell et al., 2022). Beverage characteristics included
beverage type (e.g., regular soda, water); milk avor, fat percentage,
and calories; and juice size and 100 % juice status. Based on our audit
tool, a beverage or set of beverages were classied as defaults if they
were shown immediately after a kids meal was selected through the
online ordering platform. If the platform allowed customers to take
additional action to select other beverages, those beverages were not
considered defaults. This study denition is consistent with the ordi-
nance, which denes a default beverage as a beverage automatically
included as part of a childrens meal, absent a specic request by the
purchaser of the childrens meal for an alternative beverage (City of
New Orleans, 2022).
The three outcomes assessed in this study were (1) restaurant
compliance with the requirements of the New Orleans HBD ordinance,
(2) default offerings limited to any type of water, milk, or 100 % juice,
and (3) any default offerings of soda (regular or diet).
Compliance was assessed based on the provisions of the New Orleans
HBD ordinance. For a restaurant to be compliant, kids meal default
beverages must be restricted to the following beverage types: water
(unavored, unsweetened, uncarbonated); non-fat or 1 % unsweetened
milk or non-dairy milk alternatives containing 130 cal per serving; and
100 % juice with no added sweeteners and 6.75 oz (City of New
Orleans, 2022; New Orleans Health Department, 2022).
2.2. Study sample
For a larger study of kids meal beverage offerings (Leider et al.,
2023), lists of all licensed restaurants in New Orleans and Baton Rouge
were used to identify 343 potentially eligible restaurants that had kids
meals. To be eligible for this study, restaurants had to offer a kidsmeal
that included a beverage on at least one of four online ordering plat-
forms: the restaurant website or application and three third-party plat-
forms (Grubhub, Uber Eats, and DoorDash). For each restaurant, data
were collected from each platform that offered a kids meal that
included a beverage. Prior to data collection, these restaurants were pre-
screened by research staff to determine study eligibility and remove
duplicates (i.e., the same exact restaurant location repeated more than
once) and a total of 144 restaurants were excluded (129 no kidsmeal or
no beverage with kids meal online; 11 did not use online ordering
platforms under consideration; one duplicate; three used for eld testing
or location undetermined). After data were collected and coded, an
additional 61 restaurants were excluded (30 did not use any of the
platforms under consideration; 13 no kidsmeal; 17 no beverage with
kidsmeal; one duplicate). Further, for each outcome and platform type,
restaurants were only included in the analytic sample if they had data
both pre-post policy and they were a chain present in both New Orleans
and Baton Rouge.
The nal sample for analyses of the restaurant website/application
included 67 restaurants to assess changes in compliance, 67 restaurants
to assess changes in default offerings of only water, milk, and 100 %
juice, and 71 restaurants to assess changes in default offerings of soda.
The nal sample for analyses of third-party platforms included 107
menus (from 41 restaurants) to assess changes in compliance, 148
menus (from 54 restaurants) to assess changes in default offerings of
only water, milk, and 100 % juice, and 153 menus (from 55 restaurants)
to assess changes in default offerings of soda. Across analytic samples,
7987 % were fast-food restaurants and the remaining 1321 % were
full-service restaurants.
2.3. Statistical analysis
Summary statistics were computed on default beverage offerings in
New Orleans and Baton Rouge before and after the effective date of the
New Orleans HBD ordinance. To estimate changes in offerings in New
Orleans relative to Baton Rouge, difference-in-differences (DID) logistic
regression models with robust standard errors clustered on restaurants
were employed. Both summary statistics and regression models were
weighted for each outcome so that each restaurant chain would receive
the same total weight in each site and time period. Statistical analyses
were conducted in Stata/SE 18.0 (StataCorp LLC, College Station, TX)
and results were considered statistically signicant at p <.05.
3. Results
Table 1 provides summary statistics for default beverage offering
outcomes in New Orleans and Baton Rouge before and after the effective
date of the New Orleans HBD ordinance. Prior to the ordinance going
into effect, 64 % and 39 % of restaurant websites/applications and third-
party ordering platforms in New Orleans were compliant, respectively.
Changes in compliance were similar across New Orleans and Baton
Rouge, which did not have an HBD ordinance at either time point:
increasing on restaurant websites/applications (from 64 % to 73 % in
New Orleans and from 55 % to 64 % in Baton Rouge) and decreasing on
third-party ordering platforms (from 39 % to 31 % in both New Orleans
and Baton Rouge). New Orleans and Baton Rouge also had similar
changes in default soda offerings on both restaurant websites/applica-
tions and third-party ordering platforms and in offering only water,
milk, or 100 % juice as default beverages on third-party ordering
S. Marinello et al.
Preventive Medicine Reports 53 (2025) 103067
2
platforms. On restaurant websites/applications, there was a small in-
crease in offering only water, milk, or 100 % juice in New Orleans (64 %
to 73 %) while there was no change in Baton Rouge (64 % before and
after the effective date).
The DID regression results are shown in Table 2 and revealed no
statistically signicant changes in compliance, default offerings of only
water, milk, or 100 % juice, or default soda offerings on the restaurant
website/application nor on the third-party platforms in New Orleans
relative to Baton Rouge 811 months after the New Orleans HBD ordi-
nance went into effect. Further, nearly all estimated odds ratios were
close to 1, indicating no meaningful differences in changes in outcomes
across sites.
4. Discussion
This study found no evidence of changes in chain restaurant kids
meal default beverage offerings on online ordering platforms 811
months after the New Orleans HBD policy went into effect. Online
restaurant menus in New Orleans and Baton Rouge had similar pre-post
changes in compliance with the requirements of the New Orleans policy,
default offerings of only water, milk, and 100 % juice, and default of-
ferings of soda.
These ndings suggest that any potential changes in beverage of-
ferings made at physical restaurant locations did not spill over to
restaurant menus on online ordering platforms and are generally
consistent with other pre-post evaluations of HBD policies (Pipito et al.,
2022; Powell et al., 2023; Powell et al., 2024; Ritchie et al., 2022).
Studies that assessed online ordering platforms found no statistically
signicant changes in compliance in Illinois fast-food restaurants, rela-
tive to matched comparison restaurants in Wisconsin, four months and
12 months after the policy went into effect, nor in Columbus fast-food
restaurants relative to matched comparison restaurants in other Ohio
localities four months after that policy went into effect (Pipito et al.,
2022; Powell et al., 2023; Powell et al., 2024). Assessments of physical
restaurant locations have yielded mixed results but show adherence to
HBD policies has been far from complete. The 12-month Illinois evalu-
ation found no changes in compliance relative to Wisconsin on interior
and drive-thru menu boards (Powell et al., 2024). The evaluation of
California and Wilmington HBD policies found compliance on interior
and drive-thru menu boards increased in fast-food restaurants in Cali-
fornia (10 %66 %) and remained the same in restaurants in Wilmington
(31 % before and after the effective date) 712 months after these pol-
icies went into effect (Ritchie et al., 2022). A limitation of this latter
evaluation, though, is that it did not use a comparison site to control for
other potential changes in beverage offerings that were unrelated to the
policy. Indeed, in studies that used a comparison site, some have found
increases in compliance for some platforms in both treatment and
comparison sites (Pipito et al., 2022; Powell et al., 2023; Powell et al.,
2024).
This study is subject to limitations. First, our sample only included
chain restaurants and may not be generalizable to independent restau-
rants. Second, because our sample size was limited, we could not assess
differences in outcomes between fast-food and full-service restaurants.
Third, particularly given the geographic proximity of New Orleans and
Baton Rouge, chain restaurants in both cities may have changed their
beverage offerings in response to the New Orleans HBD policy. Fourth,
because we only had data for one pre-policy time point, we were not able
to provide evidence on the plausibility of the parallel trends assumption
required by our DID models. Fifth, this study did not assess compliance
of menus at physical restaurant locations. Strengths of this study include
using the same chain restaurants from a comparison site and the use of a
reliable tool to assess kidsmeal beverage offerings.
5. Conclusions
This study found no changes in kidsmeal default beverage offerings
on online platforms 811 months after the New Orleans HBD policy
went into effect. Because online purchases from restaurants are
becoming increasingly popular, the results underscore the importance of
including online ordering platforms in HBD policies. Regulating these
platforms can increase their reach and therefore their potential impacts
on the healthfulness of childrens meals. Future studies are needed to
assess the effect of the New Orleans HBD policy on beverage offerings at
physical restaurant locations.
Disclosure of Funding and Conicts of Interest: This work was supported
by a grant (2020-85774) from Bloomberg PhilanthropiesFood Policy
Program (www.bloomberg.org). Access to the REDCap data system was
provided by the University of Illinois Chicago Center for Clinical and
Translational Science (grant #UL1TR002003). The authors report no
Table 1
Default beverage offerings in chain restaurants in New Orleans, Louisiana, and
Baton Rouge, Louisiana, one month before (December 2022) and 811 months
after (SeptemberDecember 2023) the effective date of a New Orleans healthy
beverage default (HBD) ordinance.
New Orleans Baton Rouge
Before After Before After
n% % n% %
Default beverage offerings compliant with New Orleans HBD ordinance
Restaurant website or
application
31 64 73 36 55 64
Third-party ordering platforms 51 39 31 56 39 31
Default beverage offerings limited to water, milk, or 100 % juice
Restaurant website or
application
32 64 73 35 64 64
Third-party ordering platforms 75 60 45 73 64 46
Soda offered as a default beverage
Restaurant website or
application
33 33 25 38 42 33
Third-party ordering platforms 77 35 44 76 36 44
Statistics for each outcome were weighted so that each restaurant chain would
receive the same total weight in each site and time period. Sample sizes for the
computation of percentages, in terms of unweighted numbers of restaurant
menus by site, shown in the n columns.
HBD, healthy beverage default.
Table 2
Changes from December 2022 to SeptemberDecember 2023 in default beverage
offerings in chain restaurants in New Orleans, Louisiana, relative to Baton
Rouge, Louisiana, following the effective date of a New Orleans healthy
beverage default (HBD) ordinance.
nDifference-in-differences
OR 95 % CI
Default beverage offerings compliant with New Orleans HBD ordinance
Restaurant website or application 134 1.04 0.41, 2.66
Third-party ordering platforms 214 0.99 0.57, 1.72
Default beverage offerings limited to water, milk, or 100 % juice
Restaurant website or application 134 1.52 0.70, 3.33
Third-party ordering platforms 296 1.11 0.36, 3.39
Soda offered as a default beverage
Restaurant website or application 142 0.95 0.39, 2.34
Third-party ordering platforms 306 1.07 0.35, 3.30
Difference-in-differences results are shown from logistic regression models with
robust standard errors clustered on restaurant that were weighted for each
outcome so that each restaurant chain would receive the same total weight in
each site and time period. Sample sizes in terms of the total number of restaurant
menu-level observations across both sites and time periods shown in the n col-
umn.
HBD, healthy beverage default; OR, odds ratio.
S. Marinello et al.
Preventive Medicine Reports 53 (2025) 103067
3
conicts of interest.
CRediT authorship contribution statement
Samantha Marinello: Writing original draft, Methodology,
Formal analysis. Julien Leider: Writing review & editing, Methodol-
ogy, Data curation. Melissa Fuster: Writing review & editing, Data
curation. Megan Knapp: Writing review & editing, Data curation. Lisa
M. Powell: Writing review & editing, Supervision, Methodology,
Funding acquisition, Conceptualization.
Declaration of competing interest
The authors declare the following nancial interests/personal re-
lationships which may be considered as potential competing interests:
Lisa M Powell reports nancial support was provided by Bloomberg
Philanthropies. If there are other authors, they declare that they have no
known competing nancial interests or personal relationships that could
have appeared to inuence the work reported in this paper.
Data availability
Data will be made available on request.
References
Bowman, S., Clemens, J., Friday, J., Schroeder, N., LaComb, R., 2019. Added sugars in
American childrens diet: what we eat in America, NHANES 2015-2016. Dietary
Data Brief No. 26. https://www.ars.usda.gov/ARSUserFiles/80400530/pdf/DBrief/
26_Sources%20of%20Added%20Sugars%20in%20Childrens%20Diet_1516.pdf.
City of New Orleans, 2022. Ordinance No. 28913. Healthy Kids Menus. https://cityofno.
granicus.com/MetaViewer.php?view_id=7&clip_id=3997&meta_id=572805.
Dunn, C.G., Vercammen, K.A., Frelier, J.M., Moran, A.J., Bleich, S.N., 2020. Nutrition
composition of childrens meals in twenty-six large US chain restaurants. Public
Health Nutr. 23 (12), 22452252. https://doi.org/10.1017/S1368980019004907.
Fryar, C.D., Carroll, M.D., Ahluwalia, N., Ogden, C.L., 2020. Fast food intake among
children and adolescents in the United States, 20152018. NCHS Data Brief 375,
18. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/33054908.
Gupta, A., Sacks, G., Cameron, A.J., Huggins, C.E., Peeters, A., Backholer, K.,
Vanderlee, L., White, C.M., Scapin, T., Gomez-Donoso, C., Bennett, R., Dubin, J.A.,
Hammond, D., 2024. Use of online food delivery services among adults in ve
countries from the International Food Policy Study 20182021. Prev. Med. Rep. 43,
102766. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.pmedr.2024.102766.
Jachimowicz, J.M., Duncan, S., Weber, E.U., Johnson, E.J., 2019. When and why defaults
inuence decisions: a meta-analysis of default effects. Behav. Public Policy 3 (2),
159186. https://doi.org/10.1017/bpp.2018.43.
Jakobsen, D.D., Brader, L., Bruun, J.M., 2023. Association between food, beverages and
overweight/obesity in children and adolescents-a systematic review and meta-
analysis of observational studies. Nutrients 15 (3), 764. https://doi.org/10.3390/
nu15030764.
Keeble, M., Adams, J., Sacks, G., Vanderlee, L., White, C.M., Hammond, D., Burgoine, T.,
2020. Use of online food delivery services to order food prepared away-from-home
and associated sociodemographic characteristics: a cross-sectional, multi-country
analysis. Int. J. Environ. Res. Public Health 17 (14), 5190. https://doi.org/10.3390/
ijerph17145190.
Leider, J., Pipito, A.A., Sandoval Camacho, L., Gupta, R., Knapp, M., Fuster, M.,
Powell, L.M., 2023. Default Beverage Offerings with Kids Meals across Online
Ordering Platforms for Fast-Food and Full-Service Restaurants in New Orleans and
Baton Rouge, Louisiana. Research Brief No. 131. https://p3rc.uic.edu/wp-content/
uploads/sites/561/2024/04/Leider_Sept-2023_RsrchBrf-No.-131_Dt-Bev-Offrngs-
w-Kids-Mls-FF-FS-Restrnts-NewOrleans-BatonRouge_wDOI.pdf.
McKinsey & Company, 2021. Ordering in: The Rapid Evolution of Food Delivery. https
://www.mckinsey.com/~/media/mckinsey/industries/technology%20media%
20and%20telecommunications/high%20tech/our%20insights/ordering%20in%
20the%20rapid%20evolution%20of%20food%20delivery/ordering-in-the-rapid-evo
lution-of-food-delivery_vf.pdf.
New Orleans Health Department, 2022. Proposed Regulations Governing
Implementation of the Healthy Kids Meal Beverage Ordinance. https://nola.gov/g
etattachment/Health/Health-Policy/The-Healthy-Kids-Meal-Beverage-Regulations
_FINAL.pdf/?lang=en-US.
Perez, C.L., Moran, A.J., Headrick, G., McCarthy, J., Cradock, A.L., Pollack Porter, K.M.,
2022. State and local healthy kidsmeal laws in the United States: a review and
content analysis. J. Acad. Nutr. Diet. 122 (10), 18641875. https://doi.org/
10.1016/j.jand.2021.12.003.
Pipito, A.A., Beal, V.G., Leider, J., Powell, L.M., 2022. No Impact of the Columbus, Ohio,
Default Beverage Policy On Childrens Meal Beverage Offerings Four-Months Post-
implementation. Research Brief No. 126. https://p3rc.uic.edu/wp-content/upl
oads/sites/561/2022/06/Pipito_May-2022_RsrchBrf-No.-126_No-Impct-Columbus-
OH-Dt-Bev-Policy-Chldrns-Ml-Bev-Offrngs-4-mos.pdf.
Powell, L.M., Nguyen, B.T., 2013. Fast-food and full-service restaurant consumption
among children and adolescents: effect on energy, beverage, and nutrient intake.
JAMA Pediatr. 167 (1), 1420. https://doi.org/10.1001/jamapediatrics.2013.417.
Powell, L.M., Leider, J., Pipito, A.A., Marinello, S., Szkorla, A., Moran, A., 2022.
Development and Reliability Testing of a Tool to Assess Default Beverage Offerings
with KidsMeals in Fast-food Restaurants. Research Brief No. 127. https://p3rc.uic.
edu/wp-content/uploads/sites/561/2022/08/Powell_Jul-2022_RsrchBrf-No.-12
7_Dvlpmnt-Rlblty-Tstng-Tool-Assess-Dflt-Bev-Offrngs-Kds-Mls-FF-Rstrn.pdf.
Powell, L.M., Leider, J., Pipito, A.A., Moran, A., 2023. Evaluation of short-term changes
in fast-food restaurant online kidsmeal beverage offerings following a state-level
healthy beverage default policy. Curr. Dev. Nutr. 7 (4), 100045. https://doi.org/
10.1016/j.cdnut.2023.100045.
Powell, L.M., Vandenbroeck, A., Leider, J., Pipito, A.A., Moran, A., 2024. Evaluation of
fast-food restaurant kids meal beverage offerings one-year following a state-level
healthy beverage default policy. Am. J. Prevent. Med. Focus 3 (3), 100226. https://
doi.org/10.1016/j.focus.2024.100226.
Ritchie, L.D., Lessard, L., Harpainter, P., Tsai, M.M., Woodward-Lopez, G., Tracy, T.,
Gosliner, W., McCallops, K., Thompson, I., Karpyn, A., 2022. Restaurant kidsmeal
beverage offerings before and after implementation of healthy default beverage
policy statewide in California compared with citywide in Wilmington, Delaware.
Public Health Nutr. 25 (3), 794804. https://doi.org/10.1017/
S1368980021001245.
U.S. Department of Agriculture, Economic Research Service, 2024. Interactive Charts:
Food Expenditures. https://www.ers.usda.gov/data-products/food-expenditure-se
ries/interactive-charts-food-expenditures/.
Vecchio, R., Cavallo, C., 2019. Increasing healhy food choices through nudges: a
systematic review. Food Qual. Prefer. 78, 103714. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.
foodqual.2019.05.014.
S. Marinello et al.
Preventive Medicine Reports 53 (2025) 103067
4
ResearchGate has not been able to resolve any citations for this publication.
Article
Full-text available
Introduction Ordering from kids’ menus and children's restaurant consumption is associated with greater purchasing and intake, respectively, of sugar-sweetened beverages. In response, policymakers have enacted strategies to improve the healthfulness of kids’ meal offerings. This study investigated restaurant kids’ meal beverage offerings and compliance with an Illinois healthy beverage default act, effective from January 1, 2022. Methods Using a pre–post intervention (Illinois)–comparison (Wisconsin) site research design, fast-food restaurant audit data were collected before and 1 year after the Illinois Healthy Beverage Default Act from 6 platforms: restaurant interior and drive-thru menu boards and websites/applications and 3 third-party ordering platforms (DoorDash, Uber Eats, and Grubhub). Analyses included 62–110 restaurants across platforms. Difference-in-differences–weighted logistic regression models with robust SEs, clustered on restaurants, were estimated to assess pre to 1-year postpolicy changes in overall compliance for each audit setting in Illinois relative to that in Wisconsin. Results This study found no statistically significant (p<0.05) changes in the compliance of kids’ meal beverage default offerings associated with the enactment of the Illinois Healthy Beverage Default Act in Illinois relative to that in Wisconsin at fast-food restaurants. There were some observed differences in results in the restaurants’ physical locations versus online that are worth noting. That is, after the enactment of the Illinois Healthy Beverage Default Act, the results showed greater odds of fast-food restaurants exclusively offering healthy beverage defaults with kids’ meals on restaurant interior (OR=1.83, 95% CI=0.93, 3.58) and drive-thru (OR=2.38, 95% CI=0.95, 5.96) menus, with weak statistical significance (p<0.10). However, the policy was not associated with either meaningful or statistically significant changes in healthy beverage default offerings on restaurant websites or third-party online ordering platforms. Conclusions This study found limited evidence of changes in kids’ meal beverage offerings attributable to the Illinois Healthy Beverage Default Act. Future investigations of communication channels that support awareness and implementation and the resources required for implementation and enforcement may provide insight that is key to improving compliance.
Article
Full-text available
A healthy diet is essential to prevent childhood obesity, however, adherence to a healthy diet is challenging. The aim of this study was to give a comprehensive overview of the literature investigaating associations between food and beverages and overweight/obesity in children and adolescents in order to identify dietary risk factors. A systematic search was performed in four databases and observational studies were included. Meta-analysis was performed using the random effect model. Sixty records met inclusion criteria and 14 different food or beverage categories were identified. A higher intake of sugar-sweetened beverages increased the odds of overweight/obesity by 1.20 (p < 0.05) (n = 26) and higher intake of fast food increased the odds of overweight/obesity by 1.17 (p < 0.05) (n = 24). Furthermore, higher intake of meat (OR 1.02, p < 0.05 (n:7)) and refined grains (OR 1.28, p < 0.05 (n:3)) was associated with an increased risk of overweight/obesity. In contrast, higher intake of whole grain (OR 0.86, p = 0.04 (n:5)) and more surprisingly sweet bakery (OR 0.59, p < 0.05 (n:3)) was associated with a decreased risk of overweight/obesity. In conclusion, a higher intake of sugar-sweetened beverages and a higher intake of fast food was identified as the primary dietary risk factors for overweight/obesity. Future research is needed to strengthen the generalizability of these results.
Article
Full-text available
Objective In 2019, California and Wilmington, Delaware implemented policies requiring healthier default beverages with restaurant kids’ meals. This study assessed restaurant beverage offerings and manager perceptions. Design Pre-post menu observations were conducted in California and Wilmington. Observations of cashiers/servers during orders were conducted pre-post implementation in California and post-implementation in Wilmington. Changes in California were compared using multilevel logistic regression and paired t-tests. Post-implementation, managers were interviewed. Setting Inside and drive-through ordering venues in a sample of quick-service restaurants in low-income California communities and all restaurants in Wilmington subject to the policy, the month before and 7-12 months after policy implementation. Participants Restaurant observations (California n=110; Wilmington n=14); managers (California n=75; Wilmington n=15). Results Pre-implementation, the most common kids’ meal beverages on California menus were unflavored milk and water (78.8%, 52.0%); in Wilmington, juice, milk, and sugar-sweetened beverages were most common (81.8%, 66.7%, 46.2%). Post-implementation, menus including only policy-consistent beverages significantly increased in California (9.7% to 66.1%, p<0.0001), but remained constant in Wilmington (30.8%). During orders, cashiers/servers offering only policy-consistent beverages significantly decreased post-implementation in California (5.0% to 1.0%, p=0.002). Few managers (California 29.3%; Wilmington 0%) reported policy knowledge, although most expressed support. Most managers wanted additional information for customers and staff. Conclusions While the proportion of menus offering only policy-consistent kids’ meal default beverages increased in California, offerings did not change in Wilmington. In both jurisdictions managers lacked policy knowledge and few cashiers/servers offered only policy-consistent beverages. Additional efforts are needed to strengthen implementation of kids’ meal beverage policies.
Technical Report
Full-text available
About 35 percent of children 2 to 19 years of age met the 2015-2020 DGA recommendation for added sugars, by limiting added sugars intake to less than 10% of total energy for the day. • On average, those who met the recommendation obtained 5.9 percent, and those who did not meet the recommendation obtained 18.5 percent of total energy from added sugars. • Significantly higher percentages of children 2-5 years met the recommendation than the older children. • Sweetened beverages, sweet bakery products, and candy were the top three sources of added sugars in the diet of children who did not meet the DGA added sugars recommendation
Article
Full-text available
Online food delivery services like Just Eat and Grubhub facilitate online ordering and home delivery of food prepared away-from-home. It is poorly understood how these services are used and by whom. This study investigated the prevalence of online food delivery service use and sociodemographic characteristics of customers, in and across Australia, Canada, Mexico, the UK, and the USA. We analyzed online survey data (n = 19,378) from the International Food Policy Study, conducted in 2018. We identified respondents who reported any online food delivery service use in the past 7 days and calculated the frequency of use and number of meals ordered. We investigated whether odds of any online food delivery service use in the past 7 days differed by sociodemographic characteristics using adjusted logistic regression. Overall, 15% of respondents (n = 2929) reported online food delivery service use, with the greatest prevalence amongst respondents in Mexico (n = 839 (26%)). Online food delivery services had most frequently been used once and the median number of meals purchased through this mode of order was two. Odds of any online food delivery service use were lower per additional year of age (OR: 0.95; 95% CI: 0.94, 0.95) and greater for respondents who were male (OR: 1.50; 95% CI: 1.35, 1.66), that identified with an ethnic minority (OR: 1.57; 95% CI: 1.38, 1.78), were highly educated (OR: 1.66; 95% CI: 1.46, 1.90), or living with children (OR: 2.71; 95% CI: 2.44, 3.01). Further research is required to explore how online food delivery services may influence diet and health.
Article
Aim Online food delivery services (OFDS) are popular for purchasing meals prepared outside home, increasing access to energy-dense and nutrient-poor foods. This adversely impacts dietary choices and health outcomes. Our study examined trends in OFDS use in Australia, Canada, Mexico, the United Kingdom (UK), and the United States (US) from 2018 to 2021. Methods Repeated annual cross-sectional data was sourced from the International Food Policy Study for five countries among adults over 18 years (N = 83,337). Weighted estimates for trends in i) the proportion of the respondent’s purchasing meals per week using OFDS, and ii) average number (and standard deviation (SD)) of meals purchased per week using OFDS were assessed. Logistic regression models were fitted. Findings OFDS use increased among adults between 2018–2021 (Australia: 17 % of respondents purchased at least one meal in the last 7 days using OFDS in 2018 to 25 % in 2021, Canada: 12 % to 19 %, Mexico: 28 % to 38 %, UK: 19 % to 28 %, and US: 17 % to 21 %). Average number of meals purchased per week outside home remained consistent for all countries over time (e.g., in Australia, 2.70 (SD 0.06) meals in 2018 and 2.63 (SD 0.06) in 2021). However, average number of meals purchased using OFDS nearly doubled between 2018 and 2021 (e.g., in Australia, 0.45 (SD 0.03) meals in 2018 to 0.81 (SD 0.04) in 2021). Conclusion OFDS use is increasing and are substituting the conventional forms of purchasing meals outside home. Nutritional quality of foods sold, marketing practices and purchasing patterns on OFDS deserve further attention.
Article
Background: Consumption of food and beverages from restaurants is associated with poorer diet quality and a higher intake of sugar-sweetened beverages (SSBs) among children, and SSBs are commonly offered as part of kids' meals at restaurants. Thus, an increasing number of states and localities have mandated that only healthy beverages be provided by default with kids' meals. Objectives: We examined changes in default beverages offered with kids' meals 4 mo after an IL healthy beverage default (HBD) act took effect. Methods: A pre-post intervention-comparison site study design was used, with WI as the comparison site. Data were collected on default beverages offered on restaurant website or application menus at 64 restaurants in IL and 57 restaurants in WI in November 2021, before the IL HBD Act took effect, and May 2022, 4 mo after the date on which the Act took effect. Difference-in-differences weighted logistic regression models with robust standard errors clustered on restaurants were computed to examine changes over time in beverage offerings in IL relative to those in WI. Results: There was no statistically significant increase in compliance with the IL HBD Act's criteria in restaurants in IL compared with those in WI (OR: 1.40; 95% CI: 0.45, 4.31). Although the compliance by fast-food restaurants increased from 15% to 38% in IL, there was a similar pattern in WI, with an increase from 20% to 39%. There were also no statistically significant changes in specific types of compliant beverages offered by default with kids' meals in IL compared with those in WI. Conclusions: These results highlight the need for communication and enforcement to ensure that restaurants make changes in response to HBD policies broadly, including on their online platforms, and without substantial lags. Future studies should continue to measure the effectiveness of HBD policies alongside implementation strategies to determine how these policies can best achieve improvements in the nutritional quality of kids' meals at restaurants.
Article
Background To address unhealthy restaurant food intake among children, localities and states are passing healthy restaurant kids’ meal laws. However, there is limited knowledge of what these policies require and how they compare to expert and industry nutrition standards. Objectives The aim of this study was to develop a research instrument to evaluate healthy kids' meal laws and assess their alignment with expert and industry nutritional standards. Design The study team conducted a content analysis of healthy kids' meal laws passed between January 2010 and August 2020 in the United States. Using a structured codebook, two researchers abstracted policy elements and implementation language from laws, regulations, fiscal notes, and policy notes. Nutritional criteria for kids' beverages and meals were compared to existing expert and industry nutrition standards for meals and beverages. Main outcome measures. Measures included 1) law characteristics, 2) implementation characteristics, 3) enforcement characteristics, 4) definitions of key terms, and 5) nutritional requirements for meals and default beverage options and alignment with expert and industry nutrition standards. Statistical analyses performed Interrater reliability of the coding tool was estimated using Cohen's kappa statistic, and researchers calculated descriptive statistics of policy elements. Results Twenty laws were identified. Eighteen were healthy default beverage policies, two were toy restriction policies, and one was a nutritional standards policy. The nutritional standards, default beverage offerings, and implementation characteristics varied by location. No law met the expert nutrition standards for kids' meals or beverages. Conclusions The variations in policy specifications may influence how restaurants implement the policies, and, consequently, the policies’ impacts on children’s consumption. Future policies could use expert nutrition standards to inform the standards set for kids' meals and specify supports for implementation.
Article
Fast food has been associated with higher caloric intake and poorer diet quality in children and adolescents (1). In 2011-2012, children and adolescents aged 2-19 years consumed on average 12.4% of their daily calories from fast food on a given day (2). This report presents 2015-2018 estimates of the percentage of calories consumed from fast food on a given day among U.S. children and adolescents by demographic characteristics and trends since 2003.
Article
Objective To compare the nutritional quality of children’s combination meals offered at large US chain restaurants characterised by three versions – default (advertised), minimum (lower-energy) and maximum (higher-energy). Design We identified default children’s meals ( n 92) from online restaurant menus, then constructed minimum and maximum versions using realistic additions, substitutions and/or portion size changes for existing menu items. Nutrition data were obtained from the MenuStat database. Bootstrapped linear models assessed nutrition differences between meal versions and the extent to which meal components (main dish, side dish, beverage) drove differences across versions. For each version, we examined the proportion of meals meeting the Guidelines for Responsible Food Marketing to Children. Setting Twenty-six fast-food and fast-casual restaurants, in 2017. Participants None. Results Nutrient values differed significantly across meal versions for energy content (default 2443 kJ (584 kcal), minimum 1674 kJ (400 kcal), maximum 3314 kJ (792 kcal)), total fat (23, 17, 33 g), saturated fat (8, 6, 11 g), Na (1046, 915, 1287 mg) and sugar (35, 14, 51 g). The substitution of lower-energy beverages resulted in the greatest reduction in energy content (default to minimum, −418 kJ (−100 kcal)) and sugar (−20 g); choosing lower-energy side dishes resulted in the greatest reduction in total fat (default to minimum, −4 g), saturated fat (−1·1 g) and Na (−69 mg). Only 3 % of meals met guidelines for all nutrients. Conclusions Realistic modifications to children’s combination meals using existing menu options can significantly alter a meal’s nutrient composition. Promoting lower-energy items as the default option, especially for beverages and side dishes, has a potential to reduce fat, saturated fat and/or sugar in children’s meals.