ArticlePublisher preview available

Perceived service climate and in-role and extra-role service performance: a moderated mediation model of work engagement and perceived overqualification

Authors:
To read the full-text of this research, you can request a copy directly from the authors.

Abstract and Figures

With the advent of the digital economy and the post-epidemic era, China’s retail enterprises face significant crises and challenges. Enhancing both the in-role and extra-role service performance of sales staff in physical stores is crucial for preserving competitive advantages and sustainable development of retail enterprises. Based on Conservation of Resources theory, this study proposes a moderated mediation model that elucidates how the perceived service climate impacts employee in-role and extra-role service performance through work engagement, as well as the moderating effect of perceived overqualification. Data were collected from 598 physical store sales staff and 117 direct supervisors across 19 retail enterprises using a multi-wave, multi-source survey. Hierarchical regression analysis confirmed our hypotheses, demonstrating that perceived service climate enhances employee in-role and extra-role service performance via the partial mediating effect of work engagement. Moreover, perceived overqualification positively moderates not only the link between perceived service climate and work engagement but also the mediating effects of work engagement between perceived service climate and in-role and extra-role service performance, separately. The theoretical and practical implications of these findings are discussed in detail.
This content is subject to copyright. Terms and conditions apply.
Current Psychology (2025) 44:1874–1895
https://doi.org/10.1007/s12144-024-07237-1
and building sustainable competitive advantages (Dey et al.,
2022). Within this context, physical retail outlets must capi-
talize on the unique strengths of in-person sales and focus
on elevating service quality to meet the evolving demands
of modern consumers (Wu et al., 2019). The behaviors and
performance of frontline service employees in these set-
tings play a pivotal role in shaping customer perceptions
of service quality and overall satisfaction (Alhelalat et al.,
2017). Consequently, enhancing the service performance
of sales sta—who contribute signicant customer value
through direct service interactions (Asante et al., 2022)—
has become a key management priority. In today’s dynamic
market environment, it is essential for organizations to
ensure that sales sta not only fulll their primary duties
with high quality and eciency but also engage in proactive
behaviors beyond their formal roles (Orlowski et al., 2021).
Thus, a balanced focus on both in-role and extra-role ser-
vice performance is critical to fostering the organization’s
sustainable growth and development (Zhang et al., 2011).
Introduction
In the era of the digital economy and post-pandemic recov-
ery, China’s retail industry faces heightened competition
both online and oine, creating a more uncertain business
environment (Pinto et al., 2023). To address these chal-
lenges, Chinese retail enterprises are actively pursuing
transformative strategies, such as prioritizing service qual-
ity, enhancing the integration of physical and online stores,
Beini Liu
liubeini@btbu.edu.cn
1 Business School, Beijing Technology and Business
University, 11 Fuchenglu, Haidian District, Beijing
100048, PR China
2 Personnel Testing Authorities, Ministry of Human Resources
and Social Security of the PRC, Building 6 Hepingli District
3, Dongcheng District, Beijing 100716, PR China
Abstract
With the advent of the digital economy and the post-epidemic era, China’s retail enterprises face signicant crises and
challenges. Enhancing both the in-role and extra-role service performance of sales sta in physical stores is crucial for
preserving competitive advantages and sustainable development of retail enterprises. Based on Conservation of Resources
theory, this study proposes a moderated mediation model that elucidates how the perceived service climate impacts
employee in-role and extra-role service performance through work engagement, as well as the moderating eect of per-
ceived overqualication. Data were collected from 598 physical store sales sta and 117 direct supervisors across 19 retail
enterprises using a multi-wave, multi-source survey. Hierarchical regression analysis conrmed our hypotheses, demon-
strating that perceived service climate enhances employee in-role and extra-role service performance via the partial medi-
ating eect of work engagement. Moreover, perceived overqualication positively moderates not only the link between
perceived service climate and work engagement but also the mediating eects of work engagement between perceived
service climate and in-role and extra-role service performance, separately. The theoretical and practical implications of
these ndings are discussed in detail.
Keywords Perceived service climate · In-role service performance · Extra-role service performance · Work
engagement · Perceived overqualication
Accepted: 20 December 2024 / Published online: 13 January 2025
© The Author(s), under exclusive licence to Springer Science+Business Media, LLC, part of Springer Nature 2025
Perceived service climate and in-role and extra-role service
performance: a moderated mediation model of work engagement and
perceived overqualication
DongmeiJin1· XinyuYao1· BeiniLiu1· ShiminWang1· ZhiyiWen2
1 3
Content courtesy of Springer Nature, terms of use apply. Rights reserved.
ResearchGate has not been able to resolve any citations for this publication.
Article
Full-text available
Purpose The main purpose of the current research is to examine affective and cognitive mechanisms by which the trickle-down effect of work engagement from leader to follower takes place. Design/methodology/approach The current research consisted of two independent studies. In study 1, an experience sampling method was used (N = 1,321 data points from 171 participants) to test within-person effects. In study 2, the authors recruited 266 employees working in 61 teams with two data collections one month apart, to test between-team effects among variables. Findings In two independent studies, leaders' work engagement resulted in followers engaging in surface acting (an affective process) and developing self-efficacy (a cognitive process), which in turn resulted in followers' work engagement. Originality/value The current research provides some clarifications to the literature on work contagion of engagement by examining dual mechanisms. In particular, although previous research emphasized the negative aspects of surface acting, the current research suggests that surface acting can be potentially helpful by facilitating the contagion effect of work engagement leaders to followers. Further, this research also examines the facilitative role of self-efficacy in mediating the relationship between a leader's work engagement and followers' work engagement. Finally, the authors conducted two independent studies that used different research designs, and results were consistent across the two studies, which can provide evidence for the robustness of the results.
Article
Full-text available
Drawing on the conservation of resources theory, this study examines the curvilinear relationship between social workers' meaningful work and work engagement. Data gathered from 223 social workers reveal that the relationship between meaningful work and work engagement showed a U-shaped curve when psychological capital is low. In contrast, this relationship showed an inverted U-shaped curve when psychological capital is high. Our study makes significant contributions to the literature in the following ways. First and foremost, this is the first paper that provides an established base to validate the momentary and changing nature of meaningful work empirically. Second, we further addressed how the fluctuating nature of meaningful work can be addressed through individuals' demographic variables of psychological capital. Finally, our results provide managerial interventions that support businesses in advancing the understanding of psychological processes in contexts related to the broad area of work and in organizations. PRACTICE POINTS • Meaningful work enhances work engagement. Nonprofit organizations (NPOs) should provide a safe space where social workers can share their victories, perspectives, and frustrations. • NPOs should provide ample support to employees and ensure they fit well into the new social work environment. • Given the malleable characteristics of PsyCap, NPOs can offer interventions in the form of training to increase social workers' sense of hope, efficacy, resilience and optimism. • The curvilinear effect of PsyCap on the relationship between meaningful work and work engagement shows that NPOs should also design pathways to engage social workers with high PsyCap constantly.
Article
Full-text available
While emerging studies pay much attention to the supervisory support–employee performance relationship, the supportive supervisor consequences on employees’ attitudes and behaviors have attracted little attention in this relationship. In spite of the growing concern about employees’ helping behaviors as a tool that directly benefit coworkers to be work-role focused and improve performance, supportive supervisor behavior that represents the psychological, physical, cognitive, and esteem assistance has also been deemed to be a catalyst of employees’ helping behaviors. Also, it is worth noting that employees exhibit helping behaviors when they are highly engaged in work role focus, activation, and positive affect. However, little has been espoused on how supportive behaviors could enhance employees’ loyalty to spark helping behaviors. Owing to this narrative, this study draws on social exchange theory and reciprocity norm to examine the mediating role of employee engagement in the effects of supportive supervisor behavior on hotel employees’ helping behaviors. Also, this study examined the boundary role of perceived organizational obstruction based on perceived organizational support as proposed by organizational support theory. Using a time lag of six months, a two-wave data were gathered from 461 full‒time frontline employees working in 3–5 star hotels in Ghana. Hierarchical regression was used to analyze the hypothesized relationships. The results demonstrated that supportive supervisor behavior positively related to employees’ helping behaviors. Besides, intellectual, social, and affective engagement partly mediated the relationship between supportive manager behavior and employees’ helping behavior. Moreover, perceived organizational obstruction moderated the relationship between intellectual engagement and employees’ helping behavior. However, failed to moderate social and affective engagement relationships with employees’ helping behaviors.
Article
Full-text available
The issue of how overqualified employees engage in organizational citizenship behavior towards individual (OCBI) is gaining traction. Existing literatures have mostly explored the relationship between perceived overqualification and OCBI from cognitive and affective perspectives, ignoring the motivational perspective. However, motivation, as an importance mechanism, has a great impact on overqualified employees’ OCBI. Based on status-striving motivation, we focus on the positive aspect of perceived overqualification and investigates the mechanism of perceived overqualification on OCBI. Two studies, a scenario study (N = 110) and a time-lagged field study (N = 249), are used to test our hypotheses. Study 1 and 2 show that perceived overqualification positively affects OCBI through status-striving motivation. In addition, Study 2 finds that ambition not only moderates the direct relationship between perceived overqualification and status-striving motivation, but also the indirect effect of perceived overqualification on OCBI via status-striving motivation. However, the moderating role of task interdependence is not supported. We discuss the theoretical and practical implications of the findings.
Article
Full-text available
Purpose This study aims to investigate the influence of illegitimate tasks on frontline hospitality employees’ in-role and extra-role performance via the mediating role of thriving at work and the moderating role of work centrality. Design/methodology/approach Survey data were collected from 264 supervisor–subordinate pairs from three hotels in Jiangsu, China and analyzed using structural equation modeling. Findings Illegitimate tasks negatively affected hospitality employees’ in-role and extra-role performance by inhibiting thriving at work. In addition, work centrality strengthened the impact of illegitimate tasks on thriving at work and their indirect effect on in-role and extra-role performance via reduced thriving at work. Practical implications First, managers should avoid assignment of unnecessary tasks. However, many tasks that could be viewed as illegitimate must still be performed; the results demonstrate that managers must be mindful of how such tasks are assigned and to whom, and should take steps to minimize and/or manage potential negative reactions to illegitimate tasks. Originality/value This study enriches the illegitimate tasks literature by examining its influence on the frontline hospitality employees’ in-role and extra-role performance and highlights a novel mediating mechanism linking illegitimate tasks and employee performance using conservation of resource theory. In addition, this reveals the novel moderating effect of work centrality.
Article
Full-text available
In search of sustainable strategies to improve employees’ work engagement without harming their long-term performance in the VUCA era, this study examines the impact path of subordinate moqi on employees’ work engagement based on leader–member exchange theory and organizational support theory. A total of 322 R&D staff from high-tech enterprises in Shanghai, Beijing, Shenzhen, and other cities participated in the study. The data analysis reveals that the leader–member exchange partially mediates between subordinate moqi and work engagement. Moreover, both supervisor’s organizational embodiment and perceived organizational support can positively moderate the impact of subordinate moqi on leader–member exchange. The empirical results enrich the intermediary mechanism between subordinate moqi and work engagement. Employees with subordinate moqi have better chances of meeting their supervisors’ implicit expectations, leading to a higher relationship quality with followers and increasing enthusiasm for work. The current study clarifies the theoretical and practical significance of subordinate moqi in establishing high-quality work relationships and sustainable development of organizations’ human resources.
Article
Full-text available
Drawing on the tenets of conservation of resources theory and social identity theory, this study examined the influence of workplace incivility on organizational citizenship behaviour (OCB) through the mediating effect of work engagement. Simultaneously, the moderator effect of organizational identity on the relationship between workplace incivility and work engagement is analyzed. Using the data collected from 484 full time employees from hi-tech, banking and manufacturing industries, it is found that work engagement fully mediates the relationship between workplace incivility and OCB. Furthermore, it is found that the adverse impact of workplace incivility is higher for employees with greater organizational identification, implying that experiencing workplace incivility can be more devastating for employees who see their organization as an integral part of their identity. This study contributes to the literature by jointly testing the mediating role of work engagement and moderator role of organizational identity to understand the relationship between workplace incivility and OCB. Drawing on the findings, both theoretical and practical implications are discussed.
Article
Purpose This research focuses on the work–family facilitation process to theorize and examine the potential positive impact of perceived overqualification (POQ) on an individual’s work–family interface. Drawing on social cognitive theory of self-regulation, this research identifies work–family balance self-efficacy (WFBSE) as a motivational mechanism through which POQ affects work engagement. Additionally, it proposes flexibility human resource (HR) practices as a key moderator of this process. Design/methodology/approach This research collected multi-wave time-lagged data from 342 managers in the hospitality industry. The research focused on managers with the title of headwaiter and above, while front-line service personnel were not included. Findings The results showed that POQ had an indirect positive relationship with work engagement via WFBSE. The results also showed that employee-experienced flexibility HR practices moderated the effectiveness of WFBSE in translating POQ into work engagement. Practical implications This research provides guidance and insights into how HRM systems can be customized to sustain positive outcomes in situations of overqualification. It is crucial that hotels offer flexibility options or individualization of work arrangements for overqualified employees. Originality/value The potential positive impact of POQ on employees’ work–family interface has been neglected. In addition, prior research has devoted little attention to potential organizational factors that enhance the positive effects of POQ. By examining the mediating and moderating effects, this research aims to explain how and under what conditions POQ facilitates work engagement.
Article
Purpose A small group of pioneering founders led the creation and early evolution of the service research field. Decades later, this article shares timeless service wisdom from ten of those pioneering founders. Design/methodology/approach Bowen and Fisk specified three criteria by which to identify a pioneering founder. In total, 11 founders met the criteria (Bateson, Berry, Bitner, Brown, Chase, Edvardsson, Grönroos, Gummesson, Parasuraman, Schneider and Zeithaml) and were invited to join Bowen and Fisk – founders that also met the criteria as coauthors. Ten founders then answered a set of questions regarding their careers as service scholars and the state of the field. Findings Insightful reflections were provided by each of the ten pioneering founders. In addition, based on their synthesis of the reflections, Bowen and Fisk developed nine wisdom themes for service researchers to consider and to possibly act upon. Originality/value The service research field is in its fifth decade. This article offers a unique way to learn directly from the pioneering founders about the still-relevant history of the field, the founders' lives and contributions as service scholars and the founders' hopes and concerns for the service research field.