PreprintPDF Available

Effects of Religious Fasting on Markers of Oxidative Status in Vitamin D Deficient and Overweight Orthodox Nuns versus Implementation of Time-Restricted Eating in Lay Women from Central and Northern Greece

Authors:
  • Laboratory of Biological Chemistry
Preprints and early-stage research may not have been peer reviewed yet.

Abstract and Figures

Mediterranean diet has been widely suggested to exert significant beneficial effects on endothelial oxida-tive status and cardiometabolic health. Greek Orthodox monasteries, due to their specific nutritionaland sartorial habits, comprise a population which strictly adheres to nutritional patterns with restricted eating and a plant-based subset of the Mediter-ranean diet, often accompanied by profound hypovitaminosis D. Time –restricted eating is also adopted from a large part of general lay Greek population for health promoting reasons, without restrictions on an-imal product consumption, as imposed by Orthodox religious fasting. However, comparative effects of these nutritional patterns on oxidative stress markers remain scarce. The present study attempted to evaluate the effects of Christian Orthodox fasting (COF) in a group of vitamin D –deficient and overweight Orthodox nuns from Central and Northern Greece, compared to the implementation of TRE, 16:8 dietary regimen in a cohort of adult women from the general population from the same region, with regard to markers of endothelial oxidative status. A group of 50 women from two Orthodox monasteries in Northern Greece and one group of 50 healthy lay women were included. During enrollment a detailed recording of dietary habits was performed, along with a scientific registry of demographic and anthropometric characteristics (via bioimped-ance).Orthodox nuns followed a typical Orthodox fasting regimen[daily feeding window (8 am–4 pm)] whereas lay women followed a TRE 16:8 regimen with the same feeding time-window with recommenda-tion to follow a low-fat diet, without characteristics of the Mediterranean diet. We included a complete biochemical analysis, as well as calciotropic profiles [Calcium-Ca, Albumin, Parathyroid hormone-PTH, 25-hydroxyvitamin D- 25(OH)D] as well as and markers of TAC (trichloroacetic acid), (glutathione) GSH and thiobarbituric acid reactive substances (TBARS) concentrations, as markers of oxidative status. All groups were comparable at baseline for calcium, PTH and 25(OH)D concentrations, with no significant differences between groups. Orthodox nuns manifested a lower median GSH compared to con-trols (6.0 vs. 7.2, p 0.04) and a higher median TAC (0.92 vs. 0.77, p <0.001). TBARS comparisons showed no significant difference between the two groups. No significant associations of oxidative status with 25(OH)D, PTH and markers of glucose homeostasis were evident. Results of this small pilot study indicate that both dietary regimens have advantages over oxidative markers compared to each other, with increased TAC in the groups of Orthodox Nuns after a 16th week period of COF compared to a 16:8 TRE and increased GSH concentrations in the lay women group. Future randomized trials are required to investigate superiority or non-inferiority between these dietary patterns, in the daily clinical setting.
Content may be subject to copyright.
Article Not peer-reviewed version
Effects of Religious Fasting on Markers
of Oxidative Status in Vitamin D
Deficient and Overweight Orthodox
Nuns versus Implementation of Time-
Restricted Eating in Lay Women from
Central and Northern Greece
Spyridon N Karras * , Konstantinos Michalakis , Fotios Tekos , Zoi Skaperda , Periklis Vardakas ,
Panayiotis D Ziakas , Maria Kypraiou , Marios Anemoulis , Antonios Vlastos , Georgios Tzimagiorgis ,
Konstantinos Chaitoglou , Neoklis Georgopoulos , Evangelos G. Papanikolaou , Demetrios Kouretas
Posted Date: 27 August 2024
doi: 10.20944/preprints202408.1910.v1
Keywords: oxidative stress; mediterranean diet; time restricted eating; orthodox fasting
Preprints.org is a free multidiscipline platform providing preprint service that
is dedicated to making early versions of research outputs permanently
available and citable. Preprints posted at Preprints.org appear in Web of
Science, Crossref, Google Scholar, Scilit, Europe PMC.
Copyright: This is an open access article distributed under the Creative Commons
Attribution License which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any
medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
Article
EffectsofReligiousFastingonMarkersofOxidative
StatusinVitaminDDeficientandOverweight
OrthodoxNunsversusImplementationof
TimeRestrictedEatinginLayWomenfromCentral
andNorthernGreece
KarrasSpyridon1,MichalakisKonstantinos2,TekosFotios3,SkaperdaZoi3,PeriklisVardakas3,
ZiakasD.Panayiotis4,KypraiouMaria5,AnemoulisMarios6,VlastosAntonios6,
TzimagiorgisGeorgios1,ChaitoglouKonstantinos1,GeorgopoulosNeoklis7andPapanikolaou
Evangelos5,KouretasDemetrios3
1LaboratoryofBiologicalChemistry,MedicalSchool,AristotleUniversity,55535Thessaloniki,Greece
2EndocrinePractice,DepartmentofObesityandMetabolism,Athens,Greece
3DepartmentofBiochemistryBiotechnology,SchoolofHealthSciences,UniversityofThessaly,
Larissa,Greece
4DepartmentofMedicine,UniversityofBrown,RI,USA
5AssistingNatureCentreofReproductionandGenetics,Thessaloniki,Greece
6MedicalSchool,AristotleUniversity,Thessaloniki,Greece
7DivisionofEndocrinology,DepartmentofInternalMedicine,SchoolofHealthSciences,Universityof
Patras,26504Patras,Greece
Abstract:Mediterraneandiethasbeenwidelysuggestedtoexertsignificantbeneficialeffectson
endothelialoxidativestatusandcardiometabolichealth.GreekOrthodoxmonasteries,duetotheir
specificnutritionalandsartorialhabits,compriseapopulationwhichstrictlyadherestonutritional
patternswithrestrictedeatingandaplantbasedsubsetoftheMediterraneandiet,often
accompaniedbyprofoundhypovitaminosisD.Time–restrictedeatingisalsoadoptedfromalarge
partofgenerallayGreekpopulationforhealthpromotingreasons,withoutrestrictionsonanimal
productconsumption,asimposedbyOrthodoxreligiousfasting.However,comparativeeffectsof
thesenutritionalpatternsonoxidativestressmarkersremainscarce.Thepresentstudyattempted
toevaluatetheeffectsofChristianOrthodoxfasting(COF)inagroupofvitaminD–deficientand
overweightOrthodoxnunsfromCentralandNorthernGreece,comparedtotheimplementationof
TRE,16:8dietaryregimeninacohortofadultwomenfromthegeneralpopulationfromthesame
region,withregardtomarkersofendothelialoxidativestatus.Agroupof50womenfromtwo
OrthodoxmonasteriesinNorthernGreeceandonegroupof50healthylaywomenwereincluded.
Duringenrollmentadetailedrecordingofdietaryhabitswasperformed,alongwithascientific
registryofdemographicandanthropometriccharacteristics(viabioimpedance).Orthodoxnuns
followedatypicalOrthodoxfastingregimen[dailyfeedingwindow(8am–4pm)]whereaslay
womenfollowedaTRE16:8regimenwiththesamefeedingtimewindowwithrecommendation
tofollowalowfatdiet,withoutcharacteristicsoftheMediterraneandiet.Weincludedacomplete
biochemicalanalysis,aswellascalciotropicprofiles[CalciumCa,Albumin,Parathyroidhormone
PTH,25hydroxyvitaminD‐ 25(OH)D]aswellasandmarkersofTAC(trichloroaceticacid),
(glutathione)GSHandthiobarbituricacidreactivesubstances(TBARS)concentrations,asmarkers
ofoxidativestatus.Allgroupswerecomparableatbaselineforcalcium,PTHand25(OH)D
concentrations,withnosignificantdifferencesbetweengroups.Orthodoxnunsmanifestedalower
medianGSHcomparedtocontrols(6.0vs.7.2,p0.04)andahighermedianTAC(0.92vs.0.77,p
<0.001).TBARScomparisonsshowednosignificantdifferencebetweenthetwogroups.No
significantassociationsofoxidativestatuswith25(OH)D,PTHandmarkersofglucosehomeostasis
wereevident.Resultsofthissmallpilotstudyindicatethatbothdietaryregimenshaveadvantages
Disclaimer/Publisher’s Note: The statements, opinions, and data contained in all publications are solely those of the individual author(s) and
contributor(s) and not of MDPI and/or the editor(s). MDPI and/or the editor(s) disclaim responsibility for any injury to people or property resulting
from any ideas, methods, instructions, or products referred to in the content.
Preprints.org (www.preprints.org) | NOT PEER-REVIEWED | Posted: 27 August 2024 doi:10.20944/preprints202408.1910.v1
© 2024 by the author(s). Distributed under a Creative Commons CC BY license.
2
overoxidativemarkerscomparedtoeachother,withincreasedTACinthegroupsofOrthodox
Nunsaftera16thweekperiodofCOFcomparedtoa16:8TREandincreasedGSHconcentrations
inthelaywomengroup.Futurerandomizedtrialsarerequiredtoinvestigatesuperiorityornon
inferioritybetweenthesedietarypatterns,inthedailyclinicalsetting.
Keywords:oxidativestress;Mediterraneandiet;timerestrictedeating;Orthodoxfasting
Introduction
ChristianOrthodoxfasting(COF),isavitalsubsetoftheMediterraneandiet(MD)
[1–4],whichforreligiousreasonsisconsideredtobedeeplyintegratedintheculturaldietary
behaviorofalargepartoftheGreekpopulation[5–9]forprolongedperiods(from120to180d)
annually[8].Orthodoxmonasteriesfollowthisarchetypepatternofdietthroughouttheyear,with
periodsofmorestrictfastingrituals26weeksbeforereligiouscelebrations,asawayofphysicaland
mentalprosperityandpersonalspiritualdevelopment[1,2].However,besidesthespiritual
significanceofCOF,aplethoraofcohortstudiessuggestthatCOFsharesthebeneficialeffectsofthe
typicalMDbypromotingspecificcardioprotectivemechanisms,includingreducedintakeofdietary
cholesterolandfattyacids,thusprovidingoptimaleffectsonplasmalipidconcentrations[9,10].
Thesebenefitshavebeenmainlyattributedtotheintegrationofaplantbaseddietalongwith
characteristicsofdietaryrestrictionofanimalproducts(meat,dairyproductsandeggs)[6]and
restrictionofcaloricintakeduringCOFperiods[11–14].Wehavepreviouslyreportedonthe
beneficialeffectsofCOFontheadipokineprofile[7,8,14]aswellasonglucosehomeostasisinboth
monasticandgeneralpopulations[15],asmarkersforpreventionofcardiovasculardyshomeostasis,
withtheexceptionofprofoundhypovitaminosis—DinOrthodoxMonks,mainlyduetotheir
sartorialhabits[11,16].
Additionally,restrictionoffoodintakeinspecifictime—framesduringtheday,hasalsobeen
hypothesizedtocontributetothebenefitsdescribedabove,acharacteristicwhichattractedsignificant
scientificandpublicinterestduringthelastdecade,throughvariousintermittent—fastingpatterns,
practicedworldwideasahealthpromotingdiet[17].Timerestrictedeating(TRE),includesspecific
timeframesoffoodintakeduringtheday,whichvaryfrom412hoursdaily[e.g.,20hoursoffasting
vs4hoursofpermittedfoodintake—20:4—aswellasadditionaltimeframes(18:6,16:8etc.)][18].On
theotherhand,impairmentofantioxidativecapacityofvascularendotheliumisanestablished
aggravatingfactorfordevelopmentofendothelialdysfunctionandfuturecardiovascularmajor
events[19,20].Onthatbasis,aconsiderablenumberofpreviousstudies[21–24]havesuggestedthat
MDisstronglyassociatedwithfavorableeffectsonoxidativestatus,implyingapotentialpathway
forexertingitswell—establishedcardiovascularbenefits.However,resultsonCOFasavitalsubset
ofMDanditseffectsonoxidativestatus,particularlycomparedtootherhealthynutritionalpatterns
widelyadoptedbythegeneralpopulation,remainscarce.
Additionally,thesepotentialinteractionshavesofarnotbeeninvestigatedinconjunctionwith
othermetabolicconditionsassociatedwithendothelialdysfunction,includingimpairmentofvitamin
Dstatusandinsulinresistance,particularlyinvitaminDdeficientandoverweightindividuals.These
resultscouldelucidatepotentialmechanismsofMD—relatedeffectsonantioxidativecapacityand
alsoelaborateontheresearchhypothesis,whichindicatesthemacro‐andmicronutrientsynthesis
andincreasedintakeoffoodantioxidants,ratherthanthetimingoffoodintake,asthecornerstoneof
attainedmetabolicbenefits.
ThepresentstudyattemptedtoevaluatetheeffectsofCOFinagroupofvitaminD–deficient
andoverweightOrthodoxnunsfromCentralandNorthernGreece,comparedtotheimplementation
ofTRE16:8dietaryregimeninacohortofadultwomenfromthegeneralpopulationfromthesame
region,withregardtomarkersofendothelialoxidativestatus.
Preprints.org (www.preprints.org) | NOT PEER-REVIEWED | Posted: 27 August 2024 doi:10.20944/preprints202408.1910.v1
3
Methods
Design
Thiswasacrosssectionalstudyafteraperiodof16weekimplementationofCOFandTRE,in
twogroupsofadultfemalenunsandlaywomen.
StudyPopulation
Weincluded50ChristianOrthodoxfemaleadultnuns,fromtwodifferentmonasteries,30–50
yearsofage,residingintheCentralandNorthernGreeceandanage—matchedcohortof50adult
laywomenfromthesameregion.
Orthodoxnuns(butnotlaywomen),withabaseline25hydroxyvitaminDconcentrations≥20
ng/ml(asinitiallyevaluatedfromthesameinitialcohort–resultspublishedpreviously[12–15])were
excluded.Additionalexclusioncriteriaforbothgroupswere:bodymassindex(BMI)≤ 25,
amenorrhea≥3months,pregnancy,presenceofchronickidneydisease,severeliverdisease,
diagnosisofprediabetes(fastingglucose100–125mg/dLorglycatedhemoglobin5.7–6.4%orblood
glucose140–199mg/dLat2hpost75gglucoseload)ordiabetesmellitus(fastingglucose≥126mg/dL
orglycatedhemoglobin≥6.5%orbloodglucose≥200mg/dLat2hpost75gglucoseload),
dyslipidemia,arterialhypertension,oruncontrolledhypothyroidism(notadequatelycontrolledor
firstdiagnosedandnottreated),(recentsurgeryorsevereinfections(duringthepast3months),
administrationofmedicationsthatcanalterbodyweight,glucoseandlipidmetabolism(e.g.,statins,
corticosteroids,antipsychotics),intakeofvitaminsormineralsupplements,physicaldisabilities
and/orneurodegenerativedisordersthatcouldaffectphysicalactivity,acuteinfectionsandchronic
degenerativediseases.
DietaryPatterns
Orthodoxnunswithatleast16weeksadherencetoCOFwereincludedinthestudy,whereas
womenfromthegeneralpopulation,followedTREfor16weeks,afterawashoutperiodof3weeks,
beforeinclusioninthestudy.OrthodoxnunsfollowedtheAthoniantypeoffastingaspreviously
described[1–4],abstainingfromconsumptionofanimalproducts(meat,poultry,eggs,dairyand
cheese),withtheexceptionofseafoodandfish,whichfasterswerepermittedtoeatontwospecific
weekdays,whilethegeneralpopulationgroupwasallowedtoeatlowfatmeatproducts,without
specificdistributionandcutoffsofmacronutrientsanddailycaloricintake.
Orthodoxnunsgroupadoptedan8heatinginterval(08.00to16.00),asdictatedbytypical
monasterydietaryrules,whichareobligatoryforallresidentsofthemonastery,whileTREgroup
consumedfoodfrom09:00to17:00.Adherencetodietaryplanswasevaluatedwitha3dayfood
record(twoweekdaysandoneweekendday)attheendofthestudyperiod,whiletheNutrition
AnalysisSoftwareFoodProcessor[https://esha.com/products/food‐processor/(accessedon2August
2024)][25]wasusedtoanalyzefoodrecords.Finally,levels,frequencyanddurationofphysical
activity,dividedinlight,moderateandintensephysicalactivity,wererecordedforallparticipants,
accordingtoAHArecommendations[26].
AnthropometricMeasurementsandBiochemicalAnalysis
Anthropometricmeasurementsandbiochemicalanalyseswereperformedinbothgroupsusing
standardizedprocedures.Exactmethods,referenceranges,equipmentused,andotherdetailswere
previouslyanalyticallydescribed[11].Inbrief,bodyweight(BW)wasrecordedtothenearest0.01kg
usingacalibratedcomputerizeddigitalbalance(KTronP1SR,OnrionLLC,Bergenfield,NJ,USA);
eachparticipantwasbarefootandlightlydressedduringmeasurement.BMIwascalculatedasthe
ratioofweightinkilogramsdividedbytheheightinmeterssquared(kg/m2)[27].Bodyfat(BF)mass
andpercentage,visceralfat(VF),musclemass,fatfreemass,andtotalbodywaterweremeasured
usingbioelectricalimpedanceanalysis(SC330S,TanitaCorporation,Tokyo)[28].Bloodsamples
weredrawninthemorning,aftera12hovernightfastbyantecubitalvenipuncture,andthesamples
werestoredat20oCpriortoanalysis.Calcium(Ca)concentrationswereevaluatedusingthe
Preprints.org (www.preprints.org) | NOT PEER-REVIEWED | Posted: 27 August 2024 doi:10.20944/preprints202408.1910.v1
4
COBAS8000automatedanalyzersystem(RocheDiagnosticsGmbH,D68298Mannheim,Germany).
Parathyroidhormone(PTH)and25(OH)D,weretestedintheCOBASe602immunochemistry
moduleusingelectrochemiluminescence(ECL)technology(RocheDiagnosticsGmbH,D68298
Mannheim,Germany).Referencerangesofvaluesaswellasinter‐ andintraassaycoefficientsof
variationfortheexaminedparametersareasfollows:Ca:8.4–10.2mg/dl,0.8–1.3%and0.5–1.3%;PTH:
15–65pg/mL(or1.6–6.9pmol/L),1.1–2.0%and2.5–3.4%;25(OH)D:≥30ng/mL,2.2–6.8%and3.4–
13.1%.Insulinresistancewascalculatedusingthehomeostasismodelassessment(HOMAIR)
formuladescribedbyMatthewsetal.[29]asfollows:FPI(mU/mL)xFPG(mmol/L)/22.5,whereFPI
standsforfastingplasmainsulinandFPGforfastingplasmaglucose.
MarkersofOxidativeStatus
DeterminationofGlutathione(GSH)ConcentrationinBlood
GSHconcentrationwasdeterminedaccordingtothemethodofReddyetal.[30]aspreviously
described[31].Atfirst,400μLofRBCLwasmixedwith400μLof5%trichloroaceticacid(TCA),
respectively,andcentrifuged(15,00×g,5min,5°C).Afterwards,300μLofthesupernatantwasmixed
with90μLof5%TCAandcentrifuged(15,00×g,5min,5°C).Theresultingsupernatantwascollected
andusedasthebiologicalsamplefortheassay.Regardingtheassay,20μLofthebiological
samplewasmixedwith660μLofphosphatebuffer(67mM,pH=7.95)and330μLof5,5dithiobis(2
nitrobenzoicacid)(DTNB)(1mM).Thesampleswerevortexedandincubatedfor45mininthedark
atroomtemperature(RT),andtheopticaldensitywasmeasuredat412nm.GSHconcentrationwas
calculatedbasedonthemillimolarextinctioncoefficientof2nitro5thiobenzoate(TNB)(13.6
L/mmol/cm).
DeterminationofTotalAntioxidantCapacity(TAC)ConcentrationsinBlood
TAClevelswereevaluatedbasedontheprotocolofJanaszewskaandBartosz[32].More
elaborately,20μLofplasmawasmixedwith480μLor460μLofphosphatebuffer(10mM,pH=7.4),
respectively,and,immediately,500μLof2,2diphenyl1picrylhydrazylradical(DPPH)solution
(0.1mM)wasadded.Thesampleswerevortexed,incubatedfor1hinthedarkatRT,andcentrifuged
(15,00×g,3min,25°C).Finally,theopticaldensitywasmeasuredat520nm.TAClevelswere
expressedasthemmolofDPPHreducedtothecorrespondinghydrazinebytheantioxidant
compoundspresentinplasmaortissuehomogenates.
DeterminationofThiobarbituricacidReactiveSubstances(TBARS)ConcentrationsinBlood
TBARSlevelsweredeterminedbyaslightlymodifiedmethodbyKelesetal.[33].Specifically,
100μLofplasmawasmixedwith500μLofTrisHCl(200mM,pH=7.4)and500μLof35%TCAand
incubatedfor10minatRT.Afterthat,1mLofsodiumsulfate(Na2SO4)(2M)andthiobarbituricacid
(TBA)(55mM)solutionwasadded,andthesampleswereplacedinawaterbathfor45minat95°C.
Afterincubation,thesampleswerecooledonicefor5min,1mLof70%TCAwasadded,andthe
sampleswerecentrifuged(11,20×g,3min,25°C).Theresultingsupernatantwasusedtomeasurethe
opticaldensityat530nm.TBARSlevelswerecalculatedbyapplyingthemolarextinctioncoefficient
ofmalonyldialdehyde(ΜDA)(156,000L/mol/cm).
DeterminationofGSHConcentrationinBlood
EthicalConsiderations
ThestudywasconductedinaccordancewiththeDeclarationofHelsinkionthehumantrial
performance.Writteninformedconsentforinclusioninthestudywasgivenbyparticipants.Official
writtenapprovalfortheinclusionoftheOrthodoxnunsgroupwasgivenbytheHolySupervision
Councilofthemonasteries,aftersubmissionofthefullstudyprotocol12monthsbeforestudy
initiation.
Preprints.org (www.preprints.org) | NOT PEER-REVIEWED | Posted: 27 August 2024 doi:10.20944/preprints202408.1910.v1
5
StatisticalAnalysis
ContinuousvariablesarereportedasmeansandS.D.’s.Dietaryandnutrientintakeonwere
comparedusingpairedsamplesttest.Agedifferencesbetweenthegroupswithlight,moderateand
intensephysicalactivityweretestedusingonewayanalysisofvariancewithTukeyposthoctest.
Theeffectoflevelofphysicalactivityonoverallhealthmarkerswastestedwithanalysisofcovariance
tocontrolforage.NormalityofdistributionwastestedwithonesampleKolmogorov–Smirnovtest
(exactstatistics).
TheamonggroupcomparisonwasmadeusingnonparametricMannWhitneyUtest.Linear
regressionwasusedformultiadjustedanalysis.Assumptionswerecheckedforeachstatistical
analysis.LevelofsignificancewassetatP<0.05(nondirectional).DatawereanalyzedusingSPSS
v22.
Results
Orthodoxnunswereolderthanlaywomen(medianage42vs.38,p<0.001)butdidnotdifferin
medianweightandBMI(Table1).Groupsdidnotdifferinbodyfat(%),leanbodymass(%)andwaist
circumference,aswellasdegreesofphysicalactivity,withtheexceptionofintenseactivity,inwhich
laywomenreportedhigherrates.Regardingnutritionalanalysis,laywomenconsumedhigher
amountsofcarbohydrates(gr)(194.3±23.4vs159.6±21.8),totalandsaturatedfat(24.4±0.6vs21.0±
0.1and16.4±0.0and12.7±0.0,respectively)whereasOrthodoxnunsreportedhigheramountsof
proteinandfibreintake(36.1±0.8vs24.2±0.8).
Althoughexpected,accordingtothestudyprotocol,hypovitaminosisDevidentintheOrthodox
nuns’group,resultedinsignificantlyhighermedianserumPTHthanamonglaywomen(45.6vs.
19.4,p<.001),afteradjustingforseasonalvariation.Inaddition,afteradjustingforageand25(OH)D3
concentrationsinlinearregressionacrossallpatients,PTHhadasignificantpositiveassociationwith
age(+6.0pg/mlper10yearincreaseinage,p<0.001)andasignificantnegativeassociationwithserum
25(OH)D3status(–0.61pg/mlperng/mlincreaseinserumD3).Orthodoxnunsdemonstratedlower
medianfastinginsulinconcentrations(5.3vs.7.2,p0.02)comparedtolaywomenandevenafter
adjustingforageandBMI,thedifferenceremainedsignificant;Ofmajorinterestisthefact,that
insulinconcentrationslackedasignificantassociationwithBMIorageinbothgroups.Regarding
redoxstatus,OrthodoxnunsmanifestedalowermedianGSHcomparedtocontrols(6.0vs.7.2,p.04)
andahighermedianTAC(0.92vs.0.77,p<.001).TBARScomparisonsshowednosignificant
differencebetweenthetwogroups.Afteradjustingforageinlinearregression,Orthodoxnunshad
alowerGSHconcentrationinserum(meandifference‐1.7;95%CI‐2.7to=–0.7,p.001)comparedto
controls,whiletheageeffectwasnotsignificant(p=0.45).Afteradjustingforage,nunshadahigher
TACconcentrationinserum(meandifference0.19;95%CI0.13to0.26,p<.001),whereasafter
adjustingforage,BMIandtotalfatinlinearregression,nunshadalowerGSHconcentrationinserum
(meandifference–1.6;95%significant(p=0.45).Afteradjustingforage,nunshadahigherTAC
concentrationinserum(meandifference0.19;95%CI0.13to0.26,p<.001),whereasafteradjustingfor
age,BMIandtotalfatinlinearregression,nunshadalowerGSHconcentrationinserum(mean
difference–1.6;95%CI–2.6to=–0.7,p.001)comparedtolaywomen,whiletheageandBMIeffects
werenotsignificant.AfteradjustingforageandBMI,nunshadahigherTACconcentrationinserum
(meandifference0.21;95%CI0.15to0.27p<.001);age,BMIandtotalfat,effectswerenotsignificant.
Nosignificantassociationsofoxidativestatuswith25(OH)D,PTHandmarkersofglucose
homeostasiswereevident.
Table1.
Orthodoxnuns(n=50)Laywomen(n=50)p
Demographics
Age(years)42(3650)38(3442)0.03
Wei ght(kg)71.5(6482)66(6087)0.31
BMI(kg/m2)27.0(24.229.0)26.8(22.032.0)0.19
Preprints.org (www.preprints.org) | NOT PEER-REVIEWED | Posted: 27 August 2024 doi:10.20944/preprints202408.1910.v1
6
Bodyfat(%)24.5±9.422.1±8.10.23
Leanbodymass
(%)39.9±6.341.2±7.10.15
Wai s t
circumference
(cm)
92.489.10.11
Physicalactivity
LightN=9N=70.31
ModerateN=27N=250.48
IntenseN=14N=180.03
Yea r s of
monasticism10.5±9.8‐‐
Deaconshipof
OrthodoxNuns
Baker(3);Botanist(2);Cook(5);Cookingassistant(5);Diningassistant(5);
Ecclesiasticalchanter(6);Gardener(3);Housekeeper(3);Iconographer(6);
Laundryassistant(4);Pharmacist(2);
Table2.
Energy(kcal)1565.9±64.51890.0±71.0<0.01
Carbohydrates(g)159.6±21.8194.3±23.40.03
Protein(g)89.2±1.372.3±1.30.04
Dailyfatintake(g)21.0±0.124.4±0.60.02
Dailysaturatedfatintake(g)12.7±0.016.4±0.00.01
Totalfibreintake(g)36.1±0.824.2±0.80.02
25hydroxyvitaminD3(ng/Ml)15.7(11.419.8)26.1(18.231.9)0.02
PTH(pg/ml)45.6(39.654.7)19.4(13.128.5)<0.001
Calcium(mg/dl)9.4(9.19.7)9.1(8.89.3)0.15
Insulin(IU/L)5.3(3.46.7)7.1(4.711)0.02
Fastingglucose(mg/dl)84.4±10.189.2±9.70.43
HOMAIR1.02±0.41.26±0.70.21
Oxidativestatus
TAC0.93(0.870.99)0.77(0.650.90)<.001
GSH6.0(4.46.8)7.2(5.58.8)0.04
TBARS7.3(5.88.3)7.6(6.98.4)0.28
Figure1.ConcentrationsofTACinOrthodoxNunsandlaywomengroup.
Preprints.org (www.preprints.org) | NOT PEER-REVIEWED | Posted: 27 August 2024 doi:10.20944/preprints202408.1910.v1
7
Figure2.ConcentrationsofGSHinOrthodoxNunsandlaywomengroup.
Discussion
Toourknowledge,thisthefirstcrosssectionalstudyreportingpreliminaryresultsonthe
comparativeeffectsofCOFonoxidativestatusinvitaminDdeficientGreekOrthodoxnunsandTRE
(16:8)dietaryregimeninagroupoflaywomenwithvitaminDsufficiency.Theseresultsindicated:
i)increasedantioxidativecapacity(TAC)inthegroupofOrthodoxNunsaftera16weekperiodof
COFcomparedtoa16:8TRE,ii)increasedGSHlevelsinthelaywomengroupcomparedtothegroup
ofOrthodoxnunsaswellascomparableofTBARSlevelsinbothgroups,afteradjustingforseveral
confounders,whichsuggestpotentialdiverseeffectsofCOFandTREonoxidativestatus.
MDisaplantbaseddiet,richinfruit,vegetables,nuts,herbs,withfewerfishanddairyproducts
andwithlessredmeatandredwine.MDincludesvariousnutritionalcompounds,withwell
establishedbeneficialeffectsonoxidativestatus.Aplethoraofpreviousbasicandclinicalstudies
suggestedthatMDhasbeenshowntobeoneofthehealthiesteatingpatterns,withvariousmetabolic
benefits,partlymediatedthroughitsantioxidantcapacity[34,35].Daietal.studiedtheratioof
reducedtooxidizedglutathione(GSH/GSSG)intwins.Thehighertheratio,thelowertheoxidative
stress,givingaresultofahigherratioupto7%inindividualswhofollowedtheMediterraneandiet,
regardlessoftheadjustmentoftheenergyintake[36].InasubcohortofThePREDIMEDtrial,
participantswithhighcardiovascularriskwererandomizedtoaMediterraneandietsupplemented
withextravirginoliveoilandmanifestedasignificantreductionincellularlipidlevelsandlipid
oxidation,aswellasmalondialdehydeconcentrationsinmononuclearcells,withoutchangesin
serumglutathioneperoxidaseactivity[37].
DocumentedbenefitsofMDincludeconsumptionofunsaturatedfattyacids,foundinoliveoil,
whichcontain3,3dimethyl1butanol,thuspreventingtheformationoftrimethylamine1oxide,one
oftheoxidantsrelatedtocardiovascularevents[38,39].
Additionally,MDsynthesisisrichinoleicacidandalphalinoleicacid,foundinnuts,fruitand
vegetableflavonoids,aswellasomega3polyunsaturatedfattyacids,andfiberandpolyphenols,all
ofwhichhaveantioxidative,antibacterialandantiinflammatoryeffects[40–42].Moreover,whole
grains,asavitalcompoundofMD,containapolyaminecalledspermidine,whichhasbeenshownto
extendchronologicallifespaninflies,nematodes,rodents,andhumancells.Spermidineisknownto
inhibithistoneacetyltransferases,whichresultsinhigherresistancetooxidativestress[43].
TREhasbeenalsotheobjectiveofrecentstudiesregardingitspotentialbeneficialeffectson
cardiometabolichealth.Giventhefactthathormonesundergoacircadianrhythm,metabolicand
stresshormonesasinsulin,cortisol,growthhormoneandmelatoninundergothesamevariation,
givingdifferentlevelsbetweenacalorierestrictingdietandintermittentfastingdiet,whichrestricts
thefeedingtimeincertainhours[44].McAllisteretal.studiedtheimpactofintermittentfastingon
markersofcardiometabolichealth,measuringseveralmarkersofinflammation,OS,and
cardiometabolichealth(insulin,ghrelin,leptin,glucagon,adiponectin,resistin,advancedglycated
Preprints.org (www.preprints.org) | NOT PEER-REVIEWED | Posted: 27 August 2024 doi:10.20944/preprints202408.1910.v1
8
endproducts(AGE),advancedoxidationproteinproducts,totalnitritenitratelevels,tumornecrosis
factor‐α,interleukin(IL)6,IL8,IL10andshowedthattimerestrictedfeedingresultedinsignificant
reductionsinadvancedoxidationproteinproducts(31%)andAGEs(25%);however,noother
changeswerefound[45].Recentrandomizedclinicaltrialsalsodemonstratedthata6hrfeeding
periodfor5weeksimprovedinsulinsensitivity,βcellresponsivenessandoxidativestress,
irrespectiveofweightloss[46].Theseresultswerealsopreviouslyconfirmedbyother
groups,where4‐and6hTREfor5weeks,resultedinareductionof8isoprostane,asamarkerof
oxidativestresstolipids,4hydroxynonenaladducts,proteincarbonylsandnitrotyrosine[47].
COFisaplantbasedsubsetofthetraditionalMDfollowedformorethanathousandyearsfrom
alargepartoftheGreekOrthodoxgeneralpopulationforreligiouspurposesfrom90–150daysper
year.GreekOrthodoxmonasteriesadheretothisdietaryregimenthroughouttheyear,withthe
additionofTRE(usually16:8)characteristicsintheirdailydietaryregimen,whichisstrictlyfollowed
byallmembersofthemonasterialcommunity,comprisinganoptimalsamplefornutritionalstudies
.WehaverepeatedlyreportedontheeffectsonCOFonbodyweight,lipidparameters,adipokines
andvitaminDstatus,regardingtheexistenceofseverehypovitaminosisDinOrthodoxmalemonks,
mainlyduetotheirsartorialhabits.
However,thisisthefirstreportontheeffectsofCOFonoxidativeequilibrium,particularly
comparedtoahealth–promotingpatternlikeTRE.
OurresearchhypothesisraisedthequestionfornoninferiorityofTREcomparedtoCOF,ina
vitaminDdeficientmonasticpopulation(asmostsimilarmonasticcommunitiesinGreece),taking
intoaccountthatwomenincludedintheTRE,werenotinstructedtofollowaMD—specificdietary
pattern.Accordingtopreviousresults,chronicvitaminDdeficiencyisastateofincreasedoxidative
stress,whichreducesthecapacityofmitochondrialrespiration,throughmodulatingnuclearmRNA
downregulatingtheexpressionofcomplexIoftheelectrontransportchain,reducingofadenosine
triphosphate(ATP),resultinginincreasedformationofROS,augmentingoxidativestress[48].
Maintainingoptimumlevelsofredoxbiomarkersiscrucialforpreventingoxidativedamage,
supportingdetoxificationprocesses,andensuringproperimmunefunction.Previousliterature
proposedthatclusteringofhighandlowGSHlevelsmightprovidestrongcausalityfortype2
diabetesandmetabolicsyndrome[48].OurresultsfailedtosuggestasuperiorityofCOFoverTRE,
inagroupwithconfirmedMDtypedietaryregimenandTREcharacteristicsasOrthodoxnuns,
comparedtoa16:8withoutspecificMD—relateddietarycharacteristics.
AplausibleexplanationcouldbethatthegeneralpopulationfollowingaTREpatterncomply
withahealthydietarypattern,whichdespitenotbeingidenticaltoMD,alsoexertsbenefitsonGSH
concentrations,alwaystakingintoaccountthelimitationsofthisstudy.Anotherexplanation,could
lieonthepotentialadverseeffectsofhypovitaminosisD,evidentinOrthodoxnunsincludedinthis
study,onGSHconcentrations,aspreviouslyreported[12].VitaminDsupplementationinthisgroup
ofvitaminDdeficientnunscouldelucidatethispotentialbiologicalassociationonGSHstatus.TRE
couldalsohaveindependentbeneficialeffectsonoxidativestatus,whichareevidentwithoutstrict
adherencetoaMDrelatedpattern,aspreviouslyreported[12].Finally,ourstudyfailedtoestablish
anassociationofimpairedvitaminDstatusandoxidativemarkers,whichcouldbeattributedtoits
crosssectionaldesign.Thisstudyhasseverallimitationsandcanonlybeconsideredasapilotstudy,
withfindingswhichdefinitelyrequireconfirmationinaprospectivestudy.
Indetail,thenumberofincludedparticipantswasrelativelysmall;however,thisisa
representativesampleofOrthodoxnuns,accordingtotheirdietaryandphysicalactivityplan.We
havealsonotincludedadetailedanalysisregardingtheintakeofthedietaryantioxidativesinthe
twogroups,whichcouldexplaindiversityinmarkersofoxidativestatus.Finally,sincenobaseline
evaluation,priortotheimplementationofdietaryinterventions,wasfeasibleforbothgroups,we
wereunabletoestablishcausalassociations.
Inconclusion,resultsofthissmallpilotstudyindicatethatbothdietaryregimenshave
advantagesoveroxidativemarkers,comparedtoeachother,withincreasedTACinthegroupsof
OrthodoxNunsaftera16thweekperiodofCOFincomparisontoincreasedGSHconcentrationsin
thelaywomengroupfollowing16:8TRE,andcomparableconcentrationsofTBARS.Future
Preprints.org (www.preprints.org) | NOT PEER-REVIEWED | Posted: 27 August 2024 doi:10.20944/preprints202408.1910.v1
9
randomizedtrialsarerequiredtoinvestigatesuperiorityornoninferioritybetweenthesedietary
patterns,inthedailyclinicalsetting.
References
1. Trepanowski,J.F.;Bloomer,R.J.Theimpactofreligiousfastingonhumanhealth.Nutr.J.2010,9,57.
2. Sarri,K.O.;Linardakis,M.K.;Bervanaki,F.N.;Tzanakis,N.E.;Kafatos,A.G.GreekOrthodoxfastingrituals:
AhiddencharacteristicoftheMediterraneandietofCrete.Br.J.Nutr.2004,92,277–284.
3. Sarri,K.O.;Tzanakis,N.E.;Linardakis,M.K.;Mamalakis,G.D.;Kafatos,A.G.EffectsofGreekOrthodox
ChristianChurchfastingonserumlipidsandobesity.BMCPublicHealth2003,3,16.
4. Sarri,K.;Linardakis,M.;Codrington,C.;Kafatos,A.DoestheperiodicvegetarianismofGreekOrthodox
Christiansbenefitbloodpressure?Prev.Med.2007,44,341–348.
5. Karras,S.N.;Koufakis,T.;Adamidou,L.;Antonopoulou,V.;Karalazou,P.;Thisiadou,K.;Mitrofanova,E.;
Mulrooney,H.;Petróczi,A.;Zebekakis,P.;etal.Effectsoforthodoxreligiousfastingversuscombined
energyandtimerestrictedeatingonbodyweight,lipidconcentrationsandglycaemicprofile.Int.J.Food
Sci.Nutr.2021,72,82–92.
6. Karras,S.N.;Koufakis,T.;Adamidou,L.;Polyzos,S.A.;Karalazou,P.;Thisiadou,K.;Zebekakis,P.;
Makedou,K.;Kotsa,K.Similarlateeffectsofa7weekorthodoxreligiousfastingandatimerestricted
eatingpatternonanthropometricandmetabolicprofilesofoverweightadults.Int.J.FoodSci.Nutr.2021,
72,248–258.
7. Karras,S.N.;Koufakis,T.;Adamidou,L.;Dimakopoulos,G.;Karalazou,P.;Thisiadou,K.;Makedou,K.;
Kotsa,K.EffectsofChristianOrthodoxFastingVersusTimeRestrictedEatingonPlasmaIrisin
ConcentrationsamongOverweightMetabolicallyHealthyIndividuals.Nutrients2021,13,1071.
8. Karras,S.N.;Koufakis,T.;Adamidou,L.;Dimakopoulos,G.;Karalazou,P.;Thisiadou,K.;Makedou,K.;
Zebekakis,P.;Kotsa,K.ImplementationofChristianOrthodoxfastingimprovesplasmaadiponectin
concentrationscomparedwithtimerestrictedeatinginoverweightpremenopausalwomen.Int.J.Food
Sci.Nutr.2022,73,210–220.
9. Azzeh,F.S.;Hasanain,D.M.;Qadhi,A.H.;Ghafouri,K.J.;Azhar,W.F.;Ghaith,M.M.;Aldairi,A.F.;
Almasmoum,H.A.;Assaggaf,H.M.;Alhussain,M.H.;etal.ConsumptionofFoodComponentsofthe
MediterraneanDietDecreasestheRiskofBreastCancerintheMakkahRegion,SaudiArabia:ACase
ControlStudy.Front.Nutr.2022,9,863029.
10. Trichopoulou,A.;Vasilopoulou,E.;Georga,K.Macro‐andmicronutrientsinatraditionalGreekmenu.
Forum.Nutr.2005,57,135–146.
11. Karras,S.N.;Koufakis,T.;Petróczi,A.;Folkerts,D.;Kypraiou,M.;Mulrooney,H.;Naughton,D.P.;
Persynaki,A.;Zebekakis,P.;Skoutas,D.;etal.ChristianOrthodoxfastinginpractice:Acomparative
evaluationbetweenGreekOrthodoxgeneralpopulationfastersandAthonianmonks.Nutrition2019,59,
69–76.
12. Karras,S.N.;Persynaki,A.;Petróczi,A.;Barkans,E.;Mulrooney,H.;Kypraiou,M.;Tzotzas,T.;Tziomalos,
K.;Kotsa,K.;Tsioudas,A.;etal.HealthbenefitsandconsequencesoftheEasternOrthodoxfastingin
monksofMountAthos:Acrosssectionalstudy.Eur.J.Clin.Nutr.2017,71,743–749.
13. 13Karras,S.N.;Koufakis,T.;Adamidou,L.;Dimakopoulos,G.;Karalazou,P.;Thisiadou,K.;Zebekakis,P.;
Makedou,K.;Kotsa,K.Differentpatternsofchangesinfree25hydroxyvitaminDconcentrationsduring
intermittentfastingamongmeateatersandnonmeateatersandcorrelationswithaminoacidintake.Int.
J.FoodSci.Nutr.2023,74,257–267.
14. KarrasSN,KoufakisT,PopovicDS,AdamidouL,KaralazouP,ThisiadouK,ZebekakisP,MakedouK,
KotsaK.Nutrients.2023Dec9;15(24):5058.doi:10.3390/nu15245058AMediterraneanEatingPattern
CombiningEnergyandTimeRestrictedEatingImprovesVaspinandOmentinConcentrationsCompared
toIntermittentFastinginOverweightIndividuals.
15. KarrasSN,KoufakisT,DimakopoulosG,PopovicDS,KotsaK.Changesindietaryintakeofasparticacid
duringandafterintermittentfastingcorrelatewithanimprovementinfastingglucoseinoverweight
individuals.JDiabetes.2023Feb;15(2):181184.doi:10.1111/17530407.13351.CrossRef]
16. KarrasSN,APersynaki,APetróczi,EBarkans,HMulrooney,MKypraiou1,TTzotzas,KTziomalos,K
Kotsa,ATsioudas,CPichard,DPNaughtonHealthbenefitsandconsequencesoftheEasternOrthodox
fastinginmonksofMountAthos:acrosssectionalstudyEurJClinNutr.2017Jun;71(6):743749.doi:
10.1038/ejcn.2017.26.Epub2017Mar22.
17. ManoogianENC,LaferrèreBTimerestrictedeating:Whatweknowandwherethefieldisgoing..Obesity
(SilverSpring).2023Feb;31Suppl1(Suppl1):78.doi:10.1002/oby.23672.
18. KoppoldDA,BreinlingerC,HanslianE,KesslerC,CramerH,KhokharAR,PetersonCM,TinsleyG,
VernieriC,BloomerRJ,BoschmannM,BragazziNL,BrandhorstS,GabelK,GoldhamerAC,Grajower
MM,HarvieM,HeilbronnL,HorneBD,KarrasSN,LanghorstJ,LischkaE,MadeoF,MitchellSJ,
PapagiannopoulosVatopaidinosIE,PapagiannopoulouM,PijlH,RavussinE,RitzmannWidderichM,
Preprints.org (www.preprints.org) | NOT PEER-REVIEWED | Posted: 27 August 2024 doi:10.20944/preprints202408.1910.v1
10
VaradyK,AdamidouL,ChihaouiM,deCaboR,HassaneinM,LessanN,LongoV,ManoogianENC,
MattsonMP,MuhlesteinJB,PandaS,PapadopoulouSK,RodopaiosNE,StangeR,Michalsen
A.Internationalconsensusonfastingterminology.CellMetab.2024Aug6;36(8):17791794.e4.doi:
10.1016/j.cmet.2024.06.013.Epub2024Jul25.
19. WangX,HeB.Endothelialdysfunction:molecularmechanismsandclinicalimplications.MedComm
(2020).2024Jul22;5(8):e651.doi:10.1002/mco2.651.eCollection2024Aug.
20. SharebianiH,MokaramM,MirghaniM,FazeliB,StanekA.TheEffectsofAntioxidantSupplementation
onthePathologicMechanismsofMetabolicSyndromeandCardiovascularDisease
Development..Nutrients.2024May27;16(11):1641.doi:10.3390/nu16111641.
21. DobroslavskaP,SilvaML,VicenteF,PereiraPMediterraneanDietaryPatternforHealthyandActive
Aging:ANarrativeReviewofanIntegrativeandSustainableApproach.Nutrients.2024May
31;16(11):1725.doi:10.3390/nu16111725.
22. RezigL,GhzaielI,KsilaM,YammineA,NuryT,ZarroukA,SamadiM,ChouaibiM,VejuxA,LizardG
CytoprotectiveactivitiesofrepresentativenutrientsfromtheMediterraneandietandofMediterraneanoils
against7ketocholesterol‐and7betahydroxycholesterolinducedcytotoxicity:Applicationtoagerelated
diseasesandcivilizationdiseases..Steroids.2022Nov;187:109093.doi:10.1016/j.steroids.2022.109093.Epub
2022Aug24.
23. KhalilM,ShanmugamH,AbdallahH,JohnBrittoJS,GaleratiI,GómezAmbrosiJ,FrühbeckG,Portincasa
PThePotentialoftheMediterraneanDiettoImproveMitochondrialFunctioninExperimentalModelsof
ObesityandMetabolicSyndrome..Nutrients.2022Jul28;14(15):3112.doi:10.3390/nu14153112.
24. OliveiraJS,daSilvaJA,deFreitasBVM,AlfenasRCG,BressanJ.AMediterraneandietimprovesglycation
markersinhealthypeopleandinthosewithchronicdiseases:asystematicreviewofclinicaltrials.Nutr
Rev.2024May8:nuae045.doi:10.1093/nutrit/nuae045.Onlineaheadofprint.
25. GreekNationalDietaryGuidelinesforAdults.Availableonline:
http://www.fao.org/nutrition/education/food‐ dietary‐ guidelines/regions/countries/greece/en/(accessed
on25July2024).
26. Jensen,M.D.;Ryan,D.H.;Apovian,C.M.;Ard,J.D.;Comuzzie,A.G.;Donato,K.A.;Hu,F.B.;Hubbard,V.S.;
Jakicic,J.M.;Kushner,R.F.;etal.2013AHA/ACC/TOSguidelineforthemanagementofoverweightand
obesityinadults:AreportoftheAmericanCollegeofCardiology/AmericanHeartAssociationTaskForce
onPracticeGuidelinesandTheObesitySociety.Circulation2014,129,S102–S138.
27. WHO.Globaldatabaseonbodymassindex.AccessedFebruary5,2016.Avail‐ ableat:
www.who.int/nutrition/databases/bmi/en/.
28. TanitaAcademy.Understandingyourmeasurements.Availableat:http://tanita.eu/.AccessedMay25,
2018.
29. MatthewsDR,HoskerJP,RudenskiAS,NaylorBA,TreacherDF,TurnerRC.Homeostasismodel
assessment:Insulinresistanceandbcellfunctionfromfastingplasmaglucoseandinsulinconcentrations
inman.Diabetologia1985;28:412–9.
30. ReddyY.,MurthyS.,KrishnaD.,PrabhakarM.C.RoleofFreeRadicalsandAntioxidantsinTuberculosis
Patients.IndianJ.Tuberc.2004;51:213–218.
31. VeskoukisA.S.,KyparosA.,PaschalisV.,NikolaidisM.G.SpectrophotometricAssaysforMeasuringRedox
BiomarkersinBlood.Biomarkers.2016;21:208–217.doi:10.3109/1354750X.2015.1126648.
32. JanaszewskaA.,BartoszG.AssayofTotalAntioxidantCapacity:ComparisonofFourMethodsasApplied
toHumanBloodPlasma.Scand.J.Clin.Lab.Invest.2002;62:231–236.doi:10.1080/003655102317475498.
33. KelesM.S.,TaysiS.,SenN.,AksoyH.,AkçayF.EffectofCorticosteroidTherapyonSerumandCSF
MalondialdehydeandAntioxidantProteinsinMultipleSclerosis.Can.J.Neurol.Sci.2001;28:141–143.doi:
10.1017/S0317167100052823.
34. CalderPC,AhluwaliaN,BrounsFetal..Dietaryfactorsandlowgradeinflammationinrelationto
overweightandobesity.BrJNutr.2011;106(Suppl.3):S5–78.doi:10.1017/S0007114511005460
35. EmilioRosE.,MartínezGonzálezM,EstruchR,SalasSalvadóJS,MontserratMFitóM,MartínezJA,
CorellaDMediterraneandietandcardiovascularhealth:TeachingsofthePREDIMEDstudyAdvNutr.
2014May14;5(3):330S6S
36. DaiJ,JonesDP,GoldbergJ,ZieglerTR,BostickRM,WilsonPW,ManatungaAK,ShallenbergerL,JonesL,
VaccarinoV.AssociationbetweenadherencetotheMediterraneandietandoxidativestress.AmJClin
Nutr.2008Nov;88(5):136470.
37. FitóM,GuxensM,CorellaDetal.;PREDIMEDStudyInvestigators.EffectofatraditionalMediterranean
dietonlipoproteinoxidation:arandomizedcontrolledtrial.ArchInternMed.2007;167:1195–1203.
doi:10.1001/archinte.167.11.1195[GoogleScholar]
38. TostiV,BertozziB,FontanaL.HealthBenefitsoftheMediterraneanDiet:MetabolicandMolecular
Mechanisms.JGerontolABiolSciMedSci.2018Mar2;73(3):318326.
39. CalabreseCM,ValentiniA,CalabreseG.GutMicrobiotaandType1DiabetesMellitus:TheEffectof
MediterraneanDiet.FrontNutr.2021Jan13;7:612773.
Preprints.org (www.preprints.org) | NOT PEER-REVIEWED | Posted: 27 August 2024 doi:10.20944/preprints202408.1910.v1
11
40. Widmer,R.J.;Flammer,A.J.;Lerman,L.O.;Lerman,A.TheMediterraneandiet,itscomponents,and
cardiovasculardisease.Am.J.Med.2015,128,229–238
41. Hooper,L.V.;Littman,D.R.;Macpherson,A.J.Interactionsbetweenthemicrobiotaandtheimmunesystem.
Science2012,336,1268–1273MD
42. Zhou,N.;Gu,X.;Zhuang,T.;Xu,Y.;Yang,L.;Zhou,M.GutMicrobiota:APivotalHubforPolyphenolsas
Antidepressants.J.Agric.Food.Chem.2020,68,6007–6020
43. EisenbergT,AbdellatifM,SchroederSetal.Cardioprotectionandlifespanextensionbythenatural
polyaminespermidine.NatMed.2016;22:1428–1438.doi:10.1038/nm.4222
44. AlexE.Mohr,CarissaMcEvoy,DorothyD.Sears,PaulJ.Arciero,KarenL.Sweazea,Impactofintermittent
fastingregimensoncirculatingmarkersofoxidativestressinoverweightandobesehumans:Asystematic
reviewofrandomizedcontrolledtrials,AdvancesinRedoxResearch,Volume3,2021,100026
45. McAllister,MJ,Gonzalez,AE,andWaldman,HS.Impactoftimerestrictedfeedingonmarkersof
cardiometabolichealthandoxidativestressinresistancetrainedfirefighters.JStrengthCondRes36(9):
25152522,2022
46. SuttonEF,BeylR,EarlyKS,CefaluWT,RavussinE,PetersonCM.EarlyTimeRestrictedFeedingImproves
InsulinSensitivity,BloodPressure,andOxidativeStressEvenwithoutWeightLossinMenwith
Prediabetes.CellMetab.2018Jun5;27(6):12121221.e3.
47. CienfuegosS,GabelK,KalamF,EzpeletaM,WisemanE,PavlouV,LinS,OliveiraML,VaradyKA.Effects
of4‐and6hTimeRestrictedFeedingonWeightandCardiometabolicHealth:ARandomizedControlled
TrialinAdultswithObesity.CellMetab.2020Sep1;32(3):366378
48. WimalawansaSJ.VitaminDDeficiency:EffectsonOxidativeStress,Epigenetics,GeneRegulation,and
Aging.Biology(Basel).2019May11;8(2):30
Disclaimer/Publisher’sNote:Thestatements,opinionsanddatacontainedinallpublicationsaresolelythose
oftheindividualauthor(s)andcontributor(s)andnotofMDPIand/ortheeditor(s).MDPIand/ortheeditor(s)
disclaimresponsibilityforanyinjurytopeopleorpropertyresultingfromanyideas,methods,instructionsor
productsreferredtointhecontent.
Preprints.org (www.preprints.org) | NOT PEER-REVIEWED | Posted: 27 August 2024 doi:10.20944/preprints202408.1910.v1
Article
Full-text available
Background: Vitamin D plays a key role in bone metabolism and immune regulation. Populations with restricted sun exposure or limited dietary intake are particularly vulnerable to vitamin D deficiency. Orthodox Christian nuns represent a unique group in this regard, due to traditional clothing, limited outdoor activity, and prolonged religious fasting. However, few studies have compared them with lay individuals following similar dietary practices. Objective: This study aimed to investigate predictors of serum 25-hydroxyvitamin D [25(OH)D] concentrations in two female populations: Orthodox Christian nuns and women from the general population practicing intermittent (religious or non-religious) fasting. We also aimed to develop predictive models of vitamin D status for each group based on lifestyle and biochemical parameters. Methods: A total of 85 women (40 Orthodox nuns and 45 laywomen), aged 30–50 years, were enrolled. Serum 25(OH)D, parathyroid hormone (PTH), calcium levels, and anthropometric indices, including body mass index (BMI), total body fat, and visceral fat, were measured. Dietary calcium and vitamin D intake, as well as sun exposure, were assessed using validated questionnaires. Separate stepwise multiple regression models were constructed for each group to identify independent predictors of 25(OH)D concentrations. An additional combined model, including all participants, was also explored. Results: PTH was the most significant predictor, negatively correlating with 25(OH)D concentrations in both groups (p = 0.038), highlighting its regulatory role in vitamin D metabolism. When analyzed separately, the model for Orthodox nuns showed stronger explanatory power (adjusted R² = 0.718; p = 0.013) compared with the control group (adjusted R² = 0.362; p = 0.038), with PTH emerging as a key predictor in both. Conclusions: Distinct predictors of vitamin D status were identified in each group, reflecting the complex interplay between lifestyle and physiological factors. These findings suggest that targeted interventions, such as addressing PTH regulation in fasting populations or enhancing sun exposure in the general population, may be more effective in preventing vitamin D deficiency depending on the context.
Article
Full-text available
Cardiovascular disease (CVD) and its complications are a leading cause of death worldwide. Endothelial dysfunction plays a crucial role in the initiation and progression of CVD, serving as a pivotal factor in the pathogenesis of cardiovascular, metabolic, and other related diseases. The regulation of endothelial dysfunction is influenced by various risk factors and intricate signaling pathways, which vary depending on the specific disease context. Despite numerous research efforts aimed at elucidating the mechanisms underlying endothelial dysfunction, the precise molecular pathways involved remain incompletely understood. This review elucidates recent research findings on the pathophysiological mechanisms involved in endothelial dysfunction, including nitric oxide availability, oxidative stress, and inflammation‐mediated pathways. We also discuss the impact of endothelial dysfunction on various pathological conditions, including atherosclerosis, heart failure, diabetes, hypertension, chronic kidney disease, and neurodegenerative diseases. Furthermore, we summarize the traditional and novel potential biomarkers of endothelial dysfunction as well as pharmacological and nonpharmacological therapeutic strategies for endothelial protection and treatment for CVD and related complications. Consequently, this review is to improve understanding of emerging biomarkers and therapeutic approaches aimed at reducing the risk of developing CVD and associated complications, as well as mitigating endothelial dysfunction.
Article
Full-text available
The global population is on a trajectory of continuous growth, with estimates projecting an increase from 7.7 billion in 2019 to approximately 9.7 billion by 2050. Longevity is also expected to rise rapidly, with advancements in healthcare contributing to increased life expectancies and an increase in the maximum lifespan. The aging process is accompanied by different changes, often leading to a decline in daily life activities and an increased susceptibility to disease. Age-related changes can cause cellular damage and subsequent cellular death. Oxidative stress and inflammation play significant roles in this process contributing to molecular damage and mitochondrial dysfunction. Active aging has been associated with improved quality of life and a reduced risk of morbidity and premature mortality. In this context, the Mediterranean diet has emerged as a promising approach to promoting healthy aging and sustainability. The phytochemical compounds within the Mediterranean diet have been linked to a lower risk of developing cardiovascular disease, type 2 diabetes, obesity, cancer and neurodegenerative diseases. The findings of peer-reviewed articles regarding the use of the Mediterranean diet as a healthy and sustainable dietary pattern written in Portuguese, Spanish or English were included in this narrative literature review. This dietary pattern’s emphasis on the consumption of fresh and local food aligns with both health and environmental sustainability goals. This work provides a comprehensive review of the benefits of the Mediterranean diet and its components in a healthy aging process and highlights the importance of this dietary pattern as a sustainable approach.
Article
Full-text available
In people with obesity, diabetes, and hypertension, lipid and glucose metabolism and oxidative stress generation interact. This condition, known as a “metabolic syndrome” (MetS), presents a global challenge and appears to be the underlying mechanism for the development of cardiovascular diseases (CVDs). This review is designed based on evidence indicating the pathogenic mechanisms of MetS. In detail, we will look at the mechanisms of oxidative stress induction in MetS, the effects of elevated oxidative stress levels on the condition’s pathophysiology, and matters related to endothelial function. According to different components of the MetS pathophysiological network, the effects of antioxidants and endothelial dysfunction are reviewed. After considering the strategic role of oxidative stress in the pathophysiology of MetS and its associated CVDs, oxidative stress management by antioxidant supplementation seems an appropriate therapeutic approach.
Article
Full-text available
Athonian Orthodox fasting (AOF) is characterized by energy- and time-restricted eating (TRE) and is based on the Mediterranean diet. We aimed to investigate the impact of AOF compared to another TRE model on vaspin, omentin, nesfatin, and visfatin levels. We included 25 individuals (mean age 50.3 ± 8.6 years, 24% men) who practiced AOF and abstained from animal products, with the exception of seafood and fish. This group adopted a 12 h eating interval (08.00 to 20.00). In total, 12 participants (mean age 47.7 ± 8.7 years, 33.3% men) who practiced 16:8 TRE (eating from 09:00 to 17:00) and were allowed to consume meat served as the controls. Anthropometric and dietary data and adipokine levels were prospectively collected at three time points: at baseline, after the end of the diets (7 weeks), and 5 weeks after the participants returned to their typical eating habits (12 weeks from baseline). Vaspin levels decreased [795.8 (422.1–1299.4) (baseline) vs. 402.7 (203.8–818.9) (7 weeks) pg/mL, p = 0.002] and omentin levels increased [568.5 (437.7–1196.5) (baseline) vs. 659.0 (555.7–1810.8) (12 weeks) pg/mL, p = 0.001] in the AOF group, while none of the analyzed adipokines changed significantly in the TRE group. The variations observed in vaspin and omentin concentrations in the AOF group were independent of age, sex, changes in anthropometry and fat intake. In conclusion, AOF can significantly reduce vaspin and increase omentin, whose levels are known to increase and decrease, respectively, in obesity and type 2 diabetes. The implications of these findings for cardiometabolic health warrant further investigation.
Article
Full-text available
The abnormal expansion of body fat paves the way for several metabolic abnormalities including overweight, obesity, and diabetes, which ultimately cluster under the umbrella of metabolic syndrome (MetS). Patients with MetS are at an increased risk of cardiovascular disease, morbidity, and mortality. The coexistence of distinct metabolic abnormalities is associated with the release of pro-inflammatory adipocytokines, as components of low-to-medium grade systemic inflammation and increased oxidative stress. Adopting healthy lifestyles, by using appropriate dietary regimens, contributes to the prevention and treatment of MetS. Metabolic abnormalities can influence the function and energetic capacity of mitochondria, as observed in many obesity-related cardio-metabolic disorders. There are preclinical studies both in cellular and animal models, as well as clinical studies, dealing with distinct nutrients of the Mediterranean diet (MD) and dysfunctional mitochondria in obesity and MetS. The term “Mitochondria nutrients” has been adopted in recent years, and it depicts the adequate nutrients to keep proper mitochondrial function. Different experimental models show that components of the MD, including polyphenols, plant-derived compounds, and polyunsaturated fatty acids, can improve mitochondrial metabolism, biogenesis, and antioxidant capacity. Such effects are valuable to counteract the mitochondrial dysfunction associated with obesity-related abnormalities and can represent the beneficial feature of polyphenols-enriched olive oil, vegetables, nuts, fish, and plant-based foods, as the main components of the MD. Thus, developing mitochondria-targeting nutrients and natural agents for MetS treatment and/or prevention is a logical strategy to decrease the burden of disease and medications at a later stage. In this comprehensive review, we discuss the effects of the MD and its bioactive components on improving mitochondrial structure and activity.
Article
Full-text available
Background Breast cancer is one of the leading causes of death worldwide, it affects both men and women. In Saudi Arabia, breast cancer has been the most prevalent type of cancer in women, for the past few years. Dietary habits and cultural beliefs vary according to region, and further studies are required to demonstrate the relationship between these dietary habits and cultural beliefs and the risk of developing breast cancer. This study is aimed to discover the relationship between preventive dietary factors of the Mediterranean diet and rates of breast cancer among postmenopausal women in the Makkah region of Saudi Arabia. Methods A case-control study was conducted in King Abdulla Medical City Hospital, Makkah, Saudi Arabia and included 432 Saudi female participants: 218 in the control group and 214 breast cancer patients. All participants were postmenopausal, around the same age, and all were ethnically Arab Saudis. Data were obtained using a self-administered validated questionnaire. Results Study results showed that a diet that includes 1–2 servings of legumes weekly, 1–5 servings of fish weekly, 1–5 servings of dairy products daily, 3–5 servings of fruits and vegetables daily, and more than one cup of black tea and coffee per day significantly (p < 0.05) reduces the risk of breast cancer. Conclusion This study demonstrates that consuming a Mediterranean diet, which includes legumes, fish, fruits and vegetables, black tea, coffee, and low intake of dairy products, works as a preventive factor against breast cancer in postmenopausal females from the Makkah region.
Article
Context Consumption of the Mediterranean diet (MedDiet) has beneficial effects on cardiometabolic health and aging. Objective This systematic review aimed to critically investigate the effect of the MedDiet on glycation markers in healthy or overweight individuals with type 2 diabetes or cardiovascular disease. Data Sources MEDLINE, EMBASE, Web of Science, and the Cochrane Library were searched, using the terms “Mediterranean diet” AND “glycation end products, advanced”. Data Extraction Three randomized and 3 nonrandomized clinical trials, containing data on 2935 adult and elderly individuals with normal weight or overweight, were included. All extracted data were compiled, compared, and critically analyzed. Data Analysis The authors of most of the studies demonstrated a reduction in serum concentrations of advanced glycation end products (AGEs), such as εN-carboxymethyllysine and methylglyoxal, and in skin autofluorescence levels after at least 4 weeks of adherence to the MedDiet. The MedDiet also led to positive effects on gene expression of receptors for AGEs, as RAGE and AGER1, and an enzyme involved in detoxification (glyoxalase I). There is no evidence that short-term adherence affects glycation markers. Conclusions Glycation markers improved in response to the MedDiet. The possible mechanisms involved may be related to the low AGE and refined sugars content of the diet, as well as its high monounsaturated fatty acid, phenolic compound, and dietary fiber contents. Systematic Review Registration PROSPERO registration no. CRD42021284006.
Article
We prospectively assessed changes in free 25-hydroxyvitamin D [25(OH)D] and vitamin D binding protein (VDBP) among overweight adults who followed a pescatarian Orthodox intermittent fasting regimen (n = 59) and controls who followed a low-fat 12:12 diet (n = 46). Total and free 25(OH)D, parathyroid hormone, VDBP, anthropometric data, and amino acid intake were evaluated in both groups at three time points: at baseline, 7 weeks after diet implementation, and 5 weeks after participants returned to their usual eating habits (12 weeks from baseline). An increase in amino acid intake between baseline and 12 weeks was independently correlated with higher free 25(OH)D values at 12 weeks for both groups. Our findings suggest that diet can affect free 25(OH)D concentrations, through variations in amino acid intake, independently of exposure to sunlight, providing novel mechanistic insights into the future planning of vitamin D supplementation strategies. However, this hypothesis needs to be tested in larger studies.
Article
7-ketocholesterol and 7β-hydroxycholesterol are two oxysterols mainly formed by the autoxidation of cholesterol. These two molecules are interconvertible via specific enzymes. These two oxysterols are often observed at increased amounts in biological fluids as well as tissues and organs affected during age-related diseases and in diseases of civilization such as cardiovascular, neurodegenerative, and ocular diseases as well as type 2 diabetes and metabolic syndrome. Noteworthy, 7-ketocholesterol and 7β-hydroxycholesterol induce oxidative stress and inflammation, which are frequently observed in patients with age-related and civilization diseases. For this reason, the involvement of these two oxysterols in the pathophysiology of these diseases is widely suspected. In addition, the toxicity of these oxysterols can lead to death by oxiapoptophagy characterized by oxidative stress, apoptosis induction and autophagy criteria. To prevent, or even treat, certain age-related or civilization diseases associated with increased levels of 7-ketocholesterol and 7β-hydroxycholesterol, the identification of molecules or mixtures of molecules attenuating or inhibiting the toxic effects of these oxysterols allows to consider new treatments. In this context, many nutrients present in significant amounts in the Mediterranean diet, especially tocopherols, fatty acids, and polyphenols, have shown cytoprotective activities as well as several Mediterranean oils (argan and olive oils, milk thistle seed oil, and pistacia lentiscus seed oil). Consequently, a nutraceutical approach, rich in nutrients present in the Mediterranean diet, could thus make it possible to counteract certain age-related and civilization diseases associated with increased levels of 7-ketocholesterol and 7β-hydroxycholesterol.