Content uploaded by Agnieszka Golec de Zavala
Author content
All content in this area was uploaded by Agnieszka Golec de Zavala on Feb 09, 2025
Content may be subject to copyright.
Collective narcissism of White supremacy and minority resistance
Abstract
N !"#$
%&'&(#
)#%'*+,-%&'&
#)&
N !"%&'&#
*+,-&'.(
##*+
,/*,/"$)&
*+##0&
'1.2(#
#
&,-#
#0&%&'&
)&3#*+,-#
)&
Keywords()*+
,/
1
Collective narcissism of White supremacy and minority resistance
“Prejudice needs power to be effective” 4,
“Your silence will not protect you”(,
5560
%'
753'"&(
00#-0
8&55"&9-*#
+*+50
!9.:55"&3“great
replacement”# 0
0&;*+#-
$5"�
<=0-&
0<0
$0=#>?5!51"&
#(
0#0
%'&3#
#
&
2
-
&&0>?5!51"&
00&&"
##0&0#>
?&55@(00
&&"#0
0&&>?&55@!!5@!>?
51"&80=-
0&0-
-
>?&55@!A*,8B4BC"&
<)
'.D#5E"#
&)?&5 "&
-=
)>?51!52"&
;0##
)#"
#$#"
#
#)&;0
)0-
#)#+0#
&/#1"
#)0
#0-
>?&5@!55"&;#-
##)
#
E
&-(+
#)<0
#)&3#0
00#
&'+
&
Collective narcissism, ethnocentric projection and White supremacy
-(
#0##)&
;-#
#-
B./52"&/0
#0&&#"
3&5!/&5E"&;
0&
/0+
=*#&51"&;0
ethnocentric projection*#&51"##
F*+&5G"#B./52"&
'D<D
A*,8B4BC"&
$#-<
&7;-0
#
=A*,8B4BC"&
/#
0
H
B
3$&5@!>?51!>?.,55"&
--<
000
&9-#%
:0*+-
-%&:&#
*+>?&55@"&%'
I%J
>0,/
&5"&#
=+&5"
0#
#0*+&5"&
'
0##)'#.
5"&;#-0
0#)&
/#
(0
9.>?5 !>?&5G"0
-=$
=#&
0
##
+%'%:9&5!>
?&5G"&%:
0*+-*+
>?&55@"&%'
G
+I%J
>0,/&5"&
#=
+&5"&0
##
0*+&5"&
#<##
#>?5!A*,8B4BC"&
#
)F+.K#55"&;#-
00#
)&
'
0##)'#.
5"&;#-0
0#)&
Collective narcissism and pursuit of racial equality among racial minorities
-#0#
)<
#
&#
0#*&51!
*,8B4B!>&51"&;
-&9-D#
##-0
##-&;#
"0-#0#0
"0-0#0
##-0#>?5"&)
"#
)A*,8B4BC"&'
;0
#)#
)=#$
0>?52"&9-
D###-#00
##-0#>?5"&)
"#
)A*,8B4BC"&
D0)
A*,8B4BC"&D)
0#
;.L05"&D#)0
$
#0#
&+
+)=
0"+
)&
)&L0-
&&(.?5!+&55!
?&5 "&8#-0#
0)"0
$-&
;-
#)#
?&5 "&;#
@
00
)&D#
0<
$=00=0
(.?5!?&5 "&
##0
)=
0&
0
�
#0A*,8B4BC"&#
*&5"$=0
$*&5!>
?&55@!&5"&
03&5!K&55"
B3$./$+5!>?&55@!51"&;
+0#
&;#-
#00#
=&'0
#-
=M+&
55"&;#-0
#=&;#
=
#0&5!,N&
52"&
4-#-
=#)&
5
(*+%:*+
>?&55@"&(*+%'
*+,/*,/"/&
5"&(,>*;O(P;+
-*
&5"&7/<
&;#-0
0#
)<%
'&
Overview
%&'
#0#
)"#0-"(
#)0"=
#);0"&D
##-=
##)&
3#0##
)=&
;#
0
*+,-(&)
1 B#
0'2&8#+##
'200#'1&
2 ;#0"
0#0
""
"0#&
0
1"
!2"
=*+'"!
E"
,-'1"&;
'/+0&;
#
&
Table 1
Hypotheses 1-14 Tested Across Studies 1-4 With Reference to Specific Predicted Variables.
8
8
8
/
8
'
8EH
'*,/33" P P
'*,/3132" P
'
8 55
,$)3E3H" P P
43G3 " P
'1
825
43@35" P
'2
8E5
(33" P P
'3132" P
88!P--
&;#(
0031EG@1"&;#
0032H 52"&
(##04
A*,8B4BC&(#0&(
$'/#0#
0&(##&
0&(#
#0'&
#"Strongly disagreeH"Strongly agree
#&(0QQ&Q <2QR
#SH 2H5E@GH2E0H@2G5G&;
'QQ&Q:KBSM1B'
QQ&QD88SB @ '1QQ&QDOBSE>F&
Analytical strategy
;332#L,'
;51"&0
&<+2"&;
0#5"&;
#
###0#
0#/"&;
#
###/"&
Study 1
'32&3#0
#*+,/*,/"
1
-
,')M55,55"&3#
0#
*,/&'##0
##*+#0
#&31
#0#*,/
&32#0#
*,/&'
##0#
*,/#*+#0
#&
Methods
Participants
DNEH!H11G0Q(M
1G&ESD1&@E "#H1*+H1
%&'&(D=&
Procedure
D#0&;
&L
##$&;
##00##
$#$#&9
2
&;
#$#
&L#
#$&(0)#
&
Measures
National and racial collective narcissism##E
>?&55@"=
&&IIf my [national/racial] group had more say in the world, the world would be
a much better place&J
National and racial ingroup satisfaction ##2
,.+@@"=
&&“In general, I'm glad to be a member of my [national/racial]
group”.
State repression of Black Lives Matter#
'++&552"&&II would support the government if it tapped the phones of
BLM activists.”
Participation in Black Lives Matter##E
3.D5"+#+*+,
/&B5##
*+,/#>90B+
/55&D#+)
*,/##&&IActively comment opinions on
E
Facebook/social media in support of BLM&JIParticipate in BLM protests or marches.”
"Not at allH"All the time.
Results
/0$
'/&;331#-0#
(#*,/
(*+&;332#-
*,/(
*+,/;0"&
;0#(#&
#3#
*,/0&#*+
;09"&31(
###*+,
/*++;01" 
#*,/#*+
*,/;01
9"&
/#
&#
#*,/
#*,/&'
#0=&
H
(;01#
#&'##
*,/#030
b(SE) =5&5&5"p&95%CIA5&5G15&1C"*+b(SE) =
5&G5&5@"p&5G195%CIA5&1E5&5HC" 
#*,/b(SE) =5&55&5@"p&5@
95%CIA5&1 5&5C"0*+##
*,/b(SE) =5&5&5 "p&H@95%CIA5&5E5&HC"&;
#0#
0#
&
'#3332&3#31
(
$0*,/&;0
%'0&(
(#
&;#+
#>
?&52"9.>
?52"&'#(
00*,/&
G
Table 2
Multiple Regression Analyses Of State Repression Of BLM, Study 1
% Model 1 Model 2
Predictors b(SE) 95%CI
LL,UL P β b(SE) 95%CI
LL,UL p β
88 5&15&5H" 5&5&21 T&55 5&1H 5&2H5&5@" 5&G5&H2 T&55
5&E
8 5&@5&5G" 5&215&E T&55 5&1G 5& 5&5@
"
5&2H5&5@ &551 5&1H
" &G5&1G" &225&@@ T&55 5&2E 1&E25&E5
"
2&E1&EE T&55
5&25
88U> 5&5&1" 5&1G5&2 &1G5 5&1 5&155&H
"
5&H5&5 &5H 5&12
8U> 5& 55&2" 5&E2&5G T&55 &51 5&G25&H" 5&2&5E T&55
5&@2
8' 5&5&5
"
5&1@5&5H &55G 5&1
' 5&G5&5@
"
5&1E5&5 &5G1 5&H
8'U> 5&G5&" 5&5E5&2@ &5H 5&
'U> 5&@5&2" 5&55&EE &512 5&
L0 EH EH
7Q7< 5&15Q5&1 5&GQ5&E@
Note&8'
Table 3
Multiple Regression Analyses Of Anticipated Participation in BLM, Study 1
% Model 1 Model 2
Predictors b(SE) 95%CI
LL,UL P β b(SE) 95%CI
LL,UL p β
88 5&55&5G" 5&H5&1 & 1 5&5 5&5&5@" 5&515&1 &5@ 5&1
8 5&E 5&5 " 5&25&G2 T&55 5&G 5&225&5@" 5&H5&H T&55
5&E2
" &H5&1@" & E1&1 T&55 5& 1&525&E5" &522&51 T&55
5&5@
88U> 5&5E5&" 5&@5& &H@2 5&5E 5&55&2
"
5&155&E & H2 5&51
8U> 5&@5&" &E5&H@ T&55 &2 5&HG5&1
"
5&@15&2 T&55
5& 2
@
8' 5&15&5
"
5&2G5&H T&55
5&1
' 5&5&5 " 5&5E5&H &H@ 5&5
8'U> 5&5&" 5&5&1E &@ 5&
'U> 5&15&
"
5&EE5&5G &5 5&@
L0 EH EH
7Q7< 5&G1Q5&HE 5&25Q5&G
Note&8'
5
Figure 1
Simple Slopes Analyses Of Racial Collective Narcissism With State Repression Of BLM,
Study 1. Note. VVVpT&55VVp&551&
Figure 2
Simple Slopes Analyses Of Racial Collective Narcissism With Participation In BLM, Study 1.
Note. VVVpT&55Vp&5E&
Study 2
'3E &3E#0
#$)&3H#
0#$
)&'#0#
$)#*+#0
#$)&3G
#0#&3 #
0#&
'#0#
#*+#0#&
Method
Participants and design
DN 55%&'&!1HG210Q
(M2G& SDG&E@ G"1HE*+21E
(D&
Measures
National and racial collective narcissism #'&
National and racial ingroup satisfaction##2
,&55 "
&&II think that my [national/racial] group has a lot to be proud ofJ&
Legitimization of racial inequality ##'
&5E"IEveryone in United States has a fair shot at wealth and happiness, regardless of
ethnicity or race&JIIn general, relations between different racial groups in United States
are fair.J&
Egalitarianism##2
$3&5E"
&&IPeople should work to give all groups an equal chance to succeed&JIPeople should do
what they can to equalize conditions for different groups.”
Results
#3E(##
$)(*+;02"&
#3H#&#
1
#$)0*+
##$);0291"&
3G0#(
=;0E"&
O3G(#
#*+#(
##92"&;
##3 &;#&
##&;0#
*+#p&5E9E"&(
'#&
##
0*+;0E"
0$)0*+;0H"&
'#3E 0'&
;#
0#$)#*+
#0#0
$)&4'(
#0$)0
#&
#&(-'
##*+0
#&'#
*+&(#
2
*+#0
*+0&;
*+$0
<&(#
#$0-)
D>?.*#$+5!>
?.:52"&'1##
$0
*+,-
&
E
Table 4
Multiple Regression Analyses Of Legitimization Of Racial Inequality, Study 2
% Model 1 Model 2
Predictors b(SE) 95%CI
LL,UL p β b(SE) 95%CI
LL,UL p β
88 5&H5&5G" 5&2@5&GH T&55
5&E1 5&E25&5" 5&1E5&G1 T&55 5&2H
8 5&15&5 " 5&255&5G &55E 5& 5& 5&" 5&25&5H &25 5&G
" 5&225&21" & 5&25 &151 5&2G 5& H5&E" & H5&2 &5@1 5&2G
88U> 5&55&" 5&25&5 &5H2 5&G 5&H5&2" 5&E15&5 &5EH 5&
8U> 5&2@5&" 5& 5&G T&55
5&2H 5&E55&2" 5&5&G &55 5&2G
8' 5&25&5" 5&5H5&11 &H2 5&5
' 5&5 5&" 5&15&E &2G 5&5G
8'U> 5&5G5&" 5&G5&1 &EH 5&5E
'U> 5&5H5&E" 5&5&1E &HHE 5&5E
L0 55 55
7Q7< 5&1GGQ5&1G1 5&1 HQ5&1G@
Note&8'
H
Table 5
Multiple Regression Analyses Of Egalitarianism, Study 2
% Model 1 Model 2
Predictors b(SE) 95%CI
LL,UL p β b(SE) 95%CI
LL,UL p β
88 5&5G5&52" 5&E5&5 &5G 5&5 5&E5&5H
"
5&H5&52 &55 5&
8 5&5&5E" 5&5&1 T&55 5&11 5&5&5H" 5&555&1 &5EH 5&
" 5&E5&1" 5&1H5& E &22 5&G &15&E" 5&1& &5G 5&@
88U> 5&15&5 " 5&5G5&1@ &55H 5&11 5& 5&5" 5&5 5&2 &55H 5&25
8U> 5&1E5&5 " 5&E5&5 T&55 5&EE 5&15&5@
"
5&2@5&E T&55
5&E5
8' 5&E5&5G" 5&55& &5H 5&@
' 5&25&5 " 5&5@5&25 &55 5&1
8'U> 5&E5&5@
"
5&115&51 &5G 5&@
'U> 5&5@5&5
"
5& 5&5 &1H 5&
G
L0 55 55
7Q7< 5&5H1Q5&5EG 5&5Q5&5@
Note&8'
Figure 3
Simple Slopes Analysis Of Racial Collective Narcissism And Legitimization Of Racial
Inequality, Study 2. Note. VVVpT&55Vp&5H&
@
Figure 4
Simple Slopes Analysis Of National Collective Narcissism And Egalitarianism, Study 2. Note.
VV*+p&551Vp&51G&
15
Figure 5
Simple Slopes Analysis Of Racial Collective Narcissism And Egalitarianism, Study 2. Note.
VVVpT&55W&5E&
Study 3
'13@5&3@#0
#&35#
0#&'
#0##,-
#0#&
Method
Participants and design
1
DN25!@ @GH0Q!(M
@&@1SD5&21 H@"#5%&'&,-55
%&'&&B#(D#
&
Measures
National and racial collective narcissismnational and racial ingroup
satisfaction#'&
Egalitarianism##E#
&55"&;
#IIt is important to correct social and economic inequality&JIAll groups should
be given an equal chance in lifeJIWe would have fewer problems if we treated people more
equallyJIWomen have fewer chances to get aheadJIPoor people have fewer chances to get
aheadJ&
Results
#3@(##
,-+;0H"#
0#;0H"&(-
###,-
##9E"&%+
'#
0#'
1&,-+&
%+'(#
1
<&;
(##
&'2#+)
#)#&
11
Table 6
Multiple Regression Analyses Of Egalitarianism, Study 3
% Model 1 Model 2
Predictors b(SE) 95%CI LL,UL p Β b(SE) 95%CI LL,UL p β
88 5&15&52" 5&15&2 T&55 5& 5&55&5@" 5&1G5&51 &5 5&E
8 5&1@5&5G" 5&E5&E1 T&55 5&E2 5&1 5&" 5&G5&E@ T&55 5&E1
"
&@G5&11" &1&H T&55 5&G &@5&25" &1@&@ T&55 5&H
88U> 5&15&" 5&1G5&5 &G 5&H 5&55&E" 5&15&G & G2 5&51
8U> 5&H15&" 5& G5&1@ T&55 5& G 5&H25&E" 5&@25&11 T&55 5&
8' 5&55&5G" 5&H5& &G22 5&52
' 5&555&5@" 5& 5& &@H 5&55
8'U> 5&15&5" 5&15&5G &51 5&@
'U> 5&555&2" 5& 5& &@@@ 5&55
L0 25 25
7Q7< 5&2 Q5&1@ 5&H2Q5&2G
Note&8'
12
Figure 6
Simple Slopes Analysis Racial Collective Narcissism And Egalitarianism, Study 3. Note. VVV
pT&55Vp&52&
Study 4
'232&3#0
#&3#
0#&
'#0#
#*+#0#
&31#0
#&32#
0#&
'#0#
1E
#,-#0#
&
Method
Participants and design
DNE5!H11G0Q!(M
1&H1SD&GG GG"#2@,-E
%&'&(D=&
Measures
National and racial collective narcissismand ingroup satisfaction #
'1&
Support for the alt-right ##
&&9.:55"#(IWhite people may
no longer have a say in how the country is run because racial minorities are trying to take
control&JIIf we do not control immigration, Whites will soon be replaced by minorities in
the U.S.”, IMore needs to be done so that people remember that “White lives” also matterJ&
Support for racial minorities##H
&;#0
+*+%&'&,(&;#
IMore needs to be done to protect Blacks from police violence in the U.S&JIThe police
should be held accountable for using disproportionate force against Blacks in the U.S.J
IBlacks should not be treated so unfairly by the law in the U.S.JIMore needs to be done to
protect Latino immigrants from deportation.JIUndocumented migrants from Latin America
1H
living in the U.S. should be allowed an opportunity to become citizens.JILatin American
immigrants should not be separated from their families in the U.S.J&
Results
#3(##
,-+;0G"&
#3##
#,-##
;0G9G"(#
##,-
+;0 "&D#32,-#
#;0 "#
#
#9 "&
#
&#
&#&
#;0G"&
'#,-#
#b(SE)5&5&5"p&51H95%CIA5&25&51C"#
#b(SE)5&5HG5&5 "p&1 E95%CIA5&5 2
5&C"&
$;0@&;#
(
1G
#)
##
)&;##
"#&;
#&;0#
)0
&
1
Table 7
Multiple Regression Analyses Of Alt-Right Support, Study 4
% Model 1 Model 2
Predictors b(SE) 95%CI
LL,UL p Β b(SE) 95%CI
LL,UL p β
88 5&2E5&5H" 5&115&EG T&55 5&22 5&1H5&5" 5&H5&EH T&55
5&1E
8 5&1 5&5G" 5&E5&1 T&55 5&1G 5&25&5
"
5&215&5E &5E 5&1
" &25&1" &55& T&55 5&H &5&2G
"
1&5E&@ T&55
5&H
88U> 5&525&" 5& 5&H &G2 5&52 5&5H5&E" 5&15&1H &HH 5&5H
8U> 5&HH5&" 5&25&@5 T&55 5&HE 5&E5&E" 5&15& 5 T&55
5&E5
8' 5&55&5@" 5&5G5& &2G 5&5
' 5&5&5
"
5&25&5 &51H 5&G
8'U> 5&525&
"
5& 5&5 &GE 5&51
'U> 5& 5&1" 5&515&E &5@ 5&1
L0 E5 E5
1@
7Q7< 5&2E@Q5&2E2 5&2H Q5&2E
Note&8'
Table 8
Multiple Regression Analysis Of Support For Racial Minorities, Study 4
% Model 1 Model 2
Predictors b(SE) 95%CI LL,UL p Β b(SE) 95%CI LL,UL p β
88 5& 5&52" 5&1G5&5 T&55 5&12 5&25&5G" 5&1 5&5 &55 5&
8 5&EH5&5H" 5&225&HG T&55 5&HH 5&2@5&5 " 5&115&H2 T&55 5&E
" &H@5&H" & & T&55 5&2 &15&2E" &E1&5 T&55 5&2
88U> 5&515&" 5&@5&E & 5E 5&51 5&555&E" 5&155&15 &@@5 5&55
8U> 5&G55&1" 5&@E5&22 T&55 5& 1 5&E@5&E" 5& 5&15 T&55 5&G5
8' 5&5H5&5H" 5& 5&5G &1G 5&5H
25
' 5&5&5@" 5&5H5&G &G 5&
8'U> 5&5E5&" 5&@5&@ &H@H 5&5E
'U> 5&55&" 5&225&5E & 5&5
L0 E55 E55
7Q7< 5&12Q5&15 5&15Q5&15G
Note&8'
2
Figure 7
Simple Slopes Analyses Of Racial Collective Narcissism And Alt-Right Support, Study 4.
Note. Vp&5,-p&5E&
Figure 8
2
Simple Slopes Analyses Of Racial Collective Narcissism And Support For Racial Minorities,
Study 4. Note. VVVpT&55p&2E&
21
Table 9
Summary Of Results Across Studies 1-4
'
7 7 88 8X
8 /8
bpbpbpbp
'
8EH
'*,/33" 5&2H T&55 5&G2 T&55 5&2H T&55 5& &551
'*,/3132" 5& &5@ 5&HG T&55 5&1 &5E 5&22 T&55
'
8 55
,$)3E3H" 5&E2 T&55 5&E5 &55 5&15 T&55 5& &5H
43G3 " 5&E &55 5&1 T&55 5& T&55 5& &5E
'1
825
43@35" 5&5 &5 5&H2 T&55 5&E &52 5&1 T&55
'1
8E5
(33" 5&1H T&55 5&E T&55 5&G &5 5&2 &5E
'3132" 5&2 &55 5&E@ T&55 5&5 &2E 5&2@ T&55
Note. b: $0p: p &
22
Discussion
Summary of findings
#-
#)#
#)&;
-(#
)+&
(-0#
#&#;-
&'
##
*,/0&*+#
#0&#
#*+,/#*+
##*+
,/&##
#,-##
#*+"&
##$)
#*+##$
)&##
#&
,-##
#&;
2E
#
##&
;##&(
(##<
$)
*+,/<
&;#
#0&#
(+)&
8##
*,/#
#0&
L-#6
-##*,/
&(-#
#
&'##
*+0'1#
#,-&
White collective narcissism and ethnocentric projection
;
#)(
<)&;
(<
2H
(&(0
(Isense of racial and national
greatness and entitlement”, 0%'
&5& 5 "&;
0-#
&-<
&(
Y=##Y=6
0&
;0
3.:055G!3.BD5@!:.90@ @"&*
-9&5!>?&55@!5H"#
#
&+.+55"&
0
0
9&5"&
-+
>?5!51"&;+:
-0#
&
0#&
2G
/#
#)<<#&
D+->?.
*#$+5"'>?&55"0,
&52!/&5"!<#B3$
&5@!A*,8B4BC"F+&5"&*
<00
$<
-
&;)
ethnocentric projection *#&51!B.
/52"0
&#
<&;+#
�
+)&
National collective narcissism and system justification
;(
#<))0
+#0&51"
<M5@"&*-0
+$)&'
<<&&
$+#))"#
<&&
2
="0&/
-#0
&;00
-0#
&;0<
0<
=&;
0
&&
"&&$
"&/0
0#
#&*0<
0
"&
;)-&;#(
$
&;<&;
0<)
0
#&;#
($
&'#;
#D##0
$)>?.*#$+5!A*,8B4BC"&
2@
00<)
0&;
'#<&;
<&;
0#0
$0+0
)&;
&
;#0#
-
&D+#<0
$0&8
0
0--&;
)0<0
0+
&<
+&#
+*&51!>?5@"&
(##<
+0*+00
&#,-#
0#
#�
E5
$00
<=/+Z<$+&5!
L#&52!'$$[+&5"&;
$+0
#&90#0
0#(
&3##-#
#+$0->
?.*#$+5"0'$$+&5"
0$)
A*,8B4BC"&
;#
(#
&00#
&-0
0()&
0
00
)'&52"#
B-&5G"&
8#
-(
0#
*,/#*,/
&;0
E
#
0&
#0#=+&
'0
###
>?.952"9.
>?52!>?52"
##>?52!A*,8B4BC"&'
#+
-+&50!4+&51"&
Collective narcissism and pursuit of racial equality
;
)&>?.,55!
>?52"&(
##)<)
$0
)&(
=>?52"
+&
;0&(0
#L$.,5@!;-&
55";##
=
<&3
E
/51")#
#&&B-./:#5"&#
;)
?&5 "&;
0
0#0
)
&3#
+#0
&;0&
(0#
L$.,5@!;-&55"0
+
&D#
-&'&
55"&D#-
&0
#)&()#
=&(0
#0=
>?52"&;
0
&'0
Y+=
B&52"&9
E1
##-&3#
--$#0
M+&55!K&55"&
;0#0
&)
00&4-
0+0
#3\&5!'0.
%51!%0&5"&70++
$#&(
#
-0#B3$&
5@!>?&55@!5H"0
#$
A*,8B4BC"+0+
B3$./$+5!>?&
51"&;##
#)+0&
%&
$
&'
#
F?&5 "&4-
00#
#
E2
--A*,8B4BC"&;
0$0
-)&
Is it collective narcissism?
;$0
>?51!52"&(
0#'.D#5E
0(>5"#
))
'.D#5E".*0
0#'/"&;
00<
0/0
#
>.:$+5!:$$#+55"&
#-#
0=&/0
$&
#0&;
00
&#-
00&
(--
0#)0
EE
>?5!51!52"&4-
#
##>&5"
>?.:52"*&5!
>&51"0>?&
51"-*&5"A*,8B4BC"&
D
#0
;+":
";+*&51"&/
$00
"#
>?5"&>
#
#A*,8B4BC"&
D'/"#
#
(*+,-&;
#)00
+&3#
#=
-=#
&
0$ more worthy of privilege A*,8B4BC"
EH
0-#&
)#
$0
#&;
))&;
0
)0&9
&
4-#
>&551!,.'55G"&'#
0#0
*.>5 !.9051!&
55"#0#5 !&&.
5"#&&
/-#&52"&;
&;
0
L0&51"&;
)#0&,
#
/.3+55"&
What about non-narcissistic ingroup satisfaction?
&'
&3#8
EG
&4-
&
F+.
K#55">?
51"0#0>&5"
*,8B4B!/#+&5">?&5"
<>?52!>?&
52!*,8B4B"&
0#)
)&''
)&
##
)#
*,8B4B"&
#
'/(?&5 "&;
0#
)&3#)+
0#
(.?5!
?&5 "&;
0
&
E
;00
)&(#->
?.*#$+5!A*,8B4BC"#
#*,/
##*,/
&##0$
)&;#
#)
A*,8B4BC"&;#
>?51"
#)&8
0#
)&(000
)+#
B-./:#5!B-&5G"&
9
0-&
Limitations
0
)0
#&;#%'
-)&9##$0
0-#&
(-0
<%
E@
:*&5!>?&55@!/&5"
0#D
>?.:51"&;+$
&
9##-
&##0$
)##
#*,/(*+&/
0&
(-0#
#)##
0=&;0#
$)0&;
-<<
)>?&55"&9
,.'55G";&55"&3#
#0<
))
&0
0&9-
&
H5
References
53'5"%&'&BM9*
&QQ###&<&QQQ5
(/&.?/&5"&;#
#()
&Psychological Bulletin147
HHG6G55&QQ&Q5&51GQ05555EH
*'&&(*&4+4&.%4&>&5"&]]]
]]]]]]]];,>*;
]]]];+&TPM - Testing, Psychometrics, Methodology in Applied
Psychology29"161 &QQ&Q5&22G1Q;D/@&&1
*'&&''&.>?(&51"&'
,+#00
&Cultural Diversity and Ethnic Minority
Psychology29(2),5 5&QQ&Q5&51GQ5555E5@
*:&+(&.<$+*&5"&/0/<
&Journal of
Experimental Social Psychology93525@ &
QQ&Q5&5HQ<&<&55&525@
*#/&*&>+:&.B(&51"&'-
<0&
Group Processes & Intergroup Relations16E"E@6E22&
QQ&Q5&GGQ1H 2152H H
H
*4&.>4&*&5 "&;'%
(%'&Basic and Applied Social Psychology40H"1@H621&
QQ&Q5&5 5Q5@G1E11&5 &E55H
,&5 "&(
&Journal of Theoretical Social Psychology2"
E 6HH&QQ&Q5&55Q<E&@
:&4&.90/&*&51"&#
"&Group Processes & Intergroup Relations26"152615&
QQ&Q5&GGQ1H 2155HG21
>&&.&*&55"&4-
&7Structural equation modeling79"11EE&
QQ&Q5&5GQ'E1 55G'4/5@5SE
+(&*:&#+/&.($9&5"&I8*^J
*(08M
44-&Political PsychologyEarly view&
QQ&Q5&Q& 1
+(&+(&>*&.<+(&B&50"&
R0<0&7Group
Processes & Intergroup Relations725G"G G1 &
QQ&Q5&GGQ1H 21551 5E
;&3&*#'&/&''&;&&B&;(&.,'&L&
5"&#&Journal of
Personality and Social Psychology122"1E6G5&
QQ&Q5&51GQ555512
H
/&(&.M&(&5"&R3#
&Journal of Personality
and Social Psychology1022"GE@6GGG&QQ&Q5&51GQ55H2
/&(&*F&.*#&/&55"&(##R>
0&Current Opinion in
Psychology35262 &QQ&Q5&5HQ<&&55&51&55
B'&;&*/&'4&.?/&&52"&;9+
*'/RGlobal Environmental Psychology2611&
QQ&Q5&E@H2Q&
B;&./3&52"&'(0#
48&Social and Personality Psychology Compass8"
G1@6GE2&QQ&Q5&Q1&2@
B-M&./:#'&5"&8
#&7Journal of Social
Issues777"2EG&QQ&Q5&Q<&2@
B-M&B:&.;/&5G"&;D>
(;#4)3#"&Political Psychology
38'"@6H&QQ&Q5&Q&1@1
B3$:&./$+*&5"&L
#0
&7PLoS ONE, 161"(
52G 2&7QQ&Q5&1GQ<&&52G 2
4+&+(&.'0&>&51"&
&Group Processes & Intergroup
Relations261"HH@6H@E&QQ&Q5&GGQ1H 2155 2G5
H1
99&44&*(&.,(&>&55@"&'#
>VD#1&;&Behavior Research
Methods412"2@6H5&QQ&Q5&1GE Q*/&2&2&2@
9&.>?(&5 "&5HD
.Public Opinion Quarterly 56&hps://doi.org/5&5@1Q)Q-52
9&/&9&FM&(&.>?(&5"&
8D"55%'4&The Forum
9&/&>?(&.*&5"8*
8&Political Psychology, 44,GG@H&7QQ&Q5&Q& 11
9D&'&.:8&'&55"&(DD(&
Perspectives on Psychological Science15"@56H&
QQ&Q5&GGQG2EH@H@ H 5
>'&5 M2"&D#K&Approaching Significance&
QQ0&#&Q5 Q5Q2Q#Q
>?(&5"&83;B+'
Y>,=&Social and Personality Psychology Compass5H"15@615&
QQ&Q5&Q<&GE@552&5&551E&-
>?(&5"&DFL>
8DB4->
/&Sex Roles,87EH"HG6 &QQ&Q5&55GQ@@551E$
>?(&51"&The psychology of collective narcissism&&
>?(&52"&(IJ
&7Group Processes & Intergroup Relations705"
QQ&Q5&GGQ1H 215225H @
H2
>?(&52"&*0-R
0#)&M&9&.:&94&"The
psychology of tribalism&&H2E"&L-;.9&
>?(&.*#$+:&5"&/8
8D'-&Sex Roles84"H 56G55&
QQ&Q5&55GQ@@555@11
>?(&.:L&5"&#+
&Journal of Theoretical Social Psychology5"E26H2&
QQ&Q5&55Q<E&H@
A*,8B4BC
A*,8B4BC
A*,8B4BC
>?(&.,B&55"&8'
);*%&Current Directions in Psychological Science
291"G16G &QQ&Q5&GGQ5@H1G25@GG51
>?(&+(&.+>&51"&
&7Journal of Personality and
Social Psychology, 104H"5@651@&7QQ&Q5&51GQ551E
>?(&+(&4&.M#+8&55@"&
8')&Journal of Personality and Social
Psychology97H"5G265@H&7QQ&Q5&51GQ55H@52
>?(&B3$:&.,B&5@"&D
)#=&Advances in
Political Psychology, 40, 1GG2&QQ&Q5&Q&EH@
HE
>?(&9&/&'+&>&,B&/$[+*&
[+/&.*;&55"&,#
000
&7Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 1191"G26
GH2&7QQ&Q5&51GQ5555H5
>?(&>&.'&5G"&;0#*-
<#
&Frontiers in Psychology, 8.
QQ&Q5&11 @Q&5G&551
>(&.:$+4&5"&7Anti-gender politics in the populist moment&;.
9&
>*&+(&/&.+(&51"&DB
#+
&7Journal of Applied Social Psychology753"G
1@&QQ&Q5&Q<&155@
>'&B0/&/8&.B'&551"&B
<R-
&Journal of Personality and Social Psychology842"H@G6G&
QQ&Q5&51GQ551E2& 2&2&H@G
3:&&'&+/&&>&.?/&52"&*;
L*(;(((("
9#+'4*-'
4(&Personality and Social Psychology Review28"6E1&
QQ&Q5&GGQ5 H 11G 5EH
HH
3(&*+/&/$+#$/&+:&:&.>?(&5"&
B#-
&Psychophysiology58@"1 G@&
QQ&Q5&Q&1 G@
3\;&%M&'00'&'08&*/&&5"&8
(##
&Journal of Personality and Social Psychology1222"H126HE &
QQ&Q5&51GQ55551HE
3>&.F*&52"&/>
6(#
&7Practical Assessment, Research, and Evaluation719"G&
QQ&Q5&GGEQ)$@2H
3(&:&'M&:8&''+M&D9&3+:&4&9
&.'#(&,&5E"&;8'BL;$
/D)%8#'BLG'&
Journal of Personality and Social Psychology109H"55165 &
QQ&Q5&51GQ5555511
3>&4/&./&(&5"&D3#
#&Group Processes & Intergroup Relations251"
HE6H2&QQ&Q5&GGQ1H 2155G5E2
3D&/&.D&B&5"&;0$8#+
*+,/&Analyses of Social
Issues and Public Policy21"E26EEH&QQ&Q5&Q&15
M+:&00B&:+(&&>/&;)/&3
/&.>&55"&'-)
HG
-&Journal of Personality and Social Psychology
118H"HE6 G&QQ&Q5&51GQ5555@
MM&;&5@"&()<O#
&British Journal of Social Psychology58"H16
12&QQ&Q5&Q0<&@G
MM&;&*+M&L0B&.*F&5G"&/"(
'M/(;#;
D*&Current Directions in Psychological Science26"@@65 &
QQ&Q5&GGQ5@H1G2GH@5H11
A*,8B4BC
:$_#+/&55"&B
#
&7Social Semiotics7302"E51EG&
QQ&Q5&5 5Q51E5115&55&GHH@@
:M&&9&'M&.;,&5G"&D
+)
&Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences114"E25G6
E2&QQ&Q5&5G1Q&HHEG2
,B&/&.>?(&52"&
0D&Archives of Sexual Behavior
,&&?0'&F+/&,&&D+'&9&B<*&L#++M&&.
'&55 "&>(
"&Journal of Personality and Social
PsychologyHE&
H
,M&M&.'/&;&55G"&>)-
40
&7European Journal of Social Psychology7372"G52G2&
QQ&Q5&55Q<&1 1
,M&M&.'/&;&55G"&>)-
40&
European Journal of Social Psychology372"G526G2&
QQ&Q5&55Q<&1 1
,NM&*&(+8&L0/&.,`;&52"&
0RGroup Processes & Intergroup Relations27"
G61 &QQ&Q5&GGQ1H 2151E22
,&55MG"&Lafayette Square protesters were subjected to ‘excessive use of
force,’ National Guard commander will testify&
QQ###&0#&Q#Q)#0<
-#Q
,&;4&/>&,$$/&(&./9&
55"&;F(;(4B&
Political Psychology41'"1E6G2&QQ&Q5&Q&HG
,&.+M&@@"&('4''4
L='&Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin181"1561 &
QQ&Q5&GGQ52HHG@ 155H
/>&+(&+(&(->8&.($9&5"&
%
;
H@
&European Journal of Social Psychology
52G"52G65H1&QQ&Q5&55Q<& E
/-#&'3&D&3'&&&.MM&&&"&(-
$00
&British Journal of Social Psychologyn/aQ"&
QQ&Q5&Q0<&G E
/+Z<$+>&*+M&&.(&5"&#
)
&7European Journal of Social Psychology7522"HHH2&
QQ&Q5&55Q<& 2
/9&/&51"&7Political plasticity: The future of democracy and dictatorship&
0%D&
/9&/&.3+/&M&55"&;&Current
Opinion in Psychology35G6&QQ&Q5&5HQ<&&55&5&552
/&&?(&>&.(/&/&5"&30
D&7European Journal of Sociology/Archives Européennes
de Sociologie762"1GG5&QQ&Q5&5GQ'5551@GEH5555G
/,&4&D8&,&.'M&5E"&8
4<&Cultural Diversity and
Ethnic Minority Psychology21E61H&QQ&Q5&51GQ551G 5
/++'&./&55@"&/D/0$;B
*#(&Terrorism and Political Violence21"1@6H5&
QQ&Q5&5 5Q5@E2HEE5@5GHEE5
G5
8*&,&'&K&.*4+K&55"&B;(
DF&Perspectives on Terrorism14E"6E&
QQ###&<&Q0QH@2551H
Obaidi, M., Anjum, G., Bierwiaczonek, K., Dovidio, J. F., Ozer, S., & Kunst, J. R.
(2023). -
&Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences1205"1 G25&
QQ&Q5&5G1Q&1 G25
Orazani, S. N., & Leidner, B. (2019). ;#
-"&
European Journal of Social Psychology492"H 6G52&
QQ&Q5&55Q<&EH
L#&:&,&.*&52"&(,';
*(a'/
D&7Psychology of Women Quarterly748"1 EE&
QQ&Q5&GGQ51HH 211GH
D+B&,&.*/&3&5H"&/
;
&7Developmental review741G@5&QQ&Q5&5HQ<&&5H&5H&552
&*(&.3:&5"&;D8
(0;#(&Social Issues and Policy Review16"
G@62&QQ&Q5&Q&5
:&M&M*&/&L=*:&.'04&51"&;'D
B'0>F'&European
Psychologist182"1E622&QQ&Q5&5GQ5H@525Q555E@
G
'&5M "&(3#Y=#
&The Guardian&QQ###&&Q#Q5Q<Q5 Q
##
0$(&.,b+L&51"&-
)
&7Structural Equation Modeling: A Multidisciplinary Journal730H" E@
G5&QQ&Q5&5 5Q5G5EE&51&@@
0/&L#&:&'&.,&51"&(
'/'("/-<0
<&European
Review of Social Psychology62&QQ&Q5&5 5Q52H1 1&5&52H2
'8&:&L0B&.'0&>&5E"&;
4&
British Journal of Social Psychology54"126125&
QQ&Q5&Q0<&5 5
'08&.%M&51"&;#'
0(B>=D&Journal of
Social and Political Psychology1"(&QQ&Q5&E@H2Q<&& G
'4&';&?/&.34&55"&B
;
&Journal of Personality and Social Psychology8D'8
D'&QQ&Q5&51GQ5555111
'4&?/&';&:#4&.34&52"&BB
BB(8#/(/&
G
Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin52HHG1HGH@&
QQ&Q5&GGQ52HHG1HGH@
'++,&M&*&&./4&552"&D;
D9#'055;(+(
(&Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin30H"G216GEH&
QQ&Q5&GGQ52HHG52H1@H
'3&M&.D#;&9&5E"&(
&7Social Justice Research728H&QQ&Q5&55GQ5251E
'#'&.&5"&;(=
B;-&Group Processes &
Intergroup Relations251"G@6 5&QQ&Q5&GGQ1H 21552 @1
'$$[+B&/#+/&:+(&/?&>c+D&.$/&
5"&B0#R8
0#D&7Sex Roles787"@@E&
QQ&Q5&55GQ@@551511
;-&D&'&.K$0F&K&55"&/,:/U
0R3=#=
&Journal of Personality and Social Psychology118E"@@6@22&
QQ&Q5&51GQ5555@E
;4&9&.L0B&5"&D0RB
&European Journal of Social Psychology52G"@ E6@@1&
QQ&Q5&55Q<&@
;4&9&.L0B&5"&D0RB
G1
&European Journal of Social Psychology52G"@ E6@@1&
QQ&Q5&55Q<&@
;4&9&?04&'0&>&.L0B&55"&;
&7Personality and Social Psychology
Bulletin746H" 1 1 &QQ&Q5&GGQ52HHG@ G@
;4&9&?04&'0&>&.L0B&55"&;
&7Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin746H" 1 1 &
QQ&Q5&GGQ52HHG@ G@
%0(&/>&.,&5"&;(/>('/
D<((;/
&Review of General Psychology26"H 6 E&
QQ&Q5&GGQ5 @H 55EH1
F*+,&/,&4&./+<'&5G"&>(
(8&Psychology of Women Quarterly411"
1E61HG&QQ&Q5&GGQ51HH 21GG5GG5
D<M&&.:<'&/&3&&55"&(-
'##0&Personality and
Individual Differences1595@ &QQ&Q5&5HQ<&&55&5@
?/&:/&.;?#+9&5 "&#I#J#
#I#J#"(-'/
(&European Review of Social Psychology29"6H5&
QQ&Q5&5 5Q52H1 1&5 &2G@12G
G2
F+/&.K#:&55"&
&Current Opinion in Psychology326E&
QQ&Q5&5HQ<&&5@&5H&55
F+/&:&>M&.K#:&5"&#
&7Personality and Individual Differences7184G&
QQ&Q5&5HQ<&&5&G
:&>:&,&.*B&5"&=#
0
0&European Journal of Social Psychology
522"G1E6G2G&QQ&Q5&55Q<& 2@
K&D&4&:&3&.(&55"&;
-0&Psychology of Religion and Spirituality12"1625&
QQ&Q5&51GQ5555H@
?04&'0&>&.L0B&55"&+R(
0&Group
Processes & Intergroup Relations23G"51652 &
QQ&Q5&GGQ1H 215@ G G