Article

Márta Hargitai Fleance and Obscured Scottish Futures in Screen Adaptations of Macbeth

Authors:
To read the full-text of this research, you can request a copy directly from the author.

Abstract

http://www.serena.unina.it/index.php/anglistica-aion/issue/view/788/762 The play-text of Macbeth enigmatically leaves the future of Scotland open. The play ends with Malcolm hailed as the new king, but the rest of the weird sisters’ predictions, namely that Banquo’s issue will be kings, is left unanswered even though Shakespeare’s main source, Holinshed’s Chronicles (Volume V) (1577) contains a detailed (albeit completely fabricated) sequel as to the future of Fleance. The three Macbeth film adaptations examined here – Rupert Goold (2010), Justin Kurzel (2015) and Joel Coen (2021) – all address this loose end of the play-text, leaving clues for the viewer to predict what might happen after the action of the film is over. By opening a door to the future (often literally and visually, as in Goold and Kurzel), and showing Fleance on the move, they all suggest a linear or cyclical continuation of his story and Scottish history. This article considers key elements of the adaptations, focussing on the show of kings and the endings. I argue that the directorial choices of these films, instead of suppressing the line of Fleance, give voice and prominence to his alternative narrative, while also emphasising the cycle of violence that the play suggests. Keywords: Macbeth, film adaptations, Goold, Kurzel, Coen, Fleance http://www.serena.unina.it/index.php/anglistica-aion

No full-text available

Request Full-text Paper PDF

To read the full-text of this research,
you can request a copy directly from the author.

ResearchGate has not been able to resolve any citations for this publication.
Article
Full-text available
When Roman Polanski's Macbeth hit the screens in 1971, its bloody imagery, pessimism, violence and nudity were often perceived as excessive or at least highly controversial. While the film was initially analysed mostly in relation to Polanski's personal life, his past as a WWII child survivor and the husband of the murdered pregnant wife, Sharon Tate, in retrospect its bleak imagery speaks not only for his unique personal experience but also serves as a powerful comment on the American malaise, fears and paranoia that were triggered, amongst other things, by the brutal act of the Manson Family. We had to wait forty four years for another mainstream adaptation of the play and it is tempting not only to compare Kurzel's Macbeth to its predecessor in terms of how more accepting we have become of graphic depictions of violence on screen but also to ask a more fundamental question: if in future years we were to historicise the new version, what would it tell us about the present moment? The paper proposes that despite its medieval setting and Scottish scenery, the film's visual code seems to transgress any specific time or place. Imbued in mist, its location becomes more fluid and evocative of any barren and sterile landscape that we have come to associate with war. Seen against a larger backdrop of the current political climate with its growing nationalism and radicalism spanning from the Middle East, through Europe to the US, Kurzel's Macbeth with its numerous bold textual interventions and powerful mise-en-scène offers a valid response to the current political crisis. His ultra brutal imagery and the portrayal of children echo Polanski's final assertion of perpetuating violence, only this time, tragically and more pessimistically, with children as not only the victims of war but also its active players.
Book
Deleuze and Guattari discuss the rhizome as being "absolutely different from roots and radicles" 6. The rhizome is explained via principles. 1 and 2: connection and heterogeneity.: "any point of a rhizome can be connected to anything other, and must be". Principle 3: "Principle of multiplicity" "There are no points or positions in a rhizome, such as those found in a structure, tree, or root. There are only lines". Principle 4: "Principle of asignifying rupture" "There is a rupture in the rhizome whenever segmentary lines explode into a line of flight, but the line of flight is part of the rhizome." Principles 5 and 6: Principle of cartography and decalcomania: Where traditional thought is 'tracing', a rhizome is a map. Tracing involves laying onto reality the pattern of structure, itself a construct. "The map does not reproduce an unconscious closed in upon itself; it constructs the unconscious". They take the term plateau from Gregory Bateson, it refers to a sustained intensity. "We call a 'plateau' any multiplicity connected to other multiplicities by superficial underground stems in such a way as to form or extend a rhizome". "Write with slogans: Make rhizomes, not roots, never plant!"
Chapter
These days there is a growing sense among Shakespeareans that our field has arrived at a crossroads. Throughout much of the twentieth century, the dominant preoccupation of academic Shakespeareans was to establish and preserve an “authentic” Shakespeare text. The reigning assumption has been that the source of Shakespeare’s greatness is to be identified with the verbal particularities of his scripts, which we as scholars are obliged to cherish, explicate and place in historical context. The appeal to Shakespeare’s original language, an appeal conducted from a variety of perspectives, has provided Shakespearean scholarship of the last century its distinctive cultural authority. It is no accident that professional Shakespearean scholarship—a peculiarly twentieth-century invention, we should acknowledge—can be traced to the professionalization of Shakespearean editing in the late nineteenth century and the concomitant demotion of biographical criticism’s prestige.1 The critical descent of Shakespeare the man enabled the ascent of Shakespeare the text.
Article
Justin Kurzel’s 2015 film of Macbeth takes the multi-faceted trope of childhood in Shakespeare’s play and turns it into a visual image that permeates the landscape of his film. From the pre-credit sequence, in which the grieving Macbeths are seen burning the body of their dead baby on a funeral pyre, to the closing coda, in which young Fleance returns like an avenging fury to challenge the crown, they provide a crucial interpretative framework for reading this latest cinematic adaptation. It is an interpretation, moreover, that presents the child as a complex and contradictory nexus of hopes, fears and anxieties. Not merely innocent victims, the children of Kurzel’s Macbeth are both pitiful and terrifying. This portrayal of childhood has its roots in a tradition beginning in the last three decades of the twentieth century, when directors focused increasingly on the children in this play. In this paper, I will begin with the last major English-language film of Macbeth by Roman Polanski (1971) and track the dramatic treatment of the children through to Kurzel’s 2015 release, locating the shift in focus within a larger socio-historical context of changing attitudes towards the role and identity of children more generally. By focusing on some landmark English theatre productions staged in the period between the two films, I will demonstrate a general trend away from a sentimentalised depiction of childhood towards a nihilistic vision that heralds the end of the so-called “century of the child”.
Performing the Child Motif
  • Bladen
Bladen, "Performing the Child Motif";
  • Edel Semple
Edel Semple, "'Seeds of Time': Women, Children, and the Nation in Kurzel's Macbeth (2015)", Shakespeare Bulletin, 38.4 (2020), 615-633;
Effigies of Childhood in Kurzel's Macbeth
  • Hanh Bui
and Hanh Bui, "Effigies of Childhood in Kurzel's Macbeth", Literature/Film Quarterly, 48.1 (2020), lfq.salisbury.edu.
The Real Gaze: Film Theory after Lacan (Albany: State U. of New York P
  • Todd Mcgowan
Todd McGowan, The Real Gaze: Film Theory after Lacan (Albany: State U. of New York P., 2007), 6.
The face has fallen back into the depths to be replaced by another that rises to just below the surface
  • Seminar Lacan
  • Xi
Lacan, Seminar XI, 178. 56 "The face has fallen back into the depths to be replaced by another that rises to just below the surface", "This child too sinks back down", "A third child is rising, this one wearing a crown...", Joel Coen, Macbeth: Screenplay (2020), 65-66, deadline.com. 57 Ibid., 66.
Hamlet (Two Cities Films
  • Laurence Olivier
Laurence Olivier, Hamlet (Two Cities Films, 1948).
Throne of Blood: Shakespeare Transposed
  • Stephen Prince
Stephen Prince, "Throne of Blood: Shakespeare Transposed", The Criterion Collection: Film Guides (2014), www.criterion.com.
Off-Modern Hybridity in TV Theatre
  • Huertas-Martín
Huertas-Martín, "Off-Modern Hybridity in TV Theatre", 98.
Macbeth for Our Time
  • Rasmus
Rasmus, "Macbeth for Our Time", 117.