Conference PaperPDF Available

CONCEPT FOR A PERMEABILITY MODEL FOR NON-CRIMP FABRICS

Authors:
  • Faserinstitut Bremen e.V.

Abstract and Figures

Permeability is the decisive textile parameter for the design and simulation of liquid composite moulding processes. Since the determination of permeability is both time consuming and costly, the development of a valid permeability model is important for a fast estimation during the design phase. In this paper, the first systematic steps to develop the model for a non-crimp fabric are demonstrated. In the first step, a virtual model of the meso-structure is created, in which the variations of the textile are considered. The influences of individual model parameters on the permeability are analysed using flow simulations on the generated structures. In this study, the used modulus of elasticity shows a major impact on the compacted structure, which influences the permeability. Bad chosen values lead to unrealistic meso-structures and bad results of the permeability. The shift of layers during the stacking could change the out-of-plane permeability drastically. A linear correlation between roving breadth and permeability was recognised. Further results are necessary to build up the model and validate it with experimental results.
Content may be subject to copyright.
ECCM21 21st European Conference on Composite Materials
02-05 July 2024, Nantes, France 1
CONCEPT FOR A PERMEABILITY MODEL FOR NON-CRIMP
FABRICS
D. Droste1, A. Dimassi1 and A.S. Herrmann1
1Faserinstitut Bremen e.V., Modelling and Simulation, 28359 Bremen, Germany
Email: droste@faserinstitut.de, Web Page: http://www.faserinstitut.de
Keywords: Liquid Composite Moulding, Permeability, Computational Fluid Dynamics, Darcy’s Law
Abstract
Permeability is the decisive textile parameter for the design and simulation of liquid composite moulding
processes. Since the determination of permeability is both time consuming and costly, the development
of a valid permeability model is important for a fast estimation during the design phase. In this paper,
the first systematic steps to develop the model for a non-crimp fabric are demonstrated. In the first step,
a virtual model of the meso-structure is created, in which the variations of the textile are considered.
The influences of individual model parameters on the permeability are analysed using flow simulations
on the generated structures.
In this study, the used modulus of elasticity shows a major impact on the compacted structure, which
influences the permeability. Bad chosen values lead to unrealistic meso-structures and bad results of the
permeability. The shift of layers during the stacking could change the out-of-plane permeability
drastically. A linear correlation between roving breadth and permeability was recognised. Further results
are necessary to build up the model and validate it with experimental results.
1. Introduction
Liquid composite moulding (LCM) processes are one of the most important manufacturing processes
for fibre reinforced plastic (FRP) components in various industries. Depending on the requirements,
high-quality components can be produced in this process.
Process simulations are carried out to fully understand and optimise the process. The permeability of
the dry fibre material is an important parameter in the process alongside the viscosity of the resin and
must therefore be known. The most common method is experimental determination. A standard [1] has
recently become available for determining in-plane permeability. The determination of the out-of-plane
permeability is still in the benchmark phase [2]. The experimental determination of permeability has the
disadvantage of high experimental and financial effort. For this reason, simulations for virtual
permeability determination represent a promising way [3]. However, the effort required to create the
meso-geometry, using micrographs and µCT data, is too high to obtain a quick permeability estimate
for a specific material.
Permeability models represent the third possibility. Models for woven or non-crimp fabrics (NCF) must
consider the hierarchy of the textile structure [4]. Current models instead focus primarily on the micro
level and work with parameters that can only be determined by analysing the micro-structure of the FRP
component, they cannot be applied to estimate the meso-permeability. For this reason, a concept will be
presented in this paper, in which the meso-permeability can be estimated using a permeability model
based only on known textile parameters (e.g. fibre diameter, areal weight, stitch distance).
ECCM21 21st European Conference on Composite Materials
02-05 July 2024, Nantes, France 2
1.1. Influences on the meso-permeability
There are a large number of studies in the literature on the influence of various textile parameters on
permeability. In addition to the influence of the fibre volume content, other parameters have been
identified in studies on woven fabrics. The type of fabric, the ratio between weft and warp and the
openness of the fabric showed an influence on the experimental results [5]. In the case of NCF, the areal
weight was recognised as a relevant factor. A higher areal weight is associated with a higher out-of-
plane permeability [6]. The out-of-plane permeability is also influenced by the change in the layer
structure of unidirectional NCF (change in angle). The rotation of the layers led to an increase in
permeability [7]. The stitch density also influences the out-of-plane permeability [8]-[9]. A linear
relationship between stitch density and out-of-plane permeability was derived from experimental studies
[9].
The aim of this paper is to show the first steps to build a textile-parameter based permeability model for
NCF. As the model is to be based on simulation data and experimental results, the NCF structure is first
analysed and transferred to a digital twin. The twin is used to analyse the influence of different model
parameters, as the textile parameters can be easily adjusted by simulation. The influence of several
model parameters is discussed. The next steps (experimental investigations, modelling and validation)
will be described in further work.
2. Materials and Methods
2.1. Material
In this paper, the results for a unidirectional NCF are described, which has a small proportion of 90°
rovings and stitch threads in addition to the 0° rovings as the main layer.
2.2. Generation of virtual non-crimp fabrics
A parametric model for the generation of the meso-structures is created using micrographs and µCT
images of the dry textile and different laminates. The relevant model parameters are identified by
analysing these image data. The identified model parameters for unidirectional NCF are listed in table
1. In addition to the textile parameters, further parameters are required for automated geometry
generation. These parameters ensure that the meso-structures are generated with a certain variation for
a specific textile parameter set. As the textile has variations due to the production and handling, this is
also considered in the model (cf. figure 1).
Figure 1. Two meso-structures with specific textile parameter set, but different model parameters
(offset between the layers. A: 0%, B: 25%). Grey: 0° rovings, Yellow: 90° rovings and Black:
Stitching.
The rovings are modelled as a porous medium. The micro-permeability for the rovings is computed on
different micro-structures. The correlation of local and global fibre volume content is considered.
Depending on the local fibre volume content and the fibre diameter, a transverse isotropic micro-
permeability is defined for the rovings. The generation of the meso-structures is implemented in the
GeoDict software from Math2Market GmbH using an additional Python script. A comparison between
the virtual meso-structure and the micrograph is shown in figure 2.
ECCM21 21st European Conference on Composite Materials
02-05 July 2024, Nantes, France 3
Table 1. Model parameters for digital twin of unidirectional NCF.
Textile Parameter
Model Parameter
Lower Limit
Upper Limit
Shape of Roving
Shape of Roving
Elliptical
Rectangular
0° Roving Breadth
0° Roving Breadth
1.5 mm
2.5 mm
90° Roving Breadth
90° Roving Breadth
0.8 mm
1.4 mm
Stitching Breadth
Stitching Breadth
0.325 mm
Areal Weight
0° Roving Thickness
0.6 mm
0.9 mm
90° Roving Thickness
0.075 mm
Stitching Thickness
0.325 mm
Stitching length
Stitching Length
2.5 mm
5.0 mm
Gap between 0° Roving
Gap between 0° Roving
0.2 mm
0.3 mm
Fibre type
Fibre type
Carbon
Glass
Number of Rovings
3
Number of Layers
2
6
Undulation
0%
50%
Randomness
10%
Shifting of Layer
0%
50%
Rotation of Layer
Seed
Variable
Offset in z-direction
-0.1 mm
0 mm
Figure 2. Comparison between micrograph and virtual meso-structure.
Grey: 0° rovings, Yellow: 90° rovings and Black: Stitching.
2.2. Virtual compaction and permeability measurements
The virtual compaction and permeability determinations are calculated in GeoDict. Mechanical
properties must be defined for the different materials (fibre bundles, stitches and pore space) for the
compaction simulation. These properties can be regarded as further model parameters as they show an
influence on the compacted structure (see section 3).
The flow simulations on the meso-structures are done according to the Stokes-Brinkman-Equation. A
pressure drop of 0.02 Pa is defined in flow direction. Inflow and outflow areas are defined in front and
behind the unit cell. Symmetric boundary conditions are applied in tangential direction. The
permeability of the different meso-structures is calculated based on the pressure drop, calculated
velocity, viscosity and media thickness using Darcy's law.
ECCM21 21st European Conference on Composite Materials
02-05 July 2024, Nantes, France 4
3. Results and Discussion
In order to find the input parameters and their influence on the permeability for the model, various
parameter studies were carried out. Exemplary, three influences will be considered in more detail. In the
results, K1 ( direction) and K2 (90° direction) form the in-plane permeability. The out-of-plane
permeability is described by K3. Five simulations were performed for each textile parameter set.
3.1 Shifting parameter
Before the compaction of the meso-structures takes place, the individually generated layers must be
assembled into one meso-cell. The layers can be perfectly stacked on top of each other or shifted in
relation to each other by a defined shifting parameter (cf. figure 3 A, B). The influence of this parameter
is obvious for the thickness direction. In a perfectly layered laminate, vertical flow channels are created,
through which the flow is favoured. As soon as the layers are shifted towards each other, the flow must
flow around the roving, as the flow follows the least resistance (pore space). Due to the direction change
of the flow, a greater pressure difference is required and the determined permeability decreases. As seen
in figure 3 C, the change in the out-of-plane permeability varies more than one order of magnitude by
changing this parameter.
Figure 3. Influences of the shifting parameter on the fluid flow in thickness direction.
A: Shifted 0° rovings (25%). B: No shift for 0°-Rovings. C: Results of the simulations.
3.2 Compaction parameters
In order to perform the compaction virtually, a modulus of elasticity must be defined for the rovings
𝐸𝐹𝑖𝑏𝑟𝑒 and the pore space 𝐸𝑃𝑜𝑟𝑒. The compacted meso-structure is significantly influenced by the change
of the modulus of elasticity (cf. figure 4 A-C). If the ratio of the modulus of elasticity (𝐸𝐹𝑖𝑏𝑒𝑟 𝐸𝑃𝑜𝑟𝑒
) is
set too high, the horizontal pore space between the rovings is compressed completely, which influences
the permeability both in thickness direction and in 90° direction. When the ratio is set too low, the
rovings are compacted too strongly.
Due to the disappearance of the horizontal pore space (high ratio of modulus), the resin has no free path
between the rovings. It must pass through the rovings. In this case, the determined permeability depends
massively on the micro-permeability. If the rovings were modelled as solids, no flow would be possible.
A similar picture emerges for the out-of-plane permeability, although here it depends on the shift of the
different layers relative to each other.
ECCM21 21st European Conference on Composite Materials
02-05 July 2024, Nantes, France 5
Figure 4. Influence of the compaction parameters.
A: Compacted structure with high modulus ratio.
B: Compacted structure with middle modulus ratio.
C: Compacted structure with low modulus ratio.
D: Results of the simulations with different modulus ratios.
3.3 Roving breadth
As a textile parameter, the roving breadth of the 0° roving is considered here as an example. Changing
the roving breadth changes the ratio between the pore space and rovings in the thickness direction. As
the roving breadth increases, the less pore space is available in relation to it. This results in a reduction
ECCM21 21st European Conference on Composite Materials
02-05 July 2024, Nantes, France 6
in permeability in the thickness direction. The same effect can be observed for K1 (cf. figure 5 A). The
analogue explanation applies. A smaller effect is recognisable for K2.
The influence of the roving breadth on the permeability can be described by a linear model (cf. figure 5
C). The Pearson correlation coefficient is over 0.96 for all directions, which indicates a strong linear
relationship between the parameters.
Figure 5. Influence of the 0° roving breadth on the permeability.
4. Conclusions and future work
In this work, the influence of different parameters was investigated. The shifting parameter and the ratio
of modulus of elasticity show a significant influence on the permeability. The textile parameter (roving
breadth) shows a smaller influence on the results. If the influence of the textile parameters is too small
compared to the other model parameters, the prediction of the model will be weak. This needs to be
investigated further.
The investigation of the other textile parameters (table 1) and the extension to a biaxial fabric are
required to build up the NCF permeability model. With the help of a subsequent sensitivity analysis, the
relevant parameters are determined and transferred to the model. In parallel, the validation and
calibration of the simulation results and thus the validation of the model will be carried out.
Acknowledgments
We are grateful to the Forschungskuratorium Textil for the financial support of the research project
moToPerm (IGF No. 22174 N/1), which is supported by the Federal Ministry for Economic Affairs
and Climate Action on the basis of a decision by the German Bundestag. We would also like to thank
Math2Market GmbH for their support and advice during the modelling phase.
ECCM21 21st European Conference on Composite Materials
02-05 July 2024, Nantes, France 7
References
[1] ISO. Test methods for the experimental characterization of in-plane permeability of fibrous
reinforcements for liquid composite moulding. ISO 4410:2023.
[2] A. X. H. Yong et al. Out-of-plane permeability measurement for reinforcement textiles: A
benchmark exercise. Composites Part A: Applied Science and Manufacturing, 148: 106480, 2021.
[3] T. Schmidt, D. May, M. Duhovic, A. Widera, M. Hümbert and P. Mitschang. A combined
experimentalnumerical approach for permeability characterization of engineering textiles.
Polymer Composites, 42(7), 3363-3379, 2021.
[4] S. V. Lomov, G. Huysmans and I. Verpoest. Hierarchy of Textile Structures and Architecture of
Fabric Geometric Models. Textile Research Journal, 71(6), 534-543, 2001.
[5] G. Rieber, J. Jiang, C. Deter, N. Chen and P. Mitschang. Influence of textile parameters on the in-
plane Permeability. Composites Part A: Applied Science and Manufacturing, 52: 89-98, 2013.
[6] C. Hahn, C. Binetruy and R. Hinterhölzl. A Simulation-Based Method of Permeability Prediction
for RTM Process Simulation. In 19th International Conference on Composite Materials, Montreal,
2013.
[7] H. S. Sas, E. B. Wurtzel, P. Simacek and S. G. Advani. Effect of relative ply orientation on the
through-thickness permeability of unidirectional fabrics. Composites science and technology, 96:
116-121, 2014.
[8] O. Rimmel, D. May and P. Mitschang. Impact of stitching on permeability and mechanical
properties of preforms manufactured by dry fiber placement. Polymer Composites, 40(4), 1631-
1642, 2019.
[9] S. Drapier, A. Pagot, A. Vautrin and P. Henrat. Influence of the stitching density on the transverse
permeability of non-crimped new concept (NC2) multiaxial reinforcements: measurements and
predictions. Composites Science and Technology, 62(15): 1979-1991, 2002.
ResearchGate has not been able to resolve any citations for this publication.
Article
Full-text available
Extensive experimental test programs are required for the characterization of textile permeability, which is essential for the design of liquid composite molding processes. In this study, an experimental–numerical approach is presented, aiming to partially substitute experiments by numerical simulations. This approach uses 3D microscale simulations to evaluate the permeability within rovings and attribute these values to statistical volume elements of the textile at the mesoscale. To further improve accuracy, a calibration method has been defined. In order to validate the functionality of this approach the permeability of a glass fiber woven and a non‐crimp fabric at fiber volume contents (FVCs) between 50 and 60% were predicted. For the non‐calibrated but virtually compacted models with FVCs of 55 and 60%, the deviation ranges from −27% to +42%. This seems acceptable considering the typical scatter in experimental tests, for example, a CV of 20–50% was measured in recent permeability benchmarks. The numerically determined permeability was then used as input for numerical filling simulations at part level (macroscale). The resulting filling times were then compared to results of simulations based on experimental input values.
Article
Full-text available
New manufacturing processes arise for polymer-based composites which involve resin infusion through dry pre-forms. Modelling approaches of these processes require to assess new physical characteristics of the materials. In this paper, the transverse permeability of new multiaxial stitched materials, referred to as NC2, is investigated. First, in the framework of Darcy's flows, this permeability is assessed for various biaxial NC2 using a specific device. Through this approach it is shown that the transverse permeability depends strongly on the stitching density. Then, the results from a simplified FE study carried out at the blanket scale are shown to correlate quite well the experimental measurements and evidences established in the first part.
Article
The out-of-plane permeability of two glass fibre fabrics was measured by 26 institutions using silicone oil as a test fluid. Participants in this study were free to select the test procedure, specimen dimensions and data analysis method, provided that testing was carried out at three target fibre volume fractions, 46 %, 50 % and 54 %. While results showed a variability of two orders of magnitude between participants, most values were within a significantly narrower band. A majority of participants used 1D saturated test method. A few selected 1D unsaturated and 3D unsaturated flow method which gave very similar results. Focusing on analysis of data and results of 1D saturated flow measurements, results are not conclusive, but they are consistent with number of layers in a specimen, fibre volume fraction, injection pressure and sealing of specimen edges all having an effect on the measured permeability. Specifying limits for these parameters is expected to result in reduced scatter in measured permeability.
Article
Dry fiber placement (DFP) is a technology that enables outstandingly high mechanical performance of composite parts, as preform structures with load‐related fiber orientations can be created with minimum of fiber crimp and undulation. Yet, the poor impregnation behavior of DFP preforms during liquid composite molding processing methods remains a main challenge. Encouraging an out‐of‐plane impregnation, for example, by using a vacuum assisted or compression resin transfer molding process, reduces the flow length within the preform and is a first step towards reducing cycle times. However, further improvements are required in order to apply DFP preforming methods in serial production. In a previous work, the influence of various process parameters as well as post‐treatment steps on out‐of‐plane permeability have been investigated with the conclusion, that tufting/stitching led to the highest increase in out‐of‐plane permeability (more than two decades). For further understanding, this study deals with the influence of a stitching step on the out‐of‐plane permeability of DFP preforms as well as the mechanical properties of the finished laminate depending on a variety of stitching parameters such as thread tension during stitching, denier of the used thread, stitch distance, seam distance, seam displacement, and treated DFP layup. It is shown that the biggest impact on out‐of‐plane permeability results from the achieved stitching density (as a product of stitch distance and seam distance) and denier while thread tension and seam displacement show negligible effects. For the mechanical properties, it can be stated that the presence of stitching channels in thickness directions leads to a minor decrease of tensile properties while bending properties are more significantly reduced by about 30%. POLYM. COMPOS., 2018.
Article
When unidirectional stitched fabrics are used as reinforcement in composites, plies are typically stacked on top of each other to build up the desired thickness. Strength and stiffness requirements dictate the orientation of individual layers and the accuracy of angular alignment is limited. A pressure differential across the thickness is used to distribute the resin, either from a pre-impregnated fabric or injected from a resin source, to occupy all of the empty spaces between the fibers. This process is commonly modeled using Darcy’s law, which describes flow of resin through porous media in which the flow rate is directly proportional to the applied pressure differential by the through-thickness permeability of the fabric. A different orientation between layers or even a slight misalignment during the stacking can change the through-thickness permeability dramatically due the change of resin pathways. In this work, we characterize the through-thickness permeability of a series of unidirectional fabrics stacked in various orientations to address both the effect of stacking sequence and those of misalignment of the individual layers. We conduct numerical simulations to predict the effect of change in fiber orientation on the through-thickness permeability. The results from the numerical model are compared with experimental measurements. Our results show that averaging approach is not suitable to calculate the through-thickness permeability component when using unidirectional fabrics and that the stacking sequence of the unidirectional fabrics may significantly influence the through-thickness permeability. We also show that the effects of small misalignments between individual layers do not significantly modify the transverse flow.
Article
Textile materials are characterized by a distinct structural hierarchy, which should be represented by a model of textile geometry and its mechanical behavior. Despite extensive investigations of textile materials and a number of theoretical models existing in the textile literature for different structures, a general model is not available. Hence, the challenge addressed in this work is to take full advantage of the hierarchical principle of textile modeling to create a truly integrated modeling and design tool. The algorithm for extensive simulations of complex yarn interactions uses the minimum energy principle, allowing complex textile structure computations in computer time to be counted in minutes instead of hours or days for FEM implementation of the same nonlinear, nonconservative behavior of yarns under compression and bending. The architecture of the code corresponds to the hierarchical structure of the textile material. General ideas of the hierarchical approach are illustrated by models of the internal geometry of multilayered woven fabrics and weft-knitted fabric topology.
Test methods for the experimental characterization of in-plane permeability of fibrous reinforcements for liquid composite moulding
  • Iso
ISO. Test methods for the experimental characterization of in-plane permeability of fibrous reinforcements for liquid composite moulding. ISO 4410:2023.
Influence of textile parameters on the inplane Permeability
  • G Rieber
  • J Jiang
  • C Deter
  • N Chen
  • P Mitschang
G. Rieber, J. Jiang, C. Deter, N. Chen and P. Mitschang. Influence of textile parameters on the inplane Permeability. Composites Part A: Applied Science and Manufacturing, 52: 89-98, 2013.
A Simulation-Based Method of Permeability Prediction for RTM Process Simulation
  • C Hahn
  • C Binetruy
  • R Hinterhölzl
C. Hahn, C. Binetruy and R. Hinterhölzl. A Simulation-Based Method of Permeability Prediction for RTM Process Simulation. In 19th International Conference on Composite Materials, Montreal, 2013.