"Ne desperetis vos qui peccare soletis, exemploque meo vos reparate Deos."
[Don't despair, you who habitually sin, since through my example God will restore you.]1
The Digby play, performed in a period when women were excluded from preaching, celebrates Mary Magdalene as a most successful preacher.2 It is not a marginal work: this is a large play which takes over three hours to perform, has a cast of over 60, and thus would need at least 100 people to produce.3 The play is highly entertaining, with stage mechanics, song, and dangerous-sounding pyrotechnics. With impressive spectacle the play shows the Magdalene as the apostola apostolorum: a woman who out-apostles the apostles.4 There is a challenging irony in the situation of a woman preaching before a medieval audience, as Theresa Coletti shows and investigates. Coletti, noting that "discourses of female vice and virtue are deeply implicated in visions of social order, hierarchy, and control,"5 examines the historical East Anglian context of the Digby Mary Magdalen more fully in her book, Mary Magdalene and the Drama of Saints. I want to add to Coletti's anatomization of the play further evidence of its feminine perspective. Agreeing that "Medieval dramatic performance can no longer be construed as unreflective vehicles of instruction in a timeless Christian faith,"6 I examine the way that the Digby play heightens Magdalene's transgression of gender roles. In line with non-biblical material it amalgamates several episodes now considered not to belong to the Magdalene but to other women.7 Consistently, dramatic strategies endorse the Magdalene's social transgressions: her open sexuality and her preaching. There are male foils to female action (her lust is graceful against crude male parodies; her preaching has its male foils), themes and echoes that move between characters (good and bad patriarchs bully), and reassurance that the Magdalene's breach of social codes is still contained within the gender role hierarchy (she is awarded semi-divine status, yet defers to Saint Peter). The flow of action between characters, which I am calling shadowing after Edmund Spenser's use of the term,8 endorses female escape from social stricture. Slippage of moral action between characters contrasts and compares them to the purpose of endorsing the feminist potential of the female saint.
The Magdalene motif is one whose boundaries are hard to define: there are many different Maries as represented in the different New Testament gospels, in the Gnostic gospels, and in subsequent art and literature. The play's inclusive representation is the traditional Western understanding of the Magdalene. David A. Mycoff explains that "Although the Eastern Church from an early date had maintained that the two Marys and the nameless penitent were separate, the West . . . identified them as one."9 Present day scholarship leans toward accepting that historically these women are likely to be separate in accordance with the Eastern view. However, the amalgamated "unica Magdalene" of Western tradition has taken a distinctive and compelling shape as an idea, noumenal rather than phenomenal, to use the term as developed in book 2 of Kant's Critique of Pure Reason. The idea of the Magdalene seems more accessible and more interesting than the shadows of historical women. Holly H. Hearon cites as her attraction to the topic: "Magdalene stories . . . represent an intersection of gender, power and status, and conflict"10 ; I agree but want to emphasize that it is the status as stories that allows for such an interesting nexus.
It is a commonplace to see textually-constructed women as divisible into one of two categories: they are either in the type of Eve, the temptress, or of the blessed virgin Mary.11 The unica Magdalene offers a middle ground: a sexualized, touching, intuitive woman who is also well educated and successful as an apostle.12 This is a complex version of femininity, because the Magdalene's publicly observed sensuality, an impropriety, is what gives her success in her preacherly breach of socially prescribed gender roles. Not only does she escape censure for her failure to fit into the mold of ideal woman—she is not silent, chaste, and obedient—but her rule breaking is what makes her...