ArticlePDF Available

The Black Aesculapian Snake Zamenis longissimus (Serpentes: Colubridae): characters and possible origin of the subgrisea morphotype

Authors:
  • OPHIS Museo Paleontologico e Centro Erpetologico

Abstract and Figures

The Black Aesculapian Snake, Zamenis longissimus (Serpentes: Colubridae): characters and possible origin of the subgrisea morphotype. New data acquired on the biology of the Aesculapian snake Zamenis longissimus shed light on a widespread specific morphotype in this species: the subgrisea form. Through captive breeding of groups of individuals for several generations, it was established that this morphotype is caused by a recessive mutation. The presence and combination of several traits indicate that this form is not from a single genetic mutation, such as melanoticism or axanthism but from a morphotype more complex than previously considered. The expression of this form in several specimens from different European and Middle Eastern countries suggests that the origin of the morphotype is common and ancient, not random. From genetic analyses, fossil records, and the recent observations of wild individuals, it is probable that this form originated in the Balkan peninsula, where it is more common, and spread to central Europe during the species expansion and recolonization in the late Pleistocene after the last glaciation. Zamenis longissimus could therefore be considered a polymorphic species.
Content may be subject to copyright.
101
Phyllomedusa - 23(2), December 2024
Received 13 May 2024
Accepted 05 August 2024
Distributed December 2024
The Black Aesculapian Snake Zamenis longissimus
(Serpentes: Colubridae): characters and possible
origin of the subgrisea morphotype
Alessandro Paterna
OPHIS Museo Paleontologico e Centro Erpetologico, 64100 Teramo, Italy. E-mail: alessandro.paterna@hotmail.com.
Phyllomedusa 23(2):101–109, 2024
© 2024 Universidade de São Paulo - ESALQ
ISSN 1519-1397 (print) / ISSN 2316-9079 (online)
doi: http://dx.doi.org/10.11606/issn.2316-9079.v23i2p101-109
Abstract
The Black Aesculapian Snake, Zamenis longissimus (Serpentes: Colubridae): characters
and possible origin of the subgrisea morphotype. New data acquired on the biology of
the Aesculapian snake Zamenis longissimus shed light on a widespread specic morphotype
in this species: the subgrisea form. Through captive breeding of groups of individuals for
several generations, it was established that this morphotype is caused by a recessive
mutation. The presence and combination of several traits indicate that this form is not from
a single genetic mutation, such as melanoticism or axanthism but from a morphotype more
complex than previously considered. The expression of this form in several specimens
from dierent European and Middle Eastern countries suggests that the origin of the
morphotype is common and ancient, not random. From genetic analyses, fossil records,
and the recent observations of wild individuals, it is probable that this form originated in
the Balkan peninsula, where it is more common, and spread to central Europe during the
species expansion and recolonization in the late Pleistocene after the last glaciation.
Zamenis longissimus could therefore be considered a polymorphic species.
Keywords: Balkans, Phenotype, Polymorphism, Recessive gene, Snakes.
A serpente-negra-de-esculápio, Zamenis longissimus (Serpentes: Colubridae): caracteres e
possível origem do morfotipo subgrisea. Novos dados adquiridos sobre a biologia de Zamenis
longissimus lançam luz sobre um morfotipo especíco amplamente difundido nessa espécie: a forma
subgrisea. Por meio da criação em cativeiro de grupos de indivíduos durante várias gerações, foi
estabelecido que esse morfotipo é causado por uma mutação recessiva. A presença e a combinação
de vários caracteres indicam que essa forma não provém de uma única mutação genética, como o
melanismo ou o axantismo, mas sim de um morfotipo mais complexo do que considerado
anteriormente. A expressão dessa forma em vários exemplares de diferentes países da Europa e do
Oriente Médio sugere que a origem do morfotipo é comum e antiga, não aleatória. A partir de análises
genéticas, registros fósseis e observações recentes de indivíduos selvagens, é provável que essa
forma tenha-se originado na península dos Balcãs, onde é mais comum, e se espalhado para a Europa
Central durante a expansão e a recolonização da espécie no nal do Pleistoceno, após a última
glaciação. Zamenis longissimus poderia, portanto, ser considerada uma espécie polimórca.
Palavras-chave: Balcãs, Fenótipo, Gene recessivo, Polimorsmo, Serpentes.
102
Phyllomedusa - 23(2), December 2024
Paterna
Introduction
Melanism and melanoticism are conditions in
which an individual is characterized by an excess
of melanin compared to the normal phenotype of
intraspecic individuals (Majerus 1998). This
form represents the most common and highly
variable mutation among ophidians and can
express itself in multiple forms, aecting an
individual partially or totally or being congenital
or ontogenetic; multiple melanotic forms can be
present within the same species (Senczuk et al.
2021, Fănaru et al. 2022, Jablonski et al. 2023,
Storniolo et al. 2023, Meier et al. 2024). In
snakes, mutations such as melanoticism,
melanism, amelanism, leucism, xanthism/
axanthism, and erythrism/anerythrism can
randomly occur in any individual of any species
in any location (Schulz 1996, Bruni 2017, Meier
et al. 2021, Jablonski et al. 2022), leading to the
possibility that characters may become xed
within some populations (Tokunaga and Ono
1991, Andrén 2004). Studies on melanistic/
melanotic populations of snakes are abundant in
the literature, as are reports of a single or a few
individuals (Andrén and Nilson 1981, Kuriyama
et al. 2013, Bury et al. 2020).
In this study, the “melanotic” morphotype of
the Aesculapian snake, Zamenis longissimus
(Laurenti, 1768), was examined. Previously, such
dark/black individuals have been treated as
“simple” or sporadic chromatic mutations,
involving single individuals or small populations
described in single reports from several Central
European, Balkan, and Middle Eastern countries
(Fitzinger 1826, 1832, De Betta 1853, Massalongo
1859). In these works, following Schulz (1996)
and others (Edgar and Bird 2006, Kreiner 2007),
this form is identied by the name designated by
Wern er (1 89 7) a s va r. subgrisea.
Data from the literature, together with
observations published on online platforms, were
used to dene a spatial map in which this
morphotype is found. Published genetic and
phylogenetic research about populations of
Zamenis longissimus was considered to
hypothesize the most probable origin of the
morphotype and how it spread to the locations
where it is currently found. This information was
combined with a seven-year project in which
individuals of the subgrisea phenotype were kept
and bred in a controlled environment, and several
captive-bred generations were produced to
determine the genetic nature of this morphotype.
Materials and Methods
Two pairs of the subgrisea form born in
captivity were donated to OPHIS, Museo
Paleontologico e Centro Erpetologico in 2017
and 2023. The most recently received pair
consisted of two adult individuals from
Montenegro, while the other consisted of two
young specimens born in 2017 from parents
originating from two Balkan locations (male
from Croatia and female from Montenegro). The
specimens remain at OPHIS, where they have
reproduced for two generations. The adult
specimens were raised in terraria with dimensions
of 100 × 60 × 50 cm (length, height, and
depth, respectively). Their ospring were housed
in terraria appropriate to their size and moved to
larger ones during growth.
After being collected and measured, the eggs
were placed in an incubator (38 × 58 × 36 cm)
that had the temperature regulated by an
electronic thermostat and digital probes. Each
clutch was positioned in a plastic box with a
transparent lid lled with moist vermiculite as a
medium.
Photographs were obtained with Sony α6000
and Nikon Coolpix P510 digital cameras.
Comparative or geographical data were obtained
from the literature and from the GPS data provided
in the reports on the iNaturalist.org platform.
Results
During the growth of the subgrisea specimens,
as in the classic phenotype, the juvenile dorsal
pattern fades, replaced by a uniform color
ranging from solid black to dark grey with very
103
Phyllomedusa - 23(2), December 2024
The Black Aesculapian Snake Zamenis longissimus
small white ecks (Figure 1A, B). The scales of
both black and grey individuals are iridescent,
and blue pigmentation may be present in the
contact areas of black and white. In some
individuals, four longitudinal dorsal lines may be
visible. The ventral coloration is black, with
white spots at the lateral margins of the ventral
scales. These white spots form a longitudinal
white stripe along the lower portion of the anks.
The chin and labial scales are white, and the
subocular black spot disappears completely in
adults. Scattered yellow spots appear on the
ventral, subcaudal, and labial scales of adults
(Figure 1A, B).
Juveniles of the subgrisea form exhibit a
dorsal pattern of spots arranged in four
longitudinal rows that distinguish all young
Zamenis longissimus (Figure 1C, D). Unlike the
more widespread phenotype, however,
longitudinal rows are dark grey on a lighter grey
background. As in adults, the belly is completely
black with small white dots located on the lateral
edges of the ventral scales. The chin and neck
are white ventrally with small symmetrical black
spots. The labial scales are white, the fourth and
fth with a black tear-shaped spot below the eye.
A black line extends along the postocular and
temporal scales. The head shields are dark grey,
almost black. The iris is dark; in some individuals,
the pupil is dicult to distinguish.
Three clutches were produced by the female
born in 2017: in 2019, 2021, and 2022. These
clutches consisted of 6, 2 and 6 fertilized eggs
(plus an infertile egg), respectively (Figure 2A).
The elongate white eggs featured irregular
concretions on the shell (Figure 2B). Egg length
ranged from 50–59 mm and diameter from 20–
24 mm; eggs weighed 9–14 g.
Following an incubation of 51–56 days at
temperatures between 26 and 28°C, the clutches
hatched completely (Figure 2B). The hatchlings
measured 30–33 cm and weighed 12–14 g. In the
2019 clutch, half of the specimens exhibited the
subgrisea form and the other half the classic
phenotype (two males and one female for each
phenotype; Figure 2B). In the 2021 clutch, both
Figure 1. Specimens from the breeding program of
Zamenis longissimus: (A) adult male subgrisea
from Montenegro; (B) adult female subgrisea;
(C) hatchling of the subgrisea morphotype;
(D) hatchling of the dominant morphotype
from subgrisea parents.
A
B
C
D
104
Phyllomedusa - 23(2), December 2024
hatchlings were of the subgrisea form. In 2022,
four individuals exhibited the subgrisea form,
and two were the classic phenotype. At hatching,
the individuals of the classic phenotype from the
mating of the subgrisea specimens exhibited a
darker coloration than the hatchlings of Z.
longissimus from other localities bred by the
author and those observed by the author in the
wild in Central Europe. The darker coloration
becomes paler as the snakes grow. These
ospring also exhibit a very bright orange iris
(Figure 1D) that contrasts with the dark ground
color.
Some chromatic “anomalies” occurred
among the captive-bred specimens. One of the
snakes born in 2023 (second generation bred in
captivity) from heterozygous specimens (rst
generation in captivity) exhibits typical dorsal
Figure 2. Specimens from the breeding program of Zamenis longissimus: (A) adult female subgrisea with eggs; (B)
hatchlings from both morphotypes pipping the eggs; (C) juvenile female of the dominant morphotype
showing black ventral coloration; (D) juvenile male showing characters of both dominant and subgrisea
morphotypes.
coloration but is black ventrally (Figure 2C). A
specimen born in 2022 from the original
subgrisea pair exhibits coloration intermediate
between the two morphotypes: hypoxanthistic
with darker head shields and a greysh/bluish
background dorsal coloration. The black pattern
of this individual, if exposed to light, produces
the same iridescence typical of the dorsal scales
of subgrisea individuals (Figure 2D), possibly
caused by a variation of concentration of
iridophores and xanthophores compared to the
classic phenotype.
Discussion
For many years, several authors have reported
their observations of dark or “melanistic”
individuals of Zamenis longissimus, naming this
Paterna
AB
CD
105
Phyllomedusa - 23(2), December 2024
variety/form nigra, or nigrescens (Fitzinger
1826, 1832, De Betta 1853, Massalongo 1859,
Boulenger 1913). The rst detailed information
for identifying the morphotype, the object of this
study, with those described in past literature was
by Werner (1897). This author provided precise
references to some characters, such as the dark
belly and the longitudinal white line generated
by the succession of spots located on the external
portion of each ventral scale. This particular
character was also conrmed by Angel (1946)
and Cattaneo (1975), who even specied that
this line terminates at the cloaca and is not
present on the subcaudal scales.
The subgrisea form has been documented in
France, Italy, Austria, Hungary, Croatia,
Montenegro, Greece, Romania, Bulgaria, and the
Caucasus (Werner 1897, Cattaneo 1975, Kreiner
2007, Schulz 1996, 2013). Most reports consist
of observations of single individuals, although
cases in which this form appears widespread are
known (Werner 1897, Cattaneo 2017). This latter
situation appears to be more frequent in Balkan
localities, where individuals of the classic and
subgrisea phenotypes share the same habitats.
Photos portraying these subjects appear in recent
texts (Schulz 1996, 2013, Kreiner 2007), where
details and localities are reported. Photographs
of the subgrisea morphotype of Z. longissimus
are on online platforms such as iNaturalist, with
specic localities of the observations. Both
literature and online records point out a high
concentration of subgrisea sightings in the
Balkan peninsula, and the online data conrm
the distribution area in literature records (Figure
3). Most of the specimens have been documented
in Greece, Bulgaria, Romania, Serbia, and
Croatia, with records also in Hungary and
Slovakia. The easternmost records reconrm the
presence of such morph in Russia and Turkey,
and the westernmost in Italy, France, and Spain
(Figure 3).
Figure 3. Distribution and observations of individuals of the subgrisea form. The yellow area indicates the distribution
of Zamenis longissimus. Diagonal red lines indicate the predicted area of occurrence of the subgrisea form,
based on information provided in the literature (Werner 1897, Cattaneo 1975, Kreiner 2007, Schulz 1996,
2013). Black dots correspond to recent observations of individuals of the subgrisea form from specific
localities (Cattaneo 1975, Kreiner 2007, Schulz 1996, 2013, Zadravec and Lauš 2011) and from the
iNaturalist platform (to April 2024).
The Black Aesculapian Snake Zamenis longissimus
106
Phyllomedusa - 23(2), December 2024
In the literature, this morphotype has often
been treated as melanic or axanthic (Zadravec
and Lauš 2011, Cattaneo 2015, 2017). The
results obtained by reproduction in captivity
highlight the presence of several traits for which
this form cannot be considered a single chromatic
mutation. A character uniformly present in the
subgrisea specimens is the black belly. This
character is not found in the classic phenotype,
in which the chin, belly, and tail are all colored
with the same cream/yellowish shade. Pure
melanic individuals are completely black,
lacking even the small white spots between the
dorsal scales, and any axanthistic specimen
would have a white or light-grey venter, as in
subgrisea juveniles, in which labials and the
most anterior dorsal scales on the neck are white.
Dark grey specimens with uniform white venters
have been documented and are present on the
iNaturalist platform. The same concept can be
veried in the known axanthic/anerythristic
forms of other colubroids (Fankhauser and
Cumming 2008, Borteiro et al. 2021) and in the
closely related species Zamenis lineatus (Russo
et al. 2020).
A character not described in the literature is
the presence of yellow pigment, which appears
in some scales of subgrisea subjects. This
pigmentation may aect any scale on the body,
usually covering part of the scale. The yellow
coloration is more evident in larger scales, such
as the head shields, ventrals, and subcaudals but
is also found on the dorsals. Yellowing scales in
adults also occur in other species, such as the
sympatric Elaphe quatuorlineata Lacépède,
1789 (pers. obs.). The presence of yellow
pigmentation contradicts the hypothesis of
axanthism and melanism because xanthophores
are absent or rare in purely melanic colubrids
(Kuriyama et al. 2013, 2016). The absence of
iridophores was also reported in melanic
individuals of the formerly congeneric Elaphe
quadrivirgata (Boie, 1826) (Kuriyama 2013).
The white line on the external margins of the
ventral scales is present in specimens of the
classic phenotype. In the typically colored
individuals, it is present although barely visible
against the light venter.
The data obtained from breeding show that
the genetics of this morphotype are recessive.
The results shed light on the genetics of the
original pair. One of the two subgrisea parents
that generated the individuals born in 2017 was
heterozygous because among the ospring of the
second generation (obtained from the mating of
the 2017 subgrisea specimens) some of the
hatchlings exhibit the classic/dominant
phenotype. Furthermore, in the third generation
produced by individuals of the classic phenotype,
all of the hatchlings exhibited the same coloration
as the parents. Conrmation of the recessive
nature of this morphotype is noted by Cattaneo
(1975), where a pregnant subgrisea female,
captured near Rome in a limited and mixed
subgrisea colony (possibly now extinct), laid
eggs producing ospring of both forms.
Anomalies in the livery appeared in two
hatchlings of the classic phenotype (Figure 2 C,
D). These anomalies involved typical
characteristics of the subgrisea form,
demonstrating that some characters of this
morphotype may appear individually in
heterozygous specimens. This may be a case of
incomplete dominance of the alleles but would
need to be further investigated in future
generations.
Conclusion
The results obtained from breeding suggest
that the subgrisea form is a recessive mutation.
Within the groups raised in a controlled
environment, specimens manifesting partial
traits of such morphotypes were born. An
individual born in the third generation, obtained
from the mating of recessive heterozygous
specimens exhibiting the dominant classic
coloration, featured the black belly. This trait is
characteristic of the subgrisea form, which does
not exist in the classic phenotype, as darker
iridescent dorsal tones manifested in a second
individual. This would likely mean that this
Paterna
107
Phyllomedusa - 23(2), December 2024
morphotype expresses itself in a combination of
multiple traits and would be consequently not
linked to a single gene, representing a more
complex form than a single chromatic mutation.
The fact that such combinate traits can be
found in the same form in dierent sites greatly
distant from each other suggests that the observed
specimens in the wild may not be the result of
individual/occasional mutations, but instead
these specimens have an ancient common origin
that continues to be actively transmitted by
recessive homozygous and heterozygous
individuals within populations in which the classic
phenotype appears to be the dominant one.
Recent genetic analyses and fossil records
could help determine the origins of this form. It
is supposed that in the last glacial period, the
northern and central European populations of Z.
longissimus became extinct, and these areas
were subsequently repopulated in the Holocene,
mainly by populations surviving in Balkan
refuges (Musilová et al. 2010, Allentoft et al.
2018). Most of the observations of individuals or
small populations of the subgrisea morphotype
come from the Balkans. It is conceivable that
this form was already present in the Pleistocene
of southeastern Europe, and that it has survived
to this day in certain central European populations
that were recolonized by individuals with the
genetics of the eastern clade. Further studies
focused on dermal chromatophores could
indicate where this form would have been
advantaged and more functional during the
glacial period (King 1988, Forsman 1995, Trullas
et al. 2007, Geen and Johnston 2014, Monahan
et al. 2022). The appearance of the subgrisea
form could even be backdated because records
of this morph come from the Caucasus and
Greece (Schulz 1996, 2013, iNaturalist data), of
which populations present profound genetic
dierences from the European and Transcaucasian
ones (Musilová et al. 2007, 2010), suggesting
that these southern-oriental groups remained
isolated even longer and did not contribute to the
colonizing expansion of Central Europe
following the last glacial phase.
The subgrisea individuals and populations
have been reported from coastal areas in
Montenegro, Croatia, Italy, and Russia to
mainland forests of the central and eastern
European countries (Werner 1897, Cattaneo
1975, Kreiner 2007, Schulz 1996, 2013,
Zadravec and Lauš 2011, iNaturalist data). Such
dierences both in altitudes and biotopes suggest
that the presence of this form may not depend
exclusively on environmental factors. The
occurrence of the subgrisea form could not be
selected by a switch of an environmental nature
but would mainly depend in primis on the
genetic pool of the micropopulation in question.
Considering the analyzed evidence, the
Aesculapian snake could be considered a
polymorphic species that expresses (at least) two
forms: the dominant classic one and the
recessive subgrisea, which occurs in several
countries within the entire distribution of this
colubrid.
Acknowledgments
I thank Rainer Fesser for donating the
specimens of Zamenis longissimus of the
phenotype described here to OPHIS, and all the
iNaturalist users who shared their observations
about Z. longissmus. I thank Ross D. MacCulloch,
Jaime Bertoluci, and anonymous reviewers for
revising and improving this manuscript.
References
Allentoft, M. E., A. R. Rasmussen, and H. V. Kristensen.
2018. Centuries-old DNA from an extinct population of
Aesculapian snake (Zamenis longissimus) oers new
phylogeographic insight. Diversity 2018: 1–10.
Andrén, C. 2004. Forsmark Site Investigation Amphibians
and Reptiles. Svensk Kärnbränslehantering AB. 35 pp.
Andrén, C. and G. Nilson. 1981. Reproductive success and
risk of predation in normal and melanistic colour morphs
of the adder, Vipera berus. Biological Journal of the
Linnean Society 15: 235–246.
Angel, F. 1946. Faune de France 45 Reptiles et Amphibiens.
Librairie de la Faculté des Sciences 12. 204 pp.
The Black Aesculapian Snake Zamenis longissimus
108
Phyllomedusa - 23(2), December 2024
Borteiro, C., A. D. Abegg, F. H. Oda, D. Cardozo, F. Kolenc,
I. Etchandy, I. Bisaiz, C. Priogini, and D. Baldo. 2021.
Aberrant colourations in wild snakes: case study in
Neotropical taxa and a review of terminology.
Salamandra 57: 124–138.
Boulenger, G. A. 1913. The Snakes of Europe. London.
Methuen & Co. 269 pp.
Bruni, G. 2017. A leucistic grass snake Natrix natrix
(Linnaeus, 1758) (Serpentes: Natricidae) from Tuscany,
Central Italy. Herpetology Notes 10: 313–316.
Bury, S., T. D. Mazgajski, B. Najbar, B. Zając, and K. Kurek.
2020. Melanism, body size, and sex ratio in snakes
new data on the grass snake (Natrix natrix) and synthesis.
Naturwissenschaften 107: 22.
Cattaneo, A. 1975. Presenza di Elaphe longissima longissima
(Laurenti, 1768) melanica a Castelfusano (Roma). Atti
della Società Italiana di Scienze Naturali e del Museo
Civico di Storia Naturale in Milano 116: 251–262.
Cattaneo, A., 2015. The Zamenis longissimus (Laurenti)
axanthic phenotype found on the Castelporziano
Presidential Estate: considerations on its morphology,
genetic nature and probable extinction (Serpentes:
Colubridae). Pp. 385–389 in S. Pignatti, E. Capanna, and
E. Porceddu (eds.), Castelporziano, Research and
Conservation in a Mediterranean Forest Ecosystem,
Rendiconti Lincei 26, Supplement 3, Springer.
Cattaneo, A. 2017. I Serpenti della Tenuta di Castelporziano,
tra Passato e Presente. Cromostampa. 132 pp.
De Betta, E. 1853. Catalogo dei rettili della Valle di Non (nel
Tirolo meridionale). Verhandlungen der Zoologisch-
Botanischen Gesellschaft in Wien 2: 153–160.
Edgar, P. and D. R. Bird. 2006. Action plan for the
conservation of the Aesculapian snake (Zamenis
longissimus) in Europe. Convention on the Conservation
of European Wildlife and Natural Habitats. 23 pp.
Fănaru, G., A. E. Telea, I. Gherghel, and R. Melenciuc. 2022.
Melanism in the grass snake Natrix natrix (Linnaeus,
1758) from the Danube Delta Biosphere Reserve,
Romania. Herpetozoa 35: 257–263.
Fankhauser, G. and K. B. Cumming. 2008. Snake
hybridization: A case for intrabaraminic diversity. Pp.
117–132 in Proceedings of the Sixth International
Conference on Creationism. A. A. Snelling, (ed.)
Creation Science Fellowship and Dallas, TX: Institute
for Creation Research.
Fitzinger, L. J. 1826. Neue classication der reptilien nach
ihren natürlichen verwandtschaften: nebst einer
verwandtschafts-tafel und einem verzeichnisse der
reptilien-sammlung des K. K. zoologischen museum’s zu
Wien. Wien, J. G. Heubner. 66 pp.
Fitzinger, L. J. 1832. Ueber die ausarbeitung einer fauna des
erzherzogthumes Oesterreich, nebst einer systematischen
aufzählung der in diesem lande vorkommenden
säugethiere, reptilien und schen, als prodrom einer
fauna derselben. Beiträge zur Landeskunde Oesterreich’s
unter der Enns 1: 280–340
Forsman, A. 1995. Heating rates and body temperature
variation in melanistic and zigzag Vipera berus: does
colour make a dierence? Annales Zoologici Fennici
32: 365–374.
Geen, M. R. S. and G. R. Johnston. 2014. Coloration aects
heating and cooling in three color morphs of the
Australian bluetongue lizard, Tiliqua scincoides. Journal
of Thermal Biology 43: 54–60.
Jablonski, D., B. Trapp, E. Tzoras, and K. Mebert. 2022.
Erythrism in the eastern grass snake, Natrix natrix
(Linnaeus, 1758). Herpetozoa 35: 213–217.
Jablonski, D., E. Tzoras, A. Panagiotopoulos, M. Asztalos,
and U. Fritz. 2023. Genotyping the phenotypic diversity
in Aegean Natrix natrix moreotica (Bedriaga, 1882)
(Reptilia, Serpentes, Natricidae). ZooKeys 1169: 87–94.
King, R. B. 1988. Polymorphic populations of the garter
snake Thamnophis sirtalis near Lake Erie. Herpetologica
44: 451–458.
Kreiner, G. 2007. The Snakes of Europe. Frankfurt AM
Main. Edition Chimaira. 317 pp.
Kuriyama, T., T. Okamoto, K. Miyaji, and M. Hasegawa.
2016. Iridophore- and xanthophore-decient melanistic
color variant of the lizard Plestiodon latiscutatus.
Herpetologica 72: 189–195.
Kuriyama, T., H. Misawa, K. Miyaji, M. Sugimoto, and M.
Hasegawa. 2013. Pigment cell mechanisms underlying
dorsal color-pattern polymorphism in the Japanese four-
lined snake. Journal of Morphology 274: 1353–1364.
Majerus, M. 1998. Melanism: Evolution in Action. Oxford.
Oxford University Press. 338 pp.
Massalongo, A. 1859. Catalogo dei rettili delle prov. venete
compilato dal Prof. A. Massalongo. Atti dell’I.R. Istituto
Veneto di Scienze, lettere ed arti 3: 300–310.
Meier, G., L. Cavigioli, and D. Muri. 2021. Osservazione di
un colubro di Esculapio, Zamenis longissimus (Laurenti,
1768), adulto leucistico nel Cantone Ticino, Svizzera.
Bollettino della Società Ticinese di Scienze Naturali
109: 125–126.
Meier, N., K. Lucek, M. A. L. Zu, F. Storniolo, M.
Mezzasalma, P. Geniez, S. Dubey, R. Sacchi, S. Scali,
and S. Ursenbacher. 2024. Extensive gene ow suggests
lack of reproductive barriers between the two subspecies
Paterna
109
Phyllomedusa - 23(2), December 2024
of the green whip snake, Hierophis viridiavus
(Squamata: Colubridae). Biological Journal of the
Linnean Society 141: 133–147.
Monahan, C. F., M. M. Garner, and M. Kiupel. 2022.
Chromatophoromas in reptiles. Veterinary Sciences
9: 115.
Musilová, R., V. Zavadil, and P. Kotlík. 2007. Isolated
populations of Zamenis longissimus (Reptilia: Squamata)
above the northern limit of the continuous range in
Europe: origin and conservation status. Acta Societatis
Zoologicae Bohemicae 71: 197–208.
Musilová, R., V. Zavadil, S. Marková, and P. Kotlík. 2010.
Relics of the Europe’s warm past: Phylogeography of
the Aesculapian snake. Molecular Phylogenetics and
Evolution 57: 1245–1252.
Russo, G., E. Gianrusso, P. Leanza, E. Mirone, and B.
Morello. 2020. An anomalous phenotype of the Italian
Aesculapian snake Zamenis lineatus from Mt. Etna,
Sicily. Herpetological Bulletin 154: 29–30.
Schulz, K. D. 1996. A Monograph of the Colubrid Snakes of
the Genus Elaphe Fitzinger. Koeltz Scientic Books.
439 pp.
Schulz, K. D. 2013. Old World Ratsnakes. A Collection of
Papers. Bushmaster Publications. 432 pp.
Senczuk, G., L. Gramolini, I. Avella, E. Mori, M. Menchetti,
G. Aloise, and R. Castiglia. 2021. No association
between candidate genes for color determination and
color phenotype in Hierophis viridiavus, and
characterization of a contact zone. Journal of Zoological
Systematics and Evolutionary Research 59: 748–759.
Storniolo, F., M. Mangiacotti, M. A. L. Zu, S. Scali, and R.
Sacchi. 2023. Large scale phenotypic characterisation
of Hierophis viridifavus (Squamata: Serpentes): climatic
and environmental drivers suggest the role of
evolutionary processes in a polymorphic species.
Evolutionary Ecology 37: 419–434.
Tokunaga, S. and Y. Ono. 1991. The Iwakuni shirohebis, a
group of albino Elaphe climacophora. Herpetological
Review 22: 120–121.
Trullas, S. C., J. H. van Wyk, and J. R. Spotila. 2007.
Thermal melanism in ectotherms. Journal of Thermal
Biology 32: 235–245.
Werner, F. 1897. Die Reptilien und Amphibien Oesterreich-
Ungarns und der Occupationshinder. A. Pichler’s Witwe
& Sohn. 162 pp.
Zadravec, M. and B. Lauš. 2011. Melanism variations in
Natrix natrix (Linnaeus, 1758) and Zamenis longissimus
(Laurenti, 1768) in Croatia. Hyla 2011: 39–42.
Editor: Ross D. MacCulloch
The Black Aesculapian Snake Zamenis longissimus
ResearchGate has not been able to resolve any citations for this publication.
Article
Full-text available
We examined the mitochondrial identity of Aegean Natrix natrix moreotica representing different morphotypes, with a focus on new material from Milos and Skyros. We found no correlation between distinct morphotypes and mitochondrial identity. Our results support that grass snake populations are polyphenetic and that southern subspecies, including island populations, show a higher variability than northern ones.
Article
Full-text available
Colour variability is largely widespread in the animal world as it is tightly associated with fitness and survivorship. Therefore, the drivers and implications of such variability have been of great interest for zoologists in the past decades. Reptiles are excellent models to investigate colour variations and expression under different conditions. Here, we focused on melanism occurrence in the two main lineages of Hierophis viridiflavus at the scale of the species distribution, by extracting available data from iNaturalist, a citizen science network, with the aim of detecting any pure effect of climate or local habitat on colour expression. Our analyses highlighted that habitat does not explain differences in phenotypes, whereas marked effects of geographic and climatic variables were detected. However, the observed climatic effects could be a proxy of the geographical distribution of the two groups, and thus the high occurrence of bright colourations in western populations of the eastern lineage could be addressed to an ongoing event of asymmetric gene flow in contact zones. The current distribution of phenotypes could be the outcome of the evolutionary history of the species combined with the geological history of the Mediterranean region. This investigation, though, is only preliminary and molecular analyses on highly variable regions of the genome are mandatory to address this issue.
Article
Full-text available
Animal colouration has a significant ecological role in defence, reproduction, and thermoregulation. In the case of melanism, it is a complex topic. Besides potential disadvantages such as higher risk of predation, melanistic ectotherms may have certain physiological advantages such as more efficient thermoregulation in colder climates and thus, reduced basking time. The common grass snake ( Natrix natrix ) is a widespread species throughout Europe and Asia. It exhibits a wide range of colour polymorphisms, from olive to dark grey, even albinistic and melanistic. Between 2016 and 2021, we conducted fieldwork in the Danube Delta Biosphere Reserve (DDBR) with the aim to document the geographic range of melanistic grass snakes. We categorised the melanistic expressions of N. natrix individuals as melanotic, completely melanistic, and partially melanistic. Melanistic snakes were encountered in all six localities visited, suggesting that the occurrence of melanistic grass snakes in the DDBR is geographically widespread. We observed both juveniles (n=2) and adults (n=11) with melanism, suggesting that individuals are born melanistic. However, the proportion of melanistic individuals in the general population of N. natrix from the DDBR is unknown. Only at Histria locality we studied the proportion of melanism in the grass snake population and 6.3% of the snakes caught were melanistic. Body size comparisons are not statistically significant because of the low sample size. The N. natrix melanistic morph’s geographical distribution in the DDBR is most likely due to an interaction of climate and habitats, which offer a thermal advantage in the face of predation pressure.
Article
Full-text available
We describe the unusual case of erythrism in the Eastern Grass Snake, Natrix natrix. This colour morph is very rare and has not been reported in the literature before. Despite having observed thousands of N. natrix in the field, we personally detected this morph in only three individuals originating from Slovakia, Romania, and mainland Greece, while photos of a fourth individual from a Greek island were provided to us. In addition, a recent study with a large data set from citizen scientists was unable to produce a single reddish Eastern Grass Snake. Such colouration is likewise uncommon in the western members of Grass Snakes (N. helvetica, N. astreptophora), with two examples provided herein. Because the potential biological importance of erythristic colouration is unclear, we encourage other field herpetologists and naturalists to publish their observations of reddish Grass Snakes in the printed literature.
Article
Full-text available
Riassunto: Le pigmentazioni anomale in natura sono fenomeni perlopiù rari ed interessanti. Tra queste, le varianti chiare (al-binismo e leucismo) compromettono spesso il raggiungimento dello stadio adulto dei rettili. Con la presente nota segnaliamo l'osservazione di un colubro di Esculapio (Zamenis longissimus) adulto rinvenuto nel Cantone Ticino.
Article
Full-text available
It is postulated that melanism in ectotherms is adaptive by enhancing thermoregulation, subsequent resource acquisition, and growth. Such effects may differ between the sexes as a result of the differential costs of self-maintenance and reproduction, but empirical support for the sex-specific consequences of melanism remains inconsistent. We studied the effects of melanism on body size and sex ratio in a population of the European grass snake (Natrix natrix) in SE Poland and also carried out a systematic review of the literature on the consequences of melanism in terrestrial snakes. Melanistic grass snakes of both sexes appeared to be smaller than the typical phenotype, which indicates higher predation pressure and minimal thermal benefits for black individuals. A female-biased sex ratio was observed in the typical phenotype, but not in melanistic snakes, suggesting that the costs for females and/or benefits for males are higher in melanistic individuals. In conjunction with earlier studies, our data indicate that the consequences of melanism may be related to the reproductive mode of species. In viviparous species, melanism tends to improve growth and/or body size and is more frequent in females, whereas the opposite holds for oviparous snakes. Further studies on melanism should examine a wider array of species with different reproductive strategies and traits beyond the usual thermal benefits.
Article
Full-text available
The Aesculapian snake (Zamenis longissimus) is distributed in Central and Southern Europe, the Balkans, Anatolia, and Iran, but had a wider mid-Holocene distribution into Northern Europe. To investigate the genetic affinity of a Danish population that went extinct in historical times, we analysed three ethanol-preserved individuals dating back to 1810 using a silica-in-solution ancient DNA extraction method, combined with next-generation sequencing. Bioinformatic mapping of the reads against the published genome of a related colubrid snake revealed that two of the three specimens contained endogenous snake DNA (up to 8.6% of the reads), and this was evident for tooth, bone, and soft tissue samples. The DNA was highly degraded, observed by very short average sequence lengths (<50 bp) and 11–15% C to T deamination damage at the first 5′ position. This is an effect of specimen age, combined with suboptimal, and possibly damaging, molecular preservation conditions. Phylogeographic analyses of a 1638 bp mtDNA sequence securely placed the two Danish Aesculapian snakes in the Eastern (Balkan glacial refugium) clade within this species, and revealed one previously-undescribed haplotype. These results provide new information on the past distribution and postglacial re-colonization patterns of this species.
Article
Speciation is the fundamental process that underlies the diversification of species. Different steps of speciation, such as reproductive isolation or ecological niche separation, can evolve in different orders and over different time scales. The two subspecies of the green whip snake, Hierophis viridiflavus viridiflavus and Hierophis viridiflavus carbonarius, sometimes considered as separate species, are ideal to study speciation because they diverged in isolated glacial refugia. So far, little is known about whether these two subspecies are reproductively isolated from each other. Furthermore, it is unknown whether the common melanism of the subspecies H. v. carbonarius might be genetically encoded. We quantified gene flow along two transects across the contact zone of the two subspecies using double-digest restriction site-associated DNA. Our analyses implicated the existence of two well-defined clades that experience substantial gene flow along a contact zone that is ~300 km wide. We detected a clear association between the genetic assignment and the quantitative extent of melanism within the contact zone, which is likely to be genetically polygenic. Given the level of gene flow, it seems that strong postzygotic reproductive barriers have not evolved. We conclude that the two subspecies represent evolutionarily significant units for conservation and suggest treating them taxonomically as subspecies.
Article
Genetic and phenotypic differentiation in allopatric conditions can be explained either by neutral phenomena or adaptative processes driven by selection. In reptiles, coloration can affect aspects directly related to their survival, representing a classical character under selection. In this context, secondary contact areas are natural laboratory to understand evolutionary processes underlying genetic permeability, especially when populations differ in phenotypic traits such as coloration. The western whip snake Hierophis viridiflavus presents two divergent mitochondrial clades, characterized by the presence of one of two main color phenotypes, namely one with black and yellow stripes and a fully melanic one. Here, we investigated whether melanogenesislinked genes are determinant of the chromatic differences observed across the phenotypic variation of the species. In addition, we used a multilocus dataset, including 134 original ND4 sequences, to better define the overall genetic structure and to provide a characterization of a contact zone identified in Central Italy by estimating the amount of nuclear gene exchange. While we found no evidence supporting a direct association between target genes and coloration, a non-synonymous substitution polymorphism, at high frequency, was detected in the β melanocyte-stimulating hormone whose possible function has been discussed. Concerning the genetic structure, both mtDNA and nuDNA were partly concordant indicating introgression events occurring at the contact zone. When we measured the nuclear gene flow, we found a significant amount of gene exchange, mainly guided from one clade to the other, that is, asymmetric. These results might suggest the presence of ecological and/or behavioral processes driving the observed directional gene flow.