No full-text available
To read the full-text of this research,
you can request a copy directly from the authors.
Insights into the Mechanism of Protein Loading by Chain-Length Asymmetric Complex Coacervates
ResearchGate has not been able to resolve any citations for this publication.
Liquid–liquid phase separation of biomolecules is increasingly recognized as being relevant to various cellular functions, and complex coacervation of biomacromolecules, particularly proteins, is emerging as a key mechanism for this phenomenon. Complex coacervation is also being explored as a potential protein purification method due to its potential scalability, aqueous operation, and ability to produce a highly concentrated product. However, to date, most studies of complex coacervation have evaluated the phase behavior of a binary mixture of two oppositely charged macromolecules. Therefore, a comprehensive understanding of the phase behavior of complex biological mixtures is yet to be established. To address this, a panel of engineered proteins was designed to allow for quantitative analysis of the complex coacervation of individual proteins within a multicomponent mixture. The behavior of individual proteins was evaluated using a defined mixture of proteins that mimics the charge profile of the Escherichia coli proteome. To allow for the direct quantification of proteins in each phase, spectrally separated fluorescent proteins were used to construct the protein mixture. From this quantitative analysis, we observed that protein coacervation was synchronized in the mixture, which was distinctive from the behavior when each protein was evaluated in a single-protein system. Subtle differences in biophysical properties between the proteins, such as the ionization of individual charged residues and overall charge density, became noticeable in the mixture, which allowed us to elucidate parameters for protein complex coacervation. With this understanding, we successfully designed methods to enrich a range of proteins of interest from a mixture of proteins.
Hierarchical compartmentalization, a hallmark of both primitive and modern cells, enables the concentration and isolation of biomolecules, and facilitates spatial organization of biochemical reactions. Coacervate-based compartments can sequester and recruit a large variety of molecules, making it an attractive protocell model. In this work, we report the spontaneous formation of core-shell cell-sized coacervate-based compartments driven by spontaneous evaporation of a sessile droplet on a thin-oil-coated substrate. Our analysis reveals that such far-from-equilibrium architectures arise from multiple, coupled segregative and associative liquid-liquid phase separation, and are stabilized by stagnation points within the evaporating droplet. The formation of stagnation points results from convective capillary flows induced by the maximum evaporation rate at the liquid-liquid-air contact line. This work provides valuable insights into the spontaneous formation and maintenance of hierarchical compartments under non-equilibrium conditions, offering a glimpse into the real-life scenario.
Coacervate droplets are promising protocell models because they sequester a wide range of guest molecules and may catalyze their conversion. However, it remains unclear how life’s building blocks, including peptides, could be synthesized from primitive precursor molecules inside such protocells. Here, we develop a redox-active protocell model formed by phase separation of prebiotically relevant ferricyanide (Fe(CN)6³⁻) molecules and cationic peptides. Their assembly into coacervates can be regulated by redox chemistry and the coacervates act as oxidizing hubs for sequestered metabolites, like NAD(P)H and gluthathione. Interestingly, the oxidizing potential of Fe(CN)6³⁻ inside coacervates can be harnessed to drive the formation of new amide bonds between prebiotically relevant amino acids and α-amidothioacids. Aminoacylation is enhanced in Fe(CN)6³⁻/peptide coacervates and selective for amino acids that interact less strongly with the coacervates. We finally use Fe(CN)6³⁻-containing coacervates to spatially control assembly of fibrous networks inside and at the surface of coacervate protocells. These results provide an important step towards the prebiotically relevant integration of redox chemistry in primitive cell-like compartments.
Conspectus
Cells have evolved to be self-sustaining compartmentalized systems that consist of many thousands of biomolecules and metabolites interacting in complex cycles and reaction networks. Numerous subtle intricacies of these self-assembled structures are still largely unknown. The importance of liquid–liquid phase separation (both membraneless and membrane bound) is, however, recognized as playing an important role in achieving biological function that is controlled in time and space. Reconstituting biochemical reactions in vitro has been a success of the last decades, for example, establishment of the minimal set of enzymes and nutrients able to replicate cellular activities like the in vitro transcription translation of genes to proteins. Further than this though, artificial cell research has the aim of combining synthetic materials and nonliving macromolecules into ordered assemblies with the ability to carry out more complex and ambitious cell-like functions. These activities can provide insights into fundamental cell processes in simplified and idealized systems but could also have an applied impact in synthetic biology and biotechnology in the future. To date, strategies for the bottom-up fabrication of micrometer scale life-like artificial cells have included stabilized water-in-oil droplets, giant unilamellar vesicles (GUV’s), hydrogels, and complex coacervates. Water-in-oil droplets are a valuable and easy to produce model system for studying cell-like processes; however, the lack of a crowded interior can limit these artificial cells in mimicking life more closely. Similarly membrane stabilized vesicles, such as GUV’s, have the additional membrane feature of cells but still lack a macromolecularly crowded cytoplasm. Hydrogel-based artificial cells have a macromolecularly dense interior (although cross-linked) that better mimics cells, in addition to mechanical properties more similar to the viscoelasticity seen in cells but could be seen as being not dynamic in nature and limiting to the diffusion of biomolecules. On the other hand, liquid–liquid phase separated complex coacervates are an ideal platform for artificial cells as they can most accurately mimic the crowded, viscous, highly charged nature of the eukaryotic cytoplasm. Other important key features that researchers in the field target include stabilizing semipermeable membranes, compartmentalization, information transfer/communication, motility, and metabolism/growth. In this Account, we will briefly cover aspects of coacervation theory and then outline key cases of synthetic coacervate materials used as artificial cells (ranging from polypeptides, modified polysaccharides, polyacrylates, and polymethacrylates, and allyl polymers), finishing with envisioned opportunities and potential applications for coacervate artificial cells moving forward.
Biomolecular assembly processes involving competition between specific intermolecular interactions and thermodynamic phase instability have been implicated in a number of pathological states and technological applications of biomaterials. As a model for such processes, aqueous mixtures of oppositely charged homochiral polypeptides such as poly-l-lysine and poly-l-glutamic acid have been reported to form either β-sheet-rich solid-like precipitates or liquid-like coacervate droplets depending on competing hydrogen bonding interactions. Herein, we report studies of polypeptide mixtures that reveal unexpectedly diverse morphologies ranging from partially coalescing and aggregated droplets to bulk precipitates, as well as a previously unreported re-entrant liquid-liquid phase separation at high polypeptide concentration and ionic strength. Combining our experimental results with all-atom molecular dynamics simulations of folded polypeptide complexes reveals a concentration dependence of β-sheet-rich secondary structure, whose relative composition correlates with the observed macroscale morphologies of the mixtures. These results elucidate a crucial balance of interactions that are important for controlling morphology during coacervation in these and potentially similar biologically relevant systems.
This study presents a simple strategy for the sequestration of globular proteins as clients into synthetic polypeptide-based complex coacervates as a scaffold, thereby recapitulating the scaffold-client interaction found in biological condensates. Considering the low net charges of scaffold proteins participating in biological condensates, the linear charge density (σ) on the polyanion, polyethylene glycol-b-poly(aspartic acids), was reduced by introducing hydroxypropyl or butyl moieties as a charge-neutral pendant group. Complex coacervate prepared from the series of reduced-σ polyanions and the polycation, homo-poly-l-lysine, could act as a scaffold that sequestered various globular proteins with high encapsulation efficiency (>80%), which sometimes involved further agglomerations in the coacervates. The sequestration of proteins was basically driven by electrostatic interaction, and therefore depended on the ionic strength and charges of the proteins. However, based on the results of polymer partitioning in the coacervate in the presence or absence of proteins, charge ratios between cationic and anionic polymers were maintained at the charge ratio of unity. Therefore, the origin of the electrostatic interaction with proteins is considered to be dynamic frustrated charges in the complex coacervates created by non-neutralized charges on polymer chains. Furthermore, fluorescence recovery after photobleaching (FRAP) measurements showed that the interaction of side-chains and proteins changed the dynamic property of coacervates. It also suggested that the physical properties of the condensate are tunable before and after the sequestration of globular proteins. The present rational design approach of the scaffold-client interaction is helpful for basic life-science research and the applied frontier of artificial organelles.
Metabolism and compartmentalization are two of life's most central elements. Constructing synthetic assemblies based on prebiotically relevant molecules that combine these elements can provide insight into the requirements for the formation of life‐like protocells from abiotic building blocks. In this work, we show that a wide variety of small anionic metabolites can form complex coacervate protocells with oligoarginine (R10) by phase separation. The coacervate stability can be rationalized by the molecular structure of the metabolites, and we show that three negative charges for carboxylates, or two negative charges complemented with an unsaturated moiety for phosphates and sulfates is sufficient for phase separation. The metabolites remain reactive after compartmentalization, and we show that protometabolic reactions can induce coacervate formation. The resulting coacervates can localize other metabolites and enhance their conversion. Finally, reactions of compartmentalized metabolites can also alter the physicochemical properties of the coacervates and ultimately lead to protocell dissolution. These results reveal the intricate interplay between (proto)metabolic reactions and coacervate compartments, and show that coacervates are excellent candidates for metabolically active protocells.
Proteins and peptides are attractive chemical building blocks to encapsulate and protect active substances thanks to their biocompatibility, biodegradability, low immunogenicity, and added functionality compared to synthetic polymers. This review provides a comprehensive overview of micro- and nanocapsules predominantly made of proteins—both natural and artificially produced—and peptides, detailing their different fabrication techniques and possible applications in various fields, including food technology and healthcare. Emphasis is given on the capability of proteins and peptides to assemble into capsular structures in the absence (e.g., protein cages and polypeptide-based coacervates) or presence of a template, as well as on the physical nature of the carriers core, i.e., gaseous, liquid, or solid.
Active coacervate droplets are liquid condensates coupled to a chemical reaction that turns over their components, keeping the droplets out of equilibrium. This turnover can be used to drive active processes such as growth, and provide an insight into the chemical requirements underlying (proto)cellular behaviour. Moreover, controlled growth is a key requirement to achieve population fitness and survival. Here we present a minimal, nucleotide-based coacervate model for active droplets, and report three key findings that make these droplets into evolvable protocells. First, we show that coacervate droplets form and grow by the fuel-driven synthesis of new coacervate material. Second, we find that these droplets do not undergo Ostwald ripening, which we attribute to the attractive electrostatic interactions and translational entropy within complex coacervates, active or passive. Finally, we show that the droplet growth rate reflects experimental conditions such as substrate, enzyme and protein concentration, and that a different droplet composition (addition of RNA) leads to altered growth rates and droplet fitness. These findings together make active coacervate droplets a powerful platform to mimic cellular growth at a single-droplet level, and to study fitness at a population level.
Coacervates are condensed liquid-like droplets formed by liquid-liquid phase separation of molecules through multiple weak associative interactions. In recent years it has emerged that not only long polymers, but also short peptides are capable of forming simple and complex coacervates. The coacervate droplets they form act as compartments that sequester and concentrate a wide range of solutes, and their spontaneous formation make coacervates attractive protocell models. The main advantage of peptides as building blocks lies in the functional diversity of the amino acid residues, which allows for tailoring of the peptide's phase separation propensity, their selectivity in guest molecule uptake and the physicochemical and catalytic properties of the compartments. The aim of this tutorial review is to illustrate the recent developments in the field of peptide-based coacervates in a systematic way and to deduce the basic requirements for both simple and complex coacervation of peptides. We review a selection of peptide coacervates that illustrates the essentials of phase separation, the limitations, and the properties that make peptide coacervates biomimetic protocells. Finally, we provide some perspectives of this novel research field in the direction of active droplets, moving away from thermodynamic equilibrium.
Multivalent polyions can undergo complex coacervation, producing membraneless compartments that accumulate ribozymes and enhance catalysis, and offering a mechanism for functional prebiotic compartmentalization in the origins of life. Here, we evaluate the impact of lower, more prebiotically-relevant, polyion multivalency on the functional performance of coacervates as compartments. Positively and negatively charged homopeptides with 1–100 residues and adenosine mono-, di-, and triphosphate nucleotides are used as model polyions. Polycation/polyanion pairs are tested for coacervation, and resulting membraneless compartments are analyzed for salt resistance, ability to provide a distinct internal microenvironment (apparent local pH, RNA partitioning), and effect on RNA structure formation. We find that coacervates formed by phase separation of the shorter polyions more effectively generated distinct pH microenvironments, accumulated RNA, and preserved duplexes than those formed by longer polyions. Hence, coacervates formed by reduced multivalency polyions are not only viable as functional compartments for prebiotic chemistries, they can outperform higher molecular weight analogues.
Protein encapsulation is a growing area of interest, particularly in the fields of food science and medicine. The sequestration of protein cargoes is achieved using a variety of methods, each with benefits and drawbacks. One of the most significant challenges associated with protein encapsulation is achieving high loading while maintaining protein viability. This difficulty is exacerbated because many encapsulant systems require the use of organic solvents. By contrast, nature has optimized strategies to compartmentalize and protect proteins inside the cell—a purely aqueous environment. Although the mechanisms whereby aspects of the cytosol is able to stabilize proteins are unknown, the crowded nature of many newly discovered, liquid phase separated “membraneless organelles” that achieve protein compartmentalization suggests that the material environment surrounding the protein may be critical in determining stability. Here, encapsulation strategies based on liquid–liquid phase separation, and complex coacervation in particular, which has many of the key features of the cytoplasm as a material, are reviewed. The literature on protein encapsulation via coacervation is also reviewed and the parameters relevant to creating protein‐containing coacervate formulations are discussed. Additionally, potential opportunities associated with the creation of tailored materials to better facilitate protein encapsulation and stabilization are highlighted.
Liquid-liquid phase separation plays an important role in cellular organization. Many subcellular condensed bodies are hierarchically organized into multiple coexisting domains or layers. However, our molecular understanding of the assembly and internal organization of these multicomponent droplets is still incomplete, and rules for the coexistence of condensed phases are lacking. Here, we show that the formation of hierarchically organized multiphase droplets with up to three coexisting layers is a generic phenomenon in mixtures of complex coacervates, which serve as models of charge-driven liquid-liquid phase separated systems. We present simple theoretical guidelines to explain both the hierarchical arrangement and the demixing transition in multiphase droplets using the interfacial tensions and critical salt concentration as inputs. Multiple coacervates can coexist if they differ sufficiently in macromolecular density, and we show that the associated differences in critical salt concentration can be used to predict multiphase droplet formation. We also show that the coexisting coacervates present distinct chemical environments that can concentrate guest molecules to different extents. Our findings suggest that condensate immiscibility may be a very general feature in biological systems, which could be exploited to design self-organized synthetic compartments to control biomolecular processes.
Polyamine–salt aggregates (PSA) are biomimetic soft materials that have attracted great attention due to their straightforward fabrication methods, high drug‐loading efficiencies, and attractive properties for pH‐triggered release. Herein, a simple and fast multicomponent self‐assembly process was used to construct cross‐linked poly(allylamine hydrochloride)/phosphate PSAs (hydrodynamic diameter of 360 nm) containing glucose oxidase enzyme, as a glucose‐responsive element, and human recombinant insulin, as a therapeutic agent for the treatment of diabetes mellitus (GI‐PSA). The addition of increasing glucose concentrations promotes the release of insulin due to the disassembly of the GI‐PSAs triggered by the catalytic in situ formation of gluconic acid. Under normoglycemia, the GI‐PSA integrity remained intact for at least 24 h, whereas hyperglycemic conditions resulted in 100 % cargo release after 4 h of glucose addition. This entirely supramolecular strategy presents great potential for the construction of smart glucose‐responsive delivery nanocarriers.
Membrane-less organelles are liquid compartments within cells with different solvent properties than the surrounding environment. This difference in solvent properties is thought to result in function related selective partitioning of proteins. Proteins have also been shown to accumulate in polyelectrolyte complexes but whether the uptake in these complexes is selective has not been ascertained yet. Here we show the selective partitioning of two structurally similar but oppositely charged proteins into polyelectrolyte complexes. We demonstrate that these proteins can be separated from a mixture by altering the polyelectrolyte complex composition and released from the complexed by lowering the pH. Combined, we demonstrate that polyelectrolyte complexes can separate proteins from a mixture based on protein charge. Besides providing deeper insight into the selective partitioning in membrane-less organelles, potential applications for selective biomolecule partitioning in polyelectrolyte complexes include drug delivery or extraction processes.
Polyelectrolyte complexes that form between oppositely charged macromolecules could be solid or fluid, depending on water and salt content.
Water plays a central role in the assembly and the dynamics of charged systems such as proteins, enzymes, DNA, and surfactants. Yet it remains a challenge to resolve how water affects relaxation at a molecular level, particularly for assemblies of oppositely charged macromolecules. Here, the molecular origin of water’s influence on the glass transition is quantified for several charged macromolecular systems. It is revealed that the glass transition temperature (Tg) is controlled by the number of water molecules surrounding an oppositely charged polyelectrolyte–polyelectrolyte intrinsic ion pair as 1/Tg ∼ ln(nH2O/nintrinsic ion pair). This relationship is found to be “general”, as it holds for two completely different types of charged systems (pH- and salt-sensitive) and for both polyelectrolyte complexes and polyelectrolyte multilayers, which are made by different paths. This suggests that water facilitates the relaxation of charged assemblies by reducing attractions between oppositely charged intrinsic ion pairs. This finding impacts current interpretations of relaxation dynamics in charged assemblies and points to water’s important contribution at the molecular level.
Polysaccharide-protein complex coacervates are amongst the leading pair of biopolymer systems that has been used over the past decades for encapsulation of numerous active ingredients. Complex coacervation of polysaccharides and proteins have received increasing research interest for the practical application in encapsulation industry since the pioneering work of complex coacervation by Bungenburg de Jong and co-workers on the system of gelatin-acacia, a protein- polysaccharide system. Because of the versatility and numerous potential applications of these systems essentially in the fields of food, pharmaceutical, cosmetics and agriculture, there has been intense interest in recent years for both fundamental and applied studies. Precisely, the designing of the micronscale and nanoscale capsules for encapsulation and control over their properties for practical applications garners renewed interest. This review discusses on the overview of polysaccharide-protein complex coacervates and their use for the encapsulation of diverse active ingredients, designing and controlling of the capsules for delivery systems and developments in the area.
Salt acts as a plasticizer in polyelectrolyte complexes (PECs), which impacts the physical, thermal, and mechanical properties, thus having implications in applications, such as drug delivery, energy storage, and smart coatings. Added salt disrupts polycation–polyanion intrinsic ion pairs, lowering a hydrated PEC’s glass transition temperature (Tg). However, the relative influence of counterion type on the PEC’s Tg is not well understood. Here, the effect of anion type (NaCl, NaBr, NaNO3, and NaI) on the Tg of solid-like, hydrated PECs composed of poly(diallydimethylammonium) (PDADMA)–poly(styrenesulfonate) (PSS) is investigated. With increasing the chaotropic nature of the salt anion, the Tg decreases. The relative differences are attributed to the doping level, the amount of bound water, the mobility of water molecules within the PECs, and the strength of interactions between the PEs. For all studied salt concentrations and salt types, the Tg followed the scaling of −1/Tg ≈ ln([IP]/[H2O]), in which [IP]/[H2O] is the ratio of intrinsic pairs to water. The scaling estimates that about 7 to 17% of the intrinsic ion pairs should be weakened for the PEC to partake in a glass transition. Put together, this study highlights that the Tg in PECs is impacted by the salt anion, but the mechanism of the glass transition remains unchanged.
Complex coacervation refers to the liquid–liquid phase separation (LLPS) process occurring between charged macromolecules. The study of complex coacervation is of great interest due to its implications in the formation of membraneless organelles (MLOs) in living cells. However, the impacts of the crowded intracellular environment on the behavior and interactions of biomolecules involved in MLO formation are not fully understood. To address this knowledge gap, we investigated the effects of crowding on a model protein–polymer complex coacervate system. Specifically, we examined the influence of sucrose as a molecular crowder and polyethylene glycol (PEG) as a macromolecular crowder. Our results reveal that the presence of crowders led to the formation of larger coacervate droplets that remained stable over a 25-day period. While sucrose had a minimal effect on the physical properties of the coacervates, PEG led to the formation of coacervates with distinct characteristics, including higher density, increased protein and polymer content, and a more compact internal structure. These differences in coacervate properties can be attributed to the effects of crowders on individual macromolecules, such as the conformation of model polymers, and nonspecific interactions among model protein molecules. Moreover, our results show that sucrose and PEG have different partition behaviors: sucrose was present in both the coacervate and dilute phases, while PEG was observed to be excluded from the coacervate phase. Collectively, our findings provide insights into the understanding of crowding effects on complex coacervation, shedding light on the formation and properties of coacervates in the context of MLOs.
This work reports the phase behavior and electro-chemical properties of liquid coacervates made of ferricyanide and poly(ethylenimine). In contrast to the typical polyanion/polycation pairs used in liquid coacervates, the ferricyanide/poly-(ethylenimine) system is highly asymmetric because poly-(ethylenimine) has approximately 170 charges per molecule, while ferricyanide has only 3. Two types of phase diagrams were measured and fitted with a theoretical model. In the first type of diagram, the stability of the coacervate was studied in the plane given by the concentration of poly(ethylenimine) versus the concentration of ferricyanide for a fixed concentration of added monovalent salt (NaCl). The second type of diagram involved the plane given by the concentration of poly(ethylenimine) vs the concentration of the added monovalent salt for a fixed poly(ethyleneimine)/ferricyanide ratio. Interestingly, these phase diagrams displayed qualitative similarities to those of symmetric polyanion/polycation systems, suggesting that coacervates formed by a polyelectrolyte and a small multivalent ion can be treated as a specific case of polyelectrolyte coacervate. The characterization of the electrochemical properties of the coacervate revealed that the addition of monovalent salt greatly enhances charge transport, presumably by breaking ion pairs between ferricyanide and poly(ethylenimine). This finding highlights the significant influence of added salt on the transport properties of coacervates. This study provides the first comprehensive characterization of the phase behavior and transport properties of asymmetric coacervates and places these results within the broader context of the better-known symmetric polyelectrolyte coacervates.
In food manufacturing and particular biomedical products selected proteins are often required. Obtaining the desired proteins in a pure form from natural resources is therefore important, but often very challenging. Herein, we design a sequential coacervation process that allows to efficiently isolate and purify proteins with different isoelectric points (pIs) from a mixed solution, namely Bovine Serum Albumin (BSA, pI = 4.9) and Peroxidase from Horseradish (HRP, pI = 7.2). The key to separation is introducing a suitable polyelectrolyte that causes selective complex coacervation at appropriate pH and ionic strength. Specifically, polyethyleneimine (PEI), when added into the mixture at pH 6.0, produces a coacervation which exclusively contains BSA, leading to a supernatant solution containing 100 % HRP with a purity of 91 %. After separating the dilute and dense phases, BSA is recovered by adding poly(acrylic acid) (PAA) to the concentrated phase, which displaces BSA from the complex because it interacts more strongly with PEI. The supernatant phase after this step contains approximately 75 % of the initial amount of BSA with a purity of 99 %. Our results confirm that coacervation under well-defined conditions can be selective, enabling separation of proteins with adequate purity. Therefore, the established approach demonstrates a facile and sustainable strategy with potential for protein separation at industrial scale.
The complexation of polyelectrolytes with other oppositely charged structures gives rise to a great variety of functional materials with potential applications in a wide spectrum of technological fields. Depending on the assembly conditions, polyelectrolyte complexes can acquire different macroscopic configurations such as dense precipitates, nanosized colloids and liquid coacervates. In the past 50 years, much progress has been achieved to understand the principles behind the phase separation induced by the interaction of two oppositely charged polyelectrolytes in aqueous solutions, especially for symmetric systems (systems in which both polyions have similar molecular weight and concentration). However, in recent years, the complexation of polyelectrolytes with alternative building blocks such as small charged molecules (multivalent inorganic species, oligopeptides, and oligoamines, among others) has gained attention in different areas. In this review, we discuss the physicochemical characteristics of the complexes formed by polyelectrolytes and multivalent small molecules, putting a special emphasis on their similarities with the well-known polycation-polyanion complexes. In addition, we analyze the potential of these complexes to act as versatile functional platforms in various technological fields, such as biomedicine and advanced materials engineering.
The associative phase separation of biomacromolecules can produce both liquid-like coacervates or solid-like precipitates. In this study, we found that sodium chloride (NaCl) can programme the phase transition of β-conglycinin/lysozyme (β-CG/LYS) complexes. NaCl reduced the ζ-potential of both β-CG and LYS. Their complex coacervate was formed at pHs 6 and 7 with 5–80 mM NaCl and at pH 8 with 40–80 mM NaCl. Unlike the high critical salt concentration and entropy gain driving force of polyelectrolyte-based complex coacervation, 100 mM NaCl almost completely inhibited β-CG/LYS complexation, and the exothermic enthalpy change was the main driving force for β-CG/LYS complex formation. Confocal laser scanning microscopy with fluorescein isothiocyanate-labeled proteins demonstrated dynamic protein exchange in coacervate droplets, similar to that in polyelectrolyte-based complex coacervates.
This paper investigated the formation of a novel complex coacervate between gliadin (G) and sodium alginate (SA) as well as its relationship with the encapsulation and controlled release properties by loading curcumin (Cur). G-SA coacervates (GSAC) were fabricated using the anti-solvent method to form gliadin nanoparticles (GNPs) and then electrostatic deposition with SA to form coacervates. Based on the turbidimetric analysis and ζ-potential results, coacervates were formed at a wide range of pH (1.0–7.0) through electrostatic interaction in the gliadin-SA system. The gliadin-SA interaction was spontaneous exothermic process shown by the isothermal titration calorimetry. The spherical particles of curcumin-loading G-SA coacervates (GSAC-Cur) with well-homogeneity and great-dispersion as well as particle aggregation were observed on SEM. At coacervated pHs, GSAC-Cur showed particle size from 433.55 to 1496.50 nm, PDI around 0.28, ζ-potential from −1.9 to −50.9 mV and encapsulation efficiency from 61.29% to 81.01%. Controlled release profiles confirmed that G-SA coacervates reduced the released speed of curcumin in the release process. In summary, we concluded that the properties of GSAC-Cur corresponding to the embedding and controlled release could be better by forming coacervates via pH-induced.
Multivalency-driven liquid-liquid phase separation (LLPS) is essential for biomolecular condensates to facilitate spatiotemporal regulation of biological functions. Providing programmable model systems would help to better understand the LLPS processes in biology and furnish new types of compartmentalized synthetic reaction crucibles that exploit biological principles. Herein, we demonstrate a concept for programming LLPS using transient multivalency between ATP-driven sequence-defined functionalized nucleic acid polymers (SfNAPs), which serve as simple models for membrane-less organelles. Critically, the prominent programmability of the DNA-based building blocks allows to encode distinct molecular recognitions for multiple multivalent systems, enabling sorted LLPS and, thus, multicomponent DNA coacervates. The ATP-driven coacervates are capable for multivalent trapping of micron-scale colloids and biomolecules to generate functions as emphasized for rate enhancements in enzymatic cascades. This work demonstrates ATP-driven multivalent coacervation as a valuable mechanism for dynamic multicomponent and functional biomolecular condensate mimics and for autonomous materials design in general.
Polyelectrolyte complexes (PECs) offer enormous material tunability and desirable functionalities, and consequently have found broad utility in biomedical and material industries. While poly(acrylic acid) (PAA) and poly(allylamine hydrochloride) (PAH) are a commonly used pairing, various aspects of the phase behavior of PAA-PAH complexes have not been sufficiently quantified. We present a comprehensive experimental study depicting the binodal phase boundaries for the PAA-PAH complexes prepared under acidic, neutral, and basic conditions using thermogravimetric analysis, turbidimetry, and optical microscopy. Under neutral and basic conditions, phase behaviors of the complexes were largely similar to one another and followed general expectations of PEC phase behavior, except for unusually high resistance to disruption of the complex with added salt. Stable complexes are observed up to 4 M NaCl concentrations. Under acidic conditions, strikingly different phase behaviors of the PAA-PAH complexes were observed. The polymer content in the complex phase increased initially, followed by an expected decrease as salt was added to the complexes. This behavior may result from a combination of associative phase separation of PAA and PAH chains, influenced by electrostatic interactions, and segregative phase separation, which can be ascribed to the influence of a combination of the hydrophobic interactions of the aliphatic polymer backbone and the interpolymer hydrogen bonding of un-ionized acrylic monomer units. Our systematic investigations over a range of pH detailing these discrepancies in the PAA-PAH phase behavior are expected to clarify the inconsistencies among the reports in the literature and provide the material design strategies for practical use of the PAA-PAH complexes and multilayer assemblies.
Complex coacervates have found a renewed interest in the past few decades in various fields such as food and personal care products, membraneless cellular compartments, the origin of life, and, most notably, as a mode of transport and stabilization of drugs. Here, we describe general methods for characterizing the phase behavior of complex coacervates and quantifying the incorporation of proteins into these phase separated materials.
Polyamine-salt aggregates have become promising soft materials in nanotechnology due to their easy preparation process and pH-responsiveness. Here, we report the use of hexacyanoferrate (II) and hexacyanoferrate (III) as electroactive crosslinking agents for the formation of nanometer-sized redox-active polyamine-redox-salt aggregates (rPSA) in bulk suspension. This nanoplatform can be selectively assembled or disassembled under different stimuli such as redox environment, pH and ionic strength. By changing the charge of the building blocks, external triggers allow switching the system between two-phase states: aggregates-free solution or colloidal rPSA dispersion. The stimuli-activated modulation of the assembly/disassembly processes opens a path to exploit rPSA in technologies based on smart nanomaterials.
Complex coacervation is an associative, liquid-liquid phase separation that can occur in solutions of oppositely-charged macromolecular species, such as proteins, polymers, and colloids. This process results in a coacervate phase, which is a dense mix of the oppositely-charged components, and a supernatant phase, which is primarily devoid of these same species. First observed almost a century ago, coacervates have since found relevance in a wide range of applications; they are used in personal care and food products, cutting edge biotechnology, and as a motif for materials design and self-assembly. There has recently been a renaissance in our understanding of this important class of material phenomena, bringing the science of coacervation to the forefront of polymer and colloid science, biophysics, and industrial materials design. In this review, we describe the emergence of a number of these new research directions, specifically in the context of polymer-polymer complex coacervates, which are inspired by a number of key physical and chemical insights and driven by a diverse range of experimental, theoretical, and computational approaches.
Biological systems employ liquid-liquid phase separation to localize macromolecules and processes. The properties of intracellular condensates that allow for multiple, distinct liquid compartments, and the impact of their coexistence on phase composition and solute partitioning are not well understood. Here, we generate two and three coexisting macromolecule-rich liquid compartments by complex coacervation based on ion pairing in mixtures that contain two or three polyanions together with one, two, or three polycations. While in some systems polyelectrolyte order-of-addition was important to achieve coexisting liquid phases, for others it was not, suggesting that the observed multiphase droplet morphologies are energetically favorable. Polyelectrolytes were distributed across all coacervate phases, depending on the relative interactions between them, which in turn impacted partitioning of oligonucleotide and oligopeptide solutes. These results show the ease of generating multiphase coacervates and the ability to tune their partitioning properties via the polyelectrolyte sharing inherent to multiphase complex coacervate systems.
The use of peptides and proteins in the pharmaceutical field has increased dramatically over recent years. They have been especially relevant to advances in the treatment of cancer, rheumatoid arthritis, leukemia, cardiovascular, ophthalmological, metabolic and infectious diseases. Despite the great potential of peptides and proteins, their use in pharmaceuticals has failed to reach its full potential due to outstanding challenges. They are unstable in storage conditions and biological milieu and their high molecular weight limits permeation through biological membranes. A variety of delivery systems have been investigated to overcome these limitations. Polyelectrolytes (PEs) are molecules that bear multiple negative or positive charges. These molecules play an important role in various platforms relating to the delivery of peptide/protein-based drugs and subunit vaccines. The most commonly utilized PEs include chitosan, alginate, chondroitin sulfate, and poly-γ-glutamic acid. PE-based delivery systems, such as polyelectrolyte complex (PEC), PE-coated nanocarriers, and PE multilayers, were designed to protect peptides and proteins from degradation and facilitate their absorption. These delivery systems are especially effective when administered orally or intranasally. This review emphasizes the important role of PEs and PE-based delivery vehicles in peptide/protein-based drugs and vaccines.
We investigated the encapsulation of the model proteins bovine serum albumin (BSA), human hemoglobin (Hb), and hen egg white lysozyme (HEWL) into two-polymer complex coacervates as a function of polymer and solution conditions. Electrostatic parameters such as pH, protein net charge, salt concentration, and polymer charge density can be used to modulate protein uptake. While the use of a two-polymer coacervation system enables the encapsulation of weakly charged proteins that would otherwise require chemical modification to facilitate electrostatic complexation, we observed significantly higher uptake for proteins whose structure includes a cluster of like-charged residues on the protein surface. In addition to enhancing uptake, the presence of a charge patch also increased the sensitivity of the system to modulation by other parameters, including the length of the complexing polymers. Lastly, our results suggest that the distribution of charge on a protein surface may lead to different scaling behaviour for both the encapsulation efficiency and partition coefficient as a function of the absolute difference between the protein isoelectric point and the solution pH. These results provide insight into possible biophysical mechanisms whereby cells can control the uptake of proteins into coacervate-like granules, and suggest future utility in applications ranging from medicine and sensing to remediation and biocatalysis.
In this study, diatomite fossil particles (i.e., bio-silica) was treated with strong acid solution and coated with polydopamine (bio-silica-PDA) using aqueous-based bioinspired coating method. The bio-silica-PDA was grafted with tetraethylenepentamine (TEPA) ligand to increase binding sites on the material surfaces. The biosilica-PDA-TEPA particles was characterized using Fourier-transform infrared spectroscopy (FTIR), Scanning electron microscope (SEM), X-Ray Diffraction (XRD) and Brunauer–Emmett–Teller (BET) method. The adsorption performance of the biosilica-PDA-TEPA particles was studied using a model dye (i.e., Direct Blue 74; DB-74) from aqueous solutions using biosilica-PDA as a control system. Batch system was used to optimize experimental conditions for the removal of DB-74 dye on the sorbents. The adsorption of DB-74 on the biosilica-PDA-TEPA particles was studied in the pH range of 2.0–8.0. The amount adsorbed DB-74 dye on the biosilica-PDA-TEPA was 363.3 mg g⁻¹ (using initial dye concentration 1200 mg L⁻¹, pH 3.0 and temperature 25 °C). Adsorption of DB-74 dye on biosilica-PDA-TEPA particles fitted well Langmuir model. The equilibrium adsorption time was completed within 10 min and the experimental data was defined well by the pseudo-second-order model. In addition, the biosilica-PDA-TEPA particles presented a good performance after regeneration. This result show that the presented low-cost porous biosilica-PDA-TEPA particles can be a good candidate as a novel sorbent system for removal of micro-pollutants from wastewaters.
Complex coacervation can be used as a route to compartmentalize a variety of solutes such as organic small molecules, inorganic nanoparticles, and proteins within microscale coacervate droplets. To obtain insight into the accumulation of proteins within complex coacervate phases, the encapsulation of Bovine Serum Albumin (BSA) within complex coacervates containing cationic polyelectrolyte poly(allylamine hydrochloride) (PAH) and anionic polyelectrolyte poly(acrylic aid) (PAA) was investigated as a function of mixing sequence, total polyelectrolyte concentration, BSA overall concentration, and the mixing molar ratio of PAA/PAH. Mixing BSA having a negative net charge with the polycation PAH before coacervation, increasing the total polyelectrolyte concentration and PAA/PAH molar ratio, or decreasing the BSA overall concentration led to more efficient protein encapsulation. Preservation of the secondary structure of BSA during the complex coacervation process was confirmed using circular dichroism spectroscopy. Our study shows that PAA-PAH coacervates can serve as a protective system against the denaturation of BSA when exposed to extremes of pH, high temperatures, as well as in solution of urea. Additionally, it was found that by encapsulation of proteins within coacervates via complex coacervation, the complexation between proteins and heavy metal can be efficiently inhibited. Protection of BSA against severe environmental conditions via encapsulation within polyelectrolyte coacervates provides new insights and methods to issues of maintaining stability and function of proteins.
Weak polyelectrolytes are relevant for a wide range of fields; in particular, they have been investigated as “smart” materials for chemical separations and drug delivery. The charges on weak polyelectrolytes are dynamic, causing polymer chains to adopt different equilibrium conformations even with relatively small changes to the surrounding environment. Currently, there exists no comprehensive picture of this behavior, particularly where polymer–polymer interactions have the potential to affect charging properties significantly. In this study, we elucidate the novel interplay between weak polyelectrolyte charging and complexation behavior through coupled molecular dynamics and Monte Carlo simulations. Specifically, we investigate a model of two equal-length and oppositely charging polymer chains in an implicit salt solution represented through Debye–Hückel interactions. The charging tendency of each chain, along with the salt concentration, is varied to determine the existence and extent of cooperativity in charging and complexation. Strong cooperation in the charging of these chains is observed at large Debye lengths, corresponding to low salt concentrations, while at lower Debye lengths (higher salt concentrations), the chains behave in apparent isolation. When the electrostatic coupling is long-ranged, we find that a highly charged chain strongly promotes the charging of its partner chain, even if the environment is unfavorable for an isolated version of that partner chain. Evidence of this phenomenon is supported by a drop in the potential energy of the system, which does not occur at the lower Debye lengths where both potential energies and charge fractions converge for all partner chain charging tendencies. The discovery of this cooperation will be helpful in developing “smart” drug delivery mechanisms by allowing for better predictions for the dissociation point of delivery complexes.
Membraneless organelles, like membrane-bound organelles, are essential to cell homeostasis and provide discrete cellular sub-compartments. Unlike classical organelles, membraneless organelles possess no physical barrier, but rather arise by phase separation of the organelle components from the surrounding cytoplasm or nucleoplasm. Complex coacervation, the liquid-liquid phase separation of oppositely charged polyelectrolytes, is one of several phenomena that is hypothesized to drive the formation and regulation of some membraneless organelles. Studies to examine the molecular properties of globular proteins that drive complex coacervation are limited as many proteins do not complex with oppositely charged macromolecules at neutral pH and moderate ionic strength. Protein supercharging overcomes this problem and drives complexation with oppositely charged macromolecules. In this work, several distinct cationic supercharged green fluorescent protein (GFP) variants were designed to examine the phase behavior with oppositely charged polyanionic macromolecules. Cationic GFP variants phase separated with oppositely charged macromolecules at various mixing ratios, salt concentrations, and pH values. Efficient protein incorporation in the macromolecule rich phase occurred over a range of protein and polymer mass fractions, but protein encapsulation efficiency was highest at the midpoint of the phase separation regime. More positively charged proteins phase separated over broader pH and salt ranges than proteins with lower charge density. Interestingly, each GFP variant phase separated at higher salt concentrations with anionic synthetic macromolecules compared to anionic biological macromolecules. Optical microscopy revealed that most variants, depending on solution conditions, formed liquid-liquid phase separations, except for GFP/DNA pairs which formed solid aggregates at all tested conditions.
Chitosan/tripolyphosphate (TPP) micro- and nanogels are widely explored as vehicles for protein drug and vaccine delivery. Yet, aside from the consensus that protein uptake into these particles is enhanced by stronger protein/particle binding, factors that control their uptake performance, such as differences in the chitosan, TPP and protein concentrations, remain poorly understood. Here, we show that many of the differences in the reported association efficiencies (AE-values) for protein uptake likely reflect the largely-ignored variability in the particle yield (XAgg), which is the fraction of the added chitosan that self-assembles into particles and (like the AE) varies with the chitosan, TPP and protein concentrations. Factors affecting XAgg are first systematically explored. The AE is then shown to scale almost linearly with the XAgg (which increases with the TPP and protein-to-chitosan ratios) until all chitosan aggregates into particles. Remarkably, the data collected at variable TPP and protein concentrations collapses onto a single AE ∝ XAgg curve for each protein type. Further analysis of protein/particle binding reveals this rise in AE with XAgg to reflect: (1) an increase in binding sites within the particles; and (2) a decrease in soluble (unaggregated) chitosan molecules, which form soluble protein/chitosan complexes and compete with the chitosan/TPP particles for the unassociated protein. These findings highlight the need to carefully analyze the effects of formulation parameters on chitosan/TPP particle yields and can likely be extended to other ionically crosslinked colloidal drug carriers.
There has been increasing interest in complex coacervates for deriving and transporting biomaterials. Complex coacervates are a dense, polyelectrolyte‐rich liquid that results from the electrostatic complexation of oppositely charged macroions. Coacervates have long been used as a strategy for encapsulation, particularly in food and personal care products. More recent efforts have focused on the utility of this class of materials for the encapsulation of small molecules, proteins, RNA , DNA , and other biomaterials for applications ranging from sensing to biomedicine. Furthermore, coacervate‐related materials have found utility in other areas of biomedicine, including cartilage mimics, tissue culture scaffolds, and adhesives for wet, biological environments. Here, we discuss the self‐assembly of complex coacervate‐based materials, current challenges in the intelligent design of these materials, and their utility applications in the broad field of biomedicine. WIREs Nanomed Nanobiotechnol 2017, 9:e1442. doi: 10.1002/wnan.1442
This article is categorized under: Therapeutic Approaches and Drug Discovery > Emerging Technologies
Diagnostic Tools > In Vitro Nanoparticle-Based Sensing
Implantable Materials and Surgical Technologies > Nanotechnology in Tissue Repair and Replacement
This chapter reviews the theoretical and experimental description of complexes and complex-based hybrid self-assemblies composed of flexible polyelectrolytes, with a special emphasis on thermodynamics, equilibrium structure, and properties of liquid complex coacervates. It discusses the theoretical frameworks that have been employed to describe complexation and properties of complexes, which is followed by a survey of computer simulations studies. It expores the experimental studies on the thermodynamics, structure, and bulk and interfacial properties of both coacervates and precipitates. Liquid-state (LS) theory has been recently used to explore a complete description of the correlations between the oppositely charged polyelectrolyte chains and the counterions in polyelectrolyte complexes. Perry and Sing [96] employed the polymer reference interaction site model (PRISM) to incorporate chain connectivity into a modified LS theory framework. The chapter discusses the bulk and interfacial properties, including polymer diffusion, viscoelastic behavior, and interfacial tension, of liquid polyelectrolyte complexes.
The coacervation of systems containing colloids (e.g. proteins or micelles) and polyelectrolytes (notably ionic polysaccharides) is often accompanied by precipitation. This can introduce inhomogeneity, irreversibility and irreproducible kinetics in applications in food science and bioengineering, with negative impact on texture and stability of food products, and unpredictable delivery of active “payloads.” The relationship between coacervation and precipitation is obscure in that coacervates might be intermediates in the formation of precipitates, or else the two phenomena might proceed by different but possibly simultaneous mechanisms. This review will summarize the recent literature on coacervation/precipitation in protein-polyelectrolyte systems for which reports are most abundant, particularly in the context of food science. We present current findings and opinions about the relationship between the two types of phase separation. Results vary considerably depending not only on the protein-polyelectrolyte pairs chosen, but also on conditions including macromolecular concentrations and ionic strength. Nevertheless, we offer some general approaches that could explain a variety of observations.
Proteins have gained increasing success as therapeutic agents; however, challenges exist in effective and efficient delivery. In this work, we present a simple and versatile method for encapsulating proteins via complex coacervation with oppositely charged polypeptides, poly(l-lysine) (PLys) and poly(d/l-glutamic acid) (PGlu). A model protein system, bovine serum albumin (BSA), was incorporated efficiently into coacervate droplets via electrostatic interaction up to a maximum loading of one BSA per PLys/PGlu pair and could be released under conditions of decreasing pH. Additionally, encapsulation within complex coacervates did not alter the secondary structure of the protein. Lastly the complex coacervate system was shown to be biocompatible and interact well with cells in vitro. A simple, modular system for encapsulation such as the one presented here may be useful in a range of drug delivery applications.
Stoichiometric polyelectrolyte complexes (PECs) of the strong polyelectrolytes poly(styrenesulfonate) (PSS) and poly(diallyldimethylammonium) (PDADMA) were dissociated and dissolved in aqueous KBr. Water was added to dilute the salt, allowing polyelectrolytes to reassociate. After appropriate equilibration, these mixtures yielded compositions spanning complexes (solid) to coacervates (elastic liquid) to dissolved solutions with increasing [KBr]. These compositions were defined by a ternary polymer/water/salt phase diagram. For coacervates, transient microphase separation could be induced by a small departure from equilibration temperature. A boundary between complex and coacervate states was defined by the crossover point between loss and storage modulus. Salt ions within the complex/coacervate were identified as either ion paired with polyelectrolytes (“doping”) or unassociated. The fraction of ion pair cross-links between polyelectrolytes as a function of KBr concentration was used to account for viscosity using a model of “sticky” reptation.