ArticlePublisher preview available

Exploring sources of (co-)variation in timing and total daily feeder visits in a wild population of black-capped chickadees

The Royal Society
Biology Letters
Authors:
To read the full-text of this research, you can request a copy directly from the authors.

Abstract

The timing and amount of foraging in birds are shaped by many of the same extrinsic factors, including temperature and daylength, as well as intrinsic factors, such as sex and age. Here, we investigate co-variation between these traits. We observed a population of 143 individually marked black-capped chickadees (Poecile atricapillus) over a 90 day period during the winter. For each day, we recorded the time an individual began and ended feeder use relative to sunrise/sunset, and the total number of feeder visits. Within-individuals, both earlier first feeder visit and later last feeder visit were associated with higher total daily feeder visits but lower feeding rates. Individuals also differed consistently in the timing of first and last feeder visits, and individuals that consistently started feeder use earlier in the day ended feeder use later and had higher total daily feeder visits compared with those that started later, but had no difference in feeding rate. Our study demonstrates that variation in the timing of foraging can have important consequences for energy acquisition at both the within- and among-individual levels.
Exploring sources of (co-)variation
in timing and total daily feeder
visits in a wild population of black-
capped chickadees
Nathan L. Hobbs1, Deborah M. Hawkshaw1, Jan J. Wijmenga1 and Kimberley J.
Mathot1,2
1Department of Biological Sciences, and 2Canada Research Chair in Integrative Ecology, Department of Biological
Sciences, University of Alberta, Edmonton, Alberta, Canada
NLH,0009-0006-7707-152X; DMH,0000-0001-7844-155X; JJW,0000-0002-3817-2153;
KJM,0000-0003-2021-1369
The timing and amount of foraging in birds are shaped by many of the
same extrinsic factors, including temperature and daylength, as well as
intrinsic factors, such as sex and age. Here, we investigate co-variation
between these traits. We observed a population of 143 individually marked
black-capped chickadees (Poecile atricapillus) over a 90 day period during
the winter. For each day, we recorded the time an individual began and
ended feeder use relative to sunrise/sunset, and the total number of feeder
visits. Within-individuals, both earlier first feeder visit and later last feeder
visit were associated with higher total daily feeder visits but lower feeding
rates. Individuals also differed consistently in the timing of first and last
feeder visits, and individuals that consistently started feeder use earlier
in the day ended feeder use later and had higher total daily feeder visits
compared with those that started later, but had no difference in feeding
rate. Our study demonstrates that variation in the timing of foraging can
have important consequences for energy acquisition at both the within- and
among-individual levels.
1. Introduction
Variation in the timing of activity has been widely reported both within- and
among-individuals from the same population [1–4]. For example, within-
individuals, timing of activity (e.g. wakefulness, movement and foraging)
often varies with ambient temperature [3,5–7], season [1,5,6], daylength [7,8],
predation risk [9,10] and weather conditions [5,8]. In songbirds, daylength
and ambient temperature are important extrinsic factors that shape the timing
of activity; shorter days and colder temperatures generally result in shorter
active periods [3,8]. Consistent among-individual differences in the timing of
activity have also been reported [11]. In songbirds, individuals can generally
be divided into either more active or less active types; individuals that start
activity earlier in the day tend to remain active later [8,12,13]. Differences in
activity types have been related to sex and age [1,3,4,8,14], body mass [15–17]
and metabolic rate [15,18].
Similarly, within- and among-individual variation in songbird foraging
behaviour is well established [19–22], with many of the same factors that
shape timing of activity (see above) also shaping foraging. For example,
lower ambient temperatures are often associated with increased daily food
intake [20,21], but see [23], and shorter days with larger peaks in foraging
[20]. Additionally, foraging rates often differ across age and sex classes [24].
© 2024 The Author(s). Published by the Royal Society. All rights reserved.
Research
Cite this article: Hobbs NL, Hawkshaw DM,
Wijmenga JJ, Mathot KJ. 2024 Exploring sources
of (co-)variation in timing and total daily feeder
visits in a wild population of black-capped
chickadees. Biol. Lett. 20: 20240365.
https://doi.org/10.1098/rsbl.2024.0365
Received: 26 June 2024
Accepted: 24 October 2024
Subject Category:
Animal behaviour
Subject Areas:
behaviour, ecology
Keywords:
diurnal activity patterns, foraging behaviour,
among-individual differences, within-individual
differences, small bird in winter
Author for correspondence:
Kimberley J. Mathot
e-mail: mathot@ualberta.ca
Electronic supplementary material is available
online at https://doi.org/10.6084/
m9.figshare.c.7569742.
ResearchGate has not been able to resolve any citations for this publication.
Article
Full-text available
Black-capped chickadees (Poecile atricapillus) and other species that feed at bird feeders balance the benefit of easy foraging with the added risk of predation. Individual birds respond differently to risky situations, and these differences have been attributed to the birds’ personalities, which researchers commonly assess with an “open-field” behavioral assay. However, these behavioral assays in birds have not been compared to behavior in the wild in the context of foraging in the presence of a predator (i.e., risk-taking behavior). We color-banded chickadees in a wild population and conducted behavioral assays in the field. We later used foraging trials to investigate these color-banded individuals’ responses to a predator (Cooper’s hawk, Accipiter cooperii) model or a series of Cooper’s hawk calls. We found that foraging black-capped chickadees responded more strongly to the presence of a predator model than to predator calls. Individual birds differed in their responses, and the behavioral assays (activity and exploration) predicted individual behavior in the wild during the foraging experiments. Activity and exploration assay scores were only weakly related, suggesting these two assays represent different traits. Both highly active birds and fast explorers exhibited some reluctance to visit the feeder (either reduced number of visits or greater latency to visit) when the predator model was present, a relationship that was somewhat unexpected. Our results suggest that standard behavioral assays predict behavior in the wild, but care should be taken when generalizing among species and studies.
Article
Full-text available
There is increasing evidence that individuals are consistent in the timing of their daily activities, and that individual variation in temporal behavior is related to the timing of reproduction. However, it remains unclear whether observed patterns relate to the timing of the onset of activity or whether an early onset of activity extends the time that is available for foraging. This may then again facilitate reproduction. Furthermore, the timing of activity onset and offset may vary across the breeding season, which may complicate studying the above-mentioned relationships. Here, we examined in a wild population of great tits (Parus major) whether an early clutch initiation date may be related to an early onset of activity and/or to longer active daylengths. We also investigated how these parameters are affected by the date of measurement. To test these hypotheses, we measured emergence and entry time from/into the nest box as proxies for activity onset and offset in females during the egg laying phase. We then determined active daylength. Both emergence time and active daylength were related to clutch initiation date. However, a more detailed analysis showed that the timing of activities with respect to sunrise and sunset varied throughout the breeding season both within and among individuals. The observed positive relationships are hence potentially statistical artifacts. After methodologically correcting for this date effect, by using data from the pre-egg laying phase, where all individuals were measured on the same days, neither of the relationships remained significant. Taking methodological pitfalls and temporal variation into account may hence be crucial for understanding the significance of chronotypes.
Article
Full-text available
Within species, individuals often show repeatable differences in behaviours, called ‘animal personality’. One behaviour that has been widely studied is how quickly an individual resumes feeding after a disturbance, referred to as boldness or risk-taking. Depending on the mechanism(s) shaping risk-taking behaviour, risk-taking could be positively, negatively, or not associated with differences in overall survival. We studied risk-taking and survival in a population of free-living black-capped chickadees ( Poecile atricapillus ) in which we previously showed repeatable among-individual differences in risk-taking over the course of several months. We found no evidence that variation in risk-taking is associated with differences in annual survival. We suggest that variation in risk-taking is likely shaped by multiple mechanisms simultaneously, such that the net effect on survival is small or null. For example, among-individual differences in energy demand may favour greater risk-taking without imposing an overall mortality cost if higher energy demand covaries with escape flight performance. We propose directions for future work, including using a multi-trait, multi-year approach to study risk-taking, to allow for stronger inferences regarding the mechanisms shaping these behavioural decisions.
Article
Full-text available
Foragers rely on various cues to assess predation risk. Information theory predicts that high certainty cues should be valued more than low certainty cues. We measured the latency of black-capped chickadees (Poecile atricapillus) to resume feeding during winter in response to cues that conferred different degrees of certainty about current predation risk: a high certainty visual cue (predator mount) and a lower certainty acoustic cue (conspecific mobbing calls), presented either alone or in combination. As predicted, chickadees took longer to resume feeding after the visual than the acoustic cue, and this effect was greatest under conditions of high starvation risk (i.e. low temperatures). Presenting both cues together produced the same foraging delay as the visual cue alone under low starvation risk, but surprisingly, resulted in lower responses under high starvation risk compared to the visual cue alone. We suggest that this may be due to prey using a form of information updating, whereby differences in the timing of perception of acoustic versus visual cues interacts with energetic constraint to shape perceived risk. Although the sequential perception of cues is likely in a range of decision-making contexts, studies manipulating the order in which cues are perceived are needed to test existing models of multimodal cue integration.
Article
Full-text available
All birds sleep and many do so in a specific location, the roost. Thus, every day each individual needs to decide when to go to (enter) and leave the roosting place. This determines the timing of activity, a trait shaped by both natural and sexual selection. Despite its importance in a variety of contexts, including foraging, predation, mating success and parental care, variation in the timing of activity has rarely been studied. Here, we describe this variation in a population of Eurasian Blue Tits Cyanistes caeruleus roosting in nest‐boxes using data collected over seven years. We investigate seasonal changes in the start and end of activity and assess to what extent these parameters are sex‐ and age‐specific and affected by weather. We show that the start of activity is relatively constant in relation to sunrise during winter but undergoes drastic changes during the breeding season. The end of activity is markedly later relative to sunset in mid‐winter and is also strongly influenced by breeding behaviour. Females generally start their activity later and end it earlier than males. The duration of daily activity is shorter during periods of rain and longer when temperatures are relatively high for the time of year.
Article
Full-text available
Understanding how heatwaves affect organisms is becoming an important issue in animal behaviour, given the changing climate. Exposure to high air temperatures can lead to lethal hyperthermia, when individuals are no longer able to maintain body temperature within their optimal physiological range. Animals will rapidly adjust their behaviour, prioritizing heat dissipation through activities such as drinking and sitting in shade to maintain their body temperature over other activities, such as foraging. Here, we used an automated logging system to consider both the spatial and temporal foraging patterns under a range of different air temperatures at an individual level, in a strictly granivorous species in the wild. We continuously monitored individual foraging activity of wild zebra finches, Taeniopygia guttata, a species well adapted to arid conditions, in an Australian arid area across two heatwave events. High air temperatures significantly reduced foraging activity, with the extent of this effect depending on the time of day. They also led to a significant decrease in the number of birds foraging together and to birds spending a higher proportion of their foraging activity close to a water supply. As temperatures exceeded 35 C we saw a significant escalation of heat dissipation behaviour. Our results indicate that extreme air temperatures significantly affected temporal, social and spatial characteristics of zebra finch foraging behaviour and these are likely to adversely reduce an individual's capacity to forage efficiently, and consequently its food intake in the short term, while also potentially having implications for both reproduction and survival in the long term.
Preprint
Historically, spatial ecology studies have focused on average movement patterns within animal groups; however, recent studies highlight the value of considering movement decisions both within- and among-individuals. Using a marked population of black-capped chickadees (Poecile atricapillus), we used the number of unique feeders an individual visits within our study area as a proxy for space use to assess the causes and consequences of within- and among-individual differences in chickadee space use. We found that as temperature decreased, feeding rate increased. Females, but not males, increased the number of unique feeders used coincident with the temperature-related increase in feeding rates. This may be due to sex-related differences in dominance, where males which are the dominant sex in chickadees, have priority access to feeders, while females increase their foraging areas to meet higher energetic demand. We also found that independent of temperature, juvenile males used more unique feeders than adult males. We suggest that this may be due to age-specific benefits of space use in male, where un-paired juvenile males may increase feeder exploration to gain information about potential mates. Finally, although chickadees showed repeatable differences in space use throughout our study, we found no evidence that space use predicted annual survival. Overall, our results suggest that dominance hierarchies and individual energetics impact within- and among-individual variation in space use. We provide suggestions for future studies to enhance understanding of fitness-related consequences of within- and among-individual variation in space use.
Article
Sampling, investing time or energy to learn about the environment, allows organisms to track changes in resource distribution and quality. The use of sampling is predicted to change as a function of energy expenditure, food availability, and starvation risk, all of which can vary both within and among individuals. We studied sampling behavior in a field study with black-capped chickadees (Poecile atricapillus) and show that individuals adjust their use of sampling as a function of ambient temperature (a proxy for energy expenditure), the presence of an alternative food source (yes or no, a proxy for risk of energy shortfall), and their interaction, as predicted by models of optimal sampling. We also observed repeatable differences in sampling. Some individuals consistently sampled more, and individuals that sampled more overall also had a higher annual survival. These results are consistent with among-individual differences in resource acquisition (e.g., food caches or dominance-related differences in priority access to feeders), shaping among-individual differences in both sampling and survival, with greater resource acquisition leading to both higher sampling and higher survival. Although this explanation requires explicit testing, it is in line with several recent studies suggesting that variation in resource acquisition is a key mechanism underlying animal personality.
Article
Social interactions can shape daily activity patterns, and this is an area of growing research interest. The propensity for individuals to be active at certain times of day may structure interactions with competitors and potential mates, influencing fitness outcomes. Aspects of daily activity such as timing of activity onset and offset exhibit within-individual repeatability, which raises the possibility that they may be subject to natural and sexual selection. This study used a biologging approach in free-living Arctic ground squirrels, Urocitellus parryii, to test the hypothesis that interactions between the sexes shape temporal patterns of daily activity. We predicted that males would become active earlier than females during the mating period, consistent with sexual selection on activity timing. We also examined repeatability in activity timing and how repeatability estimates are affected by sampling methodology. We deployed collar-mounted light loggers on ground squirrels and used timing of light transitions to determine daily onset and offset of above-ground activity. We observed 87 animals over 3 years, collecting over 7500 observations of daily activity. We found that daily activity timing had moderate (onset) to low (offset) adjusted repeatability. The difference in daily activity timing between the sexes varied seasonally: males remained active later than females during mating, while females initiated activity earlier and extended activity later during lactation. Adjusted repeatability estimates were sensitive to sampling methodology: they varied seasonally and declined with increased behavioural sampling. These results suggest that offset, not onset, may be shaped by sexual selection and that life history differences shape sex-dependent activity patterns in ground squirrels. We propose that activity onset may be under more strict circadian control than offset. This study suggests that researchers must consider seasonality and sampling design when estimating behavioural repeatability. Biologging could transform studies of individual variation by enabling high-frequency sampling of free-living animals.
Article
We used an automated radiotelemetry system to determine diurnal patterns of activity and temporal phenotype (onset and cessation of activity) in female European starlings during breeding. Parental care is thought to be the most ‘costly’ part of reproduction, with high rates of intense activity due to foraging and provisioning for chicks, so we predicted that variation in timing of activity should be closely related to breeding success. Diurnal variation in activity varied systematically with breeding stage in a way consistent with specific demands of each phase of parental care: incubating females were more active late in the day (1600–1800 hours), while chick-rearing females were more active early in the morning (0700–1100 hours). There was marked individual variation in timing of onset, and to a lesser extent cessation, of activity, e.g. chick-rearing females first became active 7–127 min after morning civil twilight, with low to moderate repeatability within and among breeding stages (individual explained 2–62% of total variation). On average, females were active later, and ceased being active earlier, during chick rearing compared with incubation. Chick-rearing birds had a longer active day, but only by 2.3% (36% of the seasonal increase in total available daylength). Thus, chick-rearing females were relatively less active (‘lazier’), which is consistent with the idea that parents work more efficiently rather than simply working harder. We found little evidence that chick-rearing activity was associated with variation in measures of current reproduction (provisioning rate, number and quality of chicks), future fecundity (initiating a second brood, cumulative 2-year productivity) or survival (local return rate). Our study demonstrates that time-keeping mechanisms show plasticity in response to reproductive state and can be modulated by ‘biotic’ (e.g. prey availability) or ‘social’ time (demands of parental care).