Content uploaded by Saieed Moslemi Nezhad Arani
Author content
All content in this area was uploaded by Saieed Moslemi Nezhad Arani on Sep 12, 2024
Content may be subject to copyright.
Computer Assisted Language Learning Electronic Journal (CALL-EJ), 25(3), 1-22, 2024
Navigating the Future of Language Learning: A Conceptual Review
of AI’s Role in Personalized Learning
Saieed Moslemi Nezhad Arani (s.mosleminezhad@bam.ac.ir)
Foreign Languages Department, Tourism Faculty, Higher Education Complex of Bam, Bam, Iran
Abstract
Language pedagogy is increasingly tailored to meet individual learning needs through the use of
Artificial Intelligence. Informed by Hart’s (2018) framework, this concept paper explores the
potential role of AI in revolutionizing educational practices, with a particular focus on personalized
learning pathways in language education. The integration of AI is envisioned as a transformative
tool that could fundamentally alter conventional pedagogy, yielding both promising opportunities
and significant challenges. This exploration includes a structured synthesis of the literature that
underscores the development of digital literacy, robust infrastructure, and teacher training as
critical components for effective AI integration. In the midst of examining opportunities, this paper
also confronts potential threats and ethical concerns like data bias. Through an in-depth discussion,
the paper advocates for a balanced approach that harnesses AI’s strengths while preserving the
essential human element and inclusivity, thereby proposing a blueprint for an adaptable
educational system fit for the digital era. The contemplation herein contributes to the ongoing
discourse on AI’s influence in education, providing pivotal insights for educators, policymakers,
and AI developers.
Keywords: Artificial Intelligence, Conceptual review, Language learning future, Personalized
learning,
Introduction
With the evolution of technology, Artificial Intelligence is increasingly being recognized as an
instrumental force in reshaping the educational paradigm, particularly in the realm of language
pedagogy. As global interconnectedness deepens, the need for effective language instruction that
caters to diverse learners has become more apparent. In traditional educational models, which often
employ a uniform curriculum and pace, individual learner differences can be overlooked, leading
to suboptimal learning outcomes.
This paper identifies the problem rooted in these monolithic teaching strategies and suggests
AI as a transformative solution. AI’s capabilities for customizing instruction and assessing learner
needs promise a departure from the status quo, potentially revolutionizing how we approach
language learning. Despite a growing body of research on AI in various educational contexts, there
remains a lack of synthesis examining the comprehensive role and intricacies of AI in personalized
language learning pathways. Notably, earlier studies have not fully explored the ramifications of
AI integration on existing pedagogical frameworks, nor have they systematically addressed the
ethical considerations and potential for data bias that AI implementation may entail.
2
This conceptual paper aims to fill this gap by offering a cohesive synthesis of the current
literature, drawing upon theoretical frameworks and empirical findings to illuminate the
multifaceted consequences of AI adoption in language education. The contribution lies in threading
together the promise of AI for bespoke learning experiences with the nuanced challenges it
presents, both technologically and ethically. By engaging in this discourse, the paper not only
navigates the complexities of AI’s integration but also proposes a way forward that balances
innovation with critical human values. Ultimately, this investigation paves the way towards a more
refined application of AI in education, where informed strategies lead to equitable, effective, and
ethical language learning environments.
Literature review
The concept of ‘personalized learning’ has its roots in the traditional instruction paradigm,
where teaching was primarily a one-way process. Historically, education was designed as a ‘one-
size-fits-all’ model, with a uniform curriculum, instructional method, and pace of learning,
providing little room for individual differences among learners. However, as the understanding of
cognitive science and learning theories evolved, the emphasis shifted towards a more
accommodative and learner-centered model of education (Jordan et al., 2020; Orina et al., 2021).
This shift has led to an educational approach that emphasizes tailoring the learning experience to
individual students’ strengths, needs, skills, and interests (Lu et al., 2023; Reich, 2022).
In the realm of language teaching, personalized learning takes shape by customizing
instruction, materials, and assessments to cater to individual learners’ needs (Smorodinova et al.,
2022; Vuong & Wong, 2019). Each language learner’s cognitive abilities, linguistic heritage,
cultural background, and learning preferences uniquely influence their language learning process.
To accommodate these differences, personalized language learning focuses on tailoring instruction
methods (Kupchyk & Litvinchuk, 2021; Šimonová & Poulova, 2014). For instance, certain
learners may grasp new languages quicker through visual aids, while others might excel in an
auditory or kinesthetic learning environment.
Materials and content employed for language teaching are also customized in a personalized
learning setup. Such tailoring aligns with learner’s current linguistic competence and gradually
progresses as per their pace of learning, giving a truly learner-centered experience. As stated by
Lutskovskaia et al. (2019); Mageira et al. (2022); Woo and Choi (2021); Zunaidah et al. (2023),
AI-based language learning tools have the capability to offer differentiated content, varying in
difficulty level, grammar structure or vocabulary, depending on the learner’s proficiency.
Therefore, integrating personalized learning in language instruction leverages individual
differences, enhances learner engagement, and boosts language acquisition.
Personalized learning in language teaching has been emphasized for promoting numerous
advantages. Increased learner engagement is one of the significant benefits, as this approach allows
learners to engage with the learning material that suits their style and pace, leading to higher
motivation and active learning (Kardaş, 2016; Wang, 2023). Additionally, personalized learning
has demonstrated higher efficacy in mastering language skills. By aligning instruction and content
with individual capabilities, it allows learners to grasp the language more effectively, enhancing
3
outcomes like vocabulary acquisition, reading comprehension, and listening skills (Cheung, 2013;
Li et al., 2018).
Despite the clear benefits, personalized learning is also associated with some potential
drawbacks. One significant challenge is its difficulty to be implemented at large scale. Tailoring
instruction to individual needs requires considerable resources, such as time, sophisticated AI
technology, and especially-trained teachers (Baimakhanova & Ibrayeva, 2022; Lăpădat, 2023;
Rüdian & Pinkwart, 2021; Schulz et al., 2020). Given these demands, applying personalized
learning extensively, especially in resource-poor contexts, becomes problematic. Furthermore, this
tailored approach relies heavily on data collection and AI algorithms, raising privacy and ethical
concerns. In sum, while personalized learning in language instruction indeed holds promise in
enhancing teaching and learning, it also incites certain challenges that need to be acknowledged
and addressed.
Automated personalized learning powered by AI revolutionizes the traditional education
paradigm by offering effective and efficient learner-centric instruction. AI in personalized learning
involves sophisticated AI systems capturing learners’ data, including their learning pace, styles,
and skill levels (Liu & Quan, 2022; Lydia et al., 2023; Pataranutaporn et al., 2021). Using machine
learning algorithms, these platforms continuously analyze learners’ progress by comparing their
performance with their past records or with other learners who share similar traits (Chen et al.,
2022; Hocutt et al., 2022; Sayed et al., 2022). Based on the insights gained from this data analysis,
AI platforms adapt instruction accordingly. For instance, if a learner is struggling with a particular
language concept, the system might revise the content, adjust the complexity level, or change the
learning mode to visual, auditory or kinesthetic depending on the learners’ preference. In addition,
AI platforms provide real-time feedback, identifying areas of strength and improvement (Porter &
Grippa, 2020; Wijewickrema et al., 2018). This instantaneous feedback mechanism enables
learners to improve their language skills more quickly and efficiently than through traditional
feedback methods. The use of AI, therefore, provides a highly targeted, responsive, and effective
approach to personalized learning, revolutionizing the way we view education and instruction.
Traditional and AI-based personalized learning offer contrasting paradigms for education.
According to Porter and Grippa (2020), traditional personalized learning ensures instruction
tailored to individual needs but struggles to deliver this at scale due to constraints on teacher time
and resources. Conversely, AI-driven personalized learning has the advantage of scalability (Yu,
2023). Complex algorithms allow for individual instruction adapted to countless learners
simultaneously, something unachievable in a traditional setup. Moreover, AI can provide real-time,
adaptive feedback that contributes to an immediate and effective learning process (Al Gharbi et
al., 2021; Gupta et al., 2022). By contrast, traditional teaching models may not offer immediate
feedback, delaying learning progress. Objectivity in assessment is another notable strength of AI-
based personalized learning (Anuyahong et al., 2023; Murtaza et al., 2022). It eliminates human
biases and variability, offering a more consistent and accurate appraisal of learning. On the flip
side, AI-integrated personalized learning brings its share of challenges. Data privacy is a key
concern, as learners’ sensitive information is constantly collected and analyzed (Fu et al., 2023).
Furthermore, unequal access to technology could perpetuate existing educational inequalities, with
4
students lacking requisite tech access potentially being left behind (Murtaza et al., 2022).
Consequently, while AI offers unprecedented opportunities for personalized learning, it also
presents complex challenges on the equity and privacy fronts.
Methodology
The methodological approach for this conceptual review is inspired by the framework proposed
by Hart (2018), which is designed to facilitate a comprehensive exploration and synthesis of the
literature on AI’s role in personalized language learning. We engage in a thorough literature
exploration and critical appraisal, alongside a thematic analysis, to develop a scholarly narrative
that encompasses the present scope and prospective direction of the domain. The theoretical
foundation of this review is grounded in principles drawn from educational psychology and models
of technology adoption, which serve to deepen comprehension of both personalized learning and
the integration of AI in educational frameworks. By applying Hart’s methodological structure, this
paper seeks to expand upon existing scholarship and highlight areas for future research and
innovation.
Methodological Approach
Present study’s methodological design is tailored to a conceptual examination, wherein we
systematically identify, select, and analyze scholarly texts related to the role of AI in personalized
language learning. This design follows a thematic structure that allows for the identification of
patterns, frameworks, and theories discussed across various sources.
Literature Synthesis Strategy
The procedure for the present study’s literature synthesis involved a multi-phase approach.
Initially, relevant academic databases were queried using a defined set of keywords encompassing
aspects of AI and language learning. Following this, we employed a critical appraisal technique to
evaluate the quality and relevance of identified articles. Finally, we synthesized the core concepts
and discussions to construct the narrative and arguments presented in this paper.
Scope and Delimitation
Guided by Chris Hart’s framework for conducting rigorous literature reviews, this paper
systematically examines the burgeoning intersection of Artificial Intelligence and personalized
language learning. Prsent study’s approach adopts Hart’s methodologies for literature mapping,
critical analysis, and synthesis, ensuring that the literature included is scrutinized through multiple
lenses to construct a rich conceptual landscape.
The scope of this paper is carefully defined to focus on primary scholarly works that explicitly
explore the use of AI in language education, while secondary sources are used to contextualize
and support the researcher’s interpretations. Sources are selected based on their relevance to the
field, their contribution to foundational knowledge, and their recent implications for the future
trajectory of language learning and pedagogy. In keeping with Hart’s guidelines, the literature is
5
mapped to identify key themes and patterns, with particular attention to the evolution of thought
within the discipline and emerging areas of consensus and debate.
While the present study’s review is extensive, there are delimitations intrinsic to the approach.
Consistent with Hart’s framework, the emphasis is placed on academic and peer-reviewed sources,
potentially excluding grey literature or non-peer-reviewed material that may also hold valuable
insights. Furthermore, in aligning with the structure of a conceptual paper, the reasercher’s focus
is on developing thematic narratives rather than empirical generalizability. This includes an
acknowledgement of the predominant focus on literature published in English, with the
understanding that significant contributions may exist in other languages.
The paper’s lens is further narrowed to the implications of AI in language learning
environments, which may omit broader educational technologies and applications from the
discussion. The rapid pace of technological advancement in AI also means that while the present
analysis is representative of the state of the field at the moment of writing, subsequent innovations
may not be covered within this review.
This paper presents a synthesized perspective on the integration of AI in language teaching,
shaped by a structured and critical engagement with the literature as outlined by Chris Hart’s
theoretical approach. Yet, it also recognizes the dynamic nature of AI research and the importance
of ongoing inquiry to encapsulate its evolving impact on education." Using this framework, you
clarify the methodological rigor of your review process and explicitly define the breadth and limits
of your analysis, helping to set accurate expectations for your readers.
Key Findings
Drawing on a diverse array of literature, this section will explore the sophisticated algorithms
that enable personalized language learning experiences, highlight the adaptive capabilities of AI
in real-time settings, and examine various systems and tools that exemplify the practical
application of AI in language education. We will also consider the reported effectiveness of these
AI tools in shaping language learning.
In personalized language learning, AI algorithms play a pivotal role in delivering tailored
instruction that can significantly enhance the learning outcomes. These algorithms are primarily
designed to interpret and analyze large volumes of learner data systematically to discern patterns
and create adaptive learning paths (Jeong & Park, 2019; Rizvi, 2023). Machine learning algorithms
can identify a learner’s language proficiency level, preferred learning style, common errors, and
pace of learning. For instance, an algorithm can recognize a learner’s difficulty in understanding a
particular tense in a new language and can accordingly adapt its instructions to provide more
practice or explain differently. Furthermore, according to (Ng et al., 2020; Zhaxybayev &
Mizamova, 2022), natural language processing algorithms, a branch of AI, enable the system to
understand, interpret, generate, and contextualize human language in a meaningful way. This
technology can provide immediate feedback on learners’ written and spoken language, marking a
disruptive shift from traditional language learning methods.
6
The process of data gathering and analysis is integral to AI’s transformative role in
personalized language learning. Using sophisticated algorithms, AI systems are capable of
collecting and analyzing real-time data on learner performance, helping to inform instructional
adaptations (Godwin-Jones, 2017). For instance, these AI platforms can monitor a learner’s pace
of study, the complexity of language they can handle, their mastery over specific language aspects
such as syntax, pronunciation or vocabulary, and their interactions with the learning platform. This
information not only paints a comprehensive picture of a learner’s current proficiency level, but it
also offers deep insights into their learning patterns. By analyzing this voluminous data, AI can
tailor instruction to the specific needs of the learner, providing content that matches their language
proficiency level, suggesting exercises to overcome specific weaknesses, or adjusting the pace of
instruction (Chen et al., 2022). Accordingly, the importance of data analysis in AI language
learning allows for a highly responsive system that constantly adapts and improves its instruction
based on the individual learner’s demonstrated needs and progress (Demmans Epp, 2021).
The crucial advantage of AI systems in personal language learning is their real-time adaptive
capability. Based on the learner’s analyzed data, these systems instantaneously adjust their
instruction to suit the learner’s current proficiency and requirements. Incorporation of personalized
language learning systems with AI and cognitive-based personalization can further enhance
language personalization systems (Lydia et al., 2023). These dynamic adjustments span from
altering content difficulty according to the learner’s language proficiency, presenting relatively
simpler content to beginners and, progressively more complex content as the learner advances. AI
also identifies learning difficulties through factors such as time spent on specific exercises or
recurring mistakes and ensures additional practice or explanations are provided (Chen et al., 2021).
Furthermore, an AI system may pace the instruction depending on the learner’s speed of learning,
ensuring the learner is neither overwhelmed nor under-stimulated (Cui & Sachan, 2023).
Several language learning platforms effectively apply the capabilities of AI to offer
personalized instruction in languages. Duolingo, a well-known AI-empowered language learning
platform, demonstrates the dynamic role of AI in language services by using machine learning
algorithms for data analysis to understand users’ proficiency levels, aptitudes, and learning
patterns. Then, it personalizes language pathways in real-time to focus on weaknesses and
reinforce strengths. Further, Duolingo’s language bot employs natural language processing
algorithms to generate interactive dialogues, thereby improving learners’ conversational skills in
the target language. Similarly, the AI platform Rosetta Stone applies proprietary speech
recognition algorithms offering immediate feedback on pronunciation, assisting learners in
refining their spoken language skills. This ability to provide customizable and interactive user
experiences is a testament to AI’s potential in language learning. However, ongoing challenges
like data privacy and algorithm bias should still be addressed. Woo and Choi (2021) corroborate
these advantages, showing improvements in language skills and knowledge in learners after they
utilize AI tools for error spotting, receiving feedback, and language evaluation. Vall and González
Araya (2023) discuss the beneficial aspects of AI language learning tools including reduced
learning times, personalized learning experiences, and exposure to different cultures which
signifies the role AI plays in personalizing instruction and enhancing language learning outcomes.
7
Numerous studies attest to the effectiveness of AI in personalized language learning. In a study
conducted by Moulieswaran and Prasantha (2023), it was found that the ability of AI to provide
immediate feedback, address individual learning needs, and offer customized practice tasks
resulted in a favorable learning environment, conducive to improved language proficiency.
Addressing the same issue, Zhou et al. (2022) examined the effectiveness of Duolingo, a well-
known AI language learning platform. The research revealed that the platform’s algorithm-driven
personalization provided learners with a flexible, engaging, and efficient language learning
pathway, leading to significant improvement in reading, writing, listening, and speaking skills in
the target language. This evidence reinforces the argument that AI-driven personalized language
learning can effectively support learners to develop their language skills and proficiency. However,
it is crucial to mitigate potential downsides highlighting the potential difficulties and challenges
of AI-driven language learning platforms. Zhu (2020) points out that AI-assisted language
education can advance learning efficiency and foster education equity by supplying individualized
content and personalized assistance.
Meanwhile, Fulton et al. (2021) warns of the datafication and personalized learning trends,
arguing an over-dependence on AI systems might decrease learner autonomy and critical thinking
abilities. In the same regard, given AI systems’ adaptability to the learner’s pace and content, an
overreliance could result in a lack of learner autonomy and critical thinking skills, essentials in
language learning. Haristiani (2019) investigates the application of AI chatbots as language
learning mediums, concluding that they could serve as effective tutors and autonomous learning
tools. However, if these systems provide all the answers, learners might get used to being spoon-
fed and face difficulties when having to use the language in unforeseen or innovative scenarios.
Woo and Choi (2021) examined AI-based language learning tools, touching on their positive
impact on language skills and knowledge. Yet, their study also concedes the need for teacher
preparation and identifies concerns about insufficient information. Moreover, as paralleled by Mah
et al. (2022), there could potentially be among different learner groups, which could
unintentionally widen the digital divide, favoring learners with more accessibility to technology.
However, granting the positive side, the need for large volumes of data for these AI systems to
work effectively raises important concerns. Such data includes specifics about an individual
learner’s behavior, patterns, and preferences, potentially posing considerable data privacy and
security risks.
Table 1
Real-World AI Applications in Language Learning: Platform Categorization
Type of AI
Main features
Relevant
Popular
Apps/Platforms
Relevant studies
Intelligent
Tutoring
Systems
These systems
provide
personalized
instructions
and feedback
to learners,
adapting to
their
• Interactive Instruction
• Personalized
Feedback
• Adaptive Content
• Knowledge Modeling
• Scaffolding and Hints
• Duolingo
• Rosetta Stone
• Babbel
• Busuu
• Memrise
• Mondly
• ALEKS
(Kang, 2021)
(Sakalauskė &
Leonavičiūtė, 2022)
(Namaziandost et al.,
2021)
(Arifin & Hikmah,
2023)
(Sporn et al., 2020)
8
individual
needs.
• Error Analysis and
Correction
• Progress Tracking
and Reporting
(Loewen et al., 2020)
(Winans, 2019)
(Lubis et al., 2023)
(Putri & Simanjuntak,
2022)
(Nushi et al., 2024)
(Harous et al., 2017)
Adaptive
Learning
Platforms
Platforms that
adjust the
learning
content based
on the
learner’s
performance.
• Real-Time
Adaptation:
• Customized Learning
Paths
• Data-Driven Insights
• Feedback and
Assessment
• Predictive Analytics
• Engagement Tools
• Accessibility and
Flexibility
• Comprehensive
Content Libraries
• Smart Sparrow
• Knewton (now
part of Pearson)
• DreamBox
Learning
• ScootPad
• ALEKS
(Mezin et al., 2022)
(S. Liu et al., 2021)
(Zhang et al., 2023)
(Aprilinda et al., 2022)
(Nosenko, 2020)
(Gayathri et al., 2018)
Conversati
onal Agents
and
Chatbots
AI-driven chat
interfaces that
can engage
learners in
natural
language
conversations
• Natural Language
Interaction
• Immediate Response
• Language Practice
• Personalization
• Scalability
• Error Detection and
Correction
• Availability
• Sentiment Analysis
• Progress Tracking
• Duolingo Bots
• Mondly Chatbot
• Andy - English
Speaking Bot
• HelloTalk
• Rosetta Stone
Chatbot
• Speaky
(Ruan et al., 2021)
(Wu et al., 2023)
(Najima et al., 2021)
Speech
Recognitio
n Tools
These tools
focus on
developing
speaking and
pronunciation
skills by
giving instant
feedback.
• Pronunciation
Assessment
• Real-Time Corrective
Feedback
• Interactive Speaking
Practice
• Accent Reduction
• Speech-to-Text
Conversion
• Listening
Comprehension
• Phonetic
Visualization
• Voice Command and
Control
• Contextual
Recognition
• Rosetta Stone
• Duolingo
• Babbel
• Pronunciator
• Speechling
• HelloTalk
(Floyd, 2016)
(Cavus, 2016)
(Yang, 2022)
(Febriani et al., 2023)
(Nugroho et al., 2021)
9
Studies evidenced that AI-based language learning platforms have the potential to enhance
language acquisition and provide personalized and engaging learning experiences (Jia et al., 2022;
Y. Liu et al., 2021; Tan et al., 2022). A host of AI-based language learning platforms are reshaping
the educational landscape as detailed in Table 1, each delivering unique advantages driven by
artificial intelligence. Intelligent Tutoring Systems like Duolingo, Rosetta Stone, Babbel, Busuu,
Memrise, Mondly, and ALEKS personalize the learning path for users, adapting to their individual
progress and areas of difficulty. Adaptive Learning Platforms, including Smart Sparrow, Knewton,
DreamBox Learning, ScootPad, and once more ALEKS, tailor educational content and exercises
to a student's specific needs, optimizing the learning experience. Conversational Agents and
Chatbots, such as Duolingo Bots, Mondly Chatbot, Andy - the English Speaking Bot, HelloTalk,
Rosetta Stone Chatbot, and Speaky, engage learners in dialogues to practice language skills in an
interactive context. Speech Recognition Tools provided by platforms like Rosetta Stone, Duolingo,
Babbel, Pronunciator, Speechling, and HelloTalk assist in perfecting pronunciation through
immediate feedback. Lastly, Virtual and Augmented Reality Applications including MondlyVR,
ImmerseMe, various VR offerings for language learning, AR Flashcards, Quiver, and Google
Translate immerse users in contextual learning environments with interactive 3D models and real-
time language translation. Collectively, these platforms exemplify the transformative potential of
AI to create dynamic, personalized language learning experiences. Nevertheless, challenges such
as data privacy, technological over-reliance, and access inequality must be continually addressed
to ensure the responsible evolution of these educational tools.
Available scholarly literature (Divekar et al., 2021; Ji et al., 2022; Lee & An, 2021; Rebolledo
Font de la Vall & González Araya, 2023; Woo & Choi, 2021) highlights the AI-driven applications
and AI-platforms’ success in enhancing language proficiency, reporting significantly higher
engagement and satisfaction rates compared to traditional language learning methods, concluding
that comprehensive, personalized learning pathways and feedback mechanisms resulted in
considerable improvements in individuals’ language skills. This reveals that the personalized,
interactive nature of these AI platforms can foster sustained engagement, which is a critical factor
in successful language learning. The researchers in the above-mentioned studies found that the
Virtual
Reality and
Augmented
Reality
Application
s
Some
language
learning
platforms use
VR/AR to
create
immersive
experiences.
• Immersive
Environments
• Interactivity
• Contextual Learning
• Engagement and
Motivation
• Visual Aids
• Cultural Immersion
• Gesture Recognition
• Real-world
Integration
• Multi-sensory
Learning
• Safe Practice
Environment
• MondlyVR
• ImmerseMe
• Language
Learning with
Virtual Reality
• AR Flashcards
• Quiver
• Google
Translate
(Pan et al., 2021)
(Jing et al., 2022)
(Tschanz & Baerlocher,
2022)
(Soto et al., 2020)
10
intelligent combination of human teaching and AI tools effectively increased students’ language
learning efficiency and proficiency. These studies, among others, provide robust evidence of the
transformative impact of AI tools in engaging learners, enhancing their language proficiency, and
boosting learning outcomes. Yet, it is important to remember that these platforms need to continue
addressing concerns related to data privacy, equity of access, and the potential of over-reliance on
technology.
Discussion
This section weaves together the implications of AI’s role in language pedagogy, reflecting on
how it affects student engagement and overall educational quality. We will delve into both the
individual and societal benefits that AI integration promises, while also addressing the potential
barriers and drawbacks. The future impact of AI on language education, as well as pressing
concerns over data privacy, access inequality, and ethical considerations, will be critically
examined.
Studies suggest that while AI has potential benefits in language learning, there are considerable
challenges that need to be addressed, such as the limitations of AI in replicating human intelligence
and the need for more research on skills development and pedagogy (Kukulska-Hulme & Lee,
2020; Vall & González Araya, 2023). One of the primary concerns is privacy, given the substantial
amount of data collected by these AI tools (Foulds et al., 2022; Nazaretsky et al., 2022). Such data
includes not only language learners’ personal information, but also their learning patterns and
academic progress (Hockly, 2023). Effective measures are needed to ensure the privacy and
security of such user data. Accessibility also poses a significant challenge. Despite technological
advancements, not all learners, especially those situated in remote or socio-economically
disadvantaged areas, have access to the necessary technology or internet connectivity to leverage
these AI tools. Besides, the integration of AI in language learning also raises concerns related to
the deepening of digital divide. The varied access to and quality of technology among different
learner populations could inadvertently result in disparities in language learning outcomes.
Additionally, while the functional capabilities of AI tools are impressive and continually
improving, they still fall short of replicating the holistic and intuitive nature of human instruction.
Human language teachers can provide nuanced cultural context, foster emotional connections, and
adapt to the learner’s needs in a dynamic and empathetic manner. While AI-based tools can
effectively supplement human instruction by allowing personalized learning paths and offering
immediate feedback, it remains questionable whether they can fully replace the human element of
language teaching.
The future of language learning through AI tools promises transformative potentials with
the currently burgeoning AI-based language-learning market poised to revolutionize language
teaching through more responsive, personalized, and learner-centric solutions. Continuous
advancements in machine learning and voice recognition are set to improve the quality and efficacy
of AI language tools, which could be adapted for broader academic areas. Disciplines integrating
substantial language components, like literature or history, could particularly benefit from the
personalization and interactivity provided by AI. However, realizing these potentials necessitates
navigating associated challenges, such as ensuring data privacy and security and bridging the
11
digital divide for equitable access to technology. If these challenges can be effectively managed,
AI could potentially democratize education, granting learners across the socio-economic spectrum
access to quality language learning resources.
AI-enabled personalized learning has been found to significantly improve student
engagement and motivation in language learning by tailoring teaching techniques to each student’s
abilities, preferences, and interests, making learning more engaging and thereby encouraging
sustained motivation (Alsobeh & Woodward, 2023). These AI tools encourage active participation
by addressing individual needs and goals, leading to increased intrinsic motivation and a more
positive attitude towards language learning due to the meaningful and rewarding learning
experience offered.
The impact of student engagement through these tools extends beyond motivation, with
several studies outlining how this engagement facilitates more extensive language practice and
exploration, thereby enhancing language acquisition. The persistence shown by engaged learners
when faced with challenging language concepts or skills, further emphasizes the effectiveness of
this approach in language education (Campenhout et al., 2023; Hiromori, 2023). The interactivity
offered by many AI tools promotes hands-on language learning, forcing constant active responses
and adjustments that reinforce understanding and retention of the language (Yang & Kyun, 2022).
This underlines a positive correlation between sustained engagement and effective language
outcomes, with the stimulation of learners’ curiosity and interest fostering a more engaging and
rewarding language learning environment.
The use of AI-enhanced personalized learning techniques holds significant potential to boost
the overall quality of education, primarily due to their learner-centric approach (Liyanage et al.,
2022; Lydia et al., 2023). Instruction catered to individual learners’ unique abilities, needs, and
interests fosters a more responsive and effective teaching environment. Notably, these personalized
learning methods also prioritize fostering critical thinking skills by encouraging a more interactive,
inquiry-based approach to learning, prompting students to question, analyze, and synthesize
information. Additionally, the utilization of sophisticated AI computing technologies should be
closely linked with educational theories in order to optimize learning efficiency and effectiveness.
Numerous studies also highlight the changing roles and economies of degrees as well as
increasingly scalable personal learning experiences resulting from automated technology, showing
how AI can improve opportunities for all students (Harry, 2023; Kohli et al., 2021). AI-based
personalized learning pathways in education have the potential to revolutionize traditional teaching
methods by tailoring instruction to individual learners’ specific needs, abilities, and interests.
The transformative potential of personalized learning to enhance language skills and its
consequence on both personal and societal scales cannot be understated. As Chen and Wang (2020)
elucidate, personalized learning accounts for individual differences such as learning styles, prior
knowledge, preferences, and ability levels, which can significantly enrich personal, academic, and
professional lives of individuals. This tailored approach to learning, as Wozniak (2020) argues,
can exceptionally support adult learners, fostering their particular needs, motivations, and
resources. Therefore, the proficiency earned in multiple languages in this way, not only expands
cultural understanding and personal perspectives, but also offers an edge in the professional milieu.
12
Samah et al. (2011) echo this sentiment, asserting that recognizing individual differences in
personalized learning settings leads to boosted learning outcomes, satisfaction, and engagement.
Consequently, the societal implications of these individual enhancements are substantial. Greater
prevalence of multilingual individuals breaks down socio-cultural barriers, thus facilitating mutual
respect and understanding in diverse communities. Furthermore, it stimulates economic growth by
potentially attracting global businesses and fostering innovation.
While personalized learning offers promising benefits, acknowledging potential barriers and
drawbacks is crucial. Principal among these challenges is the resource intensiveness of such
methods (Maghsudi et al., 2021). Implementing personalized learning, particularly when
supplemented by AI, requires significant investments in technological infrastructure, ongoing
maintenance, and educators’ professional development (Tapalova et al., 2022). This brings into
question the feasibility and sustainability of such approaches, particularly in resource-limited
situations. Additionally, concerns exist regarding the potential of personalized learning to
inadvertently widen existing educational disparities. As argued by Montez et al. (2019) and Teasley
and Homer (2020), students from socio-economically disadvantaged backgrounds may lack equal
access to necessary technological resources, resulting in unequal chances for personalized
learning. Hence, instead of equalizing opportunities, personalized learning might unintentionally
exacerbate existing inequities. Another salient issue is the possible isolation implicit in such an
educational approach. Gurba (2022) reported that with learners overly reliant on individual
learning pathways, the opportunities for collaborative learning might be substantially reduced.
While personalized learning is designed to cater to individual needs, it is essential to ensure it does
not isolate learners or impede their social skills development. In conclusion, while AI-aided
personalized learning can significantly enhance language education, these potential obstacles and
disadvantages need careful consideration and preemptive management for successful and fair
implementation.
The future implications of integrating AI into personalized learning could profoundly impact
language education. Foremost among these implications is the potential for AI advancements to
increase the accuracy of speech recognition. As speech recognition software becomes more
sophisticated, it can provide more detailed feedback to learners regarding their pronunciation,
intonation, and speech patterns, thereby enhancing their spoken language skills and
communication confidence in a target language. According to Alhawiti (2015) and Sathya et al.
(2017), the efficacy and satisfaction derived from employing artificial neural networks for isolated
speech recognition affirm its potential in this field. This is further bolstered by the progressive
models of artificial intelligence methodologies, notably for decoding speech patterns, underlining
the prospect of extensive applications across diverse disciplines. Ultimately, it is postulated that
the trajectory of artificial intelligence will ultimately help overcome the prevalent challenges
inherent to speech recognition. In addition to improved speech recognition, the increased
adaptivity of AI could enable more personalization in language learning. With machine learning
algorithms becoming more advanced, they may anticipate individual learners’ needs more
effectively by adapting content delivery or learning pathways at a more granular level (Chen et al.,
2021; Woo & Choi, 2021). This adaptability will provide personalized support that aligns with
learners’ current abilities, goals, and projected learning trajectory.
13
Strong arguments can be made for AI advancements’ potential to widen access to language
learning resources. The groundbreaking research by Vall and González Araya (2023) emphasizes
that AI language tools can tailor learning experiences, quicken the pace of learning, and expose
learners to diverse cultures. Similarly, Almelhes (2023) substantiates this standpoint with the
proposition of implementing AI technology in second-language learning, to refine learners’
pronunciation and diversify learning opportunities. Na-young et al’s (2019) study involving
chatbots powered by AI clearly showcases the positive impact on students’ communication skills
and motivation in language learning. Further strengthening the case, Kannan and Munday (2018)
praise the convergence of AI, ICT, and networked learning for transforming language learning. By
promoting global connections, facilitating access to open educational resources, and promoting
self-regulated learning, this integration can revolutionize language education. These substantial
findings overwhelmingly suggest that innovations in AI can augment accessibility and
effectiveness in language learning. While current AI integration in personalized language learning
extends numerous benefits, the possibilities are exciting to envision even more meaningful
enhancements to language education quality, accessibility, and personalization with future
advancements.
In leveraging AI for personalized learning in language education, the necessity for
comprehensive data consumption cannot be understated. AI relies heavily on encompassing learner
data, including progress tracking, strengths, weaknesses, and preferences, to accurately
individualize and adapt the educational experience (Fulton et al., 2021). This prominent data
requirement, however, ushers in concerns of privacy and security. If mishandled or exploited,
learner data could potentially infringe on privacy rights or be used in non-consensual ways. This
worry amplifies when dealing with minors or other vulnerable demographics, necessitating robust
security measures to protect privacy rights. Best practices may include anonymizing student data,
using aggregated data for decision-making, and regularly auditing data usage and access (Fu et al.,
2023). Clear and comprehensible transparency norms should also be established. Learners and
their families must be informed about how and why their data is being used and protected, and
they should provide clear consent to this data collection and use. So, while AI’s extensive data
usage is crucial for delivering personalized learning, students’ privacy concerns require strict
regulations, adherence to best practices, and transparency to guarantee ethical and secure data
handling.
The introduction of AI to personalized language learning presents considerable potential, but
also highlights potential disparities brought about by the digital divide. This disparity risks students
without sufficient technological access falling further behind, leading to widened educational
inequalities due to socio-economic status, geography, or age (Banerjee, 2022; Hampton et al.,
2020). To counteract this, simultaneous investment in digital literacy programs and technological
infrastructure is vital. These initiatives should aim to empower learners to engage efficiently with
technology, possibly through tech skill workshops, online safety education, and teacher training
sessions which equip educators with the necessary skills for employing AI technologies in
education. In addition, investments in technological infrastructure, encompassing reliable internet
access in schools, homes, and community centers along, and the hardware required for AI
applications, should not be overlooked. Public-private partnerships and government policies can
14
aid this area, ensuring equitable access to advanced educational technology. Therefore, although
the application of AI in personalized language learning could intensify the digital divide, through
digital literacy initiatives and concerted investments in technological infrastructure, these potential
inequities can be reduced, creating opportunities for all learners to reap the benefits of AI-enabled
personalized language learning.
The integration of AI in language learning might pose a significant shift to traditional education
systems, spawning concerns ranging from job displacement fears to concerns about the loss of the
human touch in education. AI-related challenges in education may be caused by AI with regard to
inappropriate use of AI techniques, changing roles of teachers and students, as well as social and
ethical issues (Zhai et al., 2021). However, it is vital to note that AI should not be seen as a threat,
but as a tool that can aid teachers by taking over routine tasks and offering helpful insights.
Research showed that despite AI’s efficiency and adaptiveness, it lacks the empathetic
understanding, creativity and nuanced decision-making that human teachers provide (Zhai et al.,
2021).
A potentially effective way forward could involve integrating AI with traditional teaching
methods. According to Eaton (2017), this would create a best-of-both-worlds scenario, merging
AI’s adaptability and data-driven findings with a teacher’s interpersonal skills and expertise. This
idea reinforced by Goel and Joyner (2017) believing that it is equally important to empower
educators with AI competency by providing training on how to use AI-based tools, interpret the
generated data, and integrating these tools within their teaching strategies. This would make
teachers active participants in AI-driven education, preserving their current roles and offering them
new digital skills (Lee & Perret, 2022). Even though the widespread adoption of AI in language
learning may shake traditional education systems, with deliberate integration of AI with standard
methods and investment in teacher training, the transformation of language education can remain
teacher-centric with AI acting as a valuable support tool.
The adoption of AI in language teaching brings along significant ethical considerations, the
most concerning being the potential for bias in AI algorithms, stemming from the nature of the
data they are trained on. Emphasized and concluded by Ntoutsi et al. (2020), there is a need to
embed ethical and legal principles in AI’s design and deployment, it becomes crucial to recognize
that if AI draws on biased data, its recommendations may inadvertently perpetuate these biases,
leading to unfair outcomes in language education. To tackle these biases, developers should
employ diverse and representative data sets, meticulously test their algorithms for potential bias,
and make necessary adjustments for fair performance (Hwang, 2022; Prediger, 2017). Regular
audits and evaluations should also be conducted to spot any bias in functioning AI applications.
Furthermore, it is worth stressing that AI-generated recommendations should not be followed
without question. Educators need to complement AI suggestions with their professional discretion,
and students should have some autonomy in their education. Rothenberger et al. (2019) and Ryan
and Stahl (2020) state that clear policy guidelines are necessary to manage ethical AI applications,
stipulating how AI should be utilized in language education, and putting measures in place to
penalize misuse or unethical practices. In sum, ethical factors, including fairness, prevention of
bias, and education values, are paramount when incorporating AI in language teaching. Adherence
15
to measures like diligent AI use and development, regular audits, and explicit policy guidelines
could mitigate associated concerns.
Conclusion
The rapidly evolving technological landscape and the subsequent rise of AI are fundamentally
transforming the field of language teaching. This trend has the potential to foster personalized
learning, enhance interactivity, and provide valuable data-driven insights, all contributing to a
more dynamic and effective learning environment. However, the transition to such AI-enabled
education is not without its challenges, with potential threats to traditional education systems and
ethical implications to consider, particularly concerning data bias. The successful integration of AI
into language teaching will thus require careful planning and substantial development in digital
literacy, infrastructure, and teacher training. By combining the versatility of AI and the
irreplaceable human touch of teachers, language education can navigate this digital shift
effectively, creating a balanced, innovative, and inclusive learning atmosphere for all students.
Implications of this study extend to educational policy-makers, technology developers, and
educators who must collaborate to ensure that AI tools are seamlessly and ethically incorporated
into language teaching frameworks. It is essential to develop strategies that maintain a learner-
centric approach, adaptable to diverse educational contexts and sensitive to the socio-cultural
dimensions of language learning. Moreover, investing in teacher education to include AI literacy
and pedagogical strategies for technology integration will be imperative to leverage AI’s benefits
effectively.
However, the limitations of this conceptual exploration must also be acknowledged. While the
paper provides a broad overview of AI’s potential role in language learning, empirical studies are
needed to validate the hypotheses and suggestions made herein. The current review is based on
available literature, which may not fully represent the rapidly changing AI landscape. Furthermore,
the long-term implications of AI in education, which are still unfolding, could not be addressed in
depth. Future research should aim to provide longitudinal data on the efficacy and impact of AI
integration in language teaching and learning, contributing to an adaptive educational framework
that responds to technological advancements and evolving learning needs.
References
Al Gharbi, S., Al-Majed, A.-A., Abdulraheem, A., Patil, S., & Elkatatny, S. (2021). Improving
Real-Time Drilling Data Quality Using Artificial Intelligence and Machine Learning
Techniques. Day 2 Mon, November 29, 2021.
Alhawiti, K. M. (2015). Advances in Artificial intelligence Using Speech Recognition. World
Academy of Science, Engineering and Technology, International Journal of Computer
and Information Engineering, 9, 1439-1442.
Almelhes, S. (2023). A Review of Artificial Intelligence Adoption in Second-Language Learning.
Theory and Practice in Language Studies.
Alsobeh, A. M. R., & Woodward, B. (2023). AI as a Partner in Learning: A Novel Student-in-the-
Loop Framework for Enhanced Student Engagement and Outcomes in Higher Education.
Proceedings of the 24th Annual Conference on Information Technology Education.
16
Anuyahong, B., Rattanapong, C., & Patcha, I. (2023). Analyzing the Impact of Artificial
Intelligence in Personalized Learning and Adaptive Assessment in Higher Education.
International Journal of Research and Scientific Innovation.
Aprilinda, Y., Martavia, T., Erlangga, E., Afandi, F. N., & Rizal, U. (2022). Chatbot
Menggunakan Natural Language Processing untuk Pembelajaran Bahasa Inggris Berbasis
Android. EXPERT: Jurnal Manajemen Sistem Informasi dan Teknologi.
Arifin, F. J., & Hikmah, K. (2023). Enhancing Arabic Vocabulary Acquisition: Evaluating
Rosetta Stone Application for College Students. Indonesian Journal of Islamic Studies.
Baimakhanova, A. Y., & Ibrayeva, Z. K. (2022). Advantages and Disadvantages of Virtual
Reality Tools in ESL Classroom. Bulletin of Toraighyrov University. Philology series.
Banerjee, M. (2022). The Digital Divide and Smartphone Reliance for Disadvantaged Students in
Higher Education. Journal of Systemics, Cybernetics and Informatics.
Campenhout, R. V., Clark, M., Dittel, J. S., Brown, N., Benton, R., & Johnson, B. G. (2023).
Exploring Student Persistence with Automatically Generated Practice through Interaction
Patterns. 2023 International Conference on Software, Telecommunications and Computer
Networks (SoftCOM), 1-6.
Cavus, N. (2016). Development of an Intellegent Mobile Application for Teaching English
Pronunciation. Procedia Computer Science, 102, 365-369.
Chen, S. Y., & Wang, J.-H. (2020). Individual differences and personalized learning: a review
and appraisal. Universal Access in the Information Society, 20, 833-849.
Chen, X., Zou, D., Cheng, G., & Xie, H. (2021). Artificial intelligence-assisted personalized
language learning: systematic review and co-citation analysis. 2021 International
Conference on Advanced Learning Technologies (ICALT), 241-245.
Chen, Y.-H., Huang, N.-F., Tzeng, J.-W., Lee, C.-A., Huang, Y.-X., & Huang, H.-H. (2022). A
Personalized Learning Path Recommender System with LINE Bot in MOOCs Based on
LSTM. 2022 11th International Conference on Educational and Information Technology
(ICEIT), 40-45.
Cheung, S. K. S. (2013). Hybrid learning and continuing education : 6th international
conference, ICHL 2013, Toronto, ON, Canada, August 12-14, 2013 : proceedings.
Cui, P., & Sachan, M. (2023). Adaptive and Personalized Exercise Generation for Online
Language Learning. Annual Meeting of the Association for Computational Linguistics,
Demmans Epp, C. (2021). Using Analytics and Artificial Intelligence to Support Language
Learner Decision Making.
Divekar, R. R., Drozdal, J., Chabot, S., Zhou, Y., Su, H., Chen, Y., Zhu, H., Hendler, J. A., &
Braasch, J. (2021). Foreign language acquisition via artificial intelligence and extended
reality: design and evaluation. Computer Assisted Language Learning, 35, 2332 - 2360.
Eaton, E. (2017). Teaching Integrated AI through Interdisciplinary Project-Driven Courses. AI
Mag., 38, 13-21.
Febriani, S. R., Widayanti, R., Saputra, H. Y., Safutri, J. T., & Bedra, K. G. (2023). Hello Talk:
An Alternative Media for Improving Writing Skills for Higher Education. Ta'lim al-
'Arabiyyah: Jurnal Pendidikan Bahasa Arab & Kebahasaaraban.
Floyd, A. (2016). LibGuides: Get to Know the LiLI Tools: Pronunciator.
Foulds, J. R., McDonald, N., Massey, A. K., Hamidi, F., Okeson, A., Caruana, R., Craswell, N.,
Inkpen, K., Lundberg, S. M., Nori, H., Wallach, H. M., Vaughan, J. W., Patrick, Kelley,
G., Yang, Y., Heldreth, C., Moessner, C., Sedley, A., Woodruff, A., . . . Mojsilovic, A.
(2022). Special Issue on Responsible AI and Human-AI Interaction.
17
Fu, D., Bao, W., Maciejewski, R., Tong, H., & He, J. (2023). Privacy-Preserving Graph Machine
Learning from Data to Computation: A Survey. ACM SIGKDD Explorations Newsletter,
25, 54 - 72.
Fulton, L., Hoffman, D. L., & Paek, S. (2021). Language learning in an era of datafication and
personalized learning. Educational Technology Research and Development, 69(1), 315-
318. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11423-020-09903-0
Gayathri, G., Mohana, N., Pal, R., & Murthy, H. A. (2018). Mobile Application for Learning
Languages for the Unlettered. Interspeech,
Godwin-Jones, R. (2017). Scaling Up and Zooming In: Big Data and Personalization in
Language Learning. Language Learning & Technology, 21, 4-15.
Goel, A. K., & Joyner, D. A. (2017). Using AI to Teach AI: Lessons from an Online AI Class. AI
Mag., 38, 48-59.
Gupta, C., Chandrashekar, P. B., Jin, T., He, C., Khullar, S., Chang, Q., & Wang, D. (2022).
Bringing machine learning to research on intellectual and developmental disabilities:
taking inspiration from neurological diseases. Journal of Neurodevelopmental Disorders,
14.
Gurba, K. (2022). Individual and Collaborative Online Learning – Reasonable Compromise.
International Journal of Research in E-learning.
Hampton, K. N., Fernandez, L., Robertson, C. T., & Bauer, J. M. (2020). Broadband and Student
Performance Gaps. Social Science Research Network.
Haristiani, N. (2019). Artificial Intelligence (AI) Chatbot as Language Learning Medium: An
inquiry. Journal of Physics: Conference Series, 1387(1), 012020.
https://doi.org/10.1088/1742-6596/1387/1/012020
Harous, S., Alkhoori, F., Alzaabi, A., & Saedi, S. A. (2017). Alturjoman Alsagheer: Basic
language app for kids. IEEE Conference on Computer Communications,
Harry, A. (2023). Role of AI in Education. Interdiciplinary Journal and Hummanity (INJURITY).
Hart, C. (2018). Doing a Literature Review: Releasing the Social Science Research Imagination.
Sage Publications Inc.
Hiromori, T. (2023). Unlocking Effective Language Learning: The Crucial Role of Engagement
and its Multifaceted Components. Current Research in Psychology and Behavioral
Science (CRPBS).
Hockly, N. (2023). Artificial Intelligence in English Language Teaching: The Good, the Bad and
the Ugly. RELC Journal, 54, 445 - 451.
Hocutt, D. L., Ranade, N., & Verhulsdonck, G. (2022). Localizing Content: The Roles of
Technical & Professional Communicators and Machine Learning in Personalized Chatbot
Responses. Technical Communication.
Hwang, J.-Y. (2022). Bridging the Gap Between AI Trustworthiness Guidelines and The Practice
Use of AI Service Development. 2022 13th International Conference on Information and
Communication Technology Convergence (ICTC), 2289-2291.
Jeong, Y.-S., & Park, J. H. (2019). Learning Algorithms in AI System and Services. J. Inf.
Process. Syst., 15, 1029-1035.
Ji, H., Han, I., & Ko, Y. (2022). A systematic review of conversational AI in language education:
focusing on the collaboration with human teachers. Journal of Research on Technology in
Education, 55, 48 - 63.
Jia, F., Sun, D., Ma, Q., & Looi, C.-k. (2022). Developing an AI-Based Learning System for L2
Learners’ Authentic and Ubiquitous Learning in English Language. Sustainability.
18
Jing, Y., Mingfang, Z., & Chen, Y. (2022). Feasibility Analysis of the Application of Virtual
Reality Technology in College English Culture Teaching. J. Inf. Knowl. Manag., 21,
2240020:2240021-2240020:2240022.
Jordan, O., Abiogu, R. F. G. C., & Eneogwe, E. (2020). Analysis of Learner-centered Model of
Education as a Condition Precedent for Developing Creativity in a Learner: The Nigerian
Perspective.
Kang, J. (2021). Digital Technical Language Teaching: Teaching/Learning Principles of
Duolingo. Learning & Education.
Kannan, J., & Munday, P. (2018). New Trends in Second Language Learning and Teaching
through the lens of ICT, Networked Learning, and Artificial Intelligence. Círculo de
Lingüística Aplicada a la Comunicación.
Kardaş, D. (2016). The use of personalized texts for teaching Turkish as a second language.
Educational Research Review, 11, 252-259.
Kohli, R., Phutela, S., Garg, A., & Viner, M. D. (2021). Artificial Intelligence Technology to
Help Students With Disabilities.
Kukulska-Hulme, A., & Lee, H. (2020). Intelligent assistants in language learning: an analysis of
features and limitations. CALL for widening participation: short papers from
EUROCALL 2020.
Kupchyk, L., & Litvinchuk, A. (2021). Constructing personal learning environments through
ICT-mediated foreign language instruction. Journal of Physics: Conference Series, 1840.
Lăpădat, M.-M. (2023). Harnessing Technological Transformation: An Exploration of the Impact
of Mobile-Assisted Language Learning on English Vocabulary Acquisition. ANALELE
UNIVERSITĂȚII DIN CRAIOVA SERIA ȘTIINȚE FILOLOGICE LIMBI STRĂINE
APLICATE.
Lee, C. L., & An, D.-I. (2021). Reinforcement learning and neural network-based artificial
intelligence control algorithm for self-balancing quadruped robot. Journal of Mechanical
Science and Technology, 35, 307-322.
Lee, I. A., & Perret, B. (2022). Preparing High School Teachers to Integrate AI Methods into
STEM Classrooms. AAAI Conference on Artificial Intelligence,
Li, H., Cui, W., Xu, Z., Zhu, Z., & Feng, M. (2018). Yixue Adaptive Learning System and Its
Promise on Improving Student Learning. International Conference on Computer
Supported Education,
Liu, S., Zhang, X., Chen, W., & Zhang, W. (2021). Construction of Intelligent Adaptive Learning
Platform in Ubiquitous Environment. 2021 10th International Conference on Educational
and Information Technology (ICEIT), 56-60.
Liu, Y., & Quan, Q. (2022). AI Recognition Method of Pronunciation Errors in Oral English
Speech with the Help of Big Data for Personalized Learning. J. Inf. Knowl. Manag., 21,
2240028:2240021-2240028:2240019.
Liu, Y., Sahagun, J., & Sun, Y. (2021). An Adaptive and Interactive Educational Game Platform
for English Learning Enhancement using AI and Chatbot Techniques. Natural Language
Processing.
Liyanage, M. P. P., Hirimuthugoda, U. J., Liyanage, N. L. T. N., Thammita, D. H. M. M. P.,
Wedanage, D. K. H. W., Kugathasan, A., & Thelijjagoda, S. (2022). AI Solution to Assist
Online Education Productivity via Personalizing Learning Strategies and Analyzing the
Student Performance. 2022 IEEE 13th Annual Ubiquitous Computing, Electronics &
Mobile Communication Conference (UEMCON), 0609-0615.
19
Loewen, S., Isbell, D. R., & Sporn, Z. (2020). The effectiveness of app‐based language
instruction for developing receptive linguistic knowledge and oral communicative ability.
Foreign Language Annals.
Lu, W., Yu, H., Wang, J., Teney, D., Wang, H., Chen, Y., Yang, Q., Xie, X., & Ji, X. (2023).
ZooPFL: Exploring Black-box Foundation Models for Personalized Federated Learning.
ArXiv, abs/2310.05143.
Lubis, B. N. A., Husda, A., & Zulhantiar, P. A. (2023). Memrise Application as Digital Media
Skill to Enrich Students' English Vocabulary at Junior Highschool in Medan. Journal
Education and Development.
Lutskovskaia, L. Y., Shoustikova, T., & Udina, N. (2019). AI-based Tools for Foreign Language
Training: Opinions from Different Audiences.
Lydia, E. G., Vidhyavathi, P., & Malathi, P. (2023). A Study on "AI in Education: Opportunities
and Challenges for Personalized Learning. Industrial Engineering Journal.
Mageira, K., Pittou, D., Papasalouros, A., Kotis, K. I., Zangogianni, P., & Daradoumis, A.
(2022). Educational AI Chatbots for Content and Language Integrated Learning. Applied
Sciences.
Maghsudi, S., Lan, A. S., Xu, J., & van der Schaar, M. (2021). Personalized Education in the
Artificial Intelligence Era: What to Expect Next. IEEE Signal Processing Magazine, 38,
37-50.
Mah, P. M., Skalna, I., & Muzam, J. (2022). Natural Language Processing and Artificial
Intelligence for Enterprise Management in the Era of Industry 4.0. Applied Sciences,
12(18), 9207. https://www.mdpi.com/2076-3417/12/18/9207
Mezin, H., Kharrou, S. Y., & Lahcen, A. A. (2022). Adaptive Learning Algorithms and
Platforms: A Concise Overview. Advances in Information, Communication and
Cybersecurity.
Montez, J. K., Hayward, M. D., & Zajacova, A. (2019). Educational Disparities in Adult Health:
U.S. States as Institutional Actors on the Association. Socius, 5.
Moulieswaran, & Prasantha. (2023). Investigating ESL Learners’ Perception and Problem
towards Artificial Intelligence (AI) -Assisted English Language Learning and Teaching.
World Journal of English Language.
Murtaza, M., Ahmed, Y., Shamsi, J. A., Sherwani, F., & Usman, M. (2022). AI-Based
Personalized E-Learning Systems: Issues, Challenges, and Solutions. IEEE Access, 10,
81323-81342.
Na-young, K., Cha, Y. J., & Kim, H.-S. (2019). Future English Learning: Chatbots and Artificial
Intelligence. Multimedia-Assisted Language Learning, 22, 32-53.
Najima, T., Kato, T., Tamura, A., & Yamamoto, S. (2021). Remote Learning of Speaking in
Syntactic Forms with Robot-Avatar-Assisted Language Learning System. Workshop on
Time-Delay Systems,
Namaziandost, E., Alekasir, S., Dehkordi, E. S., & Tilwani, S. A. (2021). An Account of EFL
learners' Vocabulary Learning in a Mobile-Assisted Language Environment: The Case of
Rosetta Stone Application.
Nazaretsky, T., Ariely, M., Cukurova, M., & Alexandron, G. (2022). Teachers' trust in AI-
powered educational technology and a professional development program to improve it.
Br. J. Educ. Technol., 53, 914-931.
Ng, V., Rees, E. E., Niu, J., & Zaghlool, A. (2020). Application of natural language processing
algorithms for extracting information from news articles in event-based surveillance.
20
Canada communicable disease report = Releve des maladies transmissibles au Canada,
46 6, 186-191.
Nosenko, Y. (2020). ALTA Solution from Knewton as a Tool of Support for Adaptive Learning in
Mathematics. Educational Discourse: collection of scientific papers.
Ntoutsi, E., Fafalios, P., Gadiraju, U., Iosifidis, V., Nejdl, W., Vidal, M.-E., Ruggieri, S., Turini,
F., Papadopoulos, S., Krasanakis, E., Kompatsiaris, I., Kinder-Kurlanda, K. E., Wagner,
C., Karimi, F., Fernández, M., Alani, H., Berendt, B., Kruegel, T., Heinze, C., . . . Staab,
S. (2020). Bias in data‐driven artificial intelligence systems—An introductory survey.
Wiley Interdisciplinary Reviews: Data Mining and Knowledge Discovery, 10.
Nugroho, B., Nafasya, F. D., Nurshanya, N., & Awaliyah, S. (2021). The Implementation of
HelloTalk Application in Teaching Vocabulary to Young Learners.
Nushi, M., Fattahi, N., & Ebn-Abbasi, F. (2024). An Evaluative Review of Mondly: A Mobile
Language Learning Application. The EuroCALL Review.
Orina, W. A., Macharia, S. M., & Okpalaenwe, E. N. (2021). Managing Overcrowded
Classrooms to Accommodate Learner Centered Methodologies: An Indispensable Pillar
for Teachers’ Preparedness in Implementation of Competency-Based Curriculum in
Kenya. International Journal of Innovative Research and Development.
Pan, Z., Sun, Y., Yao, Z., & Li, M. (2021). Application of Virtual Reality in English Teaching.
2021 3rd World Symposium on Artificial Intelligence (WSAI), 64-71.
Pataranutaporn, P., Danry, V., Leong, J. Y. Y., Punpongsanon, P., Novy, D., Maes, P., & Sra, M.
(2021). AI-generated characters for supporting personalized learning and well-being.
Nature Machine Intelligence, 3, 1013 - 1022.
Porter, B. A., & Grippa, F. (2020). A Platform for AI-Enabled Real-Time Feedback to Promote
Digital Collaboration. Sustainability.
Prediger, L. (2017). On the importance of monitoring and directing progress in AI. AI Matters, 3,
30-38.
Putri, A. N., & Simanjuntak, M. N. W. (2022). Students' Perception Toward Memrise Application
as Media in Learning Vocabulary. ANGLO-SAXON: Jurnal Ilmiah Program Studi
Pendidikan Bahasa Inggris.
Rebolledo Font de la Vall, R., & González Araya, F. (2023). Exploring the Benefits and
Challenges of AI-Language Learning Tools. International Journal of Social Sciences and
Humanities Invention.
Reich, J. (2022). Audrey Watters. Teaching Machines: The History of Personalized Learning
Boston: MIT Press, 2021. 328 pp. History of Education Quarterly, 62, 355 - 358.
Rizvi, M. (2023). Investigating AI-Powered Tutoring Systems that Adapt to Individual Student
Needs, Providing Personalized Guidance and Assessments. The Eurasia Proceedings of
Educational and Social Sciences.
Rothenberger, L., Fabian, B., & Arunov, E. (2019). Relevance of Ethical Guidelines for Artificial
Intelligence - a Survey and Evaluation. European Conference on Information Systems,
Ruan, S. S., Jiang, L., Xu, Q., Liu, Z., Davis, G. M., Brunskill, E., & Landay, J. A. (2021).
EnglishBot: An AI-Powered Conversational System for Second Language Learning. 26th
International Conference on Intelligent User Interfaces.
Rüdian, S., & Pinkwart, N. (2021). Generating adaptive and personalized language learning
online courses in Moodle with individual learning paths using templates. 2021
International Conference on Advanced Learning Technologies (ICALT), 53-55.
21
Ryan, M., & Stahl, B. C. (2020). Artificial intelligence ethics guidelines for developers and
users: clarifying their content and normative implications. J. Inf. Commun. Ethics Soc.,
19, 61-86.
Sakalauskė, A., & Leonavičiūtė, V. (2022). Strategic Analysis of Duolingo Language Learning
Platform. Mokslas - Lietuvos ateitis.
Samah, N. A., Yahaya, N. A., & Ali, M. B. (2011). Individual differences in online personalized
learning environment. Educational Research Review, 6, 516-521.
Sathya, R., Pavithra, M. S., & Girubaa, G. (2017). Artificial Intelligence for Speech
Recognistion.
Sayed, W. S., Noeman, A. M., Abdellatif, A., Abdelrazek, M., Badawy, M. G., Hamed, A., & El-
Tantawy, S. (2022). AI-based adaptive personalized content presentation and exercises
navigation for an effective and engaging E-learning platform. Multimedia Tools and
Applications, 82, 3303 - 3333.
Schulz, K., Beyer, A., Dreyer, M., & Kipf, S. (2020). A data-driven platform for creating
educational content in language learning. Conference on Digital Curation Technologies,
Šimonová, I., & Poulova, P. (2014). Personalized Learning and Assessment. International
Conference on Advances in Web-Based Learning,
Smorodinova, M. V., Borodina, M., Tatarintseva, E. N., Ermilova, D. Y., & Sokolova, A. P.
(2022). Distance Learning in Language Courses Under the Constraints of the Covid-19
Pandemic: The Impact of Face-To-Face Learning on Student Motivation. International
Journal of Early Childhood Special Education.
Soto, J. H. B., Ocampo, D.-C., Colón, L. d. C. B., & Oropesa, A. V. (2020). Perceptions of
ImmerseMe Virtual Reality Platform to Improve English Communicative Skills in Higher
Education. Int. J. Interact. Mob. Technol., 14, 4-19.
Sporn, Z., Chanter, J., & Meehan, D. (2020). Babbel Language Learning Podcasts.
Tan, K. M., Duan, R., Huang, X., Zou, B., & Do, X. L. (2022). A Deep Learning Platform for
Language Education Research and Development. Interspeech,
Tapalova, O. B., Zhiyenbayeva, N., & Gura, D. (2022). Artificial Intelligence in Education: AIEd
for Personalised Learning Pathways. Electronic Journal of e-Learning.
Teasley, M. L., & Homer, B. (2020). Racial Disparities in the Education System.
Tschanz, N., & Baerlocher, B. (2022). Virtual Reality in Language Teaching. MedienPädagogik:
Zeitschrift für Theorie und Praxis der Medienbildung.
Vall, R., & González Araya, F. (2023). Exploring the Benefits and Challenges of AI-Language
Learning Tools. International Journal of Social Sciences and Humanities Invention.
Vuong, L., & Wong, P. C. M. (2019). From Individual Differences in Language Aptitude to
Personalized Learning. Language Aptitude.
Wang, L. (2023). The Application and Impact of Artificial Intelligence in International Chinese
Language Education: A Case Study of ChatGPT. Education, Language and Sociology
Research.
Wijewickrema, S. N. R., Ma, X., Piromchai, P., Briggs, R., Bailey, J., Kennedy, G. E., & O'Leary,
S. J. (2018). Providing Automated Real-Time Technical Feedback for Virtual Reality
Based Surgical Training: Is the Simpler the Better? International Conference on Artificial
Intelligence in Education,
Winans, M. D. (2019). Busuu: A Social Network Application to Learn Languages. CALICO
journal.
22
Woo, J.-H., & Choi, H. (2021). Systematic Review for AI-based Language Learning Tools.
ArXiv, abs/2111.04455.
Wozniak, K. (2020). Personalized Learning for Adults: An Emerging Andragogy.
Wu, C., Lam, H., Kong, A., & Wong, W. (2023). The design and evaluation of a digital learning-
based English chatbot as an online self-learning method. International Journal of
Engineering Business Management.
Yang, H., & Kyun, S. (2022). The current research trend of artificial intelligence in language
learning: A systematic empirical literature review from an activity theory perspective.
Australasian Journal of Educational Technology.
Yang, Z. (2022). The Application of the Intelligent Learning Assistant based on Automatic
Speech Recognition in the International Learning Environment. Highlights in Science,
Engineering and Technology.
Yu, D. (2023). AI-Empowered Metaverse Learning Simulation Technology Application. 2023
International Conference on Intelligent Metaverse Technologies & Applications (iMETA),
1-6.
Zhai, X., Chu, X., Chai, C. S., Jong, M. S. Y., Istenič, A., Spector, M., Liu, J.-b., Yuan, J., & Li,
Y. (2021). A Review of Artificial Intelligence (AI) in Education from 2010 to 2020.
Complex., 2021, 8812542:8812541-8812542:8812518.
Zhang, C., Doan, K. D., Liao, Q., & Abdul-Mageed, M. (2023). The Skipped Beat: A Study of
Sociopragmatic Understanding in LLMs for 64 Languages. Conference on Empirical
Methods in Natural Language Processing,
Zhaxybayev, D. O., & Mizamova, G. N. (2022). Natural Language Processing Algorithms for
Understanding the Semantics of Text. Proceedings of the Institute for System
Programming of the RAS.
Zhou, H., Nova, A., Larochelle, H., Courville, A. C., Neyshabur, B., & Sedghi, H. (2022).
Teaching Algorithmic Reasoning via In-context Learning. ArXiv, abs/2211.09066.
Zhu, A. (2020, 17-19 April 2020). Supply and Demand of Ai-Aided Language Education. 2020
International Conference on Computer Information and Big Data Applications (CIBDA),
Zunaidah, A., Wiharja, C. K., & Febriantono, M. A. (2023). Dependency on AI-Based Writing
Tools in English Learning: Implications for Human-Computer Interaction. 2023
International Conference on Information Management and Technology (ICIMTech), 1-6.
