Article

Participatory approaches in assessing the health needs of African-Caribbean communities

Authors:
To read the full-text of this research, you can request a copy directly from the authors.

Abstract

No Previous attempts to involve African and African-Caribbean communities in a city in north England in identifying and assessing their health needs have been largely unsuccessful. A comprehensive literature review highlighted that research on Africans and African-Caribbeans is limited and uneven, and dominated by studies focusing on cardiovascular disease, diabetes, mental health and blood disorders. Health information on these communities is largely based on immigrant mortality statistics derived from national datasets. This paper highlights how participatory approaches to community participation and engagement were used in the assessment of the health needs of culturally diverse minority communities as a means of reducing health disparities. The study sought to overcome the shortcomings of traditional techniques for health needs assessment by testing a novel method of rapid participatory appraisal using a triangulation approach to ensure that all perspectives were addressed. The research adopted a mixed-methods strategy comprising distinct phases: a comprehensive review of the literature, a qualitative needs assessment involving representatives of the African and African-Caribbean communities using meta-planning, and a review of health service provision. The approach used in the study was efficient, rapid and feasible for the African and African-Caribbean people to use in obtaining data from their peers. The findings showed a convergence between areas of need identified by health providers and community members in this appraisal, and between these results and other published literature. However, there was a divergence on the extent of change necessary, with institutional responses stressing alterations within existing systems, and community members recommending the establishment of targeted services for African and African-Caribbean communities run by ethnically matched staff.

No full-text available

Request Full-text Paper PDF

To read the full-text of this research,
you can request a copy directly from the authors.

... suggested that limited awareness among the recent migrants plays an important role in shaping the lower uptake in this population. 30,31 Risk perception and limited awareness of screening were unusual themes within each of our groups; however, it was the participants who had migrated as adults, especially from regions where screening programmes are not routinely offered, who discussed being unaware of screening prior to the receipt of their first invitation letter. ...
Article
Full-text available
Background The introduction of screening in the UK and other high‐income countries led to a significant decrease in the incidence of cervical cancer and increase in survival rates. Minority ethnic groups are often underrepresented in screening participation for reasons that are poorly understood. Objective To explore experiences of cervical screening participation and non‐participation of women from minority ethnic populations in Scotland and gain insights to support the development of interventions that could potentially support screening participation and thereby reduce inequalities. Design Qualitative comparison group study using in‐depth, semi‐structured individual interviews that were thematically analysed. Setting and participants This study took place in Scotland. Fifty women were purposively sampled from four ethnic minority groups: South Asian; East European; Chinese; and Black African or Caribbean. White Scottish women were also interviewed. Results Many experiences described were common regardless of ethnicity, such as difficulties managing competing priorities, including work and care responsibilities. However, important differences existed across the groups. These included going abroad for more frequent screening, delayed introduction to screening and not accessing primary care services, language difficulties in health‐care settings despite proficiency in English and not being sexually active at screening commencement. Experiences of racism, ignorance and feeling shamed were also reported. Conclusions Key differences exist in the experience of minority ethnic groups in Scotland. These offer potential opportunities to reduce disparity and support screening participation including maximizing co‐incidental interactions and developing outreach work.
... Institutional practices and structures still act as barriers to change, for example, through the blocking of PAR research in NHS ethics committees which are largely populated by positivists (Goodyear-Smith et al. 2015). A number of challenges remain before it can be said that marginalised groups, such as people with learning difficulties, are commonly included in an empowering way in the mainstream of research affecting their lives (Aldridge 2015;Baxter et al. 2001;Okereke et al. 2007;Bennett and Roberts 2004;Cawston et al. 2007). These challenges include the attitudes of some professionals, the diversity and complexity of lay groups' knowledge, power relationships, resources (both personal and financial) and values. ...
Chapter
In this chapter PartKommPlus—the German Research Consortium for Healthy Communities—will be presented. PartKommPlus is one of seven research consortia in Germany in the field of health promotion and is the largest research project to date in that country using participatory health research approaches. The chapter includes background information on participatory research and municipal health promotion in Germany, a description of the structure and goals of the consortium, and a discussion of the challenges faced in the implementation process during the first funding phase.
... The research evidence on ethnic inequalities in health argues that limited knowledge about cancer, cancer symptoms, cancer services and lower access to health-care services among BME groups contribute to their low uptake of cancer services [17][18][19]. Some research highlights that the Black African ethnic group remains marginalised in health promotion activities due to the 'migration effect', which suggest that recent migrants to the UK may have limited awareness of health programmes which may contribute to their low access and utilisation of specific services such as the breast screening programme [20]. ...
Article
Full-text available
What is known about this topic? • Advances in breast screening services have led to improvements in early detection, reduced mortality and better management of breast cancer. • Low uptake of the national breast screening programme and delayed presentation of breast cancer symptoms means that mortality from breast cancer continues to be high among Black African women. • Reasons for low uptake of the breast screening services among Black African women are poorly understood. What this paper adds? • This paper presents salient factors leading to low uptake of the NHS Breast Screening programme by Black African women in England. • There is need for culturally relevant interventions to improve knowledge on cancer, cancer screening and treatments options for Black African women.
... The research evidence on ethnic inequalities in health argues that limited knowledge about cancer, cancer symptoms, cancer services and lower access to health-care services among BME groups contribute to their low uptake of cancer services [17][18][19]. Some research highlights that the Black African ethnic group remains marginalised in health promotion activities due to the 'migration effect', which suggest that recent migrants to the UK may have limited awareness of health programmes which may contribute to their low access and utilisation of specific services such as the breast screening programme [20]. ...
Article
Full-text available
What is known about this topic? • Advances in breast screening services have led to improvements in early detection, reduced mortality and better management of breast cancer. • Low uptake of the national breast screening programme and delayed presentation of breast cancer symptoms means that mortality from breast cancer continues to be high among Black African women. • Reasons for low uptake of the breast screening services among Black African women are poorly understood. What this paper adds? • This paper presents salient factors leading to low uptake of the NHS Breast Screening programme by Black African women in England. • There is need for culturally relevant interventions to improve knowledge on cancer, cancer screening and treatments options for Black African women.
... This approach has previously been shown to be an effective method for elucidating views on health needs in ethnic minority subgroups of African and African Caribbean communities. 11 A rapid approach was used with the resources available, involving council employees already working with migrant groups to garner the views of a wide range of community members using structured group interviews. ...
Article
Background: The majority of tuberculosis (TB) cases in the UK occur among people born in high-burden countries (73%), and are concentrated in large urban centres. This study explores migrants' attitudes and beliefs towards TB in an English District where the incidence is higher than the UK average. Methods: Community engagement workers ran 26 focus groups using a standardized questionnaire. Purposeful sampling was used to obtain a cross-section of migrant communities. The summary reports were analysed using thematic analysis. Results: Most groups did not see TB as a current issue in their community and associated it either with the past or with their country of birth. It appeared to be rarely discussed in their communities and generally not noted as being associated with stigma. Conclusions: This study revealed a change in social attitudes to TB in migrant groups to those reported in previous literature. Stigma had considerably less effect than expected. However, the evidence revealed that these high-risk groups made the erroneous assumption that, by moving to a low incidence country, they were no longer at risk of the disease. TB services need to respond by revising the information that they provide to take into account the risk perception of these populations.
... Participants for the study were selected by Health Workers or Nai Bans (Village Chiefs) in each of the districts in which the Silk Homes continue to operate. Okereke et al. (2007, pp.291–292) recognise that participants should not be randomly recruited but involve a range of people who are in the best position to understand the issues. Recent parity women were involved in focus group discussions but these sessions were always complemented by interviews with District Ministry of Health officials, local doctors and health workers who had abroad understanding of the issues confronting pregnant women in rural and remote locations in the three provinces. ...
Article
This paper follows the genesis of an evolving tool to measure the impact of development interventions on personal well-being in non-literate and non-numerate communities. The Diamond Dialogue was adapted to evaluate the impact on women of the establishment of 17 one stop maternity waiting home/health promotion/income generating centres (Silk Homes) in Southern Lao PDR. The tool elicited data not accessible by research methods which assume literacy and numeracy and revealed that 86% of women who used the Silk Homes experienced substantial improvements in quality of life. The Diamond Dialogue can be modified to assess the outcomes of development interventions in a myriad of contexts.
... To acquire a genuine and deep understanding of the issues aff ecting members of minority communities, cultural knowledge must inform the entire research process. Merely including a particular underserved population in the sample or targeting an underserved population does not make a study cross-cultural (Okereke, Archibong, Chiemeka, Baxter, & Davis, 2007). "Cultural competence must infuse and suff use the entire research process of planning, theory development, instrumentation, analysis, and interpretation to ensure cross-cultural validity and reliability" (Brandt et al., 1999, p. 21). ...
Article
Full-text available
As the workforce in the British National Health Service (NHS) has become more diverse, several researchers have reported that experiences of overseas nurses have been largely negative. This paper explores Black African nurses' experiences of equal opportunities, racism, and discrimination in four NHS trusts in northeastern England. Thirty nurses from sub-Saharan countries working in four NHS trusts were interviewed between 2006 and 2008 using semistructured interviews and focus group discussions to gain an insight into their experiences in the NHS. This study suggests that Black African nurses experienced discrimination and racism from White colleagues and other overseas nurses, managers, and patients and their relatives as well as lack of opportunities in their workplaces. Managers seemed to treat British and other overseas nurses more favorably than Black African nurses. Although much progress has been made in valuing and embracing diversity in the NHS, this article highlights areas in which more work is required.
Article
Evidence suggests that although Black African women have the lowest incidence of breast and ovarian cancer, they have the highest mortality rate and low rates of uptake for cancer screening services for these conditions in the United Kingdom (UK). This study aimed to explore the perceived barriers and facilitators to genetic testing for breast and ovarian cancer amongst Black African women in Luton (UK). We conducted a qualitative study that included one face-to-face and five telephone focus group discussions. Consistent with the health belief model, a focus group discussion guide was developed. A total of 24 participants, aged 23-57 who self-identified as Black African women and who were English speakers residing in Luton, took part in the focus group discussions. Purposive and snowballing sampling were used to recruit the participants for this study. The focus group discussions were recorded, transcribed per verbatim, coded and analyzed using an inductive thematic analysis approach, and the findings were classified. Nine themes emerged from the narratives obtained including six barriers and three facilitators. Barriers to genetic testing included (1) Cost and affordability, (2) Lack of knowledge, awareness, and family health history knowledge, (3) Language barrier, immigration, and distrust in western healthcare services, (4) Fear, (5) Cultural, religious, and intergenerational views and perceptions, and (6) Eligibility for genetic testing for the BRCA1/2 pathogenic variants and a lack of referral to specialist genetic clinics. Facilitators to genetic testing included (7) Availability of tests cost-free under the National Health Service (NHS) (8) Family members' health and (9) Awareness and education on genetic testing. The barriers and facilitators identified could enable policy makers and healthcare services alike to gain a better understanding of the factors influencing Black African women's decision-making process toward genetic testing. Ultimately, this work can inform interventions aiming to increase the uptake of genetic testing among this group.
Chapter
This chapter presents an overview of some of the influences on the development of PHR in the four nations of the UK in the context of the changing political and economic landscape of the late twentieth and early twenty-first century. Four of the strands that have informed PHR have been the overseas development tradition, community development, teacher education action research and the work of Peter Reason in Management Science. A strong impetus to development within health came from the healthy cities and health promotion movements of the 1980s and 1990s which were further encouraged by the public and patient engagement initiative with the NHS in the early 2000s. More recently the trend towards public engagement by universities and the need to demonstrate research impact have provided a further challenge as well as an opportunity for this type of research to demonstrate its benefits. However, the tension between top-down bureaucracy and grassroots ownership and control inherent in PHR continues to play out in the broader political landscape.
Article
Full-text available
This project examines the organisation and delivery of health improvement activities by and within general practice and the primary health-care team. The project was designed to examine who delivers these interventions, where they are located, what approaches are developed in practices, how individual practices and the primary health-care team organise such public health activities, and how these contribute to health improvement. Our focus was on health promotion and ill-health prevention activities. Aims The aim of this scoping exercise was to identify the current extent of knowledge about the health improvement activities in general practice and the wider primary health-care team. The key objectives were to provide an overview of the range and type of health improvement activities, identify gaps in knowledge and areas for further empirical research. Our specific research objectives were to map the range and type of health improvement activity undertaken by general practice staff and the primary health-care team based within general practice; to scope the literature on health improvement in general practice or undertaken by health-care staff based in general practice and identify gaps in the evidence base; to synthesise the literature and identify effective approaches to the delivery and organisation of health improvement interventions in a general practice setting; and to identify the priority areas for research as defined by those working in general practice. Methods We undertook a comprehensive search of the literature. We followed a staged selection process involving reviews of titles and abstracts. This resulted in the identification of 1140 papers for data extraction, with 658 of these papers selected for inclusion in the review, of which 347 were included in the evidence synthesis. We also undertook 45 individual and two group interviews with primary health-care staff. Findings Many of the research studies reviewed had some details about the type, process or location, or who provided the intervention. Generally, however, little attention is paid in the literature to examining the impact of the organisational context on the way services are delivered or how this affects the effectiveness of health improvement interventions in general practice. We found that the focus of attention is mainly on individual prevention approaches, with practices engaging in both primary and secondary prevention. The range of activities suggests that general practitioners do not take a population approach but focus on individual patients. However, it is clear that many general practitioners see health promotion as an integral part of practice, whether as individual approaches to primary or secondary health improvement or as a practice-based approach to improving the health of their patients. Our key conclusion is that there is currently insufficient good evidence to support many of the health improvement interventions undertaken in general practice and primary care more widely. Future Research Future research on health improvement in general practice and by the primary health-care team needs to move beyond clinical research to include delivery systems and be conducted in a primary care setting. More research needs to examine areas where there are chronic disease burdens – cancer, dementia and other disabilities of old age. Reviews should be commissioned that examine the whole prevention pathway for health problems that are managed within primary care drawing together research from general practice, pharmacy, community engagement, etc. Funding The National Institute for Health Research Health Services and Delivery Research programme.
ResearchGate has not been able to resolve any references for this publication.